1 0 % PQ K K$ ) $' / R L S% & 0 %
1 4 4. ‡/& J
& +. +.*:425
&; / A+ ) /" B+C +2 < )
D*E )
& 5 4+ - 6 4+ )
*2<
M"$TU
&2 &* 7 2 +
T
* 0 TWF:
+F 9 57 &9$1
! F1 &2 3 f
r P%
!
0F $4 / 4$O / 2 GF $4 O J H
" ' $87$8 )%
/ P9 57 &P%
!
F% 7 & n` & 3 +
- $ /
&% T &
Z K P6F% P &P- 5 & u
T & 4$` $J [
N HI Z T " M ! U+5#7 K
[ P, UP,.
/
$@
! 9 57 ! u7 F67 /QF O J ! 0-
+ f /- P W E PW2$ J"PB
(OLS )
A $2 & 4$` 62
!
$
! /
= P S
?
$2 9 57 o2 7
! F+P Z 4
T " w$C $87
.
& 4
! ' N HI /
C7 A $2 "
+ Z
!
" ; Q P f
"P2 &P- W
7 š", ™ $1 0- ;
/ 9 57 o2 7 F1 &2
! +F P4$W $P87 $8P /
"P
T [
" 3$2 ! $++D €)1 m $9 / 7 Z
fP u7 / P, 2 U2 X &- W
9 57 o2 7
T @ T8*
[ Z
&- W +
$2 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 +F J 2 + T
2+
a r %
! 6 +F P- A P6W s ,7 /
J "P 3 2 + T r P%
! 'P * + Z s P,7
5+
.
A
$ MV "
]
$87 +F 9 57
! +F
$` 7
+F 9 57 $2 $…q 1
! +F GF $4 O J
0
? G ># # : 95
VG P 4CE [#
!K$ LL KG 3 arahimi_k@yahoo.com
0
45 x S
!K mousaaei@ut.ac.ir
0
# x S
< 45
!K$ LL KG 3 VG
0
#
># #
? # ?
< 45
!K VG I C
0
# _# C2
< 45
!K V G I C
-+&
"L
$ GF $4 O J NC2 +
P0F $4 E "P( r % /
P TWFP:
+ P2 F
: O( &2 &* 7 +
E H 2 ,5 2 K +
!
&2 &W * $4 T
P+
3 T
`$2 ;
! F'*
! 4 N +
! +F /
< "O /
"P2 [
> P Q /P P7
TM`
+
"I F
"
! 8* "Fi /
$'2 GF $4 &% T
!
…l7 + GPF $4 $P2 &P 4$` $ P
!
2+
$ '
!
…l7 +
$ / n`
[
! 0 2 $ + B F
! K F4
!
!
P8 3 M P 2 ` `
+ E 8 "F
! 1 /
&4$B
!
&
! F4 / WF:
/ T [ K $ P` &P2 &* 7 2
F4 ; 1 4
!
F: 2 gW 7 K $ ` { )($2
$`$ p C o /
P.
/
- 7 QB & n` g "Fi +
4 "
+
! +F / 4$—
+ Z- T
! +
P8* xXP F
4 &2
$2 A $2 2 N
/ C7 + Z
! OPOC7 %$
/ P
"P Z
4 &2 F‡
. 2 " ( N /
! 3 - 7 3 a " "F P+
P "
N
2+
N T " 3$2 ":
= / S
? P
$ ( P
&P1 Q P P
!
+F / T4 2 & *
! : /
$8
!
&2 2
"7 z „
! 0F $4 %$
/ 1 * /
, n /
&2 $8 )% H
&W 7 $8 /
"2 [
O J + M0F c- , & r F /
&F / 1 " 3
P
"
! 8* P7 P(
/
+ I / [
‰)j P2 & r I gW * +
N S + P+
2 r P+
P T +
&P ( $4 F
/
" $' F 3 A $2
! 2 %$
+ Z - / . / e ^ + )
! P
&W*$
Z- &2 `"FF%
! +F +
&2 f +
+ I "5 $M
"P &PF
$2
!
Z- L B
! +F 2+
N
^ + + Z P9 " 3$2 r
$P &P6F g
4 NC2 K $`
+ +
P. 8* F
/
P J P
/ PW +
P+
'P r
/
"
= B + Z H
^ ] e [?
TWF: " { )($2 +
&2 8* F
'% H
! P g P
P4 $
N
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -+) !!!
"7 Q /
"W7 $` 7 Z-
! +
& M l F
$P87 $8P ‰: OC $
MF " Z /
F+ TWF: 2
/ - PB T 2 4 &2 /
'P% &P%
/
2 F* $% i /
-
!
"
! B / 2$1 "# E /
Z- P P
P
! P+
F /
. " ~ "B /
( + Z- &1 Q $
! +F /
2 P 'P% P*
P+
$ '
T 2
= / S
? - B / 2 J A 6W &%
+ T P
! P+
F
! P
2 $
P+
$
$
! / . &2 T &* 7 ( $
!
! $P+I &P &P TP n` _PI &P%
P }$PX P8* TP 2 $'+I / F+ &2 j &2 $ ! F+ / ) d)5
"
+4 F+ !
! F'* / $
" * / 8* $, W !
• OP ( ( &2 !
"
= / R [?
&W- X 8 Z * 2
% B /
P $ P( F $ ! F+ &% T 3
!
/ / $ &2 / 2 T+W9
$2 [ b $` "
/ WP9 + T PWJ / D+
P $
!
$2 n`$…
* TWF: Z /
O7 T + + T n`
! P
! mP F
$P7
!
$P2
!
r u
$4 Z
/
"
& 'I
! u7
$2 f
! P2 &2 ‚ I +
!
€ P
3 /
"
[
$@ &2 / - " "
/
$` 7
+
$87 F
$8 $
! '%
&P2 ‰4$P:
-+
$ E . ,7 K $ `
/ g6, &2 ; $ 6 T$ F
P " ' T4
4+
$ / 4 > &2 ; $ +
PJ 6P &P2 $'4 } - m- J /
P y+
PQ $
+
&6 2 T
…l7 T#7 B g u Z +
$2 1 $
/
"
P P 1 &P- 5 Z
$P0
!
5#7 &W- X ; GF $4 O J NC2 &% T +
2 U + 3 $ ' T "F [
t F% 7 & n` g "Fi Er #7 &2 &* 7 2
& * $ ]I
+$
! )P d)5 /
#7 GF* > J +
/ /
! /
$#7
! 2+
Z - / 2 /
$7 F: "
P0F $4 o /
-+*
& * '%
+
…l7 T#7 F +$
Er #7 Z
=
OP J 1
! + P /
?[[[
TP P2
[
r % { $O 9 57 gW- X • O( Z 0F $4 E "(
/ ,J + +
'P% F
&2
$8 H
!
€ B + 2 $87 "F • 2 +
P. $P T T /
&P $2 P
!
„FPI
J " \$ &W 7 ; 7 g- O
! 4 B
&WP 7 ; 8i g $2 2 N
2 &2 \$ Z +
": N N
+ I A $2 T "
+ N 2+F / 'Pi "FP gWP 7 "P
O J " \$ '% "F 2
!
& $2
! 3 gW 7
"F
= QFPI g $2
?
"P: T'P &P2
" ( +
"
=
& $2 W _+€ ! $, E @ !
* 8 R [?
"2 8 /
&P% TP
0F $4 E "( r % " " Z /
@ +$
+F + PI / TP "P ( [
$2 PF2 Z
$2 9 57
! 0F $4 E "( r % & * E "( r % /
3 4 "F
"P ( N TP4
[
$2 Z
! 0C I /
&2 4 Z 9 57 N
&P2 ; r P4 Q P
H r P% P2
!
0F $4 /
@ + F+ $
! 73 / 2
$ "
&
n`
!
!
; Q ; r +
[
GF $4 O J NC2 6
/ r % 0F $4 E "(
/ TWFP: & *$2 +
TP F
• #- TWF: Z /4$.
+ T n`
!
$2 PF2 TP TP- N I T#7 NP5 Z
"
$0
! T- d Q /
&% "F%
+
&F
! ( P "1
! ,P F /
$P2
! 'P7 U
4
$ N &
n`
! : O( NC2 /
T%$
! g 2 +
&
: O(
/ - / 8 P+
"
[ 0F T- &% T x9 $I /
/ 7
"
+ T n`
! +
$ gF &
nP`
!
; r
$2
! TWF:
+
@F &2 F 2 4 Q
+ ' : 7 &W * $ +&
&P% "
P+
P9 57
!
WJ /
$2 2
!
$2 F2 " 2 & >). TWF: Z
$P2 P9 57 gPW- X ; Q Z
! TWFP:
+
Fi F
+
$ Z X /
$9 ‰) %
! T [ - / : g u /
"P { )($2 &% T Z
O J
!
( g '% T,j
+
$2 9 57 " $
! +F
MF '%
/ 2 P Z
)% 8
2 $87 $8 +
T & $ '
[ ' "F 3 /
P. &P% "P /
P P
!
S 7 4 $` 7 % "W7 +
+F
!
$87 N P%
0 'Pi +$
!
& P
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -+' !!!
$` 7 "W7 &% ! . &2 Z
"B J e^
+ +
$M P S^
&P2
"B
^ + +
$` 7
N % T & 4
= [?
(2&
3
;
0 1 2 G
!
: 0 7 2
6 X jg J 3bdc [
=& G
! 2 G>P
* & 8 Z 6
>G
!
= 6
! 2 G2 k 8 6 : 3bg4
{ $.
$0
" ' / F%
+ { )($2 P "P &P6F
+F
!
$P87 $8P PW4
W:
!
"W7 2 +F
! PW4 SS
P P
S
&P2 e
P P
4 N - & 4 /
$` P 7 "W7 "
P 0 'Pi N P% E"P Z +$
!
& P
T
= e [?
-(/
0 7 7 : G 6 2 ! G
(2&
9
;
=& G
! 2 G>P
* & 8 Z 6
>G
!
= 6
! 2 G2 k 8 6 : 3bg4
F‡
+ 4$— Z + -"F: T /
! +F
!
$P87 $8 P+
"PB S -"FP: P /
S
"B &2 R -"F:
/ N % T & 4
= [?
(2&
b
;
‰
! R> = 6
! 2 6
: 0 7
6 X jg p 3bdc [
=& G
! 2 G>P
* & 8 Z 6
>G
!
= 6
! 2 G2 k 8 6 : 3bg4
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -(, !!!
5B
* U
• O(
+4 ! 9 57 $2 % B "
F+ !
$P87 P(
T ' + &9$1
2&
! .
&%
R P N % T 1 &2 "W2 &2 L PB ,5
F+
&2
"7
„ PW4 ! F+P "PW7 P+ $P87
TP "P & P %
= E
) GF $4
/ [?
$@ &2 /
&% "
NC2 O J P r % { $OP GF $4
! P0F $4 /
$8P
!
'%
& $2
‰: OC ; $ Ty$4 E J $% $I !$2 /F+' * / 7 ! mP- J
+4 NCI $ &1 Q / F+ !
"P4$.$I / P 7 ! P TP
[ 3 mP- *
&P6
F+ $` 7 N % 2
'%
&2
$2 „ "7
"W7
$` 7
NPCI E"P
& $2
" 4 7 ! T
= [?
^
^ e e^
(2&
c
;
* & 8 W/
: 0( Z (% 6 6
X jg p 3bdc [ - 0
! 2 6 (72 6
^T 0
8
"%2C
C =
.
* 6 3bg4
$2 F2
& $2 g9$1 &* 7 ( " Z
! 7 P / TP 6B
$P ZP
&P%
& $2
! 7 /
7
&2 j &2 "
P6 / P r %
! F+P ! $P2 Z+'P *
$8P
!
-(- '%
" 2 }$X [
"2 8 /
$2 &% T
!
$2 /
5 T#:
P P1 Z
&P- 5
$P9 B
Z 3 &W- X gW * > 9 [
$( T +J v( %n E" /. &i$`
/ $4
=
; 7 \$
?
&P2 $87 $8
"P7
„
+ 2 T +J ! $2 & 4 N 4 T
7 + F+
l
& $+…
" 3 $0 { $. /- - PI
/
+ W: "
!
2 ($2
Z ( / 7
"
£(
T +J N 4 P
$PI
"PF%
[
Z +4 $` 7 "W7 N % 7 T#7 / F+ !
l
! "W 1 $+…
TP P2 &P%
3$2
$2 F+ ! 9 57 o2 7 s 2$ ! $+D /
K )7 / F%
+ 7 P9 57 P 4 o
!
+F -" m- J $ /
$2 %
!
&€
+ [
B $ &2
"
+4 $` 7 "W7 N % /- / F+ !
$P87 /P.
P g
7 T#7 F% 7 & n`
l
! "W 1 $+…
T 2
[
: q B
/
$P9 B gP- 5 &%
2
‚ I 3 &2 "
+ T Z ] V D+
$
! O J
! P9 57 $2 $…q
! P &P2 Z P4 +F
=
&P2
r % &2 j
! 0F $4 /
?
$87 $8
;"%
–"
Y
A $2
9$4 q Z
+ }$ &2 &
}$X $ /
2 &%
2 3 "
+ + ]
9$4 +g ] B + 9 57 T
!
&2 Z 4 + J &2 &* 7 2 F +
2 T + 4 T + r %
! P 6
4+
2 +
T %
[
9$4 +g e]
B + 9 57 T
!
&2 Z 4 + D7 &2 &* 7 2 F P++
J "P 3 $ +
P r % TP
!
' * + 4 Z + 2 + T
[
&2 &* 7 2
&6F 6 / { "
$2 &- 5 Z /
9 57 "
! P+
$P87 F
T F% 7 & n`
O J W2 gW- X s ,7 Z
! + J & * F +
2 T + P T +F
{ $O " 3
`"FF%
`"FF% 9 57 +
J F + r % T
! 6 ' * + Z + P &P2 F
f % / 2 7 "F%
+ : q &2 /
Z
‚ I + [
$2 F2
&P* 7 2 Z Z
$2 9 57 o2 7 3$2 &2
! + . F / 2 / P S P gW- X m- J
! gPW *
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -(+ !!!
&* 7 2 $87 2&
$2 F+ ! 9 57 o2 7 w $C
! P $+D /P P:
/
…l7 + nP`$
&P2
/($2 F+ !$2 9 57 N % r
$87 / ‚ I 3 &2 +
[
$2
! l7 "F E 1). 3 @F Z P " "+
! E GPF $4 P
a54 &% / ) S
/ P !$P P 3 > $ ! F, 2 *
&PW- X ZP
T4$` $J Q 3 .
/
%
"B $87 $8 &
+ /
$` 7 gW * +F
!
&P2 'P%
• O ( ( 3 • #-
!
$2 /
$` 7 4
+
€ PB $P87 gPW * F
+ 2 T
„
& 4
!
" 3 T &2 /
7 + P $` P 7 gPW * &P2 +F
)%
$8
!
$ 2 '%
7 &2 ' a
$8 + W7 + + [
W3 $%&
/
2 @F
+
$@ E
! I+
' + 5#7 d i i &F P+
P4 P2 U +
7$7 &P2 &P% TP P+
m
9 7 + x / + [
g e
$
$ 2 +
4 F
+
&W- X N HI
! 8* 7 ( /
OP J PW2
! 1 P * /
0F $4 / - 7 "F $4 + 4 "
+ 4 TWF:
+
!
'% $8
!
; PQ 8* p C
T "
[
&2 &* 7 2
$ ` ‰, E +2 &6F
!
* s ,7 Z P
&P- 5 Z
" 0- ‰4$:
D+
9 57 { $. &2 s 2$ 1 $
! +
( }$X F
+
$P%
[
Z + ($2 &F /
&W- X
! w ( " ; Q
$P2 9 57 2 '% (
! Z P4
&2 +F
= r % &2 j &2
! 0F $4 /
?
$2 /
$%
[
" 8* p C ! '%
$P2 /QF OP J ` ` !
! P9 57 gPW- X
!
T " & 4$` f % F+
[ ($2 /
&W- X Z
• O(
gX2 + 2 F $
&
!
W * / 7 & * { $O GF $4
$`
/ 4+
! +F / '5 /
&%
+ TP
1. Time series data
-((
$2 +F V 7$
/ Y
= e
?†
9 57
! ( /
$2
! +F
! zP + V A P`
eY
= e
?†
$2 /
$2 9 57
! 4+
!
"Wœ2&
! V
€ P + Y
= e
?†
P OP J +F
V PF6
! Y
= e
? 1 4 † +
3 9 57
! +F V%
+ Y V b I
^Y P7 P
! P "P5 F +F
$2 /
…l7 +
$` 7 $2 3 $ V
+
SY
= e
? 2 +
!
&W- X
!
&2 'P
$P0
; Q
"
[ 8
$7
&W- X Z
! ( +
&2 s 2$ N HI $ V
% , `
RY
; P &P2 ! 6
V +4 !$2 9 57
! +
g1 E$… I F
+F
!
@F "PFi
=
&F- P "PFi
?Y P2
M V FI K Y
T
= [?2009
&PW- X ZP +P4 ! P9 57 P
^ 'P%
M 2 / I / !$ !
! P7 e P $2 / o2 P7 "P
! 9 57 +
$2 E : &2 F T " 3$2 +4 N !
[ Z P
! P9 57
T+ 2 g $
! 2 F%
&
J & 2 $+D &2 j +
2 T + T + -"FP: "W7 " 3 F /
&W*$ "W7
$2 `"FF%
!
$I $ + D &2 j &2 F +
$
!
3 "P P@F 5
$9 D m +$
! 2 T,j " 3 /MF T +J T " 3$
[
V
$ % Y 6 / I 55#
+
; 0'
&P- 5 g€ 2
!
; P &P2 V
$P2 P9 57
!
+
0 F
Y 9 57 o2 7 3$2 &2 ;"J
! +
M 2 F
!
$P
! P /
WX5 / '% Z [
- &- 5 Z +
&W- X Z /
&% T +
57 gF P9
! P+
F
" ; Q 0 '%
! 3
. 0 g5XF
/ P P
! S^
P7
o * 3
! T "
[ Q3 /
$ % &%
5#7 Z +
#P: 3 U +
# / P2 P+
1. Doherty
2. Vegas 3. Sluis 4. Mckenzie 5. Kim & Park 6. Nielsen 7. Marco Gambaro 8. Panel-Data Method 9. Cameron
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -(. !!!
7 M
Z /
* &2 T "
!
D 3
+$
/
= Q
!
? o2 P7
8 $% M $@"
QF OP J K M 2 3 g- W T
/ E PW2$ J"PB
W7 +
& 4
=
?GLS
gX2 E : &2e
X(
/ C7 $ + Z
= ]?1990
(ATT/CIN) = 0.12 - 0.23(Pc/P) + 1.04 (RPDI/PoP) + 0.35 PoP – 0.44 CoL - 0.001CIN ? =gX2
D+
$
! ,1 &- W Z E
"
ATT/CIN
] D &P2 j &P2 P+
3 &P% TP & P2 $
2 % "W7 $0 ATT
+ T
!
" & ( $4 +F
"W7CIN
+F
'P P
/
"
.
D+
$
! 5 ]Col
7 "W7
! 0 /
† P 0 'P% M P
]Pc
J+
2 T + T +
† F ]P
1 xX /
J+
T
† ]RPDI
WJ " 3 /
†• C ]PoP
P%
W * +
" '% T _
!
t
- " j
+ 7$7 &2 &
+
oP * gP5XF m
3
! P
' /
"
[ 6B $ % " : B w N'% T
" 3
!
$2 T,j
! P9 5 +
+F [
$W7 &2 F2 M /
$0
!
&2 Z +
&Q /
&% "
+F +
"F P r % $
0F $4 E "(
/
$F
!
" 3 N'%
! 2 + r 2 /
T ($2
[
"* /6
$7"
&W- X Z 3
+ 5#7 +
% E 5 +
; P &P2 b I V
1 P 4 P+
3
9 57
! +F ]
$% †&W- X Y
T P &%
+
E P1 • P#- F
1 P 4 P
P+
3
9 5 + 2 F* $%
/
$% &W- X
"
[
"P &W- X Z P
! 1 P+
3
$P2
! P9 57
!
+ K f % &2 F
! QF O J /
!
$
! /
= e PP S
? P C7 + Z
"
= [?2010
9 57 8 3
! + J &2 T, F +
3 TP 1 &, # N'% 2 T
* * ' + Z
!
$2 ` `
! +
" $% $%ƒ F [
P Z
! ,J P+
]7 P
€"
! 0 ( / 0'
!
$F
! E$ F%
! +5 / P+
P b $
$`$P $ /
1. Dummy Variable
2 Generalized Least Squares
+0
$ M % 5: wC
2 ? L : 4# W ? >M W s# > V >
H 0
-(&
$M7 r % &2 j &2 ; 1 gJ)1 E # P
'P * E "P(
+ P Z + P4$W F /
"P $%
[
& 4
! 7 &% ' 8 3
$`
+ J &2 ‰ 1 F +
2 T + T +
P2 P, A B F
" 3 1 +
2 /
"F s ,7 [
/6 5#7 $0 +
g- 5 &2 &2 ' E 5 V
3Y
; &2 V 1 P * E$…
/ P OP J
!
$P2
! 4 L B N +F
] ZIk †&W- X Y
K M P P2 &P% • OP (
f % &2 2SLS
! WX5 /
= FI
? P.
/
= e P
? P $2 &P2 / gPW- X
$2 $…q 1
! 4
$` 7 "W7 N +
T & ( $I ZIk F [
!
` P% &P2 2 +$
!
2+
N
^ D+
@ 5 $
+
$]
$` 7 "W7 +
J F + WJ T / 2+
$PI "PW7 T P
!
+ Z- "W7 F
! +F
!
$I 4 "W7 _ +
!
& ( M W * P
P+
T
9 57 o2 7 %
! +
C7 F
+
T Z
= [?2008
F‡
+ Z + N HI gF
! ($2 '% ( " ; Q /
$0'P HI 55#
E : &2
!
&W- X / NC2$
!
; Q GF $4 O J
"
&P%
PQF
"W7 &2
! 8
$7 . &% 8 3 Z /
( g "Fi +
$
& 4$` E : $ /
F%
+ [
6 / N HI
` 7 &2 &% / /
V / Y V + / Y 2 +F
!
; PQ $
"P
V C7 + 9 57 Z
!
$2 (
!
&2 Z 4 +F e
$P Y TP
= P / P+
/
S [?
M 2 55# Z
+ 9 57
!
$57
‰,
"
e 3
$2 &%
! -+
2 Z V P7 Y
V
$2 Y I
&
n`
! P9 57 o2 7 " $%
! P+
P F
P
! pP C
C7 '%
+
N'% 3 " Z
! J+
/
" 3
! +
$2
!
;"% $ P
P
% %
" $% &, # ' [
C7 "
+F /
$2 8 3
! 9 57
! + E P: &P2 'P% P% F
gX2 T $ ]
W1= 0/222865 -0/002692 ln p1 -0/226569 ln p2 -0/008427 ln p3 -0/014818 ln p0 -0/016596ln (e Real) +0/469129W1 (-1) ? =gX2
1. Yamamura
2. Almost Ideal Demand System 3. Deaton & Mellbur
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -() !!!
" Z ]W1
( w C
$2
!
&2 Z 4 + D &2 j &2 &% T F +
™ $P4 & 2 $
"
eReal,P3,P2,P1
7$7 &2P0
+ ' m J a "F
+ 2 TP P+
P T +
aP F
J+
$' T &
J a + WJ " 3 d % T /
J v( (
+
"F P TP [
P
„
' %n g- W : B
/ J N'% &% "
+ /
$2
! P &2 Z 4 +
PW F
•
˜
" 3 N'%
! 9 57
! +F
^R
• T [
&W- X
! E 5+5#7 $0 V
/P 1
;"P5 Y
&P2
; V
$ ! F+ ! O J + #7 !$2 /2 i i g€
Y / 7 0'P &P% $ $2
< : ;
=
>
? T " ; Q
= / 1
;"5
^ [?
$ U+5#7 Z
! P
#7 + /
!$P: F1
T( $ NC2
$P ! F+P ! OP J P+ #7 &P% $% / F 2
T [
$0' HI "Fi
$0 V 9
! Y
4 6
S N P F oPX5 $ PI 3 /
& K M 2 &% $% $8
`+
$
!
& (
!
"P $% &W- X " 2 " d C
= 9
! 6
^ [?
& 4
! 2 &% ' 8 3 +
Z + 7
! 7 +
d % gW- X
! y+
$ /
&X2 &
! - " * FW /
2 P+
P 7
!
7
&X2 & Q gW- X
! . &2 † * FW
! 4 2 &%
N P+
P 7
!
7 +
g Q gW- X N Z
N % 3
/
"2 [
V3 Y 6 /
' HI 55# $0
/ PF, /
$P2 V TP,y N P4 /0 P0i /P $2
F+ M &2 $` 7 Y
P9 57 P2
! P+
P $2 F /
TP $P%
= S [?
P Z
: 1 $0' HI
/ I +
&2 &W*$ xX 2 Z +
2 F
D &P2 &P* 7 +
P $ / Pi ]
D _F* Z +
O#7 + E) +
" 3 [[[
M 2 $87 $8 N $I
&P
$2 / Q7
#7 &
+
T $%
[
6 /
; &2 55# $0 V
$MW*
! H Y ' HI ; Q 2 /
F1 T#7 V
! P 6 / $2
; Q
&2 /'C2 ($i
g o 7 "+- 7
…3 N F+
P / E $P WP9 + P T +F
- 7 "
+ 7 "
4 o +
oX5 $
/ I "W2 ,J P+
$
! )P d)P5 /
-(*
$2 &W- X /
T
= S [?
$2 Z 9 N HI Z /
( P pW9 s 5
6'7 g "2 + 7) / F4 /
$*
/ P+
F
! P
6 $
P
!
; Q P 'PC2 /
mP- J 3
`
&F
!
$2 p C /
,7 ++
T Z
[
V J 1 / Y ' HI /
"*
; &2 "
V
$2 / P0F $4 Er P#7 2 5 s ,7 /
OP J
!
#7 f % &2 +
0 , / Y
$ 3 f % &2
! / - P +
&
=
^ PP S^
? P $2 &P2 /
0 , / 2+
r % Z
= D+
$
?
! O J
$9 & ( $I '% GF $4 0 , m
/ P2 + Z
T $% &, # 8 3 [
D+
$
! gW- X
P4 $` P 7 P $0' HI Z
+
d % "W7 '% % F1 2
"* Z
"W7 "
+F
!
T1 '%
!
& $2 NCI
!
7 J v(
+ 4$O T / J+
$M7 T x O#7 + T & $ " 3
= R [?
"* g- 5
"
&2 s 2$ $0 V
$`
/ H Y 6
! F1 T#7 V
P+ #7 /P $2
$2 $…q 1
$ ! F+ ! 9 57 Y
T
= [?
ZP { "P N HPI
P $2 / P 1
Z- +4 " !$2 ,. C T,y $…q F+ !
E P: &P2 P+
"
/ FP
!
2
F+ ,. C N % 1 Z
$+( ! P 3 mP- J
9$4 + }$ &2 &
T $% &W- X $ ]
9$4 +g ] +5 gX2 F+ ! 9 57 "5 2 $4 " 3 [
9$4 +g e]
/ N % F+ !$2 9 57 ( "W7 N 4 2
"2 [
B e / W3B U U
+ r % &2 j &2 F /
0F $4 / r % $ "F
! OP J
! P9 57 PJ $P0 I
P+
$
!
/
"F%
[ Z 9 57 ! u7
! )%
+
ef
&%
$@
g { $O
" w$C "FF%
! PF,
$9 B gW- X
$J T & 4$`
[
$2 A Z P r P% $P !$P2 /P $` P ! $4 ! 9 57
T "(
1 /W2 7
=
$+D
!
?
` ` T
[
$2 F2 Z
™ $4 /
! P9 57 "5 &%
1. The Law of Demand
2. Classic Demand Theory
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -(' !!!
r % 3 T +J /W2 7 r % $ !$2 $4
$4 " 3
= /9 5
? P2 ! r % $ T +J
&
= 6 Z+' * ! r %
?
5+ / +J @
g
$4
= /9 5
? T [
’% $+D &
/M+% !"W2 $+D / T
[
&5+ P $P++D7 $2 ! "W 1 Z+F‡
$…
/
" n`
‰7" 1 &%
,F*
g
/ /0F $4
[ /W * ! 9 57 B
= P2
?
&4 P9 P2
$+D &2 T+W * $+D $%
! r 2 /F#F /54 o * ! u7 U,.
$P4 ! P9 57 o2 7
2&
/ T
" 3 [ Z $2 F2 - W
g 2 % ! 9 57 /
P7 W 6P &P2 gP-
P2 /P9
&
$ E : T
= / 5 R
?]
Qdx = f (Px, Y, P1, P2, PoP, T, E) ? =gX2
r 2 gX2
Qdx
]
!r % !$2 9 57 "5
=x
&2
&2 j
& 2 $+D
?†
Px
]
!r P% T +J
x
= 9 57
?†
]Y
+ +9 5 " 3
†
P1
] P2 !r P% TP +J
&
= P
>
Z+'P *
?†
P2
]
P2 !r P% T +J
&
= P 6 > P
?†
]PoP
† 'P% TP+W * ]T
g5+ P +P9 5
:E
@
! / +J 9 5 +
"F 3 T [
&- W Z
$2 A { $O 4 f+ )% ! u7
"FF%
T { $O $ ! u7 Z U,.
"FF%
= /9 5
?
"P 2 /P: ( "P 3 ! &P%
$P
r % / 9 57 ! "5 &2 T "(
+2 X o2 7 &% "F%
N
" P $2 $j%"B &2 [
A P $P2
{ $O 4 ! u7
f+ )%
{ $O ! 9 57
&2 &* 7 2 `"FF%
P9$4 +&
P
! 6P $P
/
$+`
=
Heilbrun & Gray, 2004
]?
9$4 +g ] { $O " 3 2 "# T 1 &2
`"FF%
= +9 5
?
&P2 PJ P8 3 P7
l Z+
g
& (
"F d C 83 /($2 " ,Q "F + ( ! [
9$4 +g e]
{ $O d C T /5XF `"FF%
/ /W 8 3 /FW P " 3 "PFF%
T 9 $j%"B 7 "F w$( ! . PQF OP J &% "FF% : B Z6 $. (
10 Utility Function
-./
9 ! * &2 T+2 X })X:
T / % &2 $. (
"$2
•/4$OP ! P r % &6F T 8
"F % / 8 T+2 X J o2 7 $4 /
2
"
[
N'% g, # &2 &* 7 2
! e
9 57 p C /
7 + B +
$2 9 57 T
! r %
7 "(
/
"F +
5 F
D ; "% $ 2 &
+
$
!
#7 5 + F%
+ [
$2 A P
N HI
! 2&
" 3 1 2+
$ ' W- X
&
!
" ; Q 2
/P0F $4 ! P r % ! P9 57
$+@ / 1 ]
r % T +J { $O " 3
`"FF%
=
& $ " 3
?
&X ! r % T +J
= Z+' *
6
?
&2
&2 j
$+D
’% !
" 2 J /
$ "P P 0- Z++W7 d C !$+`
&P. 2
2 $…q + 2 PW- X Z /M+% $+D ‹+ &% /- B
&
P
&P 4$0 $PJ &P* 7 P
T [ Z $2 F2
$@ " " ! 0- M-q
@F &2 F+P ! P9 57 o2 P7 3$P2
$P87
$+D 6'
’% !
QF /
+
"
/ T
$+D $
@ &5+ $+@ /M+% ! P
!
+J
&% / / 7
"
!$+`
$%
Z+ C7
"
/ 8 { $:
$@
T "
[ P 1 6 /
9 57 o2 7
! +F
$2
! gX2 m- J $87 $8
= e
?
&9$1 / ]
TQc = f (TPc, Yn , Py1 , Py2 , PoP , Dum ,…) ?e=gX2
&- W Z D+
}$ &2 $
; $ n`
!
"
"
[
TQc
]
$` 7 "W7
- +9 5
+
$87 $8 F+ g
=
&2
&2 j
& P2 $+D
?
5 ! $+D $
]TPc
a T +J
$87 F+ T+ 2 ]Yn
"P 3 v(
$2
! 9 5 + + - PI v- ( " 3 a 3 &% F /
$P2
! P
$8P P( f
!
@F $87 T "
[
Py1
] J+
r % T 'P * E "P(
+ P Z + v( P &P% F
J+
$M7 T
" M $87$8 x
Py2
] J+
r % T v( P &P% P 6 E "(
J+
T % T
/
!
" M $87 $8 ]PoP
- T+W * +
$P87 $8 g
]Dum
D+
Q $
! ' E $… "F /
PF4
! P
!
"*
P ,J "
P+
] P
€"
&
! Q +
"* &2 ' $
$P2 "
! P9 57
! +
&P% TP F
1. The Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility 2. Elasticity
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -., !!!
S 9 57 F% 7 "W2 &2
! +F
&2 $
…lP7 T#7 $87 $8 H +
$PJ $
T [
$2
! D "5 @F Z +
Q $
!
$2
!
! ,J R
$P2 $MP: W
!
"1 F% 7 3 "W2
• #- &- W f /
[
` [
Z E 1). 3 o * K
&- 5
K ` / $2
!
!ƒ o2 F "F aP2
T & C2 % M T / $ F !
[ F‡
+ Z
!
/ P o2 PF +
'%
&
d B ! 3 ! TP+ 2 TP +J &2 s 2$ E 1). $ / !
0 F+
! ƒ
! T " n( a2 [
- &2 +
/ C Q
"P nP( 3
T +J ! F, $2
& I T2 … !
=
?
&+87
"
$` P 7 / P !$P 3
T+ 2 T +J a F+
J v(
+ r % T
! - I " 3 a,7$
/ P9 5 v- ( +
/. $87 $8 /
= P S
?
"P M P F+ ! 9 57 o2 7 Z+ C7
T [ +
#7 +
$2
! 2 a2 gW- X +
D Z + /- P W E PW2$ J "PB K P $
=
?OLS
&W- X &% T
! QF O J /
M 3
/ [ A $2 P
P2 gPX2 K Z +
Z
D+
$
! / 9 57 $2 $…q
!
&2 Z 4 +
$2 F / / B E"
+ T +
" $…q 1 ;"% $ &2 9 57
`+
$
! /
$`
[
K Z
+
$P2 9 57
! Z P4
&2 + D &2 j &2 F +
D & 2 $ +$
! 5 ] J+
T 2 P+
P T + - PI "P 3 F /
J v(
+ T /
! J v(
+
$M7 T
"F $87 x [
4$.
/ Z + vC'P
D ;"% $ $` &% " " ( +$
!
%n
= D+
$
! 5
? D7 "P: f P++
"PF% $
` 3 +
$2 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 + P 8* &Pi "P: "PFi F /
D7 P++
$P% "P ( $ [
F‡
+ 3 gW * Z
! g- 5
P9 5 $4 g $9 B
/ P P4 $` P 7 +
P
!
10 Ordinary Least Square
-.- +
6 $ J $@ T $87 $8 F
/ + g +F
!
d F* "#
$2 $87 $8 d$y <$ %$
/
`+
$ [
"2 8 / +P9 5 4 &% T
=
$` P 7
?
F+ &2 Z 4 !$2 9 5 " 3 $87 W4 ! F+ "W7
+ J+
2 T + J T + T
!
, / 9 57 $2 Z n` $+…l7 • #- &2
!
8 $4
/ )P P GF $4 E T
T + ; 5
` n Z++W7
&P 4$` $PJ &P* 7 P 'P% F+P T+ 2 T +J "FF%
T [
- ! Z
&5,. _I
"F2
! K $I Z "Fi
K $2
> P mP- J pP C
&- W
! QF O J /
" ; Q +
&- W
! T- B " 3$2
` P ` !
; 7 o2 7 /X( /X(
˜
; 7 / 0- m F / 0-
F+P ! P9 57 o2 P7 Z $7
W E : &2 $87 $8 0- { $. g-
/ P 1 6P &P2 Š", ™ $1 "2 /
" w$C $ gX2 ]
Ln TQc = a1 Ln TPc + a2 Ln Yn + a3 Ln Py1 + a4 Ln Py2 + a Dum + Ut ?^=gX2 r 2 gX2
!
a1
a2
a3
a4
7$7 &2 + 2 m +
$P9 $0 D m
+ P $
!
"P 5 P
J+
2 T + T +F
=
?TPc
9 5 " 3 +
=
?Yn
J v( P +
$PM7 TP x
=
Py1
?
&P2
r % &2 j
! ' * +
J v( Z
+ r % T
!
P T %
/
!
=
Py2
? r P% &P2 j &P2
!
6 + T F [
g- W &2 &* 7 2
= e
? + D „FI + D "P &9$1 $ P+
W * $ P+
T
=
?POP
- &P2 P+
FW E)6' Q /
$9 ,
m
" t
Q X(
/
"
P` "
/ 0 P, / P2
($2 / D+
$
!
"P { nB &- W " $0 [
PF‡
+ Z
Ut
)P( gP * PF1 &P2
4 O7 / 4$W "
/
"
[ g 6 D &6F $0 +
W * $ +
* %n " T 0
/ TP "
&- W g $
!
‰, $57 " 3$2 +
! FW gX2 ‹ F+P ! P9 57 P+ Z+2
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -.+ !!!
W * + ($2 Z+ C7 &6F { )($2 "' " ' T /
"
W * P+
&P2 j &P2 T P6
/
$+D
! 2 /- " $` • #- 5 +
" $ '
%nP $+D m $9 " K $2 !
3 • #- l7 ! 3 !
$` { nB / 8 " "' "+
P
"
[ 8 P T PQ _PI
;
K $2
!
C7 ` `
+
&- W > 3 Z
! C7 " 3$2 +
8 Z / o2 P7 "P
$2 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 +F
= r % &2 j &2
! 0F $4 /
?
$87 D f
+ P8i & 2 $
D+
5 $ D f
+
$ /
= Q
!
? gX2 E : &2
= S
? }$ &2
" 3$2 $ [
Ln TQc = - 0.68 Ln TPc + 1.32 Ln Yn - 1.99 Ln Py1 + 1.5 Ln Py2 + 0.52 Dum +
Ut ?S=gX2
$9
m t! 3] ?˜ •e^= ? R•e = ?˜^• e= ? • = ?e•R =
= e
•
= ?
•
= ?
•
= ?
•
= ?
• ] ? FW } X /
=
R2 • S __R2= • D.W = •
` AJ ' ) /
R L 1 2 32 /
'
$ 1 4 &
X
` A
/
;
$ -
" 0& : /
S L- Y /FW &2 &* 7 2
; P 7 "P " Z+ C7 ! $ I m $9 2 P0-
/
F‡
+ 9 57 $ 5 Z 2 Z J v( " 3 T +J
+ r % T
!
& 2
= 'P * + Z
6
? N'%
9 57 p C !
! +
$2 F
!
$% &, # $87 $8 [
Q 3 /
&P%
9 57 o2 7
! + 0- { $. g- W E : &2 $87 F /
$% 3$2 N'%
P
!
9 57
! +
$@ F
9 /
$9 W
D "P 3$P2 m +
P $
! J "P 3 + TP
2+
T +
J F
+ T
! , / gX2
= S
?
"* &% "F
=
? T " 3 [
-.(
"6 d e
` AJ ' ) M A & R L 1 2 32 /
1 4 & $' / % "
- !
:` /
dirs ' D "L
$
( ` A_ "; ` A/&" "L $j-
%
N'•% •S •S - [ 2!KW TXTPc
N'% 2 • e • e [6 . W TXYn
2
N'% • • - W TXPy1^2" 6n T *8 } *8
V H [
N'% 2 •^e •^e W TX Py2 R! & 6n T *8 } *8 V H
[
R 1 >0
$ : q A $2 /
5#7 + U 9$4 &- 5 Z +
$P% }$X &
&P2 &P* 7 P2 &P%
• %n " 3$2
& 4
! 8 3 $9 B N HI /
3
; +
R
$ J d
#
™ $4
H0
] B + /
$2
! 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 + D7 &2 &* 7 2 F ++
J " 3 $ +
P r % T
!
' * + 4 Z +
" * [
™ $4
H1
] B + 9 57 T
!
&2 Z 4 + D7 &2 &* 7 2 F ++
J "P 3 $ +
r % TP P
!
' * + 4 Z + 2 + T
[
C7 &2 &* 7 2 +
9 57 o2 7 Z
! +
gX2 $87 F
= S
?
$P9 g PFW m / P Z
M7 A $2 o2 7 +
s ,7 ‰r & 4$` E : $ P+
P9 5 "P 3 +
P9 57 "P5
!
+
… 2 T,j F
+ FW &2 &* 7 2 ‰ /
$9 2
D m +$
"P 3 N'P% " " 3
!
• 2 &% 9 57 W 3 "5 T "B $7
e
•
"P* UP,. "P &,P # "B
=
?
$2 F2 T 9 57 Z
! + T N'% 2 ‰) % " 3 &2 &* 7 2 F [
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -.. !!!
F‡
+
1 2 Z
!
J 2 N'% 2
+ r % T
! ' * + Z +F + / P7 P2 TPM`
FW &2 &* 7
!
$9 J m + r % T
! 'P * +
gPX2 Z
= S
? P+
• P2 P. Z
$P7
U2 X 3 N'% 2 "B
& 4
! 5#7 + W &% U
^
• T " 3$2 Z
&P 4 P
% B /
J 2 N'% 2
+ r % T
! ' * + Z +
TP $P87 F
[
$2 PF2
> P Q Z
+
&Q /
`+
$
™ $4 &%
H1
% 2
" 3 N'
! 9 57
! +F +
P2 P. Z
J N'%
+ / r %
! ' * + Z + l7 ‰) % F +
nI "
& 4$
/
™ $P4 P2 5
H0
/ [ R
$ J h
#
™ $4
H0
] B + /
$2
! 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 +F
&* 7 2 J &2 + 2 T + P4 T + P r %
!
4 6 +
" * [
™ $4
H1
] B + 7 T 9 5
!
&2 Z 4 +F
&* 7 2 J &2 + 2 TP P+
P4 T + P r %
!
4 6 + 2 +
T %
[
$% &% . P9 57 o2 7 w$C &2 &* 7 2
! P+
; PQ $P87 F
3
! 3 &2 s 2$
8 FW T /
$9 2
m o2 7 Z
&P 4 P
! 5#7 P+
U
3$2 2 s ,7 N'%
! J+
/ 9 57
! +
o. P5 N'P% F
= J N'P%
+ r P% TP
!
6
? ' / J N'% "1 "5 U X "J &% "
+ / fi % 9 57 TP "PB $7
W 3 "5
= S
•
? T " &, # "B
=
"*
?
$2 PF2
5 P9 57 Z
P
&
J a 2
+ T +
2 $87 $8 F
+
%
% T N' [
F‡
+
P1 2 Z
! P%
N'P%
J 2
+ r % T
! 6 +F + / 7 FW &2 &* 7 2 TM`
!
$9
gP- W 3 m
= S
? F‡
+
• 2 Z U2 X 3 N'% U X "J 2 "B $7
& 4
! 5#7 P+
"P* U
=
?
$57 3 U X "J &%
‰,
"1 &2 f e
" &, # Z
4
&
7$7 &P2 P P+
% PB m /
%
J 2 N'%
+ 2 T + T +
J 2 N'% 2 F
+ r % T P P 6 E "P(
+F
-.&
T $87
[
$2 F2
> Q Z +
&Q /
`+
$
™ $4 &%
H1
J N'% 2 +
P / P9 57
!
+ nI F
& 4$
/ - B
/ J N'% 2 &%
+ / r %
! 6 +F
= o. 5 N'%
?
‰) % /
$`
[
™ $4 2 5
H0
F, / J &P2 T, 9 57 "5 2 N'% 2 $2 +
TP
2+
T +
- F
/ 9 57 2 N'% 2 2
! + J &2 T, F +
r % T
! nI 6
&P 4$
/ [
)
$ K
! -
" 3$2 "
= gX2 S
?
% " 3$2 ! $+D m $9 g ‰, $57 P2 U2 X ‰)
"F P P@ TP8* /5XF + m $9 €)1 T F+ ! 9 57 o2 7 f u7 / ,
$2 F2 }$ &2 Z
#7 $ + M7 +$
/
"
]
P MF T )1 &2 &* 7 2 /
$9 m gX2 TPc
+ J a 9 57 "5 +
2 TP P+
T
+
T _61 $87 F
FW / 4 2
P N
J a + 2 TP P+
P T +
$P87 F
$2 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 + N % F /
&2 "2 _61
= 2 T2 … s$ &2
$P $ a
D+
$ [?
Z u7 U2 X > 9 Z
! P9 57
! P )% u +
PJ P2 f
- / 9 57 2 +
l7 +
"
/
†"F%
P &P% T FW "2 Z +F
P+
&P2 j &P2
r % / 0F $4 /
- J
/ s P,7 P2 _61$P2 &P2 &P* 7 2 9 57 2 P+
J+
2 T + T +
$2 9 57
!
&2 Z 4 + I F +
$
! /
"
[
P
$9 T,j T )1 &2 &* 7 2 m
gX2 Yn
+ - PI "P 3 aP 9 57 "5 /
9 5 v- ( +
+
5 $87 F
+ T FW / P4 P2 N P
aP N P%
- I " 3 /
$4 v- ( +
0 +
$2 9 57 •Z
!
&2 Z 4 +F +
P4 TP- B
N
N % "W2 T- B /
"2
= 2 T2 … s$ &2
$ $ a D+
P $ [?
$2 PF2 Z
> 9 Z +
u7 U2 X
! 9 57
! )% u +
l7 2 f
+
"
/ [
"P2 8 / TP
" 3 &‡ Fi
= ' &%
$( E "J "F T $4 "
? 4 N P9 57 ‰r P W "2
!
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -.) !!!
$4 + r % & * E "( r %
! 0F $4 /
@ + P $ +F /P P 7 P4 "
N
"2 [
P MF T )1 &2 &* 7 2 /
$9 m
Py1
gX2 + 9 57 "5
! +
J v( P F
+ TP
T % /
! T _61 $87 FW
/
&2 Er O# Z H
/
! P4 +
r % &2 j &2 6 E "(
+ d # F /
"
[
$2 F2 82 N % 2 Z
! Er O#
$2 9 57 $87 %n
!
&2 Z 4 + 4 F N /
&2 "2 _61
= TP2 … s$P &2
2
$ $ a D+
$ [?
W "2 Z P &2 Z 4 ; 0F $4 &% T F
+
*$P7 F + x
/ 4 Er O# "F +
! +F / - 7 +
"
! m- J /
!
$(
"
!
"PFF%
[ - P+
g &% T 3 & u Z /
! ,7 + '7 E D
$P2 U
! P P4 "
+ P
!
$% • B 4+
/ 3 &% *
"P "P ( $P% "F P
Z NP5 r P%
I 6
+ T $% "
[
P MF T )1 &2 &* 7 2 /
T,j
Py2
gX2 + J v( P 9 57 "5 +
$PM7 TP x
5 $87
+ T FW /
$M7 r % F1 &2 x ' * T "(
+ P Z + d P# F
/ [
$2 F2 4 2 Z 82 N
!
$M7
$2 9 57 $87 x
!
&2 Z 4 +F P+
P4 N
/
&2 "2 _61
= 2 T2 … s$ &2
$ $ a D+
$ [?
"2 Z TP ; 8M Z
9 5 $4 &%
/ +
*$7 F + x / Z 4 r 2 ; 0F "F
&PF P
!
$PM7 K $P` x
$2 9 57
! 2 P( Ty$4 E J $% $I @F &2 "F N % K $`
P+
&P2 $ '
+
&2 " $2 F 61
_ [
P M7 &2 &* 7 2 Z $2 F2 +
#7 $ +
& 4 /P $2 U,.
P+ "P ; PQ ! P
"
"P & ( FP ZP6 " Z $ 82 &2 j &2 %n o2 7 " K $2 • ` ` ! T [ Z++W7 m $9 2 r 2 R2
PW &% " Z S
% PB TP "P:
/
$'7 E "J
$9 x D m +
$
!
C7 5
+ P $` g- W Z +
TP [ P P8 Z
/ '
"B &% "
S 9 57 + $++D7 ":
! +
&P2 $87 $8 F
-.*
x+P9 7 " " /4$W 5 ! $+D g + /P
P [
$P2 )P1 P
Z
FW /
$9 2
m B 83 g &% " t
/ X I } + Z
"P: „FPI $P7 P+
" oJ ,5 l7 ( "
+
"
$0
!
#P: 3$P2 $2 +
P9 57 o2 P7 x
! + TP F [
3 gQ+ A $2 Z+F‡
V 2+
Z
˜ 7 Y
"P1 &P2 fP ‰, $57 &%
e
&P2
"P5 &P2 &P* 7 2 /0 , ( Z " T 6B " 3 T R2
&P% ___
Z $2 F2 " d ( K $2 ' " &, # ":
/ 7 + P: B „ P &2
F% 67 2 "
+ + W7 &W- X gW * &2 " w $C „ +
[
* $-3 / $2
$
& 4
" 3 T &2 „ 9 57 &% ' N HI Z
! +
$87 F
OP J $@
!
…l7 T#7 +
: 1 8i $
/ T ] J+
2 T + T + 9 5 " 3 F +
P $` 7
+F
J+
r % T ' * E "(
+ 6 Z [
Q 3 /
" 3 N'%
! 9 57
! P+
F P Z
2+
$2 F2 T " 3$2 "B $ ' Z
+F + P0F $4 E "P( r % /
r % &2 j &2 /
T " & ( F _% - [
PB &P% TP ; 8M "2 Z +
$` P 7 T
+ D7 &2 &* 7 2 $87 $8 F ++
$
! P2 " 3 + TP r 2 [ P9 5 "P 3 &P‡ Fi +
+F 4 "B f N
"2
= 2 T2 … s$ &2
$ $ a
? + 0 +
$P2 9 57 •Z
! P+
F
2+
N
"B f 4
" ( N T4
[
Z
& 4 2
&W- X /
&%
V 6 )2 Y VI +F
eY
= R
? V 2 ` P Y V
% P + E Y
= e e
?
; Q
"
+ 0F / [ F‡
+ Z
& 4 6B T
$PM7 &P% Z
&P2 x
r % F1
! ' * + Z +
% 2 ‰) % > " & ( F $87 F P2 N'
P Z
B + 9 5 T + + D7 &2 &* 7 2 F ++
J $ + r % T P
'P * E "P(
+ P Z +
@ F P+
$
1. Durbin-Watson
2. Blanco & Pino
3. Garboua & Montmarquette
4 4#5 + # @ = A' +B ' -.' !!!
$M7 2 K $` x +
T r 2 ' Z
/ FW gX2 &% "
! P2 + P9 5 Z + P+
F
$M7 &2 83 Z 4 $87
* K $` x [
Z 2 „
&P 4 P
! 2 P+
$ ' P55#
* ( /
@ +$
] Q /
= e
? V
% 0 + b I Y
= e
? V - % "P +F Y
= e ^
?
V
Z $ $
Y
= e ^
?
( $0' HI $0
/
"F ] V P / P+
/ Y
= S
?
V 1 Q / Y
=
^
? V 9
! 6 Y
=
^
? P+
,X7 P+
U [
$2 PF2
&P2 &P* 7 P2 Z
+ T
` n
! ( + T- $ +
gF T- "F % &2 $M g
OP7 Z + N P%
$2 9 57
! +
I F
/ T " ( [
I Z
+ 8F' / F%
+ P@F &P2 TP- &P%
'7 7 &2 "F % U
! 4+
! +
$2 9 57 ,82 F
! P+
F 2 gP P+
P T +F
T( $I
"
=
"F
$M g [?
+ . Z N'% /% B $87 ! F+ T+ 2 T +J m $9 2 : B „
!$ nI
%
&P2 Z P4 !$P2 P9 57 / +J N'% U X "J /FW T T +J &2 &* 7 2 9 57 "5 2 $2 $2 F+
]
<
S
•
=
T ; 8M "2 Z T Ep
&P%
aP TP +J &P‡ Fi
T+ 2
"2 N % N 4 ": f '% F+
= P 1 $ P " T2 … s$ &2
?
W ": f $ % F+ !$2 9 57 S
• TP4 " ( N 4 N % ":
[
/2 QF
' 9 57 2 N'%
/
&% "
+ TP +J $P++D7 P2 F+ ! 9 57 gPX2 P
"Fi /
"
[
&* 7 2
&2 T- $ Z /
7 T + "
n`
U 'P7 P@F &P2 ( !
& $
TWF: n`
+
"P N 4 m F „ "7 &2 F+ T+ 2 T +J F [
ZP
+4 `"FF%"+- 7 /Q "7 " 3 N 4 |1 2 > 9 P8 3 $ 'P+2 U '7 / F+ !
T+- W4 K $ ` &2
+ " '
/ U "F 3 U4 F+ TWF: &Q
"'C2 [
F‡
+ U,. Z
& 4
! 9 57 "
! +F 6 /
D P 1 $0
+ P $
!
$P2 $…qP
J v( 3
+ r % T
! 6 +
&% T $87 F P
N'P% 2 ‰) P% &PW- X Z
"5 U X "J
"B 3 e
T " 3$2 [
TP ; P8M "2 Z
$P` &P%
P
"PB f
J+
r % T
! 6 +F
=
&%
5#7 Z + J v( U +
P T % T
/
!
&P2 j &P2
-&/
r %
!
4$W 6
/
"
? D7 ++
"F% $ 0 3 9 57
!
$2
! + 3 •$P2 $2 "B F PFW
/ e
D7 "B ++
$% " ( $ [
Q 3 /
&%
2 6 Er O# Z +
J
!
$2
! + P &2 F /
3
$2 PF2 "PF Z
/ 7 B "
+ 9 5 T + 0 $2 3 &2 +
[ 2 &2 + 9 5 $0 +
+
P $87 F
&2 Z 4 2 +
*$7 F + x / P4 Er O# "F +
P
! P+
F / mP- J P /
! P+
$(
"
!
"FF%
[
& 4
! 5#7 NC2 Z +
2 U
& 4
!
$0' HI /
@ +$
] )2
I P6
+ PF
z +
= R
?
% 0 +
= e
?
Z $ $ $%
= e ^
? P -3 P+
‰) P%
/
%l7 ( &%
+
"
! 5#7 % , 1 $2 +5
/ T `" 0 [
aFb S%
P
$4 3
"
= S 8[?
&( # Z
W
*J8 0 1 2 = r , J
2 !J
$87 ]
) GF $4 E
/ E . ,7 $F GF $4 0' HI [
P
%$ f 2
! 8 *
! ) / $
= [?
O J 3
! [
P
$MW*
!
;$8 H
= S
<e$& 6 " 8[?
*8 /8 JI # Q VJ ( J!>(
@. W 2&
2 ! 0
$87 ]I
P GPF $4 E $PF GPF $4 0'P H
) / [
P B + Z 1" # H /
= e [?
! V 2 6
% GK
!
= _ T
"
6
W/8 Y
) GF $4 E
/ [
T ' K `
! OPOC7 /
&P- 5 P
!
`$2
$ "
[
P / 5 / 1
= R ƒI k K[?
$87 ]
& $7 t i [
P 9 Z
= S
* & 8 8 T[?
(&
J
$ Eviews e k J K
"P ] 1 P
t i [
-&- P 9
! Q A ,1 +
$M1 "
! P K
!
=
^ [?
V J8 QP8
! R J!
J 2 0 Z 6
* & 8 6 (%
Z
&(
C V8 ,
r!
Y
% & Q
"2
!
>)P.
P /
S [
P
f+F+ 7 -
= R ƒI k K ^L $ 6 (ˆ[?
E P8 / #, Z B g *$7
t i [
P 3 g F-
! '%
= [?
3 %$
$ [
P 1 Q /
“ "
=
^ [?
V 8 8 @m ^ (C 6
_ H 6
! 2 J 0 Y I P gP
% F /
) 3 0' O J g "
/ 4 "B +
% $ [
P J 1 /
&F8%
$8
! WMX- /
= R 8[?
n(+ ^8 H Š k K
6 J8
%+ 52T
! $ 2 ^ N
/
; " * $F GF $4 #7 &W 7 [
P / 1 /MXOP ;"5
=
^ 8 8(# # QL [?
0 6 2 ! 6 k K^!%+ 6 P I
gP
/ F %
< : ; 0' "
=
>
[?
P
$`
/
F 9$ )y H
+H
!
C2 3 H
P+
!
= [?
V
^J!%+ 8
^J (C
8 @m 6 2 ! 6 _ H 0
Y P 1 g F OP4 $F GF $4 0' HI /
P 'P HI / gP
0F $4 N HI /
8 [
P j+ /
= R k K[?
$87 ] t i 3 [
P jP+ /
= R _ H V8 [?
6
! C( P O T 2 0
"P ] 1 P
t i [
P / +j +
&#
+ /
= S [?
V 2/
! _ H R 6 8 (& I 6 J *8 R
! 2 9c
0 0 Y 1 g F O4 /
' HI / 1 * 4 / ' e^
[
P
& $2 W _+€ ! $, E @ !
8 *
= R
?[
& M
$2 &
&
eS^
[
P
/ ) GF $4 E
= [?
P T W +F / E PW- X $P 4
&P $2 P
!
- W4 + T
! +F /
!$O2 /W E W- X [
