BOOK REVIEW

BOOK REVIEW

fnu ns. 5'szTwfd' guCnGu

Rabin, J., Jildreth, W.B., Miller, G . J. ( 1 9 9 8 ) . Handbook o f Public Administration, 2nd ed. New York:

Marcel Dekker, Inc. 4 7 ~ 3 ~ 1246 ~1&dn61;4 ISBN 0-8247-0086-4 97R7 15,160 U7M

-

a ~ r p ~ u 5 n 7 I u s o u

I oo

il lcilurd

( I 880s-i egos)

~OunqonunauZC;duaa

~ ~ ~ n ~ s n i l u ~ ~ n n a h m ' ~ v l d ~ i ~ ~ d a w " ~ u ~ n ~ s u a ~ ~ ~ a m 4 6 l u ~ n f i a s s d Uveges

w 2 w c ' 4

UR: Keller

~ ~ ~ u u ~ a a b a l ~ ~ ~ u n ~ b ~ u a ~ m

3 ~ d L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d ? ~ d f ~ f i l ~ p d f i i ~ ~ f l ~

fiM?~fl~u?nlhI6bbfi

The Conflict of Factions Model(COF), The Rule of

4 w c r

Factions Model (ROF) bLR: The Public Interest Models (PI)

"11~~jrwuGuni187u LLdLflId~dLd~

"Search for Governance" I P ~ U W ~ 2 Holzer & Gabrielian

I I

U M ' I ? M U ? ~ ~

Rutgers ~ 7 ~ f i l d ~ b ~ ~ ? ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ M s & i r n " l ~ ? ~ d ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 5 nu9

CuI6ur-i

1)

n~aflm?~u7ad;a&msld flunaw ~mziin~sW"7~7uGnwnr::

mhufiuqsiiq

2)

~ d ~ w u n ~ s u ? ~ ~ n ~ ~ 1 u m a ~ w ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 u d s z 3 n Z n i w I u n ~ ~ W " ~ ~ i u

3)

n~tL!adLuzn7sfivumu~uu7uw"rLunn'u1daan

4)

uua21mnwAnw7wq'intsu

uywu'~,a::

5) au~~mLiuan'udsz~w~n7wuBd~dtLbnsuv?a~ntdn7fw"~7u7~

naud 4 n i 9 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . 1

nrwd

^{7 Gist} ! 6 n 6 1 ? $ d ~ ~ ~ ? ~ " u ~ d n 7 9 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4

l u n ~ o u ? w ~ t ~ f l ~ f m u ~ " 1 1 a i ~ n ~ s K m ~ ~ l q ~ ' i m a a u q u i P m u ~ s ~ n ' ~ l n 1 s ~ n w ~ 5 j d s z

d

w~fiuw?fiws'

~biluu!6~ns1zh1sKmlul~~u~~4yu"11adfiw?~u1n1tfmu~~i\1~~u d?dL?a?kdur~iriauLflmfidms7ufanm:ili 2

d?d

^1945-1970

nqsKmi?uh&7u~u

dtz~qm&quu1uului7~dtzbnw

n q 4 ~ u i i a n 9 7 ~ ~ d ~ ~ 1 p d q ~

^1970s LIZ I 9805

~ ~ Y M I I d 8 McGowan

bbaz

~ i t t m e r

!6nd7?$d~dLb~l~lnlf Km8ulq n?z¶.J?~nls6ma~

k dtz~~uh~d';a~fludsz~~"11~d~~3~n~tdd~ulsji6a~n~sKm~ul~

5

dtznlt d

~ i / u ~ ~ ~ 5 u n ~ s K m ~ u l ~ l u n ~ s u ~ ~ s ~ ~ i i ~ ~ ~ I & ~ ~ r i n ~ ~ ~ ~ m s ~ z G 6 u ~ u ~ ~ a z n a ~ u ~ u d ~

4

-

nis?lYuri~dguwnis tzuulayndanisu?wis n i ~ G w ~ s ~ ~ a z n ~ s ~ i \ r ~ r u u ~ 3 ~ nnqns' nisu?w7tqmn7w

naud 5 u s ~ ~ i u l w i r s ' u s l r w G n ~ i u ~ a ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ 9 Layer

1 6 6 ~

n ~ ~ ~ i i t ~ ~ n s r u u n z u ~ u ~ n v a ; ~ n ~ n ~ l u u s i a z r j ; ? ~ ~ ~ n ~ d f i z w " a u ~ ~ n ~ r ~ Q u ~ m

q7nn7s~d$uuLLdad&~~~fitw~~"1

& ~ m ~ ~ r n z n q t i i a ~ a ~ ~ l u ~ ~ ~ " ~ ~ a f i w u ~ ~ 4n

~qd~das'gu q m y ~ u f i q ~ n d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ s d j E d ? t ~ u ? ~ " d n 7 ~ ~ u ~ 4 m ~ ~ ~ u u ~ 6 a ~ u ? u ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ' u ~ d u n u ~ n " u a d s ' ~ u ~ a 1 u d a d 6 ~ w " i j ~ ~ u ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ u b w s w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a z ~ d a u

d

lud9.r

I 930s

ndd

wa~rjiin~~oanba~1'd6un7dn~wu7urPi~d~w"~~u?~adn'u

~~od.r~u&a~wiab

urnsn7tuntnadd?ubw~a"IIad?j

l u d a ~ u ~ ~ u i i s ~ L u ~ ~ m q t a 4

3 d , A' d

n7~fi?idnittatzuub~azn7snn"IIu7m6?~dn~u~bnm"~~u"dd 1990s

h ~ w n

10 Carter

n 6 ~ ~ i i ~ n ~ t u ~ w ~ s ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ n s l ~ ~ m 5 ~ i ~ ~ n ~ s ~ d ~ u u ~ ~ d a ~ ! d ~ d u ! s f i ~ ~ Wimz

~flulu~iwasnql*j L L U G ~

dsz~Ruw"~$ud?w~nw?q7ssld'

Tmu(~iiuu~~47iiPI

d d

nis5qismq

5

dsz~Wuwa'n I6~~r-i nis61wum riu?~rnn~nu?n'Yqm~stu~~nznis

d d

d j ~ d r z u u s i a n ~ o r i w r u i n i ~ X ~ u ~ r s c ~ i u B w i r f ~ ~ n z n ~ t ~ n a a u ! w ~ ~ n ~ ~ 5 u qnm7wlur\o7uC/viq~qu Irii~qz~iluao~gdlqnszuaun~sniu nvbun?ad

K ~ u n u a a a w G n n ~ ~ ~ ~ w a ~ ~ m o ~ ~ 8 ~ ' 6 r w " s n ~ w w ~ ~ ~ q ~ s t s b 1 d

nisfiii\rn"7uiqnqsrPim

sodarnzrji~uwqm~miid~~1u~auid"11add1uad6nisn'uwld'n~~u~unszua~n1~"u~d d

" ^{9 $4 d} dl

U , N ~ W & N V ~ ~ ' ~ I ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ u ' P ~ T ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ A ? ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I " I I W " I I ~

~ o u i ⁶ s ~ u o u R I ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ R ~ ~ u ~ N ~ ~ u ~ ' ~ Z I ~ ~ U ~ ~ U ~ ~ Wright

IUUM~

^{1 I} n ~ i a ~ ~ ~ u i n i ~ u n ~ n a i u ~ u ~ u f i ' t z u ~ i ~ t z u ~ u

" - 4 C

Allw'pdfi?J (Federalism) i i ~ ? ~ U i ~ ~ l ! ~ d L L U U L d ~ ~ t ~ " i d ~ ~ ~ w ' ~ f i t ~ ~ L U ¶ ~ A ~ I U ' ~ U ~ ! ~

4 r l - d

6u~6unitl.a"~iuiq~~m'u wsawu~nwmzw?nw q::ddwa~a&uw'ufiniwtzuii~

? ~ ~ i a I u a d ~ u u l m aiG ~edYunitjauianit~b2i4$~ nit%~lua"aw?un'umiu

ti d

~nwmz~a.~wuw u ~ a v ~ i d a n i ~ n a i u & u ~ ~ 6 4 n i i a d 4 w a i ~ n i t u ? u i t < m n i t

&

t ~ ~ ~ l 4 ? ~ U 1 ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ l h L Y Y ~ i ~ i ~ ~ d n i ~ l l n b u a d ~ ~ d i l 4 (top-down management)

LL~:/cl?fl ^{L L Y u ~ ~ ~ T}ti ^{~ ~ ~}(bottom-up approach) ^{~ ~ ~ L ~ Q ~ Y} ~L!U~&WUIU?U ^u

~ t t ~ ~ l ~ d ~ ~ l n l t T ~ 4 9LWlUlT~dnl9fi~&l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ' ~ ~ ? ~ 1 ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ R ~ ~ ~

quntzk4~,.,4~~dii~~nia:~q3~n"iac161 iinitu3uit<mnitwkruin~ii~~~du1t u w u i ~ ~ a i u 8 ~ w i a s ' ~ d ~ ~ u ~ i i 4 ~ ~ : ~ ~ i d ? ~ u i a (Intergovernmental relations 14%

d , a

IGR) M Y U L L ~ ~ J 1940 ~flu6uui

L L M ~ ~ ~ U ~ I Q ~ Y I L ~ ~ " U ~ I ~ T : : ~ ~ I ; I ~

^I 960-1 980 v a ~ IGR

~ ~ w ' W ~ l N l " n d L ~ ~ ~ ~ n l t ~ ~ t l l t t : : ~ 1 ~ l 4 ? ~ ~ l a (intergovernmental management- d - 3

IGM)

~~~af6uiim'y~w~nm~ulua~?ga~u?nitzuii~S

I 980-1 998

d d

~uuww 12 Leach ~ ~ ~ ~ M F J W ~ P I ? ? ~ ~ L L ~ : : L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ I ~ ' Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ' U

n~w'uss'guaznaiu&uw'us'~t~ii~?~uia n i ~ ~ ~ i ~ i l u d i u i q I u n i t d n n t ~ 4 , t z ~ i i ~ ? j u i " " u Y ?guiaua?~/ni9dnntaddau.Jia~tu 3wZIunitdnnsa~q~~a aadua?j diul~~unl~u~rri~1ub~iaz.Jia;1i diuiqtauquriua.r?~uianai.~

uaztzuauamrius?g~~u~lusjd~nit~m~tt~~i~flun"iuumiiuiqmiuuwuiw

r d r

uuiw1aadivifm~qu

wow; 7 ~ 1 1 ~ m ~ ~ i i 6 a u u l u u i u

IUUM~

13 deLeon & Overman ~ & n ~ l a ~ d d t z ~ f l l ~ m f ~ ~ 4 f l l ~ ~ f i i ~ ~ n ' ~ i / u a ~ o t n ' u u f u u i u $ y * ~ i u u n d i a i i ~ i l u n i a m f C / ! a ~ m ~ u i a u i u u s i

d t L ~ f l l ~ m f $ ~ u (a long past but a shot history) L i U d 4 W f l ? f t W L ~ i l $ ~k awtiufonnidn'2 ii~iamf~Liluau?wuinitw"uun'unia::LL~n6a da

R i d ~ 3 d

aniwflryui w i a r u i n i ~ ~ ~ u r i u ~ ~ u l ~ w ~ ~ k ~ ~ ~ ~ d u ~ e i i ~ u i n n i t d t r ~ 5 u ~ % 1 nisduqnu~ouiu/Intanit ~.rLiluWaluLd~dqinflq<unaiuw$au-rnaiu

Y ^{r r}

uimr~nauaa~khulu~~ia::qnaCu ~ r ! u w u 1 u i u l v ~ u u ~ ~ u a n i t 8 n w i

Y rrl r sa

~ u a u i u a ; l ~ i a n ~ w ~ i u ; l n ; l n a i u ~ ~ u a Q a ~ l n ~ n n ~ ~ a n i ~ " ~ ~ ~ ~ n u n ' ~ ~ n n ~ ~ i i

"policy orientation"

aniuniwua~~iamfuIuui~~utzuz

1950s 1960s

dL6u

d o 4 4 3

n?7~~flua~;jnu1n1snm1udndan7~.ilsyw1aad8dmuu~~n7sau1uaau~a~~uaw~

n i s A n w i ~ n i s ? ~ n s ~ z w ' ~ ~ a z n ~ s d s ~ ~ ~ u u f u u ~ u P m u ~ ~ w ~ z l u d

1960-1970

i12

4 4 9 " *

n~?u4um'?dszaurnqiuii J ~ u ~ n d e u r ~ i l ~ u 6 ~ u s z r i u u ~ s ~ ~ u v i d l u ~ $ d f i u 7 m

~~az?;3l~?aqmniw n?s4?G~ii.~assndszPd n ~ i ~ ~ f l u W I ~ u n i s i i ~ C u n i s

nwiurqnanw~uulu L ~ r ? n 7 ~ d d 7 6 Q 7 n ~ n 7 9 L ~ ~ d d d d ~ ~ d ~ f 1 7 ~ ~ ~ & 7 ~ ~ f ~ ~ 7 ~

l & ~ r i

a ~ n s ~ u i o ~ n ' u n ~ ~ u u ~ n ~ u d ~ n n d ~ ~ w ~ i 7 ~ f l o d u ~ u u 7 u ~ a u a ~ ~ ~ a z w ? ' ~ w a

d

wwn7s~i!ad

a7n~fl7wu~un~si7~Cun~sd.a'nL~uLLaz~a7u~~ufia~iau5u

&q~GuZdouuaodiimaa~qn ~ ~ i r W i 1 f i n 7 w d n q s ~ ~ r i n l t ~ u u ~ ~ u 7 n u ~ u a.molu

~ U R U ~ U A ~ ~ ~ ~ Q T - J ' * ~ a ~ ~ l a $ ~ n n ~ ? n q ~ n ~ s ~ ~ m ~ n a u w ~ i ] ~ 7 u ~ 7 ~ u (1973-1978)

ludq~nplstsa 1980s ~nuiduad8u1um1~ud7~~a~aaadfl7aLal$u~uu7u b j 7 q z

~ i l u l u r ~ i y u a e ~ n q a d t z ~ ~ ~ u ? ~ ? % f i ~ d u a d ~ ~ ~ f l u ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ m ' q m u n ? ~ s l d ' ~ $ d bwq ~$9

0 url * c.4 w

~ I R L Y ~ ~ $ U ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ w u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a u f u ~ ~ ~ a l i i l s ~ ~ a ~ n ' u n ~ s u 3 ' ~ 1 ~ s ? ~ 7 i a1R Rnwliid

~rjyun"?u.j.,ufissuuazdi~uu d?~syinid8dau * ^I nistdnil q?usssu~unisu'ivlis

4 4

-

^Y

LL~?.Z~U?TI~W ~ l l ~ w f ~ ~ u u 7 u ~ u ~ ~ u " d d ~ u ~ ~ ~ n w 7 8 u ~ ~ "policy in quiry" ulnau

y"~i;uuafdliil au~mmaa.r~~an$uFuu~uis"un'um~~ua~u~sn~~ldds'udszyn6

l . a " ~ u a ~ m ~ i u n " a ~ n i ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ s u 3 ~ 1 s ~ ~ a z ~ 1 . j n ~ s ~ i ! a ; 1 " ~ a ~ ~ u a ~ u i n n ~ ~ n 1 s ~ i d " u ~ d

uuuao~n~am~u?u'rqn~w%nitwi.iia~~"~~3.1~~~dszin~

'Luund 14 Nsgel & Teasley, 111 iquTiU76d?im~uua~i7.j7~nu~n'u d

n l ~ ? L ~ 4 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ 1 f i 7 ~ ~ ~ (public policy analysis-PPA) ~ 6 ~ d 7 d n f z q u . a ' f l ~ ~ 4 ~ i i u u I f i f i n ~ ~ u a u l u a a . ~ PPA il igun7silnwZ~an7w ~ ~ ~ w q m z w a d L ~ m q l n

d 3 w r l

n ~ s d a n l . a " u f u u ~ u a ~ f i ~ s m z n a ~ u ~ s n w ' ~ ~ s m ~ l X ~ a ~ n ~ a ~ u ~ ~ ~ y u

luunuy~auu 414 5 yuuaai7bl~~Id1~~uxi ~9111*1aL~U7::(optimality) ~ a d n ~ s ~ i i ~ u ~ ~ 4 ~ m t r i l u

~u?~~n.ilsyw~luni.jd~~l~i~un'u~Ei~~id"au

3.ilsywi I 6 ~ ~ r i 11 nmu.n'y4auae~

an~wilrywlii~uuIuu7u 2) n~~ulriuduau$t8uL6adu7q~nnq7uLdudLLazn7s a~~~~mau;'ilqa LLE 3) na~~ria13i~Zm~ssnwa (effectuality)

I~+I~zL~~uR~?UPSOLI

d w c r

47, (simplicity) (my n~lund7qi7~fluazlsduqnnil KISS-Keep Simple, Stupid!)

d 3 4 r d w

viu~?a7 L U ~ ~ R I ~ U L ~ U ~ W ~ ~ un~?7UuLauu1mm1mnsz.a'uLvlu71n'uqdau1q1u

I r c Y w 0 4 w 4 w

sz~Guu?-$~a, PPA ~~!uulm.alw~wun~~ah aai.ln'maaauinz~ztBuuG

maud 8 nqsGvns3iir ~ ~ J L ~ ~ u u L G u Y L L ~ z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I u u d I 5

& ^{w =}

c ~ e ~ ~ 1 m a b b ~ u 4 d i l n ~ s d ~ n n ~ n ~ s ~ d ~ u u 1 , ~ d a d % u ~ a ~ u ~ 6 ~ u ~ ' - ~ ~ f i ~ n ? ~ u ; ? ~ f l u & s dadn'P1aiu~u~3ilnGuubiuu nwu~vdau rnaiuumnii~aa~n~ Anis uluuiu

dc P Clq

uaznw<mnqruqnuu ~doqzl8i~~udrzlurrisian7s?mnqsd~~maa.jmu~ad lmuy' duuszyi;da~rnsbldC6qo dddwa'ld Comparative Public Administration (CPA)

&hnduuuaflmiYdGu (nuiq~nn?ma.rrinia1nis~1,aznis1w"~u~~u~v7aua~ii~

3

~PILYIII) L U T ~ ~ U L I U ? Am CPA ku?bidnivun "public choice" q l n ~ u n l d

~fiswgn~am5$~waiaa.~An~s nqsi~nomkuu Fiqqsmqq~nimussoua~An7s

n ~ s d ~ ~ d s z ~ u s ~ r n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ t ~ l ? ~ i s ~ i u ~ n ~ a nis<m;luds,uu~m~~aznitu3v~s n7~fiusrua%va.i a n ~ w nai~l8uw'uS'sz~41.j~j~~ana~~n'u nisdnnsa4d~uM"a.~Zu d?uM"?uuatun~dau~6ni~?~i]bbu?~pid"u 2 dtzmsddnng%u 5 f l v k l nfhaza n ~ s ~ ~ u ~ r u n ~ w n ~ 3 1 p ; i ~ 3 v ~ s ~ ~ a z d ~ z 3 ~ Z w a " u a . ~ f n s . ~ n s uu'nw3ryiiuba4qripl

nwn~sljmadn,m?'

n m z n ~ s d a s ~ ' n ~ o u a ~ n ~ n F g w u ~ u ~ u w ' m u ~ d t z 3 ~ 5 n ~ w n~s~qila~lilw"Gn~qufd$~Ia % ~ b a I j ~ C / d 4 m n ~ w d s z n a u n ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ t < m n ~ t

Iuund 16 Heady ~ a u ~ d t z ~ ~ u i i d ~ ~ l ~ n u a u " a d n ' u n i s u ~ v i t ? g ~ q ~ ~ d d d

1 , G u u d u u u a z u ~ u ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m z ~ f l u ~ ~ u a ~ q ~ s m ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 ~ u ~ l 3 u ~ n ~ s u 3 ~ ~ s ? j ' i q radabrisnir ~ f l u n i s ~ n r n ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ u u ~ d ~ ~ ~ u a a ~ n i s ~ l 3 ~ ~ s ? ~ i i ~ a ~ ~ d s z ~ ~ 1 1 r P i 1 ; 1 ~ h ' l u o f f m ~ a z i l q ~ ~ u nsaudirirunqs nisnuwrnn?iui !mn?iuaiu~.mao.r

d d

~ ~ z m n n s z ~ u n ~ r ~ m u ~ ~ a u ~ u ~ ~ u ~ ~ 2 uatunn?qudrj.r~qqsm~nqsu3vqs~'g

9 nqua;lvldau\rl7u~Gmaqubflua7na

l m u 5 q ~ s m ~ + m n a ~ u a ~ u ~ s n I u n ~ s i ~ n ~ u n ~ s

~~u?lbuua;lnqsd?u ~ d ~ u u 1 u ~ u ~ n

w

maun d 9 n ~ ~ u ~ m u t l i a w u a z n ~ s z t i u u ~ a G ~ K u

YMVl d 17 Rosenbloom n677'lQng~~l~n74dn~fa~ (administrative law)

riungsz~iiuuCaujni, ~ d a ~ q ~ n n g v u ~ u n ~ s d n n s a . ~ ~ z ~ f l u n a 1 n d l + n ~ u ~ u n ~ s u?vw?giiq Wiqqz~fluunngvuqu B a s s u y ~ iqk~aaddluu;rnt t ~ m a u

nffnmu nwCd6uI3 unn~qu6am'l~dsz~nqam5Mqdngvuqudnntad'uad R I l ~ ~ ~ n l 5 ~ 7 w a d d w n i a w ' m u ~ n ~ s ~ ~ 4 n ~ v u ~ u n?~uvuquuazilryama.r n g v u i m i ~ d n n m d ninj,6uHngvuqmisdnnsa.j finiiuuklflfinsau u u ? ~ m a n ~ n ~ o l j d 6 u % ~ n ~ s z b i i u u ~ d a d s z f u a u ~ ~ n ~ ~ u 3 v ~ s ? ~ i i q Iuriluaa.run y'~~~ul~~ns1z6ngvu1un1~dnnsa.~ua~~vF~a~u3n1 luniaznnatpniuuil

1980s i d 1990s r i a u V l q z ~ l u n l ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ l ~ m 1 l ; i M ' 3 7 ~ d 164

und 18 CWPLI n d l ? ~ d d O l l ~ U d 1 6 s M ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ M " b i i ' ~ ? $ ~ d n ' f l

nl?U?Ml5'?~~~

^{~ L ~ I U G V ~ P U R ~ . J I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " M ~ ~ ? U ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~}

riir7uqrranq~li6iula"

r3no:~un'~7un1~d~uTn"~~d4aiin'ni~~uinuiu 1B;ari

6qniuLi/u?5un?quaauB;qungMuiu (legitimacy)

uadnlonsounro4dwis67~

w -la

~ u ~ n ? q ~ s ~ ~ ~ ~ a o d ( n ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ ~ . ~ l u u i ~ ~ k d ~ ~ z ~ f l ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ a d n

1 1 ~ : r ~ u ~ o ~

noud l o n i s r o u ~ n u ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ i ~ w ~ i ~ n i

und 19 Laudieina ! ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 d 4 z ~ n 1 9 ~ ~ ~ ~ l u ~ S d t : f l l ~ u f l l ~ m ~ w " b ~ a

i ~ a z n " o u i ; ~ ~ ~ : G f l i a m 4 " ~ ~ ; 1 Q ~ d ~ z ~ i ~ u ~ i a w 4 & a u ~ i d n ~ ~ ~ ~ u f ~ niouddaun aqul

ni~rd~uuud~d~r.du!5'fi7.j a z d a u i ; d d k ~ l q n ~ n i ~ d ( r ~ u u ! q m

rd ⁸ d

d~:a~dw"$ey

~ r ~ . ~ d ~ z G ~ ~ a m ~ p 1 u ~ n ~ s i n g ~ u u a . ~ n i ~ a o u Q ~ d t z ~ 1 a u ~ ~ a m 5

*=i 2

&El

n f l ~ ~ L ~ d L f l ~ 5 ' l u n f l ? f 5 ' & 7 ~ ~ 1 ~ b ~ ~ d U ' b M ?

bd<U~bbdWdbd~!5'1filQ ~U5'zdfLEI:40

ilrrsn

(1 880-1 920) n l 4 ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ? ~ d t : f l i ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ f l U ! d ~ ~ ~ $ l d ~ l LLW:

n~:.j,nt:qiu

iiarilunltrio2d

vilunals~~lurdijuurrdw~iid~6ua4~.jnu 9 ~ ~ 7 d =a

l d d ~ i ~ r i i ~ u a i r 8 o ~ ~

Wilson (1 887) "The Srudy of Administration"

adnnail

! u n u ~ n l u n ~ s ~ w s z u u n ~ ~ ~ u u n i ~ a o ~ & i u ~ r f l u ~ ~ u n r&n1~8nwqlu

," t

irldw!nit~kdauinu3~~qam4oru~nuvu sulnu~$anloddra?unif~nau~u

Li&5'zLIfltlanl5'$U dddatrlnWluLflU

The American Society for Public Admin- istration) 5'11 1881 The Wharton School of the University of Pensilvania

firflu

d ~ u o n v n ~ u a ~ r j n ~ m ~ ~ ~ u ? a i 6 r i / u ~ ~ a ~ n ' ~ n 1 ~ ~ l ? ~ i ~ ? ~ Z ~ f m u r ~ ~ 6 n 1 ~ ~ u n i ~ n r j ~ d _-

7uS

1900 simu~m~s~urdurunB;iuni~u?~i~Q~Zqn"!&Qun~~~Guriuo~ Goodnow , ^a ,"t

d n ~ ~ < n ~ ~ d ~ u n ~ ~ u " u u 4 i u a u

8 ~ r ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ r u 3 n 1 ~ ~ ~ z r ~ n a o u n 1 ~ ~ n o u t u ~ 1 ~ ~

& ~ u u r j n g m ~ n ~ o i p a u n ~ ~ w o u u a ~ ~ n ~ G ~ w ' w ~ ~ $ ~ ~ ~ a n ~ ~ r u * u ~ ~ ~ o d " ~ 1 d 7 f l & ~ 3 ~ iouuiqinnwriiav?nu~ni~ uiiilqei amni,:gyrdu r~uds:iln~nlw'lunv

$ 7 ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ W ~ d d ~ f i ? ~ ~ ~ ~ z l q 6 1 d ~ t f 8 1 (L;UM<I PODSCORB

~ f l U ~ t I l ~ d 7 6 ~ ~ l ' i 1 ~

~ & n g m 5 ' i i o d u ~ h n l t u o 4 n 7 5 ' ~ ? ~ 7 ~ < m n q s (r!uuudn$i?<q1u5':uz~?~dtz

~ ~ I ~ U ~ ~ ~ W W ~ ~ I ~ ~ U B ~ W I L L M $ ~ W d (locus)

!bild

(focus) ~ ? ~ L ? ~ ! M J ? M ' ~ ' % ~ ~ L L W Z

n i 5 ' a a u ~ d ~ r r ~ ? s d ~ u u o d ~ ~ r f l u d i ~ ~

d?uqnd~nltuhd*?d~6.rl~5':~1flu

d

PODSCORB ~ f l u ~ o ~ q n ~ ~ i l f i ~ ~ a m 4 ~ ~ u n u i n q i n n ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ s ~ ~ ~ q

q n s i i ~ ~ : ~ i i a

lfiLLd'i~2yaJad~

d

Lflud?:PtITi.ld' %uw'

Administrative Science Quarterly 1 960s LLlUd

r r u ~ u i u u a a d w i n u a ~ m q i n ~ i a m ~ u ~

u w ~ i n u i b uirffdmaau

school of

Administrative Science 1970s L ~ m f d ~ ~ ~ n s u n 7 s ~ a l d ~ w a 7 n ~ a l u \ 6 ~ u n a ~ u ~ u u ~ u ~ ~ d

8nw~~~lus:6uficycy~mi~~az~mGm8nw~ina~u~nwau~~a

4' 2

6qu 6quuik

luquaauLymnqs8nwqa~qdnaquwaqnvIaquuqnid$u

h ~ ~ d q w d r l ~ t ~ w q

u ~ m s j ~ u ~ ~ a z n ~ n a ~ u ~ ~ u ~ ~ n n ~ w a a ~ w G n q m ~ cl

rdqn!auiiwanmkirqza?o

Qvind~anGnwofl?r&u~nnii

dau~nudda~~"uadnniuanw~&iu$gdszfiiau

~ I ~ ~ ~ $ ( N A S P A A )

m n a ~ i a ~ n ' u u n % ~ ~ ~ ~ u a n i . ~ n ~ s w ' ~ ~ u i ~ ~ a z u i m s j ~ u " 1 1 ~ ~ ~ G n q m s

~z6uY'cldGm8nwq uazausrnuzlu?uiadw$u

ImurinruminrGnqmtuqmtsqumas

~"uallLWI5 6X.J

^{\6kfi 1)} ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 l ~ n ~ ~ L ~ a d - k d ~ ~ - L f l 9 ~ ~ ~ ~ " u ~ . j ? j d ~ ~ n 7 ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ ~ 2)

~n~a~i;ad~fiu~muazqcldn~w~w"adaulun~szjLns~zw'

3)

mawLdduuLLda.rlu

~ ~ 6 ~ q ~ ~ 8 - n d ~ - ~ ~ a z 9 d 6 n 7 ~

4) ~ I ~ ~ . ; ~ ~ ~ I ~ ' V ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ U L L ~ ~ 5) 3 7 0 4 7 ~ 6 1 ~ n 7 t

Qn~suaznqou?w~r

l u t ~ ~ : ~ i i ~ f i n a ~ u a u l ~ 6 ~ u u ~ u u ~ u a ~ ~ ~ s m z ~ ~ ~ " u u a 6 d ~ ~ L ~ ~ ' b 6 ~ 7 n n l ~ ~ $ u w ' ~ 1 ~ ~ 7 5 ' Policy Studies Journal b6aX Policy Studies

d d

Review

67tlBail

naanuqiu~naquLuosz'ilqn'u PODSCORB

di;aLguL~uau?iim 6~Wudiuli980s

~ n 1 s ~ n ~ s z 6 u ~ c y [ y ~ f ~ ? u 6 i u ~ j d s z m ~ a u w i a m f i 0 192 ~ d d

n~u'l~lduuun~sdsun~saaud~Lmnd~dn'u o ~ w c o s

5

LLua 'bkn'

1)

fdsuntud

iiaWjn1a.f

2) n c l n ~ ~ u n a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ l u n m z Q ~ d ~ ~ f i ~ ~ u ~ ~ a m Q 31

iifds~msu

d.d Y

v I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ / n ? ~ ? T i l ~ ~ b ~ ~ v I 7 ~ 9 ~ ~

~q3.l

4) ~ ~ ~ L ~ T u ~ ? s ~ B ~ & I ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ B I ~ ~ ~ L L ~ ~

5)

1 ~ s ~ m s a ~ ~ ~ u n ~ s u ~ w ~ s ~ i a ~ \ ~ ~ ~ ~ u o i ~ . ~ ~ ~ u ~ a ~ ~ ~ u ~ u ~ ~ a z ~ u n w ~ ~ ~ " i n ~ s w ' r m u i u u a n i s a a ~ ~ ~ i g ~ ~ a z w u m n P i ~ a q ~ n ~ ~ ~ q u " ? \ r ~ T m a o u

d 3 quarters

~ ~ I J L Y ~

~Gnqmsru"uu"uluTuwqmqmkdmq.j;

uonqin?nu7~amGn inisu.li~uidua\r

I a

wGnqmsq\tdu"uu

NASPAA ~~iu?iunuinn?s~nwiu7ms~~uaadw~nqms~.jina~u auls5unq~8nwqluszKuGyryq~anuqnvu a

P m s ~ ~ w q z l u i d o ~ u q m ~

~rnzqnanqwao~n~sAn~7

n--rFj'3YO ~ Z m n ~ t n n ~ ~ u ~ n i d o e i i . ~ n a " q ~ d p 1 ~ 7 d

qnnfiastwn

d

1990s

~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ z f i ~ a ~ u ~ m ~ q u l u d s ~ ~ ~ u " u o ~ ~ o n ~ n w b l d r " u o ~ n ~ a m f ? ~ L $ ~ Y Q Q

~ G n q n s u a z n a i u ~ a u a n ~ n qnmiwaasnis8nwifiu

1990

Qjdrznqawiami

~ u u u n m u ~ o a a a n ~ i n $ j n ~ a m f a a z n ~ t u ~ w ~ s

dnisriq~ai~nnfufa8Xlu

n a u ~ a ~ m a k i a u n ~ r a a u u ~ n ~ u

a

uw~iduLTmavt~lu&w

Public Affairs

dQud19

nahva.mitdtziiiu6iuv$nqmt~~a~qmqK n t z ~ ~ a v m n a l u ~ i h a r i u qmn1w~a~iuuinulirwus'tz~ufi~~i~anu'4dtinq~M"f~m"u~6maam ^A 1 0

il:

Pmul~u'6107mau~.a'm~qulw"~~rik;1nu ud<i~zdaiu?<uwnu.a'm6i~sz~iiuuui%<u

dl d

uinvu 47uaunisAnw7L~4wttmuiLLazfiiunitAnw~dLdu?iiam6aua4 Cam4

" ^d

d 3 a n v 1 ' i q i n n i s ~ n w i v ~ ~ w u a i i i ~ ~ u ~ 32 % ~ ~ i l ~ u ~ ~ d i a u l q &~6?unitntiia

4 o ~ l u i i t l $ i u d i 6 i u d rlmnaiuMkiaMiQAiKy1 aiRnir~Guuduu6;lu

ni~u?vi~<mnitnin?~n'uni~~an"~~u r d a u ~ ~ a ~ b ~ 6 i u n i t b ~ a ~ / n i s u ? v ~ t ~ i ~ ~ i l 6LIk4da1M"~l "mindless empiricism"

~~uuld~aulfiLi1udtzL6uw'muinit6iu

I ~ ~ o ~ m ~ d ~ ~ a m a ~ 5 ~ d t z n ~ a u n i a m 4 v a i ) l ~ 1 u ~ z l 6 ~ i r q ~ ~ i t m ~ 6 a u < n $

c.4 d

~flunaid ~ ~ ~ u u ~ ~ ~ ~ u z i i a n i u n ~ t m w L d a u u ~ d v $ n q m s ~ . j ~ i L a i a u t t n u z b i l ~ Q i l i l u n i t a a u 6 a u ai? nitah~Ciu n i t & a l t n ~ t n t z ~ C n 6 i u a ' ~ ~ u s n u

~ ~ u a t ~ u d i r w i r i u a z n i t ~ ~ u a ~ a ~ " ~ a 4 w ~ n ~ i u ~ j : ~ ~ w ~ n q m t d ~ ~ ~ u n i t ~ u t a d

n ~ ~ ~ ~ m v ~ u ~ a z ~ ~ m n a " i ~ b ~ ~ n " ~ u l u ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ u a ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ n i t t

'~uund 20 Chandler ~ 6 ~ ~ ~ . l n l t ~ ~ ~ ? g d f ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ? ~ ~ f l ~ b ~ d ~ ~ 9 ] ~ 4

w'wJulnltk4m.mqwgjLLaznlndfiu~ 1mu$4idtz~niamfva.jn~s~uunitaau l u 4

a5u$uLflurdulsiintauLLua~ml6$~?~"i4

~aZva\lum?iu%Za tausaw alu~iiuud~~uaba4ui~u\rlj:auatuiu16a~ii4LQilqdiuLgudiKu luqn ~ u n ~ i l u q~umnit'iau6u-~unnitu?v1~taanqinn& iinisd jp l a i ~ n u ~ f l u n m qnd ²

-

n i a m ~ v a ~ n i s u ? v i t ~ 6 u s z ~ ~ u u ~ " f i ? ~ u n i s i m 8 u l q a t i w d ~ v I ~

lnwah~uuu~~wuua4otpinir qnm A 3 - q n ? ~ n i a m ~ ~ u i u i u d t ~ ~ d t z ~ a ~ n ' u nio~iias rlnC/ 4 -ii?~dozniauniamf~~u?~dtzniuniam4 - i d u k ~ ~ o i 1970s

~riuu~ywsQuu n v u 3 m t ~ ~ u u i i d a u h u uaznitw'~u~asA'nit$Pdiaulq ;a

c d a 1 3 A

~ d ~ ~ 6 n d i ? ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 i ~ ~ ~ d t ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ 9 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M $ 4 ~ l 4 ? " ~ l n i t ~ L L ~ n ~ l 4 d4.3

nYMfmuB~~~~~iu~,~uuqlm Graham (1950) ~ I L L ~ L ~ u ~ ~ ~ I & ~ ~ ~ ~ u M U W ~ J I ~ ? ~ Jd.3

rnam4uiaou?~dtzniauniamf iauiilgaauvluwuni4~ntw~niamf iiqzaulq 6 ~ u u P u u i u n ~ ~ ~ n s w ~ n ~ w m i uazn1m&a1ai~mz?"finitwaun"~z~~mnii~n'u1d m ~ u d t z ~ u n ~ t s d ' ~ ~ a z a l m & ~ ~ . j ~ a a u i mludqyTu

CULL^^

¹⁹⁸⁰⁾ nmiq~t661u d u i ~ i n ~ a i ~ ~ ~ i " ~ i mi? 7siivlu1 n p u i u u?~ltqti?q u ~ y w ? v l u i ~flu6u v 1 ' 1 1 f l 6 ~ r d ~ m ~ u u a ~ d ~ a i n ~ a ~ u ~ ~ u filahauinuu mau?uriu$nwmza~ dl

-

anwnitua.rnlamf~ ~ a ~ ~ o z n i o ~ d ~ r a . r u n n ~ i u u n a ~

ad

^r ~ " p l ~ ~ l 6 ~ ~ d d t z a n w ~ ~ ~ ^aI nitaau?sdozniams' 5 vuan

q i n ~ a ~ a d 1 6 ~ ~ J i ~ a u ~ l u n i t d t z ~ u u i u i ~ ~ ~

9- u

mud ^I I n i s u f s a i s ~ m ~ a u a z r n ~ w

- 6 - d

? u u d 21 ~ h e l a n ~ k ~ u a n l s u ~ v l s ~ a ~ a ~ ~ s z a f i a ~ u b w a ~ a 7 u n " l a ~ o d " l

ua~nqw~aazni~dju~ro~F~ds:miau~~amfla"~u~fludtzFu"~~Pdc~~riPdvnS"~~inis

q

-

^{d r d}

usgrindgum uuorruzSbnisnaz~ruan~4lwd~ vinwznyrnuaba.rGqi7 vinnaz

~ ~ u ! ~ ~ a a ~ w ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ r ~ a ~ d f ~ ~ i ~ ~ u i j ~ v ~ L d a a n ~ w n ~ t n i ~ d ~ u u u d a ~ ~

srlp Y

y " ~ ~ r d l n " ~ 7 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l f l ? ~ ~ ~ ~ n l ~ L I ? ~ l T ~ ~ ~ ~ b ~ ~ ~ ~ f i ~ 1 ~ h Z P d ~ ~ E I 1 0 0 ?lldv64 flu

5 daq

CuiUk~~driauaqns~~lsnn!qd

ii%s:u: 4 nmaosavPiJ ( I ~ ~ o s , I ~ ~ o s , ~ ~ ~ o s

UR: 1990s) n ~ ~ u ~ u ~ u ~ u " u a ~ ~ ~ u ~ u s z ~ u f i a ~ i u o~Gnv~al;w nmznssunls uszuliauwuXlunlsiiuu quns&qluqn 1960s ~ 3 u K u ~ ~ n u n u l n " u o q d

n ~ u ~ a r ~ a ~ d ~ ~ s ~ ~ u ~ d a n ~ s ~ n w ~ ~ < u u ~ u i ~ " ~ ~ s z u u n i s a ~ ~ r ~ w u n i t ~ u fdsrrnm us:d~ds~ulmlvrjlpdns~q?l I 960s n i s f f i ~ ~ ~ ~ q r n n ~ w ~ r m z n ~ ~ m a ' ~

4 Y d . d W

a u a ~ ~ a n a ~ u ~ ~ n ~ ~ u ~ . ~ ~ s z " ~ ~ ~ ~ u ; f ~ a . j n ~ ~ a ~ ~ r r w u n ~ t ~ ~ ~ a ~ snwaqunn~"uv~au

? U U M ~ 22 Yeager I X n ~ ~ a i i ~ ~ z ~ G u ~ ~ b S < u ~ ~ u u n s ~ ~ ~ n I ~ n i ~ A n w i

" u ~ ~ F ~ d s : m i a u ~ i a m f 5

i b 1X~r-i

nsriiAnwi n i s 8 u n l a 6 nitAnwiqm v ~ n ~ m s u s : ~ d n ~ s d 1 ~ I d ~ n u 66muq~w 4 nltd'qmm asznltthoaqlnuGq7srn~

-44 r '4 r

rrinza~n\luam us~,lu $a?wind qmriuln Xoo $as3~~ihn~qszrGuu?1?.3'u

- 4 d a

rruaasnwadrza~A r~ua~idbrr?,ud?ud~q ~ " L ! u M ~ I L w u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ? J ~ ~ L ~ u ~ gn

fns~ahsr~aulnlsriluua~hdldnsaun~u

nsuiiauynr~iyuodldli7dlu ~ i u u

~aunlaldrti7tsilu kduni7naluswii.r I 1 I ~ $ 1 ~ u i l u a u & ~ u u s ~ m l ~ n s u

dwzqiia ³¹ c1C7

i ~ u ~ u ~ u i i d m a ~ u a z b ~ u n n a l u ~ w ' u s " u ~ d y " b i u u ~ ? " ~ ~ u a d l d ~ y"r9sund~aI.~uoloua~di~@<uq:r~anl~;j~1vu&au~m~o~!alm~asmu5u

3

r - u

~1n1uua~n1s?.3'u~~szan1un~~6~3;lu3u~"~a0n1~3<o~~s:~ruz"Ld°'la~ya~ul3

-4 4 d d

v s l u l a n i r n asrwomt?qaaunaluli~da~~LLa:na~ubnu~ms~"uaqia~s~lX t u u l s n i d a l r i i n l t ~ n u l & (replication) LUDLGUIUR?? d nls~iunasl+h~uL~q

f i ~ ~ m ~ s z 3 ~ n ~ s d ~ q m n ~ ~ d s z n a u ~ u l d ~ ~ a ~ a ? u a ~ u l i ~ ~ d a ~ ' i ] K a ~ r i ~ u ; P ~ n a ' ?

Triangulation

m a d ¹² n~su~rnsuwqbiassu

Iuuni 23 H P ~ S ~biynB.r~~u~n~aaa4n~saii~n~~uM'uaU'uIm"~un~s u?vlqs4quqifistud~~a~flu 1 l u 3 oasd~uqsa'sdbu & l u a A m ~ ~ u d n q n l ~ ~ d

PI?^ (court reform)

d 4

n1sn'1~Qun~sae;lpl1a~nsz~ulunszu~un1sqifissu~~M"116aEi1~1~a~.a" ~ i u

" J "

qistsuU'ngnnsauh~mun~uy~1na~u?"tl~;dwb~u?u~maam da~wwa;wm4nqm

v l u ~ u r ~ a z ~ C u n ~ 1 u n ~ m ~ u i u 1 6 ~ ~ ! o u 1 6 a m o ~ c r B ~ w ' ~ u ~ n ~ s a ~ \ j n i s d ~ ~ d nrzu?unqsq~fisfuua4abu~ni~dLLd ¹⁹⁰⁶ u o u u ~ ~ u y n l n w ? n w d qu%fl~?fiu

d u ~ u a ~ ~ i n i l ~ < u i i u ~ u ~ i . ~ 6 1 u n ~ s 1 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ a z m " 1 u ~ ~ s w ~ Z ~ d ~ ~ f i q z i t $ 66mzimmzu?41q*9 oianqs~dauuuda~n"mqu -4 n ~ ~ u 6 a ~ n ~ s ~ ~ u d s z 3 ~ t n ~ w l u n ~ s M"~\riuaa~wia6~un~sdTuyd~.~flsfnz;lai~~ nszuaunqs ~~az%umaunism"cl~Gu

n~siio~flun~sdflqduu~ulw~

luund 24 Gazell

UMUQ

5 d s z ~ & d i K ~ j ~unini4~1s4iuqAfis~u

9" L L

P ~ u l ~ t ~ a ~ f i ~ a ~ f l ~ f l d l 4 ~ 7 n 4 7 n m ° 7 ? ~ l n & ' i 1 4 Rosove Pond (1906) !-k?"ann7961~

-4 Y r

n o ~ u ~ u C / ~ u ~ n 5 w a n ~ ~ u u ~ ~ m u ~ ~ ~ n a ~ s ~ ~ a ~ m ~ < n s 5 d s z u i u l m ~ 1 1

47uw7aiiqm"7 1 ~ a a ~ ~ n n ~ s ' i ~ d v l ~ n ~ ~ u ~ n u ~ u M " ~ a ~ i ~ ~ l d ~ z 2 m n ~ 1 6 ~ d ~ \ r s ? m ~ ~ ~

d d .?i

nisKm~~an(Gwin~inu~~~nszuuqmfissu 2) nqsnCns~aPq4ream'enios?u

~ ~ M U " L U ~ ? ~ ~ ~ C ~ I ~ U I ~ ~ ~ Ijn??u~flustuusi.lln?4~7n ³⁾ n?taf?~n?iu~fluda

r - a

eq"°dwktmmau4) n1oAnwuaznqs3neusu ~rwun~t~wu~iw%n?~ufaei~\r~fluszuu

~~tduuuC/~ilunq4nqt~azliLflunq.snqt (nqtioeu~ucqunqtuan~d~uu d ~ ~ ~ l l n l ~ n i nqs~bi~uumquaeinqmtoii~~ n-n~yuiiuu4qu) ILK 51 nqmiXu

~ n n ~ u T a ~ ~ ~ a z n ~ P i < u n ~ ~ w q ~ n s s u n i a m 4 dauM"7lfin~su7.v~sn~di.j~#umid"11d

3 V d

l 6 a E i ~ ~ m m ~ ~ ~ i d r z 8 n ' S n ~ w m n w n u y~uuu~~16~auadrz~iu~u1~n 5 h u

d n a s l d l ~ L d ~ u u ~ ~ d a ~ 6 ~ u 16uri nqs~$qt.jwqa n ~ ~ u P T ~ ~ ~ n ~ a ~ b % ; l ~ G u u ~ ~ u u n i t u ~ ~ ~ t n ~ ~ u d a a m n ' u ~ u p l i a nisz~uim~ouu'ililw7a L L ~ ~ ~ ~ T ~ I Q L L U ~ ~ I ~

nszu?un~tqifissu

u ' r v ~ t 5 3 i i q ~ : l u ' f i ~ u 7 t n ~ f l u ~ n t w 3 ~ ~ f i m f i & ~ d a ~ n 3 W P - ~ R

~ ~ u n 7 t k d n 7 t

~7nni7nqtwu7ntoin7mnz~u

adriuaniwilryv7lo~i7~l^49

~mzdmbulu

dtzln'snqw~idulqdnudaul'w~6adn7~

@.~uuh,fiuanqw~

Public Choice

Tmu

a ~ 6 u ~ u ~ u ~ a ~ q d f i ~ 6 ~ ~ n t q d ~ ~ u ~ l i a 7 u i u n o ~ n n i t ~ a u f i u a ~ i d u X ~ ~ ~ o z ~ 1 ? n i t

y"~iiuu~~.rm*~auo~ntwjn7fimf~~ualv1u'"~a~n7tu?v1~ta~6nt 14~nuc/l&?uwo

ntznumuakd5uu~uu~u~~ul~d~z~u'imaaudad6u~ui7~~un7t&audtz~u"11d d 4 A P 2 u 4 $4

wamvnnmuu n~tu?rr?rtgmnm~u4n~6ad

"look outward more, inward less" ~Cqk

q Z 6 ~ 6 i q d 7 u m a ~ 6 n i f ad7uad'iab'iu

d7Prq<ui?quitauah&aun'urwafih~ d

W ~ ? G ~ ~ G ~ ? ~ ~ ~ W ~ W @ ~ ~ L G ~ I E ] ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ P ~ L ' W U ~ ~ ~ ~ U d

und 26 Ostrom rJmi;.)%wu7i7dldL~ua$adn'unqt4nw7~arket Choice, 4 d w

Public Choice

Lbaz

Institutional Choice ~ ~ b ~ ~ n ~ L ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ d 7 d ~ t L f l ~ b t ~ d ~ ~ ~ d M " 7 n l t

4 a t n o ~ z ~ v o ~ u s z n i n ~ o z i q m L ~ ~ v f i 7 u q m ~ " 7 1 ~ ~ ~ v ~ i i n n a ~ u ~ u ~ a u u ~ n d ~ i u

ntau ~~uaflm cia~i?LLuudL~;on~n"dbLmni7~n'uld t$hu;7~fiua

Rational-Choice

Model

~ a m n a ~ A u ~ ~ u v a ~ n i ~ ~ n w

~ a r k e t Relations

~ a m n o d w q ~ u ~ a d ~ ~ u ? i a

2 Non Market n f ~ ~ L L ~ l f l n

nqw~LLoz6all~uiy

m o u d 14 i ~ l l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ f l 7 R ~ f l 7 R d

UW; 27 Gargan ~ & r ~ n i ; d ~ u a u ~ d t z n 1 f i u H 7 f i m ~ n ' u n 7 t i a u ~ u

w 0 9

~ u v l n a 7 ~ L i 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ 7 % ~

(professionalism) ~ ~ % u u w u i ~ ~ u l ~ l n i u u i u " ~ a ~ i ~ i ~

?maw

(profession)

~ozna~u~fluGaai%wn7n?~lutz&u5~u~onfi7~dauw"a~~u rruaw~anitd'sz~Qu~d~uT~~ulu?a~%w

W ' w u ~ n i t n i ~ n a i ~ ~ f l u G a a 7 b i i w l ~ ? ~ dozn~au~~snflu~~inzqnfifluGu L L ~ 1880

iflutiuu7 ii~qndqlljud~flu

The New

Public Administration (NPA) 6 7 d ~ d 6 f l U Z q a d ~ n ? a 7 n 7 t d 7 d ~ ~ d n 7 ~ d " 1 : L ? m q ~ 2

~ f l u ~ e a i % w l u n ~ s G ~ ~ r ~ m n ~ t $ ~ ~ a ~ ~ u & ~ u

ngwuqu q?usosu~~ozAosssuvad

urjnnrzdri/ua5u?jdtzn7fiufi7fimf

! ~ ~ ~ q n w " l ~

^Fry

aoz

^Nigro

Uua

⁵ L L u a i i m ~ ~ ~ r y n l j i a l % w ? j d t z ~ l ~ u

n~smdalkLri

^{I )}

nu~m

² htzvi~sn7tLiio~~un7tu?w7t

i u w n ~ n u z n 7 s

9

a'11inismd

Wilson(1887) -The Study of Administration

n7t~da~i?aazlt~u?v11~

w

k u ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ u ~ i ~ l p d n 1 ~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~ 6 p d ~ r J " U l ~ ~ b ~ .

0-27273900 M?Q E-mail address : warrasan@yahoo.com

aouniunu~1zliitlm~du~?u!~~fn~\1n~m~sa1s~~a::Lanaim~~?~1ni~

Pws

0-2727-3900 lpd?vPd~~aziqais~qn~s