l'-==' ---r

24107/56

n"rrl^t gil,rJ 1q 6rln.tn,J1:fi,r:T tr n,r:1yr ertu ltilurJaqtn

,!

TCI uaydt _lournal lrn;:act

Factor:,

*df il JgI

g \#!ft* & e v s c r * {

fl *"9'$.' sr rr i:,,

e . ( f t r [

q{il]eyt@ilt r-s o*'tr} u r ntt?-L-

l'-==' ---r -*--l

I . Jrlurnats indexed in CJatabasesxx. I I " Journals with rerevant contents (see aim and scope arrcl 1 refs) I

I . Journals rvittr high total citatiorrs;

I i . Journals lvith high irnpact factr:rs; and h-incjex I I

'

i3ilJlt't rvith highlv recommended bv researchers in tne

li I

I ' Ar:cepted as tnury international journals..

(_--_

I

_

Fl.rRT. ru:*r{qvr1$ arufFiilrunlor

By Narongnt Sombatsompop

24/07t56

J-x.,.-."

l l , r l

Definition of an interniational journal.

' Eeing visible by internationial peers, 'rhis

can ber verfrfied by' conslstent citations in interrnational rJatabases.

a a

Papers mostly relviewed Being widely known and i nternationa I resea rchers p.c"t pers), this consideri ng citations.

by international peers.

putllished by

(e>r:luding invited papers and their . Abstractedl and indexed in international

da'tabases,

By Naronqnt Sontbatsompcpt 3

-€€fff

l. Goorl timeliness of puhliciltion

2. St'ict pee;r review procesis to ensure origina.lity and correctness

3. Clear aims; anLdl scope and-ioumal policy

Harving goodi basic: .i'umal sta'dard: Consistency irr format, referer-lces, illus1ru1.ions, etc.

Pr'rninent Eilitorial board menrrtrer with g'ocr diversiqr Good diversit y' of publishing authors

7. Sufficient citations

8. Incle'xed b), internatio'al a:rd rn,e.[l-recog.ized, databasers 6. Clezu'.iournal homepa,g,e and orrrlirre submission

7. Peer recosnitic'n

'I'C,l

h,rrmepsg€

Coverage

$Fl ii',',r - -- -

ancl Nunrber ol'.iou,rnerl titles in TCI database

, litored bibliographic records since 1gg1- present

" l!umkrer c,f jourrrals tilies :- ' in 2A,0:4

. in 2A05 . in 2006 ' ln 20A,7 r ,in 2A08 . in 20Ag . in 2A10 z 'in 201 1 . h 2a12

". 100 frrles (S&I) '=;126 lll/ers /S&D :- 766 tillers (S&f

= 295 filles (S&r + H&SS) E 332 tiiles (s&r + H&SSi E Jl/ litlss (S&f + F/&SSJ

:z: J// filtls.e (S&f + HSSSJ, T2,000 artictrzs ," 428 tiilte,s (S&r + HASSI, 100,OOO aritles :t: gJQ li1'ls,e ('S&f + H&SSJ, l JA,OAO artrlc:les

24/07/56

24/07 t56

Criterionr for TCI journal evaluation:l

(Tcl rer:ognizerand de-select the existing titt,es)

M a i r r c r i t e r i o n

I . A r t i c l e s f o r p u l c l i c a t i o n r T i u s t b e p e e , " _ r e v i e w e d . 2 . T l n r e l i n e s s ( c , n e i s s u e c l e l a y i s ia l l o w e d ) .

O p t i o r a l c r i t e , r i o r

1 . T h e jo u r n a l a g r : m u s t b e : l y e a r s m i n i m u m .

2 . C ta t i o n s i n T C I o r / a n c l o t h e r in t e r n a t i o n a l d a t a b a s e : ; . 3 . G o r : d d i v e r s i l y i n a u t h o r s h i p

4 . G o r r d d i v , : r s i t y i n e d i t o r i a l b o a r d m e r n b e r s 5 . C l e a r j o u r n a l i c o n c e p t s a n d p o l i c y

6. lJniform journal forrnats (referr:rnces,, iilu:itrations, tabres etc).

7 . J c u r n a l w e b s te o r o n r i n , r p u b r i c a t i o ' ( u p d a t e , c o r n p r e h e n s i v e ) There is o slight dlfJ'erence for sociol science,.ieturncls (suc,k a:; bctok rev,ie,v.s)

Tittrr: classifications,after review I

ffii ,',, I

G r o u p , A : F ' a s s a r l l 2 r n a i n c r i t e r i o n w i t h a l l o p t i o r r a l c r i t e r i o n ( 8 0 9 : ; ) II G r o u p B : P a s s a l l 2 r n r a i n c r i t e , r i o n w i t h s , c r r n e o p t i o n a i r : r i t e r i o r r ( : g 0 % ) | G r o u p C : F a i l o n e o r b o t h o f t h e rnain r : r i t e r i o n i

&Itoulry1apenl_on.Ig_ggbSlle I

Iilhrtll-Euoup A will be fully approveci arrc inclutied in TCt datal ase. I a n d t h e r n i n v i t e r i t o b e in c l u d e d i n o J S ; a n d A S E A N c i t a t i o n n l e x I D a t a b a s e .

l'itles revision irlgloupll wil{ be incruded witl.rin .,! years tc, enter in TCr Grc,ulc, cratabase, ,A. pencrin,g sor'e I I I

Titles igprroup_e ma'y be ex,cluded fronr -lCl

database and the I deselercted titles; may r,e-iapply in the next 2 yearrs. I

I

_ ay'llaroqgl:!.Sombatsonpop

_ _j__l

24/07/56

,'rl.\

Wlr.ii

FResults of Quality Assessmnent of Thaijrournals inTCl Database (ils of April Z0l3)

l& ,',', ^Eixanpkl of titles in Gratujll\ for S&Tjournal

les Group

A A A

ronicli, ancl Communications A A

4

A

r:al Engineering A

Internet and Management

A A http:/fivtaw'kmutt.ac.th/jif/rturttic-htmt/Evarrotion/Evarurttic,n

:56.html 10 Asian pacific Journal ol Allergy and lrnrnunology

Chiang l/1ai Journal of Science

ECTI Traitsactions on i:lectrical Eng., Elect

Envirorrrnent and Nal:ural Resourr:ers Journal Internatronal Journal of Agrir:u tr.rrarl Technologir International Journal cf ApplieiJ Biomedi International Journal ,cf Renewable Ener,p;y

24t07/56

of titkes in Groulll\ for SS&H journal .sf, i' , i'

, *

Journal Titles BU Academic Review

International Journ;irl of Behavioral Scietnce Journal of English Studies

Journal of Population and Social Studie:;

Nakhara : Journal of Environrnental Design and plernning Sasin iournal of Managementr

Silpakcrn Univerrsity l nternationa : JournaI Thammasat Re'riew

1v{ra.rn::firinil?fi'nri ntvr rn;.ntur6rdoti

http:,/,/www.kmut"t.ac.th/jt;f//ltubiic_html/',Ev6luatianiEvol,uation 56.html

Jou rnal lrnpact Factors

r *

&9ri 'i , ,'

Journal lmpact Factor:; u3a flmpact Factors 1,1st1tJfi,o .iruluprio loru r"a d s,lfiu vlFt? ''trJ?t a {?.r ri{'rrt'iruQ:yldfu n I i d I o fi u lu uei Ryfl (A nteasure of the freq,ssnry with w'hich the ,everage orticle', in a journol hos L,een cit,?ot in a particuiar yeor or periocl)

6eldiu{iuIoCI Eugener riarfielcl ufirr trving H. sher nvicfin"r:Ju Instiitute for scienrtiflc Inforrnation {tstf latailelf1r6 a Thonnpson lSt 'tufl

fi.fl, t95€ts

lst ar fi n5.lut ar4 o{iia Journat citarti on Reports (t cn} ld a:..1 r't't-.ru

Fi"l iournal lrrpract Factor ?Ja0?'t?i$lftuarg'r1mil1F{]finfuily

ruprl"u1afl iltnni') 6,000 i..t unlTql nrdi1nn

1'ltdllr't A

,ii ., ,:i iEnmrii-rurrurir Journal lrnpact Factor (JlF)

drueuruvlortufi6ilrfruv[

,irueuraSrd q n iiiroi.u rfr .:'rruo

,,i*,'i!i 3.%%&

35 4t0

2s55

45

- umnarutrrfl :;g qndroffo?uril ss - uyrntru?rrfl $,1 qnd'roii.cturil ss : _lt'4 -0!ll -r-{-!!l_ql lii ii e_r-t Efr r { ii u tur it s s riri Jtr tuil ss = !0-]- 3q-

40 t' 3:;

oir ltt tufl ss = 1!l = ,+5;

1 0 0

tr 3r)

i)-ll 10

&

615f

n T 0 o5'J

= 11.666 75

0.2:',22

Tha ii-Jou rn a | | rn pa ct Fra ctors ('r-.1 I F) {a{msnr,ilvr e?vil"ir{tl

.ffir'n, *i: __ j!11 2002-?011

1.,ti99

1 . : 0 0

'1.c,00

. . , . . : J l F 201'l - ; , r J l i 2010 iiti t009

J l - i ! U E

r I ; i F 2 0 0 7

* l J l F ! 0 0 5

* t ; i F 2 C C 3 0 . 8 0 0

0.600

0.400

0.200

0.00c

1 0 0

Journal titles (lilles)

24107 t56

Top10 jourrrals

'ir - il

lr;rms of :l_:,llF in 2O'11 (sar journats)

Rank Journal Titles

htt p : //ru ww. k m u t't. a c.,t h /j if fii u b I i c_ht m l,/T- J t F, ht m I

Na4,!: g r,t t Somjats?lnpop ____-_.

I

_{t . r b}

fopt0 journerls in tenms of I..Jj.F_ in 2011 (ssaH journats) |

l*"

I

I

I Rank Journal Tiles T-J1F I

I I ,- e.,r-t*re,n*"o,.arJ

- ---T--

ojs? ---l i

I I 2 F.r^^:a',rrntirdnurtr.r-Rra;iu | ,'ot l I

| - - - F I

| | : t i B U A c a d e r r n i c R e v i r - ' w I o r a r I I ' '

| | :t lrrrn^:rn:Bqfiranfr.6urli;rrlrril:r.l I o.rae T I

| ---- I

l l 3 l r r r n r r r i e l , ' t r n p r f r r u r : i u r - r d . l l r i f l d n b n j l o . r a s i l

I l____t_ ._______J_ _ __-t I

I I e ; l l a n g u a g e I n s t i t u t e . l o u r n a l I o r z s | |

i r l

| | 6 l r r r 6 i r , r a : r ; n - R r f i l r : r l n d I o r : s I I

| ---!- |

| | B

l r r : * i r f o r ^ r r r f , i n : i e r l t . l : F t . . n t t l l a n i | 0 . , , , I I r r , ' - i

I I u p r ? f i ' r r , ' r n n i I o r r r I I

I F .r-f ______f_ |

I | 10 frr:nrrnr:{ornrrfr.li;,rrnliar. I O.Ogz I I

t * - - - l

It I http://ruww.krnutt.ac.th/jif/ltubtic_htmt,/T-JtF.htmt I

| "

t..l

l--qy rrgru::!-so,r,Qqts?!W__ 16

|

1?fi't?yrfl1L11t f1'l6 n f rt6r::41n lyr

r ?6'r t6 r.r 1 Fr lJ ?,t u'r 1.J 1 n r 6'r r'rl l n rwi'uti o n,6 g t ru fi o

rlrmnflo rnrru,r.,rdirn:nrln.rylilrfr;r

rtd ilrnr iltiq utilrtirri i:Jr; plitnfl 'l ?'l qfl yt't.: n l ty,tti M'R

'1r61?p ruy1{fl1u'tn r4r nFti 1.l14.tiuflrdfl:.Jr Inrr

_____-_:_-_

'1 t^ 1 tl n fl t::11u61 fi 1 r,ir 01J

r 16 r liyrsr 14 r d n frrr u,lr

1 rdl:1^tqnrl 2 Tnl ??'rtu

U Acad

??t't?r,,1:19q r tdr16't n l'4

r) uag€r

tni ? t,,l?t_YE

B r*mignrrtn

1 0

rrfirrn ra n ii r16lrnltiri;

24/07/56

1'op10 journals in terms of total citras in 2011

(S&"I journals)

J0urnal Titlkgs

l m r L 6 ! t e ! l [ .

Southeasi; l\sian Journal rcf TroFrrcal Meldic:ine and publ.ri

Crc,ss cites

h

?nr.flllll1nfr 132

r 3 2 i n l o u r n a l o f S r ; i e n c e a n d T e c f r n o l r r g y

tttt p : //w ww. k nt,u tt. a c.t:h/j iJ,,/ pt,u b I i c_ht m t //T -.t t F. l1t m I

" * l$i.i , r

Rank

t a '28

: 9 2P,

25 2 9

2A 27

1 9

23 _B

2'/

2"1 2 1

2C 6

2 A

- z o -

2 0

n

htt p,://'www. km u tt. cr t:. th /j if/p u b I ic.-ht m ti_t n. ntil B

24/07 /56

Journal Vlanragement

n . t : . e n i t n i d ! f f i r n n y x r i n r ) i t , r . h t d i t x " , d & r r ; , ' ! u t

nudaitninttitrivtta.tlna r t< t1

='='J (g++eriaH,lhr-Tl ruikrnrrd}-

l n ; p r o p e r e d i t o r i a l c o n t ( l n t s : J o u r n a l t i t l e w i t h tc o L r r o a d a n d / o r I t o o u n i q u e t i t l e .

I n r : f f e c t i v ' e r e l v i e w p r o c . e t s s : p o o r qualirry m a n u s c r i p t s , S i l o w a n r r d is c o n t i n u o L r s ( lazy, i rr,:spo n s i b l e ;a n r l n o n - p r o f e s s i o n a I e d i t o r : ) , D er st ru ct i ve (:o m rn L' rits, N o n - p ro fer s s, i o n a I refe re el s * *

Publisher (olvrrer)' n o n-perma ne nt la rgets, mincl-serts a nd pc licy.

Lr: nr n u m be r.9r f ggfu gg i o n s :_ D u e_ t o_(l w v i s i b i I i t iefgfjle jg14'n a | ( nee r1ryg[, ejyrna | :; ) a n r:l-p-o o r review r].!.!ces;s.

R eft: re e se I e r.Ii-o_qfJy!f:I3!-q19 e :; dqn o t a c ce p! t h e i nvita t io r N u m b e r , r f s r r b s c r i b e r r s : C o s t a n d l o l v ' q u a I i t y ? ? L i s u a l l y , f r e e o f cha rge.

24t07156

. Dartabases (fcln refer,eers' serlecti,rrrr) -- Referees" database (outsource) - Authors' clatabaser (in-sourct-.)

-- r\rticles' rJatabase {key rvords, and journal databases) . $rlstemarlic review pftlcess (for acti',re review)

- t)n-line submission and revi,ew {effectiveness) - lieview f , r n m ( a l a i l a b l e i n p u r b l i c )

- l-ollorv-up system (timelly re',rievv)

-- Monitoring systr:nr of rervier,,,r s,tertus (active r,eview) - Opportunityto p r o p o s e r e f e r r e e s { t i m e m i n i r n i z a t i o n ) . A ck;-o^w-l{ r ne quattt)t g;p e 1t-,9 ot tne Jc,urnal n <J awa rds ( r::o is rnosf influencednl i n u-o us se rvL, o f refe re e s )

!!rtu:,11*flT:r" (esp, r,eviewers) )

S y wa ro;g, t k* ba tt", i,pZf

i"invv to b,c ;l g*od ,*elitnr?

. Bt-' commifi:ed: Full-tinre, timely and higl"rly responsibler.

. Filighly visible: Meeting peclple and be friendly.

' Professiorrerl: Unbri;rsed ancJl constructi',re,

Norn'lal track of good Editor:

Gir: od sliud er nts)>>,goocl resea rch e rs>>>good authors;>>>good referees>p> (Good edijLors.

I I

-* )

By N*"Wtt S"rbatsonp-opfr

24107 /56

tlt---t_,*'tf;.,r--;,y5q-itrFiAtrr'ei-t.--,-jn=raf f jt-ee5-l?f --1

G-':"J l+gltrc:wifp;-91*q1g$e,sp.fs-r-- ___J--,)

D o n o t f o r g e t that the g<lod r e f e r e e s a r e a l w a y s b u s y l l A n d do n.t I h a v e t i m e l ! !

I l d e n r : i f y p o t e n t l a l r e f e r e r : s ( a c t i v e a u t h o r s , n o t n e c e s s a r i l y p r o f e s s o r s ) s e l e c t f r o m the respon:sible r e f r r r e e s w h o u s e d t o s e r v e t h e r e v i e w in I| t h e p r a s t w i t h satisfactiorrll ( s o , y o u neie,cl t o h a v e t h e i r r e v i e w r e r o r d s I a n d w o u l d be good if you can "score,', t l r e i r re v i e w ; c e r f o r m a n c e ) . I I n v i t e t h e a u t h o r s o f a r t i c k : s p u l c l i s h r : l d i n y o u r jo u r n r a l " T h e a u t h o r s I w i t h high numhrer o f p u k r l i r : a t i o n i n y r f , l J F i J o t J R N A L a r e li k e l y t o a : c e p t I t h e i r r r r i t a t i o n .

I L o o k a t t h e same keywr:nds o f t h e a r t i c l e s p u b l i s h e r J i n y o u r jo u r r r a l . I I n ' i t e the authors t o s u g g e s t p o t e n t i i a l r e f e r e e s ( w i t h erditor's I r e r c o l n m e n d a t i o n o f d i f f e l r e n t r e g i o n : : ; , a n d n o conflict o f i n t e r e s t s . I

e t c . ) . I

S e l e c t f r o m ,n"

: . t : . t i o n

o f t h e subrnitted m a n u s c r i p t ,

, l

R. t/*;,**^^'.;:z{

B y Na rongri t Sctm ba tsomlop

I"hs=.[dl{s{ii-glx}@sqrc r ds s" wiryslE_

a

a

rrt(:i'{inl* JfitJi'n6l vir;;ihiiili*s tr: n*t*lttial

,3 lril't ",r :; *it: r+imcl El f.-.-if---

F o r m a t g u i d e l i n r : s : C o n s i s t r : r r t a n d r e a c l a k r l e . {3elttin51 tfre journirl into dallab;rses: lSl, Scopus, TCI a n d s o o n ,

D e p e n , C a h l e p e e r review: p e e r review policy and p r o c e d u r e , R e v i e u r f o r m , p r o { e r s s i o n a l , u n b i a s e d a n r C tinnely rev'ir:w, Construrctiver comments etc.

Attending confenerrces: Getting to knor,v preople and irrvite Fotr:: ntial aruthors.

Ue friends: Being {'r'ien<js with 13ood referees and a.uthorrs (arl:so be reterees inr some stagers), rather t l r a n b e i n g enenries w i t h t f r e r r r !

By Na ro n g ri I So,n ba tso m p,z,c

tdtr,

qJ

__1

_fu:ltiJi|*rs; Etr:ukl e-*i"lsieJr:r rrv$,S; ffi

U[=--{in"l'r',s-ita;r,*r{,l

- - , -

r',;illllit'cs 1.sr pnt€r,rtinl I ,.i I rtl. n rcl' :;I r ",tde't; lTEl -

I

_I

. Filntying with referree:s anrd arctive autl^rors I . Credits frr:m refe:ree.irrg v'lork (proposr: to I univer:;itir:s, salary ri:;e"and pr'omcitirons)' i . lViaking j o u r n a l s a s c o m p e t i n g m e d i a ( i n t e r v i e t v I and trans,cription as l,:adinrrr ahd up-tci-clate I a r t i c l e : ; a n d a u t o r n a t i c r e v i E w i n v i t a t i o n ) i . Publishing c i t a t i o r r a r r a l v : , ; i : ; r t f v o u r io u r n a l I ( E c l i t o r ' s : i r n n u a l r e p o r t , t i n r e - m a n a i t e m e n t - from i sul:mis;sicln to eler:ision, erarly view iirticles, mo:st- | c i t r : d o r a c c e s s o r d o w n l o a d i n g a r t i r : l e s ) , I . B'r:st p a p ( : r a w a r r j s ( n , e e d q u a n t i t a t i v e a n d I r e r l i a b l e c r i t e r i o n ) j

- )

M;-;;:*-*^::zi

B y Na ro ng r I t Stt m ba tsom pop

..qr - "l i:* i:*it;;ffi.-dd;;*-it:i"rrlli; t.

--_l

\{ H.-- .--}-*=-."-.-

**":-":J |

I l-,,- I {:1"_; ir} .ji:,ljl-ri;'l i.1,;rr;rilil ji.,: .,_r | -t

I'j ";it:;!f;trlt-na'f t ;;fti , e;ll1' r TTII- I I

_{t l} I

C , o - m a n . a F ; e m e r l r t o f . i o u t ' f l d i l s ( c o l l a b o r a t i o n : , ; i I a r n o n g j o u r n a i l s ; r l r i t l ' r s i r n i l ; r r s c o p 1 3 s a n d a i r r s ) i I J r : r u r n a l s w i t h l' u t u r e r t h e r n e s ( u p - t o - d a t e o F r d I I

c o n s o l i d a t e ) i I

A,'t:tendir1,g, revir:winp; ancl :;electing the I a l r r c r e s T t " o m t n e c o n t e r e n c e I Jr3urnarl c,cnferelnces - aul.l'lors prefer i I c o n f e r e n r : e s t o j o u r n a l s ( b e s t p ' a p e r s I ' o r i I p t ' o s p e c t i v e j o u i r n a l : ; , l e : s s ; t i m e - c b n s ; u m i n g n i I r{er\riewinl;1, highly int:eracti've) - a :;eL of i I J o L r r n a l s r n a y w o r k t, o g e t h e r o n t h i s , r I

t l

il

_:_:-

-.-_--_-- -

By N*rrsr,itsr*but or,,;,p# _{__-J} |