:
•
, : -! ./0 1 2%3 42 567 28 9
:;%0 :<=0 >!( ?@
«Developing a Mixed Methods Proposal», A Practical Guide for Beginning Researchers.
: •
@AB C D
•
! E FG G -0A# H@I : D
8J
Paul A. Schutz
&
Jessica T. DeCuir-Gunby
"# •
!" # :
$% •
:
SAGE
&% '( •
KL M N 7# H :
) (* •
: D263
% •
&%
:
− 1440 2019
D
+# *, •
:
:(L : O!P QR S%3 TUL VWXY ,ZL7G -! ./0 F 1 [@\7 V L& )%I R -!I : O!P ? ,\] ^0 _H` GE (G @!aH b@;X=c N;2(d -e%I f gc ;-(LG -!I
N@2@\ -(LG _M = i( _HjG b@;X=B
VkW%7 VUMG V Gl Vk!( )%I R m8 n028 6 D
S%3 ./0 oaA QR @! ?! Rp qH6 Q ( N@c r3A st '7G ,Z877 a sUeG uvAB
(
*-. */0 1"
2345 -,5 67, 8 *9 : 7;# 7 −
( = "
Z@( @/@w% <7] O7 ?@Xe% ZGL8G D
a <7E )%I R 52 b6x '( Z%<7E v E 1 y/% u%\ ,z '{ |c X n} f
b~M 1 Y] @a b@a] |c !%L GE _!~ K0 GGg )k2 % -% @e L _x@0 @0] ~8 -% @!@%
D
L R o@A f a LAE @/W LA 1 @a L '7
-I7] O!% 1 @6@6= x7 608 E fc ,V0& VH0%( A f A LA ^ 1 b#G cG ,@
)%I R e7 Z@c -!%L QR D
@~ F68 E ,L8!%! 0 ak bg @e L i( F<!&
,8 NAE sH ( N8H@M '6
E7
!9 N8K '(G NL( % K w @G E w 'IG ,@eY L( c D
X68 NAE @/W
nU#G 'I ,H@~ @6 U%( 8G U=%7 c
GE b@%e E Nw\ ! 1 E |c @eY A
@6 '( f b@~
-@02 Ow 1 bH@~
'7 3 F68 E ,@e L i( Y` F<!& D
v 1 v ,
' NAE O7 V2@A G08
!9 1 s .@= '7 NL( % '7 w Y` A '7 L( uRG
" G Vf~& v v '7 ?& I E e8 NAE w '7 gc ,~
&/
D
QR ZXA 1 H @!G b/2X m8 1 a -Y8 i( )%I R m8 1 nW= 6
% m ?068 f @\7G @!( TL7 i( I8 D
1 e Ng |c HJE & [6= >!( ?@ )%I R c
Z%767 D
@& i( Vf<7 Z% 1 %M Z8# )~=G S%3 ./0 _#c @e
D '( uk(E H&R F< @w%G
_f '7 (! i( M] ^ 5{ 'I! ,S% ./0 sU(xYcG ; v QGg w @e L ?6L ,\]
Vk<7 3J 100
D
U# -% A '( s~A 7L( s #c |c O!%~LM MH 1 sU2@" O7
?! 1 %= GE 7 GE D
L F6 7L(
E L ¡HA LAd\ ,sU2@" 1 @eY L( U#G sc sUL7 80
%80
-!I ./0 !~ 7 RG ,@eY L( @G U# 7 S@" 1 ; v QGg '7 D
Yj £ 1
i( ME 52A ,-(L O7 bk 67 _#c s%@\ ,@e L J( 'R NGE '7 (!
VX3J 30
'7 Vk<7
@e L '7 L NR w8 s #E QR 80
D sUw8 @e@& '( (! uR F~A
|c E QR a '( b77 i( sUL7 ?X/AG ,'EG @&G L N%
Ng D O! j %= L!a
S% ./0 r3L UA E M L@( 7G @(LG @!I bA@0 D
N8 O7 'IG ,L O28 ?#E '7 VA@=E b X '7 @! )%I R m8 i( ?! ? ¥ M = i( qH6G m \7 Q< V6= V%¦ Vk!( & ,b X _
VxE V%¦ ?! R '7 ?P 7G D
( i( e%3 b\6< k{c 1 V§~7 Y` |c O!% '7 U6L8G \ !% 68 m E 6@6=
Y] b\6<G b!%
D ,UL 1G
L}E
@! ;eG % )%I R E6 '7 O@!
D
•
:
% -% ,bXX3% % 1 :<=0 )%I R S%3 ./0
28 1 !%¨ 'RG ,U@( V#
7 @</0 bMHG sU/L7G s =G{] S% ./ b=67 D
I x6 \& )%I R T 'G
1 ,S%3 ./0 /0 V %& I E ZL7 X6 fG
H7 O7 ,)%I R 3%M -C0L ,AcG ,Z8R s;a S% .
Y] 2%3 42
,F< ?@0M i(
Creswell & Plano Clark, 2011
;
Teddlie & Tashakkori, 2009
D '7
S% ./ 567 y/%Mf Vk@ I@ s!X7 )%I R ,st D
%G ,N</ 567 28 1 (~!
'7
./0 56 @MM] bAI F= H/!% G ,FX\ ~8 :
b#7G 76 Q©L H{B
42 s~aG D
>5 ?2 • :
?AB C/ D)E 3#, -A ?7( :
&~G @(%#f <= & @&G ,S%3 ./0 1 7( 767 ?Xe R '!x8 |c !~6L @
:@!I ,:%\
© sUe ,b_X=B ?<7 ,( bA@ 73%~ 'R :@(LG
73%~ 'R
© sUe bk 6 ?<7 ,( bA@
^@6A 1{ i( E i( :Ltf |c G<I ©L .@= , D
,L '7
-</ @6%& ,S%3 ./0 _#
7 L @6 6 FkY .t D
be% Vª ?Xe R oaL &
S%3 ./0 1 7 |c \wB ,S%3 ./0 @MM]
D ./0 1 i( :<=0 HaG
S%3 D S%3 ./0 b=67 e@«G W ?Xe -U%LG D
FG ?2 • :
-H% '5(
AB IA J*B9K C L); 8
1 s8 R 1 @ _Hj oaLG ,2%3 42 3%~8 -% y/ ] 1 ©L HG ./ ?Xe
(~ QR ,Q©L H{B y/%M i( ?!8 -% -(w %/ b©AG ,@8R bA@ G ,./0
\I H0YB i( .=0 )H% t8 @e@&G ,¥ lH @e@& sU\ @!( '7 ?& %8 gc ,@</0 Z%MH Z#GE
#A S% ./0 567 2% @MME ?7( U@m b©L £@028 'I! @&G ,@</0 b7%f i(
D
.=0 J .@=
8 1 b©L Z08 QR HG H0%(f :( 1 Ox E 28 1 GK L( ./0 ?@I
S% ./ 567 D
DG ?2 • :
D)E M E% N OP
@</ ME OwG i( .=0 ?Xe R (~
D ./ i( ?@% U73%M s% -% M] -G
2%3 42 3%~
D Z~eA F~ E .=0 i( ,@</0 M] OwG ?0aG :
7 QR 7 ?(E E HE g
@</0 N%ME _L ME M] uR '( #] 0X%M ?2%3 -a{ 567 1 Z@\ £@6/% FG=E D
'I
UL( . '7 WE 7E @( @</ ME @W D
1 ?<!%8 ?Xe R ~@; ] d\ ,NR
M] ;XYG HGE aL7 @</ ME 28 @e@& HU«c 1 NR&G ,2%3 42 567 1 @</0
& ,0ML7 6 ~ bMH #7G 2% u _2(cG s@©L8 i( (~8 I ,MH u :08
D (~8 &
4{ bg MH !;k7 @</ ME OwGG ,./0 TUL7 ª i( VxE 2%
D
M; ?2 • :
AB IA O#, *,
V@\ ./0 56 ~@; bAI 28 @e@&G ,76 ?Xe R oaA ,
? # nAE ? 9,
_ # 76\
|c \wB ,MH 1 ./0 I7 %&f 22 @& sU\ i( s (~ _6 ?@ <! ] ,®ME MH 1 Z!( s% ' 7 D
3%~ QR ./ 567 1 ~@; ~a] : a] s~6 I8 7 ( 76\
2%3 42 ,V7I=c <&] s~6 ] ,.=0 Z0%I QR W] s~6 I8 E 'I! ,C 1 ULI D
Z!& ./0 S0x QRG D
.=0 E0 EG 76 bAI7 ^ %I
@ ,MH @eY , Vk<7 ,I
-62L UMMEG 2%3 42 8G ,@8R @ ,./0 1 - QE
bAI I8 %= ©%L st ,
76 '7 @60% bAI %& ?!IG @ ,?!%I8 @60%
,-(w %/ ©A ,./0 E , Vk<7
./0 @§E D
0 P a ,Ng kY #7 1 %& 7 O7 £\%% ,?W%7 ?I 76 %& @ Z~eA .=
./0 ~aEG Q©L H{B uHI\E s@©L8 i( .=0 (~% ~@; °6L '7 V( UL 1 ?Xe R aG D
2%3 42 567 767 '7 CG ,Z</ 767
D
QR ?2 • :
"
SH% 'P4 :
M5 I79 8 AB ='( MT5
#7 Q©L H{B '!w ./0 I7 1 Ie% _0 .=0 Z# ,7 ?Xe R UaL -%
# -! Q©L H{B 4@M D
@8j M] O7 ?7% E .=0 '7 2% ,NR @6G :
F6 g7
N%MH I8 'E ?N</ I7 O7 ?7% n73%M -% @UL 42 7 ?N(w7 1 ./0 '( _
Q©A H{c @X !U7 @MM] M] uR '( #B c ? N</0 Q©L H{B '!w !;k7 @</0 2% 4{ Qg ./ 56 ?7JG ,S 7 D
|c 0~L G ?P QR 0~ s68 ,Q©L H{B
F 1 Q©L H{B |c # \wc 2%3 42 bg N%MH 6%M @&G ,7vf @</0 N%MH '7 N7%
D 6(9 ?2 • :
AB IA 72K :
7G)E =UP 7H%K P
%3 ./0 E Z% 1 ?Xe R wG Z8@!~7 GE ,u @78 ©A ,Vª <&E ?I G ,W Z%C Z S
2%3 42 C .=0 '6% E f ,S% ./ MH 1 °3AkG W
D 2%3 42 b@!~7 8
V@0~A 07G 2@~
D % A# |c ,-!&G -(A b/2X7 3%M ,0& = |c ,?!8 b @7
D 3%~G
-/2X7 G qual
@AB :8e! % §Gquan qualitative and quantitative
D ' 7 %& L\
0I =]
G QUAL
1 nw( b@!~ '7 ( @w8 s8G ,MH 1 8 |c NR\ ,QUAN
AE ! 5 O7 ,?Xe R FkY FG#
2%3 42 1 ./0 V73%M <&] s@7X%
: s@!X%
-=xB
QUAN → qual
1I%Mf >~~% s@!X% ,
qual → QUAN
)H6% Qv s@!X% ,
QUAN + qual
, V* 7/2
QUAN) (QUAL→←
?= %7 s@!X% ,
quan →→←→→←←← QUAL
D W
M -% 42 L8 i(G #± bA@0 ?@ªG O! 2%3 42 U@\ 3%~8 E 'I! -% n73%
@</0 M] '(
D @&G ,2%3 42 s@7X8 A] Q@U!% sUe .=0 G 8 i( ?Xe R &H 6\
./0 4{ s@©L8 i( s@7X% N8 (~8 D
42 s@7X8 ^ i( <7E 6G :0G ,V(@J <&] 2%3
?x\] HX 2%3 42 s@7X8 @w% b223 _Ac @e@& VxE D
M;9 ?2 • :
XB D)E AY 1"
:
*B9 D)E IA; ZR 9, [U%
1 MH _#B u%M 7G ./0 _#c ª i( .=0 ?Xe R (~
aG ,2%3 42
1 ?<!%8 ,uHI\E s@©L8 1 .=0 J M] '7 V(
:
D 1
ME 7
?N</ @!( i( ?%M @& ?N ./0 b@w\
D 2
?gG ?N%MH Z73%~%M QR S%3 ./0 s@!X8 7 D 3
?N</ 1 :&H |c ?X%M @& ?N%MH 1 &H '7 D 4
7
?N8A@ O!%M @& ?N8A@ HX7 D 5
?N8A@ ?/%M @&
D 6
?@(LG @!I N8A@ bAI7 T7%M @&
D 7
?N8A@ 1 N Q©L H{B Z0@M QR HG 7 D 8
?b0< |c 42%%M @&
D 9
?4X |c 42%%M @&
c @e@& '( /wG Ie qH6 r ?Xe R '7G S%3 ./0 _#
D
G ?2 • :
\] -*1
\] ^T_
Ng 1 , %I @!(G ./0 2 -;UL 56 *X3 7 b=af ^ ?Xe R 6
£=kG O# s~a F< ?@0M i( ,@L7v 2YG Av7 OwG ?<7 ,7 x6 VxE oaLG D
: 6 ^
?<7 ,x6 b=af i( 6\ i( FX 6%7 VHI\E 6G ,S%3 ./0 L _x(E :78 :
6%%M -% @\wB N8 567 -2%M b=a .=0 G 8 |c ?Xe R ¨ & ,./0 567 ./0 @!( 1 N D
%3 42 567 E sH %I8 @& aL7 VxE sU '7 , %I 6@t V6= £% 2
@</0 N%MH '(
D ?<7 ,H!%M G UL7 e7 f ME Z@#8 @e@& |c .=0 ?Xe R J &
, w7 7
?N%MH ,Z!& N</ 567 '( ³" _2(B [(7 n~ NAd\ ,F~ R Z#8 7L( 9
27 nAE ?
#7 HW s6% 6@6 1 D
bI '7 'I¦ ( ?a Za N@( -C0L 7 %I8 E N@( NR D
H0
%! Xa -UeJ WG ,S%3 N</ 56 % -UeJ WG N I E |c r%ª ,YE
−30 60
@At
@</0 N%MH X8 D
! ,X ./ R !~
x0 F6%Ak X 3%M UaC%~ -% ?<
£ { DD
@# MH S2´ :L%67 AIG ,N%MH '( @# sUe x! E 'Yj |c 0~L
D
M ?2 • :
A` IP : '( a CU5 >G
%~ QR I G ,)%I 1 Y] ?Xe R S% ./0 V=67 Z@\
D ?Xe R E aG
^ G ,2%3 42 b=67 # JHc ME Ng a st ,S%3 ./0 567 bAI7 #!
£=k 1 U©8 -% 42 D
L20 L b6x '( 56 F<! Ng ?Xe s%%G D
N%MH 28
/0 L20 L b6x O7 ,@6\] FW] QGg ,:@I7] @I )k{ )H i( @<
D #7 O7
I7 ?& aL7 n0=W -% 2A] &R & ,)%I R 1 UaA -% 2%3 42 567 bAI7 \&
3 42 1 ./ 567 @W i( F< R (~@
2%
D
.7 •
:
,S% ./ 56 e%3 bAI aL7 1 !U7 8 b @7 )%I R O%!%
D ?& E0 , VfGE
?Xe 1 U%aL7 s%%M -% x6 '( V7( VX37 N@28 -% s% !;6 ?X\
(~! ,V@At D
/0 @!(G FY w i(
!~ s~6 ?X\ ?& v%! ,.
, MH s~a 9
ME '7 -0H8 °A ?& %G ,
@\wc H7G 'H}G U#7 D
w! £!(E HX Ie% i( .=0 (~7 U# M] '7 X6G
Z</
D 1 (~8 " 2AE '( H0( -U\ 'H% 7E ./0 56 " I7 y/%M
D uR aL7 s%8 .@=
56 _Ac @L O0%8 ,@62L7 62 bAI MH b~# ~aE O@m 1 76 'H% 1 .=0 µ ¶··} gcG D
S% ./ 56 VkXe7 Ve%7 V#g!A )%I 1 N%!@M ,)%I '7 ?X\ ?& 1 H ¸·I7 7E D
U\ @\wB nAAB I0J i( ak bg HG b_6 !;a '!x%
D ?& #8 ,Ng |c \wB
-0H8 °A ,
L@( ~#
9 -aG ./ i( F<7 3%M ,'} ?& F&c @e@& U©8 D
3%M @e@& U©G
S% ./ 56 e%3 bAI 2% 2A]
D 52 &
1 2%3 42 s@7X8 % i( <7E )%I
S%3 ./0 1 C% HU«c p £=k D
b3c • : @0 sM ?!8 ,Z%MH _#c 1 .=0 (~8 =67 £=k7 ,£=k '7 :(A )%I %=
gA ,£@02% 1 &H b 2Y ,MH bGE ,2%3 42 LG ,@I@ rg!AG ,6\ r
,1I%Mf >~~% s@!X% ,-=xB >~~% s@!X% ?!8 S%3 ./0 s@7X% £=k7 <
?= %7 s@!X% ,T7 s@!X% ,)H6% Qv s@!X%
D
* * *
