L
3(1*$58+.203(7(16,352)(6,21$/*858'$1)$6,/,7$6 %(/$-$57(5+$'$3+$6,/%(/$-$56,6:$.(/$6;
$'0,1,675$6,3(5.$1725$13$'$0$7$',./$70(1*(/2/$ 3(5$/$7$1.$172560.180$¶$5,)187$/$1*60.<3(
186$17$5$'$160.1858/8/80/(%$.6,8
6NULSVL
8QWXN0HPSHUROHK*HODU6DUMDQD3HQGLGLNDQ 3DGD8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ
2OHK
6LOYLD,QVDQL3UDVLVND 1,0
-8586$13(1',',.$1(.2120,
)$.8/7$6(.2120,
LL
3(56(78-8$13(0%,0%,1*
6NULSVLLQLWHODKGLVHWHMXLROHK3HPELPELQJXQWXNGLDMXNDQNHVLGDQJSDQLWLDXMLDQ VNULSVLSDGD
+DUL
7DQJJDO
0HQJHWDKXL
.HWXD-XUXVDQ3HQGLGLNDQ(NRQRPL 3HPELPELQJ
LLL
3(1*(6$+$1.(/8/86$1
6NULSVLLQLWHODKGLSHUWDKDQNDQGLGHSDQ6LGDQJ3DQLWLD8MLDQ6NULSVL)DNXOWDV (NRQRPL8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJSDGD
+DUL
7DQJJDO
3HQJXML,
'UV0DULPLQ03G 1,3
3HQJXML,,
,VPL\DWL63G03G 1,3
3HQJXML,,,
'UD1DQLN6XU\DQL03G 1,3
0HQJHWDKXL
LY
3(51<$7$$1
6D\DPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZD\DQJWHUWXOLVGLGDODPVNULSVLLQLEHQDUEHQDUKDVLONDU\D VD\D VHQGLUL EXNDQ MLSODNDQ GDUL NDU\D WXOLV RUDQJ ODLQ EDLN VHEDJLDQ DWDX VHOXUXKQ\D3HQGDSDWDWDXWHPXDQRUDQJODLQ\DQJWHUGDSDWGDODPVNULSVLLQLGLNXWLS DWDXGLUXMXNEHUGDVDUNDQNRGHHWLNLOPLDK$SDELODGLNHPXGLDQKDULWHUEXNWLVNULSVL LQLDGDODKKDVLOMLSODNDQGDULNDU\DWXOLVRUDQJODLQPDNDVD\DEHUVHGLDPHQHULPD VDQNVLVHVXDLNHWHQWXDQ\DQJEHUODNX
6HPDUDQJ 2NWREHU
Y
02772'$13(56(0%$+$1
02772
³-DQJDQSLNLUNDQNHJDJDODQNHPDULQ
+DULLQLVXGDKODLQVXNVHVSDVWLGLUDLK
6HODPDVHPDQJDWPDVLKPHQ\HQJDW´
0DULR7HJXK
3(56(0%$+$1
$WDV UDKPDWGDQULGKR$OODK6:7VNULSVL
LQL6D\DSHUVHPEDKNDQNHSDGD
.HGXDRUDQJWXDNX%DSDN6ODPHW 5L\DGLGDQ,EX:DWLQLQJVLK\DQJVHODOX
PHPEHULGR¶DGDQGXNXQJDQ
6XDPLNX*XQWXU'ZL5LYDQLQJW\DV $OPDPDWHU8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL
YL 35$.$7$
3XML V\XNXU NDPL SDQMDWNDQ NHKDGLUDW $OODK 6:7 \DQJ WHODK PHOLPSDKNDQ UDKPDWGDQKLGD\DK1\DVHKLQJJD NHUMDSHQXOLVGDSDWPHPEXDKNDQ KDVLOGHQJDQ PHQ\HOHVDLNDQ VNULSVL EHUMXGXO ³3HQJDUXK .RPSHWHQVL 3URIHVLRQDO *XUX GDQ )DVLOLWDV%HODMDU7HUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD.HODV;$GPLQLVWUDVL3HUNDQWRUDQ 0DWD 'LNODW 0HQJHOROD 3HUDODWDQ .DQWRU 60. 6ZDVWD 6H .DEXSDWHQ 7HJDO´
6HJDOD KDODQJDQ GDQ ULQWDQJDQ WLGDN DNDQ PDPSX GLODOXL WDQSD MDODQ \DQJ GLWXQMXNNDQGDQ GLJDULVNDQ1\D
3HQ\XVXQDQ VNULSVL LQL GLPDNVXGNDQ XQWXN PHPHQXKL SHUV\DUDWDQ GDODP PHPSHUROHK JHODU 6DUMDQD 3HQGLGLNDQ 3HQ\HOHVDLDQ LQL WLGDN WHUOHSDV GDUL EDQWXDQ ELPELQJDQ GDQ GXNXQJDQ GDUL EHUEDJDL SLKDN 8QWXN LWX SHQXOLV PHQJXFDSNDQWHULPDNDVLKNHSDGD
3URI 'U )DWKXU 5RNKPDQ 0 +XP 5HNWRU 8QLYHUVLWDV 1HJHUL 6HPDUDQJ \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ NHVHPSDWDQ NHSDGD SHQXOLV XQWXN PHPSHUROHK SHQGLGLNDQGL8QLYHUVLDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ
'U :DK\RQR 0 0 'HNDQ )DNXOWDV (NRQRPL \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ NHPXGDKDQDGPLQLVWUDVLGDODPSHULMLQDQSHODNVDQDDQSHQHOLWLDQ
'U $GH 5XVWLDQD 0 6L .HWXD -XUXVDQ 3HQGLGLNDQ (NRQRPL \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQNHPXGDKDQDGPLQLVWUDVLGDODPSHULMLQDQSHODNVDQDDQSHQHOLWLDQ 'UD 1DQLN 6XU\DQL 0 3G 'RVHQ 3HPELPELQJ \DQJ GHQJDQ SHQXK
YLL
6HOXUXK 'RVHQ GDQ VWDI 3HQGLGLNDQ (NRQRPL \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ NHPXGDKDQDGPLQLVWUDVLGDODPSHULMLQDQSHODNVDQDDQSHQHOLWLDQ
6HOXUXK .HSDODVHNRODK60.6ZDVWDNHDKOLDQ$GPLQLVWUDVL3HUNDQWRUDQ60.
0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUD 60. 1XUXO 8OXP /HEDNVLX .DEXSDWHQ 7HJDO \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ NHPXGDKDQ GDODP DGPLQLVWUDVL SHQJDPELODQGDWD
.HGXD RUDQJ WXD GDQ DGLNDGLNNX \DQJ VHQDQWLDVD PHQGXNXQJ SHQFDSDLDQ FLWDFLWDNX
7HPDQWHPDQ PDKDVLVZD 3HQGLGLNDQ $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ DQJNDWDQ
6HPXD SLKDN \DQJ WLGDN GDSDW SHQXOLV VHEXWNDQ VDWXSHUVDWX \DQJ WHODK PHPEDQWXGDODPSHQ\HOHVDLDQVNULSVLLQL
6HPRJD $OODK 6:7 PHPEHUL EDODVDQ DWDV VHPXD NHEDLNDQ \DQJ WHODK GLEHULNDQ 3HQXOLV EHUKDUDS VHPRJD VNULSVL LQL GDSDW EHUPDQIDDW EDJL SHPEDFD GDQVHEDJDLEDKDQDFXDQSHQHOLWLVHODQMXWQ\D
6HPDUDQJ -DQXDUL
YLLL 6$5,
3UDVLVND 6LOYLD ,QVDQL ³3HQJDUXK .RPSHWHQVL 3URIHVLRQDO *XUX GDQ
)DVLOLWDV %HODMDU 7HUKDGDS +DVLO %HODMDU 6LVZD .HODV ; $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ3DGD0DWD'LNODW0HQJHOROD3HUDODWDQ.DQWRU60.6H.DEXSDWHQ 7HJDO´ 6NULSVL -XUXVDQ 3HQGLGLNDQ (NRQRPL )DNXOWDV (NRQRPL 8QLYHUVLWDV 1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ3HPELPELQJ 'UD1DQLN6XU\DQL03G
.DWD.XQFL.RPSHWHQVL3URIHVLRQDO*XUX)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU+DVLO%HODMDU +DVLO EHODMDU PHUXSDNDQ WRODN XNXU NHEHUKDVLODQ VLVZD GDODP PHQHULPD SHODMDUDQ \DQJ GLVDPSDLNDQ JXUX 8QWXN PHQJHWDKXL KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD GL VHNRODKJXUXSHUOXPHQJDGDNDQHYDOXDVLDWDVNHPDPSXDQ\DQJGLPLOLNLVHRUDQJ
3HQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQJJXQDNDQ PHWRGH NXDQWLWDWLI GHQJDQ YDULDEHO EHEDV \DQJ WHUGLUL GDUL NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX ; GDQ IDVLOLWDV EHODMDU ; GHQJDQ YDULDEHO WHULNDW KDVLO EHODMDU < 3HQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQJJXQDNDQ VDPSHO VHMXPODK VLVZD 0HWRGH SHQJXPSXODQ GDWD \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ SHQHOLWL PHQJJXQDNDQ PHWRGHREVHUYDVLZDZDQFDUDGDQNXHVLRQHU7HNQLNDQDOLVLVGDWDSHQHOLWLDQLQL PHQJJXQDNDQ XML DVXPVL NODVLN DQDOLVLV UHJUHVL OLQLHU EHUJDQGD XML KLSRWHVLV GHQJDQEDQWXDQ6366IRU:LQGRZV5HODVHGDQDQDOLVLVGHVNULSWLISHUVHQWDVH
+DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD DQDOLVLV UHJUHVL OLQLHU EHUJDQGD GLSHUROHK SHUVDPDDQ < ; ; 8ML ) \DQJ GLSHUROHK )KLWXQJ VHKLQJJD +D GLWHULPD 6HFDUD SDUVLDO XML W NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX ; GLSHUROHK WKLWXQJ GHQJDQ VLJQLILNDQVL VHKLQJJD +D GLWHULPD )DVLOLWDV EHODMDU ; VHKLQJJD +D GLWHULPD 6HFDUD VLPXOWDQ 5 NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX GDQ IDVLOLWDV EHODMDU EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDU\DLWXVHEHVDU
%HUGDVDUNDQKDVLOSHQHOLWLDQGDSDWGLVLPSXONDQEDKZDDGDSHQJDUXKSRVLWLI GDQ VLJQLILNDQ DQWDUD NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX GDQ IDVLOLWDV EHODMDU EHUSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDU6DUDQGDODPSHQHOLWLDQLQL\DLWX%HUNDLWDQ GHQJDQ IDVLOLWDV EHODMDUSDGD LQGLNDWRU PHVLQ NDQWRU SDGD 60. 0$¶DULI 18
L[ $%675$&7
3UDVLVND 6LOYLD ,QVDQL7KH (IIHFW 2I 7HDFKHU 3URIHVVLRQDO &RPSHWHQFH $QG /HDUQLQJ )DFLOLW\ 7RZDUG WKH /HDUQLQJ 2XWFRPH RI 0DLQWDLQLQJ 2IILFH (TXLSPHQW6XEMHFWIRU;*UDGH6WXGHQWV0DMRULQJ2IILFH$GPLQLVWUDWLRQDW7HJDO 5HJHQF\ 3ULYDWH 9RFDWLRQDO 6FKRROV $ )LQDO 3URMHFW (FRQRPLFV (GXFDWLRQ 'HSDUWPHQW (FRQRPLFV )DFXOW\ 6WDWH 8QLYHUVLW\ RI 6HPDUDQJ $GYLVRU 'UD 1DQLN6XU\DQL03G
.H\ZRUGV 7HDFKHU 3URIHVVLRQDO &RPSHWHQFH /HDUQLQJ )DFLOLW\ /HDUQLQJ 5HVXOW
/HDUQLQJRXWFRPH LVRQHRIWKHUHIHUHQFHVRIVWXGHQWV¶VXFFHVVLQUHFHLYLQJ
WKHPDWHULDOFRQYH\HGE\WHDFKHU,QRUGHUWRILQGRXWWKHOHDUQLQJUHVXOWWHDFKHUV
QHHGWRKROGDQHYDOXDWLRQRIVWXGHQWV¶FRPSHWHQFHDIWHUUHFHLYLQJWKHPDWHULDO
/HDUQLQJ UHVXOW LV DOVR LQIOXHQFHG E\ VRPH IDFWRUV VXFK DV WHDFKHU SURIHVVLRQDO FRPSHWHQFHDQGOHDUQLQJIDFLOLW\%DVHGRQWKHLQLWLDOREVHUYDWLRQLWZDVLQGLFDWHG WKDW WKH OHDUQLQJ UHVXOW RI PDLQWDLQLQJ RIILFH HTXLSPHQW VXEMHFW IRU ; JUDGH VWXGHQWVRISULYDWHYRFDWLRQDOVFKRROVDURXQG 7HJDO UHJHQF\ZDVQRW JRRGHQRXJK
,WZDV D TXDQWLWDWLYHUHVHDUFKHPSOR\HGWHDFKHUSURIHVVLRQDOFRPSHWHQFH ;DQGOHDUQLQJIDFLOLW\;DVWKHLQGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOHVDQGOHDUQLQJUHVXOWDV WKH GHSHQGHQW YDULDEOH < VWXGHQWV ZHUH WDNHQ DV VDPSOH RI WKH UHVHDUFK 7KH GDWD ZDV FROOHFWHG XVLQJ REVHUYDWLRQ LQWHUYLHZ DQG TXHVWLRQQDLUH ,Q DQDO\]LQJ WKH GDWD WKH UHVHDUFKHU XVHG FODVVLF DVVXPSWLRQ WHVW GRXEOH OLQHDU UHJUHVVLRQ DQDO\VLV K\SRWKHVLV WHVW XVLQJ 6366 IRU :LQGRZV 5HOHDVH DQG GHVFULSWLYHSHUFHQWDJHDQDO\VLV
7KH UHVHDUFK DQDO\VLV VKRZHG WKDW WKH GRXEOH OLQHDU UHJUHVVLRQ DQDO\VLV UHVXOWHG DQ HTXDWLRQ RI < ; ; )URP ) WHVW LW ZDV UHWULHYHGWKDW)FDOFXODWH VRWKDW+D DFFHSWHG6LPXOWDQHRXVO\5WHDFKHU SURIHVVLRQDOFRPSHWHQFHDQGOHDUQLQJIDFLOLW\ZHUH
$FFRUGLQJ WR WKH UHVHDUFK UHVXOW LW FRXOG EH FRQFOXGHG WKDW WKHUH ZHUH SRVLWLYH DQG VLJQLILFDQW HIIHFW RI WHDFKHU SURIHVVLRQDO FRPSHWHQFH DQG OHDUQLQJ
[ '$)7$5,6,
+DODPDQ
+$/$0$1-8'8/ L
3(56(78-8$13(0%,0%,1* LL
3(51<$7$$1 LLL
02772'$13(56(0%$+$1 LY
35$.$7$ Y
6$5, YLLL
$%675$&7 L[
'$)7$5,6, [
'$)7$57$%(/ [LY
'$)7$5*$0%$5 [YL
'$)7$5/$03,5$1 [YLL
%$%3(1'$+8/8$1
/DWDU%HODNDQJ
5XPXVDQ0DVDODK
7XMXDQ3HQHOHWLDQ
0DQIDDW3HQHOLWLDQ
%$%,,/$1'$6$17(25,
%HODMDU
3HQJHUWLDQ%HODMDU
&LULFLUL%HODMDU
[L
+DVLO%HODMDU
3HQJHUWLDQ+DVLO%HODMDU
)DNWRUIDNWRU\DQJ0HPSHQJDUXKL+DVLO%HODMDU
.RPSHWHQVL3URIHVLRQDO*XUX
3HQJHUWLDQ.RPSHWHQVL3URIHVLRQDO*XUX ,QGLNDWRU.RPSHWHQVL3URIHVLRQDO*XUX
3HUDQ*XUXGDODP3URVHV3HPEHODMDUDQ
)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU
.RQVHS'DVDU)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU
3HQJHUWLDQ$GPLQLVWUDVL3UDVDUDQDGDQ6DUDQD3HQGLGLNDQ
,QGLNDWRU)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU
3HQHOLWLDQ<DQJ5HOHYDQ
.HUDQJND%HUILNLU
+LSRWHVLV
%$%,,,0(72'(3(1(/,7,$1
-HQLVGDQ'HVDLQ3HQHOLWLDQ
3RSXODVL6DPSHOGDQ7HNQLN3HQJDPELODQ6DPSHO
3RSXODVL
6DPSHOGDQ7HNQLN3HQJDPELODQ6DPSHO
9DULDEHO3HQHOLWLDQ
3HQJHUWLDQ9DULDEHO
9DULDEHO%HEDV;
[LL
0HWRGH3HQJXPSXODQ'DWD
.XVLRQHUDWDX$QJNHW
2EVHUYDVL
:DZDQFDUD
9DOLGLWDVGDQ5HOLDELOLWDV
9DOLGLWDV
5HOLDELOLWDV
0HWRGH$QDOLVLV'DWD
$QDOLVLV'HVNULSWLI3HUVHQWDVH
$QDOLVLV/LQLHU%HUJDQGD
8ML+LSRWHVLV
8ML3HQJDUXK6LPXOWDQ
8ML3DUVLDO
8ML.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL6LPXOWDQ
8ML.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL3DUVLDO
8ML$VXPVL.ODVLN
8ML1RUPDOLWDV
8ML0XOWLNRORQLHULWDV
8ML+HWHURVNHGDVWLVLWDV
%$%,9+$6,/3(1(/,7,$1'$13(0%$+$6$1
+DVLO3HQHOLWLDQ
$QDOLVLV'HVNULSWLI3HUVHQWDVH
[LLL
*XUX
$QDOLVLV'HVNULSWLI9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU
$QDOLVLV5HJUHVL%HUJDQGD
8ML+LSRWHVLV
8ML6LPXOWDQ8ML)
8ML3DUVLDOXMLW
.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL6LPXOWDQ5
.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL3DUVLDOU
8ML$VXPVL.ODVLN
8ML1RUPDOLWDV
8ML0XOWLNRORQLHULWDV
8ML+HWHURVNHGDVWLVLWDV
3HPEDKDVDQ
%$%93(18783
6LPSXODQ
6DUDQ
'$)7$53867$.$
[LY
'$)7$5 7$%(/
+DODPDQ 7DEHO'DIWDU-XPODK6LVZD\DQJ7LGDN7XQWDV 7DEHO'DIWDU-XPODK6LVZD\DQJ7LGDN7XQWDV 7DEHO'DIWDU-XPODK6LVZD\DQJ7LGDN7XQWDV 7DEHO-XPODK)DVLOLWDV'L0DVLQJPDVLQJ6HNRODK 7DEHO3HQHOLWLDQ7HUGDKXOX 7DEHO3RSXODVL3HQHOLWLDQ 7DEHO3URSRUVL6DPSHO3HQHOLWLDQ 7DEHO.ULWHULD-DZDEDQ 7DEHO+DVLO8ML9DOLGLWDV,QVWUXPHQ9DULDEHO.RPSHWHQVL
3URIHVLRQDO*XUX 7DEHO+DVLO8ML9DOLGLWDV,QVWUXPHQ9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU 7DEHO2XWSXW63668ML5HOLDELOLWDV,QVWUXPHQ.RPSHWHQVL3URIHVLRQDO
*XUX 7DEHO+DVLO8ML5HOLDELOLWDV,QVWUXPHQ9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU 7DEHO.ULWHULD'HVNULSWLI3HUVHQWDVH 7DEHO$QDOLVLV'HVNULSVL3HUVHQWDVH9DULDEHO.RPSHWHQVL
[Y
[YL
'$)7$5 *$0%$5
[YLL
'$)7$5/$03,5$1
+DODPDQ
/DPSLUDQ6XUDW,MLQ2EVHUYDVL
/DPSLUDQ6XUDW,MLQ3HQHOLWLDQ
/DPSLUDQ6XUDW.HWHUDQJDQWHODK0HODNXNDQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ+DVLO:DZDQFDUD2EVHUYDVL$ZDO /DPSLUDQ.LVLNLVL8ML&RED,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ.DWD3HQJDQWDU/HPEDU8ML&RED,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ/HPEDU8ML&RED,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ7DEXODVL'DWD8ML&RED9DULDEHO.RPSHWHQVL
3URIHVLRQDO*XUX
/DPSLUDQ7DEXODVL'DWD8ML&RED9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU /DPSLUDQ2XWSXW63668ML9DOLGLWDV9DULDEHO.RPSHWHQVL
3URIHVLRQDO*XUX
/DPSLUDQ2XWSXW63668ML9DOLGLWDV9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU /DPSLUDQ+DVLO8ML9DOLGLWDV8ML&RED,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ+DVLO8ML5HOLDELOLWDV8ML&RED,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ'DIWDU1DPD5HVSRQGHQ,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ'DIWDU1LODL6LVZD60.6ZDVWD.DEXSDWHQ7HJDO /DPSLUDQ .LVLNLVL,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ /DPSLUDQ.DWD3HQJDQWDU/HPEDU,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ
/DPSLUDQ/HPEDU,QVWUXPHQ3HQHOLWLDQ
[YLLL
3URIHVLRQDO*XUX
/DPSLUDQ7DEXODVL'DWD3HQHOLWLDQ9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU
/DPSLUDQ7DEHO.ULWHULD'HVNULSWLI
/DPSLUDQ7DEHO'HVNULSWLI3HUVHQWDVH9DULDEHO.RPSHWHQVL
3URIHVLRQDO*XUX
/DPSLUDQ7DEHO'HVNULSWLI3HUVHQWDVH9DULDEHO)DVLOLWDV%HODMDU /DPSLUDQ7DEHO3HUVLDSDQ$QDOLVLV5HJUHVL/LQLHU
/DPSLUDQ$QDOLVLV5HJUHVL
ϭ %$%, 3(1'$+8/8$1
/DWDU%HODNDQJ
+DVLO EHODMDU PHUXSDNDQ WRODN XNXU NHEHUKDVLODQ VLVZD GDODP PHQHULPD SHODMDUDQ \DQJ GLVDPSDLNDQ JXUX 8QWXN PHQJHWDKXL KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD JXUX SHUOX PHQJDGDNDQ HYDOXDVL DWDV NHPDPSXDQ VLVZD SDGD VDDW PHQHULPD PDWHUL
\DQJ WHODK GLVDPSDLNDQ PHODOXL KDVLO SURVHV EHODMDU PHQJDMDU³HYDOXDVL KDVLO EHODMDUPHUXSDNDQSURVHVXQWXNPHQHQWXNDQQLODLEHODMDUVLVZDPHODOXLNHJLDWDQ SHQLODLDQ DWDX SHQJXNXUDQ KDVLO EHODMDU´ 'LP\DWL GDQ 0XGMLRQR
6DUGLPDQ PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD WXMXDQ SHQGLGLNDQ GLNDWDNDQ WHUFDSDL DSDELOD SUHVWDVL EHODMDU \DQJ GDSDW GLOLKDW GDUL KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD PHQJDODPL SHUNHPEDQJDQGDQSHQLQJNDWDQNXDOLWDVVXPEHUGD\DPDQXVLDPHUXSDNDQV\DUDW PXWODNXQWXNPHQFDSDLWXMXDQSHPEDQJXQDQ
6DODK VDWX XSD\D XQWXN PHQFHUGDVNDQ GDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ NHWHUDPSLODQ WHUPDVXN SHQFDSDLDQQ\DDGDODKPHODOXLSHQGLGLNDQ()6FXPDFKHUPHQJDWDNDQ
EDKZD ³3HQGLGLNDQ DGDODK \DQJ WHUSHQWLQJ VHUWD GLOLKDW GDUL SHUDQQ\D PDND
SHQGLGLNDQ DGDODK NXQFL XQWXN VHJDODQQ\D´ -DGL SHQGLGLNDQ PHUXSDNDQ VDODK
³SHQGLGLNDQQDVLRQDODGDODKPHQFHUGDVNDQNHKLGXSDQEDQJVDGDQPQJHPEDQJNDQ PDQXVLD,QGRQHVLDVHXWXKQ\D\DLWXPDQXVLD\DQJEHUWDNZDWHUKDGDS7XKDQ<DQJ 0DKD (VD GDQ EHUEXGL SHNHUWL OXKXU PHPLOLNL SHQJHWDKXDQ GDQ NHWHUDPSLODQ NHVHKDWDQ MDVPDQL GDQ URKDQL NHSULEDGDQ \DQJ PDQWDS GDQ PDQGLUL VHUWD WDQJJXQJMDZDENHPDV\DUDNDWDQGDQNHEDQJVDDQ´
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
GLSHQXKL6WDQGDUNRPSHWHQVLJXUX\DQJKDUXVGLSHQXKLROHKSHQGLGLNDGDHPSDW NRPSHWHQVL \DLWX NRPSHWHQVL SHGDJRJLN NRPSHWHQVL NHSULEDGLDQ NRPSHWHQVLSURIHVLRQDONRPSHWHQVLVRVLDO
*XUX VDQJDW EHUSHUDQ SHQWLQJ GDODP PHQLQJNDWNDQ KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD NDUHQD DSDELOD VHRUDQJ JXUX PDPSX PHQJXDVL NHODV GDQ PHQJHUWL NDUDNWHU PDVLQJPDVLQJVLVZDPDNDVLVZDDNDQPHPEHULNDQUHVSRQSRVLWLIDWDXIHHGEDFN WLPEDO EDOLN \DQJ EDLN WHUKDGDS JXUX GDQ KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ GLGDSDNDQ DNDQ PHQLQJNDW2OHKNDUHQDLWXNRPSHWHQVLSURIHVLRQDOJXUXKDUXVGLPLOLNLROHKVHWLDS JXUX %HUGDVDUNDQ MXUQDO 6\DKUXGGLQ GNN \DQJ EHUMXGXO 7KH 5ROH RI
7HDFKHU¶V3URIHVVLRQDO&RPSHWHQFHLQ,PSOHPHQWLQJ6FKRRO%DVHG0DQDJHPHQW
6WXG\ $QDOLV\V DW 6HFRQGDU\ 6FKRRO LQ 3DUH3DUH &LW\ RI 6RXWK 6XODZHVL
3URYLQFH,QGRQHVLD PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD ³3URIHVVLRQDO FRPSHWHQFH FDQ EH
GHILQHGDVWKHWHDFKHUV¶FDSDELOLW\WRPDVWHUWKHLUVXEMHFWVLQGHSWKDQGWKHZD\
WR DSSURSULDWHO\ GHOLYHU LW WR WKH VWXGHQWV´ .RPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO GDSDW
GLGHILQLVLNDQVHEDJDLNHPDPSXDQJXUXXQWXNPHQJXDVDLPDWDSHODMDUDQPHUHND \DQJPHQGDODPGDQFDUDXQWXNPHQ\DPSDLNDQNHSDGDVLVZD
%HUGDVDUNDQVWXGLDZDOGL60.0D¶DULI187DODQJ60.<3(1XVDQWDUD
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³6FKRROIDFLOLWLHVFDQEH
EURDGO\FODVVLILHGLQWREXLOGLQJVJURXQGVDQGVHUYLFHV\VWHPV6FKRROEXLOGLQJV
FRQVLVWRIWKHH[WHUQDOEXLOGLQJHQYHORSHZKLFKFRPSULVHVWKHEXLOGLQJIRXQGDWLRQ
DQGH[WHUQDOZDOOVRIEXLOGLQJVZKLFKLQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWKWKHURRIZLQGRZVDQG
H[WHUQDO GRRUV VHSDUDWH DFFRPPRGDWLRQ IURP WKH H[WHUQDO HQYLURQPHQW´
EHODMDU \DQJ PHOLSXWL EDQJXQDQ EDQJXQDQ OXDU PDXSXQ GDODP NHODV DWDS MHQGHODSLQWXGDQSHOD\DQDQVLVWHPSDGDVHNRODKGDQDODWDODWVHNRODK
60. 0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUD GDQ 60. 1XUXO 8OXP
/HEDNVLXPHUXSDNDQVHNRODK60.VZDVWDGLNDEXSDWHQWHJDO\DQJGLGXJDKDVLO EHODMDUVLVZDPDVLKEHOXPEDLNKDOLQLMXJDGLGXNXQJROHKREVHUYDVLDZDOEDKZD PDVLK EDQ\DN VLVZD \DQJ EHOXP PHQFDSDL ..0 SDGD SHODMDUDQ PHQJHOROD SHUDODWDQ NDQWRU 'DWD NHWXQWDVDQ VLVZD SDGD VHPHVWHU JDVDO PDWD SHODMDUDQSHUDODWDQNDQWRUEHUGDVDUNDQREHVHUYDVLDZDO \DQJGLODNXNDQ GL60.
0D¶DULI187DODQJ60.<3(1XVDQWDUDGDQ60.1XUXO8OXP/HEDNVLXSDGD
NHODV ; $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ GHQJDQ EDWDV VWDQGDU NULWHULD NHWXQWDVDQ PLQLPDO ..0 \DQJ GLWHWDSNDQ SLKDN VHNRODK PDVLQJPDVLQJ XQWXN KDVLO EHODMDUPHQJHORODSHUDODWDQNDQWRUDGDODK'DULREVHUYDVLDZDOGLNHODV;$3
'DUL NHWLJD VHNRODK \DQJ PHQHWDSNDQ VWDQGDU NHWXQWDVDQ EHODMDU \DLWX PLQLPDO GDQ PDVLK DGD VLVZD GDUL PDVLQJPDVLQJ VHNRODK \DQJ EHOXP PHQFDSDLVWDQGDUNHWXQWDVDQ
7DEHO
1LODL8ODQJDQ+DULDQ *HQDS0DWD3HODMDUDQ 0HQJHOROD3HUDODWDQ.DQWRU
.HODV;$360.0D¶DULI187DKXQ$MDUDQ .HODV -XPODK6LVZD 6LVZD7LGDN7XQWDV8+ 7XQWDV6LVZD 3HUVHQWDVH6LVZD\DQJ7XQWDV
;$3 VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
-XPODK VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
7DEHO
1LODL8ODQJDQ+DULDQ *HQDS0DWD3HODMDUDQ 0HQJHOROD3HUDODWDQ.DQWRU
.HODV;$360.<3(1XVDQWDUD7DKXQ$MDUDQ .HODV -XPODK6LVZD 6LVZD7LGDN7XQWDV8+ 7XQWDV6LVZD 3HUVHQWDVH6LVZD\DQJ7XQWDV
;$3 VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
;$3 VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
-XPODK VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
7DEHO
1LODL8ODQJDQ+DULDQ *HQDS0DWD3HODMDUDQ 0HQJHOROD3HUDODWDQ.DQWRU
.HODV;$360.1XUXO8OXP7DKXQ$MDUDQ .HODV -XPODK6LVZD 6LVZD7LGDN7XQWDV8+ 7XQWDV6LVZD 3HUVHQWDVH6LVZD\DQJ7XQWDV
;$3 VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
;$3 VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
-XPODK VLVZD VLVZD 6LVZD [
'DUL WDEHO GLDWDV GDSDW GLLQGHWLILNDVLNDQ EDKZD VLVZD NHODV ; $3 SDGD PDVLQJPDVLQJ VHNRODK PDVLK EDQ\DN VLVZD \DQJ EHOXP PHPHQXKL VWDQGDU NHWXQWDVDQSDGDPDWHULPHQJHORODSHUDODWDQNDQWRUEHUMXPODKVLVZDSDGD60. 0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ VLVZD 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUD 6ODZL GDQ VLVZD SDGD 60.1XUXO8OXP/HEDNVLX'HQJDQ..0VHEHVDUKDOLQLGDSDWGLVLPSXONDQ EDKZDKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDNHODV;$3PDVLKUHQGDKGDQEHOXPVHVXDLGHQJDQDSD \DQJGLKDUDSDNDQ
0HQJHQDLIDVLOLWDVSDGDPDVLQJPDVLQJVHNRODK\DLWXVHNRODK60.0D¶DULI 187DODQJ60.<3(1XVDQWDUD6ODZLGDQ60.1XUXO8OXPQ/HEDNVLXVXGDK GLELODQJ OHQJNDS NDUHQD SDGD PDVLQJPDVLQJ VHNRODK UDWDUDWD XQWXN PDWHUL SHODMDUDQ 0HQJHOROD 3HUDODWDQ .DQWRU KDPSLU PHPHQXKL VWDQGDU .RPSHWHQVL PHVNLSXQDGDEHEHUDSD VHNRODKDGD \DQJEHOXPPHPLOLNLDODWWHUVHEXW %HULNXW MXPODK IDVOLWDV EHODMDU \DQJ PHQGXNXQJ NHODQFDUDQ SDGD PDWD SHODMDUDQ 0HQJHOROD3HUODWDQ.DQWRUGLPDVLQJPDVLQJVHNRODK
0HVLQ.HWLN0DQXDO
0HVLQ)RWRFRS\
7HOHSRQ
3UR\HNWRU2+3
0HVLQ+LWXQJ.DONXODWRU
.RPSXWHU
0HVLQ6WHQVLO
%DN6XUDW
3HQD
3HQJKDSXV
*XQWLQJ
0LVWDU3HQJJDULV
3HQVLO
3HQD%HUZDUQD
.HUWDV,VDS.DUERQ
%HUGDVDUNDQ SHQJDPDWDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ SDGD WDQJJDO $SULO GLNHWDKXL EDKZD NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX GDQ IDVLOLWDV EHODMDU VXGDK FXNXS EDLN DNDQ WHWDSL GLOLKDW GDUL WDEHO GL DWDV SDGD QLODL XODQJDQ KDULDQ WHUOLKDW VHEDJLDQEHVDUPDVLKEDQ\DN\DQJVLVZD\DQJEHOXPWXQWDV+DOLQLPHQGRURQJ SHQLOLWLXQWXNPHQHOLWL³3HQJDUXK.RPSHWHQVL3URIHVLRQDO*XUXGDQ)DVLOLWDV %HODMDU 6LVZD 7HUKDGDS +DVLO %HODMDU 6LVZD .HODV ; $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ 3DGD 0DWD 'LNODW 0HQJHOROD 3HUDODWDQ .DQWRU 60.0D¶DULI
18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUD GDQ 60. 1XUXO 8OXP /HEDNVLX .DEXSDWHQ7HJDO´
5XPXVDQ0DVDODK
%HUGDVDUNDQ ODWDU EHODNDQJ \DQJ WHODK GLXUDLNDQ GLDWDV PDND UXPXVDQ PDVDODKGDULSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODK
$GDNDK SHQJDUXK SRVLWLI GDQ VLJQLILNDQ VHFDUD VLPXOWDQ NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDOJXUXGDQIDVLOLWDVEHODMDUWHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDNHODV; $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ PDWD GLNODW PHQJHOROD SHUDODWDQ NDQWRU 60. 0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUD GDQ 60. 1XUXO 8OXP
$GDNDK SHQJDUXK SRVLWLI GDQ VLJQLILNDQ NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX WHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDNHODV;$GPLQLVWUDVL3HUNDQWRUDQPDWDGLNODW PHQJHOROD SHUDODWDQ NDQWRU 60. 0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUDGDQ60.1XUXO8OXP/HEDNVLX"
$GDNDK SHQJDUXK SRVLWLI GDQ VLJQLILNDQ IDVLOLWDV EHODMDU WHUKDGDS KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD NHODV ; $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ PDWD GLNODW PHQJHOROD SHUDODWDQ NDQWRU60. 0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUD GDQ 60.1XUXO8OXP/HEDNVLX"
7XMXDQ3HQHOLWLDQ
%HUGDVDUNDQUXPXVDQPDVDODK GLDWDV PDNDWXMXDQGDULSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODK VHEDJDLEHULNXW
0HQJNDMLDGDWLGDNQ\DSQJDUXKNRPSHWHQVLSURIHVLRQDOJXUXGDQIDVLOLWDV EHODMDUWHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDNHODV;$GPLQLVWUDVL3HUNDQWRUDQPDWD GLNODWPHQJHORODSHUDODWDQNDQWRU60.60. 0D¶DULI187DODQJ60. <3(1XVDQWDUDGDQ60.1XUXO8OXP/HEDNVLX
0HQJNDML DGD WLGDNQ\D SHQJDUXK NRPSHWHQVL SURIHVLRQDO JXUX WHUKDGDS KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD NHODV ; $GPLQLVWUDVL 3HUNDQWRUDQ PDWD GLNODW PHQJHOROD SHUDODWDQ NDQWRU 60. 0D¶DULI 18 7DODQJ 60. <3( 1XVDQWDUDGDQ60.1XUXO8OXP/HEDNVLX
0DQIDDW3HQHOLWLDQ
$GDSXQPDQIDDWGDULSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODK
%DJL3HQHOLWL
3HQHOLWLDQ LQL GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW EHUPDQIDDW VHEDJDL VDUDQD XQWXN PHODWLK EHUILNLUVHFDUDGLVLSOLQPHQDPEDKUHIHUHQVLGDQZDFDQDPHQJHPEDQJNDQ LOPXSHQJHWDKXDQ\DQJEHUKXEXQJDQGHQJDQNRPSHWHQVLSURIHVLRQDOJXUX GDQIDVLOLWDVEHODMDUGLVHNRODK
%DJL6HNRODK
