View of [KORESPONDENSI PUBLIKASI JURNAL BEREPUTASI]Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics

(1)

KORESPONDENSI PUBLIKASI JURNAL BEREPUTASI Bagian 1: Identitas dan Indeksasi Jurnal

Nama Jurnal: Croatian International Relations Review Contact Jurnal:

Croatian International Relations Review

Institute for Development and International Relations

Lj. F. Vukotinovića 2, 10000 Zagreb, Hrvatska, Croatia, T: +385 1 48 77 460, F: +385 1 48 28 361 E: editor@cirrj.org, W: cirrj.org

URL Jurnal: http://www.cirrj.com/index.php/cirrj

URL Artikel: https://cirrj.org/index.php/cirrj/article/view/456/403 Scopus Link: https://www.scopus.com/sourceid/5600155515

Scimago Link: https://www.scimagojr.com/journalsearch.php?q=5600155515&tip=sid&clean=0

(2)

Bagian 2: Komunikasi Publikasi dengan Editor Journal

Judul Artikel: Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics

Penulis Pertama dan Korespondensi:

Dadang Hartanto (Faculty of Social and Political Science, Public Administration Study Program, Universitas Muhammadyah Sumatera Utara, Medan, Indonesia; Email:

dadanghartanto@umsu.ac.id).

Penulis Anggota:

 Nasrullah Hidayat (Faculty of Social and Political Science, Public Administration Study Program, Universitas Medan Area, Indonesia; Email: nasarutlla@staf.uma.ac.id).

Histori Publikasi

 Submit Paper: 10 Juli 2021; [CIRR] Submission Acknowledgement

 Keputusan Editor: 12 Oktober 2021; [CIRR] Editor Decision

 Submit Revisi: 19 November 2021: [CIRR] Revision Acknowledgement

 Keputusan Editor: 26 November 2021: [CIRR] Editor Decision

 Permintaan Copyediting: 29 November 2021: [CIRR] Copyediting Review Request

 Jawaban Copyediting: 29 November 2021: [CIRR] Copyediting Acknowledgement

 Permintaan Galley Proof: 30 November 2021: [CIRR] Galley Proof

 Jawaban Galley Proof: 30 November 2021: [CIRR] Galley Proof Acknowledgement

(3)

[CIRR] Submission Acknowledgement

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Sat Jul 10, 2021, 11:24 PM M to me

Dadang Hartanto, Nasrullah Hidayat:

Thank you for submitting the manuscript, "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics" to Croatian International Relations Review. With the online journal management system that we are using, you will be able to track its progress through the editorial process by logging in to the journal web site:

Submission URL: https://cirrj.org/index.php/cirrj/authorDashboard/submission/463 Username: dadanghartanto

If you have any questions, please contact me. Thank you for considering this journal as a venue for your work.

______________________________________________________________________

(4)

[CIRR] Editor Decision

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Tue, Oct 12, 2021, 5:32 PM ) to me

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to Croatian International Relations Review, "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics ".

Our decision is: Revisions Required --- Reviewer A:

Introduction

 Add significance of the study.

Literature Review

 Add some latest studied.

 In the 1^st heading of literature section last paragraph is irrelevant, better to remove it otherwise relate it from the topic.

 There is a need to review the literature carefully and sort them, remove irrelevant aspects.

Results

 Proof Of the Crime of Money Laundering Committed After the Original Crime Has Permanent Legal Force: add more detail results

 Proof of Money Laundering Offenses Without Proving the Predicate Crime First:

add more detail results.

 The Burden of Reverse Evidence for Perpetrators of Money Laundering with Narcotics Origins in North Sumatra: add more detail results.

References

 Follow APA style in text citation and references.

General Comments

 Add guide interview for reader understanding.

Recommendation: Accept Submission --- Reviewer B:

 Explain the approach and data collected technique in the Abstract section.

 In the introduction section, please give explanation for Table 1. Narcotics Crime Data.

(5)

 It recommended to rewrite the introduction by highlighting the background of the study, research issue, motivation behind study, contextual and theoretical gap, significance, and objectives of the study respectively.

 On literature review, please add some previous study for proof theory

 Explain the criteria on which the sample of the study selected samples based on convenient sampling technique. Also explain the data analysis technique in methodology.

 Present the conclusion and research implications in separate sections.

Recommendation: Revisions Required --- Croatian International Relations Review

________________________________________________________________________

(6)

[CIRR] Revision Submission Acknowledgement

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Fri, Nov 19, 2021, 08:30 PM ) to me

Thank you for submitting the manuscript revision, "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics" to Croatian

International Relations Review. With the online journal management system that we are using, you will be able to track its progress through the editorial process by logging in to the journal web site:

If you have any questions, please contact me. Thank you for considering this journal as a venue for your work.

______________________________________________________________________

(7)

[CIRR] Editor Decision

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Sat, Nov 26, 2021, 10:11 AM ) to me

We have reached a decision regarding your submission to Croatian International Relations Review, "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics".

Our decision is to: Accept Submission Croatian International Relations Review

________________________________________________________________________

(8)

[CIRR] Copyediting Review Request

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Tue, Nov 29, 2021, 11:28 AM ) to me

Your submission "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics" for Croatian International Relations Review has been through the first step of copyediting and is available for you to review by following these steps.

1. Click on the Submission URL below.

2. Log into the journal and click on the File that appears in Step 1.

3. Open the downloaded submission.

4. Review the text, including copyediting proposals and Author Queries.

5. Make any copyediting changes that would further improve the text.

6. When completed, upload the file in Step 2.

7. Click on METADATA to check indexing information for completeness and accuracy.

8. Send the COMPLETE email to the editor and copyeditor.

This is the last opportunity to make substantial copyediting changes to the submission. The proofreading stage, that follows the preparation of the galleys, is restricted to correcting typographical and layout errors.

If you are unable to undertake this work at this time or have any questions, please contact me. Thank you for your contribution to this journal.

________________________________________________________________________

(9)

[CIRR] Copyediting Acknowledgement

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Tue, Nov 29, 2021, 10:18 PM ) to me

Thank you for reviewing the copyediting of your manuscript, "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics" for Croatian International Relations Review. We look forward to sending the galley proof of this work.

_____________________________________________________________________

(10)

[CIRR] Galley Proof

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Wed, Nov 30, 2021, 11:35 AM ) to me

Please find attached the manuscript for proof of your paper, which is to be published in the Croatian International Relations Review in December 2021. Please return the checked galley proofs via e-mail (editor@cirrj.org) or via online submission system within 48 hours of receipt. Late return of galley proofs may mean postponement to a later issue. This step is entirely the responsibility of the corresponding author.

Proofreading is your responsibility, and although the Editor may also make corrections, CIRR editorial office will not be able to proofread the paper after it has been returned and will not assume responsibility for any errors that you have failed to correct in the proofs.

Please also follow these guidelines when reviewing the galley proofs and highlight the changes on the manuscript:

· Please add or check all author(s) names and affiliations.

· Please use the proofs solely for checking the accuracy of the typesetting as well as the completeness and correctness of the text, tables, and figures

· Mark your corrections, in red ink, directly on the galley proofs. Make sure that your corrections are noticeable and easy to understand.

· Check all type on the galley proofs. Check the title, the abbreviations list, and the author–paper documentation paragraph.

· Check the table data against that in your original tables.

· Check any equations against those in your original manuscript. Make sure special characters have not dropped out.

· Check to be sure that figures are entirely legible, including any small-print text.

· If you find an error, look again at the lines around the error. Mistakes tend to cluster.

· Please check all references in both text and references list with APA 7th format.

· Pay close attention to deadlines; late submissions can delay publishing.

Note: If you are completely SATISFIED with the final proof, just inform the Editorial Office about your satisfaction via e-mail or via the online submission system. Only on the receipt of your final satisfaction opinion, The Editorial Office will send your article for final publication.

________________________________________________________________________

(11)

[CIRR] Galley Proof Acknowledgement

Inbox

Croatian International Relations Review <editor@cirrj.org>

Wed, Nov 30, 2021, 2:25 PM ) to me

Thank you for reviewing the galley proof of your manuscript, "Application of Reverse Evidence for The Crime of Money Laundering Based on The Origin of Narcotics" for Croatian International Relations Review. We look forward to publishing this work.

_____________________________________________________________________