Procedia Chemistry 16 ( 2015 ) 15 – 23
1876-6196 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences doi: 10.1016/j.proche.2015.12.010 )74 BC4?B 4<?;>H43 8= C74 ?A4B4=C BCD3H F4A4 501A820C8>= >5 6>;3 =0=>?0AC82;4B 2>;;>83B <>385820C8>= >5 6;0BBH 20A1>= 4;42CA>34 DB8=6C746>;3=0=>?0AC82;42>;;>83B0=3E>;C0<<4CA8234C4A<8=0C8>=>5A+DB8=6C74<>3858434;42CA>34)74 A4BD;CB >5 C74 ?A4B4=C BCD3H 8=3820C4 C70C N" >5 # $0F0B A4@D8A43 C> 5>A< 6>;3 =0=>?0AC82;4B 2>;;>83B (4;5
0BB4<1;H?A>24BBF0B5>D=3C>68E414CC4A6>;3=0=>?0AC82;4B18=38=6>=C>6;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>342><?0A43C> 03B>A?C8>= ?A>24BB 0B8=3820C431H<>A46>;3=0=>?0AC82;4B0CC02743>=C>C746;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>34 #>385820C8>=>5C746;0BBH20A1>= 4;42CA>34DB8=66>;3=0=>?0AC82;4B8=2A40B4B4=B8C8E8CH 0B8=3820C431H6>>3;8<8C>5 34C42C8>==6 " F8C70=0224?C01;4 ;8=40A8CHA0=64F8C78= b N6 ")742>AA4;0C8>=2>4558284=C0=3?A428B8>=>5C74<4C7>3F4A4 0=3 A4B?42C8E4;H C74B4CF>27A><8D<B?4284B 70E4E4AH38BC8=2C?A>?4AC84BA+70B7867C>G828CHF78;4A8B;4BBC>G82 0=3C74;0C4A8B 0;B> :=>F=C>14>=4>54BB4=C80;8>=5>A7D<0= F7827A4@D8A438=?0AC82D;0A0<>D=C8=C74384C D4 C> C748A >??>B8C4 =0CDA4 8= C>G828CH 8C 8B 8<?>AC0=C C> 38BC8=6D8B7 14CF44= A 0=3 A+ )74A45>A4 B?428582 0=3 B4=B8C8E4 34C4A<8=0C8>= <4C7>3B C> 38BC8=6D8B7 1>C7 >5 C74 B?4284B 0A4 A4@D8A43 (8=24 A 14;>=6B C> 4BB4=C80; =DCA8C8>= 8>= A4@D8A43 5>A <08=C08=8=6 =>A<0; ?7HB8>;>6820; 5D=2C8>= C7DB CA024 0<>D=C 34C4A<8=0C8>=>5A+142><4E4AH8<?>AC0=CC>0E>83C>G828=C0:48=384C)74A470B144=B4E4A0;B4=B8C8E4 <4C7>3BDB435>AA+34C4A<8=0C8>=8=2;D38=60C><8201B>A?C8>=B?42CA>?7>C><4CAH(?;0B<0<0BB B?42CA>B2>?HB?42CA>5;D>A8<4CAH274<8;D<8=4B24=24B?42CA>?7>C><4CAH0=34;42CA>274<820;<4C7>3B
;42CA>274<820;<4C7>3B5>AA+34C4A<8=0C8>=0A4C8<44558284=C70B7867B4=B8C8E8CH0=3B?4285828CH0=3 0;B>C748=BCAD<4=C8B40BHC>DB4;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>34<>3858431H 6>;3=0=>?0AC82;4BD$&70B 144= 0??;843 C> 34C42C A+ 1H 03B>A?C8>= BCA8??8=6 E>;C0<<4CAH C> 8=2A40B4 0=0;HC820; ?4A5>A<0=24 0=3 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
16 Santhy Wyantuti et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 ( 2015 ) 15 – 23
02784E4;8<8C>534C42C8>= >5 N6 " =2A40B43 B4=B8C8E8CH>5C744;42CA>3420=8<?A>E434C42C8>=018;8CH5>A ;>F2>=24=CA0C8>=B0<?;4B%=4>5C74<40=BC>8=2A40B4B4=B8C8E8CH8B1H<>385H8=6F>A:8=64;42CA>341H4=3 7H3A>64= 6A>D? BD1BC8CDC8>= F8C7 0<8=4 6A>D? $ F7827 8B :=>F= 0B B4;5 0BB4<1;H ?A>24BB >;3
=0=>?0AC82;4BD$&8B>=4>5C74?A454AA43 <>385H8=6064=C5>AC74F>A:8=64;42CA>34
)74 ?A4B4=C BCD3H 34E4;>? D$& DB8=6 B4;5 0BB4<1;H ?A>24BB 0=3 0??;843 C74 <>385843 4;42CA>34 5>A 34C4A<8=0C8>=>5CA0240<>D=C>5A+DB8=6E>;C0<<4CA82<4C7>3
$"# $!#
.+3/)'27+'-+498
<<>=8D< 7H3A>G834024C820283 2>=24=CA0C437H3A>27;>A82 02834C70=>; ?>C0BB8D< 3827A><0C4 B>38D< 28CA0C4 B>38D< 024C0C4 B>38D< C4CA07H3A>1>A0C4 7H3A>64= C4CA027;>A>0DA0C4 CA87H3A0C4 F4A4 >5 0=0;HC820; 6A0340=3BD??;8431H#4A2:
7+6'7'9/545,)5225/*'2-52*4'456'79/)2+8
)746>;3=0=>?0AC82;4 F0B?A4?0A431HA43D2C8>=>5 DDB8=6$0)>0E>;D<4>5 <">5
<#D;<">53>D1;438BC8;;43F0C4AF0B033430=3BC8AA43DB8=6<06=4C82BC8AA4A5>A<8=DC4B)>C74
<8GCDA4N">5#$0F0B033430=3C74?F0B039DBC43C>)74?A>3D2CF0B270A02C4A8I43
DB8=6*++8BB?42CA>?7>C><4C4A0C=<0=3)#C>270A02C4A8I4B8I40=3B70?4>5C74D$&5>A<43
7+6'97'9/545,-52*4'456'79/)2+835*/,/+*-2'88=)'7(54+2+)975*+
)74BDA5024>56;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>34F0B?>;8B743DB8=6=<;%>=<4B7B0=3?0?4A)74=
8C F0B B>=820C43 8= <4C70=>; 0=3 3>D1;4 38BC8;;43 F0C4A 5>A <8=DC4B BD224BB8E4;H 5>;;>F43 1H 3AH8=6 )74 58ABC<>385820C8>=F0B2>=3D2C431H 8<<4AB8=6C7402C8E0C434;42CA>348=C>D$&2>;;>835>A7>DAB5C4AC74 8<<4AB8>= C74 D$& F0B 270A02C4A8I43 1H B20==8=6 4;42CA>= <82A>B2>?4 (# )74 B42>=3 <>385820C8>=F0B?4A5>A<431H?7>C>274<820;A402C8>=)74A402C8>=F0B8=8C80C431H8<<4AB8=6C74<>385843 8=C>2>=24=CA0C430<<>=8D<7H3A>G834B>;DC8>=5>;;>F431H8AA0380C8>=D=34A*+;867C0C=<5>A 7>DA)78BBC4?8B:=>F=0BB4;50BB4<1;H?A>24BB)74<>3858434;42CA>348BC74=DB430BF>A:8=64;42CA>34
2+)975).+3/)'23+'8:7+3+49 :8/4-*/,,+7+49/'26:28+;529'33+97=
)744;42CA>274<820;<40BDA4<4=CF0B2>=3D2C438=0B8=6;42><?0AC<4=C24;;DB8=6?>C4=C8>BC0C#4CA>7<L
NDC>;019=6++0CA>><C4<?4A0CDA4M=6 6;4;42CA>34F0BDB430BA454A4=244;42CA>34
F78;4?;0C8=D<A>3F0BDB430B0DG8;80AH4;42CA>34A+34C4A<8=0C8>=F0B2>=3D2C438=#7H3A>27;>A82 0283;;?>C4=C80;E0;D4A4?>AC438=C78BBCD3HF4A4 F8C7A4B?42CC>C746 6;B0CA454A4=244;42CA>34+ EB(
#%$# #%##!
'(7/)'9/54'4*).'7')9+7/>'9/545,-52*4'456'79/)2+835*/,/+*-2'88=)'7(54+2+)975*+
D$& F0B BH=C74B8I43 DB8=6 28CA82 8>= 0B 20??8=6 064=C 5C4A A43D2C8>= DB8=6 $0 B>;DC8>= C74 6>;3
B>;DC8>=2>;>DAF0B270=6435A><H4;;>FC>A43AD1Ha<0G =< F78278=3820C4C70CD$&2>;;>83F0B
5>A<43F8C70E4A06438<4=B8>=>5=<70A02C4A8I0C8>=DB8=6)#8=3820C4C70CC740E4A064380<4C4A>5
86 )#8<064>56>;3=0=>?0AC82;4B
F0B <>385843 1H 0CC0278=6 D$& >=C> C74 4;42CA>34 BDA5024 #>385820C8>= >5 F0B 8=8C80C43 1H ?>;8B78=6 C74 4;42CA>34 5>;;>F43 1H 02C8E0C8>= )78B BC4? F0B ?4A5>A<43 B> C70C C74 4;42CA>34 20= 14 2>E4A43 4E4=;H 0=3 <0G8<0;;H 1H C74 D$& F7827 4E4=CD0;;H 20= 8=2A40B4 B4=B8C8E8CH F74= DB43 C> 34C4A<8=4 C74 0=0;HC4&7>C>274<820;A402C8>=8B>=4>5<0=H<4C7>3BC>02C8E0C4C74BDA5024=C74?A4B4=C4G?4A8<4=C C74?7>C>274<820;A402C8>=F0B?4A5>A<431H8<<4AB8=6C744;42CA>348=C>2>=24=CA0C430<<>=8D<7H3A>G834 0=35>;;>F431H8AA0380C8>=D=34A*+;867C5>A7>DAB0C=<)78B?A>24BB8B:=>F=0BB4;50BB4<1;HF7827 20=BD1BC8CDC47H3A>64=6A>D?bF8C70<8=46A>D?b$>5C744;42CA>34D4C>C74 =0CDA4>5C740<8=4
18 Santhy Wyantuti et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 ( 2015 ) 15 – 23
86(#8<064>56>;3=0=>?4AC82;4B<>3858436;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>34BDA5024#>385820C8>=F0B2>=3D2C43 DB8=6003B>A?C8>=0=31B4;50BB4<1;H?A>24BB
662/)'9/545,9.+35*/,/+*-2'88=)'7(54+2+)975*+,577%*+9+73/4'9/54
86+>;C0<<>6A0<>5E0A80C8>=>534?>B8C8>=?>C4=C80;0C01230=34<+ 5>AN6 " A+B>;DC8>=F8C7 34?>B8C8>=C8<4B20=A0C40=30<?;8CD34<>3D;0C8>=0CB<+ B0=3 <+A4B?42C8E4;H
20 Santhy Wyantuti et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 ( 2015 ) 15 – 23
86+>;C0<<>6A0<>5E0A80C8>=>534?>B8C8>=C8<40C0B1 B2B3B0=34B5>A N6 " A+B>;DC8>=F8C734?>B8C8>=?>C4=C80;B20=A0C40=30<?;8CD34<>3D;0C8>=0C<+B<+ B 0=3<+A4B?42C8E4;H
A><C74?A4B4=CBCD3H8CF0B5>D=3C70C>?C8<D<34?>B8C8>=?>C4=C80;0=3 34?>B8C8>=C8<45>A34C4A<8=0C8>= >5 N6 " A+ 8= # 7H3A>27;>A82 0283 0B BD??>AC8=6 4;42CA>;HC4 B>;DC8>= F0B <+ 0=3 B A4B?42C8E4;H )74 >?C8<D< 2>=38C8>= F0B C74= 0??;843 C> 2A40C4 20;81A0C8>= 2DAE4 F8C7 2>=24=CA0C8>= A0=68=6 5A><C> N6 "0=3C742DAA4=C34=B8CHC>?>C4=C80;30C0>5C742>=24=CA0C8>=B8B?A4B4=C438=86 A>< C74 30C0 0 ;8=40A 20;81A0C8>= 2DAE4 A F0B 34E4;>?43 0=3 8B ?A4B4=C43 >= 86 F8C7 2>AA4;0C8>= 2>4558284=C 0=3 ;8=40A A46A4BB8>= 4@D0C8>= >5 0=3 O O A4B?42C8E4;H )7A>D67
22 Santhy Wyantuti et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 ( 2015 ) 15 – 23
86 0;81A0C8>= 2DAE4 >5 E0A8>DB A+ 2>=24=CA0C8>= F8C7 34?>B8C8>= ?>C4=C80; 34?>B8C8>= C8<4 B20= A0C4 0=30<?;8CD34<>3D;0C8>=0C <+B<+ B0=3<+A4B?42C8E4;H
8554A4=C <4C7>3 <0H 70E4 38554A4=C B4=B8C8E8CH 0=3 <4C7>3 C70C 8B <>A4 B4=B8C8E4 2>=B834A43 14CC4A 5>A @D0=C8C0C8E40=0;HB8B<4C7>3B8=248C20=34C42C;>F0<>D=C>50=0;HC4><?0A43C>>C74A?D1;8B743<4C7>3B C74 ?A>?>B43 <4C7>3 8= C78B BCD3H 70B 14CC4A ;8<8C >5 34C42C8>= 0B ?A4B4=C43 8= )01;4 E4= F8C7 0=>C74A E>;C0<<4CAH<4C7>3C74?A4B4=C?A>?>B43<4C7>370B5>DA5>;314CC4A;8<8C>534C42C8>=
)01;4><?0A8B>=>5;8<8C>5 34C42C8>=>5B4E4A0;<4C7>35>AA+34C4A<8=0C8>=
$! " C><8201B>A?C8>=B?42CA><4CAH =6 6 +8A68;8>+9'2
$4DCA>=02C8E0C8>= N6 " ;)074A
867?4A5>A<0=24;8@D8327A><0C>6A0?7H N6 " .8=6+9'2 (@D0A4F0E4E>;C0<<4CAH =6 " "8D+9'2
8554A4=C80;?D;B4E>;C0<<4CAH =6 " )78BBCD3H
! %#!
A><C74?A4B4=CBCD3H8CF0B5>D=3C70CD$&2>;;>83F8C7J=<B8I4F0B5>A<431HA43D28=6<6>5 27;>A>0DA82 0283 D; F8C7 <6 B>38D< 1>A>7H3A0C4 8= N" F0C4A 0B A43D28=6 064=C 8= #
B>38D<28CA0C4)74?4A24=C064>5 6>;3 =0=>?0AC82;4B34?>B8C43>=C> 6;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>341HB4;50BB4<1;H ?A>24BB8B5A><C>C0;BDA5024<0BB>5C746;0BBH20A1>=%,74=C74D$& F0B 0??;843 5>A 34C4A<8=0C8>= >5 A+ 1H 38554A4=C80; ?D;B4 E>;C0<<4CAH C74 ;8<8C >5 34C42C8>= 0=3 ?A428B8>=F0B5>D=3C>14 =6 " 0=3A4B?42C8E4;H
" #
8=942C8>=BHBC4<4'2./3 )9'
><V=6D4I'4=43>%;>=B>"><8;;>#A2>B#0AC8=4I# %?C8<8B0C8>=?A>243DA45>AC748=7818C8E434C4A<8=0C8>=>5 27A><8D<DB8=60=0<?4A><4CA82CHA>B8=0B418>B4=B>A4'2./3 )9'
0\)ZA:4A'"0;4#)D=R4;8(4?0A0C8>=0=3B?4280C8>=>5A0=3A+F8C7B02270A><H24B24A4E8B8048<<>18;8I43>= B4?8>;8C40=334C4A<8=0C8>=>51>C7B?4284B8=F0C4A1H500B#'2'49'
!8A0=!!D<0A!(&A0B03(DE0A370=!"4::0;0' 0=0A370=0<!(?4280C8>=34C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<0=3+DB8=6 ?A42>=24=CA0C8>=2;>D3?>8=C4GCA02C8>=F8C75;0<40C><8201B>A?C8>=B?42CA><4CAH('>'7* '9+7 8A0C0(>=30!(78:8=>%#04:0F0$870A0#4C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<0=3C>C0;27A><8D<8=B40F0C4A1H>=;8=4
2>;D<=?A42>=24=CA0C8>=8=3D2C8E4;H2>D?;43?;0B<0<0BBB?42CA><4CAH"6+)975)./3 )9'
)0=6.D4),D >=6.8=6.,0=6'0?830=3B4=B8C8E4B?42CA>5;D>A8<4CA8234C4A<8=0C8>=>5CA0240<>D=C>5AF8C7 >E0=8;;8=0<8=>@D8=>;8=4#'2'49'
0<<4;600A3"80>.? Y=B%<?A>E4<4=C>=B8<D;C0=4>DB34C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<B?4284B8=0@D4>DBB>;DC8>=1H8>= 27A><0C>6A0?7H0=3274<8;D<8=4B24=2434C42C8>=4'2./3 )9'
!0=4:>#!DA870A0#$0:0=>(!0F0B78<0);>F8=942C8>=34C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<1H8CB20C0;HB8B>=C74>G830C8E4 2>D?;8=6>5<4C7H;14=I>C780I>;8=>=47H3A0I>=4F8C7=4C7H;=7H3A>GHBD;5>?A>?H;<4C7>GH0=8;8=44'2./3 )9'
70CI8C74>3>A>D2>=><>D+>D;60A>?>D;>B)A02434C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<1HB@D0A4F0E403B>A?C8E4BCA8??8=6 E>;C0<<4CAH>=18B<DC758;<4;42CA>34B2+)975'4'2
DBP:>EP">1A>FB:8`AP<:>EP !AX;82:0+HC^0B!0C0;HC8203B>A?C8E4BCA8??8=6E>;C0<<4CAHE4ABDB4;42CA>C74A<0;0C><82 01B>A?C8>=B?42CA><4CAH8=C7434C4A<8=0C8>=>5CA0242>10;C0=327A><8D<8=7D<0=DA8=4#'2'49'
(050E8#0;4:8$(707100I8'=38A42C34C4A<8=0C8>=>574G0E0;4=C27A><8D<8>=8=2><?;4G<0CA824B1H03B>A?C8E4BCA8??8=6 E>;C0<<4CAH0C0<4A2DAH4;42CA>34#'2'49'
><V=6D4I'4=43>%'D8IB?4;C"0A2V0BC>A60=>$A2>B#0ACV=4I# ;42CA>274<820;34C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<+DB8=6 <4C0;;82=0=>?0AC82;4<>38584320A1>=B2A44=?A8=C434;42CA>34B#'2'49'
"8D"D",0=6#/8.BCD3H>5=0=>BCAD2CDA436>;3<>3858436;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>345>AC7434C4A<8=0C8>=>5CA024 A+
.+3 ")/b
8=: !84;H 4C74;;(27855A8= (4;5>A60=8I0C8>=>5=0=>B8I436>;3?0AC82;4B.+3/897=5,'9+7/'28
)80='7'0>)$8=060./78 5>=BCAD2C8>=>5CF>38<4=B8>=0;0AA0HB6>;3=0=>?0AC82;4B<>=>;0H4A>=C>1>A>=3>?43380<>=3 4;42CA>34BDA5024B.+3 '9+7
,H0=CDC8(0AC0C8.,8A30DB#"&0=0C0A0=8)9>:A>=46>A>'01A820C8>=>56>;3=0=>?0AC82;4B<>3858436;0BBH20A1>= 4;42CA>340=38CB 0??;820C8>= 5>AE>;C0<<4CA8234C42C8>=>5A49")/#+).!+8
,H0=CDC8()9>:A>=46>A>'0AC0C8.,&0=0C0A0=8H2;82 E>;C0<<4CAHBCD3H>527A><8D<+0=327A><8D<0C06>;3 =0=>?0AC82;4B<>3858436;0BBH20A1>=4;42CA>34=#.+7*49+74'9/54'2"+3/4'754.+3/897= 0C8=0=6>A4?0AC<4=C>5 74<8BCAH*=8E4AB8C0B&0390390A0=01BCA02C
A4=B>=CA>;;43=D2;40C8>=5>AC74A46D;0C8>=>5C74?0AC82;4B8I48=<>=>38B?4AB46>;3BDB?4=B8>=B'9:7+ .=8 ")/
+8A68;8>$X1A460 'T6> $4C> E0;D0C8>=>5B>;83B0<?;8=67867A4B>;DC8>=2>=C8=DD<B>DA246A0?78C45DA=0240C><82 01B>A?C8>=B?42CA><4CAH5>A38A42C34C4A<8=0C8>=>527A><8D<8=<43828=0;?;0=CB"6+)975)./3 )9'
;)074A4C4A<8=0C8>=>5 27A><8D<0=3CA0244;4<4=CB8=;'D1B7827A><8C45A><40BC4A=34B4AC6H?C1H=4DCA>=02C8E0C8>=
0=0;HB8B662!'*/'9859