i
WEB-BASED READING EXERCISES USING HOT-POTATOES
FOR SEVENTH GRADE STUDENTS
OF SMP PANGUDI LUHUR 1 YOGYAKARTA
A SARJANA PENDIDIKAN THESIS
Presented as Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements to Obtain the Sarjana Pendidikan Degree
in English Language Education
By
Fenty Yunia Vianarika Student Number: 101214058
ENGLISH LANGUAGE EDUCATION STUDY PROGRAM DEPARTMENT OF LANGUAGE AND ARTS EDUCATION FACULTY OF TEACHERS TRAINING AND EDUCATION
SANATA DHARMA UNIVERSITY YOGYAKARTA
iv
DEDICATION PAGE
vii ABSTRACT
Vianarika, Fenty Yunia. (2014). Web-based Reading Exercises Using Hot-Potatoes for Seventh Grade Students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta . Yogyakarta: English Language Education Study Program, Sanata Dharma University.
Globalisation era has required teachers to keep up with technology development, especially in teaching-learning process. The newly-introduced curriculum, i.e. curriculum 2013, also requires teachers to make the use of information technology (IT) in teaching and learning process. Through the use of online learning media, teachers could design such interesting materials which can be accessed by students. Again, through the use of Hot-Potatoes program, teachers can design short, simple and interesting materials for students. This program provides an alternative enjoyable learning. This research deals with material design using Hot-Potatoes which is formulated to answer two research problems, e.g. (1) How is the Web-based reading exercises using Hot Potatoes for the seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta designed? and (2) What does the design look like?
This research used R&D, stands for research and development as the research methodology. The steps on R&D were (1) needs analysis, (2) design material, (3) development material, and (4) evaluation the design result. This research held with data interview and questionnaire for the need analysis and design evaluation. Two English teachers involved in the interview and 127 students responded to the questionnaire. The evaluation of the design involved two lecturers of the English Language Education Study Program of Sanata Dharma University and two English teachers of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta.
The result of the preliminary field-testing, i.e. interview and questionnaire indicated that students need interesting reading exercises through online learning media as shown in the result of questionnaire that almost all students chose the agree parts (agree-strongly agree). Thus, the researcher designed a set of Web-based reading exercises within the use of Hot-Potatoes program. Then, the result of evaluation got positive result, because the evaluators chose the agree parts (agree-strongly agree). Indeed, the design could fulfill students‟ needs and the evaluators agreed if the design is used as additional exercise. Then, this design needed to add some exercises and students‟ reflections in 4 units as the evaluators suggested. The design result can be accessed at www.englishreadex.pbworks.com. Since the reading exercises are in accordance with todays curriculum to
fulfill students‟ needs, hopefully, students are able to improve their reading skill. Therefore, the design in this research will help students in learning language. Keywords: instructional design, reading, Web-based and weblog, and Hot-Potatoes.
viii ABSTRAK
Vianarika, Fenty Yunia. (2014). Web-based Reading Exercises Using Hot-Potatoes for Seventh Grade Students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. Yogyakarta: Program Studi Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris, Universitas Sanata Dharma.
Di era globalisasi seperti saat ini, guru-guru hendaknya juga mengikuti perkembangan teknologi terkhususnya ketika proses kegiata n belajar mengajar berlangsung. Kurikulum yang baru saja diperkenalkan, yang dikenal dengan nama kurikulum 2013, menawarkan kepada guru untuk menggunakan teknologi komputer dalam kegiatan belajar dan mengajar mereka. Melalui penggunaan media pembelajaran secara online, guru dapat membuat berbagai macam materi yang menarik dan dapat diakses oleh siswa. Dengan menggunakan program Hot-Potatoes, guru dapat belajar bagaimana cara membuat materi yang singkat dan menarik bagi siswa untuk menjawab 2 rumusan masalah: (1) Bagaimana ca ra membuat soal latihan bahasa Inggris untuk kegiatan membaca dengan menggunakan Hot-Potatoes untuk siswa kelas tujuh di SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta? dan (2) Bagaimanakah wujud tampilan dari desain tersebut?
Untuk menjawab rumusan masalah yang pertama, penelitian ini menggunakan metode research and development (R&D) untuk membuat desain materi yang disesuaikan dengan kebutuhan siswa. Langkah-langkahnya adalah: (1) analisis kebutuhan, (2) mendesain materi, (3) mengembangkan materi, dan (4) evaluasi hasil desain. Penelitian ini dilakukan melalui survey dengan wawancara dan kuesioner untuk analisis kebutuhan dan evaluasi desain. 2 guru bahasa Inggris di SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta menjadi narasumber wawancara dan 127 siswa dari SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta berpartisipasi untuk mengisi lembar kuesioner. Tahap evaluasi dilakukan oleh 2 dosen Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris dari Universitas Sanata Dharma dan 2 guru bahasa Inggris dari SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta.
Hasil penelitian ini menunjukkan bahwa siswa cenderung lebih tertarik untuk belajar bahasa Inggris dengan menggunakan media online seperti hasil yang diperoleh dari data kuesioner bahwa hampir semua siswa menyatakan setuju (setuju-sangat setuju). Hasil dari tahap evaluasi memperoleh hasil yang positif, bahwa semua pengevaluasi menyatakan setuju (setuju-sangat setuju). Dan itu artinya bahwa hasil desain sudah menjawab kebutuhan siswa. Grup evaluasi juga menyetujui jika hasil desain tersebut digunakan sebagai materi pelengkap. Selain itu, hasil desain perlu ditambahkan beberapa latihan dan refleksi siswa di setiap unitnya. Hasil dari desain materi dalam penelitian ini dapat diakses di www.englishreadex.pbworks.com.
Melalui kegiatan dan latihan soal membaca ini, siswa mampu meningkatkan kemampuan membaca. Tetunya, soal latihan membaca sudah disesuaikan dengan kurikulum yang dipakai saat ini untuk menjawab kebutuhan siswa dan membantu siswa dalam mempelajari bahasa Inggris.
ix
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Firstly, I would like to thank Jesus Christ for His amazing blessings in doing this thesis till the end. I know that I am nothing without Him and I could not finish my study to achieve Bachelor degree without His super blessings.
Secondly, I also give my deepest gratitude for my thesis advisor who guided me during the process on my thesis, Veronica Triprihatmini, S.Pd., M.Hum., M.A., for her precious time during the thesis consultation and in reading my thesis. My sincere thanks also go to the evaluators‟ group from the English Language Education Study Program lecturers who helped me to evaluate the reading exercises design in this research, they are Barli Bram, M.Ed., Ph.D., and Concilianus Laos Mbato, M.A., Ed.D. And also, the interviewees and evaluators‟ group from English teachers of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta, Andrea Ismargyaning Utami, S.Pd., and Yohanes Bondan Rachmat Subagya, S.Pd. Then, I give my deepest gratitude to my seventh grade students from 7 B, E, and G of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. My sincere thanks also go to Barli Bram, M.Ed., Ph.D., and Antonius Siwi Darmajati, S.J., for their time in reading and correcting my grammar.
x
Fourthly, I give my deepest gratitude to SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta members, especially for the former headmaster of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1, Antang Hartoko, S.Pd., and the secretary staff, who allowed me to do research in SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta.
Fifthly, I give my special and deepest gratitude to my family members. They are Mak Ipo, Mak, Kohde, Kucang, Kolek, Om Ive, Abi, and especially to my beloved father, Novian Karyanto for his advice, guidance and amazing discussion between father and daughter.
Sixthly, I would like to give my big hug and thanks to my ministry teams at GBI Keluarga Allah Yogyakarta, they are d’Victory and Blitz cell groups and also ESBC’s crew (Elite Soldier Boot Camp) for their kindness, support and pray so that I could do my best in doing my thesis. The last, I would like to give my big hug to my dearest friends from the English Language Education Study Program batch 2010, they are Sani, Gaby, Yuli, Maki (Lina), Dessi, Cha-cha, Gaplek (Ega), Pandhu, “GOWN” PBI Play Performance, the 2nd Undergraduate Conference Commitee 2014, my PPL friends (Program Pengalaman Lapangan) at SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta 2013, my KKN group (Kuliah Kerja Nyata) at Karangpakis 1.
Finally, I give applause to myself because I could do my best in doing this thesis. I also appreciate all people who helped me in writing this thesis.
xi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TITLE PAGE ... i
APPROVAL PAGE ... ii
DEDICATION PAGE ... iii
STATEMENT ON WORK‟S ORIGINALITY ... iv
LEMBAR PERNYATAAN PERSETUJUAN... v
ABSTRACT ... vi
ABSTRAK ... vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ... ix
TABLE OF CONTENTS ... xi
LIST OF TABLES ... xiii
LIST OF APPENDICES ... xiv
LIST OF PICTURES ... xv
CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION 1
A. Research Background ... 1
B. Research Problem ... 3
C. Problem Limitation ... 3
D. Research Objectives ... 3
E. Research Benefits ... 4
xii
CHAPTER II. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE 9
A. Theoretical Description ... 9
B. Review of Related Study ... 20
C. Theoretical Framework ... 21
CHAPTER III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 23 A. Research Method ... 23
B. Research Setting ... 32
C. Research Participants ... 32
D. Instruments and Data Gathering Technique ... 34
E. Data Analysis Technique ... 36
F. Research Procedures ... 38
CHAPTER IV. RESEARCH RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 39
A. The Result and Discussion in Designing Reading Exercises 39 1. The Result and Discussion of Interview ... 39
2. The Result and Discussion of Questionnaire ... 42
3. The Result and Discussion of Evaluation ... 46
B. The Final Presentation of Reading Exercises Design ... 53
1. The Presentation of Unit 1 as Design Revision ... 53
2. The Presentation of Unit 2 as Design Revision ... 54
3. The Presentation of Unit 3 as Design Revision ... 56
4. The Presentation of Unit 4 as Design Revision ... 57
CHAPTER V. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION 59
A. Conclusions ... 59
B. Recommendation ... 60
REFERENCES 62
xiii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. Main Competence English Language Grade VII ……… 12
Table 2. Lesson Plan Unit 1 ... 26
Table 3. Lesson Plan Unit 2 ... 26
Table 4. Lesson Plan Unit 3 ... 27
Table 5. Lesson Plan Unit 4 ... 28
Table 6. Questionnaire ... 35
Table 7. The Meaning of Agreement Points ... 35
Table 8. The Meaning of Agreement Points ... 36
Table 9. The Arrangement of Data Questionnaire ………... 37
Table 10. The Arrangement of Data Questionnaire ………... 37
Table 11. The Result of Questionnaire ……….... 43
Table 12. The Description of Evaluators ………... 46
Table 13. A Statistic Description of Evaluators‟ Feedback Using Evaluation ………... 48
Table 14. A Statistic Description of Evaluators‟ Feedback Using Evaluation ………... 49
Table 15. Lesson Plan as Final Product Revision Unit 1 ... 53
Table 16. Lesson Plan as Final Product Revision Unit 2 ... 54
Table 17. Lesson Plan as Final Product Revision Unit 3 ... 56
xiv
LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix A. Research Permission Letter from Sanata Dharma ... 65
Appendix B. Interview ... 68
Appendix B. Questionnaire ... 69
Appendix B. Evaluation ... 71
Appendix C. Raw Data Interviews ... 75
Appendix C. Raw Data Questionnaire ... 78
Appendix C. Raw Data Evaluation ... 79
Appendix D. Main Competence and Basic Competence ... 82
Appendix E. Course Outline (Syllabus) SMP/MTs ... 88
Appendix F. A Compilation of Teacher Guideline ... 93
xv
LIST OF PICTURES
Picture 1 ……….. 29
Picture 2 ……….. 29
Picture 3 ……….. 30
1 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
In this part of the study, the researcher wants to present the introduction of this research. There are six sections included in this chapter. They are research background, research problem, problem limitation, research objectives, research benefits and definition of terms.
A. Research Background
2
2008, Huot, Lemonnier & Hamers introduces, “L2 teaching and learning have seen an increasing interest in the use of computers, the Internet, multimedia resources, and what is now called ICT” (p. 84). ICT stands for information and communication technology which is now integrated in language learning, because technology has essential role in language learning.
Since English becomes one of the most essential subjects in Indonesia for junior high school, the teaching of language which integrates information technology (IT) has spread over the countries for almost four language skills, e.g., reading, writing, listening and speaking. Due to the fact that reading is one of the four skills which the students need to develop, it offers an opportunity to create and design reading materials by using technology. Therefore, this research intends to design materials for reading skill which integrates with the use of technology.
SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta facilitates and supports students‟
3 B. Research Problem
The researcher is going to solve two questions through this research. The questions are as follows:
1. How are the Web-based reading exercises using Hot-Potatoes for the seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta designed? 2. What does the design look like?
C. Problem Limitation
In conducting this research, the researcher determines with five limitations; first, the researcher specifies this research in reading skill. Second, the researcher designs the reading exercises within the use of curriculum 2013 as the newly curriculum. Third, the researcher focuses on seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. Fourth, the researcher uses Hot-Potatoes program which has six basic programs. However, the researcher only uses three out of those basic programs in designing the reading exercises. They are JMatch, JCross, and JQuiz. The last, the researcher uses weblog to help the researcher in uploading the reading exercises and the weblog usage is Pbworks.
D. Research Objectives
The researcher formulates two objectives in conducting this research. The objectives are as follows:
4
2. To present the design of Web-based reading exercises using Hot-Potatoes for seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta.
E. Research Benefits
There are some benefits that can be obtained from this research. Since this research is conducted in the educational area and for those who are interested in the use of technology for language learning, the researcher expects that this research can give motivation and contribution to English language teaching, especially for:
1. Seventh Grade Students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta
This research is about the integration on the use of technology and designing students‟ reading exercise for students in language learning. Students are supposed to be more interesting in learning language and have improvement in reading skill. By integrating the use of technology in students‟ exercise, therefore, students can maximize and optimize the school‟s facilities. Besides that, students will interest in learning English and get better result.
2. English Teachers and Reading Leturers
In maximizing and optimizing school‟s facilities, this research provides
teacher‟s guideline in designing the reading exercises using Hot-Potatoes
5
fatigue in giving scores. The program calculates the scores directly and automatically. Therefore, both teacher/lecturer and student may get positive impact in the use of Hot-Potatoes program in learning session.
3. Future Researchers
Through this research, hopefully, can give motivation and contribution for future researchers. Again, they may design another exercise with sophisticated and others program. The future researchers can learn from this research if they conduct a similar research topic. As we know that technology always changing, therefore, the future researchers need to follow the technology development.
F. Definition of Terms
The researcher would like to discuss the definition of terms which are used in this research obviously as in the keywords from the research is related to the
researcher‟s topic. The keywords are instructional design, reading, Web-based and weblog, and Hot-Potatoes version 6.
1. Instructional Design (ID)
According to Morrison, Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011), instructional design (ID) is a process designing materials which is started through identifying
the problems, designing the materials and considering the instruction for students‟
needs. Again, they state that there are six factors of instructional design have an outcome in learning process. They are students need to completing the objectives based on willingness level, have different characteristics so that the instructional
6
choose the appropriate technology or resources, the materials must have certain indicators which can support students in their learning process, the materials design can measure students‟ accomplishment, and materials designer must revise the design if the trial program cannot match with the expectations (p. 6). As a result of designing instructional media, Kemp & Smellie (1989) note that the use
of media in instructional design are assigned by “learners, objectives, content, and
instructional method.” They also add that, “media are not supplementary to or in support of instruction, but the instructional input itself” (p. 7). Therefore, this research integrates the use of technology in designing the students‟ exercises through Hot-Potatoes program.
2. Reading
7
research takes academic reading as the genre of reading related with the school context.
3. Web-Based and Weblog
Lewis (2004) defines internet as World Wide Web (WWW) which consists of text, video, pictures, and sound (p. 19). Another definition as in Teeler & Gray (2000) about World Wide Web is “a multimedia resource and
communications tool based on hypertext, a system of clickable links” (p. 5). Based on those two definitions, Web-based is a basic media to present reading exercises design in forms of weblogs or blogs. The weblog can be accessed by using Internet connection.
Lewis (2004) states the function of weblogs or blogs are to post and publish material or exercise on the Web by using text program (p. 19). Then the exercise consists of pictures, videos, audio files, and links related to the given topics. In this research, the weblog refers to the blog which provides students‟ reading exercises for seventh grade students at SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. 4. Hot-Potatoes Version 6
8
(http://hotpot.uvic.ca/). The data includes questions, answers, and feedbacks or responses.
9 CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
In this chapter, the researcher will discuss the theories related to this research and it consists of two parts. They are theoretical description and theoretical framework.
A. Theoretical Description
Theoretical description discusses about theories which are used in this research. They are the description of research and development (R & D), reading, types of reading, assessing reading, designing reading exercises and assessment tasks, weblog, Hot-Potatoes program and teaching adolescence which are going to be discussed in this research.
1. Research and Development (R & D)
According to Kemp (1989), research and development or instructional-design plan supplies to answer three questions. They are: “What must be learned? What procedures and resources will work best to reach the desired learning
levels? How will we know when the required learning has taken place?” The first
10
Morrison, Ross, Kalman, and Kemp (2011). The first research and development by Kemp (1989) have eight components. They are considering and stating the general goals for teaching, arranging the learner characteristics, broadening the learning objectives, classifying the subject content, advancing pre-assessments to
decide students‟ characteristics, adopting teaching and learning activities,
administering support service includes budget, personnel, facilities, and evaluating
students‟ learning process to make design revision. Then, the second research and development by Morrison, Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011) have ten components. They are instructional problems, learner and context, task analysis, instructional objectives, content sequencing, instructional strategies, designing the messages, developing of the instruction, evaluating the instruments, and ongoing process. This research adapts four components out of those two theories of research and development. The description of the four components are as follows:
a. Need Analysing
The first component of research and development are to analyse the problems and to identify students‟ needs in their reading performance. The researcher begins this research from analyzing and identifying the students‟ needs. As preliminary field-testing, two instruments are used to analyse and identify the
11
know the students‟ view point. Because the purpose is to discover what
acquaintance to assist students‟ reading performance, therefore, this part becomes the most important thing.
b. Designing the Lesson Plan
The researcher starts with arranging the content based on the data instruments. As Morrison, Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011) state “a well-designed instructional strategy prompts or motivates the learner to actively make these connections between what the learner already knows and the new information” (pp. 150-151). The researcher adapts Web-based instruction as the instructional strategy in this research. As Morrison et.al (2011) state about the term Web-based instruction will be assimilated into computer-based instruction (CBI). They also find that there are three major characteristics of students within the use of computer-based instruction. They are student will work as individual learner, CBI is self-paced instruction for students because they have to click the button in doing the reading exercises individually, and CBI may modify each student through the responses and feedbacks that the student will receive. The definition of self-paced is an individual learning method which calls as “individualized learning or
12
The four main competencies of curriculum 2013 as in Table 1 below. Table 1. Main Competence English Language Grade VII
Main Competence
1. Respecting and comprehending the teaching of the students‟ religions and beliefs.
2. Respecting and comprehending good attitudes, e.g. honesty, discipline,
responsibility, care (tolerant and cooperation), politeness, confidentiality, through an effective interaction with others in society and nature.
3. Understanding the knowledge (factual, conceptual, and procedural) based on curiosity about science, technology, art, culture related with phenomena and reality.
4. Trying, exploring, and presenting in a concrete way (using, explaining, arranging, modifying, and creating) and in an abstract way (writing, reading, counting, drawing, and arranging story) appropriate with what is to be learned in school and another related source which has similar point of view/theory.
c. Developing the Students’ Reading Exercises
After designing the syllabus, the researcher develops the syllabus into
students‟ reading exercises. The researcher focuses on students reading comprehension and additional knowledge from the given reading texts. Certainty, the researcher also designs the exercises by arranging the exercises from simple-to-complex. According to Morrison, Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011), the basic principle of simple-to-complex materials usage is to make the students more relax with the simple exercise in the first unit. Then, in the next units the students may encounter the difficult one where they have already experienced in the previous unit (p. 218). Again, the researcher develops the syllabus into four units exercises. The design can be accessed at www.englishreadex.pbworks.com.
d. Evaluating the Students’ Reading Exercises
13
purpose of evaluation is “to make judgments about the worth or success of people or things (e.g., lessons, programs, projects) and to determine student success in learning” (p. 272). Again, Morrison Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2001) inform that there are three types of evaluation. They are formative, summative and confirmative evaluations. In evaluating the design, this research adapts formative evaluation, because it informs the instructor or planning team how well the instructional program is serving the objectives as it progresses (p. 272). Where according to Morrison Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011), summative and confirmative description are:
... designed to examine the effectiveness of completed versions of
instruction. Summative comes after the instruction is first used, but before sustained implementation, whereas confirmative is used after
implementation has occured and the design has been used for a reasonable time (usually at least six months to a year) (p. 278).
According to Morrison, Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011), formative evaluation is a process of evaluating and developing the design through identifying the problems. The researcher needs to organize the evaluation strategies and instructional drafts. In gathering data revision, the researcher uses data information from the drafts. In this step, the researcher also designs list of questions/statements for the evaluation as the instrument.
14 2. Reading
According to Mitchell (1982), the definition of reading is to understand a text as reader‟s capability. He also adds that a successful reader has ability to comprehend a text and can integrate the purpose in each sentence (p. 1). Additionally, Wallace (1992) states that reading is a knowledge on how to use the language itself, such as reading for purpose and reading for understanding the context (p. 3). Again, Wallace (1992) also adds that there are three reading purposes; they are reading for survival, learning and pleasure. Reading for survival means to give reaction in society. Reading for learning means to learn and get knowledge from reading text. And the last, reading for pleasure produces fluency such as speed reading and simplify reading (p. 4). Therefore, this research refers to the reading for purpose by providing reading for learning so that the students may learn from the given text and have a life value.
3. Types of Reading
According to Brown (2004), there are four types of reading perfomance; they are perceptive, selective, interactive and extensive reading. The purpose of perceptive reading is to broaden the reading categories in a set of listening comprehension. The purpose of selective reading is to discover one‟s reading recognition of lexical, and grammatical. The purpose of interactive reading is to negotiate the meaning of a text. And the last, the purpose of extensive reading provides with a longer text than usual. The aim of giving longer text is to practice
15
The researcher also integrates both selective reading and interactive reading as the types of reading text. Firstly, the researcher chooses selective reading to ensure students‟ reading acknowledgement includes lexical, grammar, and short reading text. Secondly, the researcher selects interactive reading to interact a reading text by finding the meaning. The texts can be narrative, descriptive, procedure, recount, expository, announcement, memo, news report and suchlike. Therefore, this research refers to the combination of both selective reading and interactive reading as the types of reading.
4. Assessing Reading a. Reliability
Brown (2004) states a reliable test should be consistent and dependable with the issue by considering some factors. The researcher takes reliability in designing the reading exercises with up-to-date topics/issues. Therefore, this research refers to the reliability by providing topic in each unit and the reading exercises are designed using multiple choices, matching tasks, and crossword puzzles (p. 20).
b. Validity
Gronlund (1998) defines validity as “the extent to which inferences made from assessment results are appropriate, meaningful, and useful in terms of the
criterion-16
related evidence, construct-related evidence, consequential validity, and face validity (para. 22). Otherwise, the researcher implements face validity in this research. Additionaly, Brown (2004) concludes in a statement about face validity:
Face validity is not something that can be empirically tested by a teacher or even by a testing expert. It is purely a factor of the “eye of the beholder”
– how the test-taker, or possibly the test giver, intuitively perceives the instrument (p. 27).
Face validity informs that the students may encounter with a well-constructed exercise which the students will familiar with the given topic. Brown (2004) also concludes that a design material can be said as valid if the design is in accordance with real-world context. A valid design material includes students‟ daily learning and activities (p. 27). Therefore, this research refers to the validity by having time allotment in each unit to prevent students‟ boredom in the given topic, the language usage is not ambiguous, and each unit has own difficulties level from simple-to-complex.
c. Authenticity
17
providing natural and simple language in each reading text and item so that the students can get the meaning in doing the exercises.
5. Designing Reading Exercises and Assessment Tasks
According to Howard and Major (2009), designing an effective exercise for language learner is a particular challenge for teacher. Some teachers may consider the advantages and disadvantages of designing materials. The advantages that the teacher will receive are “contextualisation” materials, be able to meet the
students‟ needs, “personalisation” and “timeliness” with up-to-date topics. However, teacher may also encounter the disadvantages of designing students‟ materials based on the “organisation, quality and time constraint.” Further, teacher should consider some factors when designing students‟ materials. The factors are target learners/students, curriculum usage, sources and supporting facilities,
teacher‟s confidence and competence, copyright compliance, and time constraint (pp. 101-104). In this research, the design instructions by Howard and Major (2009) should be contextualised from both the curriculum usage and students‟
needs, attracted, activated students‟ critical thinking from reading passage given, proposed to integrate using language, authentic, suitable instructions and flexible by concerning the content. Therefore, this research refers to the design of reading exercises and the assessment as seen in the description below.
a. Multiple Choice Task
Farrell (2009) defines multiple choice task as a test type which only has
one correct answer and other answer‟s options are incorrect. Multiple choice has
18
major disadvantage of multiple choice usage is that the students could encourage guessing (p. 92).
Therefore, this research refers to the use of multiple choice task. The purpose is to gain vocabulary building and reading comprehension. The task is designed into vocabulary and picture-cued as selective reading, and comprehension questions as interactive reading.
b. Matching Task
The research applies the use of matching task is to gain vocabulary building and reading comprehension for both selective and interactive reading. Those tasks are suitable for seventh grade students within the use of curriculum 2013. Therefore, the task has more varied exercise to increase students‟ interest in doing the task.
c. Crossword Puzzle
The purpose of crossword puzzle usage in this research is to acquire
students‟ vocabulary towards the given reading text. Those tasks are suitable for seventh grade students within the use of curriculum 2013. Therefore, the task does not lack of varieties.
6. Weblog or ‘Blogs’
The description of blog, a short for weblog, according to Newby, Stepich, Lehman, Russell, & Ottenbreit-Leftwich (2011):
A website in which entries on a topic are usually posted in reverse chronological order. Blogs are commonly used as a kind of Web-based personal journal in which the author provides commentary on topics such as news and current events, politics, a hobby or topic of interest, or just the
19
In this research, the researcher uses blog to distribute students‟ material with the help of Hot-Potatoes program. Another purpose is to share the lesson plan so that the students know the indicators in learning the material.
7. Hot-Potatoes Program
As cited from http://hotpot.uvic.ca/, “Hot Potatoes program is to enable teacher in creating interactive Web-based teaching exercises which can be delivered to any Internet-connected computer equipped with a browser.” It needs Windows version programs such as Windows 98, ME, NT4, 2000, XP, Vista or 7 to operate Hot-Potatoes program. Then, it also needs a modern Web browser such as Mozilla Firefox, Opera, and Internet Explorer. There are five basic programs and an additional program in Hot Potatoes version 6. The description of those six programs are as follows:
a. JQuiz program creates question-based quiz, such as multiple choice and short-answer. Multiple choices provide specific feedback for both answers correct or wrong. While in short-answer questions, students must guess what the correct answer is. Then, students may ask by choosing the hint box to find the correct answer.
b. JCloze program creates gap-fill exercises.
c. JCross program creates crossword puzzles. The program works when the students choose the crossword‟s number.
d. JMix program creates jumbled-sentence exercises.
20
Therefore, this research refers to the Hot-Potatoes version 6 by using three out of those six programs. They are JQuiz, JCross, and JMatch as in accordance with the types of selective and interactive reading items.
8. Teaching Adolescence
Entwistle (1981) defines adolescence as students who need teacher to teach their progress by increasing their abstract ideas and knowledge at school. Indeed, teaching adolescence needs exploration and reinforcement completely so that the teacher can help students to be able in presenting their new ideas related to their previous knowledge (pp. 257-258). Another viewpoint of teaching adolescence is according to Hamacheck (1975), many adolescence students love to work in a group so that the teacher must divide the student into several groups. The groups based on gender (same or opposite sex) and lottery (p. 117).
In this research, teacher helps the students in presenting their ideas toward the text provided by answering the reading item. Then, students will receive
feedback as students‟ reinforcement so that the students will interest in doing more exercises. Therefore, teaching adolescence needs to integrate something new for them. For example, the use of technology and the given materials are correlated with academic subject matter.
B. Review of Related Study
There is a related study in this research which the title is “Designing a Set of Web Based English Reading Test Using Quizstar for X Grade Students of SMA
21
topic with this research. First, that research applied research and development (R&D) as the research methodology. It also had a target skill in reading through designing a test. The target participant was the ninth grade students of SMA N 11 Yogyakarta, and the curriculum usage in that research was Kurikulum Tingkat Satuan Pendidikan (KTSP). Then, this research applied Quizstar program as the tool in designing the reading test for the students.
Furthermore, that research was similar in the use of weblog as online learning media with different program as in this research. Indeed, this research applies Hot-Potatoes as the tool program which can be uploaded in a weblog. Again, research and development (R & D) also applies as research methodology in this research. The target participant is seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta who implements the use of curriculum 2013.
C. Theoretical Framework for Seventh Graders of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta
This theoretical framework discusses about the stages of Web-based reading exercises for the seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta using Hot Potatoes according to an instructional-design theory. As a part of synthesizing and summarizing, the theoretical framework applies all theories in theoretical description. The theoretical framework is to answer the research problems and to explain the steps in research design.
22
there are four major characteristics of instructional-design theories. They are
23 CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
In this chapter, it discusses the methodology usage in conducting research and answering the two research problems. The research methodology consists of six parts; they are research method, research setting, research participants, instruments and data gathering technique, data analysis technique and research procedure.
A. Research Method
This research applied research and development to obtain and solve the answer in the research questions related to the Web-based reading exercises using Hot-Potatoes for seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. This research combined two approaches of instructional design or research and development according to Kemp (1989) and Morrison, Ross, Kalman, & Kemp (2011). Based on the research‟s needs, the researcher started this research with analysing the needs, designing the lesson plan, developing the lesson plan into exercises, and evaluating the design. The description of research and development in this research as follows:
1. Analysing the Needs
24 a. Interview
According to Ary, Jacobs, & Sorensen (2010), interview is a way to get data which cannot be obtained through observation. Basically, interview is
someone‟s opinion, feeling, belief about something or situation (p. 438). In addition, the researcher adapted focus group as category of interview, i.e. teachers group. The given questions conducted in open-ended questions using Indonesian language. Further, the researcher also implemented qualitative structured interview as the type of interview. Ary, Jacobs, & Sorensen (2010) define qualitative structured interview as scheduled questions which cannot be responsed using yes or no and its function to get certain information related to the research, i.e., find the needs‟ analysis (p. 438).
In analysing the needs, the researcher interviewed two English teachers at SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta who handled the seventh grade students. Because of the researcher only focused on the English teacher and not other teachers, the researcher applied focus group interview as the type of interview. Therefore, this research provided eight open-ended questions covering the needs‟ analysis. The list of questions can be seen in appendix B.
b. Questionnaire
The researcher conducted the questionnaire in a form of close-ended questions within the use of Indonesian language. Best (1970) defines the term of questionnaire as:
Administered personally to groups of individuals have a number of
25
Since the seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta answered the questionnaires, the given questions use Indonesian language. Thus, the students did not have any difficulties in answering the questionnaires. Therefore, the questionnaire had ten close-ended questions covering the needs‟ analysis in this research. Likert scale implemented in the questionnaire to find the meaning of agreement points. The list of questions can be seen in appendix B. 2. Designing the Lesson Plans
After the needs‟ analysis finished, the researcher needed to design the lesson plans. It should be in accordance with the newly curriculum, i.e., curriculum 2013. The newly curriculum had four main competencies and the researcher created the lesson plans into four unit exercises. Certainty, the lesson plans depended on students‟ needs as in the result of interview and questionnaire. The design of lesson plans from unit 1 up to unit 4 presented as follows:
a. Lesson Plan of Unit 1
26
Table 2. Lesson Plan Unit 1 UNIT 2
TOPIC TIME ALLOCATION INDICATORS
Descriptive text: Body
Parts 1x45‟
1) Students are able to identify the meaning of
body parts‟ vocabulary
by filling the crossword puzzles
2) Students are able to recognize the vocabulary of body parts through reading comprehension 3) Students are able to
answer the reading items based on the descriptive text 4) Students can mention
the names of body parts by answering the items
b. Lesson Plan of Unit 2
Second, the researcher designed and integrated the lesson plan in unit 2 with Geography subject, e.g. water cycle as the topic. The given text was in forms of descriptive. It also applied to describe the process of water cycle. Therefore, the design of lesson plan in unit 2 can be seen in the Table 3 below.
Table 3. Lesson Plan Unit 2 UNIT 2
TOPIC TIME ALLOCATION INDICATORS
Descriptive text: Water
Cycle 1x45‟
1) Students are able to answer the items based on the descriptive text of water cycle in forms of song
2) Students are able to answer the items based on water cycle video 3) Students are able to
27 c. Lesson Plan of Unit 3
Third, the researcher designed the lesson plan in unit 3 with integrating the
English materials with students‟ daily activity, i.e. evacuation plan as the topic.
Again, the researcher applied procedure text in this unit as the given reading text. The procedure text functioned to give the steps of evacuation plan. Therefore, the design of lesson plan in unit 3 can be seen in the Table 4 below.
Table 4. Lesson Plan Unit 3 UNIT 3
TOPIC TIME ALLOCATION INDICATORS
Procedure text:
Evacuation Plan 1x45‟
1) Students are able to identify the vocabulary usage in giving
directions signs by filling the crossword puzzles
2) Students are able to answer the items based
28
Table 5. Lesson Plan Unit 4 UNIT 4
TOPIC TIME ALLOCATION INDICATORS
Descriptive and News
Report Text: Photography 2x45‟
1) Students are able to identify the meaning of vocabulary usage in the descriptive text
2) Students are able to answer the items based
4) Students can give their opinions toward the news report text
Regarding the research‟s needs, the researcher designed the lesson plan
into four unit exercises without any implementation in a class session. Therefore, the design of lesson plans were in accordance with the four main competencies in curriculum 2013,.
3. Developing the Lesson Plans into Reading Exercises Design
The researcher developed the lesson plans into reading exercises design which have four unit exercises. After designing the reading exercises, the researcher created the exercises by using Hot-Potatoes program. Firstly, the researcher needed to install the Hot-Potatoes Setup. After the installation finished, the researcher put a checkmark (√) in the bullet of “Launch Hot Potatoes” and
29
Picture 1. Hot-Potatoes version 6
For instance, the researcher chose JQuiz to create multiple-choice task. There will appear a dialogue box of JQuiz as in Picture 2.
Picture 2. JQuiz
30
feedback in the box provided. Indeed, the researcher chose one correct answer and saved the quiz.
Then, the researcher selected JMatch to create matching task. There will appear a dialogue box of JQuiz as in Picture 3.
Picture 3. JMatch
The researcher wrote down the items in the left side or “Left (ordered) items” and
also write down the answers in the right side or “Right (jumbled) items.” Indeed, students selected the correct answer by moving it from the right to the left. The researcher, therefore, saved the quiz.
31
Picture 4. JCross
The researcher wrote down the answers in “Words” and the questions in “Clues.”
Then, the researcher needed to choose “Across” or “Down” as the format of
crossword puzzles. Therefore, the researcher must save the quiz.
After all the quizes finished, the researcher uploaded the file in Pbworks. In uploading the file, the researcher needed to save the file by using jquiz, jcross, or jmatch formats and then, saved the file by choosing “Create web page” and
32 4. Evaluating the Design
In evaluating the design, the researcher distributed questionnaires as formative evaluation. The researcher evaluated the design with the help from
evaluators‟ group. They were two English teachers of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta and two English lecturers of English Language Education Study Program of Sanata Dharma University. The evaluation had fifteen close-ended questions and five open-ended questions covering the evaluation stages. The list of questions can be seen in appendix B.
B. Research Setting
First, the researcher started this research by gathering data interview in SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta at Jalan Timoho II No. 29. The researcher conducted the interview on April 2014. Second, the distribution of questionnaires for students‟ group held on April-May 2014 in SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. And the last, the distribution of evaluation questionnaires for evaluators‟ group conducted at different places and different time periods. In June 2014, the first evaluation conducted at school and in July 2014, the second evaluation conducted at Sanata Dharma University.
C. Research Participants
33 1. Teacher Group
The first group called teachers‟ group. Two English teachers participated in this interview as interviewees. Both two English teachers taught in SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta for seventh grade students. The researcher interviewed them with eight open-ended questions. Indeed as data analyses, the researcher took data interview results from the interviewees.
2. Student Group
The second group called as students‟ group. The seventh grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta became the participants in answering the questionnaires. They were from three different classes, e.g., 7 B, E, and G. Each class consisted of approximately forty students and the total amount of students was one hundred and twenty seven students as the research participants. Therefore, the researcher took data questionnaire results to find the need analysis. 3. Evaluator Group
34
D. Instruments and Data Gathering Technique
In order to acquire the data, the researcher implemented survey technique in this research within three instruments. They were conducting interview, distributing the questionnaires and evaluation questionnaires. The description and example of those three instruments discussed as follows:
1. Interview
In the interview process, the researcher asked in Indonesian language to get more detail information. The interview consisted of eight open-ended questions covering the need analysis in this research. The example of interview‟s questions as in appendix B (the English version):
1) Does reading skill in curriculum 2013 become a dominant skill besides other skills, e.g. speaking, listening, and writing?
2) What are your ways in designing materials for reading which relevant to the four main competencies of curriculum 2013?
In April 2014, the researcher conducted the interview for two English teachers of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta. The result of the interview analyzed in a form of narrative description.
2. Questionnaire
35
Table 6. Questionnaire
No. Pernyataan
Poin Persetujuan
1 2 4 5
1. Kegiatan membaca akan lebih menarik apabila latihan soal yang diberikan berupa teks yang berkaitan dengan mata pelajaran lainnya, seperti ilmu pengetahuan alam dan sosial, sejarah, dan lain sebagainya.
1 2 4 5
2. Saya sangat membutuhkan latihan kosa-kata sebelum kegiatan membaca sehingga saya mampu memahami bacaan yang diberikan.
1 2 4 5
Ary, Jacobs, & Sorenses (2010) define a Likert scale or summated rating scale uses to assess students‟ attitudes related to the topic in the research which is going to be asked in the questionnaire. Again, Best (1970) states that “the instrument yields a total score for each respondent, and a discussion of each
individual item, while possible, is not necessary” (p. 175). In scoring the Likert scale, the researcher cited from Ary et.al (2010), “strongly agree is scored 5, agree is scored 4, undecided is scored 3, disagree is scored 2, and strongly disagree is scored 1” (p. 210). The agreement points in this research can be seen in Table 7 below.
Table 7. The Meaning of Agreement Points Point’s
Agreement Response Category Abbreviation
1 Strongly disagree SD
2 Disagree D
4 Agree A
5 Strongly agree SA
36 3. Evaluation
The researcher conducted the evaluation which was divided into three parts. The first part had ten close-ended-statements about the look of reading exercises. The second part had five close-ended statements about the Hot-Potatoes program works in the website. Both parts adopted Likert scale in measuring the evaluation and the agreement points as the same as in Table 7 above. The last part was the evaluator‟s feedback which had five open-ended questions. The evaluators wrote feedback, opinion, and suggestion as the design improvement. The meaning of agreement points can be seen in Table 8 below.
Table 8. The Meaning of Agreement Points Point’s
Agreement Response Category Abbreviation
1 Strongly disagree SD
2 Disagree D
3 Agree A
4 Strongly agree SA
Therefore, the purpose of agreement points was to arrange the students who chose in agree part and disagree part.
E. Data Analysis Technique
The researcher divided this part into three. They were data interview, questionnaire and evaluation.
1. Interview
37
interview. Then, the researcher summarized the data transcription of interview Indeed, the researcher used the analysis to get the needs of students and teachers by interviewing the teachers.
2. Questionnaire
After the students answered the questionnaire, the researcher analysed it by classifying the number of students who had chosen certain answer. In analysing the data questionnaire, the researcher‟s technique is arranging the score as in the points of agreement. The arrangement scores in the data questionnaire were as follows:
Table 9. The Arrangement of Data Questionnaire
Statement methodology as in analysing the data questionnaire. Therefore, the researcher arranged the scores as in the points of agreement. The arrangement scores in the data evaluation are as follows:
Table 10. The Arrangement of Data Questionnaire
Statement
Points of Agreement Disagree Agree
38 F. Research Procedures
There were four procedures to obtain the data for this research such as follows:
1. The researcher conducted interviews and distributed the questionnaire as preliminary field-testing. The purpose of interview and questionnaire distribution are to find the problems and the needs‟ analysis. The reading exercises were designed from both data. First, the researcher interviewed two English teachers who handled the seventh grade students. Based on the result of the interview, the researcher interpreted the data and started to design the syllabus into four units.
2. After designing the syllabus, the researcher developed the syllabus into several exercises for four units by using Hot Potatoes. The design can be accessed at www.englishreadex.pbworks.com.
3. The next step distributed the evaluation sheet for teachers and lecturers. After gathering data evaluation, the researcher started to revise the design.
39 CHAPTER IV
RESEARCH RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
This chapter presents the results and findings, which have been ordered in ways justified in the methodology. This chapter answers two questions stated in the research problem. The researcher also divides this chapter into two parts. The first part is the results and discussion about the first question in research problem,
“How are the Web-based reading exercises using Hot-Potatoes for the seventh
grade students of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta designed?” The second part
is the final product revision to answer the second question in research problem,
“What does the design look like?”
A. The Result and Discussion in Designing Reading Exercises
This part consists of the result and discussion of interview, questionnaire, and evaluation. The description of those result and discussion are as follow. 1. The Result and Discussion of Interview
40
feel comfortable with teacher-centered method than students-centered method. Another question that the researcher asked about the facilities and Internet connection at school. The researcher found that SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta facilitated the students by using wireless provider (Wi-Fi). However, the Internet connection did not accessible if there were too many users. The teachers at SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta also used the Internet connection to browse example of procedure texts, create teacher‟s blog which can upload teaching materials and assignment. And then, the students also asked to submit their assignment via e-mail. Unfortunately, teachers who became the interviewees did not have blogs for online learning media. Both English teachers agreed that their students will open another media, i.e. social media, when the teachers asked them to browse something. Actually, the use of technology at school received
41
42
outside classroom to facilitate students‟ language learning. Regarding the previous
question about teacher‟s weblog, there was a teacher of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1
Yogyakarta who integrated information and communication technology subject by using weblog. The teacher provided and uploaded todays lesson in weblog so that the students could access it. For instance, they must open teacher‟s weblog to see what the assignment is and they must submit it in the weblog or send it by e-mail when the students had an individual project. The idea of the teacher increased
students‟ interests to integrate technology and academic subject. The seventh question was about the weblog‟s layout may become one factor of increasing
students‟ interests. Thus, the design in this research should have an interesting layout. The last question was related with Hot-Potatoes program, the teachers stated that Hot-Potatoes program was interesting and new for teachers and students.
In conclusion, the researcher designed the exercises within the use of curriculum 2013, Web-based reading exercises, Hot-Potatoes which can be uploaded in weblog, and the students can access the reading exercises.
2. The Result and Discussion of Questionnaire
43
grade students as the spiritual preparation for national examination, the researcher also got the same schedule with another researcher who conducted experimental research so that the researcher had time constraint in distributing the questionnaires, and students‟ fatigued after answering the test items from another researcher. And then, the teachers should finish their teaching material to achieve the target for the final examination. The result of the given questionnaire can be seen in Table 11 below.
Table 11. The Result of Questionnaire
Statement 1. The reading activity will be more
interesting if the given exercises related to another lesson
(interdisciplinary course), e.g. science, social science, history, etc.
2 27 88 10
1.57 21.25 69.29 7.87
2. I need vocabulary exercise before the reading activity, so that I can
understand what I read and the meaning of vocabulary.
1 18 70 38
0.78 14.17 55.11 29.92
3. The reading activity will be more interesting if the students invited to be more active although the exercises using online learning media.
1 14 82 30
0.78 11.02 64.56 23.62
4. I will be happy and will have a better understanding to find the main idea if there is a picture in the text.
2 24 68 34
1.57 18.89 53.54 26.77
5. I like browsing, opening and doing English exercises in weblog.
10 41 48 34
7.87 32.28 37.79 22.04 6. It would be much better if the weblog
provides syllabus so that the students know what the topics and the target.
10 20 76 34
7.87 15.74 59.84 26.77
7. Vocabulary exercises will be better if it is presented in forms of matching tasks and crossword puzzles.
0 23 84 20
0 18.11 66.14 15.74
44 students‟ daily activity/life that the
students face it. 0 4.72 75.59 19.68
9. I like if the exercises applied pictures, e.g. picture-cued tasks.
0 6 90 31
0 4.72 70.86 24.4
10. The reading exercises are better presented in form of multiple choices, matching tasks, and crossword puzzles.
3 20 75 29
2.36 15.74 59.05 22.83
45
This research found that 53.54% students expected the design by using pictures so that the students may get better understanding what the text is about. Fifth, the data result showed that 37.79% students agreed in statement number 5 about the use of weblog as the online learning media. Some students preferred to browse material and do the exercises online to improve their understanding in some academic subjects. Sixth, there were 59.84% students who agreed that the design must attach the syllabus so that the students know what they learn are about and the target lesson after finishing the exercises. Seventh, there were 66.14% students agreed in statement number 7. Thus, the vocabulary exercises were designed in form of matching tasks and crossword puzzles. Eight, this research found that 75.59% students agreed in statement number 8 that the given exercises should in
accordance with students‟ daily activities. Ninth, this research found that 70.86% students agreed in statement number 9 about the exercises design in forms of picture-cued items. Last, the data showed that 59.05% students agreed in statement number 10. The design of the reading exercises were in form of multiple choices, matching tasks, and crossword puzzles. Indeed, the data questionnaire showed that more students chose agree parts (agree-strongly agree) rather than in disagree parts (disagree-strongly disagree) as seen in the Table 11 above.
46 3. The Result and Discussion of Evaluation
In this part, there are four areas of discussion of the reading exercise design. They are the description of the respondents as evaluator, the results of close-ended, and the result of open-ended evaluation.
a. The Description of the Evaluator
There were four evaluators of reading exercise design. They were from two English teachers of SMP Pangudi Luhur 1 Yogyakarta who taught VII grade students and two active lectures who taught in English Language Education Study Program (ELESP) of Sanata Dharma University. The first teacher is female who had more than 15 years‟ experience in teaching English and she had Bachelor‟s
evaluate from teachers and lecturers who had experiences in teaching English, especially in reading skill and knowledgeable in the use of technology. Here are the complete data of evaluators design can be seen in Table 12 below.
Table 12. The Description of the Evaluators
47 b. The Result of Close-Ended Evaluation
48
language usage in the questions provided. Otherwise, the researcher needed to check the grammar usage and added the questions in each unit because the researcher added more varied exercises in each unit. Eight, the answers provided in multiple choice tasks are not confusing and in this statement, an evaluator agreed and the others strongly agreed with this statement. Thus, the researcher kept in consistent this statement in each exercise. Ninth, both questions and answers connected with the given statement. Hence, the researcher kept in consistent this statement in each exercise. Last, there were not any mistyped in both reading texts and reading exercises provided in each unit. In this statement, the evaluators agreed. Hence, the researcher needed to improve this part when adding some exercises in each unit. Therefore, the data evaluation result in detail can be seen in Table 13 below.
Table 13.
A Statistic Description of Evaluators’ Feedback Using Evaluation
No. Statements
Range
Disagree Agree
1 2 3 4
EXERCISE
1. The time allocation is suitable
with the exercise 1 3
2. The exercise is appropriate for 7 th
well-49
No. Statements
Range
Disagree Agree
1 2 3 4
9. The given questions and answers
are connected 1 3
10. There is not any mistyped 1 3
The second part was about the Hot-Potatoes program works in the website. This research found that the evaluators agreed if the program was easy to administer within the three programs usage, such as JQuiz, JMatch, and JCross. Then, the second statement three evaluators agreed and an evaluator disagreed about the second statement, because of bad Internet connection which made some pictures disappeared and comments box could not work properly. The evaluators agreed in the third statement about the use of Hot-Potatoes program in each unit. Then, the fourth statement got three agreed from evaluators and an evaluator who disagreed in the fourth statement. In the fifth statement, the evaluators agreed and through this research, the researcher did not need to use another weblog because it is very easy to log in by using Pbworks. Therefore, the data evaluation result in detail can be seen in Table 14 below.
Table 14.
A Statistic Description of Evaluators’ Feedback Using Evaluation
No. Statements
The program is easy to administer, such as matching tasks, crossword puzzles, and multiple-choice tasks
1 3
2. There are not any difficulties in
50 5. There are not any difficulties to
log in using Pbworks 1 3
c. The Result of Open-Ended Evaluation
The researcher also received evaluators‟ feedbacks in form of open-ended questions. The researcher asked about the design looked like, the weaknesses, the strengths, the given topic, and the needs to improve the design. These were the
results of evaluators‟ feedbacks on the reading exercises design as seen in the narrative description below.
1) The Evaluators’ Feedback on How the Design looks like
Through this research, the researcher found that the design was interesting for teen-age students and good as a whole since English is learnt using technology. It was also useful to improve students‟ interest in learning English. Probably, the design could prevent students‟ boredom in learning English.
The feedback were positive in this part. Thus, the design was quite good based on the result of evaluation. However, the researcher needed to improve and revise the design color of weblog so that the students will be more addicted in doing the exercises.
2) The Evaluators’ Feedback on the Weaknesses of the Design
