6,)$7),6,.$$63$/02',),.$6,.$5(7$/$03$'$%(5%$*$,
-(1,6'$1'26,6/$7(.6.$5(7$/$0
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
.H\ZRUGV /DWH[ QDWXUDO UXEEHU SK\VLFDO SURSHUWLHVUXEEHUL]HGDVSKDOW
$EVWUDN
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
R
² &'RVLVSHQDPEDKDQODWHNVNDUHW DODP GLYDULDVLNDQ VHEHVDU GDQ WHUKDGDSEHUDWDVSDOSHQ%HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO SHQJXMLDQ GLSHUROHK EDKZD ODWHNV NDWLRQLN/GDQODWHNVSUDYXONDQLVDVLMDP / PHQJKDVLONDQ DVSDO NDUHW \DQJ OHELK EDLN GDULSDGD DVSDO NDUHW GHQJDQ DGLWLI ODWHNV SHNDW ELDVD / GDQ ODWHNV SHNDW SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP / /DWHNV / PHQJKDVLONDQ DVSDO NDUHW GHQJDQ WLWLN OHPEHN\DQJOHELKWLQJJLGDULSDGDODWHNV/ QDPXQ PHPLOLNL HODVWLF UHFRYHU\ GDQ VWDELOLWDV SHQ\LPSDQDQ \DQJ OHELK UHQGDK GDULSDGD ODWHNV / NDUHQD ODWHNV / WLGDN PHODOXL SURVHV SUDYXONDQLVDVL $GDQ\D LNDWDQVLODQJSDGDODWHNVSUDYXONDQLVDVL/ PHPEXDWNDUHWSDGDFDPSXUDQDVSDONDUHW 'RLKWWSVGRLRUJSSNMSNYL
PHPLOLNL HODVWLVLWDV \DQJ OHELK WLQJJL GDQ VWDELOLWDVSHQ\LPSDQDQ\DQJOHELKEDLN .DWDNXQFL $VSDONDUHWNDUHWDODPODWHNV
VLIDWILVLND
3(1'$+8/8$1
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
6KDIILHHWDO
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
DO
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
5LVHW LQL PHPSHODMDUL SHQJDUXK SHQDPEDKDQ EHUEDJDL MHQLV ODWHNV NDUHW DODPSHNDWNHGDODPDVSDOSDQDVSHQHWUDVL SHQ WHUKDGDS VLIDW ILVLN DVSDO NDUHW /DWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDW\DQJGLXMLFREDNDQ PHOLSXWLODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDWPXUQLGDQ ODWHNV NDUHW DODP SHNDW \DQJ WHODK GLPRGLILNDVLVHFDUDNLPLDZL
%$+$1'$10(72'(
3HQHOLWLDQ WHODK GLODNVDQDNDQ GL 3DEULN3HUFREDDQGDQ/DERUDWRULXP3HQJXML 3XVDW 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW XQWXN NHJLDWDQ SHUVLDSDQGDQSHQJXMLDQEDKDQNDUHWDODP GDQ 3XVDW 3HQHOLWLDQ 3HQJHPEDQJDQ -DODQ GDQ -HPEDWDQ XQWXN NHJLDWDQ SHPEXDWDQ GDQ SHQJXMLDQ DVSDO NDUHW %DKDQ XWDPD \DQJGLJXQDNDQGDODPSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODK ODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDW\DQJGLSHUROHKGDUL .RSHUDVL .DU\DZDQ ,1,52 %RJRU DVSDO SDQDV3HQGLSURGXNVLROHK373HUWDPLQD 3HUVHUR VHUWD VXUIDNWDQ DQLRQLN VRGLXP
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
3URVHGXU GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ WHUEDJL PHQMDGL WLJD WDKDSDQ \DLWX NDUDNWHULVDVL ODWHNV NDUHW DODP SHNDW VHVXDL $670 'GDQDVSDOSHQVHVXDL6SHVLILNDVL 8PXP%LQD0DUJDSHUVLDSDQODWHNVNDUHW DODP VHEDJDL EDKDQ DGLWLI DVSDO PRGLILNDVL SROLPHUGLODQMXWNDQGHQJDQSHPEXDWDQGDQ SHQJXMLDQDVSDOPRGLILNDVLSROLPHUEHUEDVLV DVSDO SDQDV GDQ ODWHNV NDUHW DODP /DWHNV NDUHWDODP\DQJGLSHUVLDSNDQVHEDJDLEDKDQ DGLWLIPHOLSXWLODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDWPXUQL ODWHNV PXUQL / ODWHNV NDUHW DODP DVDP ODWHNVNDWLRQLN/GDQODWHNVNDUHWDODP SUDYXONDQLVDVLODWHNVSUDYXO
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
O D W H N V S U D Y X O G L E X D W G H Q J D Q F D U D PHQFDPSXUNDQ EDKDQ NLPLD GLVSHUVL NRPSRQ NDUHW \DQJ WHUGLUL GDUL GLVSHUVL FDPSXUDQ EDKDQ SHQJDNWLI EDKDQ SHQFHSDWEDKDQDQWLRNVLGDVLGDQGLVSHUVL VXOIXU NH GDODP ODWHNV NDUHW DODP SHNDW PXUQL \DQJ WHODK GLVWDELONDQ GHQJDQ SHQDPEDKDQ VXUIDNWDQ SDGD VXKX UXDQJ &DPSXUDQ ODWHNV GDQ EDKDQ DGLWLIQ\D
R
NHPXGLDQ GLSDQDVNDQ SDGD VXKX & VHODPDMDP/GDQMDP/
7DKDS NHWLJD \DLWX SHQFDPSXUDQ ODWHNV NDUHW DODP SDGD NRQVHQWUDVL GHQJDQ DVSDO SDQDV GLDZDOL GHQJDQ PHPDQDVNDQ DVSDO SDQDV KLQJJD VXKX
R R
&.HWLNDWHODKWHUFDSDLVXKX &NH GDODP DVSDO SDQDV \DQJ WHODK PHQFDLU GLWDPEDKNDQODWHNVNDUHWDODPVHGLNLWGHPL VHGLNLW VHNDOLJXV GLDGXN DJDU WHUEHQWXN FDPSXUDQ DVSDO PRGLILNDVL SROLPHU DVSDO N D U H W \ D Q J K R P R J H Q 6 H O D Q M X W Q \ D FDPSXUDQDVSDONDUHWGLSLQGDKNDQNHGDODP PL[HU DVSDO NDUHW GHQJDQ WHUXV GLODNXNDQ
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
7DEHO5LQFLDQNRGHVDPSHODVSDONDUHWEHUEDVLVODWHNVSUDYXONDQLVDVL 7DEOH6DPSOHFRGHGHWDLOVRIUXEEHUL]HGDVSKDOWEDVHGRQSUHYXOFDQL]HGODWH[ +$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1 .DUDNWHULVDVL %DKDQ %DNX /DWHNV .DUHW $ODP3HNDWGDQ$VSDO3HQ
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
VHGDQJNDQ NXDOLWDV DVSDO SHQ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GL ,QGRQHVLD PHQJLNXWL 6WDQGDU 8PXP%LQD0DUJD7DEHOPHPSHUOLKDWNDQ KDVLO SHQJXMLDQ PXWX DVSDO NDUHW SHQ PXUQLGDQ7DEHOPHUDQJNXPNDUDNWHULVWLN ODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDWPXUQL
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
$ /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SHNDW PXUQL /
% /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SHNDW PXUQL /
& /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SHNDW PXUQL /
' /DWHNV NDUHW DODP NDWLRQLN /
( /DWHNV NDUHW DODP NDWLRQLN /
) /DWHNV NDUHW DODP NDWLRQLN /
* /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP / + /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP / , /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP / - /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP / . /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP / / /DWHNV NDUHW DODP SUDYXONDQLVDVL MDP /
1R 3DUDPHWHU 3DUDPHWHUV 6WDQGDUPXWX 4XDOLW\VWDQGDUG +DVLOSHQJXMLDQ 7HVWUHVXOW 3HQHWUDVL SDGD R& PP ² 9LVNRVLWDV NLQHPDWLN R& F6W 0LQ 7LWLN OHPEHNR& 0LQ 'DNWLOLWDV SDGD R& FP 0LQ 7LWLN Q\DODR& 0LQ .HKLODQJDQ EHUDW 0DNV
3HQHWUDVL VHWHODK NHKLODQJDQ EHUDW PP 0LQ
7LWLN OHPEHN VHWHODK NHKLODQJDQ EHUDW R&
GLDSOLNDVLNDQGDODPSHPEXDWDQDVSDONDUHW
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
DO
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
'DULGDWDWHUVHEXWWHUOLKDWEDKZD. ODWHNVNDWLRQLN/VHEDQGLQJGHQJDQ ODWHNV SUDYXONDQLVDVL / \DQJ GLVHEDENDQ ROHK MXPODKNRPSRVLVLEDKDQSHPRGLILNDVL\DQJ GLWDPEDKNDQ NH GDODP ODWHNV PXUQL VDDW SHPEXDWDQ NHGXD MHQLV ODWHNV WHUVHEXW KDPSLU VDPD %DKDQ SHPRGLILNDVL SDGD ODWHNV NDWLRQLN PHQFDQJNXS ODUXWDQ VXUIDNWDQGDQDVDPNXDWSHNDWVHPHQWDUD ODWHNV SUDYXONDQLVDVL PHOLSXWL GLVSHUVL EDKDQ NLPLD NRPSRQ NDUHW GDQ ODUXWDQ VXUIDNWDQ %DLN GDODP ODUXWDQ VXUIDNWDQ PDXSXQGLVSHUVLEDKDQNLPLDNRPSRQNDUHW EDQ\DN PHQJDQGXQJ DLU \DQJ GDSDW PHQ\HEDENDQEHUNXUDQJQ\D.ODWHNVKDVLO PRGLILNDVL VHEHVDU GLEDQGLQJNDQ ODWHNVPXUQLVHEHVDU 6HODQMXWQ\D SDGDODWHNVSUDYXOMDP/GDQMDP/ WHUOLKDW SHQLQJNDWDQ QLODL . \DQJ FXNXS WDMDP SDGD / GDULSDGD / :DNWX SUDYXONDQLVDVL \DQJ ODPD PHQ\HEDENDQ VHPDNLQEDQ\DNEDKDQQRQNDUHWWHUXWDPD DLU GDODP ODWHNV SUDYXONDQLVDVL \DQJ PHQJDODPL SHQJXDSDQ \DQJ NHPXGLDQ GLLNXWLGHQJDQQDLNQ\DQLODL.SDGDODWHNV /
6LIDW )LVLND $VSDO .DUHW 'HQJDQ 3HQDPEDKDQ%HUEDJDL-HQLV/DWHNV.DUHW $ODP
6LIDWILVLNDVSDONDUHW\DQJGLSHUROHK GDUL KDVLO SHQDPEDKDQ EHUEDJDL MHQLV ODWHNV NDUHW DODP GDODP DVSDO SHQ GLUDQJNXP GDODP 7DEHO 7DEHO PHQJLQIRUPDVLNDQEDKZDSHQDPEDKDQ ODWHNV NDUHW DODP PHQXUXQNDQ DQJND
SHQHWUDVL DVSDO QDPXQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ QLODL WLWLN OHPEHN %HUNXUDQJQ\D SHQHWUDVL \DQJ GLLNXWL GHQJDQ PHQLQJNDWQ\D WLWLN OHPEHN EHUDUWLEDKZDDVSDONDUHWPHQMDGLVHPDNLQ NHUDV NHQWDO VHUWD WDKDQ WHUKDGDS SHUXEDKDQ VXKX GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ DVSDO SHQ PXUQL /LX $OEUND 3HUXEDKDQ VLIDW DVSDO SHQ LQL GLVHEDENDQ ROHK PHQLQJNDWQ\D HODVWLVLWDV DVSDO NDUHW NDUHQD DGDQ\D NDQGXQJDQ SDUWLNHO NDUHW GDODP ODWHNV \DQJ MXJD WHUGLVWULEXVLGDODPDVSDOSHQ$VSDONDUHW GHQJDQ VLIDW SHQHWUDVL UHQGDK GDQ WLWLN OHPEHN\DQJWLQJJLVHVXDLGLJXQDNDQXQWXN SHPEHQWXN ODSLVDQ SHUNHUDVDQ MDODQ GL ZLOD\DK GHQJDQ VXKX OLQJNXQJDQ \DQJ FHQGHUXQJSDQDV.LVKRUH *RWWDOD
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
7DEHO 6LIDWILVLNDVSDONDUHWEHUEDVLVODWHNVNDUHWDODPGDQDVSDOSHQ
7DEOH 3K\VLFDO SURSHUWLHV RI UXEEHUL]HG DVSKDOW EDVHG RQ QDWXUDO UXEEHU ODWH[ DQG DVSKDOWSHQ 3DUDPHWHU 3DUDPHWHUV $VSDO PXUQL 3XUH DVSKDOW .RGHVDPSHOODWHNV /DWH[VDPSOHFRGH % ( + . 3HQHWUDVL PP 'DNWLOLWDV FP ! 7LWLN OHPEHNR& ,QGHNV SHQHWUDVL
.HKLODQJDQ EHUDW GHQJDQ 7)27 DVOL
3HQHWUDVL VHWHODK 7)27 DVOL
7LWLN OHPEHN VHWHODK 7)27R&
'DNWLOLWDV VHWHODK 7)27 FP ! ! ! !
L N D W D Q V L O D Q J P H O D O X L P H N D Q L V P H
S U D Y X O N D Q L V D V L 6 H O D L Q L W X D N L E D W SHPEHQWXNDQ LNDWDQ VLODQJ PDND XNXUDQ SDUWLNHONDUHWDODPGDODP/GDQ/PHQMDGL EHVDU 3HQLQJNDWDQ XNXUDQ SDUWLNHO NDUHW DODP WXUXW EHUNRQVWULEXVL WHUKDGDS SHQXUXQDQ QLODL GDNWLOLWDV DVSDO NDUHW =KDQJHW DO *DR +XDQJ /DWHNV SUDYXONDQVDVL VHODPD MDP / PHPLOLNL WLQJNDW HODVWLVLWDV \DQJ WHUEDLN GLEDQGLQJMHQLVODWHNVNDUHWDODP\DQJODLQ NDUHQD PHODOXL PHNDQLVPH SUDYXONDQLVDVL WHODKWHUEHQWXNLNDWDQVLODQJDQWDUPROHNXO NDUHW ,NDWDQ VLODQJ WHUVHEXW WLGDN WHUMDGL SDGDODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDW/GDQODWHNV NDWLRQLN / GDQ EHOXP WHUEHQWXN VHPSXUQDSDGDODWHNVSUDYXONDQLVDVLMDP /0DOLWKRQJ 7KRQJSLQ
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
SHQJXDSDQ NHWLND DVSDO NDUHW GLSDQDVNDQ
R
SDGD VXKX & VDDW SHQJXMLDQ 7)27 $VSDO NDUHW GHQJDQ SHQDPEDKDQ ODWHNV NDWLRQLN / PHPLOLNL VLIDW ILVLN SHQHWUDVL WLWLN OHPEHN GDQ GDNWLOLWDV \DQJ UHODWLI SDOLQJEDLNGLDQWDUDMHQLVODWHNVNDUHWDODP \DQJODLQ'DODPODWHNVNDWLRQLN/WHUGDSDW VXUIDNWDQGRVLVWLQJJL6XUIDNWDQLQLODK\DQJ G L S H U N L U D N D Q E H U S H U D Q G D O D P PHPSHUWDKDQNDQ VLIDW ILVLN DVSDO NDUHW VHODPDNRQGLVLSHPDQDVDQEHUXODQJ
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
6LIDW )LVLND $VSDO .DUHW 'HQJDQ 3HQDPEDKDQ %HUEDJDL -HQLV GDQ 'RVLV /DWHNV.DUHW$ODP
3HQLQJNDWDQGRVLVODWHNVNDUHWDODP PHPSHQJDUXKL WLQJNDW NHNHUDVDQ DVSDO \DQJGLLQGLNDVLNDQGHQJDQSHQXUXQDQQLODL SHQHWUDVL 7DEHO 'HQJDQ NDGDU SDUWLNHO NDUHW \DQJ VHPDNLQ EDQ\DN GDODP FDPSXUDQ DVSDO NDUHW PDND DNDQ VHPDNLQ EDQ\DN SDUWLNHO NDUHW \DQJ PHPHQXKL UXDQJUXDQJDQWDUSDUWLNHODVSDO3DGDVDDW SURVHV SHQFDPSXUDQ MDUDN DQWDU SDUWLNHO DVSDO PHQMDGL UHQJJDQJ GLVHEDENDQ ROHK DGDQ\DSHPDQDVDQ3DGDVDDWSDUWLNHODVSDO PHQMDGL UHQJDQJ SDUWLNHO NDUHW DODP DNDQ PDVXN NH GDODP UXDQJUXDQJ DQWDUD SDUWLNHO DVSDO GDQ PHQ\HUDS PLQ\DN \DQJ WHUNDQGXQJ GDODP DVSDO VHKLQJJD NDUHW DODP PHQJHPEDQJ 3DUWLNHO NDUHW WHUVHEXW PHQJLVLUXDQJUXDQJGLDQWDUDSDUWLNHODVSDO VHKLQJJD DVSDO NDUHW \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ PHQMDGL OHELK SDGDW GDQ NHUDV 6LIDW DVSDO NDUHW \DQJ PHQMDGL OHELK SDGDW GDQ NHUDV MXJD GLLNXWL GHQJDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ QLODL WLWLN OHPEHN VHUWD LQGHNV SHQHWUDVL 6HLULQJ SHQDPEDKDQ GRVLV ODWHNV GLLNXWL GHQJDQ SHQXUXQDQ GDNWLOLWDV 6LIDW LQL VHVXDL
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
+DVLO SHQJXMLDQ DVSDO NDUHW VHWHODK 7)27 SDGD YDULDVL GRVLV ODWHNV NDUHW DODP \DQJ GLWDPEDKNDQ NH GDODP DVSDO SHQ P H Q X Q M X N N D Q E D K Z D W H U M D G L Q \ D SHQLQJNDWDQQLODLSHQHWUDVLGDQWLWLNOHPEHN NHKLODQJDQ EHUDW \DQJ IOXNWXDWLI VHUWD GDNWLOLWDV FHQGHUXQJ NRQVWDQ NHFXDOL / \DQJ WXUXQ GUDVWLV 1LODL SHQHWUDVL \DQJ GLUHNRPHQGDVLNDQ XQWXN DVSDO PRGLILNDVL VHWHODK XML 7)27 PLQLPXP VHEHVDU 6HGDQJNDQ VHOLVLK QLODL WLWLN OHPEHN \DQJ GLL]LQNDQXQWXNDVSDOPRGLILNDVL\DQJWHODK
R
GLXML7)27DGDODKVHEHVDU &DWDX WLGDN
R
EROHK OHELK GDUL & $OWLHEHW DO
3HUV\DUDWDQQLODLWLWLNOHPEHNVHWHODK7)27 WHUVHEXWGDSDWGLSHQXKLROHKVHOXUXKDVSDO N D U H W N H F X D O L D V S D O N D U H W G H Q J D Q SHQDPEDKDQ/GDQ/VHEDQ\DN
%HUGDVDUNDQ*DPEDUGDQ*DPEDU GDSDW GLNHWDKXL EDKZD DVSDO NDUHW EHUEDVLVDVSDOSHQGDQODWHNVNDUHWDODP MHQLV ODWHNV NDWLRQLN / GDQ ODWHNV SUDYXO / SDGD GRVLV GDQ WHUKDGDS ERERW DVSDO PHPLOLNL VWDELOLWDV PXWX \DQJ UHODWLI EDLN 6LIDW LQL GLEXNWLNDQ GDUL SHUEHGDDQ QLODLSHQHWUDVLDVSDONXUDQJGDULSRLQGDQ WLWLNOHPEHNDVSDONDUHW\DQJOHELKNHFLOGDUL
R R
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
R
*DPEDU 3HQJDUXKSHQ\LPSDQDQSDGD &WHUKDGDSWLWLNOHPEHN R
)LJXUH (IIHFWRIVWRUDJHDW &RQVRIWHQLQJSRLQW ' ( ) * + , - . / 3 H UE H G D D Q W LW LN O H P E H N 6 R IW H Q LQ J S R LQ W G LI IH UH Q F H 6DPSHODVSDONDUHW 5XEEHUL]HGDVSKDOWVDPSOH /DQJVXQJ [MDP [MDP [MDP 3HUEHGDDQWLWLNOHPEHN 6RIWHQLQJSRLQWGLIIHUHQFH &
NDUHW FHQGHUXQJ PHQJDSXQJ DNLEDW SHUEHGDDQ GHQVLWDV NDUHW GDQ DVSDO VHUWD W H U G H J U D G D V L D N L E D W S D Q D V V H O D P D S H Q \ L P S D Q D Q . D U H W \ D Q J W L G D N WHUYXONDQLVDVL OHELK PXGDK WHUGHJUDGDVL DNLEDWSDQDV%HUEHGDGHQJDQODWHNV/GDQ / \DQJ PHPLOLNL VWDELOLWDV SHQ\LPSDQDQ \DQJOHELKEDLNNDUHQDWHODKWHUYXONDQLVDVL .(6,038/$1 .HVLPSXODQ \DQJ GDSDW GLXUDLNDQ EHUGDVDUNDQXUDLDQKDVLOSHQHOLWLDQDGDODK EDKZDSHQDPEDKDQNDUHWDODPGDODPDVSDO SHQ GDODP SHPEXDWDQ DVSDO PRGLILNDVL SROLPHU DVSDO NDUHW GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQ VLIDW ILVLN DVSDO \DQJ GLLQGLNDVLNDQ GHQJDQ ' ( ) * + , - . / 3 H UE H G D D Q S H Q H WU D V L 3 H Q H WU D WL R Q G LI IH UH Q H P P 6DPSHO DVSDONDUHW 5XEEHUL]HGDVSKDOWVDPSOH /DQJVXQJ [MDP [MDP [MDP 3HUEHGDDQSHQHWUDVL 3HQHWUDWLRQGLIIHUHQFH PP R *DPEDU3HQJDUXKSHQ\LPSDQDQSDGD &WHUKDGDSSHQHWUDVL R
EHUWDPEDKQ\DQLODLWLWLNOHPEHNSHQXUXQDQ QLODL SHQHWUDVL GDQ NHQDLNDQ NHHODVWLVDQ V H W H O D K S H Q J H P E D O L D Q D V S D O N D U H W 3DUDPHWHU LQL \DQJ DNDQ EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS NHPDPSXDQ DVSDO NDUHW GDODP P H Q D K D Q N H O H O H K D Q S O D V W L V G D Q PHQLQJNDWNDQWDKDQDQJHVHU
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
SHUIRUPDQFH RI DVSKDOW ELQGHU PRGLILHGZLWKQDQRSDUWLFOHV7UHQGVLQ &LYLO(QJLQHHULQJDQG0DWHULDO6FLHQFH
$O0DQVRE 5$ ,VPDLO $ <XVRII 1,0 $OEUND 6, $]KDUL &+ .DULP 055KHRORJLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLF RIXQDJHGDQGDJHGHSR[LGL]HGQDWXUDO UXEEHUPRGLILHGDVSKDOW&RQVWUXFWLRQ DQG%XLOGLQJ0DWHULDOV ' R L M F R Q E X L O G P D W $OWLHE =$ $]L] 00$ $QXDU . -LEULQ+%$VKRUWUHYLHZRQ XVLQJFUXPEUXEEHUDVPRGLILFDWLRQRI ELWXPHQELQGHU-XUQDO7HNQRORJL &RQJ3&KHQ6<X- :X6 (IIHFWV RI DJLQJ RQ WKH SURSHUWLHV RI PRGLILHG DVSKDOW ELQGHU ZLWK IODPH UHWDUGDQWV&RQVWUXFWLRQ DQG %XLOGLQJ
0DWHULDOV 'RL
MFRQEXLOGPDW (UNXV < .RN %9 <LOPD] 0 (IIHFWV RI JUDSKLWH RQ UKHRORJLFDO DQG FRQYHQWLRQDOSURSHUWLHVRIELWXPLQRXV ELQGHUV ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI 3DYHPHQW 5HVHDUFK DQG 7HFKQRORJ\ 'RL MLMSUW *DR * +XDQJ : 3HUIRUPDQFH DQDO\VLVDQGUHVHDUFKRIZDUPDVSKDOW UXEEHU 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH WK , Q W H U Q D W L R Q D O & R Q I H U H Q F H R Q 7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ (QJLQHHULQJ S &KHQJGX &KLQD $6&( 'RL
*KDO\ 1) (IIHFW RI VXOIXU RQ WKH VWRUDJHVWDELOLW\RIWLUHUXEEHUPRGLILHG DVSKDOW:RUOG -RXUQDO RI &KHPLVWU\
*XLGHOOL (- 5DPRV $3 =DQLTXHOOL 0(' %DIID 2 *UHHQ V \ Q W K H V L V R I F R O O R L G D O V L O Y H U QDQRSDUWLFOHV XVLQJ QDWXUDO UXEEHU O D W H [ H [ W U D F W H G I U R P + H Y H D EUDVLOLHQVLV6SHFWURFKLPLFD $FWD 3DUW
$ ² 'RL MVDD
.LVKRUH.61 *RWWDOD$$VWXG\ RQHIIHFWRIDGGLWLRQRIQDWXUDOUXEEHU RQ WKH SURSHUWLHV RI ELWXPHQ ELWXPLQRXV PL[HV ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI 6FLHQFH 7HFKQRORJ\ (QJLQHHULQJ² /LX 6 6WXG\ RI SK\VLFDO DQG UKHRORJLFDOSURSHUWLHVRIZD[PRGLILHG ELQGHUVXVLQJFODVVLFDQG6+53WHVWLQJ PHWKRGV,QGLDQ-RXUQDORI(QJLQHHULQJ 0DWHULDO6FLHQFH² 0DOLWKRQJ 6 7KRQJSLQ & 7KH PRGLILFDWLRQRIDVSKDOWHPXOVLRQXVLQJ SUHYXOFDQL]HGQDWXUDOUXEEHUODWH[IRU KLJKZD\ DSSOLFDWLRQ $GYDQFHG 0DWHULDO 5HVHDUFK ² 'RL ZZZVFLHQWLILFQHW $05 0DQGHHO 7$- 9LVFRVLW\ DQG GXFWLOLW\ LPSURYHPHQW RI QDWXUDO DVSKDOW LQ +HHW$QEDU DUHDV XVLQJ LQGXVWULDO ZDVWH IRU WKH SXUSRVH RI UHF\FOLQJ7LNULW-RXUQDORI3XUH6FLHQFH
0DVKDDQ 16 $OL $+ .DULP 05 $EGHOD]L] 0 (IIHFW RI FUXPE UXEEHU FRQFHQWUDWLRQ RQ WKH SK\VLFDO D Q G U K H R O R J L F D O S U R S H U W L H V R I U X E E H U L V H G E L W X P H Q E L Q G H U V ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI WKH 3K\VLFDO
6FLHQFH
0DVKDDQ16$OL$+.RWLQJ6 .DULP 053HUIRUPDQFHHYDOXDWLRQRI FUXPE UXEEHU PRGLILHG VWRQH PDVWLF DVSKDOW SDYHPHQW LQ 0DOD\VLD $GYDQFHV LQ 0DWHULDO 6FLHQFH DQG
(QJLQHHULQJ S 'RL
1HMDG )0 $JKDMDQL 3 0RGDUUHV $ )LURR]LIDU+,QYHVWLJDWLQJWKH SURSHUWLHV RI FUXPE UXEEHU PRGLILHG ELWXPHQ XVLQJ FODVVLF DQG 6+53 WHVWLQJ PHWKRGV &RQVWUXFWLRQ DQG %XLOGLQJ0DWHULDOV'RL M F R Q E X L O G P D W 2ZDLG .$ (IIHFW RI DJLQJ RQ WKH UKHRORJLFDO SURSHUWLHV RI WKH PRGLILHG D V S K D O W U X E E H U V \ V W H P X V L Q J PLFURZDYH WHFKQLTXH (XURSHDQ &KHPLFDOO%XOOHWLQ'RL (&%
5HPL]RYD( +RO\0&KDQJHVRI SURSHUWLHV RI ELWXPHQ ELQGHUV E\ DGGLWLYHV DSSOLFDWLRQ,23 &RQIHUHQFH 6HULHV 0DWHULDOV 6FLHQFH DQG (QJLQHHULQJS'RL ; 6DORPH] 0 6XELOHDX 0 ,QWDSXQ -%RQILOV ) 6DLQWH%HXYH - 9D\VVH / 'XEUHXFT ( 0LFUR RUJDQLVPVLQODWH[DQGQDWXUDOUXEEHU FRDJXODRI+HYHDEUDVLOLHQVLVDQGWKHLU LPSDFW RQ UXEEHU FRPSRVLWLRQ VWUXFWXUH DQG SURSHUWLHV-RXUQDO RI $SSOLHG 0LFURELRORJ\ ² 'RLMDP 6KDIILH 0 $KPDG - $UVKDG $. .DPDUXQ ' .DPDUXGGLQ ) 6WULSSLQJ SHUIRUPDQFH DQG YROXPHWULFSURSHUWLHVHYDOXDWLRQRIKRW PL[ DVSKDOW +0$ PL[ GHVLJQ XVLQJ QDWXUDOUXEEHUODWH[SRO\PHUPRGLILHG ELQGHU 150% 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &LYLO DQG ,QIUDVWUXFWXUH
(QJLQHHULQJ S
6 L Q J D S R U H 6 S U L Q J H U ' R L
6KDILL0$$EGXO5DKPDQ0< $KPDG - 3RO\PHU PRGLILHG DVSKDOW HPXOVLRQ,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI&LYLO (QYLURPHQWDO(QJLQHHULQJ²
6KHQJ</L+*HQJ-7LDQ</L= ;LRQJ 5 3URGXFWLRQ DQG SHUIRUPDQFH RI GHVXOIXUL]HG UXEEHU DVSKDOWELQGHU,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI 3DYHPHQW 5HVHDUFK DQG 7HFKQRORJ\ ' R L MLMSUW
6XURVR7:3HQJDUXKSHQDPEDKDQ SODVWLN /'3( /RZ 'HQVLW\ 3RO\ :WK\OHQHFDUDEDVDKGDQFDUDNHULQJ WHUKDGDS NLQHUMD FDPSXUDQ EHUDVSDO 0HGLD .RPXQLNDVL 7HNQLN 6LSLO :DQJ7;LDR)$PLUNKDQLDQ6+XDQJ : =KHQJ0$UHYLHZRQORZ W H P S H U D W X U H S H U I R U P D Q F H R I U X E E H U L ] H G D V S K D O W P D W H U L D O V &RQVWUXFWLRQ DQG %XLOGLQJ 0DWHULDOV 'RL MFRQEXLOGPDW
:HQ<:DQJ<=KDR. 6XPDOHH$ 7KHXVHRIQDWXUDOUXEEHUODWH[ DV D UHQHZDEOH DQG VXVWDLQDEOH P R G L I L H U R I D V S K D O W E L Q G H U ,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXUQDO RI 3DYHPHQW (QJLQHHULQJ ² 'RL <LQ -0 :DQJ 6< /X )5
,PSURYLQJ WKH VKRUWWHUP DJLQJ UHVLVWDQFH RI DVSKDOW E\ DGGLWLRQ RI FUXPE UXEEHU UDGLDWHG E\ PLFURZDYH DQG LPSUHJQDWHG HSR[LGL]HG VR\EHDQ R L O & R Q V W U X F W L R Q D Q G % X L O G L Q J 0DWHULDOV 'RL MFRQEXLOGPDW =KDQJ = :X 4 =KDR = (YDOXDWLRQRIVDVRELWZDUPPL[UXEEHU DVSKDOW SURSHUWLHV3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH UG ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH RQ 7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ (QJLQHHULQJ S &KHQJGX&KLQD$6&(
