2/6/23, 10:26 AM Email UIN SAIZU Purwokerto - [resmilitaris] Editor Decision
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=953127de05&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f%3A1742488338562881111&simpl=msg-f%3A1742488… 1/1
abu dharin <abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id>
[resmilitaris] Editor Decision
1 pesan
Editor Res Militaris <Editor@resmilitaris.net> 29 Agustus 2022 pukul 16.46 Kepada: Abu Dharin <abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id>, Syufaat Syufaat <syufaat75@gmail.com>
Abu Dharin, Syufaat Syufaat:
We have reached a decision regarding your submission to resmilitaris, "COPYRIGHT WAQF: AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS".
Our decision is to: Accept Submission
________________________________________________________________________
resmilitaris
() Excellent, accept the submission (5)
(x) Good, accept the submission with minor revisions required (4) ( ) Acceptable, revisions required (3)
( ) Resubmit for review, major revisions required (2) () Decline the submission (1)
Comments from Reviewer A
The editor will forward the section below to author/s
Evaluation
(Please assign the score for each item below)5=Excellent 4=Good 3=Average 2=Below Average 1=Poor n/a=Not Applicable
Items Grade
Overall evaluation on the paper
1. Contribution to existing knowledge 4
2. Appropriate formatting and structure 4.0
3. Readability 3.0
4. Soundness of methodology 4.5
5. Evidence supports conclusion 4.5
6. Adequacy of literature review 4.5
Strengths
The paper entitled “
COPYRIGHT WAQF: AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS
” is received for review and in my view the above title is suitable for publication in Res Militaris . Weaknesses In my view
- Review of the literature on the variables and concepts need to be more exhaustive.
- Add more literature.
- The background needs restructuring to highlight the objective of
Recommendation to Editor
(Please mark “x” for appropriateoption)the study.
- Please check your references.
3
(x) Excellent, accept the submission (5)
() Good, accept the submission with minor revisions required (4) ( ) Acceptable, revisions required (3)
() Resubmit for review, major revisions required (2) ( ) Decline the submission (1)
Comments from Reviewer B
The editor will forward the section below to author/s
Evaluation
(Please assign the score for each item below)5=Excellent 4=Good 3=Average 2=Below Average 1=Poor n/a=Not Applicable
Items Grade
Overall evaluation on the paper
1. Contribution to existing knowledge 4
2. Appropriate formatting and structure 4.0
3. Readability 3.0
4. Soundness of methodology 4.5
5. Evidence supports conclusion 4.5
6. Adequacy of literature review 4.5
Strengths
The paper entitled “
COPYRIGHT WAQF: AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS
”. In my view the above title is suitable for publication in Res Militaris . Weaknesses
In my view the authors must
-Add literature review of the study.
-Purpose of the study should be elaborated extensively and logically.
-Despite some recent references are used but some of the
Recommendation to Editor
(Please mark “x” for appropriateoption)Literature references should be updated which would not be prior to 2016.
- Please add implications to the study.
- Please add future directions of this study.
-Please check missing references
3
4
2/6/23, 10:10 AM Email UIN SAIZU Purwokerto - Confirmation APC, Final revision and cek plagiarisme
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=953127de05&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a%3Ar-2207648582927267928&simpl=msg-a%3Ar-219… 1/2
abu dharin <abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id>
Confirmation APC, Final revision and cek plagiarisme
3 pesan
abu dharin <abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id> 7 September 2022 pukul 11.16
Kepada: Editor Res Militaris <Editor@resmilitaris.net>
Dear Editor In chief
We hereby send proof of payment and the results of the plagiarism check as well as the final revision of the article entitled "COPYRIGHT WAQF: AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS". thank you
Best Regard Syufa'at
5 lampiran
Document APC, Syufaat, et.al.jpeg 50K
Document Paypal Payment APC, Syufaat, et.al.jpeg 60K
Copy Right - Syufaat, et.al.pdf 368K
Cek Plagiarism WAQF_ AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS.pdf 2223K
Final Revision Article Syufa'at, et.al.docx 57K
editor@resmilitaris.net <editor@resmilitaris.net> 7 September 2022 pukul 18.31 Kepada: abu dharin <abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id>
Dear Authors
Your paper will be published in October issue.
Regards
2/6/23, 10:10 AM Email UIN SAIZU Purwokerto - Confirmation APC, Final revision and cek plagiarisme
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=953127de05&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a%3Ar-2207648582927267928&simpl=msg-a%3Ar-219… 2/2
Editorial Team
[Kutipan teks disembunyikan]
abu dharin <abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id> 7 September 2022 pukul 20.52
Kepada: Editor Res Militaris <editor@resmilitaris.net>
Thank you for information
[Kutipan teks disembunyikan]
Date: 28thAugust,2022 Ref.:RM_1075A
Letter of Acceptance
Syufa’at
1, Abu Dharin
2,
1,2
State Islamic University (UIN) Prof. KH. Saifuddin Zuhri Purwokerto Jl. A. Yani No. 40 A Purwokerto 53126, Central Java, Indonesia
Email: abudharin@uinsaizu.ac.id
It's my pleasure to inform you that, after the peer review, your paper: “COPYRIGHT WAQF: AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS” has been ACCEPTED to publish with Res Militaris“ISSN2265-6294”.The journal is publishing original research articles and reviews including wide ranging issues on: Social Sciences (miscellaneous); Safety Research; Political Science and International Relations; Sociology and Political Science
It will be published in upcoming issue of August (Issue 2) of 2022.
ACCEPTED REVISIONS REQUIRED REJECTED
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any further questions.
Sincerely,
Editor Manager
Res Militaris
Date: 28/08/2022 Invoice No: RM_August_2022-1075
Invoice To Syufa’at
1, Abu Dharin
2Journal Name Journal Name:
RES MILITARISISSN: 2265-6294 Manuscript
Title
COPYRIGHT WAQF: AN ANALYSIS OF ISLAMIC AND POSITIVE LAWS
Amount (USD) 600+5% (Tax) = USD 630 Payment
Method
Beneficiary's Name: Intellectual Edge Consultancy SDN Bhd
Bank Name Address: AFFIN ISLAMIC BANK BERHAD, MSU Shah Alam Business Centre, 2nd Floor University Drive, Off PersiaranOlahraga, 40100 Shah Alam, Selangor Malaysia
Beneficiary's Account No: 106640006258 SWIFT CODE: AIBBMYKL
Beneficiary's Address: B2-1902, TTDI Adina Jalan Judo 13/45 Shah Alam 40100 Selangor Malaysia
Note: Make sure you write the complete beneficiary’s name “Intellectual Edge Consultancy SDN BHD” otherwise payment will return to your account.
Indonesian Account (Only for Indonesian Authors):
Account Holder: CV. Intellectual Edge Consultancy Bank Name: CIMB NIAGA Shariah
Branch:Cabang Banjarmasin-Ahmad Yani Km 2.5 Account Number: 860008267700
Method: PayPal
Paypal Email: scholar_economist@yahoo.co.uk
Click on the link and make payment in USD + 5% PayPal charges
With Warm Regards, Account Office
PAYMENT INVOICE
Payment Option 1
Payment Option 2
Payment Option 3
