,3(1'$+8/8$1 3HQWLQJQ\D NHOHVWDULDQ VXPEHUGD\D KXWDQ EDJLNHKLGXSDQEDLNGDULDVSHNHNRQRPLHNRORJL PDXSXQVRVLDOVHPDNLQPHQLQJNDWNDUHQDKXWDQ DODPPHQJDODPLSHQXUXQDQ\DQJVLJQLILNDQGDUL VHJLNXDQWLWDVGDQNXDOLWDVQ\D8SD\D\DQJGDSDW GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHQXQMDQJ NHOHVWDULDQ NHWLJD DVSHNWHUVHEXWDGDODKSHPEDQJXQDQKXWDQUDN\DW SDGD ODKDQODKDQ PLOLN \DQJ GLNHOROD ROHK PD V\DUDNDW
6DDW LQL SHQHOLWLDQ PHQJHQDL KXWDQ UDN\DW OHELK EDQ\DN PHQJNDML DVSHN VRVLDO HNRQRPL
PLVDOQ\D.XVPHGLHWDOPHQJNDMLDQDOLVLV ILQDQVLDOSHQJHORODDQKXWDQUDN\DW3ULKDGLHWDO PHQLODLNHOHPEDJDDQNHPLWUDDQLQGXVWUL SHQJRODKDQND\XGLKXWDQUDN\DW6HGDQJNDQDV SHNSHUHQFDQDDQSHQJHORODDQEHOXPEDQ\DNGL NHPEDQJNDQ6DODKVDWXDVSHN\DQJPDVLKSHUOX GLWHOLWLDGDODKHIHNWLILWDVSHQGXJDDQSRWHQVLSR KRQGDQWHJDNDQGLKXWDQUDN\DW.XUDQJQ\DSH QJHWDKXDQ PDV\DUDNDW GDODP PHQGXJD SRWHQVL SRKRQGDQWHJDNDQGDSDWPHQLPEXONDQNHVDODK DQSHUKLWXQJDQQLODLND\XVDDWSHQMXDODQVHKLQJJD PHQJDNLEDWNDQ NHUXJLDQ HNRQRPL EDJL SHWDQL KXWDQUDN\DW
02'(/92/80(32+216(1*21
8178.0(1,/$,.(+,/$1*$1.(81781*$13(7$1,+87$15$.<$7
9ROXPH0RGHORI6HQJRQ7UHHWR(YDOXDWHWKH3URILW/RVV
IRU&RPPXQLW\)RUHVWV)DUPHU
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
,,0(72'2/2*, $/RNDVL3HQHOLWLDQ
3HQHOLWLDQ LQL GLODNVDQDNDQ GL KXWDQ UDN\DW VHQJRQ GL 'HVD .DU\DVDUL .HFDPDWDQ /HXZL OLDQJ .DEXSDWHQ %RJRU -DZD %DUDW 'HVD LQL WHUOHWDN NP GDUL SXVDW NRWD .HFDPDWDQ /HX ZLOLDQJNPGDULSXVDWNRWD%RJRUGDQNP GDULLEXNRWD3URYLQVL-DZD%DUDW/XDVZLOD\DK GHVD.DU\DVDUL+D\DQJWHUOHWDNSDGDNH WLQJJLDQ±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
'DWDSRKRQXQWXNPHQJKLWXQJSRWHQVLNHUX JLDQ GLSHUROHK PHODOXL SHJXNXUDQ SRKRQ GDUL DUHDOKXWDQUDN\DWVHOXDVP GHQJDQPHQJ KLWXQJVHOXUXKWHJDNDQVHQJRQSRKRQXQWXN VLVWHP ERURQJDQ GDQ VDWX SRKRQ XQWXN VLVWHP EDWDQJDQ3DGDWLDSSRKRQGLODNXNDQSHQJXNXUDQ 'EK GLDPHWHU SHU VHNVL EDWDQJ SDQMDQJ P WLQJJLEHEDVFDEDQJGDQWLQJJLWRWDOSRKRQ'DWD
SHQMXDODQ ND\X VHQJRQ GLSHUROHK PHODOXL ZD
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
PHODOXL SHQMXPODKDQ YROXPH WLDS VHNVL EDWDQJ P EHUGDVDUNDQ OXDV SHQDPSDQJ OLQWDQJYL SDQJNDO VHNVL P OXDV SHQDPSDQJ OLQWDQJJS XMXQJ VHNVL P GDQ SDQMDQJ VHNVL P
JX O
GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ UXPXV 6PDOLDQ VHEDJDL EHULNXW+XVFKHWDO 8QWXN DQDOLVLV GDWD VHODQMXWQ\D GDWD SRKRQ FRQWRKGLEDJLPHQMDGLGXDEDJLDQ7DEHO\DLWX GDWDPRGHOXQWXNSHQ\XVXQDQDODWDODWSHQGXJD YROXPHSRKRQDQJNDEHQWXNSHUVDPDDQWDSHU PRGHOYROXPHGDQGDWDYDOLGDVLXQWXNPHQLODL NHWHOLWLDQDODWDODWSHQGXJDYROXPHSRKRQ
'DODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GLDQDOLVLV GXD PDFDP DQJND EHQWXN \DLWX DQJND EHQWXN DEVROXW GDQ EXDWDQ \DQJ GLKLWXQJ GHQJDQ UXPXV 6LPRQ
D
E
'3HQ\XVXQDQ3HUVDPDDQ7DSHU
3HUVDPDDQWDSHU GLVXVXQ EHUGDVDUNDQ GDWD GLDPHWHUSHUVHNVL FPGDQWLQJJLEDWDQJSHUG VHNVL PGDULSRKRQFRQWRKPHODOXLDQDOLVLVK UHJUHVL 3HUVDPDDQWDSHU \DQJ VHVXDL XQWXN PHQJJDPEDUNDQ EHQWXN EDWDQJ VHQJRQ GLSLOLK GDUL SHUVDPDDQSHUVDPDDQ EHULNXW LQL 0XKGLQ +DNLP G' IK+D G' I^K+K+ `E G' I^K+K+ K+ `F G' I^K+G G' I^K+K+ `H G' I^K+K+ K+ `I
3HUVDPDDQ YROXPH GLVXVXQ GHQJDQ FDUD PHQJLQWHJUDONDQ SHUVDPDDQWDSHU WHUSLOLK GHQJDQWLQJJLEDWDQJSHUVHNVLVDPSDLGLDPHWHU EDWDQJFP+
!////////////////////////////////////////)5*
(3HQ\XVXQDQ0RGHO9ROXPH
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
&) H[S6((
3HQLODLDQNHVHVXDLDQJRRGQHVVRIILWPRGHO PRGHO UHJUHVL GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ PHQJXML VLJQL ILNDQVLSDUDPHWHUPRGHO<DQJHWDOGDQ PHPEDQGLQJNDQ QLODLURRW PHDQ VTXDUH HUURU 506( GDQ NRHILVLHQ GHWHUPLQDVL WHUNRUHNVL 5 GHQJDQUXPXVVHEDJDLEHULNXW'UDSHU DGM 6PLWK+XDQJHWDO
D E 7DEHO'HVNULSVLVWDWLVWLNSRKRQFRQWRK'HVFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFVRIVDPSOHWUHHV
9DULDEHO 'DWDPRGHOQ 'DWD9DOLGDVLQ
0HDQ 6' 0LQ 0D[ 0HDQ 6' 0LQ 0D[ 'FP +P 9DP
6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
9
6
QL YLGDQYLL
J JS X I D I D 9D 9GS 9D 9GS 9 SGGK + K 506(6
[L ¥\L±L Q±S 5 DGM Q± 6\ ±L L Q±S 6\ ±\L L Q L Q L
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV\LÔf YROXPH DNWXDO YROXPH
GXJDDQ PRGHO UDWDUDWD YROXPH
DNWXDO MXPODKGDWD MXPODKQ S
SDUDPHWHUPRGHO
0RGHO YROXPH SRKRQ WHUSLOLK DGDODK PRGHO \DQJ PHPLOLNL QLODL 506( WHUNHFLO GDQ 5 DGM WHUEHVDU6HODLQLWXPRGHOWHUVHEXWKDUXVPHPH QXKLDVXPVLNHQRUPDODQVLVDDQGDQKRPRJHQLWDV VLVDDQ
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
7DEHO7DEOH 'HVNULSWLIVWDWLVWLNDQJNDEHQWXNDEVROXWGDQEXDWDQSRKRQVHQJRQ'HVFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFV RIDEVROXWHDQGDUWLILFLDOIRUPIDFWRUIURPVHQJRQWUHH
$QJND%HQWXN
)RUPIDFWRU 0LQ 0D[ 0HDQ 6' &9
$EVROXW
%XDWDQ
6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
Q L 6 \LQ ¥06(3 \ 6\ ±L L 6\ ±\L L Q L Q L 6Q\ ±L L L Q 6Q\ ±L L L Q 6Q\ ±L L L Q
7DEHO3HUVDPDDQ7DSHU3RKRQ6HQJRQ7DSHUHTXDWLRQVRIVHQJRQWUHH
1R 3HUVDPDDQ(TXDWLRQV V 5 5DGM 3YDOXH G' K+ G' K+K+ G' K+K+K+ G' K+ G' K+K+ G' K+K+K+
3HUVDPDDQWDSHUSRKRQVHQJRQ.HHQDP SHUVDPDDQWDSHU EHUVLIDW VDQJDW Q\DWD3YDOXH\DQJEHUDUWLEDKZDSHX EDKWLQJJLGDSDWPHQGXJDSHXEDKGLDPHWHUSDGD EHUEDJDLNHWLQJJLDQEDWDQJSRKRQ1DPXQEHU GDVDUNDQ QLODL NRHILVLHQ GHWHUPLQDVL 5DGM GDQQLODLVLPSDQJDQEDNX SHUV VDPDDQWDSHUWHUEDLNDGDODKSHUVDPDDQNHOLPD
G' K+K+ 7DEHO
'DULKDVLOLQWHJUDVLWDSHUSHUVDPDDQWHUVHEXWGL SHUROHKPRGHOYROXPHSRKRQVHEDJDLEHULNXW 97 ' + 0RGHOYROXPHSRKRQVHQJRQ 6HPXDSDUDPHWHUSDGDPRGHOSHUVDPDDQ9 99GDQ9EHUVLIDWQ\DWD3YDOXH \DQJEHUDUWLEDKZDSHXEDKGLDPHWHUSDGDPRGHO 9 GDQ 9 DWDX SHXEDK GLDPHWHU GDQ WLQJJL SDGDPRGHO9GDQ9GDSDWGLJXQDNDQXQWXN PHQGXJDYROXPHSRKRQ7DEHO0RGHOPRGHO WHUVHEXW GDSDW PHQMHODVNDQ NHUDJDPDQ YROXPH SRKRQVHEHVDU±0RGHO9PHPLOLNLQLODL 506( WHUNHFLO ZDODXSXQ WLGDN EHUEHGD MDXKGHQJDQPRGHO9506( 8ML.RO PRJRURY6PLUQRY PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD PRGHO
93YDOXH GDQ93YDOXH PH
PHQXKL DVXPVL NHQRUPDODQ VLVDDQ SDGD WDUDI Q\DWD $QDOLVLV VLVDDQ MXJD PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZDPRGHO9GDQ9PHPHQXKLDVXPVLNHKR PRJHQDQUDJDPVLVDDQ'HQJDQGHPLNLDQPRGHO 9 GDQ 9 PHUXSDNDQ PRGHOPRGHO YROXPH WHUEDLNGLEDQGLQJNDQPRGHOPRGHOODLQQ\D\DQJ WLGDNPHPHQXKLDVXPVLNHQRUPDODQVLVDDQGDQ NHKRPRJHQDQUDJDPVLVDDQ
7DEHO7DEOH 1LODLQLODL SDUDPHWHU GDQ NULWHULD VWDWLVWLN XQWXN PRGHOPRGHO YROXPH 3DUDPHWHU HVWLPDWHVDQGFULWHULDVWDWLVWLFVRIYROXPHPRGHOV
0RGHO 3DUDPHWHU 6( 3YDOXH 506( 5 5DGM
6 1RUPDOLWDVVLVDDQ 1RUPDOLW\RI UHVLGXDOV +RPRJHQLWDV UDJDPVLVDDQ +RPRJHQHLW\RI YDULDQFHUHVLGXDOV 9 E 7LGDN1R 7LGDN1R E 9 E 7LGDN1R 7LGDN1R E E 9 E 7HUSHQXKL 7HUSHQXKL E <HV <HV 9 E 7HUSHQXKL 7HUSHQXKL E <HV <HV E 9 E 7LGDN1R 7LGDN1R E 9 E 7LGDN1R 7LGDN1R E E E
6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
7DEHO7DEOH 1LODLQLODLVWDWLVWLNKDVLOXMLYDOLGDVLPRGHOPRGHOSHQGXJDYROXPHSRKRQ9DOLGDWLRQ VWDWLVWLFVRIWUHHYROXPHPRGHOV 0RGHO 0( 3( 0$' 06(3 5( () 9 9 9ID 9IE 9WDSHU 9%
.HWHOLWLDQ PRGHOPRGHO SHQGXJD YROXPH SRKRQ
0RGHO9PHQXQMXNNDQSHUIRUPDQVLWHUEDLN NDUHQD OHELK DNXUDW QLODL0(3( GDQ0$' SDOLQJUHQGDKGDQOHELKWHOLWLQLODL06(35( SDOLQJUHQGDKGDQ()SDOLQJWLQJJLGLVEDQGLQJ PRGHOPRGHO ODLQQ\D GDODP PHQGXJD YROXPH SRKRQVHQJRQ7DEHO0RGHOWHUEDLNEHULNXW Q\DDGDODK9GDQNHPXGLDQEHUWXUXWWXUXW9 ID 9 9 GDQ9 % 7 IE
3RWHQVLNHKLODQJDQNHXQWXQJDQSHWDQL 'DODPVLVWHPSHQMXDODQND\XVHQJRQGLORNDVL SHQHOLWLDQ SHQJHSXO PHQDQJJXQJ VHPXD ELD\D SHPDQHQDQSHQHEDQJDQSHPLNXODQGDQSHQJ DQJNXWDQ 2OHK NDUHQD LWX ELD\D SHPDQHQDQ WHUVHEXW GLSHUKLWXQJNDQ GDODP WRWDO KDUJD MXDO XQWXNPHQJDQDOLVLVSRWHQVLSHQGDSDWDQSHQMXDO DQND\X7DEHO
3DGDVLVWHPSHQMXDODQND\XVHQJRQSHUEDWDQJ GDQ SHU OXDVDQ EHUSRWHQVL PHQLPEXONDQ NHKL ODQJDQNHXQWXQJDQ\DQJFXNXSEHVDUEDJLSHWDQL 6LVWHPSHQMXDODQND\XSHUEDWDQJDQPHQLPEXO NDQ NHKLODQJDQ NHXQWXQJDQ VHEHVDU VHGDQJNDQ VLVWHP SHQMXDODQ ND\X SHU OXDVDQ
7DEHO7DEOH7RWDOKDUJDMXDOND\XVHQJRQ7RWDOVHOOLQJSULFHRIVHQJRQ
6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
6LVWHP 3HQMXDODQ 6HOOLQJ V\VWHPV /XDV ODKDQ 7RWDO DUHD -XPODK 7RWDO +DUJD-XDO 3ULFH %LD\DELD\D5S &RVW 7RWDO+DUJD -XDO7RWDORI VHOOLQJSULFH P %DWDQJ /RJ 5S 3HQHEDQJDQ /RJJLQJ 3HPLNXODQ 0DQXDO 7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ 3HQJDQJNXWDQ 7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ 5S SHUEDWDQJ SHUORJ SHUOXDVDQ SHUDUHD .HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV,QIRUPDVLKDUJDGDQELD\DGLSHUROHKGDULWHQJNXODNORFDO 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LRODKGDULGDWDODSDQJ&RPSLOHGDQGDQDO\]HGIURPILHOGGDWD
PHQLPEXONDQ NHKLODQJDQ NHXQWXQJDQ VHEHVDU 7DEHO +DO LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VLVWHPSHQMXDODQND\XGHQJDQWDQSDPHQJKLWXQJ YROXPHSRKRQDWDXWHJDNDQVHQJRQVHVXQJJXK Q\DVDQJDWEHUSRWHQVLPHQLPEXONDQNHKLODQJDQ NHXQWXQJDQEDJLSDUDSHWDQLKXWDQUDN\DW
%3HPEDKDVDQ
$QJND EHQWXN SRKRQ PHUXSDNDQ VDODK VDWX NRPSRQHQSHQHQWXYROXPHSRKRQ\DQJPHUXSD NDQSHQJJDPEDUDQGDULEHQWXNEDWDQJ7LGDNDGD SHUEHGDDQ \DQJ VLJQLILNDQ DQWDUD DQJND EHQWXN EXDWDQ GDQ DEVROXW VHKLQJJD NHGXDQ\D PDPSX PHQMHODVNDQEHQWXNEDWDQJ)DGDHLHWDO WHWDSL PDVLQJPDVLQJ DQJND EHQWXN PHPLOLNL QLODL DNXUDVL \DQJ EHUEHGD$QJND EHQWXN \DQJ VHULQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK DQJND EHQWXN EXDWDQ NDUHQDGEKELDVDGLJXQDNDQVHEDJDLFLULGLDPHWHU SRKRQ6LPRQ1DPXQKDVLOSHQHOLWLDDQ PHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDDQJNDEHQWXNDEVROXWOHELK DNXUDWGDODPPHQGXJDYROXPHSRKRQGLEDQGLQJ NDQDQJNDEHQWXNEXDWDQ+DOLQLGLGXJDNDUHQD SRKRQ VHQJRQ GL KXWDQ UDN\DW WLGDN EHUEDQLU VHKLQJJDGLDPHWHUSDQJNDOPHPSXQ\DLNRUHODVL \DQJNXDWGHQJDQYROXPHEDWDQJ
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
PHQWDO6FLHQFHV
+DUEDJXQJ + .ULVQDZDWL 0RGHO WDSHU EDWDQJ WDQDPDQ.KD\D DQWKRWHFD &'& GL +XWDQ 3HQHOLWLDQ 3DVLUKDQWDS 6XNDEXPL-DZD%DUDW-XUQDO3HQHOWLDQ +XWDQGDQ.RQVHUYDVL$ODP +XDQJ6<DQJ< :DQJ<$FULWLFDO
ORRN DW SURFHGXUHV IRU YDOLGDWLQJ JURZWK DQG\LHOG,Q$PDUR$5HGG'6RDUHV3 HGV0RGHOOLQJIRUHVWV\VWHPV*XLOGIRUG &$%,3XEOLVKLQJS +XVFK%%HHUV7: .HUVKDZ-$ )RUHVWPHQVXUDWLRQ)ORULGD7KH5RQDOG 3UHVV&RPSDQ\ .XULQREX 6 3UHKDWLQ ' 0RKDPPDG 1 0DWVXQH.$VWHPWDSHUHTXDWLRQ FRPSDWLEOHWRYROXPHHTXDWLRQIRU3DUD VHULDQWKHV IDOFDWDULDLQ 3DUH (DVW -DYD ,QGRQHVLDLWVLPSOLFDWLRQVIRUWKHSODQWD WLRQ PDQDJHPHQW-RXUQDO RI )RUHVW
.XVPHGL 3 -DUL\DK 1$ $QDOLVLV
ILQDQVLDOSHQJHORODDQDJURIRUHVWULGHQJDQ SROD VHQJRQ NDSXODJD GL 'HVD 7LULS .HFDPDWDQ :DGDVOLQWDQJ .DEXSDWHQ :RQRVRER-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ 6RVLDO GDQ
(NRQRPL.HKXWDQDQ
0XKGLQ +DNLP $5 3HQHQWXDQ MXPODK SRKRQ FRQWRK PLQLPDO XQWXN SHQ\XVXQDQ SHUVDPDDQ YROXPH PHODOXL IXQJVL WDSHU-XUQDO 0DQDMHPHQ +XWDQ
7URSLND
1XJURKR%7LU\DQD7,PSOLFDWLRQVRI WKHSULYDWHSURSHUW\ULJKWWRWKHFRPPXQLW\ IRUHVW EXVLQHVVHV IRUPDOL]DWLRQ WKURXJK WKHFHUWLILFDWLRQSROLF\-XUQDO0DQDMHPHQ
+XWDQ7URSLND
3HPHULQWDK 'DHUDK %RJRU 0RQRJUDIL 'HVD.DU\DVDUL%RJRU%RJRU
3ULKDGL 1 'DUXVPDQ ' 1XJURKR % :LMD\DQWR1.HOHPEDJDDQNHPL WUDDQ LQGXVWUL SHQJRODKDQ ND\X EHUVDPD UDN\DW XQWXN PHPEDQJXQ KXWDQ GL 3XODX -DZD-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ 6RVLDO GDQ (NR
QRPL.HKXWDQDQ 6LPRQ + 0HWRGH ,QYHQWRUH +XWDQ <RJ\DNDUWD3HQHUELW$GLW\D0HGLD 6LVZR\R % +XWDQ UDN\DW GDQ VHUEXDQ SDVDU 6WXGL UHIOHNVL SHQJXVDKDDQ KXWDQ UDN\DWOHVWDULVHFDUDNRODERUDWLIGL3DFLWDQ -DZD7LPXU-XUQDO,OPX6RVLDOGDQ,OPX 3ROLWLN 6SUXJHO'*&RUUHFWLQJIRUELDVLQORJ WUDQVIRUPHGDOORPHWULFHTXDWLRQV-RXUQDO (FRORJ\
6SXUU + )RUHVW ,QYHQWRU\ 1HZ<RUN 7KH5RQDOG3UHVV&RPSDQ\
7LU\DQD77DWVXKDUD6 6KLUDVKL1 (PSLULFDOPRGHOVIRUHVWLPDWLQJWKHVWDQG ELRPDVV RI WHDN SODQWDWLRQV LQ -DYD ,QGRQHVLD-RXUQDORI)RUHVW3ODQQLQJ
<DQJ < 5REHUW $ 0RQVHUXG +XDQJ 6 $Q HYDOXDWLRQ RI GLDJQRVWLF WHVW DQGWKHLUUROHVLQYDOLGDWLQJIRUHVWELRPH WULF PRGHOV-RXUQDO RI )RUHVW 5HVHDUFK
