Penentuan Faktor Yang Mempengaruhi Produktivitas Tenaga Kerja Dan Rancangan Perbaikan (Studi Kasus Di PT. Intan Suar Kartika)

(1)

LAMPIRAN 1

KUESIONER PENELITIAN

PENENTUAN FAKTOR YANG MEMPENGARUHI PRODUKTIVITAS

TENAGA KERJA DAN RANCANGAN STRATEGI PERBAIKAN

(STUDI KASUS DI PT.INTAN SUAR KARTIKA)

Kepada Yth.

Karyawan Bagian Produksi Paku PT.Intan Suar Kartika

Terima kasih atas partisipasi anda menjadi peserta survey dan secara sukarela mengisi

kuesioner ini. Nama saya Abdul Azis Syarif, mahasiswa pasca sarjana Teknik

Industri USU, pada saat ini sedang mengadakan penelitian tentang faktor yang

mempengaruhi produktivitas tenaga kerja di PT.Intan Suar Kartika. Saya sangat

menghargai kejujuran anda dalam mengisi kuesioner ini. Kami menjamin kerahasiaan

anda yang terkait dengan kuesioner. Hasil Kuesioner ini semata-mata akan digunakan

untuk tujuan penelitian dan bukan tujuan komersil.

Nama

:

Umur

:

Jenis Kelamin

:

Jabatan/bidang

:

Pendidikan

:

(2)

Petunjuk :

Berdasarkan pengalaman anda selama ini, berilah tanda (√) p

ada kolom yang telah

disediakan sesuai harapan anda dan kenyataan.

Keterangan :

SS (sangat setuju), S (setuju), N ( Netral), TS (tidak setuju)., STS (sangat Tidak

Setuju)

No

DAFTAR PERTANYAAN

SS

S

N

TS STS

KOMPETENSI

1 Prosedur kerja di perusahaan mudah dipahami oleh

karyawan

2 Arahan dari atasan mengenai pekerjaan mudah di

pahami

3 Mampu menyelesaikan permasalahan jika terjadi

masalah dalam pekerjaan,

4. Adanya deskripsi/gambaran pekerjaan yang saya

lakukan

5. Bisa bekerjasama dengan karyawan lain dalam

melakukan pekerjaan

6. Perlunya ada rasa kedisiplinan dalam melaksanakan

instruksi kerja

FASILITAS KERJA

7 Adanya kemudahan penggunaan peralatan dalam

bekerja

(3)

9. Tersedianya peralatan kerja yang memadai

10. Adanya kesesuaian peralatan kerja di tempat kerja

11. Peralatan kerja yang ada sudah memberikan rasa aman

bagi karyawan

12. Perlengkapan penerangan lampu dalam ruangan sudah

memadai

MOTIVASI KERJA

13. Perusahaan memberikan kebebasan karyawan

memberikan ide-ide demi kemajuan perusahaan

14. Adanya kesempatan yang berikan perusahaan untuk

mengembangkan kemampuan

15. Gaji dapat memberikan dorongan untuk bekerja lebih

baik

16. Adanya kesesuain gaji dengan beban kerja yang ada

selama ini

17. Perusahaan memberikan sistem promosi karir yang

jelas bagi karyawan

18. Hasil kerja yang baik layak mendapat pengahargaan

PENGALAMAN KERJA

19. Kematangan bekerja menggambarkan penguasaan

seorang karyawan terhadap suatu pekerjaan

20. Semakin lama seorang melaksanakan pekerjaan akan

memperoleh pengalaman lebih banyak

21. Banyaknya jenis tugas yang telah dilaksanakan akan

membuat sesorang akan bekerja lebih baik

22. Perusahaan memberikan pengetahuan,ketrampilan

melalui pelatihan bagi karyawan

23. Semakin lama seseorang bekerja akan membentuk

(4)

24. Melalui pelatihan akan mampu membuat seorang

pekerja menyelesaikan tugas dengan tepat

PRODUKTIVITAS TENAGA KERJA

25. Mampu mengerjakan tugas sesuai target yang

diinginkan

26. Hasil kerja sudah sesuai dengan diharapkan

27. Produksi yang dihasilkan telah memenuhi sasaran

mutu yang telah ditetapkan

(5)

LAMPIRAN 2

OUTPUT VALIDITAS DAN RELIABILITAS

1. VARIABEL X

1 VALIDITAS

Correlati ons

1 .088 .375* .357 .428* .428* .705**

.642 .041 .053 .018 .018 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.088 1 .530** .433* .403* .269 .575**

.642 .003 .017 .027 .151 .001

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.375* .530** 1 .612** .507** .349 .741**

.041 .003 .000 .004 .059 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.357 .433* .612** 1 .440* .310 .706**

.053 .017 .000 .015 .095 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.428* .403* .507** .440* 1 .759** .818**

.018 .027 .004 .015 .000 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.428* .269 .349 .310 .759** 1 .735**

.018 .151 .059 .095 .000 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.705** .575** .741** .706** .818** .735** 1

.000 .001 .000 .000 .000 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

X1.1.1 X1.1.2 X1.2.1 X1.2.2 X1.3.1 X1.3.2 X1

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.05 lev el (2-tailed). *.

(6)

2. VARIABEL X

2

VALIDITAS

Case Processing Summary

30

100.0

0 .0

30

100.0 Valid

Excluded

a

Total

Cases

N

%

Listwise deletion based on all

v ariables in the procedure.

a.

Reliabi lity Statisti cs

.774

7 Cronbach's

(7)

Correlati ons

1 .088

.375*

.357

.428*

.349

.705**

.642

.041

.053

.018

.059

.000

30

30 .088

1 .530**

.433*

.403*

.134

.559**

.642

.003

.017

.027

.479

.001

30

30 .375*

.530**

1 .612**

.507**

.190

.723**

.041

.003

.000

.004

.314

.000

30

30 .357

.433*

.612**

1 .440*

.310

.725**

.053

.017

.000

.015

.095

.000

30

30 .428*

.403*

.507**

.440*

1 .639**

.811**

.018

.027

.004

.015

.000

30

30 .349

.134

.190

.310

.639**

1 .641**

.059

.479

.314

.095

.000

30

30 .705**

.559**

.723**

.725**

.811**

.641**

1 .000

.001

.000

30

30 X2.1.1

X2.1.2

X2.2.1

X2.2.2

X2.3.1

X2.3.2

X2

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.05 lev el (2-tailed).

*.

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.01 lev el (2-tailed).

**.

Case Processing Summary

30

100.0

(8)

3. VARIABEL X

3

VALIDITAS

4. Variable X4

Validitas

Reliabi lity Statisti cs

.769

7 Cronbach's

Alpha

N of Items

Correlati ons

1 .000 .286 .288 .410* .249 .645** 1.000 .125 .123 .025 .185 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.000 1 .530** .433* .351 .095 .538** 1.000 .003 .017 .057 .617 .002

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.286 .530** 1 .612** .465** .235 .729** .125 .003 .000 .010 .210 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.288 .433* .612** 1 .506** .247 .738** .123 .017 .000 .004 .188 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.410* .351 .465** .506** 1 .459* .796** .025 .057 .010 .004 .011 .000

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.249 .095 .235 .247 .459* 1 .566** .185 .617 .210 .188 .011 .001

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

.645** .538** .729** .738** .796** .566** 1 .000 .002 .000 .000 .000 .001

30 30 30 30 30 30 30

X3.1.1 X3.1.2 X3.2.1 X3.2.2 X3.3.1 X3.3.2 X3

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.05 lev el (2-tailed). *.

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.01 lev el (2-tailed). **.

Reliabi lity Statisti cs

.761

7 Cronbach's

(9)

VARIABEL Y

VALIDITAS

Correlati ons

1 -.098

.232

.295

.397*

.290

.553**

.605

.218

.113

.030

.119

.002

30

30 -.098

1 .354

.400*

.134

.211

.495**

.605

.055

.029

.479

.263

.005

30

30 .232

.354

1 .354

.190

.209

.572**

.218

.055

.314

.268

.001

30

30 .295

.400*

.354

1 .403*

.211

.697**

.113

.029

.055

.027

.263

.000

30

30 .397*

.134

.190

.403*

1 .465**

.562**

.030

.479

.314

.027

.010

.001

30

30 .290

.211

.209

.211

.465**

1 .537**

.119

.263

.268

.263

.010

.002

30

30 .553**

.495**

.572**

.697**

.562**

.537**

1 .002

.005

.001

.000

.001

.002

30

30 X4.1.1

X4.1.2

X4.2.1

X4.2.2

X4.3.1

X4.3.2

X4

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.05 lev el (2-tailed).

*.

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.01 lev el (2-tailed).

**.

Reliabi lity Statisti cs

.715

7 Cronbach's

(10)

LAMPIRAN 2

Correlations

1 -.089

.180

.113

.512**

.640

.340

.554

.004

30

30 -.089

1 .570**

.241

.542**

.640

.001

.200

.002

30

30 .180

.570**

1 .464**

.672**

.340

.001

.010

.000

30

30 .113

.241

.464**

1 .574**

.554

.200

.010

.001

30

30 .512**

.542**

.672**

.574**

1 .004

.002

.000

.001

30

30 Pearson Correlation

Sig. (2-tailed)

N

Pearson Correlation

Sig. (2-tailed)

N

Pearson Correlation

Sig. (2-tailed)

N

Pearson Correlation

Sig. (2-tailed)

N

Pearson Correlation

Sig. (2-tailed)

N

Y 1.1.1

Y 1.1.2

Y 1.2.1

Y 1.2.2

Y 1

Y 1.1.1

Y 1.1.2

Y 1.2.1

Y 1.2.2

Y 1

Correlation is signif icant at the 0.01 lev el (2-tailed).

**.

Reliabi lity Statisti cs

.681

5 Cronbach's

(11)

OUTPUT KORELASI

Correlations

X1

X2

X3

X4

Y

X1 Pearson Correlation

1 .800

**

.372

*

.797

**

.414

**

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

.018

.000

.008

N

86

86 X2 Pearson Correlation

.800

**

1 .211

.532

**

.280

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

.190

.000

.080

N

86

86 X3 Pearson Correlation

.372

*

.211

1 .352

*

.493

**

Sig. (2-tailed)

.018

.190

.026

.001

N

86

86 X4 Pearson Correlation

.797

**

.532

**

.352

*

1 .264

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

.026

.100

N

86

86 Y

Pearson Correlation

.414

**

.280

.493

**

.264

1 Sig. (2-tailed)

.008

.080

.001

.100

N

86

(12)

ANALISIS REGRESI LINIER BERGANDA

TABEL FREKUENSI

Model Summaryb

.726a _.527 _.504 _.422 _.527 _22.563 ₄ ₈₁ _.000 _2.653

Std. Error of the Estimate

Predictors: (Constant), X4, X1, X2, X3 a.

Dependent Variable: Y b.

ANOVA

b

16.037

4

4.009

22.563 .000

a

14.393

81 .178

30.430

85 Squares

df

Mean Square

F

Sig.

Predictors: (Const ant), X4, X1, X2, X3

a.

Dependent Variable: Y

b.

Coeffi ci ents

a

10.935

1.967

5.560 .000

.355

.143

.496

2.474 .015

-.076

.148

-.113

-.515

.608

.152

.063

.262

2.410 .018

-.206

.156

-.297

-1.325

.189

(Constant)

Coef f icients

Beta

St andardized

Coef f icients

t

Sig.

(13)

X1

86

100.0

18 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

86

100.0

20 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

86 100.0 100.0

18

Frequency Percent Valid Percent

(14)

X4

7

8.1

8

9.3

17.4

20

23.3

40.7

7

8.1

48.8

24

27.9

76.7

12

14.0

90.7

6

7.0

97.7

1

1.2

98.8

1

1.2

100.0

86

100.0

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

Y1

3

3.5

6

7.0

10.5

16

18.6

29.1

32

37.2

66.3

18

20.9

87.2

10

11.6

98.8

1

1.2

100.0

86

100.0

13

14

15

16

17

18

19 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(15)

LAMPIRAN 6

TABEL ANALISIS DESKRIPTIF

VARIABEL X1

X1.1. 1

18

20.9

50

58.1

79.1

18

20.9

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X1.1. 2

18

20.9

58

67.4

88.4

10

11.6

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X1.2. 1

6

7.0

78

90.7

97.7

2

2.3

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(16)

X1.2. 2

1

1.2

13

15.1

16.3

67

77.9

94.2

5

5.8

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X1.3. 1

3

3.5

18

20.9

24.4

63

73.3

97.7

2

2.3

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X1.3. 2

1

1.2

16

18.6

19.8

64

74.4

94.2

5

5.8

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(17)

VARIABEL X2

X1

1

1.2

5

5.8

7.0

6

7.0

14.0

18

20.9

34.9

8

9.3

44.2

27

31.4

75.6

13

15.1

90.7

7

8.1

98.8

1

1.2

100.0

86

100.0

18

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

28 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X2.1. 1

13

15.1

45

52.3

67.4

28

32.6

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X2.1. 2

15

17.4

58

67.4

84.9

13

15.1

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(18)

X2.2. 1

10

11.6

71

82.6

94.2

5

5.8

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X2.2. 2

21

24.4

57

66.3

90.7

8

9.3

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X2.3. 1

8

9.3

31

36.0

45.3

45

52.3

97.7

2

2.3

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X2.3. 2

22

25.6

55

64.0

89.5

9

10.5

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(19)

VARIABEL X3

86

100.0

20 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X3.1. 1

10

11.6

22

25.6

37.2

43

50.0

87.2

11

12.8

100.0

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(20)

X3.2. 1

9

10.5

74

86.0

96.5

3

3.5

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X3.3. 1

4

4.7

28

32.6

37.2

49

57.0

94.2

5

5.8

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X3.3. 2

17

19.8

21

24.4

44.2

42

48.8

93.0

6

7.0

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(21)

VARIABEL X4

86

100.0

16 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X4.1. 1

1

1.2

12

14.0

15.1

41

47.7

62.8

32

37.2

100.0

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(22)

X4.2. 1

9

10.5

72

83.7

94.2

5

5.8

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

X4.3. 2

2

2.3

13

15.1

17.4

54

62.8

80.2

17

19.8

100.0

86

100.0

2 Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(23)

VARIABEL Y1

X4

6

7.0

9

10.5

17.4

19

22.1

39.5

8

9.3

48.8

23

26.7

75.6

13

15.1

90.7

6

7.0

97.7

1

1.2

98.8

1

1.2

100.0

86

100.0

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

Y1.1.1

4

4.7

20

23.3

27.9

40

46.5

74.4

22

25.6

100.0

86

100.0

2

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

Y1.1.2

9

10.5

69

80.2

90.7

8

9.3

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(24)

Y1.2.1

10

11.6

64

74.4

86.0

12

14.0

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

Y1.2.2

14

16.3

54

62.8

79.1

18

20.9

100.0

86

100.0

3

4

5 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulat iv e

Percent

Y1

3

3.5

6

7.0

10.5

19

22.1

32.6

30

34.9

67.4

18

20.9

88.4

9

10.5

98.8

1

1.2

100.0

86

100.0

13

14

15

16

17

18

19 Total

Valid

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

(25)

LAMPIRAN 7

Tabel R Untuk Uji Validitas

DF = n-2

Tingkat Signifikansi Untuk Uji 1 arah

0,05 0,025 0,001 0,005 0,0005

Tingkat Signifikansi Untuk Uji 2 arah

0,1 0,05 0,02 0,01 0,001

1 0,9877 0,9969 0,9995 0,9999 1,0000

2 0,9000 0,9500 0,9800 0,9900 0,9990

3 0,8054 0,8783 0,9343 0,9587 0,9911

4 0,7293 0,8114 0,8822 0,9172 0,9741

5 0,6694 0,7545 0,8329 0,8745 0,9509

6 0,6215 0,7067 0,7887 0,8343 0,9249

7 0,5822 0,6664 0,7498 0,7977 0,8983

8 0,5494 0,6319 0,7155 0,7646 0,8721

9 0,5214 0,6021 0,6851 0,7348 0,8470

10 0,4973 0,5760 0,6581 0,7079 0,8233

11 0,4762 0,5529 0,6339 0,6835 0,8010

12 0,4575 0,5324 0,6120 0,6614 0,7800

13 0,4409 0,5140 0,5923 0,6411 0,7604

14 0,4259 0,4973 0,5742 0,6226 0,7419

15 0,4124 0,4821 0,5577 0,6055 0,7247

16 0,4000 0,4683 0,5425 0,5897 0,7084

17 0,3887 0,4555 0,5285 0,5751 0,6932

18 0,3783 0,4438 0,5155 0,5614 0,6788

19 0,3687 0,4329 0,5034 0,5487 0,6652

20 0,3598 0,4227 0,4921 0,5368 0,6524

21 0,3515 0,4132 0,4815 0,5256 0,6402

22 0,3438 0,4044 0,4716 0,5151 0,6287

23 0,3365 0,3961 0,4622 0,5052 0,6178

24 0,3297 0,3882 0,4534 0,4958 0,6074

25 0,3233 0,3809 0,4451 0,4869 0,5974

26 0,3172 0,3739 0,4372 0,4785 0,5880

27 0,3115 0,3673 0,4297 0,4705 0,5790

28 0,3061 0,3610 0,4226 0,4629 0,5703

29 0,3009 0,3550 0,4158 0,4556 0,5620

30 0,2960 0,3494 0,4093 0,4487 0,5541

31 0,2913 0,3440 0,4032 0,4421 0,5465

32 0,2869 0,3388 0,3972 0,4357 0,5392

33 0,2826 0,3338 0,3916 0,4296 0,5322

34 0,2785 0,3291 0,3862 0,4238 0,5254

(26)

LAMPIRAN 9

Tabel t

α

df

0.10

0.05

0.02

0.01

1

6.314

12.706

31.821

63.657

2

2.920

4.303

6.965

9.925

3

2.353

3.182

4.541

5.841

4

2.132

2.776

3.747

4.604

5

2.015

2.571

3.365

4.032

6

1.943

2.447

3.143

3.707

7

1.895

2.365

2.998

3.499

8

1.860

2.306

2.896

3.355

9

1.833

2.262

2.821

3.250

10

1.812

2.228

2.764

3.169

11

1.796

2.201

2.718

3.106

12

1.782

2.179

2.681

3.055

13

1.771

2.160

2.650

3.012

14

1.761

2.145

2.624

2.977

15

1.753

2.131

2.602

2.947

16

1.746

2.120

2.583

2.921

17

1.740

2.110

2.567

2.898

18

1.734

2.101

2.552

2.878

19

1.729

2.093

2.539

2.861

20

1.725

2.086

2.528

2.845

21

1.721

2.080

2.518

2.831

22

1.717

2.074

2.508

2.819

23

1.714

2.069

2.500

2.807

24

1.711

2.064

2.492

2.797

25

1.708

2.060

2.485

2.787

(27)

27

1.703

2.052

2.473

2.771

28

1.701

2.048

2.467

2.763

29

1.699

2.045

2.462

2.756

30

1.697

2.042

2.457

2.750

31

1.696

2.040

2.453

2.744

32

1.694

2.037

2.449

2.738

33

1.692

2.035

2.445

2.733

34

1.691

2.032

2.441

2.728

35

1.690

2.030

2.438

2.724

36

1.688

2.028

2.434

2.719

37

1.687

2.026

2.431

2.715

38

1.686

2.024

2.429

2.712

39

1.685

2.023

2.426

2.708

40

1.684

2.021

2.423

2.704

41

1.683

2.020

2.421

2.701

42

1.682

2.018

2.418

2.698

43

1.681

2.017

2.416

2.695

44

1.680

2.015

2.414

2.692

45

1.679

2.014

2.412

2.690

46

1.679

2.013

2.410

2.687

47

1.678

2.012

2.408

2.685

48

1.677

2.011

2.407

2.682

49

1.677

2.010

2.405

2.680

50

1.676

2.009

2.403

2.678

51

1.675

2.008

2.402

2.676

52

1.675

2.007

2.400

2.674

53

1.674

2.006

2.399

2.672

54

1.674

2.005

2.397

2.670

55

1.673

2.004

2.396

2.668

56

1.673

2.003

2.395

2.667

57

1.672

2.002

2.394

2.665

58

1.672

2.002

2.392

2.663

59

1.671

2.001

2.391

2.662

(28)

61

1.670

2.000

2.389

2.659

62

1.670

1.999

2.388

2.657

63

1.669

1.998

2.387

2.656

64

1.669

1.998

2.386

2.655

65

1.669

1.997

2.385

2.654

66

1.668

1.997

2.384

2.652

67

1.668

1.996

2.383

2.651

68

1.668

1.995

2.382

2.650

69

1.667

1.995

2.382

2.649

70

1.667

1.994

2.381

2.648

71

1.667

1.994

2.380

2.647

72

1.666

1.993

2.379

2.646

73

1.666

1.993

2.379

2.645

74

1.666

1.993

2.378

2.644

75

1.665

1.992

2.377

2.643

76

1.665

1.992

2.376

2.642

77

1.665

1.991

2.376

2.641

78

1.665

1.991

2.375

2.640

79

1.664

1.990

2.374

2.640

80

1.664

1.990

2.374

2.639

81

1.664

1.990

2.373

2.638

82

1.664

1.989

2.373

2.637

83

1.663

1.989

2.372

2.636

84

1.663

1.989

2.372

2.636

85

1.663

1.988

2.371

2.635

86

1.663

1.988

2.370

2.634

87

1.663

1.988

2.370

2.634

88

1.662

1.987

2.369

2.633

89

1.662

1.987

2.369

2.632

90

1.662

1.987

2.368

2.632

91

1.662

1.986

2.368

2.631

92

1.662

1.986

2.368

2.630

93

1.661

1.986

2.367

2.630

(29)

95

1.661

1.985

2.366

2.629

96

1.661

1.985

2.366

2.628

97

1.661

1.985

2.365

2.627

98

1.661

1.984

2.365

2.627

99

1.660

1.984

2.365

2.626

(30)

Responden

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1 ₄

₄

₅

₄

4

2

4

5

2 ₄

₅

₄

₅

₄

₅

₄

3

4

5

3

4

5

2

3

4

5

3

5

4

3

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

5

4

4 ₄

₄

₃

4

5

4

5

4

5

5 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₃

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

6 ₄

₄

₃

4

5

4

3

4

7 ₄

₅

₄

₅

₄

3

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

5

4

8

4

5

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

3

5

3

4

5

4

5

3

4

5

3

5

3

9 ₄

₄

2

3

4

3

4

2

4

5

10 ₅

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₅

₄

2

3

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

2

4

5

11 ₅

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

12

4

2

4

5

13

4

5

4

3

4

3

4

3

5

4

3

4

5

4

3

14 ₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

3

2

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

15 ₄

₄

3

4

3

4

3

4

16 ₄

₄

₅

₄

₃

₄

₅

2

3

4

3

5

3

4

5

3

4

17

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

5

4

3

18 ₄

₄

4

19 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

2

4

2

4

2

4

2

4

20 ₃

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

₅

3

4

3

5

4

3

4

3

5

3

4

3

21 ₅

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

22

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

23 ₅

₄

₅

₄

₃

₄

4

3

4

3

5

3

4

3

5

24 ₅

₅

₄

₅

₄

2

4

2

5

4

5

4

5

4

25 ₅

₅

₄

₅

₄

4

3

4

5

4

5

4

3

26

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

4 PROD (Y)

(31)

30 ₄

₄

₅

₄

3

2

4

3

2

4

5

31 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₅

₄

₃

₄

₅

4

3

4

2

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

32 ₅

₅

₄

₅

₄

₅

₄

3

2

4

3

2

5

4

5

3

4

33

3

4

5

3

4

5

3

4

2

4

3

4

5

3

4

5

34 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₃

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

35 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

4

5

4

3

4

5

36 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₃

4

3

4

3

4

37 ₄

₄

₂

₄

₃

₄

₃

3

2

4

5

4

2

4

2

4

2

4

5

4

5

38

4

3

4

3

2

5

3

5

2

5

3

5

2

5

3

39 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₅

₄

₃

5

4

3

5

4

3

5

4

3

40 ₄

₄

₃

₂

₃

₄

₃

₄

4

2

5

4

3

4

5

4

41 ₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

3

4

2

5

2

4

2

3

4

42

4

2

4

5

4

43

5

4

5

4

2

3

4

3

4

5

4

3

4

5

44 ₃

₄

₃

₄

2

4

2

3

4

3

4

45 ₃

₃

₄

₃

₄

3

4

3

4

3

4

46 ₄

₄

₃

₄

₃

2

3

4

5

2

5

2

4

2

3

4

5

4

47

4

3

4

3

4

3

2

4

5

4

3

4

2

4

5

4

48 ₃

₃

₄

₃

4

2

4

49 ₅

₄

₅

₄

₂

₄

4

5

4

5

4

5

4

50 ₃

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

₄

₃

₂

₄

4

2

5

2

4

2

5

4

51 ₃

₃

₄

₃

₄

₅

₂

₄

3

2

4

5

4

3

5

4

2

3

5

4

5

52

4

5

4

5

4

2

4

2

5

3

4

2

4

5

4

53 ₃

₃

₄

₃

₄

₅

₄

₅

₄

4

2

4

5

4

2

4

2

3

4

5

4

5

54 ₅

₄

₅

₄

5

4

5

4

5

4

55 ₄

₄

₃

₅

₄

₃

₅

4

3

5

4

3

5

4

3

56

4

3

4

5

4

3

5

4

3

5

4

3

5

4

57

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4

3

4