PART A: Editorial Office Only
SECTION I
PART B: Reviewer Only
SECTION II: Comments per Section of Manuscript
Basic Research Journal of Agricultural Science
and Review
www.basicresearchjournals.org
Reviewer’s Name: Dr. Henik
E-Mail: <hsukorini@yahoo.com> Manuscript Number: JASR-129-13
Title: In-Vitro evaluation of various homeo-fungicides and methanolic plant extracts against mycellial growth of Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. pisi
Authors: -
Date Sent To Reviewer: 24-09-2014
Date Expected From Reviewer:
01-10-2014
General comment:
1. Using simple sentences is better
2. The title was in vitro evaluation two types of fungicide, but in this research the author did separate evaluation, so the result was not comprehensive
3. For publish in this journal, this research was too preliminary research, it should added some
observations to more complete, i.e. hat the effect of fungicide against hyphae, what plant extracts content?
Introduction:
1. Using simple sentences is better
2. What methods for controlling F. oxysporum f,sp pisi so far?
3. Any methods don’t used fungicide? For example use plant extract?
4. Could the plant extracts work in other disease?
SECTION II (Cont.)
SECTION III - Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = F air) (4 = poor) Methodology:
1. The methodology was not detail, i.e plant preparation, fungicide preparation, etc
2. How to measure each variable? 3. What as control?
Results:
1. Table 1 and Fig 1 were same? 2. Table 2 and fig 2 were same?
Discussion:
Discussion part was for discussing the result not for rewrite the result, discuss and compare with other preliminary research.
Bibliography/References: The to write the references were not same with journal guideline
Others:
Decision: reject
Originality: 3
Contribution To The Field: 3
Technical Quality: 4
Clarity Of Presentation : 3
SECTION IV - Recommandation: (Kindly Mark With An X)
SECTION V: Additional Comments
Please add any additional comments (Including comments/suggestions regarding online supplementary materials, if any):
Accept As Is:
Requires Minor Corrections: Requires Moderate Revision: Requires Major Revision:
Submit To Another Publication Such As:
Reject On Grounds Of (Please Be Specific):
The research was too simple for publishing in this journal. Adding some variable
