Open Access Publisher
www.netjournals.org E-mail: njas@netjournals.org Net Journals © 2015
Net Journal of Agricultural Science
Reviewers Guide
PART A: Reviewers Information
SECTION I
Reviewer’s Name Henik Sukorini
E-mail hsukorini@yahoo.com
Institution University of Muhammadiyah Malang, Indonesia
Manuscript Number NJAS-2015-042
Title
EFFECT OF NEEM LEAF AND SEED POWDERS AGAINST ADULT MAIZE WEEVIL (Sitophilus zeamais
Motschulsky) MORTALITY Date Sent to Reviewer
Date Expected from Reviewer
Area of Specialization Plant extract, plant phatology
PART B: Reviewer evaluations
SECTION II: Comments per Section of Manuscript
General comment The manuscript was well organized
Introduction clear
Methodology
The methodology part should write clearly, expl: plant material collection and processing should mention about how much and how to make of it.
What instar that used?
Results
Neem seed and leaf neem powder should compared in one analysis, so the author can compare between both neem form.
What the mode of action of both?
Discussion Why seed and leaf are different impact? Are they have
different ingredient? Bibliography/References
Open Access Publisher
www.netjournals.org E-mail: njas@netjournals.org Net Journals © 2015
Decision Accepted with major revision
SECTION III - Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)
Originality 3
Contribution to the Field 3
Technical Quality 3
Clarity of Presentation 2
Depth of Research 4
SECTION IV - Recommendation: (Kindly mark with an X)
Accept as it is
Requires Minor Corrections Requires Moderate Revision
Requires Major Revision x
Submit to Another Publication such as
Reject on Grounds of (Please be Specific):
SECTION V: Additional Comments
