Analisa Perbandingan Kuat Sinyal antara Operator Hutchison, Indosat, Telkomsel, dan Xl Axiata dengan Menggunakan Software RF Signal Tracker di Area Jalan Protokol Pekanbaru

(1)

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

&& % & &

1 & " & 1 & "

2 3 =%7 # & "

-" $ # " & ,

-& & >0875 #

- & & & &

$ "

& & & " &

& 1 & " - " ' " & " # " & " & 1 1 & " # & " -# " " & 6: ; ! " # =%7 " %0' ; $ # >0875 ; " $ < 7 " " & " # " - " ' 1 " - # " " # & $ 2 & , 1 & # & - " " - " # & & " & & # 8 & && " " " -%" # & " & # " " " "

(2)

& #

&& & $ &

$% & $ '(

' & " $ '

& & & "

" & ( )!) $ 7 "

" (& $

" " " - & "

, " ' "

& " $ 1

& & " # &

" 7 " & $ ' " " - = )* +#7 " ' & $ ' % , " " & + 42,6 26 log 20 log 20; < )'!'

-# & & & " - " ) "

&& 1 & " - # " - " # $ # & $ # # " " & " " " ! ' " & >0875 && $ ; %0'< % " " %0' && 3ED" " 3 " $ %0' " %0' " - " ;% 1 " ( F - " - G< *'( +#% " % & % & ->0875 !'&$ " ! " ( = " 3( ≤C<3E 5 & 3)(≤C<3( ' 3 (≤C<3)( > 3 ≤C<3 ( ! " - & " # & " & 2 " , 4 " & & " - & - " 1 & " & # ; , $ *< ' & # # & " & 1 2 , ; %< $ 1 " # -& - " # " % " & & 2 " # # ; % <$ # ; % *) <$ 2 $ " - 7% ; < % : ; < " && ! - && " " - " # " % - # " 1 & & " " - 1 + $ # & # # & " 7 % " ; " , ! < " " & - # & -" - # & " $ , #

' (' &, % & & ,

' " " &

# " " &

&& & "

& ' & "

& # & " & "

(3)

* ' & " -" & $ " ' & " & & " & " # " , - . ' & " & " # " " ! ' & " & & - " & .% ' & " & & - " # " & ' * & ! " ( 8 " & # " " & # & - 3 - # & 1 & - " # = & " & " " & # " )* -#8 & 5 ' " & # ' ' ! , %' !$ " & , & , ' " $ # & " & " - # & 1 & 7 % " 2 & # ? - # & # " 1 & 8 " " # $ " # " 1 & 0875 7 % 8 1 # & " " " ;% ! $ < *'( -# ? % " " ' ' ! , !' ! , ' & )* ( ! ! " ( ' " - # &

& - & &

" " - -$ &&

" - " - " - # &

&- & # & && "

;" - < ; " $ < - " & # " - " -# & " & 8 " - " " " " " " $ # # & & # $ " -' " # & - " " " - " = * # & 1 , " ' $ # + 0 # 8 " 5- " A , 4 " " = 1 - 7 " 8 & 2 " % "

(4)

E )* .# ' & 8 % # " ' ' ' ' ! , ! , " ' 2 &-1 " && & $ ( - " - " & $ # + 4 % 4 ' &$( ! $% & - $ & -& " " & , - & " & $ ' " # , " " & " & - & & # # & " - " -' &$( ! ! - 1 # -& - " # & " - " - 4 # & " - " - # 8 - " " # " 1 " & $ " 1 , % - " # " $ - 1 # " - " & # 8 " & # $ " * & $ # + • " 3 # $ • " " " " # $ • = 2 # " # ( ! ( $!$,$( ', * ' & - " ' & " " 1 & 1 ' 5" 1 # & -" " - + • 0 # 8 0 # 8 " * & " # • " 5 A 0 # 8 " * & " # • 4 " 0 # 8 " * & " # • = 1 - 7 " 0 # 8 " * & " # • 8 & 0 # 8 " * & " # • " % " 0 # 8 " * & " # - 1 $ - " 1 " " - " = E

(5)

-120 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 d B m

(a) Jalan Cut Nyak Dien

Hutchison Indosat Telkomsel XL Axiata -120 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 d B m

(b) Jalan Jend. A. Yani

Hutchison Indosat Telkomsel XL Axiata -105 -95 -85 -75 -65 -55 -45 ₁ ₂ ₃ ₄ ₅ d B m

(c) Jalan Ir. H. Juanda

Hutchison Indosat Telkomsel XL Axiata -90 -80 -70 -60 -50 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 d B m

(d) Jalan Gajah Mada

Hutchison Indosat Telkomsel XL Axiata

(6)

B )* /#= 2 4 8 ? " ' ' ' * & ( ! 0 ! ! " ( ' " & # " " & , & 3 # " - " 4 1 " - " # & # ' & 3 " - " 3 # " - " - & 3 $ " - # & # 1 3 # " " -% - 3 " - $ # " - $ - & 3 # " 1 ' 3 ' * & ! 0 ! ( $!$,$( ', * * - 3 # " 1 ' -110 -100 -90 -80 -70 -60 -50 -40 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 d B m (d) Jalan Diponegoro Hutchison Indosat Telkomsel XL Axiata -115 -105 -95 -85 -75 -65 -55 -45 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 d B m

(f) Jalan Jend. Sudirman

Hutchison Indosat Telkomsel XL Axiata

(7)

D *'( .# 3 % # " ' ' %' !$ $, ( ! 0 ! ! " ( 1 )2 ! " , ' ' # # # # 3 %$ '&$ $ ) 4 ,- 3D $) * 3DD$ B 3D 3DD$ (B 3D $D** 3B($) " 3(* 3(( 3(D$E 3D*$ D 3(($*** 3)E$D** 3B($(EB 3 D 3 ($B 3D $ E* 3B $B 3 ($( C: 56 3B*$EB 3D $ 3 D 3DE$ E* 3B $ ** 3BD$ () ! " ( ' * , # "

-" & , &- & 3

# , - E 7 - " *'( /# 3 ? " ' ' %' !$ ( ! 0 ! $! ( 1 )2 4 ,- 3DE$E " 3( $(E 3B $** C: 56 3BB$* * " E " " # " - " & 3B $** " & " - " - " " & 3( $E 4# ' )% ( 4 " & # " 1 $ # & # & " & 3B $** " $ # & # " " - C: 56 " & 3BB$* * " $ # # & & " - 4

,-" & 3DE$E " " # &

# " -" - " " & 3( " 1 # " 1 & " " " " % " & & $ " 1 # " & - -" - - && 1 & 5 % ' ) ' & , -" 8 A - # $ % $ 7 " 5 - % $ 7

& # & - & - "

&

- " " " &

# & - " & "

- "

- / ) = % & && & "

3 5 & ) # & - # " 6 " $ > -# $ ( 5 ' # 1 " # = & ' " & *= " 7 ;% " 0 "< ' , % 1 $ & " $ $ & % -% # $ "

(8)

( , $ "# " % $ % " % $ : ?$ * 5 ' 2 & *= % " " " & ' , % 1 $ $ " : - $ " & 3 & : ' = & 5 - +HH!!! , " , H" ,H (( B B)BH & 3 & 3: 3 ' 3= & I EJ % ! $ 8 #$ 5 + 1 " ' , % $ + 8 " ' " $