! "# $
" " %" & ' & ( )*
+) , $ - - " $ "
./ 0
12 3 4 5 &# 4 6 &2 % 6
...
8 .
"0 0 20 & - 9 0 "0 & ( )*
$ 0 : ; 0 <0 =
>
*? $& 6 ; ' - ;@ A * )6 " >B ( 6
+ ) 2 $ " - ; - $
. 0 ', C: & ( " &&D4
E B FG4 " )*
0 +6 0 ' 0G $0 % 6
=(04 "0 0
209 06
2&
E H ! (4 ' ' - ) 2 +) $ 2 FG 6
.
./
/ ' - /
& ( / 12
! ! " #
.
Email : habdolah@chamran.ut.ac.ir
!"#…
$%& '(') *
"# $ "J ,
12 "G ' & ! ,
B 6
@ ' E
"0 9 0 K 0L 0& - 0 % 2 0 2 6
M0
.
& ( ) -/ -
./
NB : G "O
& E .
& (
0 0 0 & 0 C O +2&
2 & - 9 & ( & G " 9 ' &9 & ; ./
A P
&
.
"6 6 QRST UT
. 0P 0 0 G*4 9 V ? (&
H $ A " W 6 % K > 2 & - 9 & (
0 ' & (
6 :! X Y ./
. 0&&D4 0 9 $0 10P Z
1 " " C & 6[
) - ]4 0^ ', _ C0 "0 0 & 8 "
0 &9 ) , 0
( 0 4 0& ( 0& 1G0 a 0 ?
b >0 "0
"6 6 QRUT " (&
; .
"0 0 $0 1 E 6 ; ; $ A/ B4 A *4
B H & " 3 A ^ 4 ^ Z . Z c " $& W
,
& 9 +6 " "
d O0 0 B A 0 % 0 # $&0 eO0 0 ( 6
" A P ) &#
.
) G "G , ( 1P Z )0 - f 0 "0W !0&9
… ) (
&? ) - f "W )
0: 6 A ^ 4
(…
804
2&
)
%' &) # QgSU (
- 0P ; ) & 1G h
i 6 h
.
&9 +) . P 4 &&D4 $& W . "
0 C0& 0 6 :
2 & ( " " 4 –
0 0: 6 6 ; & h - 2
.
$0 0& 4 0
. Rationality . Reasoning . Positivisty . Pluraty . Tolerance . Mannheim
+
' & : 6 6 ; & & 4 3 " 1P $ $ $ NB
"0 4 +) : W " M9 k B4 - %h ' & ) 2
)* "
" W & ( )
"
( $ .
!"#$%& !'
' 0 " & ( ./ . P &&D4 " l2 $&& 4 " $ 0 " 9 h ) 2 ' & : * Y : :W ', "O 0
. X0E
./ > " "# $ 0 6[ 6 +2& G m ' " & (
" 2 : 0) , - & : 6 A &&D4 " " 4 ) 2 "
; * : * k L - n 4 .
>0 0& ( ./ 0 $&0 J 6
* 0 . 0P % ) 2 " 4 A L 4
0Y 0) , - ;
. 0 4 *2 8 ] P & ( "Y&
"0 ' 0 "0 0 06
$ G&4 6 + "W 2 & - 9 + "W ', O
. " & ( # *2 > 1 " ', "# $ $&#
G
"! $ H " 1G ; - 2 )4 ) &
"
.
; 1 4 ;- 4 P & ( ./ % c $ -
) 20 "
' )
' ' -
(
; & "
E ) 2 n 4 ) , & 4 04
"
G
).
%f 6
QgUQ % opq r oQS
)(
Q
0 "0 10&# $&0 6 "0 (
', ( 6 )
) %; :!
(…
80 s # G4 ) !0&9 0 "
#/ &E( A E ) 2 ' ' - : 6 ' 4 "G
1G ) , m & ( ; &
&
.
"0 $ 09 % 0 "0 " $ "# $ :
%', t, 8 s # G4 " 4 eO )
C 9 ' - " O , ; *
( :
. Parsons
… , !"#
$%& '(') *
2&
.
#/ 0 0&E( A 0E 0 % " B "G
F " ', ) 2 2 & ( . P " "
.
0& ( V 0 8&G!04 " $ -/ $ A t
)u 4
v
; 0 "0 ;- 0Z " c " ) 2 $ %(
; ', " %" &
. 0 ' - 09 " c & % ) 2 $ $ - G
c "
'( "
Woodiwiss, 1990) (
' 0& 0 6[ 06 " & - ' +& : )
'( 6 " c " _ G4 ' G*
.
% : A "
. 0 $0 " u 9 c " '( " c Z L &
; ) 2 ' %' - % X W "
) 20 - %' 0
… 0 (
. 2G
0 w 0B 0 & ( )* " e&^ 4 x
"
$ 9 G ', " )* y 8 " &
» 1 « ', 0t,
»
& ( « ; .
"6 c ) 2 $ "G&# Z 6
QRST QRUT (&
8&G*4 ;
" " % +6 $
0 " c " $ | - "
) '( " c (
; &9 !& & ! %X )4 *4 $&& 4 .
"0 0 & 0 )G&G!04 $0 "0& ' - "G +) Y "J ,
0c }E % & ( > $ : ~ 4 )*
"0 1G0 +20& 209
.
"06 20 & - 9 &? *& ) A c : A "
06 QRoT
QRST 0 ; 0 6 0 0 0&# 4 G&4 0 6 = c ;- Z "J ,
" $ & . P )
0) , ' 6 O4 ' O
( -
K(
] ' : [
"06 06 QRUT QRRT 0 !0& (&0
XE " 4
Baumann, 1992) . (
06 & 0 Z "0 " & ! $& W +2& 29 W Y . l ' 0& 2 1 4 8 " $ u 9 x " .C#C "
. Fairkluff . Foucault
-
" & ( ) & 1G
u 04 ; 0 6 ; 0 0) , 0G : 6
; ' .
+ 0Z 0& ( " y~! ' 4 ; :J&6 : A "
! )
! " & ( (
1G0 B H
$&0 0 0) &
hG #
Baumann, 1992) . (
6 "0 XE ' 29 "
$&0
; " & " + }E 1}
.
0 C0 ' 0 " " c ', }Z & ( " l2
"06 $6 f 4 Z " & 6 , 6 ; 9 +)
QRoT
0) 9 # 04 "0 0 0 ) $ W (&
0) 9 &!0
E + !&9 3 ? ) 9 Y
Babbie, 2001) .(
0 0 ; 0 , 0FG 0& ( "0 "0 20 ' f 6 "! "G&# Z [ ', )
%f 6
QgUQ (
0 ' ! ' : - A *
06
& ( $ ) 9 ' - * "
- . 0& ( 0: A 0 "
6 " !
<2 6 , ! - K L 4
', 0) 9 %+0 80 0 0 0& 1G0 "G , "Y&
- " K L & " & ( "G 0 10
0 .
; 0
' B W + 8 ' )
"0 0O , "0 2& + ', !&9 4
$6
• + ) 9 ] P ' B $
6 .
"0 0O , . 0F
i &
'- ' G* 0 )
QRRS (
"06 6 :!0
UT RT
; ' !0
% 0
+) f 0 ;- Z ;@ " - & ( $ : ; L "
+0 f 0 &&D4 ' - " C&W ' 6 $ c Y4 " - &
', - ' 0 209 0 " ' B4 $ : - ; d O
)
%$
QRRv .(
;- Z !&9 $& W
0 0 0 &2 "
(Babbie, 2001)
.
+&0 0 A &*! " ;- Z C 6 $G
.
"0
. Fleming
!"#…
$%& '(') *
; 9 : A
10 E 0&? . &0 >0 0 0 ;- 0Z " n 6
5&9
0 0&9 !0 6[ }E . P - C 6 " &
0 .
0 ; 0 = W - ' &# " & " " G! ' 6 $ .
"0 +06 0 "0 %"0 & ' +2 & - 9 - ‚4 " : A "
0 0 6 ; 9 + Z $& E ƒ! " ] " 6
% 0& Y
P )# $ 4 #
" ; $ 5 - 9 " c „
$& 0E ƒ!0 "
&
.
"0 "0 6 ](F0 h 0 - "0&# ' 0
0 % +&0
04 "0
"
C 9 1F ' # ) i - '
%
* -/
C & %
08 "
0 10… E 0 5 0 ; 0 .
d 0O ~ 04 0 $& 4 ' E ~ 4 <# E $ h
"
" 4 <# E ', ) i - „'
A 0 '
0 d O " 4 &2 $ 9 M9 V 2 .
A 0 # O ;- 0Z 0 0
"6 : 6 6
QRUT QRRT 0& 0& >0 0 "0 "
0
; 00 ; 00 00 00 5 00 006 ~ 004 00 >00 E
00
Raboy, 1991 ; Sayer, 1998) (.
) (4 C& " & ' " " * 80&4 & 6 0 %4
0 5
& &2 K(
}0E - 0 20 +6 Z 6
" : 6 "&# "
' 0 6 & 1G $&& 4 ](F "
. Marx . Weber . Durkheim . Parsons . Lazarsfeld . Mills 0. Frank 4. Dilthay 5. Hermeneutics
6. Cousality
.
h ;
t 0 " L $&& 4 CZ : 2 Z " A *4 $
Weber 1978) (
!&9 "G ( 1P Z 1G!0 W " & "
]4 $ ;
a 0 5&9 "
; 0 "0 & 0 "0 06
& ( >
. 0 0 a 0* 0& ( "G .
$&0 "0G 0:
1 t ' " & ( )
0 1&G!4 ' 2 6 "
06 (
C 0 4 10 0
1… E .
V Y 8&G!4 $ 0 +0 !0&9 0 ; e&0^ 4 "
&&D4 " :W & ( A * " " 4 0 "W M9 &&D4 $& W 6
< L )! + ;- Z '- ' & : * -
.
( )*+ ,
$
E !&9 & (
$
& 1G 2 & ( . F % & ( > # "
"0 6
; 1 4 ) B
.
"0 0& ( "0 0 $ Y a $&#
00 "00 00 ; ', - 00 "00 00 00 006 00
+00 , 00
(Schwandt, 1997, 132)
) 2 C: 2 A !&9 6 + )
%
00 $6 00 "00 00O , 00 !00&9 00 + M00| 00 Z C: 00 00
† +) 1P $ % ) 9
& ( ) 9 &&D4
$
(
2& t > ~ 4 3 X 4 &
(Mannheim, 1972)
C&W + ) c ^ Z NB A *4 :
. ( - " Y4 ' : M t " Y4 X 4 & ( "G , ) 2
+&
.
(
' - 3 " 3 X 4 ) 2 )* "G
: 20
)6 "
.
%"0 & ; 0 "0 0: A "
. Lived Experience
… ./
!"#
$%& '(') *
' 0 - ' 0 ' 9 % ) C ) C 9 " - ] ) 2
) ' 0
' 29 ( 1&G!4 E h $ > X 4 ) 2 )* ' "G&# Z
.
"
$ ' &
' - % 4 QR
' - - "#
vv 0 0 Z 206 A 0* "#
120 ' 0 6 ' 12 6 ' - : K L - 12 8 " k
4 * ' 1 4 ' &! ; &
) .
%' &) # Qgop (
)# !6 @9 6 " f Qgop
Qgoq 0 >4 ; "
+ 0
; , : 6 ) &# " ] >4 ' ) 2 "
w 0B# "0 " W
" " + & ( - ' 6 A W
0 " " &
" , .
)# # QgSS
QgSU "0 % 0 0G4 A 0 # O ' 6 " 2
"
4 A * 6
./ 0 . Z + 9 ' 29 ' ) 2 ' & 1
1G . Z & ( - 4 * 6 " $& W W " +&
&
.
$&0 6 0
0 9 "0 9 0 4 0 0 !0&9 "0 0 0 ' 04 0 0 O ˆ &
2 & ( ) 2& G .
)! 9 "
' 0 - 0: i &
"
) !0&9 "0 % +0 ' ) " - & ( }Z ; f ; & Y ' - 3 4 - 9 " c ;- Z .
( ! -. *, */
" " * ]( E " O 6
h &c
) QRRT ( ' 0B "
"
" c
' ! ; ^ Z ' - 9
)! " 6
2G#
) QRUv ( C & % ) QRUq ( Y , ) QRUo ( 0 "0 c _ !0 "0 ] ) C&
; & Y &
.
$ ) QRRv (
" 9 ; W
29 '
h #
) QRRT ( - 09 "0 c . 0P &&D4 " ] P
. Woodiwiss . Alexander . Giddens . Unger
.
" ' B " ; ' 29 ;
- 9 .
& 4
" : &&D4 " }E " $ "# $
"
:
Q . W
1G :
&
6
v .
6 & '
g .
$& 4
1G
&
6
p .
A/ B4 O O4 '
q .
2 - ' & D
r
"0 c 0 9 0 0: 6
0 & 0E 10P ' ) +) C
. ' <0&4 4 $ 0
$&& 4
1G
&
' 9 6
.
" - 6 " $ c 1}
0 "0 M0 ' B '
"0 }E $ 4 ;s 9
0 ; &0 0Y "0 ' 0 209 0 .
" ~ 4 O $
06 ] 0P 0 G4 " &
0) , M09 10 4 ' G " d O 0& "0 "0 4 0
0& ( 06
P )
1 +) -
( +6 . 0Y 0 ( 1&# $& 6 "
2& d O .
" " & ‚4 3 "G - 0 "0 ~0 9 "0 &
1G0 i0 6 " & & 6 1F P )! 9
0&
0 06
" "G 0 0 " ] P C& ' 29
0 - 9 )
%A 0) :
QgSR .(
0 $ " " m 9 }E " " 4 "# $ $ & ‚4 1G0 0 , $ % " " H "! & ( "
0&
06
~ C& ' P '
; 6 ! .
1G $ >
0&
06
& 6 :
Q .
"
1G G C& 6
&
6 v
.
"
C0 6
1G 6[
&
6 .
" " E Y
06 "0 &
1G H
> E 3 X 4 &
Mclellan, 1990) .(
6
" f
" " k 0 h 0 6 & ( " &
0 &
.
. Lack of Determinism
… .0 !"#
$%& '(') *
1G00 00 6[ 006 "00 <00&4 4 $ 00 00&
"00 00& 500 00) 4 "00 006
)
$& 4 &?
"
(
" $ "G % 1&G!4 & ( ' 6 6[ 6
"0 6
"cB# 6 E ' ' & "O
. 1G0 f 0 $0 0 0&
06
;- 0 ', "0 &20 20 0& ( " > E 3 X 4 4 6 . . Z 0 & 6 ' 0 J , 0& ( " l2 ^ Z . Z W " . ' 4
" "
.
E
0 4 0 $0 - 0 Z 0&
d O
u0 9 x Z L }E " ,
; 0 +6 Z 4 *& ) ' L +2& &
0 . 0&# 0 ' !0
" " " & ' & ( " 6 , 0 0& A 6 ‰
20& 0 $& 0E X 4 ' "G ', 1 ? : & ( H 8 -
0 ' 0 0 0 & - 9 " c ' - M#
Babbie, 2001) .(
1G " ; ' ! & % &# " c f
&
» « - 0 ' 0
& ( 8 ] P %+6 ' +2& G - " w B M
- 0 + Z 6
; 1 ? '
. 0) - & 0 4 0* ]( 0 " Y4 ' c "
"0 )!0 $ C& , E &? * ) - . " !&
) - ) 2 ) , - &
- 0 0B ' 0: "0 8 "
E ' .
G ' 29 "G&# Z
!0 ; 0B C0& , E E &
E
- , . - 1E 0Z 20 A "G&# Z <&4 4 $
; ' H
"0 0 + 0Z „ M0 & ( % 0
; 1 ? 1P $ - " &
6 ! " 4 6 " " Y4 . " $& J 6 A $ . "
0G - 0Z : 6 " ' )
0 0 M0 0 ? 0& ( 0&
; 9
+ % ; 6
80 ' 0 !0 +) FG4 " l2 +
. Janet Lever
.
1 ) 6 ! - "
(
"0 " 0 4 ; ; * V ', -
0 0
; G ; *
" & +6 " 4 ] L (
" M "
)
% &
QgoQ (
"6 QRRT
0 "0 0 0 "0 G (&
1G
A # O 4 &
0 6 :! " : 6 .
A 0 # O $0
' ! 0 $&& 4 & ( H ! A !&9 " 6
0
X . E E A V Y4
+ 0Z 0& ( 0 "0 0
5
" 6
&9 O & ! c )
%A 0) : QgSR
.(
"6 <&4 4 $ QRRT
0P 0P ' ) 2 &2 % ) & E ; NB
0 $0 "0 0 0E "0 4 & ( i 6 ; 6 1G ; -
; XE c C& ) 2 &2 #/ 6[ )4 *4
.
( 0 1 *2 . %& !' !"#
3 (04
0 # 5
0)* ;- 0Z )!0 $ 0 , ' 0 0Y
E ; & (
&
.
' ! #
0G*4 0 0 - " V ? "*2 6
, r
"0 h
"0 & 0 r
"0 ; 0#, : 0
; & ( &? & ( .
' ! 0 "0 ]4 0 0& ( "0 06
; ; 2 '- " ]4 & ( &?
.
"*20 !0&9 )* "G , <#
00 ; 00 00 "00 „ 00& ( "00 "00 - „ 00& ( 00&? - 00 Z V 00?
(Lioyd, 1995)
. 1G " l2 $
"0 c ;- 0Z "0 L 0c 0 Y4 0G*4 &
; &!0 5# 0W " & ( ; NB " " * +&
; . 06 "0 "J , k L " $ $ 0 f 0
0 :
„H 0 A 0P $0 % , . # Z " ' ) # Z - & ( 4 6 • *
. Lioyd
… . !"#
$%& '(') *
) 2 ' ' - $& ' *
20 0& ( 0 = M09 0 +06 A *
& 1G ', FG4 .
1G " Y -
./ 0 $& "O &
M9 ' G ( : * k L - 2 2 M9 , & (
.
1G & ‚4
" c $& W &
" "
4 & B4 6 - "0
)# 0 QgSq
' 0 - ' 0 ) 20 . 0 !0 "0 0: 6 ; 0 0Y ' 0 "
'
; G* G 6
)
%' }04 ' &) # QgSS
‰ 0 Š
; -
' # L SU QgSS .(
h& &
' ! ' ) ƒ ~ n A & B4
& ( " 6
&?
% 0 0 ' 0) &20 &t 04 "0J , "0 ˆ(0L 10 E : & ( . 0 1&# 0 0 "0 "0 0 !# W - Z ~ $
a 0 4 $& W - $ 1G ; • & ( „ 2 2 ;
0 "&Z - ./ & ( = M9 6 !# W
h 0 A 0* ) 2
.
) 20 G* 0 A/ 6 : * " ) $ -
h
06 : * % 0& ( „. 20 „ 0& k 4 - h9 4
2 –
0 + " + !&9 " A !&9 " 2
b "
8
(Rooney, 1994) .
5 ! -* #
; 0 0&9 0 "0 0& ( - FG † " Y , -
h 0 $0 f 0 0 C& : * Y & ( - ; * ./ +2& G
; &&D4 .
"0 0 0 0c =(04 80 ] 0P "… "# $ " "J , 06
0& ( ) 20 0& ( N0B " - $ 4 ' " 56 @9
. Phyllis Rooney
.+
4 & B4 Y !:6 &2
A 0^ 4 0 20 K G0 "0 0 0 4
P & & E 8 &2
.
0& ( ' 6 " &2 A ^ 4 K G $ "! +) ' A 0*
2 $& 2 $&
1G : :W ' 4
&
"0 6
$&& 4 P .
„ 0& ( 0)* $ a * ' " W
0&# 4 - 0 "0 0P 0P „ 2 &2 A ^ 4 $&& 4 5 % O 6 " c ' 6 Y
; & ' B " " - "
0 .
# 0Z
"0 0 }0E 0 ; ) 4 " & ( )* "
- " &
$ 0 a * c 2 $ - ‰ ' G "G M
+6 C& FG 1 4 .
6 (,
) Q (
f 6
5 0 0 * ' 0 0 - " & ( ' "
n 0&D "0 "0 + 0 10P $0 = M09 $ ^ C& "
M09 0&&D4 M0# CY 1 1P " ', t " - & (
./ 0 +20& G = 0 0 0 0 $ ;
: * X
. ' 0 ; C0 0 0P ' 0 & ( ](F
' 0 ~ 04 M0 & ( " N ' G* ' - #/ & 6[
" ^ .
) v (
- 0& ( - 0 ) " )* u 4 & (
; ; " 1:6 A 4 O ' - .
$0 "0 0 0& (
h 0 0 120 % ~ 4 3 X 4 ' ) - +) " ; ; "
(Lioyd, 1995)
… ., !"#
$%& '(') *
78 4
# %A ) :
) QgSR (
%
!)*+ , (! 49 ( 4:*) % ;<
+ 0 " 4 %
' )4% ! % 4
.
‰
; - ) QgSS (
%
»
= 0:
0 06
0 06
0 )4 ' 0
«
"0 %
%56 @9 v
; %
S U A B*P % QvT
r QTq
% & 00 )
QgoQ (
$
(>>' 46 ?*>>6
i 6 !00 % 6 + G# 00 "00 4 %
' )4 % ( .
& Z % ' &) # )
Qgop (
%
»
V 0 ; :! - ' " # O
« 0Z %
' )4 %' )& "2 ‹ G 5Y .
# 00 ' }004 00 00& Z% ' &) )
QgSS (
%
»
"200 "00 # O 100
1
- ' 0 0 )0 : f ' ~ t‹
$&00 ; :!00 )# 00 V 00 00 #
So SS 00 Š - 00 00)* 200
A &&D4 : 6
« 0 i0 6 A - % 0: 6 A & B4 A # O C %
' )4 % ( .
$ %K(
) QgSR (
%
!"# - ! @ ;<
' 0&9 " 20 "0 L "0 4 %
' )4 %' G 6 :
" A & B4 A # O C 6
.
h / %' ) )
QgUQ ( -
A0 0, < A0
%' 0G 6 ' & " 4 %
' )4 % !
.
^ B % ' # L
) QgSU (
%
»
;
6M0 M09 " ; :! %
«
%
>
( ! B
; %
Qg
A B*P %' 2 4 ) %
qp 0 vS .
" s % # )
QgSU (
%
»
1:6 4 A - 1 )*
«
% 0) "0 B "0 4 %
; %' ?
Qq A B*P %C&… 9 % QgS
r QoU .
.-
$ %f 6
) QgUQ (
%
' "0 ) . (!) *8 :
*D
*D @8 (2 <
– '
%' 0) h / %" &! $&2Z " 4 % ;
» 209 04 +20& -
+2&
« ' )4 % ! %' G 6 ' & " 4 % .
Babbie, Earl (2001),The Practice of Social Research, Belmount, Wadsworth.
Baumann, Z.(1992)Intimations of Postmodernity, London: Routledge.
Fleming, Marie (1997), Emancipation and Illusion : Rationality and Gender in Habernas’s Theory of Modernnity, University park, Pennsylvania State University Press.
Lenski, Gerhard & Patrick, Nolan, Jean Lanski (1975), Human Societies NewYork, MC Graw-hill Inc.
Lioyd, Genevieve (1995), The Man of Reason; Male and Female in Western Philosophy, New York, Routledge.
Mannheim, Karl (1972), Essays on the Sociology of knowledge, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul ltd. Fifth Edition, Chapter VII, 279-320.
McLellan, David (1990), Karl Marx: Selected Writings, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Raboy Marc, et.al (1991), “Cultural Development and the Open Economy” Canadia Journal of Comnunication, Vol. 19, 1997, pp.29-3.5
Sayer, Andrew (1998), “Critical and Uncritical Cultural Turns” in www.comp.lancs.ac.uk/sociology/soco17as.html.
Schwandt, Thomas A. (1997), “Qualitative Inquiry”, Thousand Oaks : Sage Publications.
Rooney, Phyllis (1994), “Recent Work in Feminist Discussion of Reason”, American Philosophical Quarterly, Jan. Vol. 31, no. 1, p1 (21).
Weber, Max (1978), Economy and Society, Berkeley: University of California Press, vol. 1 & 2.
Woodiwiss, Anthony (1990), Social Theory after Post–Modernism,
London Pluto Press.
