:
! " #$ $ %$
! " #$ % )
: 27 / 10 / 1388 - :
15 / 1 / 1391 (
&
:
# () * + , !- . /# 0 1* ( # 2
. 3 4 * 5
6 .
* 8 *9 # : ;
< 2 = < 2 - (> %?- !- 62 * @ A" * *
6 6 ! # :2 * B - * 4# ; * # 6# * C*
. : DE F G
5 C . H 4I * !-
3 J=K 5 C !- :2 L ; @ A" * * #
5 < ) . - 3
- I A" * # M D 3 5 2 $ 2 N !- L
* -. - 53 4 * O P - 8 # # 8* > * E 5N
! . 6 *
) Q9R # L * E 5 C * (
5+ , S* *
T U- 6 DK
8 4
...
6 V ; > < ! V2 - . * . ! # :2 * .
>
* " 8 C * # WX Y !- 6=V N2Z = [L- * # * 2 ;
6 .
B\
:
+ , 5 2 E; * 5 # () 5W 56 . - 5 5O* G # N X .
: 02612507762 Email:[email protected]
! "# $ %&'#
(
# ) *+$ ,- . /- %01 $ ! 23 4 51 .
78 $ ( 9:'# $ ; <=+ > ?% .# 04 @%'=/+ A0#
$ *BC 8 B C $ BD )! ;
.1 E ,+ >"3 1 @ ( # .F G8 .#*0,1 H I -
.
*BC 8 $ H BI @B JBKC L=8
4 M 'N%OP
* ) D*B- %&'B# B4 Q%:BI BR 4 @%LG $ .C S T3 C >4 U +
.*- 4 ) 4 *04 (
.1 L- >4 V W4 .'O% 1 - >'?D )! E 4 >X Y > $
Z [ JY 4
@/#
) ( *+ R!
1387 : 144
.(
%]^B $ B?% .B# ; K+ %"_ E & [ $ %LY >4 K+
BY %&'B# `4 Ba $ ; B,?1 .B# 4 ( BC - + # >b LN1 c 1 *8 d_ + 9+
) .8 T3 ; K+ $ .=%"_
) '="&+ $
1
# $ a1
.
>B4 %B"_ B 3 B# ., *B4
# $ L#
>BY D %01 .F 0[ # %# e '=D *1 %_ > W%1! ,8 Y # %# f /g
# %R
) (.+ ,?I *%#
1388 : 423
hi B?1 $ j =BO1 ) + B8 *BT $ H L[ $ # k (
@B
$ e 90 >4 d_ + l 0'[ %+ *[ 1 ( & # 1 m En $ >4 o R
$ WB L
.T%Op 9 $ f /g
# .F W[ b *C ; K+ %"_ %b N E 3 >4 .
>BN1 [ .F =BLY
.# ; K+ ) .1 ,g >4 q D .+ ,[
) ( -!
1375 : 49
)! BL+ E BLY ) '="&+ > (
*L"8 - mB @B %B"_ BY %&'B# 4 J 3 `4 a $ c g T1 *- [ 1 (E*
8 ."R c T1 4 >= T1 r a 1
%D . M B# # WB%+ .1sB# .# ; K+ >90 4 t G1
# .1 ,g ; K+ k
) ) LY : 34
.(
Mu$ >B B# @B Ba 3 'B- + ."BI q# _ (
$ ; B,?1
v =%X .=%"_ %&'# 2 1 M %+ ]
( .8 BT3 ; BK+ $ )! B4 J B3 c T1$ `4 a
v =%X 6 2. 8 K C - =# %< ], :2 :
1 - '#
# .F G8 '# ) 4 J,'1 ! "# ; ,?1 >4 .=%"_ %&
.
2 -
%B"_ wB%8 .+ B1 $*B:1 $ ; , h u .O' xs4 ( $ >4 .b I h# ;*C
# $ L"8 @ .8 T3 ; K+ $ c 'm1 .F G8 w%8 4 >= T1 .
1 .
*+ B- .1 l =:1 E 3 k Wb$ $ %"&+
. B%O B%+ ' 4 *0" 9B# E BLY >B4 $ @B Great Britain/
h%9mB
.1
*0Y . .Y - _ ><%'+ (.b L- *0b .0N J%0 > a & E 3 D
$ B%O %+ ' 4 *:'1 .b LB- *B0b
united /
kingdom of Great Britain and northern irland 4 *Y R
.
1 -
1 - 1 .
$ ."BI *1 %_
B# .+ + B8 B%y %&'B# B4 4 B L3 ( ! 2B3 .B# # .
# 0N1 @ *4 ! (S T3 z b 0%1 :
(.D 4 . Y O
.Na$ .1 LC c *8 4 j
(*mB *+ *BY R >B9+ 0X $! hBLC >B4 BR >B8sR c *B8 *B+ '4 .1 ! > *0 D
>m *+
# >
.1
*m/4 hLC c I *+
...
. B# c OC ! ; =8 :
( =B/+
.# %# Y ! Z
;$
(
; # .1 LC , !
$ Z , !
) ( $ &0b ?N[
1386 ( H$ *"[
:
78 (
1 - 2 .
!"#
l Yf$ l ! ( Y ! r + .9 /
)! B[ 1 >B4 >B B# *1!$
) =+
$ *0 ) 91 hT+ *Y /4 > [ Y >4 23
@ m+ $ 7+ 1 .= *1!$
.
E*+ R hT0b { g 3 )! I N1 ) .1 Y ()! [ 1 >4 $ *+
>4 m hR *+
$ $ 4 *Y /4 > [ Y
*B0 *1! $ m | R >4 $ *+ L4
) ) BLY : 88
.(
$ B !
*1!
}/- )! [ 1 >4 > # ) =+ Y @ %04 $ .N%OP S T3
*B 4
$ B
(*B1!
$ *- 4 ! m | R >X $ m >X >pT+ Y ~ $ 1 8 h%b )$*4 w%8
$ ) 1
*+ L4 • ?:1 .
.8 * B1 @B ! > # .1 =8 *[ $ R W%+ ! r + @
# )!
) ( %+ .F 8!
1386 : 137
.(
1 - 3 .
# d_ $*:1 w"'/1 S P >4 @ ! .
) BX .b 9B- >B4 )! hB1 "# .Y D
( "[ ( %&'#
.F B4 ; ! $ € B?'R ( OB3 (.+ + B8 %y .+ + 8 JC - 4 $ w%8
L+ R .1 . O[ 1 8 (*%NO q- _ )! h1 "# )$*4 @ ! * *: E D $ *0
.1 Y U @%N1 h:1 1 8 701 -
.
; =8 .9 > %&'# M I a 3 qY$n_
@ ! "#
( # .1 8 e 90 r a 1
%D .
1 - 4 .
!& ' ( ) *+ , - ./0 3 ! "# >4 ; <1 J,g'1 @' D .0N %&'#
) ) BLY ( $ &0b ?N[
: 1906
.(
>4 m1 0N1 (
B0N1 >B4 %&'#
: 1 - BO[ ) B %D B"[ B @' BD Z
2 - B @' BD
1 B,g >B4 q0B $ .+ + B8 B%'R >pB# $ >B4 q BR `g"= : *,&+
. .BF W[
) garner,2004:115
.(
"[ hT'=1 .? N *[ $ %&'# ) + *8 T3 b y E &+ .3spI K+
$ E O+
"y
*L"8 t '1 •spI $ @ E
1*+
.1
a 3 ‚:4 ) 4 . i / ,[ >4 @9%b
$ .1 (@%m%_ ; ,?1 $ &+ ) =9 ) 91 ;*C B[ 1 >B4 > .+! .1 *8 %&'# )
1 [ >4 J,g'1 ) 0K1 @ )!
. E %B- >4 w0C >4 $ 8 1 P >4 .B9 W%
) MsƒB1 E ?'B#
#
*04 ( .+ + 8 pR 4 /
.B1 "# = pR B-
( B- &+
. .b B3 B"[ >B
Mu I 4
* (.F G8 ; T1 '# >4 4
#
>"%
;*BC $ J,g'1 G3 >4 S O=1 $ '=D @%p4 a
$ >b >4 )$ T1 $ g T1 8$ $ >i[ 1 %y G3
$ @F 8
$ B%D c BI . c 1
0ƒ'# 1
%LY >[ .4 ='+ EW4 > .
$ h5B- 1 8 h:1 $ E 4 R 4 u
$
=%+ @i%N1 $ ; "N1 J,'1 = Z
# 7+ 1s4 $ "[ M $*4 .
.1 . OC >4 B"[ ?D )
.B1 B[ `4 Ba 1^B1 2B P >B B# . GB8 ; BT1 'B# >B4 %&'# .C + B-
) ( #$*"D 1388 : 73
.(
>'Ob 4
@%B4 B c$ B? .B"LC B]! • :b ; ,?1 c$ ? [$ Jy
.L+ E* %&'# $ "[
-
) (.3sI 1386 : 46
.(
t I $ Ba >B'9+ @B g dB (@%m%_ • - >4 "[ 4 %&'# ; ,?1 c$ ? K+
$ w%8 H N1 a 3 ‚:4 %&'# ; ,?1 > #
@ $ E O+ - 4 $ BL"8 WB%+ $
*+ & *9 hT'=1 .
w%8 78 b . -
.1 >'?D W%+ .P %'3 w%8 )! >4 .Y D >
- -
- 4 $ -
.1 E*%1 + W%+ 8 1 - 4 >
- - J,g'B1 *1! $ ! "# ;W"'=1
# @i%N1 h:1 *,&+ 2 P
) (.Tb R 1387 : 165
$ 164
.(
wB%8 >90 >4 t G1 tsBR B4
.1 hLC >4 .+u P .B i*1 4 %&'#
$ .D*%B# J'R .Y D > * ! WB%+ JB93 $*BI
.1 >1 *4
) ( -!
1375 : 155
.(
$ %&'B# ( ! "B# r$ B- >pT+ . OC >4 )! L'B#
.1 .T" w%8 -
.
2 - - ./0 1 2 :
4
56 6 78 + 59
'="&+ ; K+
>"„=1 %&'# > # E*- Q .'# >4 )
>B+ B# .C a 1
1 ,?1 . .+ + 8 ....
%&'#
(
# %N8 1 .
%C$ mB1 >B4 >B+ B E*B- %&'# ! >90
=%+ j 4 1 %&'#
Z .F B[ >4 @' @ ! $ ! > # `O 1 r a 1 @ 4 >9"4
q4 "p1 >
#
>+ E*- ;$ :1
) E*+$ _ Lewis
%B"_ ) =B >%"C southwales
v(
wB N @B
E*+$ _
Daws v.ppp
*- T
. E*+$ _ @ (
.+ B1 ( 4 E*- @%- 1 $ $ >4 > ; <1
' ; >4
>
@%- 1 > *- >'=4 ."?8 >p# $ >4 R c I >4 4
B#
>"%
J%BK0 %B"_
1 .
*L:1 ( -! >4 * &04 >+ L+ 4 .
1375 ?% .# @%F! ( H$ *"[ (
( ) , : L# c m'+
: 117 .B"C (.Tb BR $ (
) , ( ?% .# @%F!
: H$ … X (q+ ,- (
1387 : 164 .
4 E*- .
; u %&'# Q I ;sC
=%+
. ( - }g/m1 > *' .1 S ? .+ 1 %&'#
# E 4 r 0L1 @' E*- %&'#
.
@'B ! %1$ :1 4 hL'm1 %&'# Y
# }/- l "p1 h:1 >4 Z
.L+ %&'# >4 .,'01 .'%1$ :1 Y 1 -
. .1 %"_
*B+
E %- >4 ; 1 *1! $ !
"R *1 c$ ?'1 Y .BL+ %&'# >4 .,'01 > *0 >
B- .
> # @ >+ L+ k
>' d_ Y E D .1 %"_ *+
*+
) M 'g8 1 ( }T+ %D "[ K01 >4
Q"I
) (breach of peace
>&+ <9
) (detain
*4 %&'B# >4 .,'01 >90 )$
- . .# 4 ( & >+ L+
# }/- .+ + 8 Y )
>
HsBR
%B"_ B# @B9L1 )!
.# 4 ; <+ 4 > O4 94 . $ %+
B# $ Ba .Tp01 Y .
wB%8 >pB# 4 sƒB1
$ O[
( B- .BT" %&'B# 'L W%X Y E D K+ Y .# 4 @ .
>B9%b 3
2%8 @%%O i%"4 8 w%8 H 9- & $ Y %&'# @%4 1
=B%+
. .B1 B?D ) B
$ *B,&+ BK01 >B4 }/- .9 W% ! "# ( %&'# .L# $ ."I 'R # B# E BD B,+! G3 @%1^ $ ; [ 2%T: >4 kL t*Y 4 %"_ E .
>B'Ob
.1 %&'#
.' L3 *+
) protective
*- 4 (
) B B H B?P ( =B1 o /B- >9%F [ hƒ1
.1 w%8 ) - R .'1s# P R >4 C mLb h'/1
*+ - ( .1 W%+ $
>+ %&mB%_ *+
preventive
4 -
%&'B# Q"BI }BT+ %D B"[ BK01 >B4 BI h9B- >B4 }/B- >9%F [ hƒ1 * .1
Sanders and young, 2002: 113) -
( .
& c OC >4 (
.1 † .+ 1 %&'#
%B"_ =B >B *BY M 3spBI
.B1 ;sBC
# - 4 }/-
Z .+ 1 .1 E ?'# %&'# 4 $ $ >
>B .+ B1 *0
.1 ) m+ MsLC M K?b E ?'B# $ B B 3 %D B"[ B4 *- 4 ; u D > *Y
*Y R .
m+ E ?'# Qa $ Ms1 c OC D Z
1 }/B- c BI @B B: >BP 4
.L+ .T" %&'#
- . .B1 %LY 1 o R P >4 1 @ >'Ob
%&'B# >B *B4
# 0- J =1 E*- .
3 -
5 : - ./0 56 ;
3 - 1 . 5 : - ./0 ;
a 3 ‚:4 (
hB:1 >B4 @'B B4 B @B ! "# ( %"_ %&'# K01
l "p1 4
#
>"%
# %"_ Y$ %+
.
$ j =BO1 .C Ba 1 ! "B# ‚B:4 >B90 >4 K+
w"'/1 + [ *[ $ Z #
> =%+ JY @ ! "# w"'/1 S T- .# 4 H <1 db
$ ! "# .F G8 c 1 T1 J%T'=1 c 1 *8 E*+ %D 4 B4 .=B%"_ c B1 T1 c 1 *B8 B
*- 4 .F G8 c 1 T1 W <
. I WD + >4 E $*:1 M
! (hT'=1 h1 C ) 0C >4 %"_ >
.1 "# ) *+$ ,- @
*0 (
# >' D 8 a 3 2%T: r a 1 .
3 - 2 . / .6 5 8 <6 # 5 : - ./0 56 e B90 r a 1 %"_ hT'=1 %&'# .+ O1 M *LC .+ O1 ‚:4 B#
. 7B8 $ (
%"_ Y$ %+ c 1 *8 %B"_ >90 >4 c ?'b 4 .F G8 c '# <1 @%p4 a ) 0C >4
qB"LC 0O1 $ >'- hN?01 M O T qT+ %&'# ;$Wb ;*C ;$Wb E 4 %D J%L K+
$ ; 93 M I
# E I c '#
Z 9g >pT+ db (
>B4 B<1 %B"_ >B B# .LF [ M Ob y
3 I ; T1 ) 0C >4 >"R *1
%'R
# .
; BK+ > # $ a "p1 @ Q%a >'Ob
.F G8 '# 4 %"_ %&'# ) '="&+ .8 T3
) (arrest under warrant
4
#
>"%
(Q"BI E BD
@B $ *B+ [$ )! 1 .# 4 $ ‚:4 H <1 > # q R o R ; 93 74 .F GBB8 'BB# )$*BB4 %&'BB# M BBI >BBb T1
(arrest without warrant)
BB8 .BB# 4 BB1
.1
) %D
Feldman,2002:329
.(
*N
)
>LY >+ >'Ob (
.B"%b %"_ = > # .0'O1 @ 4 %&'# c %'R
.Tp01
) reasonable cause
E*- 9 1 .1 [ ) 0K1 >90 >4 T'C 4( )
(has committed
H 3
)l 9
Is committed
l B9 *BI B (
) Is a bout to commit
>'B- B# )!(
*- 4 .
=%+ ) + 8 ) %4 >4 j 4 1 .Tp01 h%b Ez $ Z
# 2 T3 4 `O 1 >9"4 .
>B4 >B =
Y D* ‡ # 4 E O'- >4 1 t N'1 :+
.
$ *B0 ; *8 ) + 8 En $ q %&'B# B%'R
@U (*0 H LC
# >'- t N'1 .
.Tp01 h%b (
.C B+ B .0%C %N1 .
)$*B4 B%b TN1
.1 .4 ~ >4 r [
(Murphy,2002: 959) - .
) B91 ‚B:4 ) B4 .BC • :b 4 >'Ob
=%+ [ 1 2%T: @ ) '="&+ S T3 $ .1 L 2%8*
.
4 . G8 '# )$*4 %"_ %&'# c %'R B?% >b $ %"_ ) + 8 ‡ #
1984
(Police and crimind Evidence Act 1984 (PACE 1984))
)! H BLC >B >B8g ?'1 @%+ B8 & $
MsLC 4
#
>"%
) + 8 1984
# >' L'#
Z Q"I ˆT+ o R u @1 %'R
) breach
(of peace
.1 LC JK+ ) + 8 r a 1 c %'R 1986
public order Act1986/ c %'R & $
d&+ + 8 | *01 *BN4 Y
(ibid: 965)1984 J=B $ ) + B8 hBƒ1
2000 B#
.
@B
1 M *LC c %'R 24
( 25 ( 26 ( 27 ?% >b $ %"_ ) + 8
) PACE
.1 E*Y m1(
- .
3 - 3 . -+ 5 8 <6 # = : - ./0 56
%&'# o R Ei B1 ) B .8 T3 ; K+ %"_ Y$ %+ hLC 0O1 (hT'=1
24
l B1 B?% B1 lsBT+ $ .1 LC Y E D .# @%F! ) + 8 1378
B#
>B
Ei 1 r a 1 ,m1 JF [ ) 8 K+ : $ %&'# %'R 21
) + B8 ) BLY
4 a > # E pC %"_ Y$ %+ >4
*+ E*- E O1 + `
1. .B1 >BK3s1 > >+ &+ LY B-
,m1 ; [ ) 0C >4 .p - 4 >'-dD ; [ >N8 $ 2gT: .+ 1 K+ (.+ d&+ + 8 %&'# $ >"R *1 >4 <1 %"_ Y$ %+ $ .T"
.1
*+
. B4 B# @B9L1 E B&+ @B
) X . OC >4 @g0T1 Q >4 >[
) 78 $ E*- (
*04 1 ( )
; [ r 8$ _ (
*04 2
$ 3
$ 4
$ 5 B8 q BR Bb B: ; [ >4 r$ - >"3 1 ) + 8 @ > - Hu*'# @%0X
.L+
*Y .
& c OC >4 (
*B+ >"R *1 23 (; [ ; L _ `T @ 1 1 .
f B/g B4 >B'Ob
> .LF [ >4 r$ - >90 4 .0O1 .Tp01 %=?
.1 l =:1 ; [ ) + 8 K+
BR (*+ -
>"R *1 >4 <1 @ 1^1 $ E 4 ; [ .C + >4 Z@'=Y
.1 7? 1 @ -
Z
>%[ @ 4 1
.1 Y U &
-
$
! ) E O+ ; [ Mu I ; [ >4 r$ - > >"„=1 @ • :b 4 >
2
B&11
Q @g0T1 > 1 Z
.'%Na$ `4 a
$ >B' D B8 B-
$ >B"R *1 ) B91
.1 [ l 9 >4 r$ - > . /- %&'#
E ( B#$ .8 BT3 c BCsP >4 >'=4 $ .
4 `4 a 1 @%0X
*
>'B- o BR .B1 [ >B4 r$ - ) 4 ; [ 2] $ .8 T3 rsgP
; [ h1 l 9 $ E $! hLC >4 .G'T1 ; *8 *- 4 4
#
>"%
1
$ E*B+ 1 K'01 9
$ %&'# >4 ; *8 ‰#
$ B%+ .B f t *Y 4 51 r a 1 @ # Qa $ _ > *0
# %"_
.
%B"_ $ %+ f /g >+ *0L- Y %4* o R @ @g0T1 # .G'T1 db
>B B?% b *BC %mBL- # $ Y ) =0 *4 $ w8 $ R E & [ $ c %'R >4 O=+
[ Š?3 E*+ 4 $ W% ( # S T3 C $ ) + 8 -
.
B:1 @ 1^1 ) '="&+ .8 T3 ; K+ tsR 4 > ‚%3 @ @g0T1 E D*
B $ E
# E L- 4 1
>"R *1 >4 <1 ) +! >
'=Y
*0 (
*T h4 8 Z #
.0B-$ >B4 @9%b
.1 4 g/m1 + .Ps'R ,m1 ; [ 2 1 * ! B[ B4 dB&+ + 8 esB J,O1 $ }
b *C
# . Ei 1 >K3s1 4 >90 Q%a 21
.1 • p1 h f • - >4 . u # ~ ! S -
>
*- 4 cu # @ >4 # _ .- + 7 .C # @g0T1 # >'= - :
1 - Ei 1 @g0T1 K+ r a 1 ; [ ! 21
>LY
& c OC >4 v # JF [ (
>"BI s4 !
1 [ r 8$ _ .
%LY J
@%Y hƒ1 Z
*B- 4 78$ B1 U + $ a 3 ( 1^1 >90 )$*4 Z
B4
1 .
‹ ; [ +$ N1 $ - (@=3 ( 1 >4 ~ wb /1 K+ ,[
1 ) , ( : ) W%1 1373 : 33 .
/- . N1 .
o R 4
#
>"%
*04 • - >4 ; [ 9 1 ) 0C >4 E* *YW4 2
Z
>B4 B<1 `4 Ba
v # ) 0K1 %&'#
2 -
*04 • - >4 ; [ r 8$ h:1 @ 1^1 >"I s4 G3 ! 1
) +!
h%b Œ%Y )$*4
.1 o R }/- %&'# >4 <1 &
v*0
3 - 4 ; [ r 8$ _ >"I s4 4 J,g'1 * 8 !
* B4 H B& h u >4 JG01
$ ; B[ ) .T" ,m1 4 . )! >4 ; *8 * 8 t I E 4 q'%1 <1
€ BpC
v # %"_ >4 %&'# %'R 4 -
&b$ ! J,g'1 ) 4
( Ei 1 24 p1 $ > # .0N1 @ *4 712
.1sB# c <1 ) + 8
•t I $ *- 4 &b$ M N8 $ Ž K+
. B ( B&b$ ; , J,'1 8 N'1 F 4 4 .'3 @%p4 a
# %&'# %'R W < 4 v
) B1 >B B# .B1 [ BY J,g'1 (@g0T1 K01 M # #
v*- 4 &b$ %&'#
!
*04 %&'# %'R 6
$ }'/1 B&b$ 4 E O1 '#
v # E*- € pC 5 -
>[ h4 8 ci*1 -dD 4 . /- D
; [ l 9 )
Bƒ1 h hB'8 (
@%p4 Ba WB+
) *4 8 $ a 3 $ %&'# >4 <1 @%p4 a ! *0
'=Y v*0
4 - - ./0 # + 9-> ? @'
4 - 1 . - ./0 # / .6 5 8 <6 @'
.1 >'?D J,'1 >4 Mu LN1
*BY %B"_ @%B- 1 B# >B4 $ # %&'# : > -
.1 - . .L+ %"_ %&'# ) 1 B . [ B4 %B"_ E WB[ E*B- %&'# *+
*0 2%T:
. 8 t*Y 4 ."LC *+W4 . 3 Œ%Y *+ 23 %"_
.IsR >+ ,4 >4 ) 7+
.8 T3 E $ m1 ) ;$ :1 4 - 4
*Y ; <+
.
* 4 @%0•LY E*- %&'#
hT'=B1 .8 T3 E $ m1 4 e R 23
) independent
.+ B<1 $( )
(free of charge
7B"p1 B-
(Franks, 2009: 5)
.
"_ Y$ %+ <4 + ' ) '="&+ .8 T3 ; K+
t BI %&'B# ) 1 % BK+
$ ?% %TN ) 91 ) +! .1 K'+
( .1 dB&4 .# *0 ! 4 >i[ h4 8 c %] *+
.
>B4
H ƒ1 ) 0C (
; B&0Y >B4 )! %"_ = > *%0- + E D >90 _ E*+$ _ k
+ [ + %&'#
. 16
?D $ >4 >b # :
a >L" k D >+ D .4 C c I .F &4 .
.1 R
J0 ....
.L+ > # W%X @ )! JY E D .+
)! @1 ) X .0 ) 0C
.1 .'# >4 J= +
Z 2"N1 >?%U$ ; <+ $ .
>B%"C .1 BLC JK+ HsR ; , E D
=+ .?'01 ) [ + .
?D .a 8 :
.L+ @1 k Œ%Y J+
.Ob p1
@B >B J0B $ B4
.1 e WD @1 >4 ) =
(The guardian, 20 may 2005) *0Y .
.+ + B8 BpR %&'# ) 1 $ a `4 a &
caution/
B#
. 2B%8 c BOC
# E*- ) %4 ) + 8 >"%#$ >4 .+ + 8 pR :
BD B1 *B% &4 WB%X *%'=B%+ O<1 L-
.F [ 4 ) 1
*N4 > W%X Y
.1 0'# )! >4 E D
*%0 (
>B4 B# @B9L1 *B%09+ f
.1 *% &4 > W%X Y *0 $ >Lpb L- c %C *- 4 h%b *+
(Code of c, 10.9) 1.
1
) 8 K+ • :"1 >4 wgU 1 ( %"_ ) 1^1 > # ."F =1 W%+ h u xs4 r a 1 )!
'=Y
*0 . - Y .1 %&'# & > }/
4 (*0
* ) BLY B %&'# h%b $
@9L1 ) 1 @ 7 # ) 1
*0 7"gp1 . H LC E*C 8 @ W%+ %"_ Y$ %+ o R
.1 - Z
*- 4 Jg"=1 - 4 h%b D .'3 Z
.+ + B8 %&'B# ( mB+ >F c CsP @ D
4 *Y /+
.
>?%U$
%&'B# ) 1 c CsgP >F
) At time of arrest
>B?%U$(
>B =B%+
[ %&'# >K:b ) LY M T%8 ) '4 Z
H BTN1 .+ B1 E $ H P # @9L1 >9"4
B- 4 =B `B# c BCsP >BF >4 %+ - ; <+ >K:b )! *N4 hO8
) Custody
officer
*- 4(
. c CsP @
# @9L1 4
#
>"%
B- >BF B9LY k
) NV: 2000 Murphy,
ibid 969
.(
4 - 2 . - ./0 # -+ 56 6 <6 @' %&'B# ) B1 J B3 .+ + 8 `4 a l 4 h ?1 c g T1 *[ $ ) .8 T3 ; K+
=%+ %"_
Z .B1 (J B3 c g BT1$ *C 8 r L<1 @9%b B# rsBgP c $ Ba ) B
.+
j O0'# h u .O' xs4 $ %&'# h u o R .
*B04 B[ 1 >4 2
Ei B1 9 S Bƒ%1
.# %# $ .+*1 .8 T3 1966
.1 w%8 > Y hB u wB%8 ) B1 *B 4 ( B-
- 7"gp1 R >%"C c 1 ,g M N # $ - E D! q?%8 .
Ei B1 B[ 1 >B4 @%B0•LY 24
S
~ ! .. ) . (*B- 4 $ Ba c BT%T: hB%L9 B4 J,'B1 B- 4 ,mB1 JF [ >•+ 0X
B- xsB4 J,'1 >4 M O' >"I s4 h u f 4 * 4 ; ,g r a 1 (...
. + LBa @g0BT1 >+ ?Bi#^'1
+ g T1 o R @ .F [ 9
S B wB%"9 B C E &•%Y W%+ .F G8 > $ $ # E
" $ a @%p4 a 4 + .T
9 :+ >4 # E c g BT1 ) p4 a (.# 'L MsLC >
.1 .C 1 S
*00 . t I >'Ob B[ @%LGB 'B# @g0BT1 Q B >B4 B%+ K+
.1 (."N ` - S w%"9 hI [ 1 >4 > Hu*'# @%0X )
32 .B# # ) + 8
1 . Y > $ >C L<1 code of c)
>C L<1 (
%"_ E %"_ c %'R $ @%+ 0K1 S T3 > # . G8 > $
.1 }/m1
*0 .
.... )
; , r a 1 ( - 4 c I J%L,? $ xs4 J,g'1 >4 M O' >"I s4 h u f 4 * 4
c*1 t U ƒ *3 $ - 24
C # ( H B# . GB8 >:b BI 7[ 1 >4 . 1*T1 E*+$ _ ( ...
- .
& t P (
hB u .BO' .Y BD! B4 J,g'1 23 @ Q%:I [ + La @g0T1
Ei 1 [ 1 >4 ; ,g 570
.1s# c <1 ) + 8 )
.3sI 11 / 10 / 1381 ( E B .B0%4 q%_
# . .1 ;sC E g T1 @ :
»
$ c 1 T1 k Y BY E &'# $ Y ,+ >4 >'=4 $ @ 1 1
() + 8 tsR 4 > .'1 93 BT1 S BT3 ) +! *0 "# "1 . /- !
(* L+ ;$ :1 .# # ) + 8 Z
B kB %1$ :1 $ 1*R H ?+ 4 E$sC 5
H B#
*B- *BY R ; B9:1 H B# ># E 1 $ O3 >4 .'b$ hy m1
«.
e dB_ ’ B B4 >B'Ob
L S c g T1 C ;*C W%+ S Hu*'#
>b LN1 c T%T: e $ i:I %] )
- *Y /+
.
5 - - ./0 1 2 =: + 9-> ? 56 6 @'
5 - 1 . / .6 5 8 <6 @'
5 - 1 - 1 . 2B # ;.6 ,C .1 %&'# & > . /-
%&'B# B Q%:BI *,&+ @%LG >4 *,N'1 *0
# E*- .
Y . /- .'8$
.1 %&'# %"_ E %y .+ 91 %&'B# _ -
4
#
>"%
.1 8 @%p4 a `g"= : *+$ ,-
%D Z 7 B# $ B# wBgU 1 %"_ 1^1
BO4 %B"_ E >B4 @9L1 ) 1 @
)
$ Y*B04 2 Ei B1 30 B?% >Bb $ %B"_ ) + B8 PACE1984
.(
+
@%'=/
>4 $ $ $*4 ; D
%"_ E 4 i#
>"%
.1 >'- 4 - 4 = -
Z - 4 =
.1 l =:1 .=%"_ c T%T: t P .4 U + > # .+ OY$ D >[ *[ $ h8 *3
$ -
[$ )! ) 0K1 . /- > # .T%T: Y hT'=1 .
@ 4 04 ( ) B0C >B4 > .+ 1
.1 hLC - 4 = O+ >[$ Œ%Y >4 *0
@%+ B0K1 @%+ 0K1 >%"C >gb @%1^ *0 ! *
>"R *1 *- 4 >'-
) (sanders,ibid:170
. @%LGB >B # - 4 = E*,C >4 >?%U$ @
$ E R 4 Q%:I ( R ) 0K1 4 %"_ ) = *0
$ B+ kB : B *B *, >B+ D Œ%Y
%&+ c I .
+ 0K1 4 c 8s1 >+ D Y c %FW[
4 ) mb "# @%
* B- 4 =B B'
- O]
. 4 .0O1 %&4 J%L * 4 > #$ @%0•LY E*B00 %&'B# =B ! >90
@%B0X > *0 3 - 4 = D v>+ # >'- ) J,g'1 4 . c CsgP
>gb
=%+ [ 1 $ W+
Z 4 E*- %&'# }/-
* - ! M
) PACE 37 (1) (b)
.(
5 - 1 - 2 . D' 5D0-/0 E 18 F 6 G HI # 5 8 J# K 18 LMNO 18
J 6 -: P + /2 - 4 >T4 # < H „=1 @%0•LY - 4 =
Custody record/
(PACE 37) # >
4 .8 T3 $ m1 JY $ E*- %&'# }/- JY
* )!
E*Y m1 B *0B- 4 >'- .‰ )! $
c BI >B4 wB%8 .+ BO1 $ >B+ B E*- .C 1 E*- %&'# }/- S T3 ! - }g/m1 E $ B%D B8 .0%4 B4 B1 (w%8 .+ O1 .0%4 4 4 J 3 2"p1 *C 8 ‡ # 4
((2.9)
(2.3) (2.1) (code of practice, supra note, code 2)) .
4 ) 0K1
* 4 k
%&'B# >B90 JBC - 7"gp1 ) & .8 T3 E $ m1 23 &
# E*- a 3 %"_ E >+ O"P$ E*- .
c BI >B4 * 4 En $ P >4 - 4 =
$ * &4 $ >4 S T3 Qa $ 8 T3 ,+! > T%T3 @ @%0•LY
. L'=1
) Continuing
rights
.1 > *0'=Y(
*0+
>"3 1 Y *+ B- H BLC B- 4 H P
....
) B 7B"p1
e %&'# &
] ....
$ [ E $ mB1 $ .8 BT3 $ mB1 4 .8 T3 E $ m1
o BR
>1 + @% ! >C L<1 . [ Y
) code of practive
w%8 4 J 3 ( (code c ,6 (a)(6-1))
.
;sC .8 T3 E $ m1 23 > '# _ k E$sC >4 .1
4 *0
* E 9-! c I >4
- E q L+ %"_
(code c ,3 (a)(3.1))
.
• B3 c BT%T: .?g8 > ) 1 Y .B1
B- (
4
* .+ + 8 pR
caution/ E 4$
- ; <+
(Code c, 10.1, 10.5)
.
4 %"_ w%8 : >LY
*
*0- 4 7"gp1 .1 >
.+ 1 Y *0+
m1 4 .8 BT3 $
*00 &'?D $ E $ m1 .I R c I >4 Z
$ *- 4 .0?" .O' ( G3 >90 JC
>90
# ‡ '# wgU 1 h% $ t P .+ <1 $ hT'=1 .8 T3 E $ m1
) Code c, 6 (a) (6.1) .(
5 - 1 - 3 .
QR E #
duty solicitor/
c 8s1 wgU 1 h% $ J,g'1 > # .'8$ [ @ .1
*B0 . h5B- B4 .8 BT3 $ mB1 $
.8 BT3 c 1*BR ) %=B%L 4 > # .I R
) legal services commission
>'=B4 B8(
.+ BR Ei B1! B *B- 4 a 3 %"_ E #
(present or on call)
*B- 4 . c
V W4 %"_
# @9L1 )*0b %"_ E hƒ1 >LY
B0X B kB B8$
wBgU 1 hB% $ *
*0- 4 a 3 .
kX c
E B1! wBgU 1 hB% $ ,B- >B1 3 B . '#$ 2P 01
4 *Y R .+ R .
h% $ 4 .+ i<1 E $ m1 23 E*- %&'# }/- > .+ 1 %"_
.L+ ( # E 9+ E D! wgU 1
*0 .F [ 4 *+
. B4 >B BO+ hB 1 E*B- %&'# }/- D
% $ 4 - 4 = (*0 E $ m1 wU 1 h
*
@ 4 B04 >B *B0 pR wgU 1 h% $ >4 (
>B4 $
.1 >F .1 E*- %&'#
> ) LG1 @ 4 *0
» LB- > # >'?D @1 >4 - 4 =
>' D .L%L
* .
>' D J%L L-
*B *+ B%+ .8 BT3 E $ mB1 >4 >K:b )! > *
«.
# ; u J &4 L- >4 . YW%X @1
:
1 - .1 ) + 8 .1 L- * D
B .+ B1 BY hB% $ .+ i<1 .8 T3 E $ m1 *%+
*%0 Z 2 - J'=Y %"_ E @1 .
.1 @1 JY*4 .8 T3 E $ m1 L- >4 ) 0 JY J+
Z
3 - .1 @1 J0 . L0Y L- ) + 8 1 J+
. .1 @1 *%Y /4 L- D B4 J+ B
J0 L- Z
4 - 4 %"_ (*%Y /4 E $ m1 @1 L- D
*
*0 wg8 '1 L- 2%T:
.
.1 E $ m1 @1 L- D
*%Y R ...
_ .b B# Œ%BY >B4 $ *B%0 GB1 >1 + @
*%0 r [ 1 - 4 = >4 >1 + @ $ *%Y*+ l [ %"_
. LB- >B4 *B 4 @%B0•LY @B1
*%Y /+ .8 T3 E $ m1 @1 D .'3 J0 >%I ...
cu B# >4 *%Y /+ D *%'=%+ O<1
*%Y*4 l [ %"_
. .1 c 9# L- 23 @ @%+ 8
*01 + .
>LY *B% &4 *B 4 L- > W%X
) ' 9# 23 L- > # @
) (silence
H LC .1
*%0 .
$ E*- %&'# }/- >4 >1 + ;
4 ) '#
.1 ,0m%_ G1
*0 :
1 - .1 @1 7 # L- JY R J0%O4 @9L1 ) 1 @
Z
2 - .L+ @1 J0%O4 L- JY R
franks,ibid:6-7) (
.
+
@%'=/
wBgU 1 hB% $ B4 c 8s1( B- 4 = 4 c 8s1 *N4 %"_ E >"3 1
# . .1 E*- %&'# >4 M C + wgU 1 h% $
* D :
1 -
@1 >?%U$
# L- r Z
2 -
@1 Ms1
$ J'=Y hT'=1
>p4 Œ%Y
; *+ %"_ 4 Z
3 - t I >"3 1 @ ( L- . + K+
# .+ i<1 @1 c 1*R Z
4 -
"% $ L- D .
JY R <0 >4 $ ) $! 4 ; R es @1 *%Y /4 &
Z 5 - .1 @1 J+
%"_ c T%T: .1 L (
LY L- J0 .Y
Z 6 - .1 $ J0 kL J+
L- $
>4 ; W'b *%8 4
G3 )
*- 4 ; u D + La (
; O4 )$ %4
(Shepherd, 1997:212)
.
Mui$ wgU 1 h% $ ‰#
( Bi%LY *B[ $ 2 T3 *0 .1 >O3 1 E*00 %&'# = 4
*4 %"_ E D*
Z M %+ ] ( .1 >O3 1 hg 1 4
*0 M ƒb ] $ *4 hg 1 %N8 1 Z
hBg 1
)*+ 1 # 4 qT3 >LY
.1 E D! %"_ Y .F [ 4
*0 .
5 - 1 - 4 . S+ =79 T U' VIW E*m+ *04 >TOP (c 1 ,g > .+ 1 %"_
*+
( .L+
}/B- l B'91 a )$*4 *+
%&4 m&+ ] $ (E*- %&'#
.
# k B] hB%b >B B# .+ B1 )! $ B[$ 0ƒ'
# E*+$ _ h u m&+
.
%N8 1 @ (
.1 %"_
E*B- %&'B# mB&+ B] *B+
%&4 .
@ [$ 4
( M I "p1 @ @%%N 4
#
>"%
) %F
(superintendent 1
.B1 c I1
B%D .
4 9+ T4 p1 $ m&+ ] D
* - ;$*N1 .
- D WB[ - >1 '/1 E*+$ _ >F O }/
4 Y 0 _ .1 L .F W[ 24 # %1 9:1 [$ c I
*
;$*N1
*+ - . h9B- @%BLY >4
.L+ %"_
Ba )$*B4 *B+ >B' &+ 8 E*+$ _ h%9m r a 1 (c 1 ,g > .+ 1 *+
%&4 9C $ E*- %&'# .O' .
B] dBR B4 # @9L1 >9%b 3
$ >B4 mB&+
.L+ 9C @' D 4 (*- hi# '1 *B- $ >4 h# '1 )
) (Code d 3 (a) (3.2) (c)) code of
practice for the identification persons by police officers
.(
.BF W[ B%1 9:1 >T4 B# B[$ c BI W[ *- >1 '/1 E*+$ _ >F O }/- D 4
*
*+ - ;$*N1 Y 9C .
>LY
>+ L+
.1 >' D E*- %&'# }/- > . Y hB%O8 -
) R ( ( i*/1 1 >4 ~ 9m1 Ei 1 Y 1 * 4
B- >'/ $ =1 >+ L+ $ Z
.B9
.4 B hT'=B1 c BI >4 7 *1 h% $ 4 & $ %"_ .[ R ,Y &m 1 ! 4 - .
>4 <01 1 @ ; <+ .Y .B1 E*+$ _ H p4
) B-
Frederice Aitchison v.Richard
bellj 1998 co/859/98 (
.
5 - 1 - 5 .
;N -' J 6 -: E 7K E @' .1 %"_ (; ,g 4 .L# E*+$ _ h%9m hO8
*0 >O3 1 J,g'1 4 *+
. wBgU 1 h% $
B# R >B90 ˆ:1 >4 $ # G3 >4 <1 )
hB% $ ( E*B-
*B- 4 (
>O3 B1 B&
.L+
- • 3 *+
(Code E, 112(2.1))
. ; B<+ `OBa B W<1 c I >4 Mu LN1 + $
.1
*0 K :1 Q%:I + `Oa h4 T1 ,+! .9 .4 R *0Y .
$ B,1 BY + ‰B#
.1 ; 1
*+ - . 4 7 *1 h% $
*
*- 4 >'- + .‰ k .
.'8$
.B1 B,1 k +
$ B-
+ 4
@%'=/
.1 r L'# 4 4 .Y - _ %TN $ # W < >4 *+ -
* 7B"p1 7 *B1 hB% $
- - E $ >4 G3 4 . I $
(Code E, q 6 (6.2))
.
*+ L4 # 23 J,'1 .
=B%+ Ei B1! B1 H LN'# .'=1 h%b >4 > . /- Z
>B4
1 >[$ Œ%Y .L+ 8 .F [ 4
%D . 4 # ) [ + ) 0K1 D
* (.8 T3 $ m1 E LY >4
- 4 a 3 W%+ @ *b $ 0
(Code cq 12 (a) (12.3) and code c, annexc)* .
B 4 .F [ 4 ,8
*
>B4
*0- 4 > , $ @-$ (; D .?91 *3 .
.L+ . /- Œ%Y
; B&0Y >B B ;W"1 )
*'= 4 .F [ 4
(Code c, 12(a) (12.9) (12.5))
4.
*
*B- 4 B<1 ) B0K1 Z
Mui$
( B- BY 8
1 . ) () '="&+ %"_ Y$ %+ >[
`4 a Constable/ Z
) OY$ D sergeant/ Z
‡ 4
inspector/ Z
‡ 4 #
chief /
inspector
%F $ superintendent/
# .
>4 >N[ 1 (j. Holtman, crimind litigation London. Jordan :
pu 2002
*4 /4 C # Z
M %+ ] ( /4 dy C ,+ 1 Z
M ƒb ] ( Y 2
*- 4 >'- ?0 C #
(Code
c, 12 (a) (12.7)
.(
5 - 1 - 6 .
# ;.6 PY
; , >90 )$*4 w%8 4 @9L1 c*1 @ 'm%4 dB_ c I
24 B# C B#
(PACE 91 (1))
.1 >O# :1 %"_ E >4 $ $ ) 1 ci*1 @ .
- .
>B+ O"P$ }/- D
ci*1 @ * %4 %"_ E >4 .B1 >OB# :1 %&'B# ) 1
(PACE 91 (2) (a) (1)) B- .
36
.1 & C # *+
4
#
>"%
- W < %"_ %F .
:1 @ c BI >B4 .+ 1 Y $*
.B1 H BLC j -$ *%8 .4 $ 2"p1 *+ B-
(PACE S 92 (1))
. wB%8 ) B1 (
wB%8 =B
(detention officer)
>"BI >B4 .?%8 B BY ‡ 4 >[ h8 *3 >
6 B_ C B#
.1 .0%4 4 r$ - E 4$ $ *0
9 Y $ *N4 C # 9
>B *0 @%LG ()! _ C # .+ BO1
[$ 0Y w%8 >%b$
(PACE s 90 (3)(b) and (a))
. J=B $ ; B[ o BR >B'Ob
J= $ %&m%_ ) + 8 2005
%&'# 4 %"_ %'R 48
.B1 T1 C #
*B0
>
5 B# * *L h4 8 $
) David Herschel and etc, 2008: 300
.(
B4 >B90 ˆB:1 >B4
, d_ c I E*+$ _ h%9m c 1 Z
.1 %"_
$ mB&+ ] J,'1 *+
B%&4 B9C .
.1 W%+ 7 *1 h% $ qp - ) ) m+ 4 $ %4 @%4 $ J,g'1 9C @' D 4 *+
Y 3 >b <1 4
(shepherd, ibid:720)
$ wgU 1
# .8 B4 E*+$ _ .B1
*B+ 1
.O%
*0 JY ; W'b >T%]$ 4 .
5 - 1 - 7 . P# I - ) 18 .1 .+ + 8 Y WL'# ) '="&+ Mu LN1 - >F O J,'1 D _
.
; 9:1 `"y >4 D
*- 4 E*- Z
.1 1 y ( # E 4 w%8 $ > .+ 1 4 b$
_ . ?% b *C ) + 8
(criminal justice Act 1988)
1 Ei 133 .1 T1 :
/- .'8$
. B1 [ >B4 ; 9:1 .
.BF W[
*- E - ˆT+ q'%1 9:1 M O8 N'1 $ Z
*B )$*B4 E*B- wmB E B .'T%T3 > 0O1 @ 4
b *C Q%:I + H LC . 3
) miscarriage of justice
# (
. 4 m ) '#
* . B/- >B4
B%1 9:1 P R >4 >
( y E B hBL: . B<1
>B4 B# E B1 BD B B‰4 B1
‰4 q+ *+$ m R Z
>B4 l =B'+ hB4 8 M BFW[ Ms >'R 0- + T%T3 m ;*C >90 &1
*- 4 ; 9:1 }/- .
E*+$ _
Lunt v . Liverpool city justices
5
‡ 1 1991 P R >4 42
>B4 wB%8 $
.":1 c %b 1 R _ ;*C h%b 25
y *+ _ WY
*B- R _ 1
. E*B+$ _
Regina
>B%"C
) *+ %F
Brockhill
1999 Z 5 hBL: P BR >B4 B1 y *B+ _ WBY 59
c B<1 $
*- R _
(franks ,2009:11-18)
.
5 - 2 . - ./0 =: -+ 5 8 <6 @'
.1 %&'# }'/1 $ Q I c T1 ,0 ?D ) .B9 B1 mB .=B%"_ Y
hI r a 1 ; ,g J%,? $ h u .O' xs4 o R 32
B1 'mB%_ > # .# # ) + 8
D 8 .# 4 Z
*B04 & $ 5
S BT3 ŠB?3 $ r$ mB1 BY ! >B4 ; B'3 ) + B8
.BB1 g BBT1 >BB BB# *+$ ,BB- :
» ...
l BB< BB BB- 4 $ %&'BB# 7BB01 hBBI
.1
> * L+
$ B# E* D @i%N1 ) + 8 > *- 4 .O% $ J93 >4 W%+ $ a 1
) D*B- %&'# E + BR $ B- H B# .F G8 Qb I 7[ 1 >4 E*+$ _ (E g T1 ",1 t U
*+ %D 8 ) [ .«
%&'B# ) D*B- %&'# E + BR rsBP 23 4 2 * # ., *4
*T h4 8 J,g'1 ) 0K1
# Z
# . + ci*- >4 @9%b .
>p4 Ba $ e dB_ c $ a
*B01
(E + R 4 J,g'1 c O 91 $ c 8s1 (rsgP (j O ) c %, *B4 q R s $ $ ) '#$
# >+u C .# k d_ + 9+
.
>B4 @%+ 0K1 *,&+ ) 1 $*:1 >'Ob 24
C B#
$ H L'3 .=%"_ hT'=1 Y %&'#
.1 qY E ?'# € # ) W%1
*Y .
; BK+ @9%b
>"3 1 @ En $ >4 J,'1 r 23 >4 U + c 0%LG ) .8 T3 24
BK+ B: > >'C #
; + (
%=4
# w%Na
) (."%4 1383 : 212
.(
.1 c– [ >4 >B[ Œ%BY @g0T1 > C )
@ .C S T3 C >4 o R
# >'- *+ >"3 1 Z
@%B0X B# @B9L1 >BX D
Ei 1 j 01 Q%T0 4 > - %=?
128 .B1 B?% .# @%F! ) + 8 B4 J,'B1 2B3 ) B
B W < c T%T: @ h% $ G3 .
B4 En B4 7Bi# 1 %=B? @%B0X e dB_ @9%Bb
#$ 4$ h9m1 4 *0 .L+ L3 )! W%+ .F G8 > $ > .p - .
.1 ,0m%_ ) _
$ d&+ + 8 - c g BT1 •sI >4 ; *8 r a 1
*B0 : ( =B/+
t BN'1 g@BU EnB $ >B4 )! .+ BO1 > # %&'# >4 ; *8 $ L"8
) reasonable suspicion
>B4 (
,m1 ; [ @ W& [ %1 <1 -
H B3 B r B8 b B 8 (; B ; B[ %NBa$ ># Y $ E*
l 9 >4
1 3 I
B%D B8 ! "B# B4 %B"_ c B%'R r Ba .
;$
(
`4 Ba
! "# _ }/m1 @%%O
h%O8 *0 :
j BO B | BR B4 J,'1 j O .&+ &X
B S BT3 Q BI ;sC ()! ` - $ c*1 $ h% $ 4 Y c 8s1 .&+ &X (J,'1 4 @ # 4 M ' ,+ $ h% $ >4 .# '# $ c 9# 23 hƒ1 B# *0'=1 $ ! "# 4 c K+ $ .0%4
)!
.
;[K : - \ ] /6 ) *+$ ,- *,&+ $ %&'#
4
#
>"%
( B%1 <1 c O] $ .# hO8 .=%"_ Y$ %+
>"3 1 BR B ( B& ) B1 Y q%4 > # .F W[ .# >%bi$ c T%T:
.1 d_ %#!
W D ) + 8 $ *4 .1 %"_
*B+$ $ B >B4 .b BL'3 c 1*BI *[ 1 *+
*- 4 ?% .#
hI 1 m . 32
Ei 1 $ .# # ) + 8 24
?% .# @%F! ) + 8
Ei 1 $ h u .O' xs4 $ ; ,g J%,?
5
%&'B# E + BR >4 rsgP ( *+$ ,- S T3 ) + 8
C b ; u c T1 >"L[ ) D*- .1 K+ : >"3 1 $ .=%"_ Y %&'# >
*B+
.
Ei 1 •g 1 1 >90 K0 I 21
; B[ 2 B1 ) 0C >4 ?% .# @%F! ) + 8
# 0'C h4 8 $ .# # c *[ $ ( ,m1 .
m > =%+ E* .b R >'9+ @ f
%&'# :I 4 U + > 1^1 ) '="&+
# >b ? $ Z
$ 2B%T: .'b BR Œ%Y
.L+ ) 0K1 >%"C h%b @%1^
*0 . E $ .0%4 4 c $ a $ ) 91
) C # *0X Y (
%&'B#
)! h u $ 4
#
>"%
(hB% $ >B"R *1 c $ Ba $ ) 91 (c 9# 23 ;sC c $ a ( u 4 ; T1
`Oa $ O] c $ a >LY
"# >4 Y |$ R $ $ $ $ Y c 8s1 $ >B d5 c $ a (.+ *+ H
(}/m1 c C # l R E $ mB1 2B3 WB%+ $ hB% $ B4 .I R ‡ L $ E $ m1 23
1sB# ŠB?3 >B4 %B"_ *B,N (E*B+$ _ >B4 h% $ J,'1 .# '# ) 91 (@%+ 8 o R
$ E*- %&'#
...
$ ) B mB $ c g BT1 2B%Op >B<%'+ >B # . C a 1 .&LY
'="&+
.1 . N1 ."R c g T1 Y .'# ) 0C >4 ,+! ()
*B0 . BT%T3 (
>B4 %B"_
4 .# *0 ! .m/4 H N ) 0C
* t I (}g/m1 $*3 $ < c I > *+ *4
*B- *BY R H p4 E*1! hLC >4 c T%T: (.1 K'+ $ ?% &%_ ) 91 K+
.
*B01 >p4 Ba
c g T1 ) O+
.B1 1 m %"_ hT'=1 Y %&'#
JB,1 ) B
> B% R @ B
4 @g0T1 > L- 4 K+ : >"3 1
*
*- 4 )! •sI *I .
VI^ _' [ Q>
- 50# "
1 . ( *+ R!
L:1 . ) 1387 ( (
^ * : )$
- (.1s# - $ A0Y c $ ) ,
: c m'+ $ … X ) 1 # .
2 . -!
*L:1 ( ).
1375 ( (
^ * : )$
( (H$ *"[
) , : L#
.
3 .
@%=3 ( %+ .F 8!
).
1386 ( (
@ ? ! () I A " ^ )
G# 6 A?
( ( ) , : ) W%1 .
4 .
*L:1 (."%4 ) . 1383 ( (
) 5 > 64 *
( -! *L:1 ' '# h%"< cu T1 >C L<1 ( ) ,
:
L# >N# $ 2%T: W 1 .
5 .
?N[ *L:1 ( $ &0b ?N[
).
1386 (
\ X # * a V=# 5
; # $ H$ *"[
( ) , : q+ —0D .
6 . ."C (.Tb R ) .
1387 (
^ * : )$ 5 (
) , :
q+ ,-
.
7 .
@ *b ; =3 *%# (.+ ,?I *%#
).
1388 ( ) <. 5 (
) , : ) W%1 .
8 . (.3sI
*BL:1 ) . 1386 ( ( : - * !D 4# . % , 6 . - * @ ? - N DX
b2 ) B _ (
.F OP OP >1sC E &m+ (*- .# 0- >1 + .
9 . [ ( O [ #$*"D .
) 1388 ( (
^ * : )$ 8
) , ( : h&0[
.
10 . ( 1
@=3 ).
1373 ( (
* 6 G# 6 H$ … X (
( ) , : ) W%1 .
11 . (.+*1
@ *bs[
).
1370 ( (
<
‹ 11 ( ) , : ) LY .
12 . A0- Y (E I + ) .
1372 ( (
5 ; Y Q ; +=
) E; ; ! /#
VB E L- 6 .
` - 5)# I
1-Franks, M, R. 2007,Your rights if arrested in England www.franks.org/pptr in England.
2-Feldman David. 2009, Civil liberties and human rights in England and Wales, oxford university press.
3-Garner’s.brayan, A., 2009, Black’s law dictionary eighth edition, Thomson west.
4-Holtman, J., 2002, Criminal litigation, London: 2002.
5-Herschel, David, Wakefield William, sasse Scott. 2008. Criminal justice in England and United States, Jones and Berlet publishers.
6-Murphy, Peter. 2002, Blackstone’s criminal practice, oxford university press.
7-Sanders, Andrew 8 Richard young. 2000,Criminal justice third Edition, Oxford University press.
8-Shepherd, Evic. 1998, police station skills for legal advisers, London,oxford university press.
