: ! " #
) :
2 / 3 / –91 :
15 / 8 / 91 (
:
!
"# # $
%
"&
$ '
"( %) ! * $ +# ( %
" , - # . "& %) ! *
# " / 0
# "(
1 $ & 2 . (
2 34
& 5 6 3( 7& .# # $ .
+ / 9 1 : ; & ") #
" , <
$
1 =*
%
"&
>5
?
%) < + $ @
(
* "
»
" , %
$
«
#
#
# 1 ; .
" , % ' $
! :.( $ +# <@
$1
!
- - C # D E
!
!D E 1 & 2 F/(
:.( 1 G 0 3 #
% $1
.
" , % $
@ - C # "& % 1 & ' "# $ !%) < + 1 @ 5 . "&
% %) .H
. I ! C
6 9 9 1 " ) +
" , %
$
"J
% (
.
:
!%)
%) !$ (
" , < + H3 K# " # ! 3 ' " # !$
!
" , %
$
* :
: 66409595 Email:[email protected]
: ! "
$ %& ' ( ) * + ,( -& . /)01 2( ( -, 3, , 4
/ 56 7 8591 : 5& (
43;
<*
( 2
interdisciplinary studies)
3=& - )9( >(
),:; :?9 ; .
, A 5 5,( 2 5 B 2
$ %& C()DEF9(
; >-, 3, G ( C F9 H -I%<J / & .
)9(
. -5 5 ' > H1 4 ( ; C( 5
-, 3, K9( :L( + 9( -, 3, $ %& C 9 ( -& . >M39(); C ) : & N ( 4 9
:<E :?9 ( 2(
- :?9 GO , ( 1 C(
(:P Q 2B( :R )5* ; G ()9
. 45 ( 5 (
GO ,
>2 N 0 ; C B SL
)5* G)59( 35*
. :5Q(1( B(
5A 1970 5N U53 5;
$ %&
5 / 5 :?9 B( -H 5 ; /(B( >$ %& 4 ( V . C WH /X N 1 -& E<H(
-9 WH
1C)*
;1 1 >
C 9 ; G U3%N
$ %&
-, 3, FLB ; . Y
» 5; 5 1 C)9( :LB ;
-%[( G \ H ](
« 6 H -%[( G) ( >
C , D*
,( G ; -J .
KA1_5R `5,( ()5 2 5A a
b
) 1979 ( c:d 1 : E5e*1 f5 :< 1 Y9( ( :<3R G(:EA ; 1( -; < 2Y )
1985 ( ()<5,(: 1
)9 ; C' )* ( 4 ( / ()P( 4 :<EW B( -`
:3
; . G)5* g& ; / WH 4 ( 5 1 5
55D9 / & 5. B( -635,1 h53d C 9 5 / 56 7 )
2 5` : ( 65,
>435 X
> 55 : (
2 3,' K 9 1 -P:*
1 -A)9 B , / 0i[(
-, 3, EA j9 H 1 9 a
; -9B / ,
43;
(:5P -%%E (
(Skocpol, 1985: 3) :53L .
( - )59( 5;
k(:5l >
$ 5%& :F53R C )5 >-5, 3,
2 A :` 1 1 G ; ,( -I%<J
m( ( ,( G)*
.
( ) C <
) 1981>1953 (
$ %& -%[(
59(: ' n5 B -\9 5\a -5, :; ( -, 3,
]B ( - 6 H A )9(
)
>4 5e 1 5,( R 1387
: 33
.(
5; -5, 3, K59( B( -5 % 45 ( )5Da:A
GB 0 ( 5D6 -F59( 21 5 5 1 C1); -, 3, K9( ( ,( M3E6 U; P Y39 -< 1 (: 2 A
39 .
; 1
C B , W9 C( D&
o 3E n; D n B 1 p3 J -%[( > 6 H G)DA
-& E<H(
social scarce resources) (
,(
. ,( G , -<36P(1 U[ 0 -; 3E :
n; D C ; 1)N
,( Q 1 AB 39 ; - \J, R 2(:;
1)N 9 2 A .
- 5E& 2 5AX >o 53E n; 5D B( ?D
:;1 ,(
) 1946 ( -%5[( <, , ( W9' /1:5q
>2 5<P(
5 YD 1 -& 5E<H(
/ )P -, 3, M3
,( G : 2)D;
.
) ) ; ( <* 9 4 ( 1 ; 9( 2(
2 :`
1 >C' 2 N C 9 1 , 3,
`j* V(Y9 C ` 1 >C' - A
,(
- M3E C( B( 2:<F3; MW, )D*
2:3L
)9:3\; 3<Q( ( o 3E n; D .
`j* , 3, :` 1 Y : (
2 5,( c:7 G) ( 4 (
1 . 0 : & > 9B1 YE3H :?9 ; -9 WH
>C)*
1 C WH MA B DA C WH , A
. r( ' 4 :<EW B( -Q:; 6 7 2(:;
> 9B1 . s :
> 9B1 YE3H ) 1378 (
>
» -L)3t3R uP D 1 A -9 WH 2 A C)*
«
>
% ' 5
>
* G E 52 p[ >C < B >
1034 - 1019 . 1
> 9B1 YE3H ) 1382 (
>
6 * '
1
>
-%& EH:
.
> 3d C(:W : ( /( F<9 G)`FA1_R 2 :jA( / 6 7 .
`j* ,( 2 ()Q >-, 3, KD / )5P B( 2:<F53; MW5, 0 :3L - A
)D< A . :` 1 4 ( - ) c:d ; 4<Q( :R 2(:;
-I3 U3%N ]1 B( G I<,( ; 45 ( ()5<;( >
K,:R - c:7 (
`j* U3%N M3D 3a 2(
5, = -5, 3, K59( C' G \ H 1 +
& . B: 1)0 M3* - =D ( -
M3A C F9 ( A :` 1 4 ( .
U53%N ; )6; KJ;
`j* j 9 :, ; A
- c:7 ( 3wP 4 ( >-& E<H(
:5, 5 M3D
>-& 5E<H(
B( -5`
`j* H - ( ( A
, .
`j* $1 )6x; :; Y :E ; 2 =DA )6x; -D6 A
) )56x; > 1( )56x;
2 <Q , ( - >
9 L G H1 ; C(
`j* C1 :, B( :\ 2(
-R A :;
: -56E<= :,
`j5* H :, -D6
y-[ 5<Q( 1 2 5N9( 2 5A :5,
5 2(
5=3<9 2 5AB:
-E`N
;Y E 2(:; ,(
zC(:\ ; -FJ ,( G)* = ( `j* B( { Q
.
>KJ;)5Da 45 (
`j* , 3, gN; ; 1 1 2(:; 2 1:. / ) 2(
)D< A . -5 C F9 >- W9 gN;
M35A
, 3, B( ?D
`j*
U3%N ; >2(
`j*
5,( 5 1 U3%N 2(
. 5 ( :5` 1 4
e
V . ( 1 > Q - 7D - - ) - (:P U3%N
)A . 4 );
, 3, :` 1 > D6
`j*
, 3, $ %& -%[( V . ; FLB ; C :H ( ( 2 :` 1 ) ; ( 2(
- 9(
.
# $%
& '
0i7[( > `j*
- ,( MWj .
45 ( B( G I<5,( 5tJ 5; : 5<J -A \9 ) ; >1:D ( B(
*( ci7[(
t9' B( 2:<W; s ;
» U3%N
`j*
2(
«
Network Analysis) (
- G)3 9 5*
, .
( ,( -0i7[( > `j*
6D[ GB 0 ()<;
- 5 2O 5 D`
(:5P G I<5,(
:L .
`j*
2O D` 2 A
technical networks) (
G( > <3 :<` ( )D9 B( 5R 1 oi. >4A'
(:P H `j* $ 9 ; -\EA 9:<D ( >C'
< :L )9(
. 6 H >C' B( R C B 5, -5, D*
C 3 /1 I gN; ; A C B ,
1 A (B ; >
1 A (:5P G I<5,( `j* ci7[( >
:L
Boyer, 2004) .(
1 :\9 3; `j* ci7[(>GB 0 4 ( 5H
-\DA 5EA -E5, :3l :3 5
; -9 9( C( (YL C 3
Granovetter, 1985) .(
( B( (SL 2 D6 ; :3 I 4
» C( 5D& 5; `j*
ci7[(
«
Network as a Term) (
; »
$ 5WI C( D& ; `j*
«
Network as a Concept) (
5,(
. :5;
> Dj 4 ( - fE ; , , 2 (Y;( `j* $ WI
-5Q:; |35. 5; P )D
)R G) M3* ; A .
»
`j*
« - ( 7;( B( -[ Q V 9 C(
> (: ( B( -D36 & E= 43; G)DA )9 3R
: h :6 n P1 r 3*(
)
>-` D3% 1 s 9 1387
:
.(16
& E= `j* >:\ / j& ; B( ,( 2(
G:L 7 9 , UP()0
node) ( } j ( 2 ()6 1
tie) ( } j ( H1 $)& H1 G)DA)9 F9
G:L C 3 A ,(
. G:L 4 ( - A )D9(
G1:L > (: ( 1 A)0(1 > A
5A C B 5, )D5* ;
)
1 C :<5*(
>C( `EA 1388 :
.(23
- h :6 4 ( 2 Dj :;
G 5 > `j* B( ?D IL C(
KD5 B( 2(
2 5A
C B ,( 4`E ,( $ : B( 2 3 ; 43; U; <
C 5` 1 A )5A 21 h5%<J 2 5A
)
4EL1:;
>
1389 :
.(14
EA >-% G \9 U53%N
`j5* 2 5A 5N 1 5 -5% rY5H 1 2( ( 2(
U3%N $ & -L_ 1 > W9' U3%N 1 Y= )D< A -, ,(
`j5* 2 A 5,( 2(
. 5N 1 45 (
B( )D j&
: / & . B( 2( <, G:L C EA
36P > A ~5;(1 B( 2( <5, 1 C(:\FD A
j / & . 4 ( C 3 A
edges) ( )9 3R >
A
links) ( )3 9 / d j ( - G
)9 * .
>M3A I 4 (
s B l'
`j*
G) )R B( 2(
,( -& E<H( 2 A .
`j* U3%N f3D` > A)< & E= ; 2(
- <IL - A (Y;( 1 A U53%N W9' •)A *
jDH 1 A <Q , 5,( `j* f A <Q , 4 ( -d j ( 2 A
Slaninov´a and et al., 2010: )
.(117
)DE*B ( / d j ( )
:q 5 1 ( 5 M3 < 5 >} 5j ( 5 )59 3R C( 5D& 5; C(:\F5D C 53
G:L C 3 >M3 < :3l - M3,: ~j : MA ; 2 A
5*
. -5 C(:\F5D > 5=D ( > (:5 ( )5D9(
A C B , G1:L
)D* ; ~j : MA ; 2 A)0(1 B( <, :A >-% d ; 1 A
1. : 4 ( ;
> 53
-
SNA C(
>-5<9:<D ( / NI5[ > (:5 ( B( -635,1 h53d >h5%<J c 7, U3%N 2(:; (
G ( 9 Q G1:L > A fa 2 A A C B ,
% -<0 1 >o(Y0( >€ Y; 2 :; ; A
Zhang, )
2010: 3-4
.(
# $%
( "
)
M%&
, 3, 6 H K9( •iQ:;
>-, D*
-E9 C(
`j5* $ 5WI 2(:5; 2 5 B ; ,
.
$ 5%& C()DEF59(
-5, 3, 5; 435 1( 2(:5;
5A ~5,(1(
1970 ci75[( B(
»
`j5*
2 (S\<, 3, «
policy network) (
G I<,(
)9 : . )56; ; C B 4 ( B(
I B( >
$ 5W
`j5*
5 2(:5;
5, 3, :; -< 1 :3l 1 -< 1 C(:\FD :3q h3[
• 5Q / E3E 5 5 5A
Hazlehurst, )
(2001
1
; G *( 2(:;
/(: 1 ; -< 1 :3l 1 -< 1 C(:\FD C 3 ~;(1 B( -; a a A
, 3, ‚ J ( 2(:;
G ( ; >) ' 1 , 2 A )D< 5A -5`< 5W9' / 5&id( 1 A
Alcañiz, )
(2010
G I<,(
)*
. C < 1 U; ,( - % 4 ( 4<
) 2007 ( D3 1 1:5 1
$1:5<
) 2001 (
`j*
(S\<, 3, 2 A - -% ( & ( 2
-,(: 1 ; $ ?9 h ƒ1 2(:H( U3W g& ; )D9(
- y * ) 9 ' 4m L )
2011 ( - V . 4 ( -, :; ; 2(
59 \a 1 (:a B( :R
`j* 4 ( ]i U3W g& ; 2 (S\<, 3, 2 A
2(:5H( 1 5jP - 5E& -5,(: 1 ; 2 5A
- 2 (S\<, 3, /( `<;(
* . -9 5 B -5,(: 1 ; ~5, 5`<;( f ]: SR >) 9 ' :?9 ;
1 .
> 4 ( :<F3; 6 7 2(:;
. s :
Watts, D. J. (1999), “Networks, Dynamics, and the Small-World Phenomenon”, American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 105, No. 2, pp. 493–527.
- k I ( n3,1 >: : SR‚ I9 2 (S\<, 3, `j* )< ( w5&( C 3 h36. 2 A)9 3R )H(1 1 :
)* ; - „ -9 B `<;( 4 ( 2(:H( 1 1 :<`a 5 >: S5R‚ I9 :<E 2 (S\<, 3, `j* )A
2( ( 3R )* ; w&( C 3 2 P 2 A)9
Arnold, 2011: 1) .(
`j5* 1( :5?9 ; 2 (S\<5, 3, 2 5A
5* <5*(SL (:5H( ; 1 jP `<;( f )D* ; <*( H1 ) ; - 1 I<
. 365.1 45 ( (
C( 5<; ) *
»
`j5* M 53 ( %R 2(
«
network pluralism) (
)53 9 .
`j5* :5` 1 5D 5; 2(
1 >2 (S\<, 3, -< 3 ( R 1 -< 3 ( %R :` 1
- 5; 2)0 )9 ( H1 Y39 -< 3<3 (
, 3, `j* -< 1 :3l 1 -< 1 C(:\FD :3q -5 2 (SL
)59B( :R . :5` 1 5 - 50
M3E 5 $ ?9 2 AB 39 :; :<F3; -< 3 ( %R > ( )53 2 (S\<5, 3, `j5* -5, 3, 2:53L
-< 3<3 ( :` 1 -
( R , 3, 4336 1 ~% K 9 :; :<F3; >-< 3 D A
K5 9
-55A(:EA G1:55L G)55DD 2 55A
C B 55, ( 55H 55<
Ranaei and et al., 2010: 136-145) .(
KA1_R 9 ) 2 A s
) 1994 (
`j*
, 3, 2 A -
5L g5& ; Y39 U53%N :<F53; ]:<
`j*
$ %& 2(
)* -, 3, .
1(
> Q 6 7
»
`j*
-, 3, 2 A :
MF5a 2 <Q 5, 2B()59(
«
>
`j* U3%N M5A 2 :5` 1 ( (:L <Q , -%3%N C( D& ; 2(
C 5 :H 5; C( 5Q K59( -%5[(
- -, 3, )9(
. E3A I 3A -, :; ; 1(
C a - 3<,:R >‚ I9 >/ )P >-9 _A _
1 ...
U3%N
`j*
,( <Q( :R 2(
. KA1_R B( -FJ;
Q < 2 A
$ %& : KA1_R >-, 3, 5; 5 )D< 5A - A
`j* :` 1 B( G I<,(
`j* :3q U3%N ; 2(
C()91:W* -d j ( 2 A :;
-5, 3, 5<
5W9'
<Q( :R )9(
. Q:;
KA1_R 4 ( B( - A
Leighley and Matsubayashi, 2009) (
G)* c:d - \ ( -
- C' B( G I<,( ; V D C 3 j 9 C(
,1:R 435; -d 5j ( 2 5A
<5, h5%<J 2 5A
C()91:W*
) G 3, >C <, R)3I, )D9 C(:H 5W >C <5, R
( 5[:& • 5Q 2 5A < B1:5; 5;
(:P U3%N ( -, 3, (
.
-* ; 1 -%\3
-L_ 1 ;
`j* /1 I< 2 A 2 5A
G1:L >-& E<H(
5j… 5, R K5,:R 45 ( ; >2 (_9 1 - P 2 A G (
/1 5I 5 ' 5 )59(
`j*
G1:L C 3 2 A 2 A
-& 5E<H( 365.1 1 536P /1 5I g& ; h%<J -
2 5<P(
(: ( :. 0
`j* 4 ( - A
2 A < U3%N ; W9' + * G1:5L 5; 85%6< (: ( -, 3,
2 5A
`j* /1 I B( 2) 3R ( A < 4 ( >h%<J 2 A
< 9( -& E<H(
)9(
C1 (:5 ( 45 (
- UE& C' )DD
.
KA1_R B(:\ -Q:; 2 N K,:R A
B( ; / j&
: ( 7a (:5 ( - 5J* / d j
`j* C1 K (:L > A W9' -, 3, 2 A
/ ; J<9(
GB 50 - 5A -5 U`5* ( ; F5 +)5A
, R B( -Q:;
4 ( ,( G ; 4 ( A
`j* / d j ( 9 L l( 5A
g5& ; 5%
s K (Y5 (
( -, 3, ( B( (:
-
*
Huckfeldt and Sprague, 1995) (
e/ 5d j ( 4 ( 1
`j5*
g5& ; 2(
-, 3, ( F ; (: ( 8 F
Klofstad, 2007; McClurg, 200) (
- () )9 o J<9( 1
pJF
Beck et al., 2002) (
-
* .
†9 , KA1_R 43H
†59 H
2009)
21 :5; (
-5, D* <
-% / ; J<9( - 6 7 ; - ` : ( C()91:W* C 3 - ; J<9(
, ` : ( 2000
Y539
- C F9 gN; )A
`j* C1 -, 3, 2 A 43; 2 A
-A 5L' K (Y5 ( 5; 5WD 9 - J*
fE (: ( -, 3, -
)D ( :;(:; C()91:W* C ( (:P ; `%;
G) ( > ` A
< 2
>/1 5I g5& ;
*
• I A() )9 C 3 w C)* : F |7, :; 8 :d C' B( 1 G)* W9' -A L' K (Y ( 1
- -<j… :3q -, 3, (SL
.
A , A
`j* U3%N D ( 2(
Q * 5< 2:3\EF5a ]:< L $ %& h%<J 2 A
,(
.
`j* U3%N 5,1 h53d ; 2(
A 56 7 )5D9 / & 5. B( -63 5
5A 1 -5, 3, 2
• `* >-\DA:
[:& G ; 2 A
`j5* :; C' :3q 1 - E&
-9)5 2 5A
Melucci, 1996; )
Doherty, 2003
(
`j* K 9 83 N >
:, )D (: U3W -& E<H( 2 A (: ( 2 (SL
KD -6EH
McAdam, 1988; Passy, 2003) (
K 9 U3%N >
A C B , 9 j%d1( 2
G1:L 1 2 A
2‚
nI9
`j5* - E&
2 (S\<5, 3, 2 5A
Laumann & Knoke, 1987) (
/ & 5. 3 5; 1
- :\
B( :R
Baldassarri & Diani, 2007: 737-739) (
A 1
<* B( -63,1 h3d ; M
$ %& 2 A
$ 55%& 1 -& 55E<H(
55 -, DF559(1 B( -55,)DW 55<P(
B( 1 55 / 355. 1 55 ' 1 : 3b 55
$:H -, D*
,( < G(
. U3%N > D6 4 );
`j*
M3 2 AB: 2(
( K59( B( f3,i 2)D;
,( G ( :33‡
. C( D& ;
> … 4E : U53%N 5 P 5 - & 5. h3d >
`j5*
5 2(
< :L (:P -, :;
C a 2 ( ( )9(
»
s:N 6 7
:; -D3F9:W* :3q >-%‡*
E0 > (: ( -
pJF >-& E<H(
/ 6 7 >-& E<H(
(B ; >-;
1 i,
...
« - )59(
Freeman, 2004: )
.(4
# $%
)" *+,
`D ( ;
`j* U3%N )*
E< 2 B )0 2(
; -& E<H( :, U3%N B( Y ( G
A B(
1990
`j* U3%N ˆ = )
; • (:< -& E<H( 2 A -& E<H( :, U3%N
< :L :?9 )5*
.
-& E<H( :, - WI
6 H >/ = > <P( ,(
5*()W; 1 -, D*
- 5E&
C' B(
1 C1 / d j ( ; G *( WH C 3
G I<,( -A1:L -
* )
> 57&
(.1391
5Wa >-% d ;
-5 ( -& 5E<H( :, :` 1 :E5*:; C( 5
: 5& EH :5` 1 59 (:L
Communitarian) (
>
`j* :` 1 2(
Networks) (
2 W9 :` 1 >
Institutional) (
MA :` 1 1 -5 (B1:39
Synergy) (.
`j* :` 1
:, 2 c:7 :` 1 Wa B( -` 2(
,( -& E<H(
.
& D< `*( 1 )6< h 6 2( ( -& E<H( :, -
,(
: 4E% 2(:; -& E<H( :,
) 1990 ( :<t3A 2(:; >-& E<H( 2 A =DA )
1983 ( R 1 ) 1993 ( jEA 2(:5; 1 -A1:L -\<
$ D R ) 1995 ( F C B ,
A ,( -9) 1 9 j%d1( 2 .
C EA (
‰5Š% d
) 1996 (
/:; 1 ) 1997 ( G *(
G :
`j5* ‹:<5, n; 5D 5; ˆ m()<;( -& E<H( :, >)9(
2 5A
( G *( -& E<H(
Lin, 1999b: 471) (.
G:5L 2 D6 ; 4 ( 5 ( C 5Q
5; -& 5E<H( :5, G)
`j* U3%N
`j* - % 2(
:, B( 2(
,( -& E<H(
. C EA > :` 1 4 ( 2 Dj :;
5 5d
- -6EH U`* MA 1 2 : / [ ; MA -9 9( :, -` Y3 :, 5H )5D9(
G:W; K (Y ( G:5W; :5; MA -& E<H( C( (YL C 3 ~;(1 1 -& E<H( / d j ( >)9 * 2 1
2 1
G1:L 1 (: ( - :3qΠA
)9 (SL . 4 );
G ; U6I ; n; D M (: -& E<H( :, > D6 2(
5,(
Q D5* 5 - D5*' :5; -5D<j G)5* 5D W9 K35; 1 M ~;(1 B( - (1 ; `j* •: ; G)* <, 3R MA ; :d1 )9(
. f5 •: 5 5N -& 5E<H( :5, M5=0 >‹ 5,( 45 ( :;
- 1( - A)9 3R `j* GB()9( ; > (YL M=0 1 C(Y3 ; 1 )D •3 ; 2:qŽ G N9 ; )9(
:,
; 2(
(YL f •: N ( -\<
5& E= U5 53` 5N -5<0 5 >
C' ; 1( ,( -9( (YL 5,( G :5 (:P:; )9 3R A
)
> 5 ; 1384 : 147 -
.(148
> :5` 1 45 (
`j* U3%N 1 -& E<H( :, :?9 4<, 3R MA ; U[ 0 ,( 2(
.
o <
» G:I0 2 <Q , 2 A «
Structural Holes) (
G)53D M5A 2 5 B :3q 5 /:5z; ) 91
`j* U3%N 1 -& E<H( :, C)*
*( 2(
. G:I0 C 3 } j ( /:;
/)5* ; 2 <Q , 2 A
5,( G :5 U53%N ( -& E<H( :, h6. 1 .
G:5I0 1(
( 2 <Q 5, 2 5A
» C 53 - ()5H
‹ E )m(B:3l 2 A «
Burt, 1992: 18) (
- )9(
. L( >:\ / j& ; G:5L C 3 } j ( C ` ( :
2 5A
) (: ( (
• `5* > F59 (:5P:; } 5j ( 45 ( ( )* ; <*( H1 `j* 1 5A
-
<Q 5,
-& E<H(
=) G:I0 2 <Q , 2 A (
- H1 ;
) ' .
>1( :?9 ; C(Y3
-& 5E<H( :, -<j 59
5;
5; -& 5E<H( :5, /• 5P 5`%; ()59 / d j ( 1 A)9 3R 2)DE )P G:5I0 C :5 :R
2 5A
( -\< ; 2 <Q ,
Burt, 2000: 11) .(
G) ( 1(
-5 ~ 5; ( 2(
s 5 45 ( B( K35R 5 )5A
: 1 9(:L )
1973 (
; G : c:7 .
G1:L B( { Q 2 w&( ; h36. 2 A)9 3R >: 1 9(:L :?9 ;
- G1:L 2 w&( 3 1 / &id( ] :L U3W g& ;
* . 5 5, D6 C()5; 4 ( 59
e/ d j ( C ; 2 P C1
C1:5; h365. 2 A)59 3R `%; -A1:L
43Ew5 ( 53 -5A1:L
- )D . :, B( 1( - %
`j* :; 2 B )3 >-& E<H(
-d j ( 2 A /1 5I< (:5 ( C 53
-
* . 43 C 9 ) 1982 ( c:d ; Y39
» -& E<H( n; D :?9
«
social resources theory) (
>
:;
1 5; 45 (
,(
% %, <Q , -& 9 -& E<H( Ci <Q , n; 5D p3 5J 8 :d B( ,( -j (:
- 4•36 / )P 1 -& E<H( 36P >/1:q C a 2 )6<
: SR
1. 1( :?9 ;
>
-& 5E<H( :5,
-D6 V E=
- ( (
`j* H 2 A A
Lin, 1999a: 30) (
1 B( 5 -56jD C( 5D& ; 85 :d
( - MA(: / d j
* G1:L > (: ( •()A( ; -; 3<, 2(:;
> A A C B , M5W 3 ; n ( H 1
,(
Zhang, 2010: 18) (.
<FR F )9(
3 5,( 45*1 >-5 % 45 ( C j :
:5, ~5;(1 2 (S5L
E<H(
, e FLB ; 2(:; ?<9( 1 -&
.
>V E=
`j* :` 1 - ( -& E<H( :, ; 2(
a C( 5 :5 5[iQ 435D :
:5,
H MW - ( ( >-& E<H(
d j ( o a a -
,( G)* (:P:; (: ( C 3 ,(
. 45 (
- G)3 9 `j* >o a a
* .
`j* ,( 2 :` 1 ; `*' ‘ 6 >- % 4 ( ( 5A
- -& E<H( :, B( -FJ;
)9(
. :, U3%N ) j9 )9 1 ; 4 ( :; -Q:;
5; ( -& 5E<H(
`j* U3%N 5H Y539 C' :5\ 56;( 5; )5 ; -& E<H( :, U3%N `%; ( U3% 2(
*(
Tinggaard Svendsen & Haase Svendsen, 2009: 3) (
$ 5D R /:;(
)
1380 :
(285
4 :5<EW >
,( :3Q( :` 1 n () :
» B 5, C L 9 L G H1 >-& E<H( :, B( ?D :53?9 -& 5E<H( C
`j* 1 A =DA > E<&(
,( A
«.
`j* >( `*' $ D R ( -WH1 ( A
:, B - -& E<H(
)59(
0
`j* :` 1 - :, >2(
:, -& E<H(
( 2 2 H
`j* C1 A 1 2) 3R
`j* H1 B(
A ,
Burt, 2008: 31) .(
- ./
:A 2 <Q 5, )6x; 1 :; <*SL B( )Da
structural) (
-<Q D5* )56x; 1 -
2 5=DA
cognitive-)
normative
( -; ( G)* )3 -& E<H( :, >853P -%`5* ; 1 4 ( C 3 2 (SLY E ) :
]i N
5,( • 5WR' 4’ 59 2:` 2 A .
• 5WR' ) 2000 ( 5 1:L 1( B( 5R 1 m
1 /:
:mi<, ; ) 2002 ( E G : M3,: )6x; 1 4 ( C 3 83P 2Y )9(
. U3W 5 g5& ; 2 <Q 5, )56x;
KD K 9 8 :d B( :d1 -6EH 2 A
`j* C1 H:; R 2 A - -& E<H( 2 A
5*
. 45 (
KD -5 -9 j3<F5R 8;( , 1 U0(: >439( P ; ˆ E& -6EH 2 A )9 5*
Hitt and et al., 2002) .(
DA U * Y39 -<Q D* )6x;
]B ( > A = K (:5L > A
5,( s:<F5 2 5A 1 ; 1 5A (Krishna &
Uphoff 2002; Uphoff, 2000) .
$ =9( (: ( t9' 2 D6 ; 2 <Q , )6x;
- K 9 U * )DA > 5A
1 >)&( P - ‹ 0( (: ( t9' 2 D6 ; -<Q D* )6x; 1 A)D (: 1 E6 2 A
U 5* )5DD
]B ( > A =DA ]:\9 > A
A - A 1 ; 1
* . -591:3; 2 <Q , )6x; - 0
extrinsic) ( 1
.1
>43 :?9 :<F3; 6 7 2(:;
. s :
Lin, N., K. Cook, and R. Burt (eds.) (2001), Social Capital: Theory and Research, New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Press.
G)A F G)A F 1 -91 2 =DA )6x; > ,( : SR ,( : SR 9
. G)E& KJ; )Da:A (
2 / 3; ( B(
`j* ; } ;: ( -& E<H( :, 2 <Q , )6x; >-& E<H( :, • (
< 59( 5A
Putnam, )
1993, 2000; Coleman, 1988, 1990; Ariaksinen, 2008; Van Deth, 2008
(
`j5* B( -5 % ( 5A
H C1);
A =DA ;
>
`j* U3%N 2(
,( pP 9 -%`* ; .
5H1 :; -Dj - )< 9 F9 MW H1 > (: ( C 3 G)9 * (:` U; < KD >-% d ; ,( `j* f
Ostrom & Ahn, 2009: 24) .(
:` U; < KD 4 ( 2( ( > (:5 ( C 53 G)9 5* (
,( - \ ( C EA
`j* <Q , ,(
.
> (:5 ( C 53 U5; < ~5;(1 2 \ ( >:\ / j& ;
,( `j* <Q , .
- > <Q , 4 ( C F9 )9(
:5<E 1 43 R ; X ; B( :<F3; -d j ( V 9 G)DA
X ; ; 43 R )
2 E& :<F3; <Q , (
9 1 :;(:; 9 (: ( C 3 (:5 ( C 53 -5 ( :<F53; -d 5j ( V
)* ; :;(:; ˆ j : .
<Q , - ( 2 E& :<F3;
`j5* C(
5Q 2 5A -
5N
ego-centric )
networks
( / 5[ 5; :<F53; >- 50 zC(:5\ 1 SID< : C 3 ~;(1 2 \ ( >C'
/( 5?<9( -5Q:; 5 <9( 1 <5, ; H( 1 X ; B( <,( Q 1)[
5,( 43 5R B(
. U53%N
`j*
- - 3%E& A)9 3R `j* 0 :; A <Q , > A 45 ( C(:\F5D / 3[ Q 1 )9 *
)9 ( 2 9 q 3EA( >U3%N V 9 .
5,( G (Y5L 45 ( ]: S5R 2 D6 ; M`0 4 ( -67P ]: SR :
`j* U3%N :` 1 5,( 2 <Q 5, U3%N 2_ (:<,( B( -% V 9 A
. 5;(1 4<5 C 53 ~
-5 -d 5j ( 2 A <Q 5, $()5 g& ; ( w0 Y39 -DA‚ 2: D& >C(:\FD 5*
. G ( (
-5E9 ( 2 `EA $1() 2(:; W9' ,( Q 1 `j* U3`F 2(:; C(:\FD 2 A <Q 5, 5; C( 5
*()DR C ` `j*
.
•()5A( C)35, ; • 76 > `j* f C(:\FD C) ' MA :L ˆ , ,(
,( s:<F .
)5DD -5 53 6 C' 5 -; a 5a B( (:5 ( - % V 9 1 •)A 4 ( 3A
)
`j* 2 AB:
( ,( A `j* B( 2:\ )6x; ; ~j : >
: -<Q D* )6x;
-
`j* 2 =DA .
)5Da:A
=DA >-% d ; ( ()9 H1 -D*1 :?9 V EH( > A =DA h :6 - ( A
C( 5
9( -9 6 B( - ?9 - 436 36P f :3 I 1 h :6 ; C' B( G I<,( ; :
B( :R
Horne, 2001: 3-4) .(
`j* :` 1 - MA ,( j 1 2:3FE* -& E<H( :, >2(
56ID g& ; )9(
)
=DA (
* - MA 1 C B 2 A) 3R )9(
2 ; )
=DA 9 (
<*(
)* ;
Woolcock & Narayan )
.(2000
:, 3A
`j* C1 - A C :H A
)D< A j ( >
53A 5; -E3 < 5 }
( A =DA 9
) .
-5 pJF5 `j* f 2 A =DA
`j5* C' C1 :5, 53A 5 )5D
3a .
-% ( `j* H :, 3A
- |7, 4 : 1 -& E<H( :, 1 ; C(
: M3 -6E<= :, .
:5, C 53 Y E $ & 36 :5, 5; -& 5E<H(
-56E<=
| :[ -%`* ; ,( 2 =DA -5 U3`F ( 2B ; G)& P >-DE.
)5A : 5; C)35, :5L(
( H1 $)& ; }1:F >o 3E n; D
`j* ; } j M< 53, B( { 5Q 2 5A
5 >)5* ; 2:5\
-%[( -6E<= :, :, 4 :
,( 2(
5 -; 53 :L( >U; y ( H1 `j*
z:53l 5; } 5j ( 1 5j 5H1 5; }1:F >o 3E n; D B( 2:<F3; )0 ; -; 3<, B( { 5Q
- f Y9 -& E<H( :, 3A ; `j* C1 :, >)* ; M< 3,
* . 4 );
:, > D6
:, -6E<=
Q( 1 2 5N9( % 5Q )5H(1 5,( 2(
-[ 5<
exclusive) (
5 - 50
B 5; 1 2 5N9(:3l >-& 5E<H( :, -%[( -L_ 1
inclusive) ( 5,( C' C 5;
. )5Da:A
:, ( -6E<= :, >-& E<H( :, / 3; ( C1 -& E<H(
- -A1:L 2( ( )D9( Q
-; -L_ 1 M -d j (
U3`F 2 A)0(1 C 3 -d j ( G)DA
G1:L f G1:L : , ;
( ,( A
I5[ ki5d( 5d 435EA 1 A =DA ; :, 4 ( 3A } j ( U3 ;
» -& 5E<H(
« 2(:5;
G) )R -E9 ( C' >-& E<H(). 2(
)3 9 -& E<H( :, C(
.
C1 -\< jEA :; 2 3 ; )3 =D ( C1:5; } 5j ( 2 H ; -A1:L
-5 -5A1:L 5*
Oorschot, 2006) .(
(
; 4 -6E<= :, < ; <Q , 2 D6 :5, B 5; <Q 5, U5;
{ 5Q :<E 1 C1 :<F3; >n; D :\ 1 / &id( >-` 2 d ; ,( -& E<H(
,( KQ:a 0 G1:L B(
. :\ U;
2 G1:5L C1 n5 B 5; o 53E n; 5D >
G)F9 1)N )9(
. U &
-\< jEA A d ;: `j* (:a ,( - 30 -6E<= :,
-5 5 C(:\ ; Y E 4 ( B( ( Q )5D
. A 53A >1:5D ( B(
`j5* 5 :5, 2 5A
(:P >-6E<=
; -< 39 L <9' 7;( f 4<*(
» C(:\
« ,(
.
\ :d
B( 2:\ , >C(:
MA ; -\<I3*
%0 1 C( 1 ; ,( C ` Y9 2 A
. 56 H U53%N “ 5N 5; >n5P(1
<Q D5*
-
>
-& 5E<H( ~5;(1 C)5* -%3 5 A 5; K (:5L ,( -<36.1 - 7D - -6E<= :, )* ; < :L /)*
.
%3 A -
homophily) (
G) )R >
( 2
~;(1 gN; D*' 5; 1 ,( -& E<H(
- kid( -<36.1 9 3R = ( ; 2) )* K (:L (: ( C' *
-9 5 5; -& E<H( 2 A)
)D5* ; 5W9' 5Q 5; 3j5* ˆi 5 5 )59 (
Coleman, 1958; Lazarsfeld & Merton, 1954; )
McPherson,Smith-Lovin & Cook, 2001
.(
,( 4*1 2 4 ( 87D :
» / 5d j ( > ; F5 B(
- G (B
*
Similarity breeds connections) (
«
Yuan & Gay, 2006: 106) .(
1 :53l 5; 5Q
/)*
2 A)5 3R %EH B( C W; F ; -\<I3* D C(:\ ; j 9 -ID / , 0( 4< :L
- o N -%3 A
* .
- `j* f C1 C(:\FD )Da:A 5Q •()5A( 5 )D*
)5DD 85 N ( )
2 5Dj :5;
:6 : SR -59i & o J<9( 2 V 9 C' B( 9 (:L : -, D*
G)5* 5<
( :5, 5 (
KD B( U[ 0
* - o N -6EH - ( ( > W9' 2 A .
5N9( 53A :5, < 5; 1 2
- g& ; -6E<=
`j* >nP( B( 2 3 ; * 5; :53L > % 5Q 4 ( U 0 2 A
5; 2B
`j* : , ; :I[ nEH U[ 0 )9 * A
. V 9 4 ( -5 C' ; -& E<H(). -<3A >KD )F5J;
.
(
‹ :; A 4L ,( 2)91 C EA 4 )
1975 ( -& 9 C( D& ; C' B(
» -[ 5<Q( ,1:R -
-9) C)*
«
civil privatism process) (
- )D
1. : B U`* 1
>
:, /1 I 5; -& E<H(
:, f3 E* / [ ; -6E<=
G)* M3,:
,(
.
`j* C 3 } j ( >U`* 1 4 ( A
0 1 ,( G)* G)3F : ; -.:
. 0
`j5* C 3 } j ( > 1(
2 5A 56 5
f
`j* ,( GB 0
; A :,
”3A C 3 -d j ( >-6E<=
`j5* B( $() 5A
C1 5a
GB 0 f )
GB 0 ˆi…
5, 3, - ( 1 5a GB 50 C 53 5A
()59 5H1 .
} 5j ( 53EA( )5Da:A
`j*
2 A GB 0 2 A V . >:\ )` ; h%<J G)5 ( U ‚ ( 39 <* 9 4 (
5; 56 H
V 5E= C( 5D&
`j5*
B( } 5j ( U`5* 455 ( > 5A 53EA(
X 55;
( 5Q:; - 5,(
.
`j5*
55;
:, E<H(
>-&
`j* ‹ `6 36.1
; :, -6E<=
,(
.
U`*
1 :
`j*
2( ( :, U`*
2 :
`j*
2( ( :,
-6E<=
) C L)D 9 ( -& E<H(
) C L)D 9 (
2 1
3 4
9 > :, 1 4 ( C 3 Y E C 3D;
/ ,( `j* B( C1:3; zC(:\ ; } j ( -L ; =DA .
C EA
nEH :A d
63,1 - -E9 ( )3 9 6 H C(
) C EA 4 (
)9 D : ,( 2Y E
1 . -[ <Q(
C)*
privatism) (
-[ Q B( /1 I<
C)*
privatization) (
,(
. 1 M< 3, ]:< L ; >‹ :; A :?9 ;
j%d1( F >- E& [:& C1 ; C' $ =A - (1B ; 1 - E& [:& 9
1 . C(Y3 B( > 36.1 4 (
KD
`j* 2B 1 KD M=0 ; 1 <, - E& 2 A
`j* 2B 1 - G 1Y ( -[ Q 2 A
* . ,1:R 4 ( ‹ :; A (
-[ <Q(
- -9) C)*
) 9 . C B' 6 7 2(:;
-;:=
> :?9 4 ( . s :
Wuthnow, Robert and Clifford Nass (1988), “Government Activity and Civil Privatism:
Evidence from Voluntary Church Membership”, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, Vol. 27, No. 2, Jun., pp. 157-174.
! 2 1
3 4 !
) % !! !
! ! !( ,
!! ! ( , ! %
!
39 ) 1887 ( FDE3L C 3 )
V E<H(
( F YL 1 )
6 H (
; G : M3,:
( :, :A >
2(
`j* C1 -E9 ( ,( -& E<H( 2 A
)3 9 -& E<H( :, C(
. :, $ WI
- -6E<=
83P MW ; )9(
:, :
\FD C 3 ~;(1 <IW9 2 A C(:
)D fE .
4 ( 9 L
-; Y E - A KD )A C F9 ; )9(
- 1 I< • <9 >Y E< -<3A ; -d j ( 2 A
*( )DA( Q .
`j* > D6 4 );
2 N9( -<3A ; GB 0 :A 6 2 A )
6E<= :, -
(
`j* ; /1 I< ˆi 2) 3R 1 2 N9(:3l -<3A ; A
B ; ) :, -& E<H(
( )DA( Q
*(
. :, a:L(
`j* B( -Q:; H -& E<H(
- ( ( > A
`j* C(:\FD -[ Q
IH >~;(1 4 ( > 39 n3,1 ~;(1 B( - ?9 ; ( MA ; ~j : :\FD 2 A
- U < : )D
Scott, 2000: 3) (
- ( > WH 4 ( B( 1 ,( -6EH
) C(Y3 >:\FD :A G \ H ; < ; )Da:A
G:W;
; )A( Q /1 I< Y39 - ( ( 4 ( B( 2)D (
B( :\ -Q:; H -6E<= :, (
`j*
( ( > A - - )A ; C)3, ) P ; ,( -9(:\FD -[ Q )
C(:\ ; ).
:I[ nEH U[ 0 ; 2B ; f (
`j* >
( 1 < ; 2(
G ( U3`F 2 N9 )9(
.
:L(
1 ( -, 3, GB 0 :\ B ; 4 :<EW G 5\9' >M39();
5, 3, U53%N -%5[( V 5.
`j*
2(
Network Politics) (
, 3, G \ H C( D& ; 1 U3%N ,( 2B 1
: 5; 21 1
`j* s B( G I<,(
-& E<H( :, B( 2(
.
`j* s :, B( 2(
2(:; C' ~ ; 1 -& E<H(
-& . , 3, U3%N K9( ) )H
-, 3, ,(
. - C 3 4 ( KA1_5R 5; C( 5
2 5A
`j* U3%N B( : G *( :3W9' / E%A 1 -9 KjDH 433j 2(:; 2(
1 -& 5E<H( 2 A
G : G I<,( , 3, [:& ; W9' 1 1 )9(
. - -9 I<,( ; )*
`j* U3%N B( G 5; 2(
Kj5DH - 5N )591 -\9 \a 1 -< 3a -& 5E<H( 2 5A
- B( :5b; -5, 3, .
U53%N 1(
`j*
nP(1 -A \9 ‚ J ( 2(:; (Y;( 4 :<W; ( 2(
-5 -& 5E<H( 2 A <Q 5, ; (:L )59(
Diani, )
2003: 4
.(
: W9' E%A )
2001 >
2004 (
`j* :` 1 B( G I<,( ; Y39
; 2(
6 H U3%N -9)5
- -9 WH B( :R
. 1(
2(
Anheier, 2003) (
oY0 :ID 2 w&( K 9 G 1 C E ' 2B 9
1925 1930
>
]:< 5L :5; C' :3q 5 1 2B 9 oY0 C 3 0 L:H ; w&( 4 ( {1:Q 1 1 1
0 KjDH M B 9 -
- (:P U3%N ( )A
.
`j5* , 3, :` 1 ( 1 >2(
2 :5`
( :3 4 ( ,( Y E<
.
`j* U3%N ; -& E<H( :, 2 83I%
`j* :` 1 -D6 2(
>-& E<H( :, ; 2(
`j* , 3, U3%N :< ; ,( 2(
.
`j5* 5, 3, U53%N -%5[( } 7Q >-% |7, ( 2(
- : [iQ 43Da C(
:
`j* C1 -[ Q n; D A
2 :H -, 3,
< 5; )D< A C
:5, U 5* > `j5* B( C1:53; zC(:\ ; `j* C1 (: ( 4<*(SLY E V 9 ; H(
5 -& 5E<
:, - -6E<=
* .
`j* 4 ( - A
B( 2:<F3; MW, )D*
M3E / )P
2:53L 5
6 H o 3E n; D )
-, 3, / )P (
5 1 B( 2:<F53; MW5, -D6 (
)D5* ; <5*(
. B(
>1:5D (
`j* , 3, B( ?D
`j* U3%N ]1 ; >2(
,( 1 U3%N 2(
. MA > =D (
-
& E= C( D& ; ( 1 C(
`j* B( 2(
o 53E n; D :, :; ; P 6 -, 3, 2 A
1 9(
- MA 1 1 B( KJ; :A C(
) :A )D9 , 2( P B( f 5 - 5?9 2 5A1:39 9 L
-<3D ( (...
(:5 ( B( $()5 :A >C' : U3%N pJF 2 AB: ; -; a a C( D& ; (
-9 5 _A 5 W9 1 Q `j* : X ; G \ H 4< :L (:P :, :; `j* :A :. 0 )D< A ; P 0 >-, 3, / )P •: •)A ; 1 B( KJ; C' .
V 5. > Dj 4 ( :;
N -%[(
`j* , 3, U3%
`j* V(Y9 >2(
/ )5P B( 2:<F53; MW5, 0 2(:; -, 3, 2 A
,(
.
<, 1 :E< } j ( 1 >G:L 1 UP()0 C' ,( -; a a >-, 3, `j* f 2(
( H1 Pi& / & . B(
. G:L >f “ N ;
> (: ( U * A A C B ,
:5\ 1
-< A D< A -& E<H( 2 A )
. C 53 :E< 5 / d j ( > D6 4 );
5A C B 5, 2
-5<0 1 -5, 3,
`j* H1 2 D6 ; A F B( - A
A C B , 5,( A F5 1
. V(Y59 5 5 1
5A >
( -%[( V .
% %, r GB 0 / )P (:
43;
-%%E ( ,(
.
- 1
`j* V 9 1 -, 3, GB j C 9 )9(
; -5, 3, 2 A )5*
:
`j5*
-5, 3, 2 5A
1 2 N9(
/
`j*
B ; 1 2 N9(:3l -, 3, 2 A .
> 5 1 -J 5 <Q , 1 D3F3R )Da:A
A 2 AB:
- pJF C(:\FD 2(:; ( -[ Q -<
2)D ( 2_ (:<,(
`j* C(:\ B ; 2 A 2 A
o a 5a $1()5 -%[( U & >-, 3, 2 <Q 5, 2 5A
- 5 5,( 5 1 -J .
B( -5 % 45 (
<,(
]i N >2_ (:
:` 2 A 2
; ) 1992 ( ,(
. 2_ (:<,(
`j* C(:\FD 2 A 2 5A
55,( ( <55,( -55%E& 8557D 2 55Dj :55; -55, 3, .
`j55* 2 55A =DA >1:55D ( B(
1 -55, 3, 2 55A
2_ (:<,(
-5 > Q `j* B( { Q zC(:\ ; -FJ;Y E 2(:; W9' 9 A L' 2 A 2 5AB: )59(
pJF ( -, 3, $ ?9 )D
. C1 > 1(B 4 ( B(
1 A :5, 5; -, 3, `j* 9 L 1
,( C :H /1 I<
:
`j*
`j* 1 -6E<= :, ; -, 3, 2 A :5, 5; -5, 3, 2 A
-& E<H(
. 1 A 2 ( - )53 & 2 5AB: <*SL 2 (:b -
)5 ; ( )D<5*( (:5P -< 5A
1 .
; :3R - - W9()3 & E= ( 1 Y39 )9(
C' C(:\FD - V(Y9 / )P :, :; -, 3, )DD
)
>4<9 1 G: *
1385 : 84 .(
.2
:3 ; -\< ;(1 G) ( 6 ˆ j : G (YL 4 ( Path- Dependent)
( 2 -J - (:L W9 2 A ,(
.
; -\< ;(1
:3 - <IL -<36.1 ;
* G)D ' F 2 W<, 3, (:` g& ; <*SL 2 W9 o J<9( f C' * .
. s :
Pierson, P. (2004), Politics in Time: History, Institutions, and Social Analysis, Princeton:
Princeton University Press.
1 A
`j* ; - :, -, 3, 2 A
1 >-6E<=
1 A 2 1 -D3 B:5, 2 AB: C )
( )D< A -% 3E 0 )H(1 1
A
`j* ; - 2 A
:, -, 3, : - % -& E<H(
.
`j* / & . 5,( / )5P > 1 9 L 1 :A -, 3, 2 A
. 5Pi& 5 V 5.
`j*
(:3R C1 Y39 V(Y9 UN 1 / )P >-, 3, 2 A 5,( 1 C
. 5 C' 5WH 5;
M3E > 1 G \<, : 5<WH 5W9' •3 5; 1 56 H n; 5D p3 J 2:3L
-
• Q
`j* > ,(
G \ H B( 2:<F3; MW, )9 ( ]i -, 3, 2 A )
D ( ( -5< 1 2 5A
)DD 0 .
-5, 3, o 53E n; 5D 5; -,:<, C(Y3 -D6 V(Y9 V . )
-5, 3, / )5P (
`j* f 2 AB:
- 4336 ( -, 3, )D
. n; 5D 45 ( 5; -5, 3, `j5* f5 -,:<, a:A
:\FD 2 AB: >)* ; :<F3; -, 3, o 3E 2
n3,1 Y39 `j* C' 2 (SL:3q 1 5; )5A( Q :
.
5; U )5j 53%; P -& 5E<H( 5 YD 1 2 5<P( /1:q -D6 -& E<H( o 3E n; D :\ :L(
; <*( -, 3, / )P U53Q -5, 3, `j5* :5A 2 5AB: •)50 4336 Y39 ( W9' ) ; >)D*
9(
.
>-% d ; 43536 >V(Y59 V 5. C( D& ; -, 3, / )P $ WI
H G)5DD
•)5A 1 G 5\
KD B( -, 3, C(:\FD 5,( 2( `j5* 5, 3, U3%N GO(1)3% >2B 1
.
>/ )5P > 5=D (
-5 5P ( :\F5D ,( -9i & 3 :ƒ C 5 < 9 -%`5* 5; 5 B 5,
asymmetric) (
:5;
, / E3E 9 L ; (S\; :3q C(:\FD :
,( Q 1 n D >G ( ( WH W9' 2(
2 5A
)DD $()P( -%[( :\FD .
K (:L f >/ )P , D6 4 ); -9i & 3 :ƒ )
2 : ,( Q
-DA‚ 1 (
~;(1 -& 9 `%; 39 )
-D3& / 9 ` ( (
,(
. 9 5 5, D6 4 )5; Y39 C ; C <
1 -<% Q >~;(1 2 (SL:3q - 0 f5 F53EA >/ )5P ~5;(1 5 ( ( ,
: X ; , :\FD
<*(
,( 4 : , B( :<F3; 1( 2 (SL:3q )0 1 .
4 );
`j5* >21 5 2(
% %, : X ; (: 2 <Q , “ N ; ˆ 6jd 1 ,( / )P (:
2:<F53; 2 5A (Y;( )H(1
53j… 2(:5; Y539 2:<F53; C 5` ( > ,( Q •()A( 2 , ; -; 3<, 2(:;
536P 1 5Q
M3E / )P :<F3; K (Y ( C :H 1 2:3L
( 2B , .
oz:e :?9 ; )
2004 (
>C 5` 1 36P >
C EA (:a ,( - id C 9 P
<`9 4 ( ; ) ; /i‡< 1 si ( d : H
`j5* U53%N > ( (:5P :W5* 2 5= >f5% 4 ( `j5* C 5` 5; )5 ; Y539 2(
% %,
*( H U3%N GB 0 (:
. 57;( Q 5, U53 5; > H1 4 ( ; C 5WH 2(
)P ”3A > , 3, -
39 8%7 .
45 ( C)3F5 K 5a ; 1 1 C ` ( F3EA > D6 4 );
H1 ~;(1 (
. 2 LB 5, 1 8; 57 21:539 B( ]: S5R $)5& 1 5 1 21:39 - \DA
- C L:L / )P ~;(1 > * :<F3;
)9 * . /(:533‡ 5D ( Y39 / )P ~;(1 -9 L:L )0
- pJF ( 2 <Q , /X N 1 2 W9 )D
Castells 2009: 10) .(
MA ) ; ( G \ H $ WI $ 5WI ; )9 3R
» 5 Y :
«
centrality) (
59(
.
$ 5WI >n5P(1
C F9 Y : C < 9 % Q G)DA
`j* / )P C ; ,( A
.
`j5* , 3, 5; … 5; 2(
`j* C1 (: ( ; P :5; ~% 5 1 5Q C 5 (:3R ~;(1 `j* :; -9 _A 2(:; -, 3, 2 A
G R - Y39 ( 1 B( 2(
5 Y : 1 Y : $ WI P C(
C1 -D3; 5D3;
1 `j5*
C 3
`j*
N A
(: ( D6 4 ); ( (:P U3%
( 5Q `j5* -D3; D3; 36P 2(
B( >
C ` ( 5Q C 5 (:3R ~5;(1 `j5* f539 _A 536P 4< :5L (:P 2(:5; 2:<F3; 2 A
Q:;
)D< A ( . (:P M`0 4 ( f39 _A 36P 4< :L
`j5* 5& E=
2 5A
,( k [ Y39 1 B( G R f C1 .
`j* , 3, 5 Y : -5D6 Y : V 9 1 >2(
C1
`j*
43; Y : 1 2(
`j*
( H1 2(
.
C1 Y :
`j*
5 :5 36.1 ; 2(
- 3 6 C' -[ Q `j* zC1 ( G *( 2 (: (
>: X 5; H B( >)DD / 5d j (
o %7 36P 1 :<F3;
)D< A ( Q:; 2:
. 43; Y : >U;
`j*
2 (: ( : ; 2(
536P 1 :<F53; / 5d j ( >: X 5; H B( > `j* C1 C F<36P Ml ; ( G *(
o %7
`j* B( -63,1 & E= C 3 : )D< 5A ( 5Q:; GB 50 f5 6 2 A
. 5W9'
`j* Y : 4<*( Ml:3%&
U5R K 9 > Q -d j ( 2 A
`j5* C 53 -d 5j ( 2 5A 2 5A
- W9' ; 2:`FD -` _ (:<,( K 9 > 36P 4 ( 1 )9 ( G)W& :; ( h%<J )A
. 1 Y5<D3
Y ( * ) 1985 ( C' -%3%N (
»
‹( U53%N «
peak analysis) (
-5 45 ( 53EA( 5; )5D 9
R U
`j* U3%N -d j ( 2 A G : G *( 2(
)9(
1.
(
`j* 9 3 2 (:
)9 ( (:P h%<J 2 A )
`j* Q `D ( :; G1i&
( ~5;(1 B( 2(
G ( U`* Q C (:3R )9(
( 2 (Y B( >
» C 53 -L 5;
«
betweenness) (
-5 G I<5,(
)5DD . /:5;
) 1999 ( 2:5` C(:5jA (:a `D ( U3%N >)D< 5A ( 5Q:; - X 5; -& 5E<H( :5, B(
G1:L C 3 2 AB: 4<*( (:P 1 W9' 36P ( 5A
53 M5W 5W9' -& 5E<H( :5, C(Y
- )9(
.
`j* , 3, MA(:5 r w5&( EA 2(:; -6 D >~;(1 B( U[ 0 :, a:L( >2(
- 0 >V 9 ˆX1( > : :A G \ H ; < ; ( )D 5 :533‡ 1( / d j ( ()6 1 M=
-
>ˆ 539 q 1 )5D
nI9 C(Y3
; )A( Q /1 I< 1( 2:;
.
`j5* G 5\ H 1 `j5* :5 G \ H ; < ; >4 (:; D;
-5 :33‡ 1( / )P 3EW, > 1 Q , U 1( ~;(1 )5D
. H :5; )53 45 ( 5 ( 1 G 5\
-; ]: SR 2 D6 ; 36P G \9( }:* 1 )3P
A
• 5Q 5; 5 39 9 (:L <Q , 2
.1
C' )9 1 ; 4 ( :; W9'
; ( (Y= `j* 1 Y : 2( ( 1 )DE )P : 1 ‹( 7 9 1 > … C( D& ; 2Y3a
`j* / )P >1:D ( B( 1 >U[1 MA - 8%Q ( 2(
`j* 1 4 ( C 3 -d j ( UR K 9 ,( 2 : 7 9 >)D ( (
. 2(:;
:<F3; 6 7
>
. s :
Mintz, B. and Schwartz, M (1885), the Power Structure of American Business, Chicago:
University of Chicago Press.
:?9 >C' 2 Dj :; 1 ,( G)* < : SR -< 3 ~% 2 A
» GO 5, 5 YD 5; 9 (: ( 2 5A
C 3D;
‡*( M`0 ~ `%; > (SL Ci 0 1 C L)DD
träger) ( G \ H - A : 1 A 5 )59(
- UE& )3 / j, D C1 )DD
.«
)
>:%3 1384 :
.(11
`j5* U53%N F5 )9( 5`9' Ml:3%&
5; 2(
G 5\ H 1 36P U3%N > ,( / d j ( 1 ~;(1 U3%N ; / 3[ Q U3%N B( (SL 2 D6 - C F9 -, 3, -L_ 1 )A
•: 5 ; `j* ( -A \ H 2:\FD / 3[ Q 1 A
Q G 1' - >
C ` ( ; )9(
4 ( 2 A )FJj; 3%6 G \ H .
<IW9 <Q , 83I% >nP(1
<IW9 2 (YL 1 36P 4336 >:\FD G ( ( 1 ,( Q
B( f5 :5A ,( -EW, G)DD
; )DA( Q ( Q:; 6 H H o 3E n; D B( -, 3, C(:\FD .
$1()5 >n5P(1 4 (
-L_ 1 C EA
» C < 9 -L ; «
asymmetricness) (
:; n; D n B 5,( G \ H 0
. 45 ( :5;
`j* 4< - w&( C 3 1 C < 9 -%`* ; o 3E n; D > Dj :\ )` ; ~;(1 B( 2(
< )9 3R G:W; 1( ()6<,( 1 ] A 1 :\FD :A G \ H ; < ; )9(
K<36P 5 B( 2 ( :5;
- n B > `j* <Q ,
* .
V E=
:A , 3, [:& >
5 9( 2 B (: ( C 3 / d j ( C j9( ) ; ( F
- )9 1' , ; ( R 1 YD >/ )P o 3E n; D B( 2:<F3; M=0 )D*
. G 35* 45 (
`j* , 3, :` 1 >U3%N 2(
5
»
`j5* 5, 3, 2(
G)5*
«
networked politics) (
( $ 59 .
`j* , 3, :` 1 U3%N B( /1 I< 2(
,( 2 (S\<, 3, `j*
. 5; 2 (S\<5, 3, `j5*
2B ; :3q 5 2(:5; -5< 1 :3l 1 -5< 1 h%<J C(:\ B ; C 3 ( G *( - A :5; 2 (S5L
/ E3E 5 :5; 2 (S5L:3q B( 2)591 5; G 5*( 5 ( C 5 :H -5[ Q M3E 5 , 3,
`j* , 3, - 0 ,( f3 (: 1 ; KD ; G *( 2(
- A C (:3R 1 C1 (
(:; 1
•: 2
B( 2:<F3; MW, / )P
,( C :H -, 3, C(:\ B ; C 3 .
0 +- P 1 $ WI ; ci7[( B( (SL ; `j*
`j* U3%N 2)D;
I\* :3 >2(
B( 2Y3\9(
- ;:= ( U3%N D ( ]:< L )D
.
<5* :<E ) *
$ 5%& • 5Q 5; >2(
>-& 5E<H(
`j* U3%N B( C' )* ; )5* ; G)F59 G I<,( 83 N / & . 83E6 2(:; 2(
.
3, $ %&
: , B( : : )Da:A Y39 -, K9(
A ~,(1( B( > A 1970
`j* U3%N >
5 P 2(
`j* U3%N :L (:P H 2 (S\<, 3, 2 A
.
`j5* :5` 1 2 (S\<5, 3, 5; 2(
,( G : )* -< 3 ( R 1 -< 3 ( %R :` 1 1 D .
`j5* :3q U3%N -d 5j ( 2 5A
U`* C()91:W*
/ & 5. 5; A)56; Y539 5, 4 ( B( - & . 1 -, 3, < 2:3L
`j* U3%N B( G I<,( ; -%3%N ,( G)* G 1Y ( -, 3, $ %& 2(
. 1 V . B DA (
, C( D& ; 5,( 5< :L (:5P 5%Il 5 -, 3, $ %& -9 9 GO
. U53%N -%5[( V 5.
`j* , 3, ,( , 3, G \ H C( D& ; 1 U3%N 2(
: s B( G I<5,( 5; 21 1
`j*
-& E<H( :, B( 2(
.
`j5* U53%N ; -& E<H( :, 2 83I%
:5` 1 -5D6 2(
`j*
; >-& E<H( :, ; 2(
`j* , 3, U3%N :<
,( 2(
. -%5[( } 7Q >-% |7,
`j* , 3, U3%N - ( 2(
: [iQ 43Da C(
:
`j* C1 -[ Q n; D -, 3, 2 A
Y E V 9 ; < ; )D< A C :H
> `j5* B( C1:53; zC(:5\ 5; `j* C1 (: ( 4<*(SL
-6E<= :, -& E<H( :, U * -
`j* 4 ( `D ( Ml:3%& y * - A
MW5, )D5*
5 YD 1 2 5<P( /1:5q >-5, 3, / )5P -5D6 56 H H o 3E n; D B( 2:<F3;
5,( -, 3, / )P ; -; 3<, >V(Y9 -%[( V . >)D* ; <*( 3<Q( ( -& E<H(
. U5N
5,( 5 1 C 5 (:3R 1 C1 5 -5< 1 [:& >V(Y9 .
)5Da:A
<Q 5, 5 853 N
U3%N 2 N C 9 >-& E<H(
`j*
`j* , 3, ( ,( G ; 2(
5; C 5 YEA 5H 5; 2(
-<Q D* 6;( 1 2 <Q , 6;(
- 2_ (:<,( V 9 1 A =DA 3I3 :; >2 =DA C(:\F5D - A
- ‚ J ( -, 3, / )P B( 2:<F3; MW, ; -; 3<, 2(:; -, 3, ( )3 )DD
.
`j* > (: ( A
- 3, (
:, j ; )DD C1 -& E<H( 2 A
`j*
2:5<E C 5 B > 5A M5=0 5;
5, 56 H 5H o 3E n; D B( 2:<F3;
)5DD ()53R .
4 )5;
-5, 3, C(:\F5D > 5D6
9i & -9(:\ B ; -
& E= )9(
G:W; )3 ( ; ( / d j ( B( 2(
G)D ' 2 ( :;
- U`*
)5DA .
o 3E n; D ; -, 3, `j* f -,:<, a:A -5, 3,
:\F5D 2 5AB: >)5* ; :<F53;
2 1
n3,1 Y39 `j* C' 2 (SL:3q
; )A( Q : .
\ :L(
/1:5q -5D6 -& 5E<H( o 53E n; 5D :
YD 1 2 <P(
-, 3, / )P ; U )j 3%; P -& E<H(
( Y539 ( 5W9' ) ; >)D* ; <*(
9( U3Q -, 3, `j* :A 2 AB: •)0 4336 .
5WH ; > 5 1 G \<5, : 5 5 C'
M3E
; D p3 J 2:3L
-5[ Q WH W9' •3 ; 1 6 H n
`j5* > 5,(
2 5A
G \ H B( 2:<F3; MW, )9 ( ]i -, 3, )
D ( )DD 0 ( -< 1 2 A .
> D6 4 );
1 21 ) ; (
`j* , 3, :` 1 C 9 9( 2(
. C a -%m > 1 : G \ H
•(:3 45 ( B( -%m 5 1 56 H ; 1 7;( > A >2:\FD :< ; 1 -J 5,
`j* , 3, )D< A - & . ; 5W9' |35. ; P ) ; 2(
)5*
. :5` 1 53 1( c:5d
`j* , 3, (:; )* ; 2:3 ) * >2(
KA1_R 2
$ 5%& C' :<F3; 2 :; 1 2:?9 2 A
U3%N B( G I<,( ; ( Q 4 B l' V . >-, 3,
)A (:P U ) )H 2 A
.
:
. :
1 . C( `EA 1 •: 3 >C :<*(
) 1388 (
>
+# - 3 ' .0 L $1 .3
:
" 5 $ & I K N O.0 L $ 0
>
C(:W : 9:; :<
DA: / 6 7 1 -& E<H( 2Y 4 1 / 3 N >$ %& / (B1 -\
2 1' .
2 . C1: >4EL1:;
) 1389 (
>
" , & $ #*
3 ' $ 0 U3%Q EH: >
C(:W >- (B:3 :
6 H /( F<9(
C , D*
.
3 .
; R >
:3 ) 1384 (
>
» U`*
:, 2 A
« { >
>C 3 >KJ;
( # ! N3 ! 3 ' " #
"HN N
5EH: >
C(:W >C R 4 0 1 B j Q 43F ( :
p[ >GB(:3* :F9 132
- 165 .
4 . /:;( >$ D R )
1380 (
>
%. ( #
# $ 0 C(:W >B1:I - )EN EH: >
:
$i, 9B1 /( F<9(
.
5 . 4<9 3 1( 1 43< : >G: * )
1385 (
>
& P C(:W >-j< -w : EH: >
: :F9 -9 .
6 . )36, > 7&
) 1391 (
>
3 ' " # $ Q $ 0 .&
) 3 ' " # &
( Y >
: Y G \F9( /( F<9(
.
7 . R 2( YE3H > ,(
.
-R ) 1
. 4 e ) 1387 (
" Q>
4 E $ 0 C(:W >G (B –()j& EN EH: >
: g q :F9 .
8 . :<3R >:%3 ) 1384 (
>
T ! P D E
C(:W >G) )9 WH 43F ( 1 ] Q:, `39 EH: >
: -9 :F9 .
9 .
—( YE3H 1 ) >s 9 .
-` D3%
) 1387 (
>
< +
" ,
>
& C L_ EH:
-E3?
M : 1 -E* A )WF5 >- `5,(
: /( F5<9(
WH )WF -A \F9(
.
. :
1- Alcañiz, Isabella (2010), Bureaucratic Networks and Government Spending: A Network Analysis of Nuclear Cooperation in Latin America, Latin American Research Review, Vol. 45, No. 1, pp. 148-172.
2- Anheier, Helmut (2003), “Movement Development and Organizational Networks: The Role of ‘Single Members’ in the German Nazi Party, 1925-30”, in Mario Diani and Doug McAdam (eds.), Social Movements and Networks: Relational Approaches to Collective Action, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 49-74.
3- Arnold, Gwen (2011), "Cycles in Policy Network Structure and Policy Adoption Implementation Processes: The Importance of Alignment", Working Papers, paper 58.
4- Baldassarri, Delia & Mario Diani (2007), “The Integrative of Civic Networks”, American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 113, No. 3, November, pp. 735-780.
5- Burt, Ronald S. (1992), Structural Holes: The Social Structure of Competition, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
6- Burt, Ronald S. (2000), “The Network Structure of Social Capital”, Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol. 22, pp. 345-423.
7- Burt, Ronald S. (2008), “Structural Holes versus Network Closure as Social Capital”, in Nan Lin, Karen Cook & Ronald S. Burt (eds.), Social Capital: Theory and Research, New Jersey: Transaction Publishers, pp. 31- 56.
8- Castells, Manuel (2009), communication power, New York: Oxford University Press.
9- Diani, Mario (2003), “Introduction: Social Movements, Contentious Actionsm and Social Networks: ‘From Metaphor to Substance’?”, in Mario Diani and Doug McAdam (eds.), Social Movements and Networks: Relational Approaches to Collective Action, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 1-18.
10- Freeman, L. C. (2004), the Development of Social Network Analysis: A Study in the Sociology of Science, Canada, Vancouver: Empirical Press.
11- Granovetter, M. (1985), “Economic Action and Social Structure: The problem of Embeddedness”, American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 91, Issue 3, Nov., pp. 481–510.
12- Grootaert, Christiaan and Thierry van Bastelaer (2002), Understanding and Measuring Social Capital: A Multi-Disciplinary Tool for Practitioners, Washington: The WorkBank.
13- Hazlehurst, D. (2001), "Networks and Policy Making: From Theory to Practice in Australian Social Policy", available online at:
http://www.insna.org/INSNA/PNBIbliograghy.htm
14- Hitt, M. A., Ireland, R. D., Camp, S. M., and Sexton, D. L. (2002), "Strategic Entrepreneurship: Integrating Entrepreneurial and Strategic Management Perspectives. In M. A. Hitt, R. D. Ireland, S. M. Camp and D. L. Sexton (eds), Strategic Entrepreneurship: Creating a New Integrated Mindset,Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
15- Horne, Christine (2001), “Sociological Perspectives on the Emergence of Social Norms”, in Michael Hechter and Karl-Dieter Opp (eds.), Social Norms, New York: Russell Sage Foundation, pp. 3-33.
