1 : 2 3 e&(a" E *H ': & O /5 $ /*F ) */ ) * & 1&(8" E& N 4 (< : E *H N ;' (' ) &amp lt; B/ 4 0 4!N / X/ 0 (' B ' $ /*F (&lt B X= $58 / E *H E&< 4!N / : O 5 !/ B I = J/ b E *H : 0 ) I = J/ X / 4 (< BLH U/ A& :5 6/% (& ' / ) F*(3/ G *&(< B8 F : ;< = &gt E D5

1 - ! "

#

$%&' ( ) ) " *' +

2 - -./ ( 0 1/ $ 2&23" / &

4/5 ! "

) "

)

3 -

&

! "

) "

)

4 -

*8 8+

4& "

9 */

) "

)

D5 E

>5!' + *(3/ : ;< = B8 F G *&(<

' / ) F*(3/ (&

+,

: -

E *H )

5 !/

B I = J/

K L/

*&M&

'

!N / O

F N B + 4 0 P'

$58 /

!N / : &

B

4 (<

* / E&/%"

': &

!N / ) Q B &(' B

*<

= R ; / ) +: &

$ S (

&

. E ; BLH U/

G <

B V;/

W

X / 4 (<

: E *H E )

*+

.

. / A& BLH U/ E : B

Y 1& 3"

3/

? 91 - 1390

$ S 4=

.

4 /

) *;;

9 B (

&

; !/

[*'

\ * *+

B (

&

"

)*&

B ] !+

' B/

4=

. E * R&" "

31 A 18 / : E *H )

5 !/

B I = J/

BL0 /

*;;

B / ) "

+ ) "

) ;+

E P' ^ 4 +

* . ' : _ ` B!< a/

B(&

F B = ' b :

4 /

) *;;

$ *; / X(0 Q *+

B Y 2 ) Induction method (

/ B "

1& 3"

N 4=

.

B = : 0 ' 1S <

: 1& 3"

' B B2!`

S 18 / : X / /:

)

!(

;' ('

$ ` !"

/:

!(

E& N

(<

B 0 ( X / B= <

) WLG (&"

!(

4&<5S B= <

) ; ( X / F 8+Q

( .

1 : 2 3 e&(a"

E *H ': & O /5 $ /*F ) */ ) * &

1&(8"

E& N 4 (<

: E *H N

;' (' ) &/

) /:

' (<

B/

4 0 4!N / X/ 0 (' B

'

$ /*F (<

/

*; "

B X=

$58 / E *H

E&<

4!N / :

O 5 !/

B I = J/

b(

*; ( .

4%

E *H : 0 )

I = J/

X / 4 (<

BLH U/

A&

:5 6/%

(& ' / ) F*(3/ G *&(< B8 F : ;< = >5!' + *(3/ E D5 ! " # $ % &% ' () * % .

: A& $ 2&23" B /.

4/5 1393 f 3 ) 4 :(

316 - 305 .

:' /# 8 / 9 23

/ 4 / 93 :.2 ?@ 8 / 9

27 / 8 / 93

-

(&

I = J/

X + E "

4

"

8 &=

)

4 . E *H E ) B 1&H j +

*&M&

E/ / O

4 0 4 */

4!N / : ) +* : = e' =

) (

= 1 F

*;/: &

: 4 (<

B= <

E = X ;/

$ /*F / ) +: &

*; ' ) 2 1 .(

e' ) /:

*+

O B ) ': &

O F

&&J"

/

*;

(

*

Y5"

+

$58 /

!N / O

: _ ` 4 (<

2"

8 ( F [ `

) 3 2 .(

/ *; /

& F N ) X ;/

" /*F 4!N /

: O 5 !/

4 2"

*<

F

& 0 :

&

F BL/ 0

/

* "

= E *H F 2"

*' ) 6 - 4 .(

: &

B

4 (<

(

&>

(

$ /*F ( 0 :

': &

*(

F ' O

5 !/

B

"

4

*<

(&

: ': &

B X ;/

0 / BL/ 0

k / / + ) 7 .(

/ 18 23 ) (&

n 2< B/

O X( / \ a/)

1 / ) /: / ( ?

1989 5&/

\ a/

o /

+ /5

) B ) ; ) N / p /

*;A

1372 ( E *H j " O * 4

n 2<

? L/ )

&!

:

*H E A 4& " W q

*+

e' = ) (

$ 8/

R ;/

O

*H E

%"

&

* 4H

# ' E

&

) ( B/

Wq / B $* /

R ;/

e' = ) ( 4 (< $ /*F X/ 0 X& '

)Q F ? L/ ) '

/

*;+

) 8 .(

B `

? (L/

'

? <

BL "

= 1S <

: (&

O E *H P&

: ' BL "

B =

f4 r B

&

F ' B X ;/

= R ;/

* * B

` B E *H )

5 !/

B (&

E/ / 4!N /

: O PH r ' B0 / /

* + B

+ : ) *2=

4 (<

' U&3/

4 ) 10 9 .(

#L

& $5& " ' F

' )

5 !/

e' = /

*;;

/ F ' R <

3 B

$ /*F

$58 / e

P&

/ B0 /

/

*;+

. #L

4 (< $ LH U/

= : F ' )

5 !/

RH >

X ;/

= e <

R n 2<

H /

E& N

= L/

* ) 12 11 .(

* F :

4 (<

=

;/

B

* "

E *H 4!N /

\ U/

: P F O

#

F P = : &

B 4!N / /5

P'

K A;/

O F

<

BL/ 0 / +

) 14 13 .(

` E&223/

$ LH U/

W / B

;!/

P' 4/5 4&A&

* : E *H )

5 !/

B

"

4

*; = B V;/

& &

: R& Q '

) !0 s

$ G 4 (<

: F ' O

5 !/

B

"

j + E/ /

*& %"

* :

* . E&;M('

*

F :

4 (<

'

= R ;/

P -

&

: B =

' E&223/

4 ) 22 - 15 .(

B0 "

B B = ' B 4

*/Q :

$ LH U/

) 22 - 15 (

E B E *H

` 4!N / : O 5 !/

B j + E/ /

43"

4 (<

= -./

N B + * ('

$ G

4 (<

: ) Q /

*& %"

E&223/

4 / 1 N 1/%"

/

*+

. E

$ LH U/

$ LH U/

B / t

*; / 1(3"

4!N / P'

4&A&

* : B;&/:

'

!(

4 (<

-./

= B

` S a F 9

\ "

= u / 8

* . : )Q 0 B

&

B O

:

$ & 0 b

* * BU&<

$ <

W`

'*; = 8=

/ 4 B : _ ` Y ' A&

) 8/

/ s )

23 ( E&;M(' B0 "

B 4&(' O

$ & "

= B

4=

4 (<

<

BU&

v;' =

$ 8/

BL/ 0 B

)Q

* : /

*;;

E BLH U/

B

V;/

E&&!"

X / 4 (<

: E *H )

5 !/

B I =

J/

? 91 - 1390 8

A&

* "

O

:

* * / BLH U/

R . B = ' BLH U/

G <

/

* "

B e&(a"

) * &

BS 4/5 t "

' 8' 4 0

X=

$58 / E *H

E&<

4!N / E :

O

*;' .

. /

E BLH U/

: BLH U/

A&

B B = ' )Q

1S <

1& 3"

3/

B 2/

*/

' /

*+

. 1& 3"

3/

$ 2&23"

A&

L&

) 24 (

e' = ) (

*' + W&S "

wG BS5F

*+

:

* *

V /

Y

! ;/

\ 3/

/ + ) 25 .(

B V;/

&

B [*' BLH U/

\

4 /

) *;;

B Y

; !/

[*' : >Q

*+

"

)*&

B

] !+

' B/

4=

.

= BLH U/

4 +

* *+

B B "

* 4 (<

: E *H )

5 !/

B I = J/

*; + Q

= ) : B ;+

/ E *H e' 4 :

(' 4!N /

*;;

: O .*

E * R&" "

19 : A

E *H ) 14 / 5

* J/ I = B 5 !/ ) ( BL0 /

) " / B *;;

) " + E& &/

;

2 / 41

? a3" wU

$5&

H " e o &

B "

4!N / :

; ) E&

16 - 5 / 2 ? 5 !/

x U B

J/ I = W / )

: AF W&

*+ "

* $58 / ) *

('

*; / I; "

$58 /

*

*&;+

/5 R2

* /

;'t

*

? ; X=

_!`

Y E *H

/ ( E&;M('

*L"

12 A : ) ;+

18 / :

*/

/ )

9 ;+

b+

) ;+

: <

) "

E& &/

; 5 / 42

? B "

17

? E P' ^ / 4

*; + .

4 0 X(0 Q '

:

" *; /

*; / ) N X/ 0

4 (<

: n 2<

E&H L/

) 26 ( E& Q B/

) 27 (

B!< a/

' y

*+

* 0

&

: B!< a/

B(&

F

B =

4 /

) *;;

A

* B!< a/ . ' /

) "

B ? ;/ ) / _= " _!` /

B&

B!< a/

' j!G

*+

(" R < B!< a/ . 1

Q /

4 /

*;;

E&

60 - 30 N B2&

*L"

B!< a/

'

4 /

*;;

: b "

B 0

&J / . ) 0 B!< a/

"z .

*; /

» r 4 (<

: E *H )

5 !/

B I =

J/

B F

$ S (

| &

Br

"58 /

& /

4 (<

: E *H 0

| r : b(

) b

F

|*& &

« Q : >

* . o~

B&8"

"z . B

1/ L"

B!< a/

* + B!< a/

*;;

* * /

*/Q B/

4=

. E&;M('

&

( $ 5` B _&

"

: . $z

= ) M('

»

&

G "

w&

'

*&

: ) " V;/

B (0 A B

*&

N _&

"

) &

;

*&

« A

*+

.

B V;/

1& 3"

'

*L : )*+

' B!< a/

4 /

) *;;

1 =

" S B 4N 4

*+

. E /

1S <

: B!< a/

' E *;r

;L/ '*< .*+ * F

)

Meaning unit

( )Q u / BS5F

:

)

Condensed

( '*<

;L/

A&S "

b B E /

*+

= o~ . :

'*

B& "

;& : /

;L/

E&&L"

4' !+

'

$ A"

' 0 /

;L/

'*

B / B Y ' )

Reduction

( 2 3U

"

0

* *+

B 2/

*/

$ 2!` :

$ 2!`

1 N

? !N 1S <

*+

.

) ;&(`

: _- /

) )

Trustworthiness

(

B = ' : Y '

! )

Credibility

(

)

Dependability

( 4& N

? 2 )

Transferability

(

s *& %"

)

Conformability

( A

*+

. ) ;&(`

B

B = ' L

*+

[ S 4N

= 4 0 X(0 Q '

8/

' A : ] ;"

B (

&

)

\

4 /

) *;;

: / W / H

S aF

&

\

4 /

) *;;

4&LN / ' W / b&= /

\ "

$ A / : <

4 (<

E *H ( P =

*L"

B!< a/

F:

B

4 /

) *;;

*& %"

$ 2!`

1S <

*+

: E /

B!< a/

j "

4 /

) *;;

B '

!

&

+ . 4 0

&

B 83 : Y B =

'

A f*+

B

` B B!< a/

' 4 o

*+

4 0

1& 3"

;& : B

# '

$%&

( A& _&23" B ;+Q

B

*+

"

: 3/

I ) ;&(`

1S <

+ . B

I 1 `

$ 2&23"

A&

4& N e&(L"

* BM ;r

=

B = '

$ & "

F _!U;/

*; * / ) "

4A

4& N

? 2 B = ' I 0 ) 28 .(

E _&23"

4& N

? 2 s B = ' j + B / B ) *; F

s / .

B V;/

4

$ V<5/

N5F :

B &(

n5F

4 0 0 _&23"

%"

B *&

R

* :

)z . / / / ) "

: 0 B =

*+

. E&;M('

$ 3&G "

= 4&('

[ *' _&23"

B / 3/

)

$ a /

$ 5`

: 0 A : j!G

*S B

;'

B!< a/

* ' B

!0

* * "

4 0 4 + P' ^

& F [ a '

B < / : _&23"

B ' b 4 +

) *;;

*0 j +

*+

.

4 /

) *;;

4 0 4 +

_&23"

= 4 G B ' Q

#/

* .

0

1& 3"

B = ' X / 4 (<

: E *H B

B2!`

S

X / /:

X / B= <

X / F 8+Q

(

B B/

x + )Q '

*/Q 4 .

* %

& C

X / /:

18 / : L / 4

B B

`

; :

X / F E *H

:

$5& "

4 (<

=

4!N / : O 5 !/

B I = J/

/

*+

. E B2!`

B2!` :

»

!(

;' ('

$ ` !"

/:

!(

E& N (<

B 0

« 18+

4=

.

1 -

!(

;' ('

$ ` !"

/:

!(

;' ('

$ ` !"

WLG $ S B /:

` !"

;' (' E&

) /:

'

$ /*F

*;'

) B &(

*/

$ : 4+ * Y: /Q Y

/ /Q ) (...

E + * /Q w&3S B/

'

e&V;"

B0 x U/

.

!(

j /:

B

$ /*F

!N / ' =

B B F * 4 . B 1&H

!(

k !"

/:

) /

B ) ; ) ;

B= <

) /:

4+ * Y: /Q

8+

B ) ;

= jF

?

B 0 / E *H

B `

? (L/

5`

: ]

$ /*F

(<

) /:

/ ] 0 E *H B ) /:

*; + * . 9 ;+

*/

19

? B2

WLG

` !"

) &/

) /:

' q :

) ...4 ;" / ) /:

»

'

*;'* b(

$ /*F B E *H F

&

: E / "

e&

B e&' .

/ . H E&

) /:

) ' '

W /

* ) /:

*;+ B + k !"

• ) 9 4+ * $ : '

/ B+

B / t B ( / *; "

k !" ) U

' N /

*;; "

« .

*;

0 X0 /

b(

4 0

: *;( "

E&!N / F

!(

('

;'

) /:

' 4 (<

*;;

H /

*; / ) /:

B &(

*/

B0 "

B

!(

B0

"58 /

b(

B

=

* * / Q B _!`

?

4 F

!N V ;/

4F b(

B; '

* . 9 ;+

b+

B "

4 */

& &

;' (' E&

/:

*;

$ /*F q ( :

=

»

/ $ /*F 0 : B

&

/ € + b

2 4 A B&

...* ( B 5 ' /:

1•/

B &(

*/

:

? Y F b(

/

*;

. 8

b(

' 4=

/

*;

8 4=

(

*;

. )‚

/

E ' ( "

e&

; ? ; e&

N . E

1< 18 /

/ + B : V b

*+ ) /:

f / ) /: *L * "

‚ .*+

"*/ : *L F r + B A ) ) ":

*

4 &

.«

2 -

!(

E& N (<

B 0

E& N !(

B 0

<

:

!(

;& N

4 B 4!N /

* O

E *H ) Q

/

*;

. b B e&(a"

) * &

B ' ƒ F

R a"

0 E& N

!(

B/

B0

S a F 0

E& N B

' 0 E& N

) ;&(`

B 0 )

)Q 4

/

*;

.

! E& N

J+

*; /

$ (

E *H )

5 !/

) B

^ ) /

( ) *2=

*

^

„2 n 2<

E&H L/

B ' W "

o&

(;' 4

)*

_<

^

$5& "

( 0 ) B

;'

? J+

)*+

) 8/

O F

ƒ a / E&H L/

j "

' F

( : B (0 /

x U/

*+

4 . E& N (<

/ :

B 0

F

*; &

. ) a2 1(LH

' 4 A>

:

#L

' r 4&H L/

) )

I = J/

( 0 E& N

(<

18 / B0 / /

*;

.

* 0 E& N (<

0 /

&

("

a3 4 (<

H / :

#L

' r 4&H L/

G / 4

B o&D E(

] =

: n 2<

)z L/

B/ : 0 e0 )

?

*;A 1390 ( E

B q :

)

»

0 ' 4 B N 4 (<

: )z L/

:

? P&

B = s 4

:

*L/

'

&

4 B ) N L/ 0 4 (<

: n 2<

)z L/

*

/ ) N X/ 0 : 4 (<

)z L/

4 (G 0

* .

9 P B/

' j2=

z L/

:

E

) /:

_<

4=

/

*;;

B BL G

*;+

. _<

B B(' )z L/

/ + .

= :

) /:

*H "

I =

*+

Q _<

A : _<

| *

) « 29 .(

0 E& N u / Y: /Q O

4 (<

&>

e&2 /

: E *H 4 . Y: /Q O

; )

#<

9 */

O * / '

: B (0 / 1 N

4&(' E *H

/

*+

B

* 4 E& N j!" /

L / 4 (<

: E *H /

*+

. / 31 BH O

5 !/

B I = J/

] j / 4A :

0

»

B F 18 /

;'t

* 0 PH !N

(

*;;

. 1N *<

5 - 4 "

O * / e =

…&'

* PH !N

* 8 . v : : ) /:

*; A

*

* : = (+

? !N

*;;

.«

0 ) N (<

Y: /Q O

B 1&H

!(

B0 ƒ a F B =

* B/

_23/

( + .

) L/

) "

) /:

` B!< a/

:

B/

BL/ 0 (' )

21 ) Q 1391 ( E

` q :

)z L/

»

Y '

L&!`

*

= eH b

B */

9

*;

<

O * / )

? L/

) eH 8

*+

. _!`

B&/5 ) /:

4+ *

0

* Y: /Q Y

9 */

*

$

B= G Y: /Q

)

? L/

ƒ a F B= G

e L/

4F

*;

/ E / 9 */

/ _23/

( +

) « 30 .(

* % 2) %

E B2!`

) *2=

) a2 1/

4 (<

*;;

: E *H V

/ - ! "

4 B E *H

$58 /

!N / B0 /

/ ( . E B2!`

* &

$ 2!` :

» WLG (&"

!(

4&<5S B= <

« .

1 - WLG (&"

: V;/

WLG (&"

)*+

' /

O j "

E&aa /

= B= <

W / ) *

k !"

1/ L"

B= <

=

* ]5`

) /

:

*N /

*8 /

u /

*

? !"

Y

: 4&LG 4= &

O (' W&LG

[ *'

/ u / )

* X/ 0 / ) *2=

1/

& &

*;;

$ V

*"

/ O

V

B = )*

E *H e&"

) /

!(

4H F B "

E *H e&(a"

&

' / /

*+

.

*

k !"

E&

# /

*/Q E *H

b+

ua / )

18

? B2 4A :

"

»

e&

) "

* $ S B

*;r aa "

k !"

E&

' aa "

*+

H ' 9 ;+

aa / Y F

/

*;

B ) 8

* .

Y F '

&

B E + Y ...B ) +

B ) + b+

B

*(' (

...*;;

‚ ) )

"

*; = / A e' E/ B;

$ <

X e;

X "

E / BM .B+

†z S

+ ) ;&

? !"

( B+

e &

Y ' 0

* ' . / S aF P

Y F

/ .B;

E u2 e &

/ ) "

/ B 4

! V / e ;/

j!" /

† LN F PH r "

*+

* / * XUN

E = \ 0

: / N

*'

.«

' V B = )*

E *H B

; ) 8(' e&"

) / 0 "

B B "

!N / ) Q

<

: O

)*

j "

) / E *H

x U/

. / 45 BH

O 5 !/

B I = J/

* *+

4A :

B

»

) (&

e A E ƒ N

*G I; "

B E

( BM :

/ Y "*

E/ : ...B;

B E/

J+ ' . "

/ F

*;;

0 ) + F

*H E ( 9 e; 8= .* t '

)

;+

B * *

/ E 0 / F

*;;

.«

2 -

!(

4&<5S B= <

) ;

A/ E 18 /

:

!(

P

$ /

* L"

B= <

Y A;/

4!

B ) / ) "

O

5 !/

/

*+

.

!(

P

$ / J+

': &

E *H u& "

) / O

*

$ /

= N

k !"

R ;/

E *H

#L XN /

;+Q ) ;

W q J+

*

&

= F

= J+

/ ) ! B 0

#L : W q

0 "

B

$58 / E *H

*

? !N 4&H . / o<

BA&q E + * (;'

E *H /

* B

) ; : 0 W q J+

/ .

!(

$ /

N k !"

#L :

= B= <

B

$ S F

R ;/

E *H

;'

&F%"

B

$ 0 /

) *

4

&F%"

!F )

* 4/5 O

) O + '

* 4 4/ <

E *H ' V"

/ . 9 ;+

*/

19

? B2

!(

+

#L : ) ; q ( :

e <

»

:

...

*/

( $ S B

H S (

ua / 9 ;+ B+

*/

* e .

9 ;+

< ` ' *; '

†5S 9 ;+

*; &

*

*; &

F .

&

' */ : /

Q

* e' Y: /

* * : .

*

/ + /

*

*/ ? S „2 e'

B;

...

E *N

\ F /

; B ( : 0 F B :

*

*;;

.«

F =

J+

E + *

&

4&A&

8 ( ) ;

4!

B ) / ) "

O

? 2

&

‡ B E *H P' /

*' . / 40 BH

* : = 5 !/

B I = J/

&

P' 8 (

#L

) /

B 4 0 ˆA<

‡ 4A :

E/

»

G B e &

( (' ...*;;

E&

/ )

/ ) &

/ B;

/ ? BM .B :

B e A

QN ...

E /) 0 S aF

(...

: BM / o

" r / H ( ...

4A . )

‡ 0 (

4 : * F ( e "

E 0 e;

.«

'

* ]5`

= ) ;+

$ 8/

$5& "

0 / 3

B& "

1

!N / R ;/

)

*; /

E ( R!

/

*+

) Q B B

*<

\ U/

N B 4 (<

: E *H

*;+ ! . Y A;/

4!

B ) / O

#L :

# ) /

/ / B B B

) / O

5 !/

B I = J/

B ƒ aF ]

* *+

* = B

B )

/

* ) /

O )*&

B E 4 4 .

? A`

13 ?

B2

&

E 4A :

" /

»

) (&

"

$ &

8+

* e B

E ' N _&

* * 4

E *H (;'

fB;

E ) r

*;" A / ' ' =

" A / e;/ .*

B E

( ' B e ;+

B

* /

e 4!N / BM ) "

? ;/

)5=

...

† LN X U/

e &

B 0 Br F B

/ b(

*;;

BM B I = J/

H

* ) 8/

: 4!N / E

. * O E

B H / b(

/ * + b(

/

* + 5`

* ) ; B . " B

E

) (&

) " ? A`

4 /

' e;

…&

/

/ (

/ e' B e ;+

/

#

= L/

e;

e ) (;' E 4!3S 0 4&

/

#L .*;;

*H E / 8=

/ B *;;

„ I = J/

(' b+

&

. * / / 4A E / 8= ' BM *;;

e / E/

4 &

( P \ F ' 8(' : .*;

F

:

;+

*&

BM B

I = J/

N k !"

( ...

/

*; A

= Br B

* / r F B

\ F E x5US ] B

0 "

B&

= ...

B&

*H E E

.* ; ) '

< ˆA<

$ &

BM + F ) + )

&

Y:

B( /

« .

* % 3#% D

4 *3/

' E&

# F )

# B '

F )

b ( X / : b(

B E *H

/ + . X / 0 / E&

# F )

b :

$ 0 ( 0 H / /:

4= / k !"

A`

O

$58 / E *H

x U/

4 .

* "

( 0 B 1&H

5 B (&

E z : &

E + B b(

)

/ B

) 8/

b(

B E *H O 5 !/

B 1N *<

/

* . F ) ! : 4L H / ) 8

4&H J /

&a3"

- J+

*

#<

$ 4!N /

B : : O : 4= /

!(

j A`

!(

N k !"

' * B

0 "

*

4F ;+

$58 /

B F

' E *H E&/%"

': &

!N / O

: ) 8

: X / b(

B

E *H

\ 3/

/ + . / n = 4 (<

: E *H

/

* "

s ) /:

1< / W / E : O

4!N / : ) ( + .

*H E 4A :

E

»

I;

? b

*<

4 B F ...

f

) r

&F

&

( B "

&F e'

* BN5F . 8=

/ e;

1 N ( 4 ' B e F P &

s H

&

( B "

P b(

B;

. Y *S

&F

*;

F : ) 4H <

E"

*S

&F / B "

(&(S

4 &

...

B(

Y e' E&('

` :

?

&F

*

! k !"

N B;

.«

' b(

' : )

1 u& "

(&

&

B / ) /:

B P' / . / 29

BH O 5 !/

B ]

* *+

I = J/

q ( :

1

»

' F /

* */

<

B *('

? !

' /

e& = .

"

B / /

? r

*;"

*;"

/

* */

v : /

* : B Br /

; ...

† *L Y

Y e

*+

.«

EF

B = ' BLH U/

G <

X / 4 (<

: E *H B

*L

/:

B= <

F 8+Q

( .

!(

;' ('

$ ` !"

/:

!(

E& N (<

WLG (&"

!(

4&<5S B= <

#L ) ;+

E&aa /

V ( 4 *3/

' /:

` !"

/5

=

b(

*;;

() )

!(

4F ;+

B0 "

B

$58 /

!N / E *H

: X / (<

B F ;+

* *+

. B = ' )

) /:

' 8 : B ' E *H

*; ' B : _ `

E& N

;' (' ' E&

/:

/

*; "

: E *H

4 (<

*;;

. ) /:

' B B

` e&2 /

&>

e&2 /

4&H . / 4 (<

: = 5 !/

B

"

F

*

* B 1&H P' k !"

;' ('

*;

B

$ /*F (

*; "

)Q B B

* P2 F A

*;;

.

!(

;' (' E&

/:

!(

E& N

1(LH '

$58 / BU&<

8 ( ) ;+

B = '

$ LH U/

&

x U/

*+

f4 B

` B

F /:

-

;' = ) *2=

$ 2/

1(LH '

B= <

*

;' ('

&

E

!(

&

'

ua / :

X / (<

4

*;;

B

$ /*F /5

= L/

* ) 32 31 .(

) *2=

4 & e ;/ Br ~8 4 */

s '

R0 / R ;/

/ + B E&

;' (' j!" / '

:z 4 0 X=

$58 / ( 0

= ) r H L/

&

E

4!N / ) *;;

)Q ' ) & $ S F B 33

.(

!(

B/ !( B0 = u&a " E& N '

b(

/ ? H / 4 (< E&/%" B;&/: E *H B .*;

E *H : (< E& N !(

(0 : / B /

*+

B

X/ 0 ) N E&H L/ : 4 (<

0 $ S B )Q B

B F

* 4 .

;M('

&

E ) *2=

N

&

E "

&

$5

J+

*H E ) 5 !/

!(

B0 "

B E

:

*H E ) 27 26 ( 5/

$ (

$58 / 1<

*

: E O 5 !/

*H E N / s .

Graungaard

* Y F BLH U/ ) 8('

)Q : P& E *H : 4 (< B j!" / E *H ': & B

*+ E&&L" P& : E& N RH N *+

! ;" B 4

f * E *H ': &

B

` B / E *H

B

1&H [ S 4N : 4 F

8/

: 4=

$ /*F

(

*&/

/

* + ) 34 .(

Carduff Finucane

&

B

* *& B & E B

N

&

E P2

"

&

e 4!N /

/5 (<

4 :

!N /

&

E F

= 5 !/

B

&

(

*+

* : X / 4F ;+

&

:

!N /

&

E /

*+

) 35 .(

B F ;+

)* /

&

':

*H E O )*

&

':

) Q B ) ;

!N /

&

E O /

* "

B e' = )*

N

&

E (<

"

&

"5

;/

.

* L" $ / P !( B ) G < BLH U/

B= <

F

!(

&

) ; B= <

E + * H / : ) Y: /Q *; / " / *N 0 B

= .*+ B F ;+ E *H : \ U/ 4 (< 0 / X / B= <

O $58 / 9 : ;+

- X= *H

/ $58 / -./ P2 *; "

4 (<

: E

* B +

*;+

. E B = ' I

$ LH U/

) 37 36 ( (' .

BLH U/

N /

$ B 3/

) 8(' /

*; /

F

$ :

N E + * 0

aa "

: X / A P2

= L/

* ) 36 .(

*;8

) 8(' P'

*/

) ; B

$ S

*

<5S

&

4

= P

$ /

&

= P

) Q : PH r ' 0 / B

$ /*F t

* ) 37 .(

223/

&

E

&

B L /

*; / ) *2=

k !"

&

E ) ;

B/

' o ‡Q ' W / Y

' A;/

) Q

b(

!(

&

e <

: WLG "

&

(

4

*; = ) 39 38 .(

9 I BLH U/

G <

WLG "

&

( B

) &/ ;' (' !( $ S / '

) " ) / *; = $ V & & !(

O

.4+ ( E *H 4H F !(

*H E ) ' (' (

O '

*;

B : O 4F ;+

=

* V

*H )*+ B = R< S B + + ) ; B E

V

\ 3/ / 4 (< * e / / ) / e&" j "

/ E& E + ) *;' B ) &/ ;' (' $58 /

e&(a" e & : E *H ) y F !N / $ /*F &

*; = ? (L/ ` B E *H B 4 "58 / B (0 : : 4!N / / B " O

) *;;

41 40 .(

jF !( : < G < BLH U/ I /

(< '

4&<5S 4 A * B= < '

/ B * * "

E *H : 4 (<

1 /

* ( R!

+

*H E

4!N / : O : E B

PH r '

*L / r

* + B

&A

&

4 4!N / : O 18 / B0 / /

*;

.

White

) 8('

` 23"

&2

&

) B * ) *2=

(<

4 BL/ 0 : 4!N / ) *;;

F :

X /

*

&

P2 4!N /

*;;

/

*+

) 42 .(

B `

? (L/

b(

B

*H E :

#

F )

b B

$ S Y 0 F

/

&

/ I

*+ 1S <

) B / B

z 1

$ A /

# F

( )

N B b(

B

*H E

&

*;

E / /

* "

&

:

*H E B b(

= P

* :

*H E 4!N / : O 43"

-%"

&

N

*' .

*(3/

) 8('

&

*

4 /

F /:

&

B;

R ;/

B b(

B =

*;(H : X / b(

!N /

&

E F 4!N /

Y

) * 43 .(

z ) 8('

F BLH U/

* Y

B

LG

&

4 ( 0 R ;/

= B " P

a N $58 /

) ; B F # : B J /

*;; *3/ 1/

* = L/ F B

) 44 G < BLH U/ . 42 U/ G < BLH U/ I B (

b( = B ) &

N B &(' F )

B b( *;/: & ) + F ' ! */ '

' .*;

Burkhard

BLH U/

F B E B &

*&

; *H B : b(

' /

‰ * ' F /

* *+

B / ) /:

/ ;' B

O 5 !/

B E 0

/

*&

: b(

' )Q ' B 1&H

$ = 5

B (&

3/

/

* *+

) 45 .(

("

1< / 4!N / : O

;L : : >Q 5 O

` 1< /

*L

&

:

*H E B 4=

(<

4 0

&

: B (<

4 4+s ) /:

= P

*+

1/ 8"

O

5 !/

= P / f*

&

':

B /%"

&

E )Q '

;"

:

` _

F )

) 8/

s

&

4 B8

&

' B= <

*/

) aa /

&

E ) ;+

( A : N

&

E (<

B 0 :

` _ B '

" /*F (<

B R ; /

&

':

!N /

*H E

*+

&

:

` _ 4!N / X/ 0

v;' (' 3/

4

*H - O /

*; "

B : ` + B

*H E E )

*;' .

1 2 3

;' (' ' !(

4 *3/ 8 ( ) a2 ' '

B ( 0 ' -

N 0 / X / : /

J/ I = B 5 !/ ) E *H : X/ 0 (' 4 (<

/

*+

.

" / *N ) M('

1&(8"

E& N (<

B ' 0 P = N

k !"

;' (' E&

/:

< ` 0

B/

' b(

B

E *H

! 8 ( ) ;

B= <

B Y: /Q

F ˆA< [*' E *H (< ': & '

*H 4/5 2"

- O /

* "

& / 4!N / E :

O 5 !/

H o< (' E *

.*' P' ) Q ' ;

E 0 4 t ) + B = B

G < BLH U/ '

8 A&

4& N e&(L"

s I 4 *&/ f *

* B / $ 2&23" I ; n = X=

X /

4 (<

: E *H )

5 !/

B

$58 / E/ /

"

s -

*+

. ) *;

) 0 BLH U/

;!/

< `

?*/

4 (<

: E *H 4!N /

*;;

: O 5 !/

B I = J/

B&S "

/

*;;

%#/ G 2+H9

BH 2/

G <

B = : ) B/

/

*+

.

) *;

B (&(S R" /

9 ~ F : B&

4 /

) *;;

E P' ^ 5

/

*; ( . E&;M(' :

E&H . /

) ;+

/ ) "

B B

! "

) /:

) ) "

B

4 0

&(' 0

E _&23"

*N / 1( B

* Q .

References

1. Lindblad BM, Holritz-Rasmussen B, Sandman PO. A life enriching togetherness--meanings of informal support when being a parent of a child with disability. Scand J Caring Sci 2007; 21(2): 238-46.

2. Scott Ricci S, Kyle T. Maternity and pediatric nursing. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2009.

3. Hockenberry MJ, Wilson D. Wong's nursing care of infants and children. 8^th ed. Philadelphia, PA:

Mosby/Elsevier; 2007.

4. Johnson CP, Kastner TA. Helping families raise children with special health care needs at home. Pediatrics 2005;

115(2): 507-11.

5. The Michigan Developmental Disabilities Council. Family Resources and Services Utilization [Online]. [cited 1992 Dec 2]; Available from: URL: http://mn.gov/mnddc/parallels2/pdf/90s/92/92-FSS-MDD.pdf

6. Goodman H, Davison J, Preedy M, Peters E, Waters P, Persaud-Rai B, et al. Patient and staff perspective of a nurse-led support programme for patients waiting for cardiac surgery: participant perspective of a cardiac support programme. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs 2009; 8(1): 67-73.

7. Almasri NA. Family needs of parents of children and youth with cerebral palsy. Boca Raton, FL: Universal- Publishers; 2010.

8. International Committee of the Red Cross. Convention on the Rights of the Child [Online]. [cited 1989 Nov 20];

Available from: URL: http://https://www.icrc.org/ihl/INTRO/540?OpenDocument

9. Mobarak R, Khan NZ, Munir S, Zaman SS, McConachie H. Predictors of stress in mothers of children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh. J Pediatr Psychol 2000; 25(6): 427-33.

10. Resch JA, Mireles G, Benz MR, Grenwelge C, Peterson R, Zhang D. Giving parents a voice: A qualitative study of the challenges experienced by parents of children with disabilities. Rehabil Psychol 2010; 55(2): 139-50.

11. Schuengel C, Rentinck IC, Stolk J, Voorman JM, Loots GM, Ketelaar M, et al. Parents' reactions to the diagnosis of cerebral palsy: associations between resolution, age and severity of disability. Child Care Health Dev 2009;

35(5): 673-80.

12. McManus V, Michelsen SI, Parkinson K, Colver A, Beckung E, Pez O, et al. Discussion groups with parents of children with cerebral palsy in Europe designed to assist development of a relevant measure of environment.

Child Care Health Dev 2006; 32(2): 185-92.

13. Brehaut JC, Kohen DE, Raina P, Walter SD, Russell DJ, Swinton M, et al. The health of primary caregivers of

114(2): e182-e191.

14. Mendenhall AN, Mount K. Parents of children with mental illness: exploring the caregiver experience and caregiver-focused interventions. Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Social Services 2011; 92(2):

183-90.

15. Akbarinia S. Investigation on depression rate in the parents of cerebral palsy children and its correlative factors in rehabilitation day centers of Kermanshah city [Thesis]. School of Rehabilitation Management, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Science 2010. [In Persian].

16. Khanjani MS, Hatamizade N, Hosseini MA, Rahgozar M, Arhmand M. Survey of effect of education of care of cerebral palsy children on family caregivers' quality of life. J Rehab 2009; 10(3): 38-42. [In Persian].

17. Khayatzadeh M. A comparative study about quality of life in mothers of children with cerebral palsy, mental retardation and mothers of normal children. Daneshvar Med 2009; 16(83): 49-58. [In Persian].

18. Sajedi F, Alizad V, Malekkhosravi G, Karimlou M, Vameghi R. Depression in mothers of children with cerebral palsy and its relation to severity and type of cerebral palsy. Acta Med Iran 2010; 48(4): 250-4. [In Persian].

19. Samieie S, Parsa Z, Mehran A, Masori S. Compare of adaptive behaviors in sisters or brothers' children with chronic disease with healthy children. Hayat 2003; 9(1-2): 33-40. [In Persian].

20. Sharghi A, Nabaei B, Parak M, Farokhi AR. Depression in mothers of children with Thalassemia or blood malignancies in pediatric medical center. Tehran Univ Med J 2005; 63(7): 599-606. [In Persian].

21. Mohamadkhan Kermanshahi S, Vanaki Z, Ahmadi F, Azad Falah P, Kazemnejad A. Mother's experiences of having mental retarded child. J Rehab 2006; 7(3): 26-33. [In Persian].

22. Radfar M, Ahmadi F, Falahi khoshknab M. Family: the main shelter of depression patients. J Rehab 2013; 14(1):

108-19. [In Persian].

23. Strauss A, Corbin JM. Basics of qualitative research: techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory.

New York, NY: SAGE Publications; 1998.

24. Hsieh HF, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res 2005; 15(9): 1277-88.

25. Elo S, Kyngas H. The qualitative content analysis process. J Adv Nurs 2008; 62(1): 107-15.

26. Welfare organization Aoora. The comprehensive law for supporting disabled persons' right [Online]. [cited 2004 May 26 ]; Available from: URL: http://www.behzisti.ir/modules/showframework.aspx [In Persian].

27. Department of Development and Management of Human Capital. Regulation of distance working [Online]. [cited 2010 Jul 7]; Available from: URL: http:// www.assc.ir/content/media/law/634310340869257500.doc [In Persian].

28. Polit DF, Beck CT. Essentials of Nursing Research: Methods, Appraisal, and Utilization. Philadelphia, PA:

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2006.

29. Yoshisizadeh M. Chairman of the rights of Iranian disabled persons Association, laws of support for disable persons don't have sanction [Online]. [cited 2011 Feb 20]; Available from: URL:

http://www.magiran.com/npview.asp?ID=2452704 [In Persian].

30. Proportion of fuel charge for disabled persons, interview with Yahya Sokhangoe, rehabilitation assistant of welfare organization [Online]. [cited 2012 Nov 12]; Available from: URL: http://www.hamshahrionline.ir/

[In Persian].

31. Negarandeh R, Oskouie S, Ahmadi F, Nikravesh M. Patient advocacy barriers and facilitators in nurses' experiences. Razi j Med Sci 2005; 12(47): 175-86. [In Persian].

32. Khankeh HR, Mohammade R, Ahmadi F. Facilitators and barriers factors for health services during disasters events. J Rehab 2005; 6(1): 23-30. [In Persian].

33. Mosavi Chalak SH. Obstacles of presence of handicapped persons in society [Online]. [cited 2013 Dec 4];

Available from: URL: http://www.khabaronline.ir/detail/326017/weblog/mosavichalak [In Persian].

34. Graungaard AH, Skov L, Andersen JS. Becoming a client of the Danish social service system increases stress in parents of disabled infants. Dan Med Bull 2011; 58(6): A4270.

35. Carduff E, Finucane AK. Understanding the barriers to identifying carers of people with advanced illness in primary care: triangulating three data sources. BMC Family Practice 2014; 15: 48.

36. Movaghari Sadatmahale M, Amir Hosseini M, Movaghari R, Rahimi S. Perspective of clinical nurses about their role barriers. Iran J Nurs Res 2013; 8(2): 26-36. [In Persian].

37. Eskandari M, Abbaszadeh A, Borhani F. Changing care: New challenge in health care process in rural society according to health care providers' experience. J Health Promot Manag 2012; 1(2): 66-74. [In Persian].

38. Kruzich JM, Jivanjee P, Robinson A, Friesen BJ. Family caregivers' perceptions of barriers to and supports of participation in their children's out-of-home treatment. Psychiatr Serv 2003; 54(11): 1513-8.

39. Vasli P, Salsali M, Tatarpoor P. Perspectives of nurses on barriers of parental participation in pediatric care: a qualitative study. Hayat 2012; 18(3): 22-32. [In Persian].

40. Ngui EM, Flores G. Satisfaction with care and ease of using health care services among parents of children with special health care needs: the roles of race/ethnicity, insurance, language, and adequacy of family-centered care.

Pediatrics 2006; 117(4): 1184-96.

41. Reagin A. Strengthening health care for children: primary care and the medical home. Washington, DC: National Business Group on Health, 2009.

42. White CL, Korner-Bitensky N, Rodrigue N, Rosmus C, Sourial R, Lambert S, et al. Barriers and facilitators to caring for individuals with stroke in the community: the family's experience. Can J Neurosci Nurs 2007; 29(2): 5-12.

43. Mohammadi F, Dabbaghi F, Nikravesh M. Facilitator and barriers factors in family caregiving process of Iranian frail elderly: qualitative study. Iran J Nurs 2008; 21(55): 55-65. [In Persian].

44. Pouladi S, Anoosheh M, Kazemnejad A, Zareiyan A. Factors limiting families in elderly care: a thematic analysis. J Qual Res Health Sci 2013; 2(2): 146-57. [In Persian].

45. Burkhard A. A different life: caring for an adolescent or young adult with severe cerebral palsy. J Pediatr Nurs 2013; 28(4): 357-63.

1- PhD Candidate, Department of Nursing, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences AND Faculty Member, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran

2- Associate Professor, Social Determinants of Health Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran

3- Associate Professor, Department of Nursing, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran 4- Assistant Professor, Department of Nursing, School of Medicine, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

Barriers to Support for Parents of Children with Cerebral Palsy:

A Qualitative Study

Nasrin Alaee¹, Farahnaz Mohammadi Shahboulaghi², Hamidreza Khankeh³, Sima Mohammad Khan Kermanshahi⁴

Abstract

Introduction: Parents who have children with cerebral palsy are exposed to the complicated care procedures of the afflicted child. Thus, they need support in order to decrease problems in this respect.

However, their needs are not sufficiently met. Therefore, this study was conducted to explore barriers to support for parents of children with cerebral palsy.

Method: This qualitative study was conducted in 2011-2012 using content analysis. Purposeful sampling was used to select the participants and continued until data saturation was reached. As a result, 31 participants from among parents of children with cerebral palsy referred to the rehabilitation centers in Tehran, Iran, and experts were selected. The data were collected by in-depth semi-structured interviews and from collected documents, and were analyzed by induction method.

Results: Data analysis results revealed three main categories of organizational barriers (poor institutional coordination and communication, and lack of supportive laws with administrative support), professional barriers (poor teamwork, and lack of professional competency), and family barriers.

Conclusion: Through understanding parents' needs and complementing supportive laws for parents with afflicted children, coordination among supportive organizations, and planning for comprehensive care along with supportive services packages, policy makers and health services managers can help eliminate parents' problems with regard to caring for their children with cerebral palsy.

Keywords: Parents, Cerebral palsy in children, Support, Barriers, Qualitative study

Citation: Alaee N, Mohammadi Shahboulaghi F, Khankeh H, Mohammad Khan Kermanshahi S.

Barriers to Support for Parents of Children with Cerebral Palsy: A Qualitative Study. J Qual Res Health Sci 2015; 3(4): 305-16.

Received date: 14.7.2014 Accept date: 18.11.2014

Original Article