2017 XBRL and the Qualitative Characteristics of Useful Financial Information

(1)

Accounting Research Journal

XBRL and t he Qualit at ive Charact erist ics of Usef ul Financial Inf ormat ion

Jacqueline L Birt Kala Muthusamy Poonam Bir

Article information:

To cite this document:

Jacqueline L Birt Kala Muthusamy Poonam Bir , (2017)," XBRL and the Qualitative Characteristics of Useful Financial Information ", Accounting Research Journal, Vol. 30 Iss 1 pp.

-Permanent link t o t his document :

http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/ARJ-11-2014-0105 Downloaded on: 24 March 2017, At : 21: 09 (PT)

Ref erences: t his document cont ains ref erences t o 0 ot her document s. To copy t his document : permissions@emeraldinsight . com

The f ullt ext of t his document has been downloaded 36 t imes since 2017*

Users who downloaded this article also downloaded:

(2017),"Do Government Administered Financial Rewards Undermine Firms’ Internal Whistle-Blowing Systems? A Pitch", Accounting Research Journal, Vol. 30 Iss 1 pp. - http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/ARJ-07-2016-0087

(2017),"Regulatory Enforcement, Financial Reporting Quality and Investment Efficiency: A Pitch", Accounting Research Journal, Vol. 30 Iss 1 pp. - http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/ARJ-07-2016-0094

Access t o t his document was grant ed t hrough an Emerald subscript ion provided by emerald-srm: 602779 [ ]

For Authors

If you would like t o writ e f or t his, or any ot her Emerald publicat ion, t hen please use our Emerald f or Aut hors service inf ormat ion about how t o choose which publicat ion t o writ e f or and submission guidelines are available f or all. Please visit www. emeraldinsight . com/ aut hors f or more inf ormat ion.

About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com

Emerald is a global publisher linking research and pract ice t o t he benef it of societ y. The company manages a port f olio of more t han 290 j ournals and over 2, 350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an ext ensive range of online product s and addit ional cust omer resources and services.

Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.

*Relat ed cont ent and download inf ormat ion correct at t ime of download.

(2)

XBRL and the Conceptual Framework

! " # $ # #

% & #

# # #' # $

( ! % )* +, - $ . )* ) % /

# &0- 120- 3 # 2 $"

&0- )* * )

# # # ! # # # # #

# %+ ₃ _# _!

# %

2 # # # 4 5 $

4 5 672 # ! !

# ! 888 % 4 ! 9 #

# ! )* * % 0

# 6 7 # 2 672

# # # # 0

)**+, 7 # % )**) %

)

# ! &0- 20- " $ &0- 00- "

$ 0 &2 - )**: 00- )* ) % # !

&0- 20- " $ 0 %

+

2 %

(3)

)

# $ # # #

# # 4 %

)**; % 2 # # '

# ! ( #

)**; % #' # ! #

# ! # #

( # )**;, < )* ; %

! #

$ # %

# # ! $ !

)* ), 4 5 )* ), % % )* ; % '

! ! # #

% # # =

% )* , > % )* ) % #

" # # $ %

$ )**?, % % )* ; % 2 #'

! # $ % )**?, %

# # #

# #

! # # 4 % )**;, 0

6 # #$ )* ) %;_& _!

09 )* % #

%

;

# ! # #

# # # 4 % )**; %

(4)

+

@ < )* * % &

A-- # # 3 - 3 #

! )**:

# # )**8 @ < )* * % - # # !

# # AB

2 # ( - 9 @ . )**C 3 '

# ! '

9 @ . )**8 % & # # 3 . D

-B - - !

9 @ . )**8 % - # ( )* * 0 !

# %

& #

! # # $ #

% & ! !

$ # ! ! #

# 672

# # # $% 0 #

$ # " # #

E

0 0## - F00- G% )**8 H %

6 # # #

# 0 6 # #$ )* ),

(5)

;

% )**?, ( ! 5 # )* *, > % )* ) % 4 !

# # # # %

# ! ! #

# # &0-

120-3 # 2 $" ' ! # # # % 5 ! #

# # ! 672 # $% &

# # " # # ! %

# # # 0 # # #

% # !

# A- 0 7 # )* ) %

# 0 0

: % 0 ! #

0 7 )**H !

0 09 )* % ! !

# # % 7 # !

!

# # # #

% 4 # ! #$ ##

# # # " %

!

! # 672 # # %

- # # #

# % 0 !

(6)

:

! #

# 672

%

# # % 2 !

! # # # %

- # ! #$

# #

%

# # #

! # #

# % #

# 0

! # ( # # - ; )* ) %

6 # # #

" # $ $ #

# # 4 )**), 4 % )**;

( ! % )* ; % = 5 )**8

# ! #

# = 5 )**8 % 2

# # # #

(7)

?

! # #

# ( ! 5 # )* *, 6 $

/ )**8 % # #

# $ # # #

%

7 #

# $ 4 % )**;, % % )* ; % A

# ! ! # / #

)** , % % )* ; # !

$ # 672 4 5 # 7 %

)**8, % % )* ; % ! #

# ! " # $ # %

! # # ! '

# ' < %

)* % 2 ! # #

## # # # # #

# 5 % )* *, > % )* ) %

!

! # # # 5 % )* * %

! #

# " $ # ## %

(8)

H

! # #

! " # $ % 4 % )**; !

# # #'

# $ ! # %: _!

# # # # ! # #$

# # 672 #

4 % )**; % # ! #

# $ # 4 %

)**;, 5 % )* *, 6 # )**H %

= % )* 4 % )**;

# # #

# ? _# _## _! _%

# 4 5 672 %

# #' !

! " # % # # # 4 % "

)**; # ! # # ! "

#' # % # # !

# # ##

# # %

:

4 % )**; 5 0 #

# ) $ ! # %

?

2 # ## # # ! # ! # #

# # #

# = % )* %

(9)

C

0 = % )**8 # ! # !

672 4 5 %

## # # !

= % )**8 % 6 $ /

)**8 # ! # # # ! #

# #

# # ! # $ % ( ! % )* +

# # #

# # # 672%

E ! # #

# # %

6 # ! ! # #

# # # ! 6 $ / )**8 ! #'

4 % )**; # !

6 $ / )**8 % 4 !

# # %

( ! % )* + # # !

# ! # %

$ # ! #

% & # ! # '

# ! # #

$% # #

# ## # %

(10)

8

2 4 % )**; #

! ! # #$

% 4 # ! ! #

# %

3. Theoretical framework and hypotheses development

% )**? # ! '

# ' ! # # #

% % ! # %

' # !

% )**? % # #

# # > )* ) %

% )**? > % )* ) ! #

# # %

! $ ! %

E # ! # ! #

$ # &0- )* * I3) %

4 ! # #

I ! 3 # # 2 #

! % 2

# # # !

&0- )* * I3; %H _& _#

H

# # # # +%)%

(11)

*

# #

&0-20- )**C % 3 # 2 $ #

$

% )**?, > % )* ) % % )**?

> % )* ) # ! ' !

# # # # ! %

0## ! # ## 3 # 2 $

! $ # " # &0- )* *

I3; % 2 # # $ # #

# ! # ! &0- )* * I3H %

# ! " # $ %

2 # ! 9 % )**: #

' ## % #

# '

! % # # 672%

J # #

# ! # ! < %

)* % # 4 % " )**; %

# # #

$ #' # ! %

(12)

# !

# # #

> % )* ) %

5 ! # # !

# > % )* ) %

# # !

# # # !

# $ < % )* # # ! #

# # % )**? %

# # !

! # $ #

# % #

K

! "

!

#$% &'

! "

A ' ! # # # # #

# # # # # &0- )* * I3 +* %

& # # ! , $

(13)

)

$ # &0- )* * %C _.

# #

# 672 $ # ##

# % 2 #

# ! #

#$ !

# 2 #$ 5 )**;, 5

% )* * %

! ! # ##

## # #

## # )* ) % #

# ! # # #

# ## > % )* )

! # 7 # % )**: % 2

# !

# # ! !

&0-

20-% )**8 20-% # L $ # $ "

# # % #

K

!

" " !

#$% &'

C

& # ! # $

# &0- )* * %

(14)

+

# "

0## 3 # 2 $ # # ' !

# # #

# &0- )* * I3) % 2

# " # # #

#

! &0- )* * I3)* %

A # #

# $ # # ! #

# # "

# > % )* ) % 2 '

# ## # % &

# #

# # %

)**?, ! % )**) % # %

& # # # #

# #

# # $

# % K

(15)

;

"

! #$% &

'

#

0## ! # " # # #

5 % 88H % &

- )* $ # # # # !

# % ! # # #

00- ;

- %

- 0 6 # #$ )* )

! % #

" # 0 6 # #$ )* ) %

# !

# % # #

# #$ @<

)* *, )* ) % A # # !

% 4 ! #

! # ! # #

# $ # # %

K

(16)

: !

! #$% &

'

$

%&

6 # ! #

$ # = % )**8, = % )* , 4

% )**;, 4 6 $ )**?, 6 $ / )**8 % 0

! ## #

! ! # 5#7 4 88? % .

# 2 # # %

/ # ! # ##

# ! $ # # #

$%

2 ! ! # " ! # $

# # # # # 5 )**:,

( ! % )* + % 6 # # #

! # $ # $

# 4 % )**; % 2 ! $

# $ $

# 4 % )**;, 6 $ / )**8 %

(17)

?

;%) #

# # #

' % # # #

# 672

# E # ! %8

# # ## # # *

- # # 3 A - % #

# ! '

# 5 # # %

& ! 672 # # #

# ! # "

# $% ! ! E

# # * # % !

# # #$ #

! # #

% ! # #

# %

8

672 # % #

672 # 4 % )**; % 672

# # = % )**8, 4 % )**; %

*

0 # # # ! 5#7 4 88? %

(18)

H

# #

# %

# # !

# # % $ # #

! # # ## # ## #

# % A ! #

# # #$ $ M # N

# ! - 3 %

# ! #

672 % - '

# # # #

' # ' # # 0 % & # 0

# ' # #

) % . ' ! #

# $ # # % &

# # # # # #

# ! # # *

** ! - )* % ' #

! % ' '

# ! $ # M N

M N = % )**8, 6 $ / )**8 %)_{- #}

' ' # # ' %

& # # %

)

H # # " ! #

%

(19)

C

' # $ # #

# # #

%

$

'

"

0 # E # ! # !

# ! # #

&0- )* * % # ) +

H $ # %+ ₄ _;

- )* # # ! #

# # * ** ! %

# # * ** !

;%

# "

# # # " E # #

$ # # # !

% 0 # ! #

## # # %

-0 )* !

! # %

+

# ! %

E !

%

(20)

8

# # $

# % )* %

2 # # # $ # 3

! # # ! ! #

0 # # # 3 %

)* , / . 888 % = % )**8 4 % )**;

! # ! "

# ! ! %

" # # # !

! % # ! # %

$ $ '

0 ! !

J # 5 % !

# # % ,

= + +

(' )

= + +

(' )

= + +

(' )

(21)

)* = + +

(' $)

! %

"

* 6 # " # ! #

! #

$ 672 #

# H $ # %

* ! " 6 # " #

! #

$

672 # # H

$ # %

* # "

$* #

6 # " # ! # #

# $

672 # # *

** # %

6 # " # !

#

# $ #

672 #

(22)

)

! K

"

0 ! # #

*

%

# "

+ 0 ! # #

* %

, 0 # "

$ ! ) + ; #

O 8 ); ): +* + +? P+? %

- %& 0 ! # #

# 1 ## #

$ # * %

. 0 ! # #

0 # 9 *

%

% 0 ! # #

3 #$ * %

/ 6 # " !

# #

* **%

# H $ # %

(23)

))

0

0 1 #

6 0 # # # 8C # # !

# # ! % J ! # 672

# # # %

# $ # # L %;

2 3.% 4 4, % % %5

0 6 "

6 # ! #

# # # " % &

# ! # # #

672 # % ! # ! # :%C8 H

:%: H 672% A #

:%8; :%H+ # ! % # #

:%)H ;%8? #

# ! % 3 # !

# # ! # ? %?+ **

# 672 # :?% ) ** % #

# 672 # %

;

! #

672 # % & # #

$ # % J! H*Q 3

#

(24)

)+

:%+ 3 #

) # # 6 #

-$ # 0 # ! % - $ #

# ! !

# # ! - )* % 6 - $

# # # %

0 # # # $ # !

# % 6 ! #

# % # ! #

! ! # # % 2

! # ! #

! # :: # %

# ## ! #

# 5 8H; %:₀ _#

! ! # ! # %?

# # ! ! #

# #

! # )+ # +* # + # # ! %

- ' ! - $ # %

! ) +% . ! # !

:

5 8H; # ! # #

# $ # $ %

?

0## 2 )**: # # # ! #

*%C ! # %

(25)

);

# # # % &

! # #

:: # # C* # %

2 3.% 4 4, % % %5

0 $ ,376,

+ # #

672 ! # R )%+H R *%*) R +% O*%*

# R +%) O*%* % # #

# # ! R %?+ P*% % # #

! # R )%* R *%*: %

2 3.% 4 4, % % %5

0 0 '

) + ;% 5

! # $ #

# # ! % #

#

! $ # # #

% ! 5 ! # ( )

+%*? O *%* 6 ) *% )% #

# # ! #

(26)

):

$ # # # % H

2 # ! # # ! #

5 K( )+%+ O *%* # "

# #' ! = % )**8 %

/ $ # # 0##

2 # $ # # ! #

! ! # %

5 ) %

) # #

# $

# # # % 0 #

; 5 ) ! # ( )+%*C O

*%* % C _! _{# !} _#

# $ #

# % 8 ₃ _! _$ _#

# # # %)*

&

# # ## # $ #

! #

%

H

# % )**? > % )* )

# # ' ! # # # ! # #

! # 3 # 2 $%H 4 %

C

6 ) 5 ) *%*8)%

8

# # # #

" # $ 7 # % )**: , 2 #$ 5 )**;, > %

)* ) % 3 # 2 $'

)*

# # $ #

%

(27)

)?

& + + #

$ ## # ! % ; 5 +

# ! # # 3 (R

+%+; R O*%* %) _# _$

# $ #

# # % ! #

! $ #

% )**?, 5 % )* *, > % )* ) %

# % )**?, 2 #$

5 )**;, > % )* ), < % )* # #

# #

% 2 # ! !

# # # # %

2 3.% 4 4, % $ % %5

# # #

! !

% & # #

% 4 # ! ! #

# $ #

E # ! 3 # 2 $ 2 # %

2 3.% 4 4, % 0 % %5

)

6 ) 5 ) *%*H)%

(28)

)H

5.6 Ease of use and user friendliness of XBRL

& ## # # !

> % )* ) %

6 # $ H $ #

# # % A

# Q # # ! ! #

! 9 R )%?* O*%* % #

! # $

# # % . ! # #

:Q ! # # %

6 # $

# # %

A ! #

Q # # ! 9 R )%C: O*%* % !

! # #

# 672 # %

:%H - !

& # #

% 2 ! # J -%

A #

J 5 # # %

# # Q # # ! % - # !

(29)

)C

, $ # #

) +% 0 #

Q # # ! # %

J! ! 4 ) +

# I ! 3 # # 3 # 2 $ 2 #

# ! # # #

%

# # 3 # 2 $'

8 #

9

E # !

#

# # $ # #

% #

3 # 2 $ 2 # # I !

3 # # A 2 # & % % ! #

# % ! # # # !

# %

# ! # #

# # %

# !

7 # % )**), = % )**8 % # # !

(30)

)8

# # # #

% % )**? > % )* )

# # # E # ! #

# ' !

# # # # %

!

# # ' ! # # # 3 #

2 $ 2 # # ! #

# # % 0 !

# ! # # !

# $ # # %

! # # $ #

# $% &

# ! # # # 672 # %

3 # 2 $ 2 # ! # #$

% !

# # ! !

! # ! %

# ! % 2

# # ! %

- ! # # !

(31)

+*

# # # 4 % )**;, = % )* , # #

# ! # $ 6 $ / )**8 ,

# ! = % )**8 % !

# E # ! #

! %

# # # !

%

& 0 # # #

% ! # # # !

! #

# % #

! #

% 4 ! #

! 0 % & $

0 #

! % ! #$

# % & # #

! ! ## # %

E # ! % 2 # !

# ! # # " !

# # # $ %

- # # # # ! #

! % - #

(32)

+

# 5 # # % 0

# # ! - 3

! # #

%

# #

! #

% #

# ! # % J

# 2 # # #

# ! #$ % 7

! ! #

!

# $ % 0 #

!

# 0

%

# # % 2

# # ! #

! # % - #

#

# # 4 5 % # # # "

! # # !

# ! #

(33)

+)

! # %))₂ _{# #} _#

# ! # % # #

# ! #

# ! # %

,,.

( ::;)9

7

"

:9 ( :

)9

*<<===

"

<

:0< ;</

=

>:?@:$>#7'1

:?>: @:;

,,.

( :

)9

7

"

:9 ( :

)9

*<<===

"

<,"

@

@,,. </

@

& @ A

B8

,

9 ,

9 , ( :: )9C

*

=

C9

!

"

# $

$ %

&

6

3 89

80@ ::

,

9 '

1

9 ' ( :

)9

C-D ,

=

C9

!

"

$ !

&

6

9

; @ :B

0 5% 7 # % )* ) S ! # S

* + ,- !> % + % C+

8*%

0

0% B%

.

% B% 0% )**8 S&

# !

#

K 0

! !

$

S

*

%

.

> %? . %+

% )?) )H)%

0 >% (%3% 6 (% % - % -% )* ) S #

' ! # ! # $ K & #

S * + ,- !

> % + %) )*%

))

& # ' ! # # !

! %

(34)

++

0 4% ( B% 5% / %7% 888 S3

S + / ( !> % + . % + %); ):H%

0 = ! % )* ) J 6 K A J

-- 2 2 # . ! %

09 -% % 7% )* S- 0 K>

$ # # #

S + - $ " > % *

% ? ; %

(35)

+;

09E

&%

2

5%

8H:

0

&

'

!

(

%

$& )

*+

= 9 , , 9

= 9 # %

4

9

. ( ::8)9

C

* ,

=

C9

"

,

$ $ (

$

$&

6

9

;?@

8

= 9 , ,

4

9

. ( :

)9 C4

* ,

C9

(

!

"

# $

$ %

6

9

@

$

" 9

'

7

9 4 ( :: )9 C

=

" "

*

+

9

C9

(

-

"

,

&

6

8 3

9

8 @ ;

9 6

1

9 E ( :: )9 C

= "@

"

* ,

=

C9

(

$ % '

&

6

0 3

9

00@ B?

9 F

.

9 + ( :

)9 C/

C

$ %

"

6

$ 3

9

$0@ 8?

G9 F %

3

- + ( ::B)9 C4

.%#H

%

* ,

A

C9

.

!

$&

6

3

&

8@0:

G9 F % 9

3

- + ( ::;)9 C,

@

* 4

!

4

#

C9

"

!

6

3

9

$;@?B

9 ' 9 %

9 ' 9 .

9

1

6

9 '

, ( :: )9 C

:::

&

"

@

DC

"

!

&

6

89

80@ B

(36)

+:

#

9 1 9 #

9

1

9 # ( :

)9 C4

I

* ,

,

@

#

C9

,

$ % '

&

6

3

9

0 @ B

#

9

6

( ;;B)9 C,

C9

'

% '

&

6

? 3

9

:?@

B

9 /

( ;B;)9 C1

9

@

C9

)! -

&

6

9

;@

;

9 /

( ;; )9 C!

*

9

"

C9

!

"

)

*)

&

6

B9

$?0@$B?

"

9

9 #

9 , 9 + @, #

9 F F

9

9 3

9 1 ( ::0)9C /

.%#H

* ,

A

C9

"

!

&

6

;

3

9

; @

:

"

9

+

9 +

( :: )9 C4

*

'

C9

!

"

$ !

&

6

9

$?@?$

"

9

+

9 +

'

9 4 F ( :: )9 C/

= "

* -

=

C9

(

!

"

# $

$ %

&

6

3

9

@

"

9

+

9 +

9 , ( :: )9 C4

C9

"

$

/

&

6

3

$@09

? @ ;$

9

9 +

9 , -

= 9 , , ( :: )9 - "@

"

*

9

!

"

$ !

&

6

$9

B0@ :

(37)

+?

9 4 #

9

9 ,

'

9

( ::;)9

* 4

=

9

.

9

@8;

%

9 F 9 1

9 F

.

9

' ( : $)9 C

D %

@

C9

"

%

9 6

8?9

:;;J

:0

%

9

E

F

"

9 1

( ::$)9 C#

"

C9

$

0

&

6

B 3

$9

B:@;8

%

K L

( : :)9 ,

*

"

.

"

B9 :

9

*<<===

<1 "

< = !,

<,

>

@

=<M/

%<,

%

K L

( : $)9 -

D

3

"

:9 : $9

*<<

*<<===

<!.<

<

<+

@

<

<,

@

@- "@

%

"

@

/,. 9 K ,.

( ::B)9 F

=

.

"

:9 ( :

)9

*<<===

"

<@

I

<

>

">

>

( ::B)

/

9 F

'

9 F ( ::$)9 C4

H

H A

I

C9

(

$ % '

&

6

?; 3

9

88?@8B8

+

9

( : $)

9

=

3

"

:9 ( : $)9

*<<===

<3 = @

'

<#

@

<

< :

@

@'

@

@-

@4

@/

&

(38)

+H

+

9 % E 9

=

9 /

4

9 . ( ::;)9 C

* !

9

C9

(

!

"

# $

$ %

&

6

;9

$0@;B

+

9 % E 9

=

9 /

4

9 . ( :

) C/

&

* %&

C9

(

$ % '

&

6

$ 9

B8@ ;;

+

9 +

'

9

- ( ::;)9 C

*

=

"

C9

!

"

#

1 '

&

6

8 3

9

:?@

9 3 ( :: )9 C,

* #

DC9

$

2

B$ 3

9

8 @8

9 4 .

'

9 . ( :

)9 C,

&"

C9

.

& .

,3

$

9 -

1

3

"

4

9 /

9 E

9 F F

'

9

, ( ::$)9 C

@

C9

(

$ % '

&

6

?; 3

9

8B?@?:

9 /

1

' ( ::8)9 C4

&

H

C9

"

$&

$ 4

&

6

3

9

8?@ ;

9 E ,

9 F / / ( ;; )9 C4

" =

"

C9

$

&

6

3

9

@ $?

,.

( : :)9

.

$

*

/

.

(39)

+C

F

9

'

9 ' / ( : :)9 C4

* ,

=

C9

% '

!

&

6

$ 3

9

@ $

F

9

9 '

9 ' /

1

9

( :

)9 C

9

%&

1 /D 4

C9

"

!

6

? 3

9

0@$;

F

9

%

9 F N ( :: )9C#

G

9

=

"

C9

$

0

&

6

0 3

9

:;@

E

9 '

3

9

( : :)9 C

H

C9

"

)

$

$&

6

8 3 $9

B@$$

9 # 9

9

9 . 9 #

9 /

9 + 7

4

9

( : $)9 C4

1

#

C9

#

9 6

0;9

$ J

$;

9 + ,

'

9 ' F ( ::0) C#

* ,

A

C9

$

&

6

9

@

0

9 , ( ;;;)9 C4

%

C9

(

,

$

% '

&

6

B 3

9

B;@ :

'

9

, 9 '

9

.

9 ' . ( ;;?)9

C

H

I

C9

"

$ %

&

6

09

@ $

'

9

+

/ ( ::$) C%&

"

* 4

@

C9

!

"

&

6

; 3

9

8:@B

(40)

+8

'

9

( ::;)9 C4

" A

C9 1

,

%

,

'

9 .

/

9#,9 @ B

'

9

9 '

9 E 9

9 ,

1

9 E

( : :)9 C6

G

"

= *

O

P

DC9

(

!

"

# $

$ %

&

6

:9

?@0$

'

9

.

9 F

'

;;8 C4

&

@

C9

.

$

%

&

6

3

9

;@ 0

'

9

9 .

9 '

.

!

: :9

C

5'

& 3

3

C9 E

-%

'

9 F

( ;?$)9 CQ

"I

* ,

"

C9

"

$ %

&

6

3

9

BB@ ;B

1

9 ' 9 /

9 # ,9 +

"

9

( ::;)9

C

C9

!

"

#

1 '

&

6

8 3

9

$@ $:

1

9

( ::$)9 C4

"

* ,

C9

"

,

&

6

0 3

@ 9

0@ ?

1

9

( ::B)9 C,

&

C9

(

!

"

# $

$ %

&

6

B 3

$9

B @;8

(41)

;*

1

9

-

9 1 ( ::;)9 C3

H

@

"

@

C9

!

"

#

1 '

&

6

89 3

9

$ @ 8

1

9

1

' , ( ::B)9 C,

C9

$

0

&

6

9 3

9

0 @ 8B

1

9 F 4 9

9

- ( :: )9 C,

A

C9

(

5

"

&

6

: 3

09

B@

$

1 =

9

/ 9

, ( ::?)9 C'

G

=

C9

-&

8@

=

9 , , 9 .

9 '

,"

9 ' .

( :

)9 C#

"

C9

+

% '

%

&

6

3

9

;@ 0$

9 . 9 /

9 L9

E G

9 ' ( ::;)9 C

*

C9

!

"

#

1 '

&

6

8 3

$9

00@ 8;

="

9 3 9 ,

9 ,

, ( ::0)9 C,

&

= "

C9

!

"

$ !

6

8 3

9

@

0

="

9 3 9

, ( : :)9 C%&

C9

"

$ %

9

6

3

9

;:@ :B

(42)

;

.%# ( : :)9 /

* =

=

H

D

'

$ ( :

)9

*<<===<

<

<&" <=

@ @

Steenkamp, L.P. and Nel, G.F. (2012),"The adoption of XBRL in South Africa: an empirical study", The Electronic Library, Vol. 30 No. 3 pp. 409 - 425.

(43)

;)

4

9 9

( ::?)9 C

* ,

=

=C9

,

"

!

'

&

6

: 3

9

?8@ ::

6

9

' ( :

)9 C / .

&

* 4

C9

!

"

$ !

&

6

9

8 @

B:

6

9 6 E 9

.

9

1 ( :: )9 C%&

"

@

"

*

C9

!

$

% '

6

8 3

9

$ @0;

6

9 ' , 9 #

9

L

E

9 F 1 ( :

)9

C#

A

C9

"

!

6

8 3

9

00@ 8?

-

9 , ( :: )9 %

A

% '

&

6

009

8 @ ?;

-

9 , ( :: )9 C4

=

C9

&

6

; 3

9

;@

-

9

( ;B:)9 C,

@

&

C9

,

&

6

$B 3

$9

B ?@B B

-

9 .

3

9 . ( ;;;) C

* %&

C9

(

"

/

$

6

; 3

9

: @

0

( :

)9

"

.

"

89

( :

)9

*<<=== &"

<+

.

L

9

9 N 9

#

9 , 1 ( :

)9 C

DC9

"

%

&

6

8$ 3

&

0?@ 8

(44)

;+

L

9

-

9 L ( ::;)9 C.

A

"

G

C9

!

"

)

$

&

6

$ 3

9

?@

;

(45)

!

"

# $ $ %$ & '

($ # $ $ %$ & '

!

) $ #

*$ #

+ ,

($ + ,

, - . !/ !/ !

0 * 1

2 3 / /

4 , / / !

$ , /! /

! $3 # , $5 5$ 3 $ $5

5 $ / $3 # , $5 6 5$ $5

$ / 7 $ 6 $ $ 3 $5

3 8 # , $ ,/

7 3 5 5$ $% 7 6 3 $5

3 8 $ 3 $ 9 & : " # # $ % 7 6

3 $5 # ,8 $ 3 $ 9 & : $ % ;

7 6 3 $5 $ , $ 3 $ 9 & /

(46)

& ' (

) $ * # # $ % ' $ % + , #

- .

(

/

"# 0 % %

2 3 /

4 , / <<< /

$ , / !<<< / <<< /

=029 / << / <<< / <<< /

/ < / / < / /

> / / / !< / / /

?$ & +' / !< / / / / << / /

) $ # / / / / / << / / !< /

+ , / / / / / << / / / << /

, / !<<< / / / << / / / / / /

2 3 /

4 , / <<< /

$ , / !<<< / <<< /

=029 / <<

/ <

/ <<< /

/ <<< / <

/

/ /

> / ! / / !< / / /

?$ & +'

) $ # / / / / / / / /

/ << / <<

/ /

/

/ !< /

+ , / / / / / << / / / << /

, / !<<< / / / << / / / / / /

! <<<8 <<8 < * $ 5 @8 @ @ 3 8 3 ,/

(47)

1

* % # $ 2 0 ++ #

+ " # + "

) $ + " + " 3

2 3 / / / !<<

4 , / / ! / <<<

$ , /! / / <<<

! <<<8 <<8 < * $ 5 @8 @ @ 3 8 3 ,/

7 3 5 5$ $% 6 3 $5 3 8 $ 3

$ 9 & :" # # $ % 6 3 $5 # ,8 $ 3

$ 9 & : $ % 6 3 $5 $ , $ 3 $ 9 &

/

(48)

" 4 # + + 56 78 " # # $ % 56&7 # $ % 5617

# =β +β XBRL report + ∑ !"#!$β controls, +ε

# & % & '() & *+ +), =β +β XBRL report + ∑ !"#!$ β controls, +ε

# 1 -./0 ' *+ +), =β +β XBRL report + ∑ !"#!$ β controls, +ε

#

5 7

9

# &

5* # # $ %7

9

# 1

5' $ %7

9

) $ ' :3 ' :3 ' :3

=029 / / <<< / / <<< / / <<<

/ /! < / / < / / <<

> / ! / / / /! / <

?$ & +'

/ / < /! / < / / !

) $

#

/ / / / / /

+ , / / ! / / / /

, / / <<< / / << / / !

9$ & $$ / /! /

# $ 2 / / / !

! <<<8 <<8 < * $ 5 @8 @ @ 3 8 3 ,/

7 3 5 5$ $% 6 3 $5 3 8 $ 3

$ 9 & :" # # $ % 6 3 $5 # ,8 $ 3 $

9 & : $ % 6 3 $5 $ , $ 3 $ 9 & :

5 3 =029 5$ 5 $ 8 $ % : + $

$ $5 6 8 & 3 # 8 8 8 5$ 8 8 $ " 8

3 ,: + # 5 8 $ % : 2 . ( 5

$ # $ $ %$ & ' $# $ 5 8 $ % : "#

5 $ # $ A 8 $ % : 0 % 5

$5 & $# 8 $ % : % 6 5 , $

$ $ 5$ 8 ' % $ /