Pengembangan Model Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi

(1)

(2)

Pengembangan Model Pembelajaran

Menulis Deskripsi

(3)

(4)

Pengembangan Model Pembelajaran

Menulis Deskripsi

(5)

Pengembangan Model Pembelajaran

Menulis Deskripsi

Dr. Mohammad Siddik, M.Pd.

Layout

Tim Tunggal Mandiri Publishing

Desain Cover

Moch. Imam Bisri

Penerbit

TUNGGAL MANDIRI PUBLISHING

Anggota IKAPI JTI No. 120

Jln. Taman Kebun Raya A-1 No. 9 Pakis Malang 65154 Tlp./Fax. (0341) 795261 HP. 082233663896 e-mail: tunggalmandiri.cv@gmail.com Jumlah: viii + 140 hlm. Ukuran: 15,5 x 23 cm Cetakan I, Januari 2018 ISBN: 978-602-8878-27-2

Hak cipta dilindungi undang-undang.

Dilarang mengutip atau memperbanyak sebagian atau seluruh isi buku ini tanpa izin tertulis dari penerbit.

(6)

P

enulis menyampaikan puji syukur ke hadirat Allah Swt. berkat rahmat dan hidayah-Nya lah maka buku Pengembangan Model

Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi dapat diterbitkan. Buku ini

berisi tentang penerapan model pembelajaran menulis deskripsi bagi siswa, khususnya siswa sekolah dasar. Selain itu, di dalamnya juga berisi konsep dasar dan beberapa pandangan tentang menulis des-kripsi.

Buku ini diharapkan dapat memberi bekal dan memacu para guru dan pengajar, dosen, pelajar, mahasiswa, praktisi, dan peminat tulis-menulis untuk dapat menuangkan segala buah pikiran dan penga-lamannya secara tertulis serta dapat memberikan sumbangan yang berharga dalam pembelajaran menulis khususnya dan sumbangan terhadap pendidikan pada umumnya.

Terima kasih tak lupa penulis sampaikan kepada Tunggal Man-diri Publishing yang telah bersedia menerbitkan naskah buku ini secara professional. Penulis menyadari sepenuhnya bahwa buku ini masih dalam proses belajar, belajar, dan terus belajar sampai akhir hayat. Untuk itu, saran dan kritik membangun dari para pembaca guna perbaikan buku ini dan karya tulis ilmiah lainnya di masa mendatang sangat diharapkan.

Samarinda, Januari 2018

Penulis

KATA PENGANTAR

(7)

(8)

Daftar Isi

KATA PENGANTAR ... v

DAFTAR ISI ... vii

BAB 1 PENDAHULUAN ... 1

A. Dasar Penerapan Model Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi ... 1

B. Identifikasi Permasalahan ... 10

C. Manfaat Pengembangan Model Pembelajaran ... 14

D. Manfaat Tulisan Deskripsi ... 15

BAB 2 PANDANGAN KONSEPTUAL TENTANG MODEL PEMBELAJARAN MENULIS ... 17

A. Hakikat Tulisan Deskripsi ... 17

B. Pendekatan Pembelajaran Bahasa Indonesia di Sekolah ... 26

C. Hubungan Tulisan Deskripsi dengan Tulisan Lain ... 32

D. Macam-Macam Bentuk Tulisan Deskripsi ... 33

E. Strategi Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi Berdasarkan Pendekatan Proses ... 45

F. Model Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi yang Dikembangkan ... 48

BAB 3 ALUR PENGEMBANGAN MENULIS DESKRIPSI ... 65

A. Model Pengembangan ... 65

B. Prosedur Pengembangan ... 67

C. Uji Coba Produk ... 73

BAB 4 APLIKASI MODEL PEMBELAJARAN MENULIS DESKRIPSI YANG DIKEMBANGKAN ... 75

A. Produk Perencanaan Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi ... 75

B. Produk Materi Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi ... 95

C. Produk Evaluasi Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi ... 100

BAB 5 PEMAKNAAN HASIL PENGEMBANGAN ... 101

A. Produk Perencanaan Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi ... 101

B. Produk Materi Pembelajaran Menulis Deskripsi ... 116

(9)

BAB 6 PENUTUP ... 129

A. Produk Perencanaan Pembelajaran ... 129

B. Produk Materi Pembelajaran ... 130

C. Produk Evaluasi Pembelajaran ... 131

DAFTAR PUSTAKA ... 133

(10)

$ '$6$53(1(5$3$102'(/3(0%(/$-$5$10(18/,6 '(6.5,36, 3HQ\HOHQJJDUDDQSHPEHODMDUDQGDODPNXULNXOXPEDKDVDWLGDN WHUOHSDVGDULNRQVHSFDUDSDQGDQJDWDXSHQGHNDWDQWHUKDGDSOLQJXLVWLN 3HQGHNDWDQOLQJXLVWLNPHPEDZDSHQJDUXKEHVDUWHUKDGDSNRQVHSGDQ SHODNVDQDDQSHPEHODMDUDQEDKDVD.RQVHSGDQSHODNVDQDDQSHPEHOD MDUDQEDKDVDSDGDGDVDUQ\DGDSDWGLEHGDNDQDWDVSHQGHNDWDQIRUPDO GDQIXQJVLRQDO3DGDKDNLNDWQ\DGDODPNXULNXOXPNXULNXOXP EHUEDVLVNRPSHWHQVL.%.GDQNXULNXOXPWLQJNDWVDWXDQSHQGL GLNDQ.763\DQJGLVHEXWNXULNXOXPSDGDPDWDSHODMDUDQEDKD VD,QGRQHVLDGLNHPEDQJNDQEHUGDVDUNDQSHQGHNDWDQIXQJVLRQDO

3ULQVLSSULQVLS SDQGDQJDQ IXQJVLRQDO PHODKLUNDQ WHRUL GDVDU \DQJGLJXQDNDQGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQEDKDVD'LGDODPWHRULGDVDUSHP EHODMDUDQ EDKDVD GLQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD EHODMDU EDKDVD SDGD KDNLNDWQ\D PHUXSDNDQIDNWDVRVLDOVHEDJDLVDUDQDXQWXNEHUNRPXQLNDVL5LFKDUGV GDQ5RGJHUV2OHKNDUHQDLWXEHODMDUEDKDVDDGDODKEHODMDU EHUNRPXQLNDVLGDODPEHUEDJDLLQWHUDNVLVRVLDO6\DIL·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

$#$

(11)

.RPXQLNDVLOLVDQPHQFDNXSNHWHUDPSLODQPHQ\LPDNGDQEHUEL FDUDVHGDQJNDQNRPXQLNDVLWHUWXOLVPHQFDNXSNHWHUDPSLODQPHPEDFD GDQPHQXOLV.HWHUDPSLODQPHQXOLVVHEDJDLVDODKVDWXNHWHUDPSLODQ EHUEDKDVDPHUXSDNDQVXDWXNHWHUDPSLODQ\DQJKDUXVGLPLOLNLVLVZD DJDUPDPSXEHUNRPXQLNDVLVHFDUDWHUWXOLV

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

(12)

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

(13)

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¶FRQWRK· WHUVHEXWGLNDWDNDQVHEDJDLPRGHO6LVZDODLQGDSDWPHQJJXQDNDQPRGHO WHUVHEXW VHEDJDL VWDQGDU NRPSHWHQVL \DQJ KDUXV GLFDSDLQ\D0RGHO MXJDGDSDWGLGDWDQJNDQGDULOXDU 6HMDODQGHQJDQKDOLWX5HLJHOXWKMXJDPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZD SHQLQJNDWDQNXDOLWDVSHQGLGLNDQGDSDWGLODNXNDQGHQJDQPHPSHUEDLNL NXDOLWDVSHPEHODMDUDQ3HQLQJNDWDQNXDOLWDVSHPEHODMDUDQGDSDWGLWHP SXKGHQJDQPHQLQJNDWNDQSHQJHWDKXDQWHQWDQJEDJDLPDQDPHUDQFDQJ PRGHOGHQJDQPHWRGHPHWRGHSHPEHODMDUDQ\DQJVHVXDL'HQJDQGH

(14)

PLNLDQPHWRGHWHUVHEXWGLKDUDSNDQGDSDWPHQJKDVLONDQSURGXNPRGHO \DQJOHELKHIHNWLIHILVLHQGDQPHPLOLNLGD\DWDULN

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

(15)

GDQ NHWHUDPSLODQ SDUD JXUX XQWXN PHQWUDQVIHU KDVLO SHPEHODMDUDQ NHSDGDVLVZDQ\D

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

(16)

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

(17)

0RGHO5'GLSHUJXQDNDQXQWXNPHQJHPEDQJNDQPRGHOSHP EHODMDUDQ\DQJVHFDUDRSHUDVLRQDOGLPRGLILNDVLPHQJJXQDNDQSHQGH NDWDQSURVHV%XUQNDUHQDNHGXDQ\DPHPEHULNDQNHVHPSDWDQ PHODNXNDQDQDOLVLVNHEXWXKDQUHIOHNVLGDQUHYLVLSDGDWLDSWDKDSDQ SHPEHODMDUDQVHMDODQGHQJDQSHODNVDQDDQSURVHVPHQXOLVPHODOXLWD KDSWDKDSSHUHQFDQDDQSHODNVDQDDQGDQHYDOXDVL .HQGDODODLQ\DQJGLKDGDSLSDUDJXUXGLODSDQJDQDGDODKDORNDVL ZDNWX\DQJWLGDNPHPDGDLWRSLNSHPEHODMDUDQGDODPNXULNXOXPPDWD SHODMDUDQ EDKDVD,QGRQHVLD SDGD WLDS MHQMDQJ NHODV VDQJDW OXDV GDQ EHUDJDP GDQ WLGDN DGD WXQWXWDQ PDXSXQ GXNXQJDQ GDUL EHUEDJDL NDODQJDQXQWXNPHZXMXGNDQVXDWXVXDVDQDSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHV NULSVL\DQJLGHDO$NLEDWQ\DSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLGLODNVDQD NDQWHUEDWDVSDGDXVDKDXQWXNPHPEDKDVWRSLNWRSLNDWDXNRPSHWHQVL GDVDU SHPEHODMDUDQ \DQJ GLWDUJHWNDQ ROHK NXULNXOXP2OHK NDUHQD LWXPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLSHUOXGLNHPEDQJNDQVHEDJDL NHEXWXKDQLQWHOHNWXDOSHVHUWDGLGLN 6HODLQLWXSHVHUWDGLGLNMXJDPHPSXQ\DLNHEXWXKDQNHEXWXKDQ ODLQ\DQJVLIDWQ\DSHQWLQJ\DNQLSHQJHPEDQJDQSURJUDPLQVWUXNVLRQDO \DQJHIHNWLI6HKXEXQJDQGHQJDQSURJUDPLQVWUXNVLRQDO\DQJHIHNWLI JXUXGLKDUDSNDQGDSDWPHPSXQ\DLZDNWXOHELKEDQ\DNXQWXNPHPEDQ WX SHVHUWD GLGLN GDODP SHUNHPEDQJDQ HPRVLRQDOQ\D$UWLQ\D JXUX DNDQGDSDWPHQFXUDKNDQOHELKEDQ\DNSHUKDWLDQQ\DGDODPPHQGDP SLQJLVLVZDGHQJDQSHUNHPEDQJDQLQGLYLGX\DQJXWXK+DOLWXPXQJNLQ WHUMDGLMLNDJXUXPHPSHUROHKSHQLQJNDWDQSHQJHWDKXDQGDQNHWHUDP SLODQWHQWDQJFDUDPHUDQFDQJSHQJHPEDQJDQLQVWUXNVLRQDO\DQJOHELK HIHNWLIHILVLHQGDQPHQDULNGHQJDQSHQGHNDWDQSHPEHODMDUDQ\DQJ VHVXDL %HUEDJDLSHQGHNDWDQ\DQJGLJXQDNDQJXUXPHODOXLSURJUDPLQ VWUXNVLRQDOVHFDUDWUDGLVLRQDOGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQEDKDVD,QGRQHVLD GDODPPHQJHPEDQJNDQNHPDPSXDQPHQXOLVGLNHODVVHODPDLQLGLQLODL NXDOLWDVQ\D PDVLK UHQGDK5HQGDKQ\D NHWHUDPSLODQ PHQXOLV VLVZD PHQXUXW7RPSNLQVHWDOGLVHEDENDQSHQGHNDWDQ\DQJGLSHUJX QDNDQROHKJXUX\DQJWLGDNPHQJDUDKNDQVLVZDDJDUGDSDWPHQXOLV GHQJDQEDLN

3HQGHNDWDQ GDODP SHPEHODMDUDQ EDKDVD,QGRQHVLD GLSDQGDQJ VHVXDLGHQJDQVHSHUDQJNDWDVXPVLWHQWDQJEDKDVD\DQJVDOLQJEHUNDLW

DQ3HQGHNDWDQ\DQJPHQJDFXSDGDVHSHUDQJNDWDVXPVL\DQJVDOLQJ

EHUNDLWDQGHQJDQVLIDWEDKDVDGDQSHQJDMDUDQQ\DDGDODKSHQGHNDWDQ NRQWHNVWXDO SHQGHNDWDQ NRPXQLNDWLI SHQGHNDWDQ WHUSDGX SHQGH

(18)

NDWDQORNDNDU\DSHQXOLVGDQSHQGHNDWDQSURVHV3HQHUDSDQQ\DGDODP SHPEHODMDUDQ SHQGHNDWDQ GLJXQDNDQ JXUX VHFDUD EHUYDULDVL VHVXDL GHQJDQ NDUDNWHULVWLN PDWHUL \DQJ DNDQ GLVDPSDLNDQ3HQGHNDWDQ SHQGHNDWDQWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLJXQDNDQJXUXVHEDJDLVWUDWHJLXQWXNGLLP SOHPHQWDVLNDQNHGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLXQWXNVLVZD GLVHNRODK

%HUEDJDL SHQGHNDWDQ GDODP SHPEHODMDUDQ PHQXOLV GHVNULSVL WHUVHEXWGDSDWPHPEDQWXVLVZDPHQHPSDWNDQPHUHNDVHEDJDLVXEMHN \DQJDNWLIGDQNUHDWLI3HQJHPEDQJDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLV GHVNULSVL PHQJJXQDNDQ'LFN &DUH\ &DUH\ GDQ5' GHQJDQ SHUWLPEDQJDQPHPEHULNDQNHVHPSDWDQPHODNXNDQDQDOLVLVNHEXWXKDQ UHIOHNVLGDQUHYLVLSDGDWLDSWDKDSDQSHPEHODMDUDQ.DUHQDLWXPRGHO WHUVHEXWGLSLOLKVHEDJDLDFXDQXQWXNPHQJHPEDQJNDQPRGHOSHPEHOD MDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLVLVZD %HUGDVDUNDQSHQJDPDWDQPHODOXLVWXGLSHQGDKXOXDQGLSHUROHK LQIRUPDVLEDKZDEHUEDJDLXSD\DVXGDKGLODNXNDQROHKEHUEDJDLSLKDN GDODPPHQ\LDSNDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLXQWXNPH QLQJNDWNDQ PXWX SHQGLGLNDQ PHODOXL NHPDPSXDQ PHQXOLV GL6' 1DPXQ EHOXP WHUOLKDW XSD\D PDNVLPDO GDODP PHQ\LDSNDQ PRGHO SHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL\DQJPHQJDFXSDGDSURVHVPHQXOLV VHFDUDXWXK%HOXPPDNVLPDOQ\DSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLLWX GLVHEDENDQJXUXEHOXPVHSHQXKQ\DPHPDKDPLSHODNVDQDDQSHPEHOD MDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL\DQJPHQJDFXSDGDSURVHVPHQXOLVVHFDUDXWXK XQWXN PHPEDQWX VLVZD GDODP PHPHFDKNDQ PDVDODK EHODMDU *X UX GDQVLVZDEHOXPWHUELDVDPHQJJXQDNDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLV GHVNULSVL\DQJPHQJDFXSDGDSURVHVPHQXOLVVHFDUDXWXK 2OHKNDUHQDLWXSHUOXGLNHPEDQJNDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPH QXOLVGHVNULSVL\DQJUHSUHVHQWDWLI0RGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHV NULSVLLQLGLNHPEDQJNDQEHUGDVDUNDQSHQGHNDWDQSURVHV3HQGHNDWDQ SURVHVPHUXSDNDQSHQGHNDWDQ\DQJEHUVLIDWWHUSXVDWNHSDGDVLVZD $UWLQ\DVLVZDGLEHULNHVHPSDWDQVHOXDVOXDVQ\DXQWXNPHQJHPEDQJ NDQSHQJHWDKXDQVLNDSGDQNHWHUDPSLODQQ\DGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQ 3HQJHPEDQJDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLLQLGLZXMXGNDQ GDODPEHQWXNSURGXN\DQJPHQFDNXSSHQJHPEDQJDQSURGXNSHUHQ FDQDDQ SHQJHPEDQJDQ SURGXN PDWHUL GDQ SHQJHPEDQJDQ SURGXN HYDOXDVL

(19)

% ,'(17,),.$6, 3(50$6$/$+$1

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

'DODPUDQJNDLWXODKNXULNXOXPKDGLUVHEDJDLDOWHUQDWLI NXULNXOXP \DQJ PHQDZDUNDQ NRQVHS RWRQRPL SDGD VHNRODK6DODK VDWXNRQVHSRWRQRPLVHNRODKWHUVHEXWDGDODKPHQHQWXNDQNHELMDNDQ VHNRODKGDODPUDQJNDPHQLQJNDWNDQPXWXGDQHILVLHQVLSHQGLGLNDQ DJDU GDSDW PHQJDNRPRGDVL NHLQJLQDQ PDV\DUDNDW VHWHPSDW VHUWD PHQMDOLQNHUMDVDPDDQWDUDVHNRODKPDV\DUDNDWLQGXVWULGDQSHPH ULQWDKNDEXSDWHQGDQNRWDGDODPPHPEHQWXNSULEDGLVLVZD.XULNXOXP VHEDJDLWLQGDNODQMXWNHELMDNDQSHQGLGLNDQGDODPNRQWHNVRWR QRPL GDHUDK GDQ GHVHQWUDOLVDVL.XULNXOXP PHUXSDNDQ NXUL NXOXPRSHUDVLRQDO\DQJSHQJHPEDQJDQQ\DGLVHUDKNDQNHSDGDGDHUDK GDQVDWXDQSHQGLGLNDQ+DOLQLGLODNXNDQDJDUMXUDQJSHPLVDKDQWDUD SHQGLGLNDQ GDQ SHPEDQJXQDQ VHUWD NHEXWXKDQ GXQLD NHUMD GDSDW VHJHUD WHUDWDVL

(20)

.HEXWXKDQ \DQJ PHQGHVDN GDODP XSD\D PHQLQJNDWNDQ PXWX SHQGLGLNDQVDDWLQLSHUOXGLODNXNDQSHUEDLNDQNXDOLWDVSHPEHODMDUDQ 3HQLQJNDWDQNXDOLWDVSHPEHODMDUDQGDSDWGLWHPSXKGHQJDQPHQLQJNDW NDQSHQJHWDKXDQWHQWDQJEDJDLPDQDPHUDQFDQJPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQ 0HQJLQJDWNRQGLVLSHPEHODMDUDQGLVHNRODKEHOXPWHUOLKDWDGDQ\DXSD \DPDNVLPDOGDODPPHQ\LDSNDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL \DQJ PHQJDFX SDGD SURVHV PHQXOLV VHFDUD XWXK.HWLGDNWHUVHGLDDQ PRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLLQLDNDQEHUODQMXWSHQJDUXKQ\D SDGDNHVXOLWDQSHQFDSDLDQWXMXDQSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLV\DQJGLKDUDS NDQ2OHKNDUHQDLWXGLXVDKDNDQPHPEDQWXPHQFDULDOWHUQDWLISHPH FDKDQPDVDODKGLODSDQJDQGHQJDQPHPHQXKLNHEXWXKDQ\DQJGLSDQ GDQJPHQGHVDN6DODKVDWXDOWHUQDWLISHPHFDKDQPDVDODKLWXDGDODK SHUOXGLUDQFDQJVXDWXPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLXQWXN VLVZD\DQJPHQFDNXSEDJDLPDQDPHQ\XVXQSHUHQFDQDDQPDWHULGDQ HYDOXDVLQ\DVHUWDSHQHUDSDQ\DQJPHQJDFXSDGDPHQXOLVSURVHVVHFDUD XWXKHIHNWLIHILVLHQGDQPHPLOLNLGD\DWDULN 'LSLOLKQ\DSHQJHPEDQJDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL VHEDJDLDOWHUQDWLISHPHFDKDQPDVDODKGLVHEDENDQSHUDQDQPRGHOSHP EHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLSHQWLQJGDODPSHQFDSDLDQWXMXDQSHPEHOD MDUDQ PHQXOLV'HQJDQ GHPLNLDQ PDVDODK NHWLGDNWHUVHGLDDQ PRGHO SHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL\DQJPXQFXOGDSDWWHUDWDVL

3HQJHPEDQJDQ3URGXN3HUHQFDQDDQ3HPEHODMDUDQ0HQXOLV 'HVNULSVL 3URGXNSHUHQFDQDDQVHEDJDLDFXDQJXUXGDQVLVZDGDODPPHOD NXNDQEHUEDJDLDNWLYLWDVSHPEHODMDUDQ3URGXNSHUHQFDQDDQSHPEHOD MDUDQPHPXDWVHMXPODKNDWHJRULSURGXN\DQJVDOLQJWHUNDLW3URGXN SHUHQFDQDDQ\DQJGLNHPEDQJNDQPHQFDNXSSURGXNVLODEXVGDQSURGXN UHQFDQDSHODNVDQDDQSHPEHODMDUDQ533VHFDUDNRQVHSWXDO\DQJGL MHODVNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW

D 3URGXN6LODEXV3HPEHODMDUDQ

3URGXNVLODEXVPHPXDWSHQMDEDUDQOHELKODQMXWGDULXUDLDQPDWH ULNXULNXOXP\DQJEHULVLVHFDUDJDULVEHVDUODQJNDKODQJNDKSHPEHOD MDUDQ\DQJSHUOXGLSHODMDULVLVZDXQWXNPHQFDSDLVWDQGDUNRPSHWHQVL GDQNHPDPSXDQGDVDU.RPSRQHQGDODPSHQJHPEDQJDQVLODEXVSHP EHODMDUDQPHQFDNXSPHQJLVLNRORPLGHQWLWDVPHQJNDMLGDQPHQJDQD

(21)

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

3HQLODLDQ SHQFDSDLDQ NRPSHWHQVL GDVDU VLVZD GLODNXNDQ EHU GDVDUNDQLQGLNDWRU\DQJWHODKGLUXPXVNDQGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQGDWD GDQLQIRUPDVLSDGDHYDOXDVLSURVHV\DQJGLKLPSXQPHODOXLXQMXNNHUMD SHUIRUPDQFHPHQJJXQDNDQSDQGXDQREVHUYDVL'DWDGDQLQIRUPDVL SDGDHYDOXDVLKDVLOPHODOXLSRUWRIROLRPHQJJXQDNDQUXEULNSHQLODLDQ

(22)

8QMXNNHUMDGDQSRUWRIROLRGLKDVLONDQEHUGDVDUNDQWXJDV\DQJKDUXV GLNHUMDNDQVLVZDXQWXNPHPSHUROHKSHQJDODPDQEHODMDU

E 3URGXN5HQFDQD3HODNVDQDDQ3HPEHODMDUDQ

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

E 3URGXN'HVNULSVL0RGHO3URVHV3HPEHODMDUDQ

3URGXNGHVNULSVLPRGHOSURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQEHUXSDSRODLQWHU DNVLEHODMDUPHQJDMDU3URGXNGHVNULSVLPRGHOSURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQ

(23)

SHQHUDSDQQ\DGLZXMXGNDQGDODPEHQWXNSHWXQMXNSHODNVDQDDQROHK JXUXXQWXNPHQ\DPSDLNDQEDKDQDMDUGDODPSURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQPH QXOLV GHVNULSVL XQWXN VLVZD3URVHV SHPEHODMDUDQ GLVXVXQ EHUGDVDU SDGD SHQGHNDWDQ SURVHV PHQXOLV PHODOXL WDKDS SUDPHQXOLV SHQJH GUDIDQSHUHYLVLDQSHQ\XQWLQJDQGDQSDVFDPHQXOLV'HVNULSVLPRGHO SURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQ\DQJWHODKGLVXVXQVNHQDULRQ\DGLOHQJNDSLSHODN VDQDDQQ\DGDODPEHQWXNYLVXDOLVDVL

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

& 0$1)$$7 3(1*(0%$1*$1 02'(/ 3(0%(/$-$5$1 3HQJHPEDQJDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQVDQJDWEHUPDQIDDWNDUHQD GLKDUDSNDQGDULKDVLOQ\DGDSDWGLSHUROHKVDWXSURGXNPRGHOSHPEH

(24)

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

0RGHO SHPEHODMDUDQ PHQXOLV GHVNULSVL GDSDW GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQJRUJDQLVDVLNDQSHQJDODPDQEHODMDUGDQSHPEHODMDUDQWHUWHQWX $JDUPRGHOGDSDWGLJXQDNDQXQWXNPHZDNLOLUHDOLWDVSHPEHODMDUDQ VHVXQJJXKQ\D GLSHUOXNDQ PRGHO SHPEHODMDUDQ \DQJ EHUIXQJVL PHQMHODVNDQPDNQDNHJLDWDQSURVHVPHQXOLV

3URVHVPHQXOLVGDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQLQWHUDNVLEHODMDUVHFDUDDNWLI PHQLQJNDWNDQLQWHUDNVLNHODVVHFDUDNRODERUDWLIGDQPHQLQJNDW NDQNHPDPSXDQVLVZDGDODPPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL$JDUSHPEHODMDUDQ PHQXOLV GHVNULSVL PHQLQJNDW GDQ EHUIXQJVL VHFDUD PDNVLPDO GLSHUOXNDQWDKDSWDKDSSHPEHODMDUDQWHUWHQWXVHVXDLGHQJDQWD KDSDQSURVHVPHQXOLV

(25)

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

(26)

3

DGDEDJLDQLQLDNDQGLXUDLNDQEHEHUDSDKDO\DQJVLIDWQ\DWHRUHWLV EHUNDLWDQHUDWGHQJDQSHQJHPEDQJDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQX OLVGHVNULSVL+DOKDOWHUVHEXWPHOLSXWLKDNLNDWWXOLVDQGHV NULSVLSHQGHNDWDQSHPEHODMDUDQEDKDVD,QGRQHVLDGLVHNRODK KXEXQJDQ WXOLVDQ GHVNULSVL GHQJDQ WXOLVDQ ODLQ PDFDPPDFDP WXOLVDQGHVNULSVLVWUDWHJLSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVLEHUGDVDU NDQSHQGHNDWDQSURVHVGDQPRGHOSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL $ +$.,.$778/,6$1'(6.5,36,

3DGDKDNLNDWQ\DWXOLVDQGHVNULSVLPHUXSDNDQXVDKDXQWXNPHQJ JDPEDUNDQ GHQJDQ NDWDNDWD ZXMXG DWDX VLIDW ODKLULDK VXDWX REMHN 0HODOXLGHVNULSVLVHRUDQJSHQXOLVEHUXVDKDPHPLQGDKNDQNHVDQKDVLO SHQJDPDWDQGDQSHUDVDDQNHSDGDSHPEDFDGHQJDQPHPEHEHUNDQVLIDW GDQULQFLDQ\DQJDGDSDGDVHEXDKREMHN3HQJDPDWDQWHUKDGDSREMHN \DQJVDPDGHQJDQPRWLYDVLEHUEHGDDNDQPHQJKDVLONDQGHVNULSVL\DQJ EHUEHGDSXOD+DOLWXEDQ\DNNLWDMXPSDLSDGDWXOLVDQGHVNULSVLVDODK VDWXQ\D\DQJGLWXOLV0DUN7ZDLQGDODPQRYHOQ\D/LIHRQWKH0LVVLV

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

$#$

(27)

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

(28)

SHQXOLVPHQDPSLONDQNHXQLNDQDWDXSHQDPSDNDQNDUDNWHULVWLNGHWDLO VXDWXREMHN

6XSDUQRHWDOPHPEHULNDQSHQJHUWLDQWHQWDQJGHV NULSVL\DQJEHUDVDOGDULEDKDVD/DWLQGHVFULEHUH\DQJEHUDUWL´PHQJJDP EDUNDQDWDXPHPHULNDQVHVXDWXKDOµ'DULVHJLLVWLODKGHVNULSVLDGDODK EHQWXNNDUDQJDQ\DQJPHOXNLVNDQVHVXDWXVHVXDLNHDGDDQVHEHQDUQ\D VHKLQJJD SHPEDFD GDSDW PHQFLWUDL PHOLKDW PHQGHQJDU PHQFLXP GDQPHUDVDNDQDSD\DQJGLOXNLVNDQLWXVHVXDLGHQJDQFLWUDSHQXOLVQ\D

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·LHHWDO PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD ZDFDQD GHVNULSVL GLEHGDNDQ PHQMDGL GHVNULSVL IDNWDZLGDQGHVNULSVLNKD\DOL:DFDQDGHVNULSVLIDNWDZLEHUXVDKDPH PHULNDQGHWDLOVHSHUWLEDQJXQXNXUDQVXVXQDQZDUQDEDKDQVHVXDWX PHQXUXW NHQ\DWDDQ XQWXN PHPEHUL LQIRUPDVL :DFDQD GHVNULSVL NKD\DOL EHUXVDKD PHPHULNDQ FLULFLUL ILVLN FDUDFDUD EHUODNX VLNDS VHVHRUDQJGDQNHDGDDQVXDWXWHPSDWPHQXUXWNKD\DODQSHQXOLVQ\D

'HQJDQGHPLNLDQWXOLVDQGHVNULSVLGLDUWLNDQXQWXNPHPHULNDQDWDX PHQJJDPEDUNDQVXDWXREMHNEHUGDVDUNDQIDNWXDOGDQNKD\DODQ

8QVXU8QVXU0HQXOLV'HVNULSVL

8QVXUXQVXU WXOLVDQ GHVNULSVL PHOLSXWL SHQGHNDWDQ PHWRGH SLOLKDQNDWDGDQNLDVDQ8QVXUXQVXUWXOLVDQGHVNULSVLGLJXQDNDQDJDU

(29)

ELVDPHQLPEXONDQNHVDQ\DQJVHJDUGDQKLGXS6HODLQLWXXQVXUXQVXU GHVNULSVLGDSDWPHQLPEXONDQLPDMLQDVLGDQPHQFLSWDNDQNHVDQ\DQJ PHQGDODP+DOLWXEDUXGDSDWGLFDSDLDSDELODSHQXOLVGHVNULSVLPH PLOLNLNHPDPSXDQXQWXNPHPDGXNDQXQVXUXQVXUSHQGHNDWDQPHWR GHSLOLKDQNDWDGLNVLGDQNLDVDQ

3HQGHNDWDQ WXOLVDQ GHVNULSVL EHUWRODN GDUL SDQGDQJDQ EDKZD WXOLVDQGHVNULSVLVHEDJDLVXEMHNGDQREMHNGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQ6HED JDLVXEMHNWXOLVDQGHVNULSVLGDSDWGLJXQDNDQGDODPNHJLDWDQSHPEHOD MDUDQPHQXOLV6HEDJDLREMHNWXOLVDQGHVNULSVLGLJXQDNDQXQWXNEDKDQ SHPEHODMDUDQ\DQJGLVHVXDLNDQGHQJDQVSHVLILNDVLSHQGHNDWDQGDODP PHQXOLV GHVNULSVL6XSDUQRHWDO PHQJHPXNDNDQ VHFDUD VSHVLILNEDKZDSHQGHNDWDQGDSDWGLJXQDNDQGDODPPHQXOLVGHVNULSVL

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

(30)

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

(31)

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

(32)

DNWLYLWDVPDQXVLDSDGDZDNWXZDNWXWHUVHEXW6LNDSSHQJDUDQJEHU NDLWDQGHQJDQDVSHNZDWDNSHQJDUDQJGDQKXEXQJDQDQWDUDREMHNGDQ SHQXOLVQ\DGDSDWGLUXPXVNDQGHQJDQNDWDODLQEHUXSDPDVDODKVLNDS \DQJ GLDPELO WHUKDGDS REMHNQ\D0HODOXL VLNDS LQL GDSDW GLNHWDKXL NHDGDDQSLNLUDQSHQJDUDQJGDSDWGLNHWDKXLVLIDWGDQVXDVDQD\DQJ NLUDQ\DPHQJXDVDLSHQJDUDQJSDGDZDNWXPHQJDGDNDQGHVNULSVLLWX

&DUDPHQGHVNULSVLNDQREMHNRUDQJDGDODKFDUD\DQJVHULQJGL SHUJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHPEXDW GHVNULSVL \DQJ DNXUDW WHQWDQJ ZDWDN VHVHRUDQJVHODLQPHPSHUJXQDNDQDVSHNDVSHNILVLNMXJDPHPSHUJXQD NDQ WDIVLUDQ ZDWDN DWDX NDUDNWHU VHVHRUDQJ PHODOXL GHVNULSVL SHU EXDWDQGHVNULSVLILVLNVXDVDQDULLOGLDORJUHDNVLWRNRKWRNRKGDQ SHQGHNDWDQSVLNRORJLVGLXUDLNDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW

&DUDXQWXNPHPEXDWGHVNULSVLZDWDNDGDODKPHQJJDPEDUNDQ ZDWDN PHODOXL GHVNULSVL SHUEXDWDQ &DUD LWX PHUXSDNDQ MDODQ DWDX FDUD\DQJSDOLQJHIHNWLIXQWXNPHQDPSLONDQSXODVLWXDVLVLWXDVL\DQJ DGDVDQJNXWSDXWQ\DGHQJDQXQVXUXQVXUNDUDNWHUGDULVHRUDQJWRNRK

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

(33)

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

3LOLKDQ NDWD \DQJ EDLN GDSDW GLDUWLNDQ VHEDJDL ¶PHPLOLK· GDQ ¶PHQ\HOHNVL·NDWDNDWD\DQJWHSDW.DUHQDVHWLDSSHQJXQJNDSDQ\DQJ EDLN\DQJGDSDWPHQLPEXONDQHIHNWHUWHQWXKDUXVPHQJJXQDNDQSXOD NDWDNDWD\DQJWHSDW\DQJWLGDNVDMDDNDQPHQJJDPEDUNDQREMHNLWX VHPLULSPXQJNLQWHWDSLGDSDWMXJDPHODKLUNDQVHWHSDWWHSDWDSD\DQJ GLPDNVXGNDQ

(34)

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

3HQJLQVDQDQDWDXSHUVRQLILNDVLGDODPKXEXQJDQLQLKDUXVGLEHGD NDQGDULSHUVRQLILNDVL\DQJGLFLSWDNDQVHEDJDLVHEXDKEHQWXNQDUDVL DWDXSHQJLVDKDQVHSHUWLKDOQ\DGHQJDQGRQJHQJGRQJHQJOHJHQGD

(35)

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

.RQVWUXNWLYLVPH PHUXSDNDQ ODQGDVDQ EHUSLNLU ILORVRIL SHQ GHNDWDQ&7/\DLWXEDKZDSHQJHWDKXDQGLEDQJXQROHKPDQXVLDVHGLNLW GHPLVHGLNLW\DQJKDVLOQ\DGLSHUOXDVPHODOXLNRQWHNV\DQJWHUEDWDV GDQWLGDNVHUWDPHUWD3HQJHWDKXDQEXNDQODKVHSHUDQJNDWIDNWDIDNWD NRQVHSDWDXNDLGDK\DQJVLDSXQWXNGLDPELOGDQGLLQJDW0DQXVLD

(36)

KDUXV PDPSX PHQJRQVWUXNVL SHQJHWDKXDQ LWX GDQ PHPEHUL PDNQD PHODOXLSHQJDODPDQQ\DWD(VHQVLGDULWHRULNRQVWUXNWLYLVDGDODKLGH EDKZDVLVZDKDUXVGDSDWPHQHPXNDQGDQPHQWUDQVIRUPDVLNDQVXDWX LQIRUPDVLNRPSOHNVNHVLWXDVLODLQGDQDSDELODGLNHKHQGDNLLQIRUPDVL LWX PHQMDGL PLOLN PHUHND'HQJDQ GDVDU LWX SHPEHODMDUDQ KDUXV GLNHPDVPHQMDGLSURVHVPHQJRQVWUXNVLEXNDQPHQHULPDSHQJHWDKXDQ 'DODPSURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQVLVZDPHPEDQJXQSHQJHWDKXDQPHUHND PHODOXLNHWHUOLEDWDQDNWLIGDODPSURVHVEHODMDUGDQPHQJDMDU6LVZD PHQMDGLSXVDWNHJLDWDQEXNDQJXUX

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

(37)

6HWLDSSLKDNKDUXVPHUDVDEDKZDVHWLDSRUDQJPHPLOLNLSHQJHWD KXDQSHQJDODPDQDWDXNHWHUDPSLODQ\DQJEHUEHGD\DQJSHUOXGLSH ODMDUL.DODXVHWLDSRUDQJPDXEHODMDUGDULRUDQJODLQVHWLDSRUDQJ ODLQ ELVD PHQMDGL VXPEHU EHODMDU GDQ LQL EHUDUWL VHWLDS RUDQJ DNDQ VDQJDWND\DGHQJDQSHQJHWDKXDQGDQSHQJDODPDQ

'DODP VHEXDK SHPEHODMDUDQ NHWHUDPSLODQ DWDX SHQJHWDKXDQ WHUWHQWXDGDPRGHO\DQJGLWLUX0RGHOLWXELVDEHUXSDFDUDPHQJRSH UDVLNDQVHVXDWXDWDXJXUXPHPEHULFRQWRKFDUDPHQJHUMDNDQVHVXDWX 'HQJDQEHJLWXJXUXPHPEHULPRGHOWHQWDQJEDJDLPDQDFDUDEHODMDU 'DODPSHQGHNDWDQ&7/JXUXEXNDQVDWXVDWXQ\DPRGHO0RGHOGDSDW GLUDQFDQJGHQJDQPHOLEDWNDQVLVZD6HRUDQJVLVZDELVDGLWXQMXNXQWXN PHPEHUL FRQWRK6LVZD ¶FRQWRK·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

(38)

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·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

3HQGHNDWDQNRPXQLNDWLIDGDVHEDJDLUHDNVLWHUKDGDSSHPEHODMDU DQ \DQJ WHUODOX PHQHNDQNDQ VWUXNWXU VHKLQJJD PHQJDEDLNDQ IXQJVL EDKDVDVHEDJDLDODWNRPXQLNDVL5LFKDUGVHWDO6\DIL·LH PHQ\DWDNDQEDKZDWXMXDQSHQJDMDUDQEDKDVDEHUXSD\DPHQJHPEDQJ NDQNRPXQLNDVLVLVZD'HQJDQGHPLNLDQSHUKDWLDQJXUXKDUXVOHELK GLSXVDWNDQ NHSDGD SHQJJXQDDQ EDKDVD XQWXN PDNVXG NRPXQLNDWLI 6LVZDGLELPELQJXQWXNGDSDWPHQJJXQDNDQEDKDVDEXNDQVHNDGDUPH QJHWDKXLWHQWDQJEDKDVD3HQJDMDUDQEDKDVDGHQJDQSHQGHNDWDQNRPX QLNDWLIGLDUDKNDQXQWXNPHPEHQWXNNRPSHWHQVLNRPXQLNDWLIVHFDUD XWXKEXNDQVHPDWDPDWDPHPEHQWXNNRPSHWHQVLNHEDKDVDDQ

(39)

'LGDODPNRPSHWHQVLNRPXQLNDWLIWHUGDSDWEHEHUDSDXQVXU\DQJ SHUOXGLPLOLNLSHPDNDLEDKDVD8QVXUXQVXUWHUVHEXWPHQXUXW6ZDLQ GDODP6\DIL·LH VHEDJDL EHULNXW SHQJHWDKXDQ GDQ VLVWHP NDLGDKJUDPDWLNDO\DQJPHOLSXWLHMDDQIRQRORJLPRUIRORJLVLQWDNVLV GDQSHQJXDVDDQNRVDNDWDSHQJXDVDDQVHJLVHJLVRVLROLQJXLVWLNEHUX SDPHPDKDPLNHVHVXDLDQSHQJJXQDDQEHUEDJDLNRVDNDWDGDQNDLGDK JUDPDWLNDOXQWXNGLJXQDNDQGDODPEHUEDJDLIXQJVLNRPXQLNDVLVHSHUWL SHUVXDVLQDUDVLHNVSRVLVLDUJXPHQWDVLGHVNULSVLPHPEHULSHULQWDK GDQVHEDJDLQ\D3HQJXDVDDQVHJLVRVLROLQJXLVWLNMXJDEHUXSDNHPDP SXDQPHPLOLKUDJDPEDKDVD\DQJWHSDWGDODPEHUNRPXQLNDVLGHQJDQ PHPHUKDWLNDQWRSLNKXEXQJDQDQWDUSHUDQNRPXQLNDVLVXDVDQDVHUWD ODQFDUNRPXQLNDVLSHQJXDVDDQNHZDFDQDDQEHUXSDNHPDPSXDQ PHQ\XVXQJDJDVDQJDJDVDQGDODPEHQWXNWXUXQDQ\DQJNRKHVLIGDQ NRKHUHQGDQSHQJXDVDDQVWUDWHJLNRPXQLNDVLEHUXSDNHPDPSXDQ PHQJJXQDNDQVWUDWHJLQRQYHUEDOXQWXNPHQJDWDVLEHUEDJDLNHVHQMDQJ DQ\DQJWHUMDGLGLDQWDUDSHPELFDUDDWDXSHQXOLVGHQJDQSHQGHQJDU DWDXSHPEDFD.HVHQMDQJDQLWXPHPXQJNLQNDQGLVHEDENDQROHKSH QJXDVDDQEDKDVD\DQJNXUDQJNXUDQJQ\DSHQJXDVDDQNRQVHSNRQVHS PDWHUL\DQJGLVDPSDLNDQKXEXQJDQ\DQJNXUDQJDQWDUDSHPELFDUD DWDXSHQXOLVGHQJDQSHQGHQJDUDWDXSHPEDFD 3HQJDMDUDQEDKDVDPHQJDUDKNHSDGDSHQXPEXKDQNHWHUDPSLODQ PHQJJXQDNDQEDKDVDVHEDJDLDODWEHUNRPXQLNDVLEXNDQVHPDWDPDWD NHDUDKSHQXPEXKDQSHQJHWDKXDQWHQWDQJEDKDVD2ULHQWDVLEHODMDU PHQJDMDUEDKDVDEHUGDVDUNDQWXJDVGDQIXQJVLEHUNRPXQLNDVLGLVHEXW SHQGHNDWDQNRPXQLNDWLI 3HQGHNDWDQ/RNDNDU\D3HQXOLV &DONLQVGDODP7RPSNLQVPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZDORND NDU\DSHQXOLVDGDODKFDUDEDUXGDODPPHQJLPSOHPHQWDVLNDQPHQXOLV SURVHV.RQVHSGDVDUORNDNDU\DSHQXOLVGLODQGDVLROHKDOLUDQNRQVWUXN WLYLV\DQJGLSHORSRULROHK3LDJHW6XSDUQRPHQ\DWDNDQEDK ZDJXUXPHQXUXWSULQVLSNRQVWUXNWLYLVDGDODKVHRUDQJSHQJDMDUGDQ VHNDOLJXVEHUSHUDQVHEDJDLPHGLDWRUGDQIDVLOLWDWRU3ULQVLSLWXODK\DQJ GLWHUDSNDQGDODPORNDNDU\DSHQXOLV'DODPSURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQORND NDU\DSHQXOLVPHPEHULNDQSHQHNDQDQNHSDGDVLVZD*XUXKDQ\DEHU IXQJVLVHEDJDLIDVLOLWDWRUPHGLDWRUGDQPRWLYDWRU7XJDVJXUXPHP EDQWXVLVZDDJDUSURVHVSHPEHODMDUDQGDSDWEHUMDODQVHVXDLGHQJDQ WXMXDQ\DQJGLKDUDSNDQ

(40)

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

$GDEHEHUDSDWDKDSGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQPHQXOLVPDQGLUL\DNQL SUDPHQXOLV SHQ\XVXQDQ GUDI UHYLVL SHQ\XQWLQJDQ GDQ SXEOLNDVL 'DODPWDKDSSUDPHQXOLVVLVZDPHODNXNDQNHJLDWDQVHEDJDLEHULNXW PHPLOLKWRSLNPHQJHPEDQJNDQWRSLNPHQJLGHQWLILNDVLSHP EDFD\DQJPHQMDGLVDVDUDQQ\DPHQJLGHQWLILNDVLWXMXDQPHQXOLV PHQHQWXNDQMXGXOGDQPHQ\XVXQNHUDQJNDNDUDQJDQ

'DODP WDKDS SHQ\XVXQDQ GUDI VLVZD PHODNXNDQ NHJLDWDQ PHQXOLVGUDINDVDUPHQJHPEDQJNDQWXOLVDQGDQWXOLVDQPHQH NDQNDQSDGDLVLGDULSDGDPHNDQLN'DODPWDKDSUHYLVLVLVZDPHODNX NDQNHJLDWDQPHPEDJLNDQWXOLVDQGDODPNHORPSRNPHQGLVNXVL NDQWHQWDQJWXOLVDQWHPDQQ\DPHPEXDWSHUXEDKDQWXOLVDQVHVXDL GHQJDQKDVLOUHIOHNVLGDULWHPDQWHPDQGDQPHQ\XVXQGUDIDNKLU WXOLVDQ

(41)

'DODPWDKDSSHQ\XQWLQJDQVLVZDPHODNXNDQNHJLDWDQPH QJRUHNVLKDVLOWXOLVDQPDVLQJPDVLQJPHPEDQWXPHQJRUHNVLWHPDQ VHNHODVDWDXNHORPSRNGDQPHQLQJNDWNDQLQWHQVLWDVGDQNRUHNVL NHVDODKDQPHNDQLNWXOLVDQPLOLNQ\D'DODPWDKDSSXEOLNDVLVLVZDPH ODNXNDQNHJLDWDQPHPEDFDWXOLVDQGLGHSDQNHODVGHQJDQVXDUD GDQLQWRQDVL\DQJWHSDWVHUWDPHPDMDQNDQWXOLVDQSDGDPDMDODK GLQGLQJDWDXUXDQJDQ\DQJWHODKGLWHQWXNDQ

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

(42)

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

' 0$&$00$&$0 %(178.78/,6$1 '(6.5,36,

%HUGDVDUNDQ EHQWXN WXOLVDQ FDUD SHQXOLV PHQJXQJNDS REMHN NDUDQJDQGHVNULSVLGLEHGDNDQPHQMDGLGHVNULSVLNDWHJRUL\DQJOD]LP GDQEHUGDVDUNDQXUXWDQULQFLDQ

7XOLVDQ'HVNULSVL%HUGDVDUNDQ.DWHJRUL\DQJ/D]LP

0HQXUXW.HUDI$NKDGLDKHWDO6XSDUQRHWDO

EDKZDDGDGXDREMHN\DQJGLXQJNDSNDQGDODPGHVNULSVL\DNQL WHPSDWGDQRUDQJ'HVNULSVLWHPSDWPHPHJDQJSHUDQDQSHQWLQJGDODP VHWLDSSHULVWLZDGDQVHWLDSSHULVWLZDWLGDNGDSDWGLOHSDVNDQGDULOLQJ NXQJDQGDQLNDWDQWHPSDW6HPXDSHULVWLZDWHQWXWHUMDGLSDGDVXDWX WHPSDW7HPSDWPHUXSDNDQJHODQJJDQJEHUODQJVXQJQ\DSHULVWLZDSH ULVWLZD6HPXDNLVDKDNDQVHODOXPHPSXQ\DLODWDUEHODNDQJWHPSDW -DODQQ\DVHEXDKSHULVWLZDDNDQOHELKPHQDULNNDODXGLNDLWNDQGHQJDQ WHPSDWWHUMDGLQ\DSHULVWLZDWHUVHEXW

(43)

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·EDKDNDQPHUDVDNHFLOVHNDOLDWDVNHEHVDUDQ7XKDQGL VDPSLQJWLPEXOUDVDNDJXPGDQEDQJJD3HQXOLVGHVNULSVLKDUXV PDPSX PHPLOLK GHWDLOGHWDLO \DQJ UHOHYDQ XQWXN PHQJJDPEDUNDQ VXDVDQDKDWL3HQJDUDQJGLWXQWXWSXODXQWXNPDPSXPHQHWDSNDQ XUXWDQSDOLQJEDLNGDODPPHQDPSLONDQGHWDLOGHWDLO\DQJGLSLOLKQ\D

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

7XOLVDQ GHVNULSVL EHUWXMXDQ PHQJJDPEDUNDQ VHVXDWX GHQJDQ MHODVGDQWHUSHULQFL0DQDULQFLDQ\DQJSHUOXGLGDKXOXNDQGDQPDQD \DQJEHULNXWQ\D0HQXUXW.HUDIEDKZDSHQXOLVGHVNULSVLGLWXQ WXWPDPSXPHQHWDSNDQXUXWDQ\DQJSDOLQJEDLNGDODPPHQDPSLONDQ GHWDLOGHWDLO\DQJGLSLOLK6XSDUQRHWDOPHPEHULNDQULQ

(44)

FLDQODQJNDKODQJNDKGDODPPHQXOLVNDUDQJDQGHVNULSVLVHEDJDLEHUL NXW0HQHQWXNDQDSD\DQJDNDQGLGHVNULSVLNDQRUDQJDWDXWHPSDW

0HUXPXVNDQWXMXDQSHQGHVNULSVLDQGHVNULSVLGLODNXNDQVHEDJDL DODWEDQWXNDUDQJDQQDUDVLHNVSRVLVLDUJXPHQWDVLDWDXSHUVXDVL

0HQHWDSNDQEDJLDQ\DQJDNDQGLGHVNULSVLNDQGHVNULSVLRUDQJEHUDUWL \DQJ GLGHVNULSVLNDQ DGDODK FLULFLUL ILVLN ZDWDN GDQ JDJDVDQQ\D 'HVNULSVL WHPSDW EHUDUWL \DQJ GLGHVNULSVLNDQ DGDODK NHVHOXUXKDQ WHPSDW DWDX KDQ\D EDJLDQEDJLDQ WHUWHQWX VDMD 0HPHULQFL DWDX PHQ\LVWHPDWLVNDQKDOKDO\DQJPHQXQMDQJEDJLDQ\DQJDNDQGLGHV NULSVLNDQ 8QWXNPHQGHVNULSVLNDQRUDQJKHQGDNQ\DVHRUDQJSHQXOLVKDUXV PHQJHQDOLNHNRPSDNDQPDQXVLD\DQJWLGDNKDQ\DGLGXNXQJROHKVWUXN WXUDQDWRPLGDQPRUIRORJLWXEXKWHWDSLMXJDPHPLOLNLMLZDDNDOGDQ EXGLDNDQPHQ\XOLWNDQVHVHRUDQJPHODKLUNDQGHVNULSVL\DQJPHPXDV NDQ6HVHRUDQJ \DQJ VXQJJXKVXQJJXK PHPEXDW GHVNULSVL WHQWDQJ VHRUDQJWRNRKKDUXVPHQJHWDKXLFLULXWDPDNHSULEDGLDQVDQJWRNRK 0LVDOQ\DPHQJHQDLWLQJNDKODNXEHQWXNWXEXKZDWDNSHQDPSLODQ GDQVHEDJDLQ\D6HRUDQJ\DQJEHUWDPSDQJJDJDKEHUSDUDVPHQDULN EHOXPWHQWXPHPLOLNLZDWDNGDQPRUDO\DQJEDLN6HEDOLNQ\DVHRUDQJ \DQJEHUZDMDKVHUDPEHUWLQJNDKODNXNDVDUPXQJNLQPHPLOLNLKDWL \DQJEDLN'HQJDQGHPLNLDQGHVNULSVLWHQWDQJEHQWXNOXDU\DQJGDSDW GLOLKDWGDQGLDPDWLPLVDOQ\DEHQWXNODKLULDKWXEXKFDUDEHUSDNDLDQ GDQODLQODLQGLKDUDSNDQDNDQPHODKLUNDQGHVNULSVL\DQJREMHNWLI $GDEHEHUDSDFDUDGDODPPHQJJDPEDUNDQDWDXPHQGHVNULSVL NDQVHRUDQJWRNRKVHEDJDLEHULNXW3HQJJDPEDUDQILVLN\DQJEHU WXMXDQ PHPEHULNDQ JDPEDUDQ \DQJ VHMHODVMHODVQ\D NHDGDDQ WXEXK VHRUDQJWRNRK'HVNULSVLLQLEDQ\DNEHUVLIDWREMHNWLI3HQJJDPEDUDQ WLQGDNWDQGXN VHRUDQJ WRNRK'DODP KDO LQL SHQJDUDQJ PHQJLNXWL GHQJDQ FHUPDW VHPXD WLQGDNWDQGXN SHUEXDWDQ JHUDNJHULN VDQJ WRNRKGDULVXDWXWHPSDWNHWHPSDWODLQGDQGDULZDNWXNHZDNWXODLQ

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