laporan penelitian dosen muda

(1)

!

"

(2)

! " #

$ %" " &'( ) ! "

" "*" +)"% " "& # , &", !-'. .

/ , "* # ") 0 ")

1 # 2$ 2 3 456

" +)"!7 ' & " +7 # "!" " 7 " 7 2$ 2 3 456 "/"!" )"&" + # , ,! 8

9 :") !", 7 & ," # * )" 7 )" "& )' "8

2 * "8 * ! # $ " '&" +

; ')", ! " # &'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!"

6 " +)" <")! # 4 / "

= "-" -" + % & )" # % > 533 333.33

'+-")"&!". $$ , */ & $334

+ !"8 . ! " ! .

)" :") !", * )"

& 18*" "& & , &", !-'. .

23 >2= 4 2$ 2 3 456

- ! ( . ! " */"+" ! " ? &, !", + & '+-")"&!"

(3)

$%&'()(% (%

*++(,-( " % ! " " " "8 ! ) * ") )" ?" ", ! +)"! )'*% ! , % + ' " ,"! + "!" "("& . , 8 ++" +" "%"! ) !"8 ! +)"! ) *"*% " % + ' " -" + " " ,""! " "%"! ) !"8 )'*% ! , "%" ,"(" -" + / * * & )" ) "," , &!" 9'&*", 0 9'&*", " -" -" + / &)" !" +" )'*% ! , ! &, / ! "& % ! " 8"&"%)" % &' 8 *" 9""! / & %" ,!" "& , /"+" "1 " /"+ % & 1" " %&'+&"* % +)"!" )'*% ! , % + ' "

&'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!"

!' -" + + ")" " "* % ! " " " "8 % ! " ,)& %! 9. *" " " "* * !' / &! ( " ! ) * ++"*/"&)" , 9"! , , "! -" + ! +"8 / & " +, + %" " ,""! & , ! ") )" " * * & )," , /"/ "& , "! + (" " '% ",

" "* % ! " " " "8 % + ' " . +" ) &" * *" 3@ )"& " %'% ", 1 ) % / ,"& -" ! , ) !"& 6$4 % + ' " "& 5= " "! % + *% "!" -" + / 8 '* " " "* % ! " " " "8 " +) ! A , ' &

,"*% + " "! " -" , % &! '/, &?", " ') * !", "!" -" + ! &) *% * " " +) ! ) * " " " , , ) " ! !"! 9 ! " " , , * % ! & &"!" ) &(" %" " , ! "% )'*% ! , ","& -" + % &!"("* +" * +)"( & &"!" , ! "% )"!'& , 8 ++" % &' 8 ) ", 9 )", ,!& / , " / & ","&)" ,!" "& & "! 9 "!"

*" " ) )" , , '&" + , " 8 / +)" +" )"<" 0 )"<" -" " "* ) '*%')

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

(4)

,('(.(

+" " % ( " ,- ) & % ! %" ("!)" ) 8" &"! "8 -" + ! "8

* *%"8)" &"8*"! " 8 "-"80 -" , 8 ++" % ! "%"! * - ," )"

% ! " ', * " !"8 $334 -" + / &( ?" ", ! +)"! )'*% ! ,

% + ' " ,"! + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! &'% , " &"8 ,! * <"

'+-")"&!"

, * -" "& /"8<" ) " 1"&" " "* * - , " * - ," )"

% ! " ! ") %", "& /" ! " -" + / & )" ' 8 / &/"+" % 8") 8 )"& "

! +" , +" " ) & "8" 8"! . % , * + 1"%)" ! & *" )", 8 ) %" "#

)!'& ? &, !", + & '+-")"&!" -" + ! "8 * *9", !", % ! " "*

* - ," )" % ! " ', * "

$ ! " */"+" ! " ? &, !", + & '+-")"&!" -" + ! "8

* *9", !", % ! " "* * ")," ")" % ! " ', * "

2 )" :") !", * )" -" + ! "8 * */ & )" ) * "8" " (

" "* % ")," "" % ! "

; ! " & ," : -" + ! "8 * */ & )" ) * "8" / &')&", "

) ' ++"&" /"+ % ! ! ) "%"! ")! 9 * ")," ")" % ! "

"%" +"

6 )" 0& )" ', & ," : -" + ! "8 * */" ! % ! " "*

* ") )" ,) , " * */ & *", )" ! ) % &/" )" % ! "

= + ' " &'% , -" + ! "8 / &, " * " +)" <")! -"

, /"+" & ,%' % ! " " * */" ! ) " 1"&" %&', , % ! "

, * -" "& " "* % - , " % ! " *", 8 (" 8 "& , *% & "

" /" -") ) ) &" +" . )"& " -" 8"&"%)" *", )" , &!" ,"&" -" "+"&

% ! " * (" / 8 /" ) )8 & )"!" % , / &8"&"% % ! " "%"!

/ &*" 9""! /"+ , * " % 8") *

'+-")"&!". $2 , */ & $334

(5)

(6)

?

(/.(, (0

"/ $ '*% ! , &,' " " ', " 2

/ $ $ '*% ! , ) , ;

"/ $ 2 '*% ! , )" * , =

"/ $ ; '*% !, + */" +" "-" =

"/ ; "&")! & ,! ) ,%' & ","&)" , ) &("" $;

"/ ; $ "&")! & ,! ) ,%' & ","&)" , "* $;

"/ ; 2 "&")! & ,! ) ,%' & ","&)" +)"! )" $;

"/ ; ; ,!& / , ,%' & ","&)" "/ %"! 7 '!" $6

"/ ; 6 ", ( & "/ !", $=

"/ ; = ", ?" ", '*% ! , &,' " ', " $5

"/ ; 5 ", ?" ", '*% ! , ) , $4

"/ ; 4 ", ?" ", '*% ! , )" * , 23

"/ ; > ", ?" ", '*% ! , + */" +" "-" 2

(7)

?

(/.(, (+1$,(%

,!& * ?" ", '*% ! , + ' " 2>

$ "/ !- ;;

2 " !- ;;

; ", ?" ", '*% ! , '*% ! , ', " ;=

6 ", ?" ", '*% ! , '*% ! , ) , ;>

= ", ?" ", '*% ! , B '*% ! , )" * , 6$

5 ", ?" ", '*% ! , )'*% ! , + */" +" "-" 66

4 ", ?" ", '*% ! , + ' " 64

> &,' " " "+" ! =

(8)

(.(, ('(%&

)" * & %")" , )!'& % ! + -" + / &% &" ")! 9 " "* * +)"!)"

% */" + " /" +," %"/ " * 8"! )' , *",-"&")"! ' , " , )"&" +

*", 8 /" -") -" + / * * "%"!)" % "-" " % )" ! & !"*" ! )

*",-"&")"! )' '* * +"8 ) /"<"8 "8" -" / "-" % )" * (" 9")!'&

!"*" /"+ *",-"&")"! , 8 ++" * & )" ! ") * "%"!)" ) , *%"!" ! )

* + -"* % )" /"8)" ,"*%" , )' "8 ","& , )" %

" "8 -" %"&! , %", *",-"&")"! " "* % )" * +") /"!)" , *")

* +)"! -" " +)" ) *, ) " " ) /' '8" ") ("&" + *",-"&")"! -" +

* +" "* / !" 8 & 9 , /"+" )' , ) , "& ) &" + -" % )" /"+ * & )"

! ) * + &" + *"," "8 ! &, / ! % & " " -" "-" " % )" -" + "%"!

* - ! 8 *",-"&")"! 8 ++" "% ," /"<"8. *" " % )" ! ") 8" -"

* * ,"!)" %" " (" & % )" 9'&*" ,"(". * " )" * " (" & % )"

" -" ! % )" ' 9'&*" " % )" 9'&*"

- ++"&"" )" ' :'&*" "!" )" "& )' "8

*"), )" ! ) * */ & )" % "-" " % )" ) %" " *",-"&")"! -" + ! ")

* +) ! & "-" % )" -" (" & % )" 9'&*" &'+&"* -" +

, ++"&")" " "* )" ' :'&*" : * % ! . &'+&"*

) , !"&"" )" ","& "& )' "8. &'+&"* */ &" !"," !" & 9

* " "),"&"" : +, ' " . &'+&"* "*" "1"" ",-"&")"!. &'+&"*

)" & *% " . '+&"* )" &) " ( !" . &'+&"* */ & "-""

" + */" +" ,"! + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! " &'+&"*

+)"!" " !", */ & "-" " , " + ' " %&'+&"* "& . ' 8 "

! ) *",-"&")"!

" "8 ,"! %"-" -" + ! "8 ") )" ! ) * + */" +)" %&'+&"*

% )" (" & )" "& )' "8 " " "8 ! &/ ! ) -" ,"! + "!"

(9)

$

) *",-"&")"!" " &"8 , ! *%"! * & %")" ," "8 ,"! ( + !'*/")

% + */" +" %&'+&"* ! +)"! "%" +" )"& " " +, + / &, ! 8"

+" *",-"&")"! "& , 8"&"%)" % + ' " *"*% * + */" +)"

& -" , 1"&" *"), *" " "* * "-" " * + */" +)" %&'+&"*

% */ & "-"" *",-"&")"!

,"! + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! * & %")" ," "8 ,"! " ! & "! 9

-" + "%"! % 8 " (" )" "(" + % */ & "-"" *",-"&")"! " , "&",

+" % * ) &" /"8<" +" * */"+")" ")" /" -") %'! , -" +

, "*" ! ") ! &+" ")" "%"! +" . ! */ 8)" . *" 9""!)" "

"-"+ ")" 8 ") -" * (" % * 1 " % - ! *'! ?", " )& ",

*",-"&")"!

&'+&"* % )" -" + " " *",-"&")"! , "*" / &, 9"! ,!" "&.

/ &'& !", ")" * ,. " ) &" + / &*") " /"+ ) 8 %" , 8"& 08"& . *",-"&")"!

8" -" * (" % & *" %&'+&"* " /"8)" ! ") * * ) "), , -" + / &"&! " "*

% & 1" "" . % ")," "" . % " " 7% + " " %&'+&"* % )" ' ,

* - /"/)" *",-"&")"! ) &" + )& "! 9. *" & " "* , " "* * + ,"8")"

% )" -" + , , " +" ) / ! 8" " %'! , +) +" -"

" "* &" +)" * */ & "-")" *",-"&")"!. -" + * & %")" %"-"

* *% &, "%)" *",-"&")"! , & + +" %"-" * *% &) "! ) */"+""

*",-"&")"! "+"& *",-"&")"! *"*% * < ( )" ) *"( " . ) *" & " "

) , ("8! &"" " "* , "," " ) " " ,', " -" + / &) " ( !" . *")" % - ++"&".

% + ' " " ! "+" % +"("& 8"& , / 8 / &) " !", ! ) * 1"%" ! ( "

-" + ! "8 ! ! )"

'&" + % + ' " 8"& , *"*% * +")'*' ", )" , & 8 %&'+&"*

*",-"&")"! " * ("* (" " -" %&'+&"* +" /" ) "* )' , -" +

" " ,""! * ( ))" /"8<" ) / &" "" + ' " / * *"*%

* < ( )" ! ( " "& %&'+&"* -" + " " " " !"!"&" '% &", ' " . *", 8

," +"! /" -") 8", "& %&'+&"*0%&'+&"* -" + " " ! ") * 1"%" ,!" "& -" +

(10)

2

%"-" * +)"!)" * ! % )" ' , " ! "8 "*" ") )" .

+" / &/"+" '?", %&'+&"*. % +)"!" 9", !", " % +)"!" ! "+"

) % )" . "* * ) " 8 ++" ,""! * ! % )" ' , " ! & -"!"

*", 8 (" 8 ! &! ++" "& +"&"0 +"&" " / &"%" % ! " ( +" * ( ))"

/"8<" ?"& "/ % )" " "! 8" * & %")" ?"& "/ -" + ) 1 % +"& 8 -"

/"8)" , /"+ " ! ") / &% +"& 8 ! &8" "% ) &(" ! "+" ) % )" . 8"

* +) , /"/)" ' 8 )"& " ) "! ! &, / ! ! ") &" 1" + , , " +"

) / ! 8" & % , &!" "%" +"

& ," "& % " /"8<" "!"& / ")" + % )" % + ' " ," +"!

8 ! &'+ . ' 8 )"& " ! % "! 8" ! ) , /" ) , / * *" % , "*"

* ")," ")" ! +", ," +"! "8 % & ") )" &/"+" % "! 8" ! &, / ! % & )"

! ) * +)"!)" ) " !", % + ' " . , 8 ++" "& % "! 8" ")"

* 1 % + ' " +" ) *"*% " -" + * *" " " * *% -" *'! ?",

" ) *" " ) &(" -" + ! ++ +" * +)"! -" ) " !", , '&" + % + ' "

, "8 %",! ")" * *% +"& 8 ! +)"! ) / &8", " %&'+&"*

*",-"&")"! -" + !" +" ' 8 % + ' "

"&! , %", ," ( & ," % )" "& , )' "8 -" + ! & /"! " "*

% ")," "" " % + ' "" ( +" " *", 8 ," +"! & "8. /" ) !

%"&! , %", "!", ) ," "&" , & . *" % %"&! , %", "!", ","& % ) &("" "!"

) <"( /" '*% ! , , /"+" % + ' " % )" "& , )' "8 , ' "8 ! ")

/ &+ " ) ! )" * & )" / 8 * * 8 ! ) / &%&'9 , "& (" & ) " , /"+"

"*%") "& ) / (")" % * & !"8 -" + ! ") % & "8 * *%& '& !",)" ! "+"

) % )" ' 9'&*" " "* 9'&*", % & *"" % +"<" " % &/ & )

+" & "8 -" % *"8"*" %"&" % */ "! ) / (")" * + " ! "+" % )

" ) % )" ' 9'&*" . , 8 ++" & )& !* % +"<" / " + % )" '

9'&*" *", 8 /" -") -" + ," "8 ,","&" . " "* "&! ,% , 9 )", % ) &("" ! ") , , "

+" % ) &"("" -"

/ &*"1"*" "!"& / ")" + % )" %"&" % + ' "

* * +) )" ! &(" -" ) , (" +" " !"&" )'*% ! , % + ' " -" + , 8"& , -"

(11)

;

' 9'&*" * * ) )"&")! & ,! ) -" + / &/ " +" % )" 9'&*" . *" "

% *"8"*" ")" )"&")! & ,! ) *",-"&")"!. *' 0*' % + */" +" "

% */ & "-"" *",-"&")"!. *' % */ "("&" *",-"&")"! " *" "( *

%&'+&"* % )" ' 9'&*" 8"& , / "&0/ "& %"8"* " ) "," . , 8 ++"

%&'+&"*0%&'+&"* -" + " " "%"! / &(" " , , " +" ! ( " -"

+ ' " , "*" / &"," "& +) +" , ) !"& -" -" + " ++"%

*"*% * (" " )" 9 +, *" "( & " . !" %" * *% &,-"&"!)"

) *"*% " 0) *"*% " ! &! ! 8"& , * ) " -") %"&" % , " "!"

/"8)" + & 0+ & ,"*%" -" + ! &( * (" % + ' "

+) +" -" ' , ,"! , , * *" + * + ! +)" . *" " % + ' "

," +"! * + " )"&")! & ,! ) "& <"&+" *",-"&")"! *" " ! &, / ! & )" .

, 8 ++" %&'+&"*0%&'+&"* / ," ," +"! , , " +" 8"&"%" *",-"&")"! "*

% + ' "" ! ") 1 ) % 8" -" +" * + " )"&")! & ,! ) *",-"&")"! ,"(".

")" ! !"% *", 8 /" -") "+ -" + % & * & )" ) "," , %"-" -" + * & )"

) ' " "%"! / &(" " +" ! &! /

%.$/$'()$ ()( (

"& "!"& / ")" + "!", "%"! ! 9 )", / / &"%" % &*"," "8" " !"&"

" #

&'+&"* % )" *",-"&")"! ,""! *", 8 / &, 9"! ,!" "& &'& !",

")" * ,. " ) &" + / &*") " /"+ ) 8 %" , 8"& 08"&

$ ",-"&")"! 8" -" (" % & *" %&'+&"* " ! ") * * ) "), , -" + / &"&!

" "* %&'+&"* -" + ")," ")"

2 "&! , %", ," ( & ," -" + ! & /"! " "* % + ' "" "

," +"! & "8

; + ' " * * ) "!"& / ")" + % )" -" + / &/ "0/ ".

* - /"/)" ! &(" -" ) , (" +" )'*% ! , % + ' " -" + , 8"& , -"

(12)

6

2 ,*+*)(% ()( (

"& 8", ! 9 )", *"," "8 "!",. ! & +)"% /"8<" , "*" % + ' "

* * ) "!"& / ")" + % )" -" + / &/ "0/ ". & )& !* % + ' "

! ") ","&)" %" " ) *"*% " " )'*% ! , -" " "* *" "( * % )"

' 9'&*" . *"8", ,<" "!" % ," "& ( & ," % )" "& , )' "8 ! ")

"-"+ ")" " "* % + ' "" . " ,"*%" +" ,""! % + ' "

/ * *"*% * < ( )" ! ( " "& %&'+&"* -" + " ". , 8 ++" % ! "

," ! ) * ") )" ?" ", ! &8" "% )'*% ! , -" + * ) ' 8 %"&"

% + ' " . , 8 / +" +" ! . *")" % &*"," "8" -" + ")" ) * )")"

" "* % ! " " " "8# "+" *" ")"8 ! +)"! )'*% ! , % + ' "

&'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!"C

! " ?" ", "%"! + ")" ! ) * 1"& ("<"/" "& % &*"," "8"

! &, / !. *" " 8") )"! % " " " " "8 ) + "!" -" + , ,! *"! , ! )

* + *% )" . * +' "8 " * -"( )" "!" "!" 9'*", -" + % & )" , /"+"

*", )" ! ) % +"*/ " ) % ! ," 8 ++" "& 8", ?" ", 8"&"%)"

"%"! * */ & )" *", )" /"+ %"&" % */ "!" ) / (")" ! ) * +8", )"

,!&"! + 0,!&"! + *" % %&'+&"* ! ) % +)"!" ) " !", % + ' "

*3*(% % $.$(%

+)"! )'*% ! , % + ' " ,"! + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! % & ! )

") )" ?" ", . , 8 ++" ) *"*% " % + ' " -" + " " ,""! "%"!

) !"8 ! +)"!" -". "%"! ) !"8 )'*% ! , "%" ,"(" -" + / * * & )"

) "," " 9'&*", 0 9'&*", " -" -" + / &)" !" +" )'*% ! , %"&"

% + ' " ! &, / ! 8 )"& " ! . % ! " * * ) ! ( " ! ) * + !"8

! +)"! )'*% ! , %"&" % + ' " &'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!"

(%/((. % $.$(%

"% *" 9""! -" + 8"&"%)" "& % ! " " " "8 % &' 8 8",

?" ", -" + "%"! (" )" , /"+" "1 " /"+ % & 1" "" %&'+&"* % +)"!"

(13)

=

!

,"! ) + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! -" + * & %")" ! ") " ( ! "&

+"+"," ! "8 ) " ' , " , (") !"8 "*

% 8" 1"&" ) */"+"" . % & ! ," -" ' , " +" "*" /"&

* " %" " !"8 >>4 , (" " +" %"-" ! ) * *% & ", ) , *%"!"

*",-"&")"! * *% &' 8 "-" " % )" (" ". $332. $

,"! + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! " " "8 ! *%"! % */ "("&" " "*

/ ! ) / &/"+" *"1"* ) ! &"*% " +" * *" 9""!)" ,"&" ". %&","&" ". "

, +" " %'! , -" + " " , ) !"& +) +" ) 8 %" *",-"&")"!. "+"& *",-"&")"!

* * ) ) ! &"*% " " % + !"8 " -" + "%"! *" 9""!)" ! )

* +)"!)" " * *% &/" ) !"&"9 8 % -" "! *. $333. =

/ &" "" * * ) %'! , / ,"& ! ) (" )" , /"+" )''& ",

%&'+&"*0%&'+&"* % */ "("&" *",-"&")"! &, " -" % + ' " 7

% - ++"&". ! "+" % +"("& 7 ! !'& -" + / &) " !",. * & %")" "-" % )"!

! &, & /"+ *",-"&")"! ! ) "!" + ) ( " " " "8

* */ & "-")" *",-"&")"! ! ) ) *" & " . * " " %&'+&"*0%&'+&"* -" +

")," ")" . "+"& "%"! * */ ! ) *" , " -" + * * ) % + !"8 " .

) ! &"*% " . " , )"%. , " +)" 9 +, "& , & " " "8 8'*/ +.

>>># 3 #

D "&! -" ! *%"! <"&+" *",-"&")"! "%"!

* */" * " * *% &' 8 / &/"+" ( , ) ! &"*% " " % + !"8 "

9 +, ' " -" + "%"! "-"+ ")" , 1"&" 1 %"! " ! %"! " "* %"-"

% &/" )" ) " !", 8 % " ) 8 %" -"

$ D "&! -" , /"+"

! *%"! % &! )"&" / &/"+" %'! , -" + " " " / &) */" + *",-"&")"!.

, 8 ++" * (" , "! , &+ -" + "* , " "* %"-" % */ & "-""

(14)

5

2 D "&! -" <"8" " *",-"&")"! * " -")"

/ &/"+" 9'&*", ! !" + / &/"+" ( , ) + "!" % */ "("&" "

) ! &"*% " 9 +, ' " -" + / ! 8)" *",-"&")"!

; D "&! -" ! *%"!

/ &/"+" ( , ) ! &"*% " " % +" "*" -" + * ) ' 8 *",-"&")"!

-" + / &," +) !" +" %& , % ," + / "("& " * */ "("&)" * "

,) , * + " % &*"," "8" -" + 8" "%

6 D "&! -"

! *%"! " ")" -" / &/"+" % &! * " %"&" % + ' " " , */ & / "("&

! !'& /" ) , 1"&" ! & *" % +" , ) !"& -" ! ) * */"8",

/ &/"+" % &*"," "8" " ) " " -" + 8" "% " "* % + ' ""

" % */ "("&" *",-"&")"!

= D "&! -" ! *%"! -" + , 1"&" ! & ,

* & , + ")" ! ) ) + "!" / "("& /"+ *",-"&")"! " "* / &/"+"

/ ! )

" " %& , % -" ,"! + "!" "("& ",-"&")"! / ! ) "& . ' 8.

" ! ) *",-"&")"! +" * *% &8"! )" , +" " %'! , -" + " " , ) !"& -"

8 )"& " ! " "* %&', , % */ ! )" " % - ++"&"" -" / 8

* ++ ")" * !' 7% )"!" -" + , 1"&"

+"& , / ,"& %& , %0%& , % -" * % ! # / "("& "& *",-"&")"!. *",-"&")"! , /"+"

, /- ). ," + * */ "("&)" . % */ & "-"" *",-"&")"!. * + " %'! , "

% -" "&" . % & * ," *"," "8 " % ! " %& '& !",. ! 9 )", % * 1"8"

*"," "8. % * 8" " ! & "! 9 % * 1"8" . % & 1" "" " % -"( " & 1" "

) + "!" . % ")," "" ) + "!" . *' !'& + " , % &? , . " ?" ", "! *

$333 /"+" / ! ) "% )", %& , %0%& , % ! &, / !. *")" " "* %&', ,

% */ ! )" *" % % - ++"&"" % */ "("&" " " "8#

" ! )"!" "%"! ") )" * "

!')'80!')'8 *",-"&")"! -" + " ++"% * *% -" % +"& 8

,"7) &"8" ! &, / !. * ," -" ) " . ) ! " 7 . &"87) %" " ,".

(15)

4

*",-"&")"! +" %&'+&"* -" + ")" , ++"&")" " "*

% )"!" *",-"&")"! % &) " )" +" / &/"+" *"," "8 , &!"

" " -" %'! , -" + * ) ' 8 *",-"&")"! -" + * +) "%"!

* (" + % ")," "" %&'+&"* )"!" ! &8" "% !')'80!')'8

*",-"&")"! +" * */ & )" ) , *%"!" ! ) * ! )" 1" '

% - ++"&" , & , , " +" -" + 8"&"%)" ' 8 <"&+"

*",-"&")"! +"& ! +", % - ++"&"" " "* ) + "!" / 8

* "8. *")" , , " '&+" ,", % - ++"&"" " " "8 , /"+"

/ & ) !#

*/ &# "<" * &. $333# 2

/ " # #$!% ! 9 )", ") )" ' 8 1" '

% - ++"&" " /" ! ' 8 !')'8 *",-"&")"! , &0 , & -" + % &

(16)

>

-" + " !"&" " * % ! # <"&+" / "("&. "&" , */ &7! !'&. ,"&" " / "("&.

! *%"! / "("&. ) '*%') / "("&. " " / "("&. " %&'+&"* / "("&

1 ! & " ( " -" " " "8 ! ) * + !"8

%& '& !", !"*" -" + 8"& , ") )" ' 8 % - ++"&" / &,"*" +"

!')'80!')'8 *",-"&")"! , / * ) + "!" % */ "("&" * "

# " "* % ")," "" ) + "!" 8 ") -"

* ,-"<"&")" / 8 "8 +" <"&+" / "("& ! ) * ! )"

(" <" ) + "!" / "("&. , 8 ++" % ")," "" -" ! ") * +" "*

8"*/"!" ")," " ) + "!" "," ")" , 1"&" %"&! , %"! 9 -" +

* /"!)" */"+"0 */"+" ! &)" ! " *",-"&")"!

'( + "!" ?" ", 8 ") -" ") )" ' 8 % - ++"&"

" !')'80!')'8 *",-"&")"! , ) !"& ,"*% + ! ) * + !"8

) / &" "" " " 8" -" + %" + % ! + ! ) / 1"&")" +"

!')'80!')'8 *",-"&")"! ! !" + ) " "78"*/"!" -" + ! * , "*"

% ")," "" " , )" + , /"+" *" " 1"&" % * 1"8" -"

"! * $333D $

%& 4 ((%

+ ' "" * & %")" ! &( *"8" "& )"!" *" "+ * ! " "* "* ,

,"& "8"," ' , " , / !)" /"8<" % + ' "" / &"&! % - ++"&"" .

* & ! &, - " " 18"& >4$ 9 , )" , /"+" / & ) !# E*" "+ * ! ",

<'&) + !'+ !8 & < !8 '& !8&' +8 % '% . ? " '& +&' %,. !' "11'*% ,8

'&+" F"! ' " +'" G ( )" "&! )" *" "( * " " "8 ) + "!" / ) &(","*" "!"

* " '&" + " . /" ) % &'&" +" *" % ) '*%'). ! ) * 1"%" ! ( "

'&+" ,", (" ". $332#

& ! "& ' "* , '. % + ' "" " " "8 , /,!" ! 9" "& * + ' ".

, " +)" * + ' " " " "8 , "! ! ")" -" + * " "& % - , " "!".

* & 1" ". * +'&+" ,", )" . * ")," ")" ,"*%" +" % +"<"," "

(17)

3

, , "! ! "%"! * & %")" , */ & % - *% & "" " % +)"!" % + ' ""

, " ( ! -"

9 , " * - / !)" /"8<" % + ' "" " " "8 % - ++"&"" "!"

% & * ," "+"& , , "! -" + ) ' " "%"! / &(" " " 1"&. 9 )! 9 " 9 ,

& ) !'. >>2#4 ( ",)" % " /"8<" % + ' "" * % ! /" -") ) + "!" "

, * " -" ! / &,"*"0,"*" * +8", )" , "! 8", ")8 & -" + * */ & )"

9'&*", /"+ % - *% & "" % &) + "!"

" "* * 1 %!")" )' , -" + * * +) )" <"&+" / "("& * 1"%"

! ( " % */ "("&" , 1"&" 9 )! 9 " 9 , *")" , & 8 , */ & "-" % )"

! % & ) ' " " + ")" , '%! *" * +) */ & "-" % )" -" +

/ & %" *" , ". ) " +" . ,"&" " " %&","&" ". * !' " , /"+" -" 8"& ,

& 1" ")" . '&+" ,", . "&"8)" " "<", "+"& ! &1"%" -" ! ( " % )"

" "%"! 1"%" ( )" 9 +, 09 +, % + ' "" ") )" +" /" ) "%

9 +, 09 +, % + ' "" ! " " "8 , /"+" / & ) !#

: +, & 1" ""

& 1" "" " " "8 ")! ? !", % +"*/ " ) % ! ," ! !" + ,","&" "%"

-" + ")" 1"%" . ! ")" "%" -" + ")" "*/ " "* &" +)" * 1"%" ! ( "

"!" ,",&" ! &, / ! " , "%" -" + ")" * ")," ")" ! +", ! &, / !

&8" . >>;# =5 ,% ) % & 1" "" * % ! # "%" -" + ") )" . , "%"

-" + 8"& , * ") )" . )"%" ") )" . *" " ")" ") )" . /"+" *" "

* ") )" -". "%" ,"(" -" + % & )" "+"& ! &1"%" -" ! ( " "%"! *"), *"

$ : +, +&'+" ,", "

+'&+" ,", " " " "8 ")! ? !", * - , "!" * */ ! ) 8 / +" 0

8 / +" ) &(" " !"&" '&" +0'&" + -" + ! & /"! " "* ) ,"! " ,"8" / &,"*"

" "* * 1"%" ! ( " -" + ! "8 ! !"%)" " "* ) + "!" % +'&+" ,", "

! & "%"! " " -" % */"+ " ! +",. < < " + " !" ++ + ("<"/ -" + ! & 1

* &! / " +0/ " + " /"!",0/"!", ) < " +" -"

2 : +, +"&"8"

" "* ) + "!" % + ' "" . / ! )0/ ! ) % +"&"8" -" + "%"!

(18)

" ( "," ! !" + "%". * +"%" " /"+" *" " ! +",D

/ & !" %& '& !", % - ," " D

1 &', & ) &("

"&" " " */ & -" + "%"! *" 9""!)" D

8")0% 8") -" + ! &)" ! +" & ," -". /" ) " +, + *" % ! ")

" +, +

9 "+" *" " * ") )" % " " ! &8" "% % - ," " ! +", ! &, / !

; : +, +"<"," 7 ' !&' " " "

+"<"," % & )" ! ) * 8"! , (" 8 *" " 8", 1"%" & !

& 1). % +"<"," * & %")" %&', , ","& -" + , 1"&" , , " ! !"%

% & )" /"+" *" "% & * ! " ", -" , "! '&+" ,", &', , ","& -"

! & & "& ! +" !"8"%D * !"%)" ,!" "& % ")," "" . $ % + ) &"

% ")," "" % ) &("" /" +)" +" ,!" "&. " 2 * ! )"

) , (" +" ? ", " !"&" % ")," "" +" ,!" "& " & 1" " :"!"8.

$333# 3

2 %& 4 (

+ ' " " " "8 ! "+" ) % )" "& , )' "8 / )" % +"<"

+ & -" + & )& ! ! ) * + ' ' " ) + "!" '% &", ' " %&'+&"* * "

"& * & 1" ")" . * ")," )"" . * */ */ +. * " " * "%'&)" 8", 08",

% ")," "" %&'+&"*0%&'+&"* "%" +" ! & !"*" %&'+&"* % )"

*",-"&")"! & )!'&"! )*",. >>4

+", %')') , '&" + % + ' " " " "8 " "* 8" * + ! 9 )",

) / ! 8" / "("& *",-"&")"!. * & 1" ")" % ")," "" %&'+&"* -" + , , "

+" ) / ! 8" *",-"&")"!. * */ " % ")," "" %&'+&"*. * ") )" % " "

! &8" "% %&'+&"* -" + / &(" " " * "%'&)" % ")," "" %&'+&"* ) %" "

% ("/"! ! &)" !

/"+" ! "+" % + ' " . *")" , 1"&" & 1 ! +", + ' "

" " "8 . $33;#> #

(19)

$

$ +" ")" )' ,' ", %&'+&"*

2 - , %&'+&"* / "("& , , " ) / ! 8" / "("& *",-"&")"! " * */ "!

% !" %&'+&"* , ! "% ,"

; - , & 1" " ) &(" * ++ " . / " " . ! +"8 !"8 " " !"8 "

6 - "%)" ) / ! 8" " * ,!&", % ")," "" %&'+&"*

= 1"& )" " * - "%)" ) / ! 8" / ) . " "!. ! "+" 7 */"+" -" +

% & )" " "* % ")," "" %&'+&"*

5 1"!"! ) *"( " / "("& <"&+" / "("&

4 +"*"! " * 1"!"! % ")," "" %&'+&"* / "("& * +"("&

> +"<", " * + " )" , * " % ")," "" %&'+&"* / "("&

3 - , "%'&" / " " . !& < " . ! +"8 !"8 " " !"8 "

*/ & )" ,"&" 0,"&" % &/" )" %&'+&"* "!" * + */" +)" %&'+&"*

/ "("& * +"("& , , " +" ) / ! 8" . %'! , . )' , " , ! ", " &"8

$ * 8 " * ! )" 1" ' <"&+" / "("& ! ) , ! "% ( , %&'+&"*

/ "("& ") ! . ") ! . ") ! B. ("& ,"8". ", ,<". "+" +. &, ,

) , *",.

2 +" ")" & ! ," %&'+&"* -" + '?"! 9 , , " +" %'! , . )' , "

, ! ", +) +" , ) !"&

; + */" +)" ("& +" ) &(". /" ) +" ", 7 ,!" , ! &)" !. "

,"8" " */"+" ) " +"

6 + */" +)" ,"8" %&' )! 9 , , " +" % &* !"" %","&

4+1 . %)$ %& 4 (

'*% ! , * & ! B ,8" " " "8 % + !"8 " . ) ! &"*% " "

) *"*% " -" + ) "," ' 8 , , '&" + -" + ! "8 * (" /"+ " "& & -".

, 8 ++" " "%"! * ") )" % & ") 0% & ") )'+ ! 9. "9 )! 9 " %, )'*'!'& )

+" , /" )0/" ) -" -",". $33$ & ! &! &,' . )'*% ! , " " "8

)"&")! , ","& -" + ! & & "& ) *"*% " ,) . % + !"8 " ) '< + , &!"

"!& / ! % &,' " " -" -" + *"*% * */ ")" , , '&" + -" + % &9'&* " ! ")

(20)

(21)

(22)

(23)

(24)

5 ( ( * " "* % + &! " ) * )")"

/"8<" % " " "!" ?" ", * & %")" %&', , * + ! 9 )", " * + *% )"

9'&*", ! ) * */" ! %"&" % +"*/ ) % ! ," " "* * * 8 " ! & "! ?

) % ! ," ) >4 * + * )")" /"8<" E ?" "! ' , !8 %&'1 ,, '9

"11 &!" + !8 1 , '" "& ", '9 1' 1 & . , 1! + "%%&'%& "! 9'&*"! ' . "

1' 1! + " " " -F + 9'&*"! ' '& & !' & %'&! , **"&- "!" , 9 !'

1 , ' *") &, , 1! + "*' + " ! & "! ? , (" ". $332#$==

& ","&)" % + &! " "!",. *")" % " " " " "8 , /"+" ) + "!" -" +

, ,! *"! , ! ) * + *% )" . * +' "8 " * -"( )" "!" "!" 9'*", -" +

% & )" , /"+" *", )" ! ) % +"*/ " ) % ! ," "!"," * +" +

! +" , & % ! + -" ! ) + "!" , ,! *"! ,. "!" "!" 9'&*", . " % +"*/ "

) % ! ," + "!" , ,! *"! , * +" + *") " /"8<" % " " ! ") )"

* " %&', & ! &! ! -" + ! &! /. "!" "!" 9'&*", -" + ) *% )" , /"+"

9') , ) + "!" % " " . % &' 8 * " % + *% " . % +' "8" . " % -"( "

+" * ++ ")" * !' " ! ) ) * "8 +"*/ " ) % ! ," * )" )"

/"8<" "!" "!" 9'&*", -" + ,"( )" ! ")" / & " + " "%"/ " * ("

*", )" / &8"&+" ! ) %&', , % +"*/ " ) % ! ," ! !" + " ! & "! 9 -" + ")"

"*/ +" * ) " % " " * & %")" ) + "!" -" + ! &"! & ! )

* *% &' 8 "!" -" + / &+ " /"+ % +"*/ " ) % ! ,"

+ &! " , /"+" *" " -" + ) * )")" "!", * ( ))" /"8<"

% " " * * ) )" !" "!" / & )"! +" % ! " " " " % ! "

* * ) % &,"*"" " % &/ "" &,"*"" -" " " "8D % &!"*". /"8<" % " "

" % ! " * & %")" ) + "!" -" + , ,! *"! , ! ) * + *% )" .

* +" " , , " * -"( )" "!" "!" 9'&*", "& , */ &0, */ & , 1"&" '/( )! 9

". % " " " % ! " %" " ","& -" " "8 % &"%" 9 +, *

% + !"8 " -" ! ! ) * *"8"* + ( ,. * ( ",)" + - ,.

* &"*" )" + ,. " * + " )" + ,, "! + (" " "!" 9 '* "

! +". ) + "!" % " " " % ! " * * & )" * !' " ! ) ) * "8 ! )

* - , &" 1" +" + ,. % + ) &" . " " , ,. " % */"8"," 8", *%"!.

(25)

4

"!" -" "%"! '/, &?", . " "! ) & -" "( + " "%"! % &1"-". , &!" 8", -"

* * ) " + " *". % " " " % ! " "%"! * ++ ")" % )"!"

)! 9 " )! 9 "*. ) + "!" % " " " % ! " . " "* 8" ! &! ! .

"%"! +"/ +)" -" + ) " +" ,! "8 % ! " ?" ", + (

, (" ". $333#$=4

" .4 7( *()$ 8 %$ ($(%9

1"&" * * % " ! &/"+ ) " "* " )"! +'& -" ! % " -" +

/ &'& !", %" " * !' " % " -" + / &'& !", %" " *"," "8 / &"%"

* !' -" + "%"! + ")" ! ) % " " " !"&" " (" ". $333#$46

! ),% & * " ),% & * *

! ),% & * % ! + + ")" ( )" % " + * 1"& ("<"/"

/ &"+"* ! &8" "% % &!" -"" ! !" + 9 )! ? !", %&'+&"* "!" )'*%'

! ),% & * ! ") + ")" ! ) * " % & ,! <" *"," "*%"

$ !' '& ",

1"&" * *. )'& ", " !"&" ,!"! , ) &" + ) " " "* ?" ", %&'+&"*

" "8 ,"! , /"/ -" " " "8 /"8<" %"&" ?" "!'& / 8 /" -") * !" ! )

* ") )" ,! )'& ", , &8" " ++ "" * !' )'& ", "%"!

+ ")" " "* / &/"+" , ! ", -" + / &*" 9""! ! ) * ("<"/ / / &"%"

% &!" -"" ! !" + %&'+&"* % )" '& ", " !"&" / "-" % )" "

9 )! ? !", %&'+&"* -" + ) !"8 * " ,! !", %&'+&"* "!" * , 0

* , %&'+&"*. * +) / &*" 9""! /"+ % +"*/ ) % ! ," ! !" +

) / & " ( !" "!" *' ? )", %&'+&"*

2 !' &?

-!' , &- - "%"! + ")" ! ) * ("("+ . * + *% )" .

* ++"*/"&)" . * &" +)" ,","&" "!" '/( ) -" + ?" ", " "*

* ("("+ . * + *% )" " * ++"*/"&)" . * !' / &+ " ! )

* + +)"% , ! ", "!" % & ,! <" "& ") * ", "!" ,)& %! 9 !'

! ") * +8"& ,)" ! ) , " * 1"& "!" * ( ",)" 8 / +" 0

(26)

>

*% )", &? - * +) * (" * !' -" + ! &/" ) /"+ %"&" %")"&0%")"&

* ,'1 " -" + / &* "! " "* % + *% " "!" , 1"&" " +, + ! )

* ++"*/"&)" %'% ", / ,"& !' % ," +"! 1'1') ! )

* + +)"% , )"% " '& !", %'% ", -" + / ,"& ( * "8 -"

; ! ", ,

! )", , )"!")" , /"+" " " , , " ,)& %, , 1"&" * " "* , &!"

! & 1 ! !" + , "! '&+" ,", . */"+". "!" 9 '* " " "* )' ! ),

+) +" -" &,' . >56 ! )", , ," +"! / &+ " ! )

* + */" +)" 8 %'! , , -" + "%"! * +"&"8)" %" " % " " " "*

,)" " / 8 / ,"& " ! ) * +8 *% ,"&" 0,"&" * + " / &/"/"+

?"& "/ " " "! % + ) &" -" + ")" + ")" " "* % " " -" +

/ &,)" " / 8 / ,"&

6 +"*"!" 9'&*"

/ &"%" / ) ! &"! & * + +)"% /"8<" % " " %" " ","& -"

" +)"! "& ) ,"), " ,"), " " " "8 ) "& / &/"+" % & 1" "" "

?" ", %&'+&"* % &! " "* %&'+&"*0%&'+&"* % * & !"8 /" ) " "*

/ " + ) , 8"!" . % )" " " -". )" " +0) " + ) ,"), " "8

(27)

$3

)($% 4'()$ (% (+1 % $.$(%

!' -" + + ")" " "* % ! " " " "8 % ! " ,)& %! 9

!' ,)& %! 9 " " "8 * !' ,)& %! 9 / &! ( " ! ) * ++"*/"&)" , 9"!

, , "! -" + ! +"8 / & " +, + %" " ,""! & , ! ") )" " * * & )," , /"/0

, /"/ "& , "! + (" " ! &! ! &"? &,. >54 " "* , . >>> !'

/ &! ( " ! ) * ("<"/ % &!" -"" -" + * -" +) ! , , "! %" " <")! , " +

/ & " +, + -" %&', , & , ! "-. >5= " "* , . >>> ! " ,)& %! 9

* * ) / &*"1"*0*"1"* ! ( " % ! " #

.,

( /, (

( B''% & H 18 &. $332# = %

!' % ! " "%"! * */ & )" 9'&*", -" + * !")8 & , 8 ++"

"%"! * */ & )" / 8 /" -") *" 9""! ! ) % &) */" +" * % + !"8 " "

"%"! % " ! &"%)" %" " / &/"+" *"1"* *"," "8 ! " ")" ") )"

" &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!". -" + ! & & "& *%"! )"/ %"! " ,"! )'!" *" -".

" !"&" " # "/ %"! *" . "/ %"! " ! . "/ %"! ' %&'+'. "/ %"!"

+ " '!" '+-")"&!"

'% ", " "* % ! " " " "8 % + ' " " &"8 ,! * <"

'+-")"&!" ) &" * *" ,"*% -" + "%"! ! & *" / & ","&)" %" " ,"

% ! " -" + + ")" . -" ! , /"+" / & ) ! "- " "* , . >>> #

a. _!' _{,)& %! 9 * *"} _{3@ %'% ", .} _{! ) %'% ", & "! 9 ) 1}

* *" $3@ %'% ",

b. _!' _{,)& %! 90)'& ", ' " . * *" 23@ , /( )}

c. _!' _{I %',! 9"1!' * *"} _{6 , /( ) % & ) '*%')}

d. _!' _{),% & * !" . * *"} _{6 , /( ) % & ) '*%')}

"& /"!"," "!", *" " % ! " " " "8 % ! " ,)& %! 9. *")"

(28)

$

-" + " " "*% * & %")" % + ' " -" + ! , /"& , & 8 )"/ %"! "

)'!" -" + ")" % 8 +" * ++ ")" , *% &" '* ,"*% +. , ! "%

)"/ %"! " )'!" ")" <") ' 8 * *" ; *" " , ! "% *" "

, ! "% ")" <") ' 8 / / &"%" % + ' " 8 ++" % &,-"&"!" * *" 3@

,"*% ! &% 8 "& , ) !"& 6$4 % + ' " "& 5=

.4 '%$' (% %).,*+ % %&*+1* (% (.(

+ *% " "!" -" + ")" ") )" " "* % ! " * ++ ")"

* !' '/, &?", . ') * !", " " +) ! /, &?", ")" ") )" %" " ) + "!"

-" + ! &(" " "* % ")," "" % ! " ') * !", + ")" ! ) * 1"&

9'&*", / & %" % , &" ') * , % &! / ) "%'&" . % / )", "

% + * *" +) ! " " "8 " "! % + *% " "!" / & %" % &!" -"" 0% &!" -""

-" + 8"& , ("<"/ ' 8 & ,%'

2 %:(.(.(% %&4 ( (% (% %( $)$) (.(

"!" -" + ! &) *% /" ) "& 8", % +"*"!" . ') * !", " " +) ! ")"

" " , , + ) &" )'*% ! , ")" ") )" +" ! ) ) % " " ' 8

"!"," . *" " ) ! " % + ' " ")" * " )'*% ! , )"&-"<" -" +"

1"&" * */ & )" % " " & ! &8" "% , ! "% / ! & ,!& * -" + ,"( )" ! )

* + !"8 ! +)"! )'*% ! , "& % + ' " . ")" + ")" ,)" " ?

!'&-! ,!'&-! +" ; '%, ,!& * ! , , " )" +" ! ) ) % + ) &" *" "

% + ' " , /"+" '/( ) , )" + , , /( ) % + ) &" +" 1"&" * */ & )"

% " " ) *"*% " -" %" " & !" + ,)'& ,"*%" ;. -" + "&! -" ) *"*% "

! & "8 / & ,)'& " ) *"*% " ! &! ++ / & ,)'& ; . $33;# >

! ) * ! )" ! +)"! ) *"*% " % + ' " / & ","&)"

)'*% ! , -" + ) */" +)" *")" "!" 8", % + ) &" )'*% ! , % + ' "

")" " " , , +" * ++ ")" " " , , ,)& %! 9 +" * ++ ")"

& &"!" 1"%" " ) &(" %" " *", +0*", + )'*% ! , ! " " , , * % ! & &"!"

) &(" %" " , ! "% )'*% ! , ","& -" + % &!"("* +" * +)"( & &"!" , ! "%

(29)

$$

#

()$ % $.$(%

( " "& ) + "!" % ! " " " "8 ! ) * + !"8 ! +)"!

)'*% ! , %"&" % + ' " &'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!" " ! )

* + !"8 ! +)"! ) , (" +" " !"&" )'*% ! , -" + , 8"& , -" * & )" ) ","

+" )'*% ! , -" + ! "8 * & )" ) ","

! ) * ("<"/ % &!" -"" ! &, / ! "!",. /"<"8 ")" +"*/"&)"

8", % ! " -" + % &' 8 % ! "%" +"

)',$1)$ 4'()$ % $.$(%

&'% , / &" " %" " % & +)"! ) 2 +" ,)'& 53.4 "!"0&"!" , "

8"&"%" 8 % % ) 5$.; !"8 &, !", " +)" * ) 8 & 9 <"," " " "8

46.>@ "!"0&"!" "*" , )' "8 4. !"8 + "&" % & )"% !" % = .233.33

8"! "& ), */" + " & +0 1 ( " -, !"8

$33$. &'% , / &" " %" " % & +)"! ) 0$ +" ,)'& =6 $ "!"0&"!" , "

8"&"%" 8 % % ) % & *% " " " "8 5;.$ !"8 . ") 0 ") 53.; !"8

&, !", " +)" * ) 8 & 9 ! ) % & *% " 55.6@. ") 0 ") >3.;@ "!"0&"!"

!"8 , )' "8 ! ) % & *% " 5.2 !"8 " ") 0 ") >.3 !"8 &, !", %&'%'&,

! "+" ) &(" ! ) % & *% " " " "8 ;;.;@ " ") 0 ") " " "8 66.=@

) &" % */ & "-"" % & *% " 0 ' !

* ( ))" /"8<" &'% , / &" " %" " % & +)"! ) 0; +" ,)'& 6=.

&, !", % & *% " / &" " %"& * " " "8 >. @. % & *% " %', , ) %" ".

,!"99 *" "( * " ! ) , " " "8 25.;@. " % &, !", ! "+" ) &(" % & *% "

" " "8 ;;.;@ * !"&" ! . ), * ,) " ) +& ( " -,

!"8 $33$ * ( ))" /"8<" &'% , / &" " %" " % & +)"! ) = +" ,)'&

$ .3 , " 8"&"%" 8 % % ) ,"*%" ;3 !"8 " " "8 =.5@. % &, !",

(30)

$2

!" %" "), , 9", !", ) , 8"!" 5.5 @. " % ) /"<"8 6 !"8 ) &" + *")"

" " "8 =.>@

& ","&)" )"/ %"! . "/ %"! *" * *%"! & !" ) 023 ! )

) */" + " " , " +" " +)" 8"&"%" 8 % * 1"%" 5$.= !"8 .

" +)" * ) "),"&" '&" + <"," 44.= @ " &"!"0&"!" <")! , )' "8 " " "8 >.5

!"8 "/ %"! " ! * *%"! & !" ) 0>; +" " +)" 8"&"%" 8 %

* 1"%" 53.; !"8 . " +)" * ) "),"&" '&" + <"," 42.; @ " &"!"0&"!" <")!

, )' "8 " " "8 5.= !"8 "/ %"! ' %&'+' * *%"! & !" ) 05=. *" "

" +)" 8"&"%" 8 % * 1"%" 5$.= !"8 . " +)" * ) "),"&" '&" + <"," 42. @

" &"!"0&"!" <")! , )' "8 " " "8 5.2 !"8 "/ %"! + * *%"!

& !" ) 0 ;3 +" " +)" 8"&"%" 8 % 53.2 !"8 . " +)" * ) "),"&" '&" +

<"," 42.; @ " &"!"0&"!" <")! , )' "8 " " "8 5.2 !"8 '!" '+-")"&!"

* *%"! & !" ) 02 +" " +)" 8"&"%" 8 % * 1"%" 5$.> !"8 . " +)"

* ) "),"&" <"," >;.> @ " &"!"0&"!" <")! , )' "8 " " "8 3.5 !"8

"& "!" "!", "%"! 8"! /"8<" '!" '+-")"&!" * *%"! %', , -" +

/ 8 /" ) /" +)" +" " -" &'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!"

+" * *%"! % & +)"! ) 02 ", ' " " "* ) */" + " " , ".

, , ) * " "/ %"! *" . "/ %"! ' %&'+'. "/ %"! " ! "

"/ %"! +

(,('. ,$).$' )14% %

" , , )"&")! & ,! ) & ,%' " "* % ! " * % ! # ,!"! , % ) &("" .

( , ) "* . " ! +)"! % )" , &!" ,!& / , & ,%' / & ","&)"

)"/ % ! "!" )'!" +)"! % )" )"! +'& )" * (" *%"! -" !

% )" . . . . % '*" $ " 2 . "8", ,<". "

% )" $ "/ )"&")! & ,! ) & %' / & ","&)" ,!"! , % ) &("" ! ( ))"

(31)

$;

"/ ; "&")! & ,! ) ,%' & ","&)" , ) &(""

4 ! %$) ' ,3((% !*+ (

+"<" + & % $6

$ !" ;

2 <",!" 24

; & 23

6 , " 2

2

"& "!" "!", ! & 8"! /"8<" "& ,"*% -" + "*/ , /" -") 33 '&" +.

) !"8 /"8<" , /"+ " / ,"& % + ' " / &,!"! , % ) &("" ,<",!". + & "

% +"<" + & , % . , " +)" /"+ " ) 1 -" " " "8 % !" " % , "

& ) ! -" " " "8 "!" & ,%' / & ","&)" ( , ) "* ,"( )" " "* !"/ ; $

"/ ; $ "&")! & ,! ) ,%' & ","&)" , "*

4 ! %$) (+$% !*+ (

") 0 ") 62

$ & *% " ;5

2 %

"&")! & ,! ) & %' / & ","&)" ( , ) "* -" + (" )" , /"+"

,"*% % ! " * ( ))" " +)" -" + 8"*% & ,"*" -" ! ") 0 ") 62 '&" + 62

@ " % & *% " ;5 '&" + "!" ;5 @ & ) ! -" "!" & ,%' / & ","&)"

! +)"! % )" ,"( )" " "* !"/ ; 2

"/ ; 2 "&")! & ,! ) ,%' & ","&)" +)"! )"

4 $%&'(. % $ $'(% !*+ (

2

$ =

2 ;

; 6

6 $ >

= 2 4

5 "8", ,<"

4 ;>

> $ 6

(32)

$6

* "8 & ,%' % + ' " +" ! +)"! % )" / &( * "8 ;>

!"*/"8 / &,!"! , *"8", ,<" , 8 ++" / &( * "8 63 '&" + 63 @ / 8 /" -") "&

-" + " ,%' +" ! +)"! % )" / &( * "8 $6 '&" + $6@ .

+" % )" % '*" $ " 2 / &( * "8 5 '&" + 5@ . % + ' " +"

! +)"! % )" $ / &(* "8 6 '&" + 6@ " / &( * "8 2 '&" + 2@ )"

8"! "& ! +)"! % )" . , 8"& , -" ) *"*% " ") * , % + ' "

"%"! )"!")" /" ) " , /"+ " / ,"& , "8 * * 8 % &,-"&"!" , /"+"

% + ' " )" ! !"% ( )" )" !)" +" )'*% ! , , /"+" % + ' " / * / ,"

%",! )" . * + +"! ) / &"+"*" "!"& / ")" + %&'+&"* ,! "!" ( & ," '

( & ," % )" "& , )' "8 -" + * & )" % &' 8

& ) ! -" " " "8 ,!& / , & ,%' / & ","&)" < "-"8 "/ %"! 7 '!"

&'% , " &"8 ,! * <" '+-")"&!" ,"( )" " "* !"/ ; ; , /"+" / & ) !#

"/ ; ; ,!& / , ,%' & ","&)" "/ %"! 7 '!"

4 ! %$) ' ,3((% !*+ (

*" $6

$ " ! =

2 ' %&'+' $5

; + $5

6 '!" '+-")"&!" 6

2 %

"& !"/ "!", "%"! 8"! & ,%' "& , ! "% )"/ %"! 7)'!" ) 1 "

"/ %"! " ! = '&" + " '!" '+-")"&!" 6 '&" + * * ) ( * "8 -" + 8"*% &

,"*" -" ! $6 " $5 '&" +

5 3$ #( $ $.() (% 3$ $(0$ $.()

( ?" !", " & "/ !", ") )" +" * ") )" ( 1'/" ,!& *

! &8" "% 23 '&" + & ,%' % + ' " 1"*"!" ! " "/ %"!

"+ " + "<" +"8

( ?" !", -" ! % + ( " &8" "% ) " !", ! *0 ! * ( ?" !", ") )"

+" 1"&" * +)'& ", )" " !"&" ,)'& ! "% / ! & J +" ,)'& !'!" -" +

(33)

$=

*'* ! -"&"! * * * ! ) " ++"% ?" "%"/ " & K 3.2= + -' '. $334

"& 8", " " , , * " % &8 ! +" 6 9'& < '<,. ) !"8 "& =; ! *

) , ' &. -" + * * 8 ,-"&"! ?" !", / &( * "8 6; ! * , " +)" 3 " -"

! ") ?" " & ), "% ! * -" + & ), " !"&" " # ! * '* & 6. >. 3.

22. 2;. ;6. ;5. ;4. ;>. " =2

,!& * -" + & "/ " " "8 ,!& * ! &, / ! 1 ) % /" ) , 8 +" *"*%

* + +)"% "!" -" + / ," % &1"-" ,!& * -" + & "/ ")" "%"!

* +8", )" "!" -" + "%"! % &1"-" ( +" "/ !", ! !"%)" +" * 8"!

" %8" B&' /"18 "! % + ) &" " ++"% & "/ ( )" " %8" K 3.6 ",

%8" B&' /"18 %" " "/ ; 6

"/ ; 6 ", ( "/ !",

Cronbach's Alpha Cronbach's Alpha Based on

Standardized Items N of Items

Keterangan

,961 ,962 54 Reliabel

Sumber; data penelitian diolah

6 ()$ 7( *()$ 4+1 . %)$

?" ", ") )" ! &8" "% )'*% ! , % + ' " -" + ! & & "&

*"%! )'*% ! , !"*" -" ! # )'*% ! , % &,' " ,', " . $ )'*% ! , ! ) ,.

2 )'*% ! , ")" * , " ; )'*% ! , % + */" +" / "-"

( ()$ 7( *()$ 4+1 . %)$ ,)4%( 4)$(

'*% ! , &,' " ', " % + ' " ! & & "& / / &"%" )'*% ! ,

","& -" + 8"& , * ) ' 8 % + ' " -" ! # * * ) " 0 " 8 %. $

",% ) , )"% ! &8" "% ) '*%') ,","&" . 2 ",% ) )'* )", % &,' " . ; ",% )

8 / +" 7 ) &(" ,"*"7 ,', " & ! & " ?" ", * ++ ")" 4 "%" ) ", 9 )",

! & & "& # " +"! " ) )" . " ) )" . " ) . / 8 "& B ) % B .

B ) % B . &" + . &" + )" . " " +"! &" + )" ! "%

)'*%' )'*% ! , * * ) )& ! & " -" + / &/ "0/ " , , " +" "!" *%& ,

-" + % &' 8 "& "%" +" & ) ! " " "8 8", " " , , ?" ", )'*% ! ,

(34)

(35)