ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL
Associate Editor's Report
Article No. : 537
Title of Paper : High Temperature Oxidation Behaviour of Fe-Cr Steel in Air at 1000-1200K
Comment on Descriptions
Criteria Evaluation
Associate editor's evaluation
Yes No Comments
1. Originality of the article
Free of Plagiarism/Similarity (max20%) v
New article/not yet Published (presented/ in proceeding max 30%)v 2. Related to nuclear/atomic science
and technology v
3. References
The number of references at least 10, at most 20 for nonreview papers; at least 26 for review papers.v
The use of recent references 80 %(maximum 5 years ago) x
Only 9 of 13 references (69 %) are from 2011 or later. Please add recent references/reduce less recent ones.
Type of the references (primarily,secondary etc.) 85 % from journals v
DOI reference (traceable) xPlease add DOIs to make the references more traceable. For instance, for [2] (Nikrooz, Zandrahimi and Ebrahimifar), it would be http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10971-012-2786-7 .
Reference style standard: Elseviernumeric without title v
Please use commonly accepted abbreviations for publication names. For instance, “International Journal of Hydrogen Energy” may become “Int J Hydrogen Energ”. Some examples are in https://www.elsevier.com/__data/promis_misc/B MCL_Abbreviations.pdf and
https://images.webofknowledge.com/WOKRS520 B4.1/help/WOS/A_abrvjt.html .
When reference has more than 3Authors, write only 3 names, et al. x
For Ref. [4], four authors are named. It should be changed to name just the first three: should only be given as: T. Hosono, C.C. Su, R. Delinom, et al., instead of the first four.
Article follows the Atom Indonesiatemplate and guidelines x
Nominally, the article appears to follow the templates. However, it is unorthodox in its use of frames and its composition of figures from smaller elements (superimposing bitmaps and texts in unusual ways, etc.) that potentially makes it difficult to format the paper for publication.
Table (clear, without vertical line) v Not applicable, as there are no tables here.
Figure (clear, min 300 dpi) xIt appears that none of the figures reaches 300 dpi (for example, Fig. 2a, size 0.94” × 0.92”, and resolution 108 × 105 px, thus its pixel density = resolution / size = 115 × 114 dpi). Please use higher-resolution images.
Final recommendation:
1. Continue review process [ ] 2. Return to the Author [ v ] 3. Reject [ ]
Comments:
The article should be returned to the authors to allow for the necessary improvements to be made.
