) :
31 / 5 / 1388 - :
26 / 8 / 1388 (
:
" #$% & ' ( ' )$ * + ,- . /"0 % 1 - .
1 $ 2 $34 )$,5 )$ %
* ' 2 67 *8 ' 9: . 2 , .
.
$: ) <$" - 4 ) "
$= >
.
? 4 + &0 ' @ AB =:
& $ ' C : D E: A F : ) ,. & G H / ,H
* 2 " I .
.
? 4 : JE ' G H / ' @ )H =:
,H KH 2 '
&
'
: A' L M: ' 2 5
4 ) I
) 5 ' 2 & ) ?" N *3 => )E
L" 3 )4 " 4 I I 2 ' @ 1 2 O: & 0 "PQ 67 ' 3:
R" 5
& * 5 ' 2 & ) ?" 4 " . .
=: )4 5 4 ' <. ?" ' A' @ C 5 S:
A' F &0
2 $ 5 $: Q AB 8 & 4 )4 1 2 - . & - 5
* Q C 5 G H / + 5 ' 2 ' /"0 % ?"
.
IG :
2 5 : Q 1 G H / + 1 &0 A' @ 1 - . .
: 2294355 - Email: [email protected] 0711
! " #$% &' ( )* ! + ,! * + "*- " (*. / (- 0 "1. / '2 & 34! (5
($67 ) ! + 8 ! ! 9 :3.! ;$ < / &= > < (- "<?- !'% "$< '$>
&
' 2 / ( @0
! ,A ,!B*$ CD *. / & 34! '2 ( ($E!(
. G(*H
& *I% * &' *. ! (*5%
% !(E J4!/ & 0K E' / &= > <
"*% $-'- * / "*% $- L *M N"
*$OK! P *M "*
9 /(* ! N *.! Q M RS- 8 ! "?H T ! 0%A "- 83M! (U / ! V/ &= > < ! 9 :3.!
! W*< ; = > < XY I (- ,A ($67 / 34! 9 T 9Z / "- / @+! [ "- ,'2 W% 0V X D / & 34! '1- ! @K " .! W + \ 8$-
, % * W4 *]T (*5 ! @K / )?O>!
! !(4 "V
) NW*4^M!
1383 N P 11
/ ! - 34! / ! A X D 9 /( ! (.
» ,'*2 W% *0V '* A(
,A
« 8$- X D / 34! > a " (5% X H "- N N *.! "*3 (E !(*4 L( b*U W??O>!
. ; ">B "- " &' A(
/
& 34!
-
?c W4 ]T
"%! ! A "> I 0V ( bU %B (E / d
2 e'I X 'M / XY S f % "OK '
e *T *K *$ $+ / K $ Kg "OK ,A (U / 9
J ! V $14 & . , #< N K ( ,' % @K - / N' 3#K ,/B ! / e S / W% E(E 3T! X!([ h (-!(- $% i'+ / ,A J ! &' 9(0- j?3h ! ,A ! W*2 % W> *O
2! 'K! M WU .
3#*V 8* ! N&(k- ,'O / WE'% (- &= > < '$: 6A / ' ! "- 83M! (U ! l & *K 9 *T &= *> < & K ! - f! %! / &($E )<2 RS- "- 83M! (U 8O\ @ 'H
34! ,'2 W% 0V ' A( $OK! / m I ! "- NW% 0V / W? j?3h (*- & D & . ! A /
X /(*\ "*- N V $1\/ "1> c 8O\ / "3M! (U &= > < e ]3%! & K ! !(4 / X D 8$*- X *D n *]T / X *D *- W*? & *34! n ]T / 34! 8$- '% $U WK *o% W*??O>!
@ !'% $- . 5 "- D ! 9 U & 34! (5 ! f \ (30- @0
&'*$? , E=!/ &!
"*- ! pI (*
3M!
j (1 W
@$
:
- .
Globalization)
:(
L(3#*E (*$M! "*K / @* *. "* q^c*H! 8* !
*.! "*3 ,/B ! /
1N
*-
*: (1 ! * K N,A *$OK! / Q!/ @a(
W J% * / J *V N8*2/
82/ ,A r$4 i 0: "<%A & V "- B$% , bE - / #$% ! M(- 2
(- N O*2 "c$T / e
W (3k$- WE (3#E / 9'2 9 /B ! ,A " ! '*-
. ! &'*%/ 8Os*3 i *0: 8* ! *]$]T
1 .
% &!(- ,'2 W% 0V q^cH!
8$3#h - - .
"?$
# /(U Theodore Levitt e *.
1983 ] ,! * + *S &! "*>
»
! - / ,'2 W% 0V «
'2 9 :3.! !/ K 9 ok%! W% E - "?D .
. t .
"- : http//www.ifla.org/iv/ifla73/index.htm
.! 34! / . $. & K ( ! I+ / W% E(E u
& [ "-
;I. W3T / v K( / @?+ "
W (- ! (k- WE'%
($E . W ! ,'2 W% 0V / 8 ! ! 9' 'U ,!
" #%! &'1- ' w &!
e <2! "- N&= > < NW 5% NW4 ]T NW. $. N& 34! NW+ O3V! j?3h
/ #* p$*S
...
W &(#
'-
) NW% ! W> O 1383
N P 109
.(
W d #S W1$I[ &' A( " .! 8 ! ,'2 W% 0V x M ! &/ * (6! " 2
X +^[!
) Information Technology
/ WE (k V N;$%/(3<>! X [ I ! /(
/ , *0V @ !(
W 0% #%! , $ W1OV WK EA M 2
. N * ! 9'* A(- &(* ! ,'2 W% 0V y .! 8 ! (-
"* *.! &(k*- WE'*% j*?3h & K "H(+ "I% V "OK / 9 (3#E & (E!( / ! "k 3$14!/ / 9' % ! W? & K ( W
.! 8 < e T .
2 - .
) Economic Globalization
:(
W< ,! + "- 34! ,'2 W% 0V J4!/
9' 'U N,'2 W% 0V & K 9 T ! 3M *. / *$K )$?S " .! ' 'V / @0 $#- &!
8$- / W. $. / & 34! @5%
W !(4 9 :3.! , 0V & K k W??O>!
($E . 8 (* WSc.
34! 'T!/ ; "- " .! 8 ! 34! ,'2 W% 0V )<2 pI (* , *0V (*.!(. "- k &
2
) NW% c?.
1382 N P 22
W* 1 "*- W*? *[ "- 34! ,'2 W% 0V (.
» / "*H(+ 83* 8$*- !
W? & K 34! WD ' i! ! ! .! X I+ ,A - WEZ / / .! W? & 34! & K ( 8$- 34!
b*E " (*. / X '*M / *KY X *D @*DT L(3#E r ([ ! )?O>!
& !
& *K
8$- W??O>!
. 8$- 34! "H(+ p !(2 8 ! ,!'*$ "*<?- N #*$% K k* 9 I " SH N)?O>!
W $4 (K " .! &! "]- # '2 - ,A 9'%(- 'K! M
«
) N,! V 1381 N P 241
.(
&0 A' @
Free Trade)
:(
X *D *>/ "*?M!' i'*+ *. $. & 1 "- i 0: 8 !
8$- .! W??O>!
. 8$- @$#] & I (- X D NL/ 8 ! > 4
* B "* (5% / * W*??O>!
W X H WI#%
($E .
W I. L/ 8 !
W% *0V zc*. J- * "* $0- x$ *h "* 2
2 ({ !'T ' A / "3 (E X H .
:E ' - "OK 8 ! - -
8* ! ;* | & *4 "%! 3k*U @a(
%! ! A }^ X D " .! '$1- Ni 0:
*03>/ "* !(*w (*$E X *H & k* "?$./ "- "
.! 8<O
> M W D X 5T^ ! ($a W??+ "- X D ( ! f * &!(*- }^{* u'*
W+ O3V! ) Y "- W?
.
(
! "
# -
% &' ! () *) +
- N)]% / )OT & K 9 T ; = > < / WO?+ XY S (U i/ W% 0V v V ! '1 i *5% N, E *% E X '*M "*\(+ / XY *S f! *%! '$> & K' !( / X +^[! NX [ I !
> <2! '2 r & ! " (.
W
*D ! W% *0V *34! ! x *h / * @$#*] ! 8 %
'
) N % & K 1379
N P 1
» (.
.! d ?c "% N"w ~< , 0V 8 ! WE' #- M / W < ! M
/'] "% /
«
, OK N P 3
u(
(*- '* - N9' A & ! " (. i 5% W. (- $OK! <%! ,/'- /( ! !
& *34! X I*. (*$$• N,!( ! ' % "3 "1. (3O & K k &!(- " - 9'$]+ 8 ! WO% W% 0V y $]
K '%!
W?*H! "?|#* "<?- '2 - X' 9 W 3 . / ; B% W '
*.! W31 *H "1 V "- W3 . "1 V ! B$ A $] !bE NW K k 8$ w .
e *S 8* !
& 3M . N
*$OK! e *S 8* ! r* 1 * J (# / .! "V M W? & 03>/ C]%
! &'$?
. (- & !bo3. $. @0 )€ # "?OV ! X I*. r$# / @$5 N !bE 8 ! r]S &!
.! W% 0V 34! p !(2 / 0 /(\ - . 3 d ?c W4 ]T & K(3#- / W? & 34!
.
K - ! ,'2 W h '%']31 ! A X D ,! !' ([
W '*$> ) ! + &!(- ! (3k$-
2! 'K! M WU .
X! (] / 8$%! 4 J\/ &!(- j?3h & K k i!'4!
@K!(* / *S%!'\
W X H d w w 8 ! - 4 , < ! " $ , ( ($E
.
"* S ! )$<k*
/ W* (OE & *K
"]c
& 34! j?3h & 0% . / &!
- 8$- W4 ]T
! A X *D L(3#*E *0V W??O>!
"K " .! W !'4! (o ! NW% 0V W* e *I% &'*V [ "- ($M! & K
*2 .
"*$V
I 8$- X D & K & | NRS- &(5% W%
)*$> "*- X *D ! )*H T J * (- } . .! )?O>!
" BK X/ : '*% ! '*$ 7 j*?3h & K k* , $ WI#% & K B / '$> & K
. (*- * -
X '*M / *K Y ! M . 'K! M 4 ! K k NX D / x h N V X $\(
(3k$- -
; - "# ]
: M @3#$.
- 9 :3.!
X 0 / x h " Wc !(2 , w '
& 34! 9 C !B ! "- Y ,A X D / '$> N .! (3k$- WH M &Y '$> &/($%
(D '2 'K! M .
W* x h W KY '$> K k J4!/
*- ! ,A '* %! 3- "* '* -
'$> ( 8$ U & K " BK '
)
% r?c • B " (5 .(
'$> W< k / , $ ! "‚% w !
!(* '*2 ' K! M J:3 X D ! , ‚OK k / (K N'2 - ( ! &(o "- I#% W Y W* k* (K !b> / ! V/ WI#% W ! X/ : K / '*$> x *h *- '*%!
3 N .! ( ! ,A " W Y X! H 2 J:
) WI#% B " (5%
1 ( .
*2 (o k (- k ; WI#% B / n• : R+ - .! 8<O " @0 ) ! + ! N
! ! ! k ; & ! M(- / ; = > < zc. X/ : W
(* "3 (k*$U / (3k*$- &(*< & K
! W*M(- NW* C*%! * / X *+!(3M! ,!B$ / zc. , - ( Y - )$> "- "<% w u .!
'*$>
1 . .
.
Stewart Frances (1981). Technology and undevelopment , second edition , London , Mac Milan press LTD. P.157.
- / 2! ' K! M WI#% B 8 ( . (- X 'M , E' "\(+ XY S , E' c>
JI
W . &(3k$- J "- &= > < X D r ([ ! -B & K k k ' -
.
&= > < e ]3%!
) Transfer of Technology
8Os*3 "* *.! W *0: N(*\ T RS- (
& ! !(4 G([ / sT "*> I "*- W4 *]T *> 4 "* .! W I$ ( (- )O3k )- ]
/ ' D%! W &= > <
*.! & D / & ! !(4 "V/ &! ! .
&= *> < "*- W- $3*. 8<$*>
) Access To Technology
y(3. ! &= > < " .! W K 9 $2 9 :3.! rT & 1 "- (
W4 ]T W]$]T P h2! ! @+! Ni O+
&= *> < ! & ! (*- 9(0- ! 0%A / 'K W !(4
W 8<O3 $%
. .
! A L (*E / k*3%! & * 1 "*- *.! 8*<O 83*2! W*.(3.
& *D / & ! !(*4 *> 4 } /(\ "< A ,/'- '2 - ; = > < , / i ?+ / X +^[!
'D o- . .! W4 ]T "?OV ! &= > < "- 832! W.(3.
&g ,A K k / )? i O "
W / 9 - rT 9 :3*.! &(k*- 8 *$ - n *]T / t(3k* ƒ!($ ,! + "- ,A ! ' %!
u'*
WO% W h2 k „$K " W6!($
,A "*- I#% & S%! $3 ! / rT ' + ! '%!
! /
W 9 :3.! M J &!(- p] ,A ! '%!
( 9 / P h*2! (*o / ,A '* ! ! ! *0K/(E
i/(S ' . e H! " #$% i 0: ,!'- &= > < "- W.(3. & ! A " 2! "V ' - !
% ! A X D / & 34! & . ! A (- @ T 2 "32 o%! 9'
.
! A W- $3*. N8h*. (o "-
W O 3h & K k* , *$ r*T 8* ! (- &/ # / &= > < ! )? / i! 4!
?*H! Nj*?
W
8$- zc. W4 ]T 9'2 "3 ( bU 8Os*3 e *HY! W*?+ &= *> < e *]3%! * ! N .! W??O>!
"+ OD
& ! !(4 X I$ ( ! &!
- W4 *]T / & ! !(*4 9Z* / X € s*34! ! "* *.! & D
W $1I
' . L^
% / J D & K 0
j?3h & K 8$-
' % W??O>!
» W31 *H "1. , $#$O
S3 )?
'
)«
UNIDO
/(
» 'S3 )? "1. / X D , $#$O
)«
UNCTAD
/(
» W% *0V , .
&(**< **$<>
) «
WIPO
< ! A , ** (V ! ** OT & 3**.! N(
**>
i **O W**.(3. / &=
Y *- &= *> < ,! * &! ! NW* a / (*$] N… B- / ;w ! @+! K k
* "*- N,A ,/'*-
.! , ' &= > <
u 3. & ! A !(
W* & k (K &!(- N&= > < "- W- $ 8$Os* '*%!
O0*. 9' W
;* = > < & 03 (k*$U ! &/ #* / (*-!(- 5%
/ W*. $. NW+ *O3V! & *0
'2 - & 34!
) Kasto , 1993: P.125 (
.
8$*- zc. V ; = > < & 0 '+ # / & <OK W*??O>!
*
# )$0 "*- W*.(3.
† ' 'V / & /( ! &= > <
.! (6 .
"- &= > < ! A , (V "w (E! " .! W> T 8 !
*- &= *> < "*- W*.(3. & ! A , *$ @*K * K 8<$> N .! &= > < "- W.(3. & 1 & ! A 9' /'S ) ! + ( . / 8$%! 4 J\/ ! 1% O GbT "3 ( bU i D%! & 02^
! V/ & } 3I#% "?H N -B
) ibid:P.126
.(
-
"
8h. (o -
)* O "* $14!/ 8 ! @a(
8$- " SH V &= *> < , * (V & ! A ! , $O[! e T , K! M G([ ; ! W??O>!
W* j$1s ! & ! A 8 ! " '% ! V/ & J%! (o G([ ! N .!
W*.(3. / '*
)*O+ "- &($E ?V ,A ! / /'S ! &= > < "- , .A W*
'*% /A . ! } * O+ "* W1%! *
&(*< & *03$<> n ]T V -
! *V W% % *4 8 ! * * (U / ' 3#*K ;* = > <
8$- OT
)* ! + ! *M } *1c4 N *0%A " . ; 832 o%! 9' % / '% ! M(- W? / W??O>!
9'% ! - (*2 "* *- '*K! M ,A "*%! ! A X D / &= > < ! A , (V
8* ! p#*- / q
> D f \ W
'I?[ W ! (o .
, -
- .) /.0 * 1 23 4 5 ' 6
L(3#E e T +(. "- ! A X D / 34! ,'2 W% 0V '%/ " .! $14!/ ; .!
. W*: / I{ j?3h & K' $U / 6A - i‡ &' A( 8$ w " .! W1$I[
9 *T
- 'K! M W4 ]T / & 34!
.
& K k* 8$*- W% *0V X *D 9'O+ 9 /( ! " W> T
W i D%! W% 0V X D , . 9 ! % M s+
*. @K N 2 ( b*U % *<%! N'* A( 8* ! *- W
W ' O%
. 2! &= > < e ]3%! 9 T & 34! W !(E , 0V 6A WM(- "- " ! ! @$K! M 9
( :
1 -
*0 8 ' 6
*.! "3 C !B ! "1. e T & K k &= > < "- $% " .! 8 ! @ˆ?# '4 / J[ *4 *$OK! "*- *-B & K k ({ ! NW% 0V W> / & 34! XY 1 !'%! @kw /
8$- X D &( bU - 4 $?- 4 &!(- &= > < 9' !B W??O>!
9 (- WU '*%!
. 3*.! 8* !
B$% W 02^
- .
"?$
*- *M ;* = > < G <*2 / "?*H CK * &!(*- n * & K k*
&= > < "- W- $3. / "3 "1. (3k$- & K k
*.! "*3 (E X H $% & K .
* !
L^ A " .! 8 ! e! |.
ƒ T X!($$• "- "V - -B & K 9'2
< 9 T / &= >
W N&= > < , IT H 3 ‰ 2 W- ! I{ / . '%!
& *34! e *1 J ! V % V ! 9'2 d #T / . i!'4! ,/'- -
8$*- W4 *]T NW*??O>!
, E ! / 'S3 )? , . 9Z - 3 (k*$U " .! '$1- N,A "- "3#-!/ & 34! / W4 ]T & K
W
, ( (U ($oOkw / "5T^ )- 4 ' A . "- V G <2
. L^
"*3 (E X *H & *K
- .
"?$
"K 'S3 )? , . X D / "1. , $#$O 1970
8 /'* *0V & ^$
"+ OD
! A "*> I / L (*E )$0#* G'*K *- &= *> < e *]3%! "*- m -( X! (] ! &!
L^ "?OV ! N&= > <
9'2 i D%! & K -
.
"?$
D "H(+ XY 1 8$- X
&= *> < W??O>!
) .!
Skelton , 1981 : P.381
.(
2^ 3.! 8 ! 0
S% "- W% 0V X D , . & . ! 9'2 i D%! &
&
e *]3%! (6
9'*2 J*4!/ (E * "*3 "1. (3O & K k "- "3 "1. (3k$- & K k ! &= > <
.!
. W " "% o% OK ([ ! , . 8 ! @$%!
& s* *D ! j*?3h & K " % ] ! r
8$- X D " W s+! &!(- & D ! A W C]% & : ! N' 3#K ($E )?O>!
'*
.
*] !
&(< $<> n ]T & D & K "I V " %
) TRIPS
! (] &/ T (
W
* OT d *- P M
W &(< $<> n ]T ! W I. " '2 -
2 e 1 & 03 (2
"1*. (*3O & K k
*- ' *2 - *4 N& *<OK X I$ ( ( . / t(3k & !bE " (. & K ! !(4 ]1%! - "3 @K!(* *M & K k* "*- ! &= > < e ]3%! )$0# " $ N& D p !(2 )$0# "- +
'% /A . W* I*. &(< & 03$<> n ]T ! (3k$- "w (K OT
*2 WV *M & (*2
"1*. (*3O & K k "1. / r$]S (3k$- '01 83 ( bU / t(3k & !bE " (.
r k / $a( N, -B$ / "3 2
'%
. W W?M! & (2 " .! ' A( 8 ! ! '1- @*K ' %!
>/! (- @K / ; = > < X ]$]S &! 3S (- '% !bo- ($67 ,A & K
) X!( !b* , *. 2 9/(E
N& D 1381 N P 102
.(
W 8 !(- - eY'3.! "% E 8 ! ,!
(
&(< $<> n ]T ! OT "
,A
" % ] ! "<% w
»
~ ( «
*6A * 0% N *.! 9'2 W $- C$U
&
'*2 (*- *I{
2!bE 'K! M W4 - "1. e T & K k W+!(3M! & K' A(
. X'* 9 * "w(E
H .! 8<O Ch- ! W1
K
! !/ 8$1 W 0- '
3k$- W (
*- &!(-
"
r*T , /A *.
'% ! (~- 9'2 I6 & K &= > < f!(3M!
.
»
~ ( &! 2
) «
TRIPs Council
W* X *5% / e(*3 ! "* % ] ! &!(V! " (
* N'
W '013 ! "3 "1. & K k
*- … B*- & 03 (*2 ! i Y & K 9B$o%! '
*5 "
*D ! Wo3 * "1*. "*V 8 (*3O - & K k "- &= > < e ]3%! r k / Š ] ! '*
.
,! * + "*- ,A ! } O*. "* X +^[! & / " % ] ! NX +^[! & / " $ 8$ ‚OK
» X **+^[! & / ** XY **S X **D P **M ,!(** / "**$ ^+!
) «
Minesterial
Declaration on Trade in Information Technology Products. W (
J*%! )*$?] *- *2
&= > < e ]3%! )$0# " $ NX +^[! & / XY S X! H / X! !/
) y(3. -
XY S 8 ! , ! !(4 (
.! 9 ( @K!( ! "1. e T & K k "-
) , OK N P 103 (.
W B$% X 'M 9 T
! ( *. (- &= > < ($67 X! ! "- X D & . ! A :E ,
$> 1 W N& 34! & K /A @K!(* ! X 'M X D )$0# X IV '%!
. '* ( ,/'*-
X '*M NW3*2!'0- X '*M NX *[ I ! N)*]% / )*OT X '*M *V/ ,/'- & 34! „$K
W2 A N / W> X 'M WO% 9($a
' $> 1 '%!
.
! / W% *0V X *D , *. " % ]
X! (] } H M
» X '*M X D P M W O+ " % ] !
) «
GATS
"*- (‹ *% "* (
& *. ! A L(3#*E &!(*- ! i Y & s 8 ( '13# / 8 ( ( bU , < ! N' 2 - W> X 'M .! 9 ( "€! ! X 'M
) N&(4 - 1385 N P 71
X! (*] / *V '13#* & s .! W0 '- (.
*
W @K!( W 'M . & K &= > < e ]3%! )$0# &!(- ! " $ N9'2 /A
.
G!'K! "5T^ - -B
" ']
» W*? "* % r !
«1
/
»
*.† "* % r* !
«2
, *.
j*?3h & K k i ( WE'% 9 / "1. / I0- ! X I+ W? c- " W% 0V X D W
"D$3% 8 ! "- N'2 - W
! A X *D * X *D & *. ! A - 9'2 G!'K! " @$.
- 'K! M r]S "- / , 0V zc.
.
* g J*. / i + )H! ". $O T 5 8 ! r]S (
.! "3 (E !(4 L( bU N K k WV M / W?M! X D (-
) N hI<$%
1382 N P 80
:(
1 -
»
& •>! )H!
W O
& *D & 0s$1I
«
"* N
*3 )*H! '* % W> *H! (*- )O3k*
W?
) WV *M / W?M! X 'M X!'$> - 3 Œ$1I i'+
(
! *>! "*? e/ )*H! N
)
" % ] ! s+ / 'K 13 j?3h & K k - 3 Œ$1I i'+
(
"*%! & *c+! J* N
/ ...
! . .
2 -
» X D , (V 03 /'S J )H!
« i!B>! (U "
?*. / K " (1 CK "-
k "- KY / / &!(- 'T ! C$- W (OE • ! + / X $> J\/ J 0%A C !B ! rT / ...
W (E 9 ?V 2
.
3 -
»
$%Š . ,/'- / @> . - 4 )H!
« X! *$3 ! Š c+! J )$I4 ! W !'4! (U "
"V ($a )
"%!
( C !B ! &!(- W?M! XY S "- / WV *M XY *S *- *- 4 X '4
W <*2 ! - *5 "*- 9Z *- W?*H! *O$4 ( "- (o k X 'M Y L/( J k ,A W?M! XY S )
v $~ ! $+ O
( / ...
W ?I3
2 .
8 !(- - N W4 *]T e *H! ! *$1I X /(\ "- (5%
- / ! A X *D (*- @ *T & *34!
W% 0V N [ "- j*?3h P h*2! / K k N&= > < e ]3%! ' A( Jc4 )
e *]3%! ! @*+!
&= > < , E'%($E e ]3%! / , E' K (
9 U + "- ( BE % C$*U ! / xhk* X * 5% &!
8$- 9'2 j (1 "*H(+ s*T / *$> 1 3M . - 0%A "- "V i'+ " ' 2 - W W??O>!
1 . X E 3M! "- " .! X D / K " (1 P M W? " % r ! N 5 )
General Agreement on Tarrifs
(and Trade e . ,A WO '4 83 / 2 W 9'$ %
1947 e . / @$5 1994
% ] ! / - 9!(OK / '2 q^H!
"
W 1 (o /GATS
TRIPS W% 0V X D , . (3w S '% ! !(4 WTO
.
2 . W% 0V X D , . $.7 " % r ! N .† " % r ! ! 5 Agreement Establishing The World )
Trade Organization (
e . " .!
1994 b W 0% ' . "O$O\ .! ! / '2 Š s ! C !(
& D X!( !
e . " '2 - W "€ E/ ! / 1995
'2 W% 0V X D , . )$<k "- (D .
A X D / !(E , 0V 34!
,!'$ ! & E , - "- / ! X ! -
*.
"?$
j* (T (*D
'2 'K! M .
2 -
*0 ' 6
9Z *- W4 ]T XY S / 02^ 'K 2 N,'2 W% 0V "H(+ ' 'V & K (< / e I% "- 8$- X D 9 T
@$3#K &= > < W??O>!
. W1*. W4 *]T / & *D N& *34! ,! !BE
4 8 ! W oOK '*% ! &= *> < & *K ! - ,/B* ! / & K $% - W% %
. 8* ! 8 (* 9'*O+
X! (*] q^*H! / W% *0V X *D , . $.7 j?3h !/ ! X!( !b > 4 X !'4!
e . X E 1994
X *D * *E "* % *] ! 8 /' N KY X D
e . X 'M 1995
& K "I V " % ] ! /
"*- i *. &(*< *$<> n *]T & *D
8$*- X D 9 T ƒ T 8 % )€ # ! (673 " .! ?I3 e . , OK ~ ( W*??O>!
.! 9 - ! A X D / 34! ,'2 W% 0V "?OD .
(*- "* '% ! V/ (o 9' '+ 'K! 2
(* "* 0% 0V $% j?3h & K k / NJ D N 0% . L^
/ W4 *]T 9 *o V ,
8 /' 9'2 i D%! X 1> c 0%A 8 ( - ' 2 " ! >Y &= > < e ]3%! W% % 4 1-!
8$- J V , % 4 ; % C$U
&= *> < e *]3%! W??O>!
-
*.
"?$
»
*3<%!
« - , *.
'S3 )? , . "1. / X D -
e . ! ,A 9( !b " '2 - 1970
L^ / f/(2
, % 4 8 /' 0V -B
e . ! 1972 '2 aA } O.
. NX!( !b* NX *1> c N, * ,A !
%!(: / N 03#k%
! " ! ! , O m -( & K u
!(*VY! i Y X! (*] 8 /' "- , W>/
8 ! (D
% k 9'
) .!
UNCTAD Secretariat. 1990, PP:144-146
/ q(2 " (
8* ! p#*-
. / 8 ! /
> D W% % 4 & 0 W
W ! (o 'I?[
.
Y ** X **D d **- '**13 & **K "** % **] ! **]1%!
) X **E '** % OK
)(
GATT
/(
X 'M ) E ' % OK
) (
GATS
&(*< & 03$<> n ]T & D & K "I V N(
)
~ (* '* % OK (
) TRIPS
X ^3M! & 0? / )T /( )
Dispute Settlement Understanding
*. + ! 8* ! 9! *E (
.
" % ] ! W z (k ! D X € {3.! / X D & . ! A e H! -B & K
} O*\ / '*
" (1 CK &!(- K k X!'01 8Os3 , (* *- B$% / & D J%! ( . / W (OE & K
W X 'M & K ! - ' 2 -
.
*$% ! W *K "* / *-B & K " % ] ! ) * / )*T &!(*- B
"3 (E (5% X ^3M!
3 / '%!
&
W (] "1. e T & K k &!(- ! P M / '% !
W j‹ ! 03>/
'% . G :2 ! M & D & 03. $. ' .
9 *EA *- & . G :2 8 !
*€! ! *- 8$* ‚OK / K k* & *V & *K $1 / 8$%! *4 ! W% *0V X D , . 83M . "
@5 & 02 !BE -
.
"?$
*. $. 9 - , . ,A "% M($- X *H K k* & *D & *K
W ($E .
"*- " W% % 4 , 3 N"€ E/ ! / & D "I% V ' w X!( !b Ž 3% > c .(0 e . W% 0V X D , . )$<k 1995
& ^$
(D /'T (- )O3k N'2 60
*] !
N" % .! W !B>! s+! &!(- 0%A ! $1I " .! " % @K : / N@$O N . $U )
& {3*.! "*-
'2 - 9'2 !bE!/ s+! M "- WH M X! (] J\/ " & !
1( .
*.! 9 *- ($oOkw ! - (- @ T X! (] r$# / @$5 9'2 i D%! & 02^ "w(E u
WO% e T 8 ! - X /(\ / &' A ! ,!
'% ) a 8$%! 4 q^H!
.
• *S> "*- , *$ 8* !
q^*H! / , % *4 "*- )*. N ! - &' A % q^H! 9 w 0 NXYY'3.! / X 5T^ WM(- "3#*%! ( (6 * / N(* G c1%! )- 4 N( ' A Nz?H! 8$%! 4 "- W- $3. &!(- 8$%! 4 "I% V "OK .! 9'2
) 8$k$U N&(4 - N
P 73
.(
<%! ,/'- ! (*5% "*- X /(*\ 8 !
W*
)*- 4($a m *I ! '*.
- & D / & 34! )€ # ##E (3#-
W+ *O3V! NW*o K( ! ' % OK N(o j?3h & K N
/ Wh NW. $.
...
"% E "- } (*H ! ! *- &'* A % / X^<k )T 9! ($-' " .! &!
WO%
"> T! ,! !bo% % 4 "- ,!
( . 0‹ - 9Z - /
N ! *- - 4 8 % & K "H(+ C !'$U
N'* 'V & *K ! - C k*E / &= *> < e O*2 , *0V / ($oOkw e S / (k$U ' % OK W (T ( ]+ i'4 ; & !bo% % 4 / , % 4 "? 4 9 ! OK / J[ *4 ($67 ! / 8 ! ! / '
WO% ! - & K >/! (- ; = > < XY S <%! )- 4($a w ,!
'$*2 U @k .
8* ! ;*$>
W 8h. ,A e ]3%! / &= > < (- ! A X D / 34! ,'2 ($o% 0V ($67 ! i ] / @$€ E
<+(- "%
. 8Os3 X D & . ! A / 34! ,'2 W% 0V 9 (3#E / 9'$‚$U ' A( " .! W1$I[
.! , ‡ [ "- W: / I{ W4 ]T 6A .
W (5% "- 8<$>
'.
e *S 8 ! W: 6A /(-
9 U R$T ! 9Z - X '*] ! N K k W? W4 ]T 8 ! / e H! - 0 ( • / 0\ 1 &!
W ' A( 8 ! (U " .! (o I{ G!'K! r]S
*- *0%A ! ,! * "
*- P *M
"
J*:%
#V 9(0- "3 "1. (3O & K k .
2 @K!( 6A 8 ! 8 ( - "?OV ! W4 *]T " $ ,'
'13#
.! &= > < e ]3%! &!(- .
9 * i/ ' - 66
W% *0V X *D , *. "* % *] !
! 8 ! I
W (] m
! :
» 9B$o%! N s+ "3 "1. & K k /(*O?4 J*4!/ X #*. / ,! !BE &!(- ! W K
,!B*$ 8 (*3O &! ! s*+ & K k* "*- &= *> < e ]3%! r k / (Ik$U 5 "- M
1 . 8 ! (3k$- "1> c &!(- .
t .
"- : xH N 8$k$U JI N hI<$% \ '$OT 131
- 67 (:1V'*OS NW (0V &(I 4 /
) 1382 .(
X D W??O>! 8$- & K 0%» :
W% *0V X D , . / X E «
) @:
? $4 2 $ A : $ % 2
$ ,H N
9 O2 28 xH N 242 - 149 8$ ‚OK / .
t .
"- :
Qureshi Asif H. (1999). International Economic Law , London : Sweet & Max well , pp.253-287.
/ i/!'* W< = *> < & * I '* %! 3- *-B & K k* ( ' K! M D ! NWo3 "1.
' D ! ! W3.
«.
! 7 / 8
~ ( " % ] !
$<> n ]T ! OT i/B>(- 9/^+
'*$ 7 & / * e *]3%! )$0#* / K k* "1*. X /(*\ (*- N&(*< *6A , IT H &(<
! . 9 Nn ! (- 9/^+ ~ ( " % ] ! 67
W (]
"1*. & K k* "* '*
( 8$ U " W K k "1. e T & K k & \ ] m(2 "- "3 "1*. zc. 8
W !(4 G([ / r ! " W I$ ( / ' 3#K Wo3 W* & *<OK i D%! "- '013 N ($E
/ W K k 8 ! &!(- W>
' 2 - .
*] ! ! &!(V! )$0# N9'2 & 0 <OK ! G'K
*.! )*? "*OK WE'% 9 / "1. W 1 W% 0V X D , . W? G!'K! r]S / " % .
& <OK X I+ 9 8 ! Q ' W & K
!
! .
:
"* W ! (] / 8$%! 4 "$0 ;O
J*\/ *0%A ! 9 :3*.!Š . ! &($E *?V * / n *]T 8 ! &!(V! / &(< $<> ! OT W '% 2 . 8$OK )*$M W*?M! & 0% *. / ( ] $.7 ! OT ) 2 [
! W !( ! L A ' % OK 9 T 8 '2 -
. (I *. " t(3k " % ] ! W[ 0 ! (- 9/^+
1995 W% 0V X D , . 8$-
) WTO
&(< $<> W% 0V , . /( )
WIPO
N'*2 ']1 (
9 * A ;*O ) *2 N .! 9'2 "3 (E (5% K k &!(- " 9'2 ( g W & 0<O f % N8$%! 4 83 83M . / &(*< *$<> & *K @3#*$. & *. % / i Y & *K 0% D ! L A
.! "[ -( 8$%! 4 &!(V!
. / ! W< s+ & k " #$% ,A "- m/(k 0<O 8 ! "€! !
'2 - / (K , . .
& *<OK X /(*\ (*- 9'*2 * W4 *]T *.! *: '$ 7 V/ -
3%! & 3.! "3 "1. (3k$- & K k / XY *S N(*o & K k* "*- &= *> < e *]
C> w 8 ! V & K '1-
.! 9'k% j4 3 K .
9 /( ! -
"*K ; ! C$- 2bE @a(
"I V N" % ] ! , ! G^3*M! m ]% N&(< $<> n ]T X D - pI ( & K
T & K k "1. "- $% ! W2 % } O+ " V B$o%!(-
% G([(- N .! "1. e k
9'
/ "*3 "1*. & K k* 8$*- j> *h "*0IV / X * ^3M! ' 'k / /(- "- ( ! 8 ! /
&(< $<> W% 0V , . "3 "1. (3O & K k (D
9'2 .!
"* & *[ "- N
R+ - ( ! 8 ! 2
J\ ! NW? X 5T^ "- - 9'2 & K k ! "3. / (K 9' 9 o V /
' f M ; = > <
. ! f * X /(*\ ! (* "3 (k*$U / &= > < T H & K k
W 8h. M ; = > < ( (- $14 ! W2 % "% <> n ]T e *T & K k* / '* E
'M "- 0V "1.
"1*. 5 "- C M & K $% 8$ 7 &!(- n ]T 8 ! , /A
W L^
' .
! 9 o*2 - s*+ & K k* "*- 83*. $U *I{ W4 ]T & K' $U "- 9 2! (o & .
W &= > < e ]3%! ( ! W% 0V X D u)$I4 ! & ! "- ,!
»
*D ! "* $ ,'*2 @K!(
8$*- W4 *]T & K !'% 3*.! ! $1I / W? & !bo% % 4 ( ! X I6 W*??O>!
«
& *K 9 *T
D "- m -( j?3h NWV *M & !b*E " (*. N&(< & 03$<> n ]T NX 'M / Y X
"*- WE'$*. d *?c / W*]c "*./(U ;* "€! ! ' O%! W s4 @3#$. / W. ! 8$ A 8$ ‚OK N9 T 8 ! ƒ T X ^3M!
» e/ *3 / W? 3 W? e H! & !B ! 9 :3.!
! >! "?
«
*M , $O[! e T X IV "
;* = > < XY *I G(*[ / &!(*- ! ([
8$*- X *D "H(+
W* @K!(* W*??O>!
B*$% / /A
» 83 * / X k* )*H! ! & ! *M(-
W% 0V X D , . X ^3M! ) / )T i 5% "%Y + & 0?T 9!
« / ...
9 2!
( .
,'2 W% 0V ' A( W4 ]T Ž 3% / 6A )$?S ;2 W- c- X D & . ! A / 34!
d *?c W*o K( / W+ O3V! N& 34! NW. $. 6A "?OV ! 6A ( . "- "V ,/'- / r?c
#$%
. 8* ! *- W #OK 9B$o%! - " W ] ( A / W $.A & K k ! & $#- $1\/ W. (-
rS? X D W% 0V , . "- ' A(
2 9'
" .! ,A 9' K , k% N'%!
& K k* s*+
> S }^O+ G H W
d ?c / "%! ! A W.(3. y #S 9 *. e *]3%! / &= > < "- (
/ W+ *O3V! N& *34! $1\/ ($$• ,A JI "- / K k 8 ! "- &= > < ( 8|Oc / (
*OK &!(- X! (] (O3# ($$• "c.! - 0%A W4 ]T i 5% ' w (K N .! 9 (<% D ! W. $.
#
( .! 9'2 B$% eB>B w NW% 0V & K !'% 3.! / X! (] - 0%A , .
-
- .) ' 0 :) ; < : =
j?3h & K k / P h2! 8$- W% E - & KY "- { "- M i + & 1 &= > <
W "> I 2 . ( 9 /'S .! 8<O "> I 8 ! 8$- & K ( 9 /'S W? & K
W*??O>!
($E i D%!
. -
"
W* X *H W% 0V / W? y $] / &= > < e ]3%! 8h. (o (*$E
.
"*- *34! ! Wkh- ! / (o 1 H "- W31 H ! &= > < N& ( ,/ W? 9 /'S 4 (o xh2 , . "- xh2 / , . ! / N,A (o Ch-
*.! e *]3%! )*- .
e *]3%!
8$- e *T k / N"3 "1. k / , $ .! 8<O &= > < & ( ,/(- W??O>!
*2 i *D%! <+(*- / "1. e T k ; "- "3 "1. k ; ! N"1.
.
9'** K e **]3%! **V/ e **T(0- Nn ** 9'**2 , **$- ! ** ! ;** (K
) Transferor
**]3%! /(
e
9'%($E
) Transferee
.! WO3T (
. p?# / "1. e T & K k WK EA % )$> "- "32bE
W !(4 "? 1 (3k$- "‚%A N&= > < e ]3%! '%/ (- W31 H ( "3 (k$U & K k (E
- XYA 8$2
) N& *34! ! %/ 1 W. 2 9/(E 1373
N P 138
<> * / W* C*%! "% / (
& *03$
; = > < / &(<
. WO% } 1I[ XYA 8$2 ,A e ]3%! / 8 ! ! ;* = > < "1*. #%!
'*2 - "32! WU ! "3 "1. (3O & K k .
"*- 83M! (*U ! (*5% G(*H 9B*$o%!
& *K
9 *o - / N k* / 8$- ! !(4 rI[ " .! & D '3./ ! W+ % &= > < e ]3%! N8$ ([
W r]S xh2 /
W #T "? 1 / 2
'*2 - , E *% E / X/ *:3 '%!
.
/ M *. C%! N K q([ / "k]% N' A( N 02/ NXYA 8$2 / X!B$0D )$I4 ! W + \ / & *. % C*%! N ( ' C%! NX!($O1 / & !'0o% C%! NX 'M "\(+ KY '$>
"- .! 8<O WoOK "1.
* &= > < i #4! / !BV! ,! + "- , ‡ & X H
'%($E !(4 "? 1 .
W% E % E & K ! - /(- / 0‹ "- 5 8 ! r]S (D
W
"* *2
'% ! C]% ,A e S / "1. W- $3. (. (- - 4 &= > < ! A L (E .
" ! ! "‚%A
- f! %! "- WK o% N' A 'K! M e *]3%! / )*]% &!(*- W s* ,! * + "*- " .! V & K !
8$- W?M! X D 9 T &= > <
*M "*- ! &(E! *. "*H(+ ,Y *1 "V NW??O>!
.! "32! G c1 .
# -
- .) * > *?@ ' 0
M! zc. ,A X D &= > < e ]3%! / )]% " .! z\!/(U Wo3#*- N k (K W?
/ *K &= *> < f / ; = > < & 03$?- 4 "-
» WI#*% * B «
j*?3h & 0k*h- "* !
'% ! /(. ,A - / ! M(- ,A ! & 34!
. e { [ "- N
*KY '$> & 03$?- 4 "- "3#-
*K 9'* 'U / &(*< & 03$<> f % / 8$1 X 'M "\(+ / P M XY S
*6A /
)M! -B & K 9 T X/(6 L (E , < ! NW? /(O?4 V ; = > < / &(<
W @K!( Q M "- ,A /'H / k W '*] / &(*5% R*T I "* "*% E , OK / ' A
W?M! ! - r%/ N (E !(4 9 2!
) WV M W3T / (
(* (- &'* O%! / W ! * "*-
f \ .! "3#-!/ j?3h X + \
.
N *M W4 *]T / & *34! & 03*. $. / z> * *- *. 3 k* (K e HY! W?+
W* W*T!([ ;* = > < XY I r%/ / r]S &!(- ! W hk W4 ]T d w w '*
.
*-
! * OT "*- m *-( 8 ! * "*1> c / W*?M! & K ! !(4 W O+ '+! 4 / e H! "5T^
" ( A W- * ! * xhk* / -B XY I W4 ]T d w w N; = > < / &(< & K
W !(4 ($E .
*. % / X^<k* ! l 9 T 8 ! .! W0 '-
"*- m *-( W> *O3T! & 0$
W N .! ! !(4 WV M ( + ; "?M!' ! W2 % }Y H! " 8$%! 4 • 1 ($-' "- ,!
P M J V W?T 9!
*. ;* = > < XY I W4 ]T 1-! / K ! !(4 ]1%! 9 S%
.
& /A % & K o>! N W?M! " SH W? [ "-
"*- I#*% k ; ! ; = > < & K
, *. ;* j?3h & K'T!/ ,/ W3T / (o , . "- W% . ! / (o k
'2 - X/ :3 .! 8<O .
!BE * / 8 ! ! '* - &= *> < X *D / *0 /A % "*H(+ ,!
8$$1 o>! i!' ' )
(*K WI#*% * B / N"*1 V N ! *- N *V & *03$14!/ "*- "*V *-
&= > <
( .! ( d ?c &= > < &! ,/ "1. N
) N( W<?
1375 N P 21
3*.! 8 ! (.
< & 0 /A % , ( e I% / )$ S &!(- . & o>! ".
)*- 4 k* )*M! ;* = >
(5% "- ( g W
'.
:
1 -
& I (- & /A %
»
"1. / r$]S «
W> *S * ' 'V &= > < f!(3M! ,A G'K "
.! ' 'V }^
.
& K k* / W31 *H "3 (k$U & K k "1. / r$]S G'K "3I>!
.! X/ :3 "1. e T .
"1. / L(3#E "- }Y O1 e/! 9/(E
*V &= *> < & K (
W
*% ! ! V & 0 = > < ' 2 W }Y O1 "1. e T & K k W>/ N' k '%!
f!(3M! / )$ S
"- { "- W]? 8 ! "% :.73 '
»
•(w 9 -/ f!(3M!
«
! / 2 W d #S
]$ N L/ 8 ! boK ! " ./ 8 ! W
K k ! "3. 8 ! ' + ,!' w
*.! 9'k%
.
&= > < } O+ N ( "3 (k$U / W31 H & K k W *]$]S B !( / 0K ok%! ! ' 'V & K
8 ! ! / ! , (V W31 H / &'$> B !( O. "-
&= *> < & *D '3*./ ! W+ *% /
.! , (V 9 T / 8 ! 8$- u
W> T e *T & K k* d *?c )* 1 8* ! "*
. .! 0k (3O "1 .
2 -
& I (- & /A %
»
"- W ! !/ & K &= > < & .
«.
,A -B & o>! ! 9 :3.! B
'*$> / &($E *<- " 2 W "\(+ ! - "- W Y S / K &= > < 9! 8 ! ! " .!
.! "32!'% "]- . k )M! 0%A .
! (*5% G(*H '* 'V &= *> < "*<%A "*D$3%
7k*
W d #S W - &= > < ; N,A d #3 ! W*?M! & K ! - "- "\(+ $?- 4 0 "% / 2
W M "<?- N ! ! @*K k ! Q M "- ( "- ( S / )]3# &= > < ,! + "- '%!
'- e ]3%!
. (o 9'2 W31 H 9 & K k 8$ ‚OK / K W U!= $] W?H! ) + o>! 8 !
W ) (- / ; B< NW- V 9( ' % '*2 -
. (*2 e *{ &!(*-
» WV * «
&= *> < N8*U!=
W < ( A (2 ! ! W~ & 0 $2
»
!(
« 9 X'* W*[ " WD ' & #0- - / ' (M
•(1 ! W < ( A (2 / M . !( M ! (30- & 0 $2 N ! i D%! 0%A (- e .
! !(4 Wo3#<2 / .
3 -
&= > < i a ! & I (- & /A % :
.! 8<O " "3 (k$U &= > < ; N o>! 8 !
&= *> < ;* *- N'*2 - 9' A . "- Q M ! &= > < e ]3%! / "1. / r$]S 9! ! W i a ! V W ' 'U 8 % &'% $U WI$ ( &= > < / 2
/A . 8 ! '1- W* U!= B$%
K W 9 $2 8 ! (E aA 3.! ! ' %!
.
&= *> < *$ ( *- ' 3#%! 8U!= J H e { [ "-
W3 .
»
;$% <
«
"3 (k$U &= > < /
»
;$%/(3<>!
«
&= > < f!'-! "- N
»
;$%/( <
« 9' A ) %
8$2 / L!( & K
» W. ,! W.
«
"\(+ ! - "- W3 . L!( 8$2 & V "- ! '
.
, - ) 23 A > 1 ! * *??&
W% *0V '* A( ! W*2 % & 0 /(*\ N'2 "3:E K k W?M! n ]T 9 T "‚%A (- - .! 9'2 R+ - X D ,'2 ! A / 34! ,'2 W O
@K!(* r* ([ ! W4 *]T & 0 5%
( 8$*- X * 5% L( bU / k )M! i Y W% % 4 (3#- ,
* NŽ* ! W*??O>!
'13#* & s
! *M '*$: 9(0- r ([ ,A ! / '% . @K!( &= > < ,!/ / ! A XY I &!(- ! W4 ]T '% /A . "- .
8$- "H(+ ! ! , E *% E )* ! + ($67* *S ; = > < XY S NW??O>!
"1*. K k* ! W*M(- W % / K k ( . W1$I[ ( Mg "- W- $3. X /(\ "?OV '* w & 03 (2 $> 1 9 T L(3#E e I%'- 8$ ‚OK / & 34! "1. "- $% / ; = > <
& K ! - NW3$?
' 'V 8$- 8$- X D 9 T W??O>!
D ! )?O>!
2 (* ! 8* ! ($67 S / 9'
Ž* ! , 0V &= > < X D &!(- B$% j?3h & K 9 $2 '*2
*.! 9 . NL/(* / '* (M
% #$> & K ! !(4 8$*- & *D & 0 !b*E " (. N
@$]3#* & !b*E " (*. ! @*+! W*??O>!
& ! !(*4 (o '13 & K 9 $2 / W+ :3%! k & K ! !(4 / WV M -
*V & *D
8$- X D ! &' 'V i 0: / s C !'$U (- >Y
& *34! '1- ! 0 "% " ! W??O>!
-
B$% W4 ]T 0V ! "<?- & D X *D n *]T / W*?M! n *]T ' 'V XY S - i‡
8$- .! 9 - W??O>!
) (Dunfee & others , 1989:PP.1243-1275 .
! *- *V W3- *4 p !(*2 )$?S / " BD & I (- ! &= > < ?a! , %! 34!
W !(4 "1> c ' K
. Y ( *. "> I "- { "- &= > < (E! 8 !(- - / N *2 "3#*%! *K
)*O+ W3- *4 X *S$V( & * I (*- / "%! ! A [ "- K ! - "‚% w X *H ,A N'*
G(H @K &= > < / 2! 'K! h% V/ W?<k "% E „$K @K &= > < e ]3%! P M
*- '*K! M e *]3%! )*- 4 }! * / WE *. "- ,A Š k ! (5%
. , %! *34! ! &! 9 *U 8<$*>
) Archibugi & Petrobelli, 2003:P.864
XY **S / &= **> < 9Z** / x **M **I3+! "**- (
WO% '%']31 ; = > <
"+ OD "- ! &= > < ,!
)*O1>! 3. / q([ ! &!
9 *. & *K
W 0%A ! $1I X H " ( "$Ik
"D$3% "- ,!
&!
. 8$1 .
8 !(- * - N e *]3%!
?€ # 8Os3 &= > <
W
&' O%! / 03$?- 4 - " - 'K! M @0 / 9!(*OK k* ; & K
3*H( ,! * + "- ,A ! / ! r / W?S p !(2 - ! ,A ,! 3- .! 8<O / - 'K! M i‡
W
! 'K ! ,A V p !(2 t i'+ "c.! - "< ! N ( 9 :3.!
. X I+ "- (*o
N e *]3%!
"1*. *0V ,A ! ! * / (6 * 9 :3*.! *- ! Q *M ! ,A d #3 ! / dbV &= > <
W '% $U & 34!
"1*. 9'* 8$Os* NWV *M &= *> < db*V G(H / 8 ! ! N'K
$% ; = > < / W31 H
# .
3$?- 4 / #< ! 9'%($E e ]3%! $% 9 /'S / f % "- "3#- 0
*34! &
e *]3%! & *D / &
. N . (o ! &= > < , E' K /
P *M j*?3h & *K ! !(4 / W4 *]T & *K
*.! 9' A V - / WT!([ &= > < "> I 9 S%
. 8$*- & *K ! - "*H(+
/ f * W*??O>!
& *34! X S•V( / $•14 ! (673 }Y H! " &= > < e ]3%! & D & K 9 $2 W% E % E )*$?S N *.! 9 *- i‡ * W4 *]T & 0$E'*$‚$U *- 9 ! *OK N *.! "*> I 8$ (*[ & D / W* !(oOK ! W*2 % XY *S W*U ,A ! W*2 % W4 *]T )€ #* / & ! !(*4 & K / . .! (o e D V/ iB?3# W% 0V & 34!
.
,!(* ! W4 *]T i 5% 9' '+ W4 ]T J%! N& 34! & 0$ . % ! l "* ! *V/
.! ! A ! - & 0$EZ / / p !(2 - #OK / & 3M . ) '1 / q(V iB?3#
. J*%! 8 !
W. $. i 5% (- @ T W4 ]T e H! &! 9 U 9(<$U -
'* % OK W*. .! , % *4 / ,!(* ! W+ *O3V!
, % *4 ' % OK & + 8$%! 4 / @0% / W. / ' < N@< / 3kK Ni 0w / )0w Ni 0w e H!
"- NW $> NW (OE N"O$- NW<% - ! 9 T X 'M X D 8$%! 4 NWV M & !bE " (.
*.! Q *M e *] 8* ! "?*H T ! *0%A p#*- / q(*2 " .! 9'K k )- 4 q \/
. i'*+
8$- W4 ]T & K !'% 3.! / 8 ! - W #OK NX *E '* % OK Y * X *D "* $ W??O>!
N E ' % OK X 'M W4 *]T W*. .! J*%! (o ! N ~ ( ' % OK &(< & 03$<> /
/ W Ok- " $ 8 ! .
, *. W*? "* % *] ! "*- n *S>! i'*+ "c.!/ "- ,!( ! k
& *D *. & K(3#*- ! 83 (*E 9(0- / W oOK W]$ N,A @€ O\ / W% 0V X D M / W?M! X D 0%A (- / V
*.! 9 / *$% *. "*- M WV
) N W*4^M!
1383 N
xH 26 - 21 N E'% / 1384 N xH 157 - 143 (.
.)
! !(4 K W+ *O3V! / W*. $. NW4 ]T N& D NW31 H p !(2 ! (673 &= > < e ]3%! &
W ']1 , E % E '% 2
.
":> 8 ( 9'O+ ! 8* ! W4 ]T / & 34! 1-! 8$$1 (6 & K
% W N K ! !(4 f ! W2 % X € s34! / 34! ,'2 W% 0V 9Z - / ,'2 W% 0V ' A( "- ,!
9 2! ! A X D (
.
& K k* &!(*- ,A $<> / B (O / &= > < ; Z !(3.! $OK!
& ! !(*4 e 1 , M @0- R+ - &= > < "- "1. e T & K k 9Z - $% / P M / X % < ! /
&= *> < , E'* K e *]3%! W% "% w X '4 ] 0V 8$ ([ & 0$ %!
"*- W4 *]T e *H! *- ( *• W3T / G!BE p !(2 / X!'01 )$OS R+ - } s1- " 2 W
W &= > < , E'%($E e ]3%!
2 . 8* ! (*- @ *T P *M X $s*3] "*- * + *- /( ! !
. ($-' N K ! !(4 /
4 ]T & K &= *> < e ]3%! ' A( (- X 5% / e(3 &!(- d ?c W
8$- & K ! - "H(+ } H M N, ! 3 Wc !(2
*.! & /(*\ W*??O>!
. '* A( ! (67*3
X H & 02^ N& D ! A XY I 0V d ?c p !(2 t !' / 34! ,'2 W% 0V 9 U 8 /' > 4 "3 (E 8$- & K , $#%! &!
8$*- & 0% . WM(- L^ / W??O>!
W*??O>!
- W % ! '$: boK 8 ! "
W (5%
8$%! *4 8 /' & 3M . & . - / e S / '.
, $#%! /
& 34! & 0% . X 5% S / )<k>!'S3 & K -
W4 ]T 8$- W*??O>!
- 9Z* /
&= > < e ]3%! & K ! !(4 -
& *0 5% / K k* i!B*>! / 8* ! ! *$1I "*- W4 *]T W*?
W ! W4 ]T & K / . 'I?[
. W4 *]T & *0 5% i Y W% % *4 X $Os* *D ! e I%'*-
8$- "H(+ / W?M!
! &= *> < , E'*%($E e *]3%! J * ! OT / $% 8$ 7 &!(- W??O>!
K e **]3%! ;** = > < (** (- **$14 / W% % **4 X **SV( / n **]T ‘**:T / #**<
, E'**
.'- ; = > < & 0 /A % / 8 % XY S / "1. / , .A "> I N . (o ! &= > <
W e *]3%! / & !bE " (. ! W2 % W4 ]T / & 34! ;# CK (U 0% / ' A e *]3%! & *K ! !(4 : / m/(2 ) '1 0V i Y W4 ]T & K(3#- / p !(2 N&= > <
> <
W ] / @K!( , ! 3 / e ]1 X - &=
2 .
B@C >
# -
*D
1 . /(0- NW4^M!
) 1383 ( N
»
$" 4 7 4 ,H ? 4 2 2 W )4 :X 5' ' 5 YH
« N
2 5 RQ ) @:
9 O2 N 5 4 ]T & 0kK/ZU / X 1> c "#. N,!(0 Ni . e . N C%! (02 W
.
2 . W:c N, #>!
) 1385 .(
WV M & !bE " (. r ([ ! & / e ]3%! W4 ]T 1-!»
« N
2 5 RQ ) @:
9 O2 N 9 N
C%! (02 W4 ]T & 0kK/ZU / X 1> c "#.
.
3 . OS N&(4 - )
1385 ( N
*E d w w z?H! W> 8$%! 4 "- W- $3.»
« N
$ $ )$ @:
$ $
9 O2 N 74 .
4 . (0w N& $3h- )
1380 ( N
& D & K & !bE " (. ! OT W4 ]T & 02/ / J%! NW% I» -
W??O>! 8$- & 34!
« N
4 - 1 -' /-' ): " Q
.
5 .
\($?+ NW% c?.
) 1382 ( N
>/ C]%» 34! ,'2 W% 0V ' A( "1. e T & K k i a !
« N AB : ) ,@:
2 - .
W% E - & 0kK/ZU X 1> c "#. N,!(0 N .
6 . K( N,! V )
1381 ( N W% *E - W% *0V , . "- 83. $U - ,A m 3- ! / X! H "1. . $.»
« N 1 $ A $ X>
2 9 O2 N 180 - 179 .
7 . 1# NW% ! W> O )
1382 ( N X 'M ,'2 W??O>! 8$- / 34! ,'2 W% 0V»
« N
$- . Y" ,5 AB : ) ,@:
2 W% E - & 0kK/ZU / X 1> c "#. N,!(0 N .
8 . N,!(* ! W ^.! & 0OV & D $3MY! i WE' O% & D X!( !b , . 2 9/(E 2 $4 " /$-0
:& $ $
. A' @ N
) 1381 ( N
& 0k*K/ZU / X *1> c "#*. "*- "3#*-!/ W% *E - (k*% / ’ *w (2 N,!(0 Ne/! ’ w
W% E - .
9 . W* ! ! / & 34! ! X ! / & 34! ! %/ 1 W. 2 9/(E )
1373 .(
[=$ 9" /$ YM4 ' G H / +
"
! X ! / N,!(0 Ne/! ’ w N W ! ! / & 34!
.
10 . W:c N E'%
) 1384 ( N ,!( ! WV M & !bE " (. (- @ T W4 ]T i 5% (- @ T W4 ]T i 5% (- W?M'»
« N ) @:
2 5 RQ
9 O2 N 7 C%! (02 & 0kK/ZU / X 1> c "#.† N,!(0 N .
11 . )$]+ N( W<?
) 1375 ( N
> < / @?+ &Z !(3.! W]$Ic "1> c» , * i/ W% 0V v V ! 8U!= / < ( A &=
« N
$" Q
9" / / : -' /-' ):
= : 3/
.
12 .
\ '$OT N hI<$%
) 1382 ( N W% 0V X D , . W4 ]T i 5%» WTO)
(
« N
$ 2 A 8 ) @:
4 - 9 O2 N
37 .
13 . (0- N % & K /
) 1379 ( N
" ' .' ' PI )" : ,!(0 N e/! ’ w N
: / ,! ( CK/ZU / (k%
.
, -
*3 @
1-Ameri Feysal (1994). The International Legal Regim For the Transfer of Technology To Developing Countries with Special Reference to Deep Seabed Mining, ph.D. Thesis, Facully of Law, university of Manchester.
2-Archibugi Daniele and Petrobelli Carlo (2003). The Globalization of Technology and its Implications for Developing Countries Windows of Opportunity or Futher burden?
Technological Forecasting & social change, No.10, available: at: <Http//www.
Sciencedirect.com>
3- Dunfee Thomas W., Gibson Frank F. and other Authors, (1989). Modern Business Law, Second edition , New York , Rondom House Business Division
4- Kasto Jalil (1993). International Law of Technology, first edition, London print center 5-Skelton James w. (1981). "unctads Draft code of conduct on The Transfer of Technology: A
aritique". In vanderbilt Joumal of Transnational Law, vol.14 avaiable at:
http//www.Heinonline.org/14 vand./J.Transnatl L/
6-Unctad Secretariat (1990). "The Relevance of Recent Development in the Area of Technology to the Negotiations on the Draft International code of conduct on the Transfer of Technology". International Technology Transfer (2001). Edited by S.J.Patel, Netherland , Kluwer law International.