Implementation of PID controller tuning using differential evolution and genetic algorithms

½

!"#"$"

!$%"&'$"#"

¾

(#

!")* #"

*+, -#"

.*//#

!" # #

# $ #"

%#%& '(

% !" % # % ! #

'(" # !

) $* "

$0 01 2 3 "

"4

!

" " " #

" # !

# $ % &"# "

"

%

"

" # '( )" "*

" " "

+" # " !

" # , -" '( ." .

'/( " " )" " * !

" %

" Æ " " " * "

"" ! " ! *

, !-" " "" " ""

#"" ."!." # "+!

" '01( )"Æ ""

# " " 2

, !-" '3( '4(" #" !

5"6 " "

5 '7( % 5

"6 # " "

"# "

# '8(

9:"* ""#

"" #

; '( 9: " #

# < &= " " #

" " > '( "# 9:

# , '(

9: # 5# ! $*

+ " "

# " ! # " ?

"" 9: " " # " # "

" " " 2

)" 9:@ #

# '/(

? " # " 5

" + '0( ? " # 2 "

6 # 5"6 " #

" "

" !A ! #

'0( )"# " " " '1(

" ##? 5<+&= 5

#2 #"? <"

A="+&B ."'3( ?

" # !" # #

+ " # # " "

"A : '4( ?

# " "

" ? " # #6

" " 5

? "" " 9: ? " *

" " " " "

)" # "

" " 9: ? )" # # 9: ?

" "

# " #""

" ! " )" "

##"9:?"", !-" "

)" # 9: ?

! 5"" " 2#"!

C " )" 6 # "

# "C #

)" # * $ +!

4 )" 5 #!

"6

)" 5 # + $ * " # #

+ / 0 " # 9: ? "6

, !-" " + 3 " " # #

" # "" " ! " + 4

" # " 5 " "

+ 7

#" @ !

:

# " " # "

#" '4( )"##

# @

<=D <=

<=

D E

E

<=

)" # # " & "

" " " " "

)" <= "

" " " # "

<= " )" )"

" "

- <= " )"

!

/ ! 9: 2 "%

'7( " 5 "6 " " #

9: " # "!

" " # " "" #

2#

F"2#" 2 #"

" @ )"

# " " " #

"" " )"

# " # @

"# $ ! %"" $ " " " "& "

%%" ! '"$ 9: " 5 )"

6 " 5

# " " 5 #

D8

D " # D

)" "

"" 0 2 2 )" 6

" # 6@

<

=

<=

"

" #

# * # '(

'1(

'( "

6 <=6 11 )"

" " 0 ""

: "

" " "

0 " "

'"" ($$ ! " $ )" 2 # " "

"" "

)" # " "

# @

D

E <

=

<

=

</=

* " #

@

)"* $ " '"

@ 384

@ /3/0

@ 314

)"# " @

DE384

< =

D3

DE/3/0

<1 =

D4

DE314

< =

D3

?" # : #

" # " 2 2

G# " " 6 <H+?=

<:?= " " G # / " " $" #

" )" # 9: # 2

D

<<==

<0=

D

<= <1=

! $& $$' " " : " ""

" " 2 )" "" " 2 "

" " )

'8("""A G

9:" #

"" " #6

2

:#" " !

9: " )" "

! *" " " # "

A

H " "

" . " " %"

" " "

' %" $% + ! "$ :#

" " # " " "

" * :

# " # 2

)" "" /6 "

# " " 2 " )" " 9:

" $" " /

0 ," ' ! A ? <?= "

" 5 " I 9: "

# ? # $

)" "? " #

F ? " " A "

)" # @ J " 5 J "

J" A < #=

" " ?K Æ "

+ '( " "

" )" @

)" 5 " " " G

##

6 " '( "

< /= # " '7(# "

D""#

)" " '1(

)" "" " 5 " " "

"

)" #"#?K """#?K

G'0( )" A ? ""

@

% #" %"" $ " 5 D

D 8 D 3 #

D )" " #

" G # " #

" #

"" 6 / )"

" * # '(

" D "" D

"# ' %%" 5 "

" " 2 # "

DE< =

<= D D <3=

D <

= <4=

"

<

=D

<<==

# H+? <7=

<

=D

<= # :? <8=

<= J F# 5

" 5 " 2

)" 2 <4= "" # H+? :? <7=

<8= " # " 0 " "

# 2 * # '(

'/(

'7(

<=D7

<=D7180

<=D04"" "

@

'(

DE< =

<=

D7D

'/(

DE< =

<=

D71800D

'7(

DE<7 = <=

D040D

)" #

" 2 #

" )" " #2

<# 0=

)" # 2

! " " $$' )" 5

" # )" 2 2 # "

" 1 )" "

" #"

<= " " )" 2 <H+?C:?= # "

"

" " < = !

@

! D E< = <=

I # "

"""

"#"

" " )" * ""

" 3

- # # " "

"

" D<" " " =

" D

! # <

=< D=

"

D

. " # "

# " " )" ""

" 4

' !* -"* $" # " < #

= " "" <

= " # " C <# =

" <" #=

#

#

'(

DE< =

<= <=

?6 <= " "

< = "

' + ##" 2

" " # " " L " 2

H

.

' %"$%$./0%%" % M""2

" " " " 5 #

" ""

2!

)" # /1

" )" "

"

' %" $% 1 ! "$ )" 3

" # : " " 5 )"

# 2 " "" #

# & 5 8

1 0 23$ , !-"

" '( " #6 # " ! !

! +

"# , !-"

3

#

#7

" : " " #

"

" " #

#6 "

F " ,

-" " " )

" "

"6 M" " # " "

2 H 2 " #

" 6 5

3 "$ $

3 *$ $ $ " " " #

? 9: "" <= " <=

$ F # ? "

! "

<= )" @

<=D

1

EE/

E317

E10

E47

E4E

<=

<=D

<E7=<E=

</=

<=D

< =

<E=

<0=

)" ## 6<H+?=

<:?= """ "G #"

" 2 # " "C 9: ? 9: ?

" 2 " # " " " "

# G #" 2 " "C "

##"?9: ", !-" "

3 " $$ " " "

5"6 <? 9:= " N " #"

" 5 "6 " 6

" 2 # "C " :

# " # "C #

+" N " 6 +

" # ? 9: "

# " <=!<0= )" # ?

9: 5 " ) " '( )" #

") /" '/( )" #!

# " " # *

" # " " # H+? :? "

" " # " G #

"# # ? 9:

5 D 5 D

. D8 . D8

A D3 H D

9D 9D

"#

*$

*$ 0

"*

3

"$ *$

"" "4 "4 "4

1

/ 1 1

7 1 1

)" # ! #?9:""

<=!<= <= " " #

? 9: " " )" # "

" ) 0 )" # * " H+?

:? ? 9: " F" "

# ", !-" " :#) 0, !-"

! "" "

" # " ? 9: 5 H+? :?

" " <= ? 9: 5 H+?

A " ? 9: 5 :? % ?

9: 5 :? " ""

# 0O " ? 9: 5 H+?<# )

1= ? ""? 9: 5 :?A "

" ? 9: 5 :? " " #

" , !-" "

" # ! " # " #

" " " A "

: " "A " <=

? 5 :? " # # ?

5 H+? 9: 5 H+? 9: 5 :? , !-"

" % # " " 9:

56 7 +"#" 56#" 8+#

56 %""#"

% + #

"# . # # ,- ? 9: # ""

*$

2

56

56

5 6

5 6

J J J

J J J 003 0007

$ 5$6 /80 344 344 34 34

5$6 87 00 0/7 /874 043/

'$ 576 141300 484 4187 70/0 71/81

/88 /113/ /41 4147 41

07 837 880 183 48

801 7 7 7 7

" /O 4O <# ) 3= %

# " , !-" " " "# ?

5 H+? 9: 5 H+? 9: 5 :? ? 5

# 2 '0( M" # " "

!A "C" "

H+? :? G # # "

" # " <=!<0=" !

<=!<= )"

" 2 )" ) 4

# " ? 5 H+?

)" # # ! "

<=!<= <= <= " " 2 #

"# . # # ,- ? 9: # "

*$ 0 "*

2

56

56

5 6

5 6

J 87 87 J J

J J J 73847 741

$ 5$6 340 314 3303 /08 /08

5$6 4740 830 700/7 3433 3477

'$ 576 00/8 11//8 130 08 708

333 388 31 3487 347

18 07 8/4 34 33/

380 18 78 /08 /13

"# . # # ,-? 9: # !

"

3 "$ *$

2

56

56

5 6

5 6

J 78 7 J J

J J J ///1 38

$ 5$6 14111 0073 443 7141 0814

5$6 4811 1038 370 413 /1140

'$ 576 J 4/4 J 800 J

$ 576 /7 037 140 14 34/

11 8/ 770 4 741

/ 381 30 431 30

77 /1 33 4/ 741

"# , !-"

*$

*$ 0

"*

3

"$ *$

" "

331 17

" %

78/ 7/00 843

/88 333 11

803 04 073/

/4 0/ 3

56 7 +"#" 56 #"8+#

56 %""#"

"

" #? 9: 5 :?

" # " "6

" % # ? 9: 5 H+? " "

# ? # " 9:<# <= <== !

2 $"

#1 " #! " ?

# " 9: " :? " 2 #

. 1 # " # " "

" " #

)" " # 2 # " " !

. # " # 2 # #

? 9: # /!1 " 2

" ? 2 " 9: " # 2 #

. # ? 9: "

" " ? " # 9: #

56 0 %9+# ' 56 2' %9+# '

56 0 %9+# 5+6 2' %9+#

. 2 #

4 "" % ! $ $ % #" $

# " # #!

"6 '1( 3 " " " "

" # # " !

'3( 6"" 2#"

M" " " 2 ! " 5

2 " "2 " H+?

:? M" 5 " " !

" "

7 $$ " , !-" " !

" " ? 9: # "" "

! " "

# " " " #""

#H+?:?""#"" "

56 0 56 2'

. # ""

56 0 56 2'

. # "

H+? :? % # ! " ? 5

H+? # " " !A *!

"" # ? A"

#2 % " # " #

"" " ! "

" # " * $ "

80 $ )" "" " " I H <I-H

:= I ) H <I)H= # " # #

" " )" "# I ) H "

56 0 56 2'

. #! "

F # "

:; </,/'" +)/7+! + (#!$

/

:; ,/2/3+ /-/ "=%"" ""!(' /&

/%%/>?>&/

:; 2/7/ +2/'/ ) "+ ++ "!(' />?

:; 2/*@//0/A++/ /2 @ """+% +B+

"%+ " % """8 ++" !

(# /& /%%/&&/

:?; )/ , + / ,/ =%" $0$ " "8

! # / /%%//

:&; </,/'" )/7+/ /7+A/ </7 ' ++% $ 0

"C'"# / /%%/&>/

:>; </,/'" +)/7+ + #+ (#

!?/

:; $/-/+ = + ""8 $0 %9 D 'E%

" ! -+%" 7#%%/

?/

:; / @/ @" ' , % % 287 F +

?/

:; ,//<,/7/<,//$*//$*/G/ +7/7 ' $ 0

"+ % + " " "" %

(# / /%%/>/

:; (/ G ,/ A + / 2 - ! !

. ( / %-7+/

:; -/'/ /3/=/) *+/(/) $ 0"+ "* HE%

8 %9 " 0 -1( (#

' ( '" 2%%/??&/

:; ,/ '+ $/ # + )/ 0 ' % "++ B

% " %9 ! ( / /

%%/&/

:; @/ +</$01 C'"%+Æ" %9

""%" % 23 / /%%/?>/

:?; @/0 01 ""%"8 %9 $ 0 +""

4 * )I%%/&/

:&; G/ F + J/ ) $0 %" #+ " "#" "+

+1 " 5 !

#%%/?/

:>; F/0/ '#7/</+/,01 %9 $ 0"

( / /?

%%/?&/

:; 0/ / 2 + ! ( 23 ' . '++"

A"#$" / //

:; ,/ 3 J/ 7 / 2 + ,/ 3 %" % 8 +1 "

"" "% "

' ! ! 6%

%%/??/

:; @/ =" +1 %9 " 733# $

(#-*#'!'%%/??&/

:; /< 0 @ B+""+1 -/!(

! ( /? /%%/&>&?/

:; 2// +'+ / / @/ / 2/ % + @/G * #'%%

% B$ 0 %"+"+ 3 "4

.*( /&?/

:; $/ +)/780" $ 0 "" "%% 8+%

" 8"% "%".*( />/

:; A/ ," 3/ G + A/ A =% +" $ K$0 %"

"#" ' 8 / /&/

:?; A/F/=$/J/F+/L/7/ +#"#"""+

%"8 %9 ' !7

%%/>/

:&; / '+ F/ 3 + ,/ / @+ = $

"#" " 5 !