View of Relationships between Work Honesty and Work Efficiency of Accountants in Education Solution Under office of Vocational Education Commission

(1)

!"# $ %&'( )"#%&' Relationships between Work Honesty and Work Efficiency of Accountants

in Education Solution Under office of Vocational Education Commission

²!"³

SupanneeThapthaneeSuttinee Prachsriphum² and Kesinee Muenthaisong³

(

#$%& '" '#()"&* +*,&##-"&#.*(%/0,(", 4"5*"",/)67"+4"&*#678+%/9,,*,):

&*"*/:,#,#59*$",/)67"+4"&*#67

$4# 274&)( /9/#&59*!+9-#&&#&)+)*%

&=#$%,#-+9&#.*(%(-*(*" - ' &#, 4"*%-"

%4&8+%&- >&#)+)*% -,0.127

!+,+

&#.*(%/0,(" 4")67"+4"&

*#67

___________________________

*(+,8 (,,B(&,$+# %%&

Master Student, Master of Accountancy, Mahasarakham Business school, Mahasarakham University

2*$%&,$+# %%&

2Lecturer,Mahasarakham Business School, Mahasarakham University

3=9-#%($%&,$+# %%&

3Assistant Professor, Mahasarakham Business School, Mahasarakham University

(2)

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to verify the relationships between work honesty and work efficiency of accountants in education solution under office of vocational education commission.

A questionnaire was used for collecting data from 274 accountants in education solution under office of vocational education commission. The statistics used for data analyzing were multiple correlation analysis and multiple regression analysis. The findings revealed that the only work honesty in aspect of honesty to self had a positive relationship with work efficiency significantly. The regression coefficient was 0.127.

Keywords :

Work Honesty, Work Efficiency, Education Solution under Office of Vocational Education commission

1-++

/8%&8#( %"*%-"(-**"*%-* '"/*"5*" &88%*

7G$ "& #I 67.6"9#:&#$ "+9#() +56 '*%-"#+:#/

%" ':%-*+(-" J%- 58%8$ $(&*

N9*7Q,"#"R(*,/#"* , +,-#6"+$

R(-#,&& 5+&$% R(*"& $# 4" (-**

-#"=9,"&,,) # 4":(9 8+%5*" $(R(*,/*"&*

)67&*&#!-.*(%:4& +&#9 -!-)6" "7G$!-+=945+&

$%&# %* % ),,,"&,:-8%-#(#9*"$6"-*/9+ $(

&*8+%N*%-"%""+9,&#%"(-* $(/ 4"*"$59* ", +"/9:)6"=+4"G ""5*"*"&# '"+"/9:)6"&#)/,

$+*"& #"=+4"**,(+/$ &#,&4, ,$+%/

*"&X#*4, 2555 : 1) +" '&#.*(%/0,("5*"",$6":*" (9*"%6+)*

0,((*+ # '"*"&( '"(-=9,"+"$)6""+,-"+&#.*(%:$$%4&

$ 4/9+4"

&#.*(%/0,("XWork Honesty\: 4" %6+&#)(9*" &#%(

7&#,-#%7=8% %(-"J 5*"*"&/959* !-,+,*$&#:$"

!-&+&+8"**#"=9*!-R(=+ 4 =+Q%.6"&#.*(%/0,("

5*"")*:&7*6""&5*" *"&X,7%"", 2555 : #:,!.+\&#.*(%

/0,("!+9$4**:4 +9 &*+9&#.*(%(-*(*" XHonesty to Self\+9&#.*(%(-*

,&&*XHonesty towards Others\+9&#.*(%(-*9 XHonesty to Duty\+9&#.*(%$((-*

-&XHonesty Groups\X #"67, 2551 : 14\.6" 4"$,&#4:$: -

*/$ '$4:(9*"*%,% &(*-"I,&/*"&/9&#.*(%$(

(3)

(*+$*+/ 4"*$-#%&#9&#)/#"=+4"/9 (-*!

4"XWorkEfficiency\:&#)/0,("5*",& ( '"/$

0,("*%-"(:&#)8+%/9#* && 4" )9"=" &: -*/$

)&+&9++"# 4"/9!+9=+%"56 '*%-*+" ' / 4"5*"",

$6":= +$/9&#9&#) 7/0,("*%-"( '"/$(:&#) 8+%-*/9+8%"+-*"& '*" %&-/9$-%""/0,("9*% + 4&)4/9*(+/$ :8%(-**"&!+9*%-" -#" X/$7,2546 j6\

4"5*"",$(9*"*"&*,(-"J&* 4"(9*"*)*!+9 XReliable Working\"4:$ #XTimeliness Work Success\="!+9(GXStandardized Work\

X#(,,2551 j35\+" ' / 4"5*"",$6":=$/9&#9

&#) *%-"(: +9#%&#.*(%$(*/9*"&*%-*+%"%(-*!

,(#5*"4"&*#67 '" 4&*%-"%" $4*"&!-

&#:,=4:$!+9+"#% -#!#9#-4"&*#67“+4 /=(I4"&**"(*,&#(9*"(+""/I 9"7 + /9,*#679"&#%/%#/9,"&”X4"&*#67,2558 j#:,!.(\.6"-#4& $44"&*#67!-&#:!+9 ' %,&&

-#"$(9*"-#*-#"/0,("*%-"(:&#9&#).6"",)*:-#" 4&

4,4"&*#67-#%" -"59* ", +$+"/9:)6"

&#)5*",$+*"&=9,$459* ",/9/#"=

*/9/(+/$+" '",$(9*"0,(9 *%-"(:&#9&#)+9#%&#.*(%$(

*/9+8%"+(-**"&

$(= -#9#59"(9=9#$%$6"/$67#$%&##-"&#.*(%/0,("

, 4"5*"",/)67"+4"&*#678+%

#()"&* +*,#-&#.*(%/0,("&#, 4"*!-*%-"!

.6" 4:,#,#59*$",/)67"+4"&*#67=

!+9$#$%)4!/9:# "4,=9,)67/,*"&/

4"* &&0,("*,"R(/0,(" 4/9",

&#.*(% 4/9=0,(" %"56 '(-*!

2-++. /#.# 03456 /

/67#$%& '" '&#.*(%/0,("!+9)4+/9:(#*&#

, 4"$#()"&59"(9)*,#&+/#$%!+9+" '

(4)

7

8.(4 34

H1

2.1 (Work Honesty\%)6"0,(9 8+%%6+)*&#)(9*"

(Q%+9#%&# %"("&#,=+*,&#8-"/!-*&()(#$*,!+9 4"

+9#%&#( '"/$&#%(7% +,*-#" '"/*"&+%#(-"*"&

X #"67}2551 : 14)*,+9#%

2.1.1 +9&#.*(%(-*(*"XHonesty to Self\%)6"&#$"/$ '"/+*

0,(8+%$+0,(("(&#&+ '"(-*(*"(-*=9*-!-5959"(*" &#96=+

*,#+&#*%"#(-* 4=+!-++!-*#"!-&+8/5*"=9*%*,

=+$ 45*"(*"

2.1.2 +9&#.*(%(-*,&&*XHonesty towards Others\%)6"&#:(

(-*,&&*6"*%.6"&#:( '$&" )#*%-!+9(*+!:(9*"&#.*(%!-&+&+ % (-*($6"$%#!-.*("(-*9#:%-*$(&#&& 4/9!-***%-/"&

!+9%#&*$"(*+# !--#&4 :$(-*=9*7&4 /9!#9,=9*

!-*%,=9*!-)**5*"&*:5*"(8+%!-!+9,*(!- $(&#R(+ '"(-*9 ,"=9*

2.1.3 +9&#.*(%(-*9 XHonesty to Duty\%)6"R( +"**)6"&#,=+*, (-*9 (*" 4*!+9,*,% 4/9+ +&#("(-*#!-/9*4$9 !/ "

=8%-#(70,(9 (Q%*,%,59*,"&,!- $(*#"=8%

-(*"*&*,&# &#("(-*#!-*#/9 !/98%-#(#

2.1.4 +9&#.*(%(-*-&XHonesty to Groups\%)6"/9&#-#*-#/$

/ 4"+9#%&#, >/$ !-:-8%-#( *+59( &#&&/-& !- 4" =+

Q%!- 4=+,%,59*,"&,5*""&*-&

2.2 +(Work Efficiency) %)6"= +$0,(" "+9 ,*%-"(:&#)(9% *"&4+!#9!+9*%-")(9*"&,)9#*)*!+9%+#

(-*(/9 %*%-"&9&- 4/9=4:$5*""!+9(G *,!+9#%

(#(,, 2551 : 35) *,+9#%

+;HSODG) 1. +9&#.*(%(-*(*" (HS)

2~+9&#.*(%(-*,&&* (HO) 3~+9&#.*(%(-*9 (HD) 4~+9&#.*(%(-*-& (HG)

tZd^

1~+9 4"(9*"*)*!+9(RW) 2~+9":$ # (TW) 3~+9="!+9(G (SW)

(5)

2.2.1 +9 4"(9*"*)*!+9XReliable Work\%)6"=0,(" "+9,!+9

*%-")(9*", 6 *)*!+9 (-*(#+:#%"*)#: */$- -%/*"&

2.2.2 +9":$ #XTimeliness Work Success\%)6"=0,(" "+9, )0,(" !+9,*,%/9:$-#"(%#*((G ( '"!#9

2.2.3 +9="!+9(GXStandardized Work\%)6"=0,(" "+9, )0,("&&#)(9*"%,9*%4:$,&,)9#(4+**$+$

&#,&"*4,/9"!+9((G&,)9# '""&

$ -#59"(9$:!+9#-=90,("+9,&#/9&#4&/0,("+9#%

&#.*(% '",(*"=9*9 -&&#.*(%:#% 'G/0,("+9,

*$-"=/9",&#-*)*:$ (#="!+9(G.6"-*/9+

4" :8%(-*(*" *-#"*"&=9#$%$6"( '"59*(G!#9+" '

56 /

^: &#.*(%/0,("&#= ,",#, 4"

3. #(. /

3.1 34#.445

-(#*%-" /9/#$%!+9-",/)67"+4"&

*#67$4#421 & X4"&*#67} 2558 j#:,!.+\ .6"$4", ( )67 &*"* /9/:,#,#59*:,,*,).6"+4$+:,,,*,) "!7%!%"-(#*%-" '"+$4#421 &!+9,,,*,), '" '$4#274 +:

,,*,) )(9*"&,)9# '"+&+:*(=(*,,9*% 65.08 .6"*+&9*",Aaker, Kummar and Day X2001 : 1\!+94*#--",,*,) "!7%(9*"*((*,,*%-"9*%9*% 20

$6"$)*#-%*,!+9#-5+5*"59* /#&59*%#/:,59* '" '47 # ,( '"(-# 15 (& – 30 R$% 2558

3.2 (5)4') 3

&#.*(%/0,(":(#*.6")$4**: 4 +9$4#20 59*!+9- 1) +9&#.*(%(-*(*" $4#5 59*8+%&*,& '*%#,&#.*(" '"&#&+0,((-*

(*" 2) +9&#.*(%(-*,&&* $4#5 59* 8+%&*,& '*%#,0,((-*,&&*/

-#%"#)6"= , &#%%&#*%,(-*,&&* 3\+9&#.*(%(-*9 $4#

5 59*8+%&*,& '*%#,R( +"**&#,=+*,(-*9 0,(*!+9,*,%

4) +9&#.*(%(-*-& $4#5 59* 8+%&*,& '*%#,,"&#&+:/9&#-#*

-#/$/ 4"R(+"**0,((-*-&

4":(#(.6")$4**:3 +9$4#15 59*!+9-

1) +9 4"(9*"*)*!+9 $4#5 59* 8+%&*,& '*%#,/0,("4*59*

&#-*)*2) +9:$ # $4#5 59* 8+%&*,& '*%#,,#/ 4"

/94:$-#"(4+# 3) +9="!+9(G $4# 5 59* 8+%&*,& '*%#,

(6)

=0,(" :!((G 4+*%-"&

3.3 5) .(

=9#$%!+9 4 +*,&#*&# %"("5*"&*"*8+%#&&-*4$$4 :%59*XDiscriminant Power\8+%/9 &&Item-total Correlation .6"&#.*(%/0,("

&-*4$$4Xr\*%-#-"0.799 – 0.8700 4"&-*4$$4Xr\*%-#-"

0.554 – 0.743 .6"*+&9*",Nunnally X1978\!+94*#-&-*4$$4#-0.40 :&- %*,!+9#- 59*&4)&#*+&9*",$+-"%/#$%&-&#*XReliability\5*",,*,) :%+9 8+%/9&- >* XAlpha Coefficient Method\(#5*"&*,&XCronbact) .6"&#.*(%/0,(" &- >* *%-#-" 0.844 – 0.890 4"

&- >* *%-#-" 0.658 – 0.7198.6"*+&9*",Nunnally and Bernstein X1994\!+94*#-

&-&#*5*"&*"*#+.6"*%-/+,#-0.70 :&- %*,!+9#-&*"*&#

$4!/9/:,#,#59*,-(#*%-"!+9 3.4 $#"0 /

4,#$%& '" '=9#$%!+9/9#&)+)*%,,& +*,&#5*"

&#.*(%/0,(", 4"5*"",/)67"+4"

&*#67 .6"5%!+9+" '

WRTS = ȕ_଴+ȕ_ଵHS+ȕ_ଶHO+ȕ_ଷHD+ȕ_ସHG +ᖡ

*WRTS 4"8+%#

HS &#.*(%/0,(" +9&#.*(%(-*(*"

HO &#.*(%/0,(" +9&#.*(%(-*,&&*

HD &#.*(%/0,(" +9&#.*(%(-*9 HG &#.*(%/0,(" +9&#.*(%(-*-&

(7)

4-+?44/34?4

+1#&5*"&#.*(%/0,(", 4"8+%#5*""

,/)67"+4"&*#67

3 WRTS HS HO HD HG VIFs

9

3.87 3.84 3.93 3.87 3.84

S.D. 0.56 0.68 0.62 0.61 0.65

WRTS 0.850* 0.900* 0.897* 0.875*

HS 0.745* 0.645* 0.581* 2.372

HO 0.385* 0.325* 3.145

HD 0.609* 3.393

HG 3.072

%4& ")( +,0.05

$("1 ,#-(#*(-+9&#.6"*$+:Multicollinearity +" '=9#$% 4 +*,Multicollinearity 8+%/9&-VIFs 0#-&-VIFs 5*"(#*&#.*(%

/0,("&-( '"(-2.372 – 3.3933 .6"&-9*%#-10 +"#-(#*&#/+,

!--*/9+Multicollinearity (Black, 2006 : 585)

+2 +*,&#5*" >)+)*%5*"&#.*(%/0,(", 4"8+%#5*"",/)67"+4"&*#67

8( (WRTS)

t p-value J

$($

4(.4 6

&-&" Xa) 3.340 0.174 19.211 0.000*

+9&#.*(%(-*(*"XHS) 0.127 0.056 2.267 0.024*

+9&#.*(%(-*,&&*XHO) 0.064 0.071 0.894 0.372 +9&#.*(%(-*9 XHD) 0.069 0.075 0.921 0.358

+9&#.*(%(-*-&XHG) -0.014 0.067 -0.211 0.833 F = 8.537 p = 0.000 Adj R² = 0.099

%4& ")( +,0.05

$("2 ,#-&#.*(%/0,("+9&#.*(%(-*(*" &#

= ,",#, / 4"8+%#*"$&#.*(%/0,("(9$&#

.*(%(-*(*": 'G5*"&#.*(%(-*,&&*(-*9 (-*-&!(4+, 8+%&#.*(%

(8)

%":$%,59* =90,("+9,(9*"%6+)*0,(: 'G =9*,#, 6"0,("+9#%&#.*(%$(.*("(-*#!-&+8"!-*#"0,("("(&#:$"

"+9,(9*" (-*#!+9(G 4& +59* 4*(9*"&#-*)* =9/9 )4!*,(+/$!+9*%-")(9*" -#" *+&9*","#$%5*"*"$ (2555j , &+%-*\,#-,(9*"(/9&#4&(-*0,(&(*,$%,,+9 7&#,&#.*(%$(9"&#*/4*59*&"!#9.6")#+9,

*=0,("5*", &#-*)*8%(-*(+/$*%-" 9$" 4*(-*=9/9"

#)6":# "/0,((* 4"5*",/956 '*+&9*",

"#$%5*" 8>,"(2554 j43\,#-$99 ",R(&-%9%%+ 4/9"

)(9*"R(&-%.*(%&#,=+*,R(&-%8-"/(#$*,!+9*R(:

+5*"*"&:=9$(7(-*! '&*"$"/$/-R >" &( +(-*R(

4"*%-"$%"(="$%"

&#.*(%/0,("+9&#.*(%(-*,&&*+9&#.*(%(-*9 +9&#

.*(%(-*-&!-&#= ,",#, 4"*"$0,((-*=9*

56 '*%-,* 5*""9*"#+9*(-*R(* 45*"&)9!+9,"(9*"#+9*/

"-+R(:**+(-)9"(9:!/"-,:*$!+9=R(/"-,**,&&-#/-

*,/9=9*/$+"&#.*(%/0,("(-*($6"$-"=/9(/9&#.*(%,!%"=9/98+%

&#.*(%/ 4"$-"=8+%("(-*(#*"7-#,&& &**"*,9/(#=90,(#-:&

&#.*(%*!-*$ '#!)6"=(-**"!%"-#%"*"&.6"*+&9*", Innes andMitra (2013jAbtract\,#-$ *+*,&#!-.*(%$-(#*%-"/G*8., *+%, &*%

*,&&0,("-#,*-#"-#/-:&!-.*(%$8* $ 4/9,&& '!-.*(%

&#!-.*(%:*,:8&(+(-*+" '&#!-.*(%*$%,!+9,!#%"&(+(-*%#59*",&!- .*(% -!&:%"8* $(+ '*&#!-.*(% - '*+&9*","#$%5*"Church (2012jAbstract\,#-=94*%" ""!-&#.*(%(-*,&&*(-*9 (-**"&

*"$=8%-##-"=9$+", 4/9&#.*(%(-*=9/9%" ""+

9*%".6"-"=/9%"%#,",!- 4/9%"%#,$+&#

=++8+%!-&46")6"&#%% *$$+56 '(-*=9/9%" "" '!+9 +*,& '" *"

8+%=9,/9&#4&&-"&++9&#.*(%$((-*9 /0,("5*",&,#-

=9$+",,"(#*"+9&#.*(%/0,(" =8%-#56 '

(9)

5-++ 0. 3 / 348" /

5.1 0. 3 /

5.1.1 &# 467&##-"&#.*(%(-*(*", 4"

5*",&-%*J *%6+)*:$%,&-%/0,("/9+ "+

5.1.2 &# 467%, %,&#.*(%/0,(",$$%* J*459* !+9 4+:# "/0,(*,$+*"&(*+$:# "/9!5

* /+4"(-*!

5.1.3 &# 467/"6*& '"#-(/+&#.*(%+9&#.*(%(-*,&&*

+9&#.*(%(-*9 +9&#.*(%(-*-&$6"!--"=(-* / 4"5*", 5.2 8" /

5.2.1 =9*4#%/)67"+4"&*#67&#/9-"

*"&#.*(%(-*(*"*%-"(-**"4*.6"$-#% / 4"5*",&/*"&

%"56 '

5.2.2 ",/)67"+4"&*#67&#/9&#4&

, 4"/9 8+%()6"&#4&5*"&#.*(%(-*(*"/ 4"*%-*

*/9+4",=(9%5*"=9,)67

5.2.3 =9*4#% /)67"+4"&*#67&#"

/9"&#.*(%$(8+%9+9.*(%(-*(*" .6"$-"="+(-* 4"

6. 5?4/

&#.*(%/0,(" +9&#.*(%(-*(*" &#= ,",#, 4" + '" '",/)67"+4"&*#67 &#4 59* !+9$#$%& '" '!/9: 'G/0,("+9#%&#.*(%$(.*("(-*#

.6")*:$%, 4&5*"=9*,#,=9,&#9"&-%+9&#.*(%

/0,(" 595:"/+4 *%-"*9"&#-*)*5*"*"&*%-"%"%

.0

#"67#~ (2551). " j~

(,$*~ (2542). " j! %#I~

*"$ ~ (2555). !" # $% & !' ()

$%+ ,%-" ./& ! # %,~~&. # %%

&.

8>,". (2554). 0)&1()2 +# &342. " j%-"I"

=-+"&4",I*"&&#9~

,7%""~ (2555). 603)47Integrity84/ &9*18 &2557}$

http://www.gotoknow.org/posts/408036.

(10)

#(,~(2551\~, !() .1 99, 3")& !' () :49)4147%84/(' !));0)~# %,~~

&~# %%&~

#*4~(2555\~ $%03) 1 4(& '" 21)~" j*8!"~

/$7~(2546\~ & !'/ (& '" 5)~" j&# %$+

),0# ~

4"&*#67~(2558\~.<:/1 #! )%<:

&9*20&2558,$httpjwww~vec~go~th~

&*~(2554\~ 0)&1()2 +# &342 " j%-"I"

=-+"& 4",I*"&&#9~

Aaker, D~ V~, Kumer V~, Day, G~ S~X2001\~Marketing research 77^th ed8 New York jJohn Wiley & Sons~

Black, K~(2006\~Businesses statistics >4For contemporary decision making~(4^th ed~\~USA jJohn Wiley &

Sons~

Church, B. K. (2012\~Shared interest and honesty in budget reporting44Accounting, Organizations and Society~37,155-167~

Innes, R., & Arnab, M. (2013\~4Economic Inquiry. 51(1), 722-734~

Nunnally, J~G~, & Bernstein, I~H~(1994\~Psychometric theory 73^rded8~New York jMcGraw-Hill~