PHAP LUAT & BAN DOC
f n i N \ i \ \ r i i i s i , ' * ( « '•.>[! (M
l«ll>r!,,.t.o*^M.-.
H U Y E N M A N G Y A N G - GIA LAI:
Bl THir HUYEN UY X i m UfNe" CHO DOANH NGHIEP GIA OINH CHIEM Gia THAI PHEP 45 HA HAT CONG ?
Thdi gian gdn day, mpt sd cdng ddn cU tru tgi huyen MangYang (Gia Lai) lien tuc gdi dcfn din Oy ban Kie'm tra tinh dy Gia Lai vd cdc ccf quan bdo, ddi de td cdo dng LUdng Nggc Thiep, Bi thd huyin uy MangYang Icfl dung chdc quyen
"phd phep" cho gia dinh xdm chiem 45 ha ddt cdng. Phdng vien Phdp Ly dd ve tdn ndi de tim hieu thdc hUvu viic.
DEM 45 HA OAT CONG CHO MUON: CHUYEN ^J
"THAT" NHl/"OUA"d MANGYANG
Cdng ty chd Ayun (tiln thdn Id Ndng trudng ehe Ayun-PV) ddng chdn tren dia bdn huyen MangYang. Do eung cdch dieu hdnh Idng l i o nen hidu qud kinh doanh lao dde dan den tai sdn bj ke bien di thi hdnh an vao nam 2012.
D i l n hinh cho each qudn ly cau thd, thieu trdch nhiem nay la vide Ldnh dao Cdng ty che Ayun cho Cdng ty Lpi Dien mUpn dat.
La mdt doanh nghiep sdn xuat, kinh doanh phdn hdu CO vi sinh, trdng cay Idy cu, cay ldu nam, Cdng ty Co phan Phat t r i l n b i n vdng Ndng Ldm nghiep Lpi D i l n (gpi tat la edng ty Lpi D i l n - PV) cd tru sd ddt tai 168 Tran Hung Dao, thj tran Kon Ddng, huyen Mang Yang, chd tjeh HDQTIdbaDoThjKhdy.
Ngay 15/10/2010, chdp thdi eo edng ty che Ayun ngap nghe bd vdc pha san, cong ty Lpi D i l n lam don xin mUpn 50 ha dat bd hoang tai ddi 744, dja bdn xd Dak Djang de trdng cay thUc nghiem phdn bdn. Don do ba Dd Thi Khay ky tdn ddng dau, dupc dng Nguyen Minh Qudn, giam ddc cdng ty che Ayun ky xac nhan ddng y.
Ddng thdi, dng LUOng Ngpc Thiep, chd tjch UBND huyen MangYang eung true tiep k^ ten, ddng dau "bdo chdng"
trong don.
T i l p dd, ngdy 20/10/2010, hai edng ty da t i l n hanh giao nhan thue dja 45 ha dat kem so d6 vj tri, gidi cdn.
Trong Bien bdn va sodd, dai dien ben giao la dng Nguyen Trpng Ldm, Phd gidm doc cdng ty ehe Ayun cdn dai dien ben nhan van la ba Dd Thj Khay (trong khi luc nay, giam ddc cdng ty Lpi Dien la dng Dd Van Khdnh - PV).
Nhu vdy, chi bdng mdt Id don mUpn dat h i t sde don
gian, Cdng ty Loi D i l n da nghiem nhien nam gid 45 ha dat ma khdng phat chju bat ky mdt rang budc traeh nhiem hay nghTa vu tdi chinh nao trong Idc cdng ty che Ayun ehuan bj gidi the.
Viec cdng ty ehe Ayun t u quyen eho edng ty Lpi Dien mupn dat da vi pham nghiem trpng Ludt Dat dai 2003 va Nghj djnh sd 181/2004/ND - CP cua Chinh phd. Vi edng ty ehe Ayun trude day nguyen la ndng trudng, dupe UBND tinh Gia Lai giao dat khdng thu t i l n de trdng che nen So DT+CT!2/2014 TAP CHl PHAP LY 37
PHAP LUAT & BAN DOC
khong cd quyen chuyin doi, chuyen nhupng, tang eho, cho thue, the chap, bdo ldnh, gdp vdn bdng QSD dat. Chua not d i n viee bd hoang quy dat va eho mupn "khoi khoi" 45 ha ddt d l cdng ty Lpi D i l n sd dyng vao muc dich khae khi chua cd ;? kien cda UBND tinh Gia Lai.
Trudc dp lue eda cdng luan, ngay 25/4/2012 (luc nay dng Thiep da chuyin cdng tde lam Bi thu huyen uy MangYang - PV), UBND huyen MangYang dd "chan chinh" viec nay bdng thdng bdo sd 52/TB-UBND.
Thdng bao khang dinh vtec cdng ty che Ayun cho cdng ty Loi D i l n muon ddt khi dang lam thu tye phd sdn la trdi quy dinh phap ludt va yeu eau thu hdi, huy bd cac giay t d lien quan.Vdi cdng ty Lpi Dien, UBND huyen MangYang ydu eau ddng eae hoat dpng sdn xuat kinh doanh tren dien tich ndy khi chua dUoe co quan cd tham quyin giao ddt, cho thue dat theo quy dinh.
CHU T K H HOQT C 6 N G TY LOI D\iU L A M E V C B I T H U H U Y | N UY?
Phdt Id ydu cau eda UBND huyen MangYang, hOn hai nam qua cdng ty Loi Dien van "kien cudng" bam try vd day manh cac hoat dpng dau t u ha tang, sdn xuat tai khu dat "vdng"
nay.
Td qudc Id 19 chung tdi re vdo con dddng dat dd vdi nhdng vudn tieu xanh tdt dep nhu mo trdi dai hai ben dudng. Vao sdu chdng hai cay sd la den khu dat cua cdng ty Lpi Dien tren ddi 744. Mdt vung dat bdng phang vdi cdc tuyen dudng phdn Id dai tft tdp cd hao ranh va hang 38 TAPCHIPHAPLV S5DT+CT12/2014
--«**^*-
Dudng phdn Id chay ddi gida hai thda ddtdd trong san cua cdng ty LgiOiin.
rdo kem gai vay bpc ehung quanh.
Phan Idn dien tieh dd dupe cay xdi trdng sdn, vat gian nha dang dupe xdy dung thap thodng an hien trong lum cdy trung tam vdi hethdng dien ludi dupc keo d i n tan nOi.Tdt ca moi tha deu quy cu ddu ra day ehdng td chu nhdn dang nuoi mdng ldu dai tai day.
Tim gap mdt sd hd ddn gan dd, qua trao ddi nhieu ngudi phdn dnh vdi ehung toi, tuy gidy t d eho mupn chi ghi cd 45 ha nhUng thuc t l dien tieh cdng ty Lpi D i l n dang chiemgidtaidaytrenSOha. Nenkhi cd don thd td cao, cdng ty nay da chuyen nhupng "chui" khodng 5 ha eho bd T.N d thj tran Kon Ddng vdi gia t i l n tren nam tram trieu va edn dang chuan bj nhieu "phi vu" sang nhuong khac?
Vi sao cdng ty Lpi Dien lai dupc dac quyen Uu ai nhUvay? Lan theo ndi dung eae don thu td eao, t d cdc ngudn tin thu thdp ehung tdi
cd CO sd xdc dinh ba Do Thj Khay, Chu tjch HDQT cdng ty Lpi Diln ehinh la me vp eda dng LUOng Ngpc Thiep duong nhiem Bi thU huyen iiy huyen MangYang. Cd nghTa cdng ty Loi D i l n ehfnh la "doanh nghiep gia dinh" vj ldnh dao nay. Dieu dd ly gidi vl sao viec eho mupn dat gida cdng ty ehe Ayun va cdng ty Lpi Diln mac dd trai quy djnh phap ludt van dien ra sudn sd, vi sao dng Thiep lai ky, ddng dau "bdo chdng" trong don xin mupn dat. Va dUa vao dau edng ty Loi Dien van "ung dung" ehilm gid 45 ha dat trong khi chd the cho mupn, cdng ty che Ayun thi dd bi
"xda ten" tdhai nam nay.
Vdi dja the trdi rdng ben qudc Id 19 thuan Ipi giao thdong, dat dai mau md, huy&n MangYang tdng duoc ky vpng la diem sang theo hudng phat trien kinh te Ndng, Lam trUdng, Tram trai cua tinh Gia Lai. Nhung vi sai Idm trong phUOng phap qudn 1^ trong luc gid dat tang
P H A P LUAT & BAN DOC
ehdng mat, them vdo dd la te nan lam quyen d l true loi t d dat dai eda mdt sd quan chdc nen n h i l u nam qua, dja ban nay dd trd thanh diem ndng trong viec lan chiem, xd xdo dat rdng, dat cdng. NgUOc lai, nhilu trudng hpp le ra phai dupe den bu khi gidi tda thi ehfnh quyen lai bd qua dan d i n khieu kien keo ddi. (Phdp ly da cd loat bdi phdn dnh trong nhdng sd trude -PV).
K H d N G T H ^ D ^ T I ^ P D l i N T l N H TRANG " N H A D O T Ttr N 6 C " ?
Sang 27/11, chdng tdi da cd budi t i l p xuc vdi dng Truong Van Bidn, Chu tich UBND xd Dak Djang. Ong Bien cho biet:" Sau khi edng ty ehe Ayun Idm dn thua Id phdi phd sdn, tinh da thu hdi toan bd dat dai giao ve cho huydn vd cudi cung huydn lai giao trach nhiem qudn ly cho xa.
Nhung thUe sU chi giao tren danh nghTa vl 45 ha dat eua cdng ty Lpi Dien thi hp van rao gidvd trdng eay ngdn ngay t d mdy nam nay, cd trd ddu ma bdo xa qudn ly? Gid lai nghe ndi t d yeu cau cua edng ty, huyen dang de nghi vdi tinh cho ho t i l p tue thue lai khu dat nay".
Be Idm rd van de nay, Phdng vidn Phdp ly dd den UBND huyen MangYang ddng ky lam viec va trao ddi qua dien thoai vdi dng Vo Le Minh Thien, Trudng phdng TN&MT.
Ong Thien xac nhan khi td chdc bdn dau gid tdi sdn cdng ty che Ayun, cd nhieu tdi sdn gan l i l n tren dat. Vi vdy theo nguyen vpng cua cac td chdc, ed nhan trdng dau gid, UBND huyen da xin y kien UBND tinh thdng nhat ehu truong cho ho thue lal phan dat
Nhdng gian nhd dang dUtycxdy dung trong ldm cdy trung
gdn vdi tai san. Rieng 45 ha cdng ty ehe Ayun eho edng ty Lpi D i l n mupn thi d i n gid hp van gid d l sdn xuat. Vda qua, edng ty Lpi Dien Idp Td trinh xin thue lai dien tich nay vd huydn cung dd cd vdn ban xin y kiln chi dao cua UBND tinh.
Kht chung tdi neu van di cd hay khdng viec cong ty Lpi Dien bang hinh thde ehuyin nhupng hoa mdu dd ban "chui" 5 ha dat nhu phdn dnh cua ngUdi ddn dja phuong thi ed dng Bien va dng Thien d i u trd ldi chUa nghe thay viec nay.
Cd the thay, Ipi dung thdi co cdng ty che Ayun sap phd sdn, bang hinh thde mupn dat, cdng ty Lpi D i l n dd nhanh chdn nhdy vao chilm gid 45 ha dat va viee lam trdi quy dinh phdp ludt nay dupe thue hien trdt Ipt nhd sU "gdp sde" dac idc cija dng Luong Ngpe Thiep (khi do Id Chu tjch UBND huyen). Den khi cdng ty che Ayun giai the, todn bd quy dat phdi hoan tra eho chinh q u y i n dia phUOng quan ly thi doanh
nghiep nay van ehilm gid 45 ha dat de tao tinh hudng "chuyen da rdi"
xong lai IdpTd trinh xin thue lai toan bd dien tieh, mdt hinh thdc "danh bun sang ao". Trong luc cd nhdng cdng nhdn tdng gdn bd vdt cong ty che sudt bao ndm lai khdng the cd ddpc mdnh dat nhd nao di lap vudn san xuat khi cdng ty giai t h i .
"Nha dot t d ndc". Manh khde du tinh vi d i n may cung khdng t h i che day SUthdt h i l n nhien. Cho nen d u luan dang ky vpng bien phdp giai quyet rdt rao cua Uy ban Kilm tra tinh uy va UBND tinh Gia Lai. Khdng chi don gidn Id viee thu hdi hay t i l p tuc cho "doanh nghiep gia dinh" bf thu huyen dy thue 45 ha dat, day edn Id mdt phep t h d tfnh nghiem minh trong thue thi luat phap cda eae co quan edng q u y i n , trudc hien trang dat dai dang trd thanh ngudn loi kech xij di mdt s6"edng bdc"cda dan mac tinh thao tung.
D U Y T H A I So DT+CT12/2014 TAP C H l P H A P L V 3 9
