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
.H\ZRUGV-DYDDUDELFDFRIIHHLQFOXVLYHEXVLQHVVOLQNPHWKRGRORJ\FRRSHUDWLRQIDUPHUVQRQFRRSHUDWLRQIDUPHUV &RUUHVSRQGLQJDXWKRU(PDLOSULVFDFKULVWLDQ#JPDLOFRP
WK WK WK
5HFHLYHG0D\ 5HYLVLRQ-XQH $FFHSWHG-XOL
3ULQW,6612QOLQH,661'2,KWWSG[GRLRUJMPW &RS\ULJKW#3XEOLVKHGE\8QLW5HVHDUFKDQG.QRZOHGJH6FKRRORI %XVLQHVVDQG0DQDJHPHQW,QVWLWXW7HNQRORJL%DQGXQJ6%0,7%
0RGHO%LVQLV,QNOXVLI 5DQWDL1LODL.RSL$UDELND
GL%RQGRZRVR-DZD7LPXU
3ULVFD&KULVWLDQ3HUPDWDVDUL $EGXO%DVLWKGDQ+HWL0XO\DWL)DNXOWDV(NRPRQLGDQ0DQDMHPHQ,QVWLWXW3HUWDQLDQ%RJRU
3HQGDKXOXDQ
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
5HMR 7DQL PHUXSDNDQ NRSHUDVL NRSL GL %RQGRZRVR \DQJ EHUGLUL SDGD WDKXQ 7HUEHQWXNQ\D NRSHUDVL 5HMR 7DQL PHPEXDW %RQGRZRVR GLWHWDSNDQ VHEDJDL ZLOD\DK ´5HSXEOLN .RSLµ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
6HODLQ LWX /XQG\ PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD %HODQGD PHPLOLNL VHEXDK RUJDQLVDVL +LYRV \DQJ EHUNRQWULEXVL GDODP SHUGDJDQJDQ NRSL \DQJ DGLO GDQ EHUNHODQMXWDQ +LYRV EHUVDPD .HQ\DPHQJHPEDQJNDQPRGHO/HYHUDJH4XDOLW\ ,PSURYHPHQW/4,/4,EHUWXMXDQDJDUSHWDQL UDN\DW GDSDW PHPSHUEDLNL NRQGLVL SHULODNX SHWDQL VHKLQJJD SHWDQL GDSDW OHELK SURGXNWLI GDODP PHPSURGXNVL NRSL .HEHUODQMXWDQ ELVQLV NRSL NKXVXVQ\D SHWDQL \DQJ PHQMXDO PHODOXLNRSHUDVLGDQSHQJXPSXOGL.DEXSDWHQ %RQGRZRVRSHUOXGLNDMLOHELKPHQGDODP
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
3HWDQLNRSHUDVL5HMR7DQLWHODKPHQXQMXNNDQ NHLQNOXVLIDQ GDODP UDQWDL QLODL +DO LQL GLEXNWLNDQGHQJDQDGDQ\DNHWHUOLEDWDQSHWDQL GDODP SHQHQWXDQ KDUJD NRSL GDQ GDODP SHQJDPELODQ NHSXWXVDQ LQRYDVL SURGXN 6HGDQJNDQ SHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL EHOXP PHQXQMXNNDQNHLQNOXVLIDQNDUHQDSHWDQLQRQ NRSHUDVL PHPDVDUNDQ SURGXN GHQJDQ KDUJD \DQJ WHODK GLWHWDSNDQ ROHK SHQJXPSXO GDQ KXEXQJDQ \DQJ EDLN NXUDQJ WHUMDOLQ GDODP UDQWDL QLODL VHKLQJ J D NXUDQJ PHPLOLNL NHWHUOLEDWDQ GDODP SHQJDPELODQ NHSXWXVDQ LQRYDVLSURGXN
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
0HWRGRORJL3HQHOLWLDQ
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
+DVLO GDUL ZDZDQFDUD GDQ NXLVLRQHU \DQJ GLGDSDWNDQ NHPXGLDQ GLDQDOLVLV GDQ GLRODK XQWXN PHQGDSDWNDQ GDWD GDQ LQIRUPDVL \DQJ GLLQJLQNDQ GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ DODWOLQN PHWKRGRORJ\ \DQJ PHOLSXWL SHWD UDQWDL QLODL ELVQLVNDQYDVSULQVLSPRGHOELVQLVEDUXGDQ VLNOXV SURWRWLSH/LQN PHWKRGRORJ\ PHUXSDNDQ DODW \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL NHLQNOXVLIDQ SHWDQL UDN\DW GDODP UDQWDL SDVRNQ\D
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
6LNOXV SURWRWLSH PHUXSDNDQ PHWRGH WHUDNKLU GDODPOLQN PHWKRGRORJ\ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQJXML PHQJHYDOXDVL SURGXN DWDX VLVWHP VHFDUD EHUXODQJ VHKLQJJD SURGXN DWDX VLVWHP WHUVHEXWGDSDWGLNHPEDQJNDQ6HKLQJJDVLNOXV SURWRWLSH GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQGHVDLQ VXDWX VLVWHP DWDX SURGXN DJDU-DYD $UDELFD &RIIHH GDSDW GLNHPEDQJNDQ VHKLQJJD SHWDQL GDSDW PHUDVDNDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQ
+DVLOGDQ3HPEDKDVDQ
0RGHO%LVQLV,QNOXVLI -DYD$UDELFD&RIIHH
0RGHOELVQLVLQNOXVLI PHUXSDNDQPRGHOELVQLV \DQJ WHU MDGL NDUHQD DGDQ\D KXEXQJ DQ NHPLWUDDQ \DQJ PHQGXNXQJ SHODNX ELVQLV .HPLWUDDQ EHUSHQJDUXK XQWXN PHPSHUNHFLO NHVHQMDQJDQ \DQJ WHUMDGL DQWDU SHODNX GDODP UDQWDLVHKLQJJDWHUMDOLQKXEXQJDQ\DQJVDOLQJ PHQJXQWXQJNDQ 0RGHO ELVQLV LQNOXVLI PHQXUXWOLQNPHWKRGRORJ\PHQFDNXSLGHQWLILNDVL UDQWDLQLODLPRGHOELVQLVNDQYDVSULQVLSPRGHO ELVQLVEDUXGDQVLNOXVSURWRWLSH\DQJPDVLQJ PDVLQJDNDQGLEDKDVVHEDJDLEHULNXW
5DQWDL 1LODL .RSL -DYD $UDELND GL .DEXSDWHQ %RQGRZRVR
5DQWDLSDVRNPHUXSDNDQVHUDQJNDLDQNHJLDWDQ SURGXNWLI GDUL KXOX NH KLOLU \DQJ VDOLQJ EHUKXEXQJDQ SDGD VHWLDS NHJLDWDQ GDQ PHPEHQWXN VXDWX UDQWDL QLODL GDODP VHEXDK LQGXVWUL 6HKLQJJD VHWLDS LQGXVWUL PDPSX PHPLOLNLGD\DVDLQJGDQWHWDSGDSDWPHQMDJD NLQHUMD GDQ SHUIRUPD LQGXVWUL WHUVHEXW 2OHK N D U H Q D L W X V D O D K V D W X \ D Q J G D S D W PHPSHQJDUXKL GD\D VDLQJ LQGXVWUL GDODP PHUDLK NLQHUMD SHUGDJDQJDQ \DQJ RSWLPDO DGDODKUDQWDLQLODL\DQJHIHNWLI
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
SHWDQL 83+ NRSHUDVL HNVSRUWLU HNVSRUWLUEHVDU 8QLW3HQJRODKDQ+DVLO %XGLGD\D GDQ SDVFDSDQHQ 3HQJRODKDQ +6 3HQJRODKDQ JUHHQEHDQ 3HPEXDWDQ EXEXNNRSL 3HQJLULPDQ NHSHPEHOL .RQVXPHQ GDODPQHJHUL .RQVXPHQ OXDUQHJHUL SHWDQL SHURUDQJDQ NDIHZDUXQJ NRSL SHWDQL NRSHUDVL SHWDQL SHQJXPSXO SHURUDQJDQ NDIHZDUXQJ NRSL /LQJNXQJDQ 6RVLDO%XGD\D .HELMDNDQ3HPHULQWDK 7HNQRORJL (NRQRPL
0LWUD.HUMD
/HYHO\DQJNHGXDSDGDUDQWDLQLODL\DLWXPLWUD NHUMD 0LWUD NHUMD PHUXSDNDQ DNWRU HNVWHUQDO \DQJEHUSHQJDUXKGDQEHUSHUDQSHQWLQJGDODP IXQJVL ELVQLV VHKLQJJD NLQHUMD PHQMDGL OHELK HILVLHQ/XELVPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZDPLWUD NHUMD PHPSXQ\DL SHUDQDQ SHQWLQJ GDODP PHPEHULNDQ SHODWLKDQ GDQ SHPELPELQJDQ VHFDUD ODQJVXQJ NHSDGD SHWDQL NRSL GDQ P H P E L P E L Q J S H W D Q L S H P X O D G D O D P PHQJKDGDSLSHUPDVDODKDQ\DQJVHULQJWHUMDGL NKXVXVQ\DEDJLSHWDQLNRSL$UDELND0DQGDLOLQJ 1DWDO %HUGDVDUNDQ KDO WHUVHEXW PDND GLSHUOXNDQPLWUDNHUMDGDODPUDQWDLQLODLDJDU SHWDQLGDSDWOHELKVHMDKWHUDGDQPHQGDSDWNDQ NHXQWXQJDQ GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ DNWRU ODLQQ\D
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
$3(., EHUWLQGDN VHEDJDL SHUZDNLODQ SHWDQL GDQVHEDJDLSHUDQWDUDDJDUSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVL GDSDWEHUJDEXQJGHQJDQNRSHUDVL3HWDQLODLQ \DLWXSHWDQLNRSHUDVLGDQSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVL PHPLOLNLKXEXQJDQ\DQJVDOLQJPHJXQWXQJNDQ NDUHQD VDOLQJ EHU WXNDU LQIRU PDVL GDQ SHQJDODPDQVHKLQJJDSURVHVSHQJRODKDQNRSL EHUMDODQVHVXDLVWDQGDUSHQJRODKDQ
3HQJDUXK(NVWHUQDO
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
0RGHOELVQLVLQNOXVLI PHUXSDNDQPRGHOELVQLV \DQJ WHU MDGL NDUHQD DGDQ\D KXEXQJDQ NHPLWUDDQ \DQJ PHQGXNXQJ SHODNX ELVQLV .HPLWUDDQ \DQJ SDOLQJ EHUSHQJDUXK EDJL SHWDQLNRSHUDVLGDQSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVLDGDODK GXNXQJDQGDUL3HPGD%RQGRZRVR0HVNLSXQ GXNXQJDQ GDUL 3HPGD WLGDN VHFDUD ODQJVXQJ GLUDVDNDQSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVLQDPXQSHWDQL
QRQNRSHUDVL GDSDW PHUDVDNDQ NHELMDNDQ SHPHULQWDK VHKLQJJD SHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL GDSDW PHQMDODQNDQ XVDKD NRSL WDQSD DGDQ\D IOXNWXDVLKDUJD
0RGHO %LVQLV .DQYDV .RSL $UDELND GL .DEXSDWHQ %RQGRZRVR
3HQHOLWLDQ SDGD-DYD $UDELFD GL %RQGRZRVR PHUXSDNDQ PRGHO ELVQLVRIIHUGULYHQ\DLWX LQRYDVL \DQJ GLEXDW XQWXN PHQFLSWDNDQ QLODL S U R S R U V L \ D Q J E D U X V H K L Q J J D G D S D W PHPEHULNDQ GDPSDN NHSDGD VHJPHQ EORN \DQJ ODLQ 3HUEHGDDQ PRGHO ELVQLV NDQYDV SHWDQLNRSHUDVLGDQSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVLGDSDW GLOLKDWSDGD*DPEDU
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
3HWDQL NRSHUDVL GDQ QRQNRSHUDVL GDSDW PHPLOLNL VHJPHQ SHODQJJDQ GHQJDQ EDQWXDQ NHPLWUDDQ \DQJ GLPLOLNL .HPLWUDDQ \DQJ WHUMDOLQ SDGD SHWDQL NRSHUDVL PHOLSXWL 3HPGD %RQGRZRVR $3(., %DQN %, %DQN -DWLP
3XVOLWNRND GDQ 3HUKXWDQL 6HGDQJNDQ SDGD SHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVLSHWDQLPHQMDOLQNHPLWUDDQ GHQJDQ SHWDQL NRSHUDVL SHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL ODLQGDQSHQJXPSXO
3URSRVLVL QLODL PHUXSDNDQ SURGXN \DQJ PHPLOLNL QLODL WDPEDK \DQJ GLEHULNDQ NHSDGD NRQVXPHQGDQGDSDWPHQDPEDKQLODLNHSDGD VHJPHQWDVL \DQJ OHELK VSHVLILN 6XWDQG\R PHQ\DWDNDQEDKZDSURSRVLVLQLODLSDGD 0RQRSROH &RIIHH /DE \DLWX EHUIRNXV SDGD SHUIRUPDQFHEHUXSDSHOD\DQDQGDQPXWXSURGXN \DQJ GLEHULNDQ 3DGD SURSRVLVL QLODL-DYD $UDELFD&RIIHSDGDSHWDQLNRSHUDVLGDQSHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL PHPLOLNL SHUVDPDDQ VHSHUWL SHQMXDODQ EXDK NRSL ELML +6 NHULQJ 26( NHULQJJUHHQEHDQGDQEXEXNNRSLQDPXQSDGD SHWDQL NRSHUDVL WHUGDSDW SHQMXDODQ EXDK NXDOLWDVUHQGDKGDQSDGDSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVL WHUGDSDW SHQMXDODQJUHHQ EHDQ KRQH\ 3DGD SURSRUVLQLODL-DYD$UDELFD\DQJEHUSHUDQGDODP SHPEHQWXNDQ QLODL WDPEDK \DLWX NLQHUMD NXVWRPLVDVL PHUHNVWDWXV GDQ DNVHV .XVWRPLVDVL PHU XSDNDQ SURGXN \DQJ GLVHVXDLNDQGHQJDQNHEXWXKDQNRQVXPHQKDO LQL VHVXDL GHQJDQ NHDGDDQ SDGD UDQWDL SDVRN SHWDQL NRSL 0HUHNVWDWXV GHQJDQ ,*-DYD $UDELFD&RIIHHVXGDK GLNHQDO NRQVXPHQ VHKLQJJD PHPEHULNDQ QLODL WDPEDK GDODP PHQLQJNDWNDQVWDWXVVRVLDOHNRPRQLSHQLNPDW SURGXN-DYD$UDELFD
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
*DPEDU 0RGHO%LVQLV. DQ YDV -D YD$UDELFD&RI IHH 3 HWDQL. RSHUDVLGDQ3 HWDQL1RQ. RSHUDVL
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
3ULQVLS 0RGHO %LVQLV %DUX -DYD $UDELFD &RIIHH GL .DEXSDWHQ%RQGRZRVR
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
+XEXQJDQ DQWDUD SHWDQL GHQJDQ PLWUD NHUMD GDSDW GLOLKDW GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ NULWHULD NHWHUOLEDWDQ 3HQLODLDQ WHUVHEXW GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQ NHWHUOLEDWDQ SHWDQL VHUWD PHQLQJNDWNDQ KXEXQJDQ SHWDQL EDLN SHWDQL NRSHUDVLGDQQRQNRSHUDVLGHQJDQSHODQJJDQ 6HODLQLWXSHQLODLDQGLOLKDWEHUGDVDUNDQDVSHN NHXDQJDQ OHPEDJD SHPHULQWDKDQ GDQ
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
1LODLWHUWLQJJLSDGDSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVL\DLWX SULQVLS NHWLJD 3HWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL PHPLOLNL WUDQVSDUDVL GDQ SHPEDJLDQ ULVLNR \DQJ MHODV NDUHQD VHWLDS SHQJDPELODQ NHSXWXVDQGLODNXNDQROHKSHWDQLPDNDULVLNR \DQJ DGD DNDQ GLWDQJJJXQJ ROHK SHWDQL WHUVHEXW 6HODLQ LWX VHEDJLDQ EHVDU SHWDQL PHPLOLNL NRQWUDN GDQ PHNDQLVPH SHPEHOLDQ \DQJ MHODV DJDU NRQVXPHQ SHUFD\D NHSDGD SURGXNNRSL\DQJGLMXDO1LODLWHUHQGDKSDGD SHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL \DLWX SULQVLS NHHQDP 3HWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL PHPLOLNL NHOHPDKDQGDODPPHQJXPSXONDQPHUDQFDQJ GDQ PHQJHYDOXDVL SHQHOLWLDQ VHKLQJ JD VHEDJLDQ EHVDU SHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL EHNHUMD VDPD GHQJDQ SHWDQL NRSHUDVL XQWXN GDSDW PHPSHUROHKLQIRUPDVL2OHKNDUHQDLWXSHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL NXUDQJ PHODNXNDQ NHJLDWDQ SHQHOLWLDQGDQHYDOXDVLNLQHUMDXVDKDQ\D
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
VHFDUD OHELK FHSDW GDQ HIHNWLI \DQJ GLVDMLNDQ GDODP EHQWXN SHWD 'DODP SHQHOLWLDQ VLNOXV SURWRWLSH PHUXSDNDQ DODW DQDOLVLV WHUDNKLU GDODPOLQN PHWKRGRORJ\ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHUDQFDQJPHQJXMLGDQPHQJHYDOXDVLVHFDUD EHUNHODQMXWDQ PRGHO ELVQLV DJDU GDSDW EHUNHPEDQJ/XQG\PHQ\DWDNDQEDKZD V L N O X V S U R W R W L S H P H U X S D N D Q P H W R G H SHQJHPEDQJDQVLVWHP\DQJGDSDWPHQJXMLGDQ PHQJHYDOXDVL SURGXN DWDX VLVWHP VHFDUD EHUXODQJVHKLQJJDSURGXNDWDXVLVWHPWHUVHEXW GDSDWGLNHPEDQJNDQ7XMXDQQ\DDGDODKXQWXN PHQGHVDLQPHQJXMLGDQPHQJHYDOXDVLPRGHO ELVQLV DJ DU VLVWHP DWDX SURGXN GDSDW GLWLQJNDWNDQ%HUGDVDUNDQDQDOLVLVSDGDSHWDQL NRSHUDVL GDQ SHWDQL QRQNRSHUDVL GLUDQFDQJ VXDWX LQRYDVL XQWXN GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQ GDQ PHPSHUEDLNL SURGXNVL VHKLQJJD GLGDSDWNDQ XVDKDNHEHUODQMXWDQSDGDSHWDQLNRSL,QRYDVL GDQ SHQJHYDOXDVLDQ EHUXSD SHQJDPELODQ NHSXWXVDQ GDQ SHUHQFDQDDQ LQRYDVL GDODP NHJLDWDQ SURGXNVL NRSL 3DGD EDJLDQ EHULNXW DNDQGLEDKDVVLNOXVSURWRWLSHSHWDQLNRSHUDVL GDQSHWDQLQRQNRSHUDVL 3HWDQLPHPLOLNLLQRYDVLGDODPPHQFDSDLNHEHUODQMX WDQXVDKDNRSL 3HWDQLGDSDWPHQ\HOHVDLNDQPDVDODK 3HWDQLGDSDWPHQJDPELONHSXWXVDQ 3HWDQL\DQJEHOXPPDQGLUL 3HPGD.DEXSDWHQ%RQGRZRVR 3XVOLWNRND 7XMXDQ XWDPD 7XMXDQ 0DVDODK $OWHUQDWLI .HWHUJDQWXQJDQ DODWGDQ WHNQRORJL .HWHUJDQWXQJDQELELWXQJJXO )*' 3HODWLKDQGDQSHQ\XOXKDQ 3URGXN RODKDQODLQ ,QRYDVL 3XSXN 3HPEHQLKDQ NRPSRV 3HQ\RUWLUDQ ELELWXQJJJXO $NWRU .ULWHULD PDVDODK 3DNDQ WHUQDN %ULNHW DUDQJ 6HPLQDU *DPEDU 6WUXNWXU+LHUDUNLGDQ,QRYDVL3HWDQL.RSHUDVL
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
*DPEDU
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
6LPSXODQ
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
'DIWDU3XVWDND
$WNLQVRQ $$ .DSODQ 56 0DWVXPXUD 0 <R X Q J 6 0 0 D Q D J H P H Q W $FFRXQWLQJ8SSHU6DGGOH5LYHU1HZMHUVH\ 863UHQWLFH+DOO%RQQHOO 9 9HJOLR ) ,QFOXVLYH EXVLQHVV IRU VXVWDLQDEOH OLYHOLKRRGV
)LHOG$FWLRQV6FLHQFH5HSRUW7KHMRXUQDO
RI ILHOGDFWLRQV²
>%3$73@ %DGDQ 3HQJHOROD $OLK 7HNQRORJL
3HUWDQLDQ ,QGLNDVLJHRJUDILV GDQ
LQGLNDVL DVDO -DNDUWD %DGDQ 3HQJHOROD $OLK7HNQRORJL3HUWDQLDQ >%33'@ %DGDQ 3HUHQFDQDDQ 3HPEDQJXQDQ 'DHUDK-DZD7LPXU'RNXPHQWDVL + D V L O 3 H O D N V D Q D D Q 3 H P E D Q J X Q D Q .DEXSDWHQ.RWD 6H-DZD 7LPXU 7DKXQ 6XUDED\D %DGDQ 3HUHQFDQDDQ 3HPEDQJXQDQ'DHUDK-DZD7LPXU
'DU\DQWR $ $ULHI 'DU\DQWR 0RGHO
%LVQLV ,QNOXVLI GDODP ,QGXVWUL 6XVX 7URERVFRPKWWSZZZWURERVFRP >'LWMHQEXQ@ 'LUHNWRUDW -HQGHUDO 3HUNHEXQDQ
3URGXNVL .RSL GL .DEXSDWHQ
%RQGRZRVR -DNDUWD 'LUHNWRUDW -HQGHUDO 3HUNHEXQDQ >+XWEXQ@ 'LQDV .HKXWDQDQ GDQ 3HUNHEXQDQ .DEXSDWHQ%RQGRZRVR+XWEXQ .HPHQWULDQ .HKXWDQDQ GDQ /LQJNLQJDQ +LGXS%RQGRZRVR *ROMD 7 3R]HJD 6 ,QFOXVLYH EXVLQHVVZKDWLVLWDOODERXW"PDQDJLQJ LQFOXVLYHFRPSDQLHV-RXUQDO,QWHUQDWLRQDO 5HYLHZRI 0DQDJHPHQWDQG0DUNHWLQJ
+LOPDQXJ UDKD , )DNWRUIDNWRU
NHEHUKDVLODQPRGHOELVQLVLQNOXVLI SDGDUDQWDL QLODLVXVXVDSLVHJDUVWXGLNDVXV.8'JLULWDQL .DEXSDWHQ %RJRU >VNULSVL@ %RJRU ,' ,QVWLWXW3HUWDQLDQ%RJRU
/LNRNR( .LQL-,QFOXVLYHEXVLQHVV ²DEXVLQHVVDSSURDFKWRGHYHORSPHQW -RXUQDORI (QYLURQPHQWDO6XVWDLQDELOLW\
/XELV 1 0RGHO %LVQLV ,QNOXVLI .RSL
$ U D E L N D 0 D Q G D L O L Q J G D Q 6 W U D W H J L 3HQJHPEDQJDQQ\D GL .DEXSDWHQ 0DQGDLOLQJ 1DWDO 6XPDWHUD 8WDUD>VNULSVL@ %RJRU ,',QVWLWXW3HUWDQLDQ%RJRU
/XQG\ 0 /,1. PHWKRGRORJ\ $ SDUWLFLSDWRU\ JXLGH WR EXVLQHVV PRGHOV WKDWOLQNVPDOOKROGHUVWRPDUNHWVS &,$73XEOLFDWLRQ1R /XQG\0/,1.PHWKRGRORJ\YHUVLRQ $ SDUWLFLSDWRU\ JXLGH WR EXVLQHVV PRGHOVWKDWOLQNVPDOOKROGHUVWRPDUNHWV S&,$73XEOLFDWLRQ1R 0DNLQHQ6 6HSSDQHQ0$VVHVVLQJ E X V L Q H V V P R G H O F R Q F H S W V Z L W K WD[RQRPLFDO UHVHDUFK FULWHULD0JPW 5HV
1HZV
0LFKHOLQL / &UHDWLQJ 6KDUHG 9DOXH LQ
/RZ,QFRPH 0DUNHW 6RFLDO ,QQRYDWLRQ DQG 1HZ %XVLQHVV 0RGHOV -HUPDQ 6SULQJHU 9HUODJ%HUOLQ+HLGHOEHUJ
0LFKHOLQL / )LRUHQWLQR ' 1HZ EXVLQHVV PRGHOV IRU FUHDWLQJ VKDUHG YDOXH-RXUQDO 6RFLDO 5HVSRQVLELOLW\
0XO\DZDQ . + )XDG $ 8WDULQL $ 3HQJHPEDQJDQ3URWRWLSH6LVWHP ,QIRUPDVL 0DQDMHPHQ 5HJXODVL 3UDNWLN .HGRNWHUDQ %HUEDVLV :HE 'HQJDQ 3HQGHNDWDQ6LVWHP,QIRUPDVL*HRJUDILV -XUQDO 0DQDMHPHQ 3HOD\DQDQ .HVHKDWDQ ² 0XVWLND$2NWDYLDQL5 6XNDUGL 7UDWHJLHV7R'HYHORS%LRGLHVHO,QGXVWU\ 2I 3W ;<= ,Q 2UGHU 7R ,PSOHPHQW &SR6XSSRUWLQJ)XQG3ROLF\,QGRQHVLDQ -RXUQDO RI %XVLQHVV DQG (QWUHSUHQHXUVKLS 2VWHUZDOGHU$ 3LJQHXU<%XVLQHVV
0RGHO *HQHUDWLRQ -DNDUWD ,' (OH[
0HGLD.RPSXWLQGR
3RUWHU ( 0 &RPSHWLWLYH $GYDQWDJH
& U H D W L Q J D Q G 6 X V W D L Q L Q J 6 X S H U L R U
3HUIRUPDQFH1HZ<RUN86)UHH3UHVV
5HHG':KDWGRFRUSRUDWLRQVKDYHWR GR ZLWK IDLU WUDGH" 3RVLWLYH DQG QRUPDWLYH DQDO\VLV IURP D YDOXH FKDLQ SHUVSHFWLYH-RXUQDORI %XVLQHVV(WKLFV
6DUL16DQWRVR7<XVLDQWR 0DZDUGL6
0HQJHQDO NRSL DUDELND -DYD ,MHQ
5DXQJ NRSL EHUVHUWLILNDW LQGLNDVL JHRJUDILV
SHUWDPD GL -DZD 7LPXU :DUWD 3XVDW
3HQHOLWLDQ.RSLGDQ.DNDR,QGRQHVLD 6DZP\ 0 6 *URZLQJ LQFOXVLYH
EXVLQHVV PRGHOV LQ WKH H[WUDFWLYH LQGXVWULHV GHPRQVWUDWLQJ D VPDUW FRQFHSW WR VFDOH XS SRVLWLYH VRFLDO LPSDFW-RXUQDORI WKH([WUDFWLYH,QGXVWULHV
DQG6RFLHW\
6XWDQG\R ( & 0RGHO ELVQLV SDGD PRQRSROH FRIIHH ODE PHQJJXQDNDQ
EXVLQHVVPRGHOFDQYDV-XUQDO0DQDMHPHQ %LVQLV$JRUD :LFDNVRQR$$6\DULHI5 6XSDUQR2 %XVLQHVV 0RGHO ,Q (OHFWULFLW\ ,QGXVWU\8VLQJ%XVLQHVV0RGHO&DQYDV $SSURDFK 7KH &DVH 2I 3W ;<= ,QGRQHVLDQ -RXU QDO RI %XVLQHVV DQG (QWUHSUHQHXUVKLS =RWW&K$PLW5 0DVVD/7KH EXVLQHVV PRGHO 5HFHQW GHYHORSPHQWV D Q G I X W X U H U H V H D U F K -R X U Q D O R I
