Rethinking Kevin Lynch�s Concept �the Image of the City� in Rethinking Kevin Lynch�s Concept �the Image of the City� in Contemporary Urban View; case study of kampungs, Surabaya- Indonesia - Scientific Repository

L

----L

>--r

rr

\ BBe

*ery

\ _{\ =q*.-- -,2} -7

ASEASIJK

,esKAs&$K

X&

CONFERENCE

L

xffi-xe

trffi"$

4

PROGRAMME

University

of

Brighton

r=4

L-r--a

L-L-1

L

L'

L---a

L

7

-4

L

,.

L.

.1 =J

L

rr

r

L--a

L-L-..4

L-L-a

L-t--a

L-

".-

L-r4

L-

-

L-

t---

L-

r---

L-

t--t_

.4

-4

.-,

-4

-_-J

-a

-a

1

----

_--4

----_.

-a

--L

Contents

Arrivaland

registration...

...2

Conference

Events

...2

Conference schedule at a

glance

. ...3

Panel timetable at a

glance

...4

Useful

information

...6

Getting here and getting around

Brighton.

...1

Performances and

performers

...9

Publishers

Exhibition.

...12

ASEASUK - get

involved....

...13

Panels and

Abstracts....

...14

Campus and city

maps.

...11g

Contact

Us

The academic host for the conference

is Becky

Elmhirst and organisation is being handled by the Events f eam Clare Hodgson and Emily Bretnoll from South Coast Conferences. ln addition, we are being assisted by a number of student volunteers. Please ask any of us for any assistance. To contact South Coast Conferences, email Southcoastevents(dbrishton.ac.uk or telephon e +44-1273-642L56.

To contact Becky Elmhirst, email R.J. Elmhirst(O briehton.ac.uk

Welcome

Welcome to the 2014 ASEASUK Conference, which we are very pleased to be holding at the

University of Brighton. This is the 28th conference of the Association of South-East Asian Studies in

the UK, and we look forward to an exciting programme of academic panels, workshops and cultural

performances in a convivial and friendly setting. The conference has benefited from the generous

support of the James Henry Green Charitable Trust, which has enabled us to hold our dinner at the

Royal Pavilion in Brighton. We are also pleased to include a panel on museology, convened by Helen

Mears, Keeperof World Art, Royal Pavilion & Museums, Brighton. There are 20 panels running

across five parallel sessions over the two days of the conference, and with the exception of the

conference reception and dinner on Saturday evening, all activities take place on the Falmer campus,

offering plenty of opportunity to meet new people and catch up with old friends. This year, the

conference welcomes lndonesian performance artist Agus Nur Amar, generally known as P.M.Toh,

as artist-in-residence. We are also delighted to host Phakamas Jirajarupat and her team of Thai

dancers, who are offering performances and a workshop. ln this document, you will find practical

information about the conference venue and timetable, together with a detailed programme, paper

abstracts and contact details of panellists. lf you have any questions, please contact South Coast

Conferences Event Support (for practical matters) or the academic host Becky Elmhirst (for academic

matters). Contact details may be found on page of this document.

Arrival

and

registration

Registration opens from 15.00 on Friday 1-2th September, Checkland Building Foyer, Falmer Campus,

University of Brighton. lf you are likely to arrive earlier than that time, please notify the Events Team

at

South Coast Conferences. You

will

be able

to

check

into

your room

-

accommodation is on

campus and just a short walk from the registration desk.

Conference Events

Welcome Reception,

Friday

12th September, 18.30,

Westlain

House, Falmer Campus. The

conference will open with a brief ceremony and welcome reception, followed by a refectory dinner

at 19.00. Thanks to generous support from the Ford Foundation, ASEASUK is delighted to welcome

lndonesian performance artist, Agus Nur Amal, known as P.M. Toh, as artist-in-residence at the

conference. As

part

of

our

welcome event,

at

20.30 there

will

be an opportunity

to

see the

documentary film,'Promised Paradise'(dir Leonard Retel Helmrich), which features the work of

P.M.Toh. This is followed

by

discussion, chaired

by

Professor Matthew Cohen, Royal Holloway

University of London, in Room 129, Mayfield Building.

Pre-dinner Drinks Reception, Saturday 13th September, 18.30-20.00, Brighton Dome, Brighton. All

delegates are invited to join us for a complementary drink and to enjoy a performance of Thai court

and folk dances by Ms Phakamas Jirajarupat, Miss Manissa Vasinarom, Miss Pawinee Boonserm,

Miss Purita Rungjirayos, Mr Cheerawat Wanta and Mr.Krailas Chitkul.

Conference Dinner, Saturday 13th September,20.00, Banqueting Room, Royal Pavilion, Brighton.

For those that have booked the conference dinner as part of their registrationpackage. With the

L

['

t:

>--a

L.

---a

L.

---a

L

=-1aa

L-L{

r

rr

L-4

r

L-a

L-.-1

L-L-a

r

L-{

r

1-1

r

.*1

r

.--1

r

l-a

r

r----a

r

a-4

r

.--a

L

a-a

r

.--a

r

r

l--{

r

r.--<

r

r--{

L

t-*.4

r

]--a

r

r---a

L

a*-1

L-L-1

L.

13 ding its conference dinner in the splendour of the Banqueting Room, where 200 years ago

George lV dined in style.

Conference

schedule

at

a

glance

Friday 12th Sept 15.00 onwards Registration and room check-in Checkland Foyer

18.30 Welcome Reception Westlain House

19.00 Refectory Dinner 1"t floor, Westlain House 20.30 Documentary Film Show Mayfield Building

Saturday 13th

Sept

07.30-09.00 Breakfast Westlain House

08.30-09.00 Registration for day delegates Checkland Foyer

09.00-10.30 _{Panels Various rooms} 10.30-11 .00 Tea/coffee Asa Briggs Foyer,

Checkland

1 1.00-13 00 _{Panels Various rooms}

13.00-14.00 _{Lunch Asa Briggs Foyer,}

Checkland

14.00-15.30 _{Panels Various rooms} 15.30-16.00 _{Tea/coffee Asa Briggs Foyer,}

Checkland

16.00-1 7.30 _{Panels Various rooms}

18.30-20.00 Pre-dinner Drinks Reception Brighton Dome

20.00-23.00 Conference Dinner Royal Pavilion

Sunday 14th

Sept

07.30-09.00 Breakfast Westlain House

08.30-09.00 Registration for day delegates Checkland Foyer

09.00-10.30 Panels Various rooms

10.30-1 1 .00 Tea/coffee Asa Briggs Foyer,

Checkland

1 1.00-12.30 Panels Various rooms

12.30-13.15 ASEASUK AGM Checkland C21B

13.15-14.00 _{Lunch Asa Briggs Foyer,}

Checkland

14.00-15.30 _{Panels and workshops Various rooms} 15.30-16.00 Tea/coffee Asa Briggs Foyer,

Checkland

16.00-17.30 _{Panels and workshops Various rooms} 17.30 Closing Ceremony Asa Briggs Foyer,

I o o J o

-L E o o

=

_o G J_(E o L

o

I C 6' 0 cD tr T'

=

)

o

!, tr (E -t_(J o E

o

lv lo l6' laE lU| lo lo IE

l>

l.E

t:

lo

IE

lc

IO l(E IL 1.9

lo

lo

It

l>

l(E

lo

l\. Itr

lo

lrtt IL lP ll,r tEl lo

It

lo lfl IG

lJ

il

rl ol cl oi 6 o (,)

o

E E (t, (L o

)

*o, E6r

(E-rJg

bE

EE

ES

o, cl ol E_ C-(E.Y -D !AC

o{ --'r= 0 X

;(tr-c o)

6.95 il ooU)

-o:l cl El -l col

ol

_CI ol =lol c)l rl OI ^t Ll o)l tLl a oi c,

'-co o a

t.

I r.>

IC l=

t*

t0) Its tl lco UC rf)t L

-,)

F(go (UOJ

i<

E

..-o

g -:.Y*

orS6

clo) (! o:

o-(/) Y

oi cl EI rl col

ol

_CI ol =lol ol -l OI _t LI ol o LL o ol .o'l CO o a l0) lo) Its to lo

l*

t(E la) IF C)c F(oo 60J

i<

E

"aV

- iiI

_{olS o}

cfc) O-CD Y

o

9-

_Eo

(E-Os

b3

EI

Tg

E :(E

o

P_-.i.;2'8fi

EE

b6

FBBE

lL u)

o)-E

C

::

o)

o

q-

_L-.

- >,c is

E.E

b;

FSBp

LL (,)

O)-5

o_

(n_ oD

=!2c

! _..(t]

L.-X

Y o-o_{' Ortr} oqd

C'- C

(gdk O--c Y

--o- ol

-v-C_{-.(tr i}

Y

'

or-o

9)E a)l! c)

C'- C

odk O--c Y

e8

13

Ep

oH

O-Y

EE

aE5 L(J a

L-c<9

Poto

a

3Ek

NPH-E

;.Y lh o)

6:oo=

o-(/)>c0o

o

i:a(s

a

3Ek

N9lHoE

Xo c.Y F

(EiQor

(L(,)>c0o

(U c 6= !(, U:> 'E C=

@E oh o) @-Y F:

(E O6 f (LO -M

(E

E->.

- L.= L -= _=- f

>co

x=

..--c tE g2

r Y''-'= v

:

F

PF'-R

E

PeE

e

(LLUO (E!

ll

c0 I

ol

_cl ol =O o) -C O 0) LL a c,) o)

'-lco l(E la l< I o.r

ld) Its

l8

lod

lo

lo) IF

9E

1E

Es

oh

d!.Y

E8

(E!

r! (J E

;

=

o;

"JE

E 6(Ef_io?

fEE

o)

2

=-o;

,i'j

P

P, ;i(El

EoP

tr

E.E

C .9 O)

oP

dd

d>:

;.8

U Y -'E

N= o

tL(I)o-;

'6)

:-

_0):

s6

d)-='6

_{t!'= 'a}3

o:

o

O-oo

u,

(,

iE

G':

ok

6,-Y

EE

8,.tr

r!()

o)

5

€

'Eo

fE

+.s

9[!or

d -:'(S

o-E6

o

55

'-! (5; C

+.o _

EEo

k.eE

d

Et;

,9

a.c.o

=c-a

6 (g:<

o

zEz

c.j O .(n :\ ;i itr Gc

E h,'o

5

(!='(! 0

o->t-u)

j=

3 p-=.*

b 6

F<

o

I'E6

d.J E.U H

6 N.g5

_c

=o f

O .Y'G O

o_>ta

g1 N

1fr

5E

ET

aEr r! (J

o) o E_o

E.a

'F(s OYC

Ltg

N

6E

o>oY

c o';

_GOC o_tu

o_

o o o

E:{

'E (I,

=T=

L6P

N ac

609

c o';

(U()c

O- tlJ 0.1 ₌

o) o .E o

E.1

=_s

olzc

L6P

N

6E

ooY

c

o'=

(U _{O c_} O-LU o=

6) .9 o dJ

o_-'4(I,

FEF

uoH

N

6=

60Y

c

o'=

(E O C-(LTU 0)=

oP

lar

Ep

ok

gT

E-c

IL(.) o

3

P-o

^

o-(/)E=

..

>,

o!=

_ og

E ;i CP 0)

E.(E

dp

(E@t9

(L<

(o

t

a

3

P,---= L

o

^

o=

(,E=

.. oE=

>,

- oS

S

7ic+0)_{X (E:;E} (!(/)i9

(L< o

E

@

fls,

o. o=

(,E=

_{-. o E.=}>

- o(E C ;i c€ o

;.q

i, P

G(,t!/

o-< (E E

*o

3

P,--c .= .=

3

x 3>

(/)E=

..

oE=

>,

- oS

E ;cP0)_{X (o;;-o}

o(4t9 O-{ o t

o

q

O)

o

o

c? t\ o o q o, o o a? o o o (Y)

o

o

o

o)

o

o_o o (t o

o

o

(t

o

o

o o

{

o

o

(Y)

o

(,) ro o o t

o

o

@ o (t 1,) o (v) F

o

o

(o

o

-o

E

o

o-o

a

t

(9

(E

E

t-+, G' CD

o

o

(u

o

G

+,

(u

a

6

(u o-CI ol =lql Ll col *l_ot >J -=l_al o)l_>l 'Et

ll

dl :tl oJ LEI l(El

l?l

lo)l lEl l(trl ItL I t^t lLl l0)l t>i lo lr.L

l.i

lc l-o ll lao

lo

lc l(o l:z to lo) l-c IO t-lo lo Iro

t;

lo IL la

l6

lo-lo lc lo l(! lL lr lt/, lsr

lo

It

o o 16 C o o -o

s

_o (U 0)

:

= a E

t:

IL lo IE l! lo IE IE

l8

_lo l(E to tc It lo lo l-c It: a l d E (u o o E (g LL a) u) l

-.= o =U) 0.)

=

f o .ct o_(!

o

o) -c G o O C 0)

p

a L I C .T a

=

o a (! -C_o

F

o-a (g c = o E -v j (E E f

z

a :) O) al

EI

_(Ul

o,l

ol

cl

(6t

EI

o 0)

;o-cc

O.G CA

b9

s!

o)=

e(D l= -la E 16 a lo-ll

lo9

19o

t(o-lc o)

loF

l-o-

9

lo G) loE

l&e.

lrX

U

ICJ L

lh?

H

l=tll=

ls?

b

O) = =

o

s

.)a o od !t

o6

-v

o+

Oc

u-o

o* E)?{ o)E

o3

G_ o9

<6

_{.. LL}

a--.9:

aa

'd E^

<-u

Tq

o=

oo

UJ LL

:=

o .lJ

(/)E

oo

Oe

9^-.eu

E,i

3>

O-c oc)

sI

_Ca (!0) OE d,l:

fii

a_

oP

Oi

'P'3

o)= cv) .j9

6;-ox

.6) (E-. 9U

-o5

oo

.9E 6O) f(E

o-5

ii

.o

E:<

o:)

et

_{E rrt}

o;

o<

o o O) o F o o

)

o I lo tl lo. lc l(tr IO lo) IE l(E ItL

l.

l0) t> lo lr.L lo, t_! lro l'= lco lo lc l(E IJ o o -c. (J (t, (I) o ot 0)l 0)l EI >l (El EI -l ol El CI .el (trt LI @t 'd 9l o .9 o o o

o

6

E (! (L tt, J

9c,

EN (U-(J15

bE

tr:

Eg

N O ! c o Y (-) -c O (, Y

f

a

uJ

a

lo) lc l! l co 6 =O o E O c) o LT a o, o,

'-col

.l

al

1l

II OI =t FI LUI l.Ll trl

]I

c0l al, l o, -c.

=

= o-o o lz o = q) o

qa

tro

OF (l)a :-o-HE oJE

C<

o-!l c7 a <-(U

--3F=

a

2

_H**

!6q=

:>

6

E s

oco Q

ao^.Y

H= E6

3E=>

5

=o-

P=

+

.o.,? x_n

6 (E.= (IJ=

=

.'>.'.c

.=a )

-. - urv

€

E

E%T

(o O (, i--Cc G:r-!

Fo->o->

o J o-Eo (Ilr

oE

bE

EE

Go

tr=

F

6

-oF.

.o^=

-o

(/,,Y

= c{ I

:: -ao ('r E (E '=

-.4 I

= 6)E= X

cilX (!foX

o- o-(/) 6

s3

FT

G:

oE

b=

EE

E.c

r!() o

.. o (E

\r E o O ; CJ o-O

O-O -O o .c

:

_f c0 c =(.)

.. O (!

0-

o

aL)

o C ! = @ ! C (!

q5

1{

(!: vaE oL

E8

(E&

Io

.)o

9)- A

,E:<

aJEU c C=rA

dd

3-q

u .C (J L 0) o LL o .o' c0 (! .)o

a)- a

.c h<

AJC@

:;_< -o)!l_E

E=.X

0-

o

a.c

C (! 'a c) C '. - !+ o);L '=rnq A(!ol LL.Z tr o

o c) -c O !i c) o u_ a '= m C .G a C) c U

'-=

O)Fs

-\-.\

-i

L-Eooi

u-2. c a

C

o

E

a)

o

g1 c)

=v, =ur F

c:

oh

o,-Y Co :q

,I6

;

E

€

o!E

3H

oi->6

_o

.tr_

F(U

e6

k'6,

dp

Y lrJ

t

cr) TU tu LL tL

o

O = C oSE o;i

>o

_o

s_

ro

_C Oo

d9

c_ o i,/)

-o (,

:o)

J!

>(!;

(E=-'

^ L.=

No-E(, -tr()o)

_=oo

P#EE-6 P#EE-6 I

!0'6

(IO<sd-<

G @ o) C) o od G 0) F c_

o

a/)

_o G'

:o JE

$6

Pa

oo

oo

-co(E

P S'6

(I, o-<

(E o o-E o o O N o) o (L 6N =1o =uJ

Ep

oH

oX c(J

:9

₍₉₅ L(J o o =o (5f

o_-?_o

Idv '-q

N

6E

ooY

c o';

(Uo-tL tll 0)

O)

.cU

E?

_OE

E2

6

,iiEE

' o O_

HEHs

LoO<

o,

=

c O=

t-of,,

-Y tii6E -do9E _LC> o

lEoa)

tL O)E

o)

c =c o= dz h

-Y

,bdF

_;-o

o66

LE>

o0)o

L

L'

r

t

?-,

L

L-L4

L-r--aa

L-r

L'

L--{

L-L--a

L-.--a

L-L--a

L-L--a

L-

--

L-

L=-

L-L--a

L-L-4

L-L-1

L

l--a

L-t1

L-t-1

L-r'1

L-L--4

L-

L---

t_-

r---

L-IA

L-r-4

L--4

,--.

-.

-4

----ASEASUK

-

get

involved

ASEASUK is Britain's national association forSouth-EastAsian studies. lt aimsto promote and

support the professional and scholarly development of South-East Asian studies in the United Kingdom by facilitating co-operation and co-ordination between individual scholars, institutions and research programmes in South-East Asian studies and the general advancement of its members' mutual interests. ln particular the Association is concerned with the circulation of professional

information amongst scholars with South-East Asian Interests, and the projection of South-East Asia

as an important field of study within the United Kingdom generally. tt was established in 1969 and has grown to include a _{membership drawn from more than 40 universities} in the country and includes academics, postgraduate students and those involved or interested in South-East Asia.

ASEASUK has an increasing number of members based in universities in South-East Asia and beyond. We welcome new and longstanding ASEASUK members to the conference. ASEASUK's annual general meeting takes place on Sunday 14th September, at 12.30 and will be held in Checkland 21g. You are strongly encouraged to come along. ltems for discussion will include commlttee

membership, funding opportunities (including the call for proposals for ASEASUK-British

Pane! 17 I Sunday 14 Sept 14.00-15.30 Checkland E513

Panel 17 ll Sunday 14 Sept 16.O0-17.30 Checkland E513

PANEL

17

Contemporary

architectural

and

urban

practices in Southeast

Asia

Convenors: Ofita Purwani {University of Edinburgh} and Wido Prananing Tyas (University

of

Sheffield)

PANEL ABSTRACT

The architecture and

the

cities

of

Southeast Asia have been considered

to

be 'traditional'

in

architectural and urban discourses. Many studies have been conducted on

the

architectural and

urban 'tradition'. While the discourse on tradition is a product of colonialism that put the traditional

East

in

opposition of

the

modern West,

the

existing architectural and urban theories are mainly dominated by the Western approach which does not always

fit

those of Southeast Asia which is the result of the difference in climate, socio-cultural and political situation. This panel will examine the practices of architecture and urban planning in contemporary Southeast Asia

to

contribute

to

the knowledge on architecture and urban of Southeast Asia. The papers in this panel are expected to focus

on but not

limited

to

empirical studies on architecture

or

urban planning, urban policies,

architectural and urban discourses that show the gap between the Southeast Asian practices and

Western architectural and urban theories.

Biography: Ofito Purwoni is o _final yeor PhD candidate in Architecture in the University of Edinburgh, lJK. She just had her PhD vivo and passed on April 2014. She has experience as o teaching ossistant

ond

lecturer

of

architectural history, architectural design studio

and

architecturol criticism in tJniversitos Sebelas Maret, lndonesio since 200L to 2009. Her interests ronge _from Javanese built environment, troditionalism,

heritage

issues, tourism, urban studies,

spatiol

politics, invented traditions and sociology. Her current PhD research is about power ond built environment in the cose of lavanese cities. Contact: O.Purwoni@sms.ed.ac.uk or ofito92@vahoo.com.

Biogrophy: Wido Pronaning Tyos, PhD student in School of Architecture, Planning and Londscope,

Newcastle lJniversity, lJK, ond lecturer in Urbon Planning in Universitas Diponegoro, lndonesio. Her

interests are in urban plonning, housing issues, home bosed enterprises,

ond

sustainable livelihood.

Co nta ct : w. p.tv qs @ n cl. o c. u k.

PAPERS

Panel 17 (l) Sunday 14.00-15.30

9.

Rethinking Kevin Lynch's Concept "the lmoge

of

the

Citt''in

Contemporary Urban View; case

study of young people in kompungs, Surabaya- lndonesia.

96

I

:I

=

J

J

J

l

}.--ri

-I

:I

*I

rE-l

I

F-I

F.|

I

F-I

t-l

-l

F{

I

LI

I

r-l

J

-I

I

-I

fE{

I

l-- {

I

p-{

I

t---{

I

T

F-{

I

r-i

I

=

I

l={

I

F,-.--I

r---_l

L

r

a-L

rl

L

L

L-4

L

1t

L

rr

r

L-{

L

.1

L-rt

L

LJ

L

rl

L-rf

L

rl

L

r

r--J

L

r---l

L

rl

L

r

r--l

L-rl

L-rr

r=-{

L

L-a

L

rf

L-r-{

L

r,

L

rt

L

.*1

L

-?

Rully Damayanti, PhD student in Architecture, University of Sheffield.

Abstract: Kevin Lynch's theory in the "lmage of the City" (1960) is widely accepted in urban design

and architecture education, practices and public policy. The concept is still discussed and applied

because

it

widened the scope

of

practice: considering qualities of a place through identification of the five major elements in navigational ability (path, nodes, edges, landmarks and district). Lynch

appears

to

put less emphasis on the category of 'meaning' because of its social and cultural aspects

that

is very relative. However,

in

Lynch's later writings, he places social, cultural and historical background of the setting and observers as important factors. This article applies the contemporary urban view, especially in reading cities or neighbourhoods that is free from categorization of

high-end, low-end and traditional conditions of post-colonial settings. lt focuses on the concept of spaces

as

social production. The

view

will

challenge

the

Lynch's concept

in

reading neighbourhood, particularly in considering meaning perceived by the observers;

will

it

be the same? The article is

based on a study in kampungs (urban village) in Surabaya, lndonesia, with specific respondents of young adults aged 20-25 years old, and living in the kampungs since they were born.

Biogrophy: Lecturer

in

Urban

Theory

and

Design, Architecture Department,

Petra

Christion

University, Suroboyo, lndonesia, currently Postgroduote Student, School

of

Architecture, The

University of Sheffield, UK

Contact: arpllrd@sheffield.ac.u k.

10. Public Perceptions on the Street tmage and Place Attachment of a Traditional Street: The Case

of Pecinan Street, Magelang, lndonesia

Arif Budi Sholihah, PhD _{Candidate, Department of Architecture and Built Environment, University of}

Nottingham, UK

Tim Heath, Professor, Chair of Architecture

&

Urban Design, Department of Architecture and Built Environment, University of Nottingham, UK

Amy

Yue Tang, Lecturer

in

Architecture, Department

of

Architecture

and Built

Environment, University of Nottingham, UK

Abstract: Street image refers

to

things

that

first come

to

someone's mind when visiting a street, what symbolises a street to someone and how people can describe a street in a physical and

non-physical sense. Meanwhile, place attachment refers to the bonding established between people and

places (Shamsuddin & Ujang, 2008). These two elements, urban image and place attachment can be

regarded

as

intangible characteristics

of

a

traditional street

that

contribute

in

creating street

identity. ln Southeast Asia, streets have specialities and significance in the context of urban public life. Streets traditionally served the city as public spaces, places where people come together to do

commerce,

to

eat, and

to

socialize. Many scholars point out

that

public space including streets in

Southeast Asia is perceived as being informal and spontaneous in nature, being much more complex

than those in other region because they contain more mixed usage. This character is somewhat unique, formal and informal activities coexisting

in

mutual harmony providing

a

rich

blend of

97

I

I

t

I I

t

t

f

J

l

1

I

I

l

(

* t

I