یکشزپ مولع رد شزومآ ی هعسوت ی هلجم

(1)

!

: #$% & '(

) *

1

!" 2

$% & 3

( )" 4 5

+3 4 5

#6 7 + : , - - . / 0% (1 2 , 3 ! 4 5 , 3 6 7 2 8.

- : 1 !;

[email protected]

89 3 : 27 / 2 / 94

!;3<

: 24 / 6 / 94

+ !, -+. #/

@ A : B 5 C , : , D E 3 ,: 5 ,: 3 $ ( % 1 F

G $ " H -., I;: .

, $8; 2 :7@

: %D 1 2 8; , $ D .

F

%( K L:04 , 2 , M , 1 .

$ D N.

O,1 , : B

2B P, 7. Q 3 : I 00R. S:

5 7 : B O,1 .

0

%( K : T

$ , @ 3 10

O,1 4B V 2 , T : I 00R. S:

8 : B / , 3 2 8.

5 7 , 4 " 0

$ G ,:H .

3 1 W : $ X Y ,1B 6 ; O $ Y, I) WA Z1,

: [ . 3

- N 1,

$ G , D [ . 1 /7. ,:

. H \ , ) @ ] , \ 3 1

X :. [ . ! % E 3 ^ .

O T _ - . .

. # ( [ ` 1aA H b :

E ) O,1 3 1,1 , 1 , 4 $ 1

`( c 3

: B 1 , 4 :

$ 5 C , N. $ D ! 1

$ .

1 #2 3 E 3:

, : I

! , $ D

Z : B 3 O N.

c, dN , 8 6 ; 1 , ! ( 3

, N , 2 :!\ 3 [ 0 . 2 ,1 8!@ A I !

G .

3 1 + *

; & !" :

& 8=>

" 4 ?@

*/ / &

A &

0 B

# +4

-., 1 eT" . 1 f ` 3 O1 \ $

$ 5 C $( , 1 F . ^8 % ;

3 8; 1 -K!

. 5:8T 3 $ O 1

O , 1 2 1, ^); $ g " 5 , ,:4 3

$ ;:. ,: @3 6 :; 1 ) % :. , \ ; .

. 5:8T 3 $ , $( \ . !c ^ 3 Z

O1 G 2 , , h % . Fi"

- 1 ) j R

H 2 , $ g " 3 \ ; j R -

1 - V T P 0\ @R :. - - . / 2 : 1 2 : k0R @ 1aA , @

2 8. @R :. 1 ) /83 5: \ O E@

2

2 - 4 $ O N@ 1aA 2 : k0R. S:

, - - . / O : -

: 1 !;

, @ 2 8. N /A 5: \ O E@

2 2 8.

3 - , A : B O1 G $ 3 l: \ ; [ :\ - - . / , A , @

@R :. 1 ) /83 5: \ O E@

2 8.

2

4 - O N@ 1aA ,1, 3 $ 83 , - - . / O : 4 $

- : 1 !;

, @ 2 8. N /A 5: \ O E@

2 8.

2

5 - , 3 im. - - . / O : 4 $ O N@ 1aA 2 : k0R. S:

, 2 8. N /A 5: \ O E@

2 8.

2

Downloaded from zums.ac.ir at 8:28 IRDT on Sunday May 14th 2017

(2)

[3 D ,:H 3 1 O :3 2B -., 1 $ V ! 3 8; 2 Oa 1 3 1 8; 8;:. / , 8;:.

$ 83 3

. N /A 5: \ Z : B $ 3 C ,

, 3 E 4: B ` $ 3 .

,: $ 4

-., ;:

^ , % ; $ ,1B

,1 Y

$ $ j R K " 2 E 4: B ` , :4 `- T $8; , 5 o B, 1 8%. :.

1, , p! ,:H 3 $ -., 1 eT" . 1 2

! 3 , ,:4 3 5 C 21 3 .)

1 (

, 6D 1 . :;1 ,

Z : B 5: \ N /A 3

2 :7@

, 3 2B N@

! ( 3 O B

2 @ , N \ :4 .B 3

8 B

; : :

3 .

! 3 [H "

%( K 5 7

O ,

! 3 O 1

6 . N@

83

!%

, 3 /

O B ,:H

G ) 3 1 2 (

3 !3 3 ;:.

Z : B 2 ! ,

^ ) 83

;

& 2 N /A 1

&

$ :(1

^8

$ . Z : B

! ( 3 :;:

) : Z1

A 3 A m.

G:

1 &

2 , 3 , C

, V "

:G G

83 ^ ) 1

I .

` ! A

; -.,

$ T 1 s:(:!N.

;

` A 1 3 2 3 X

t A :G 3 ).

4 1 3 (.

3 , 2 : -3 2 / ` / ^ , Oa 1 $ D `R3

2 : ) 5 ( 2 :3 K4 u % , 1 :

2 v : 3

:.

C N.

o 4 )" k - G

-

, , N@ 1 0\

) 7 6 ( $8; , . D :!

N. $ D I ! Z : B ,

O,1 I : B

$ E ,:H : )

9 1 8 (.

: B O,1 : I 00R. S:

V , 1365 ,

1 I :0. 2 V ,

1388 3 ,: 2B : B

Z iA 3 5 D o Y " V " , 1 $ G , D E 3 22

, , 9 WA N /A 5: \ O E@

" 0 5 7 1 )

10 .(

3 : B

8;:. [3 D G )G (:. 2: A1 : I 1 3 , ,:4 3 $ D

. , , 3 2 ,1 [ D

) 1 : O,1 2 A $ D $ 3 w:3 [

, :4 , , : 1 !; , )

10 .(

1 (:. ` / 3

Q, 2 : -3 )

11 (

$ D 3 ! N.

! 3

^ ) O :" , k0R 1 3 ! .

O,1

, 2 : I 00R. S:

` $

2B 2 E 4: B , ! :. 1 Z E ` $) 3

! 3 O :"

.

F

`R3 , N. $ D 2 : Oa 1 $ D

1 $ " $ :-. $8; 2 D X . , 3 1 Q, : : 1 , $ 3

. ) :

-., N B 83 $ D $ T )

American Institute

of Health Care Quality Improvement

(

!; ]!A

G C , 21 3 , : , 3 v:

,

`R3

$ O : 2 3 2 : Oa 1 $ D [

P :4 $ D , 3 , 1 $

Q 1

$ D

1, 1 V: % . 1 ,: O : 4 $ D

^( X

3 2 : Oa 1 $ D `R3 , )

12 - 13 .(

, 2 G j H:. 3 Z . c G O,1 , N. $ D L:04 : \ N /A : B

%( K G ,:H 2 : 00R. 1 , o1

00R. S: O,1 2 , , 3 @ 3 l 1 O :

$ O :3 ,:H 3 [ . 3 , D $ T x ( 3

: B _ \

! 3 ) 19 - 17 (.

B 7

3 3 , ` C Q 3 : B

, ,:4 3 Oa 1 , \ 1 Z , 2 E 4: B

$ ) 17 (

, O,1 2 , M , 1 P, 7. [ . $ D

N.

:3 Z : B , 5 . :0. :.

(3)

^ )

19 18 .(

[ ( 3 N 1, 3 %( K

T L:04 , 2 , M , 1 . F 3 $ D

N.

O,1 , 0R. S: : B

3 : I 0

2B P, 7. Q O,1

5 7 : B .

0

Z1, ` 1aA , V : v: 3 ;:. 3 [ .

: 8!A

) ( latent

Z1, 3 / . 3 1 , D

) Conventional Content Analysis

O T (

. [ .

3 F K% [3 D Z1, & : ! O [ .

$ . [ -. F 3 N 1, 1

1 O , 4

C % :. [ 8).

G ,:H )

21 20 .(

, Z1,

: [ . , D

1 O :3 O A j H:. F

O :", 0R@ & ,:y.

:;: %( K

3 O 3 , :

. Z1, , [ . $ . :

)T. $ . 1 kR@ !% " 1 1 O O :4 , 3 , iG 1 G , D - Q 3 :

)

Induction

( )T. 1 K3 , 1 - 1 - :

2B G z R 22 )

21 ( O \ I( D & , 1

3 ! V " \ , 1 ^8 [3 D 1 2 E 3 \ V:H

, " 1 %3 %( K , A ` 2 :!\ 3 . {O

G , D O T ,: O ! B 3 / , 3 )

22 21 (.

,

%( K

$ 2 G !!

3 Z1, : G

!

)

Purposeful Sampling

( O E@

5: \ N /A 2 8.

8

@83 1 2 P R .

3 Q

2 ,

O,1 S:

00R.

I : , V 51 [ 0 .

`( c V

O 3 7. , V1 %3 3 ! B 1

, $ D 3 Q 3 : B

I) O,1 V1 V ,

:3 O ) O,1 S:

00R.

( 1 3

( 1

[ . 3 $ P R 3 . 3 ! , %( K ,

W!;1 -3 1 ,

! ( 3 ) 3 . 8 V ( O :" , 2 :

1 2 : , 1

%( K .

: G .

2 ,

3 v

$

" 0 , O v 3 V : ^ @

:8@

2 ! i4 $8; N ( 2

E " 0 /

5 7 G . E ,: 3 " 0 65

K , - D

B 5 , 2 , 3 [4 ,

1 5 7 , 1

O [ .

" 0 ! , Q 3 1 , 4 " 0 :3 O , _ - . ^ . . 3 5 7

. H o :

2B $ @ A 3 1 ,:H 3 $)R 1 / ,:H 3

@ )

Probing

( [ . .

V g ,: 3

"

:Ec :

K4 A

$ D

| ! H 0 4 ,

,:

$ D N.

c D , ,

!

| 5 : 1 1 !\

: B O,1

3 ,

&

!

|

"

. " ,

H \ $ " 0 )

Field Note

( O T / , .

` 1aA

" 0 3 2 :!\

" 1 [ . , C G

1 [ .:H

" 0 1, i O A 1 7

[H "

3 [ .:H

$-3 K O

.

$ H :

2 ! [H "

: . Wd 3 O T )T.

} -

O , iG 5 7 -

,:8~

,

^ 5

1

^ T V 0

. 3 ,:C!

` / , \

.

" 0 1

$) ( - X :.

2 , N

E@ 1aA )

Peer Check

( ,:

! 3 3 , D

$ G .

F E , \ 3

, D 2

`R3 j R

- , , 4 b%3 .

1 b\

\

, S:

00R.

: I )

External Check

( ,

&

• 3 1 G /

1 ) - C

1 T.

2B _ :.

, 2 @ ,:

$ "

, D

$ G . , ,:H :;1 F 4 C , )T.

7

3 1(

v:;, 1 Wd v ; C 2 , N

C

, D

$ G .

!€

8.

1 1 . Z, /G

•1 @

%( K 1 L 0 4 2

o:

3 6 ; %( K ,1B

1

[ . O

)

ProlongedEngagements

( E 8;:.

(4)

, , \

@R3 3

%( K :3 ) 25 - 23 .(

WA ` 1aA

,: , I :0.

5: \ O E@ S 4 1 @ 1aA

@R :. 1 ) /83 )

3 O, 29341 ( 5: \ O E@ 1

2 8. N /A 5 7

%3 " 0 . 1 $ Y,

2 G !! $ , @ GB G X Y

.

# ( .

%( K _3 K , 8c

2: b H O,1 ,

: B

‚

‚ 00R. S:

‚

‚ : I

‚ 2 , ,

Z : B O,1 2 : 3 N. $ D

( 3 ,

7.

‚ 3 M , 1

‚

!!

‚

‚ [

"

E )

‚ 3 1,1

O,1

"

‚ 1

‚ $

‚ 4

‚ , , –

‚

"

3 `( c

‚ : B

"

! 1 , 4 :

D

‚ N. $

‚ C ,

‚ 5

‚ $

"

G V 0 .

V1 ; 1 H 4 ,:K3

‚ 2 @ , : 1 -

.

7 6G 1 : . =@ ;3" C H

) %H

. =@ ;3"

" # I J*+3

O/ E 3 2 , Pi; 3 7. 3 2 , Pi;

*K 83 6/

- # ;B B

"

:;1 5 \ ! ( 3 , 8 I) 5 \ Z E Z : B 3 ;:. 5 \

c, dN Z : B : , I 1 63 ! : I ! ! ( 3 X

; : B 8 1, O T 5 \ ! ( 3 3 7. 3 ,

" 4;I M N

, 3 , , 3 E 3 51/(

` C - , 8 1 Z E

O : 4 $ D [H 3 ;:. " S 4 3 ;:. N. $ D , ,:

8=> ; 653 ;9 *K =4 8 O P4

[N.1 A 1 o G : $ 5 C , " [ ) 3 $ :(1 5 C , j ~1 • 1 E A ^ ) 2 : kR@

$ 1 :

N. $ D k0R

1 - %( K 3 _3 K O,1 3 1,1 E )

: B 3 1 3 7. 3 2 , Pi; ; T R %3

G 3, , O/ E .

, 1 ! B $) 3 : O,1 , 1

" , ! ( 3 V:H 3 3 7.

O : 2 : I 2 : 1

8 B o: $ D 1 K4 A

! 3 1 %3 ! : 3 . o: u, :\

I 3 w:3 2 :

3:4 3 ,

!! [ \ _ : O,1 1 O M, .

N 2 ,

,

$ , 8~ !

"

3 7. D G ^!N N

‚

:. 3

O,1 %3 1 [ D 3 1, A

O T `3, 7. 1 !N3 7 1, $) :

!N3

"

) DB 42 ( (.

(5)

, )3 2 ,

:3 - % 2 ,

O/ E 3

N@ ^ \ N. $ D Z : B : 1

1, 3 7. I) 1 Z : B V 3 2 :4 .

N

, 2 $ , 8~ ! ,

"

1 ^ , 5 :4

, $ D

^ G 1 1, : ^ : O @ o " . ,

L:04

^! $

"

) 4 32 ( (.

2 - , 4 $ 1 -

, Z : B b

, , H :3 %( K , N. $ D

3

Q M , 3 4 2 ,

$ 1 1 N@

, D l . $ . 3 , N. $ D $ T , 1 - 3 ;:. 5 \

Z E Z : B

I) 5 \

! ( 3 , 8 :;1 5 \

c, dN Z : B

! ( 3 X : I !

: , I 1 63 ! :

3 7. 3 ,

! ( 3 5 \ : B 8 1, O T

; 3

.

, Z : B , ƒ H Z E $) 3 O

2 ,

$ D „ , 3 ;:. :G 3 ! 7 N.

$ (: % 1 :. 1 u, :\ E@ A ,:C! 3 3 . . $ D ! , I ! Z E !€

1

,: O : 4 6D 1 . ,:

: . 4 3 :G 3

2B " 1 . : E O 3 H 2 B 8 ,

! ) N. $ D .

$ N

$ , 8~ ! , 2 G !!

"

N! $ \ 3 7!

, 1 O 2: , 3 %.

$D1 , 3 , 3 G

%3 [ ) 3 ^ :R3 N! 3 \ O G 1, $H ^ 3 8! 1 [ N. ! , $ D [g

^ ,

"

) DB 35 ( ( .

2 G !! $ 4 3 C Q 3 2 ,

, 8

. $ D „ , $8; 5 o ! ( 3 Z : B 1 N

!! $ , , 2 : 3 N :G 3

$ , 8~ ! , 2 G !! $

"

` \ 1

, 8

^ N . !% $) O :" , 1

, 3 N. C 1, 2 : ^ :R3 ^ Z : B 7 2:@ N. 3 ! ( 3 , 1 ^ !

^ 3 5 . ^

C ^ 1 ^ , [N@ @ C D

o 3 ! ( 3

: 3 !3

\ ,

^ 5 7

"

) 4 30

( (.

P, 7.

2 , Z : B b%3 2 @ ,:H 3

3 c, dN 1 ,:H 3 1 &T!

2 B 1 : ,

, : , )3 , [3 D ! ( 3 1 C Z : B

: , O ! A \:Y: i( ! 3 2 c, dN : _- 8 B !3 6 ; 1 .

2 G !!G $ N

2 3 /

"

Z : B 3 , , / c 4

P 3 1 C Z : B 3 H 1 O, \ ^ - ) 5 7 @ .

\ 3 $) Z : B

! ;:. 1 ! 3 .

D1 1, Q, : ! 3 g

, 1 ,:; c ! , 3 :R3 V ! A:(: 1,: C ! Z : B 3 1, @3 5 7 3 " c

O E3 :. 5 B N. N. 1 .

:. 3 3 5

"

) 4

50 ( ( .

! ( 3 X : I !

I ! N / b 3 [ @

, $8; / 87. 1 N : 1 4

:3 2 , P, 7. E N N. $ D .

3

$ , 8~ ! , 2 G !! $ N :G

"

3 N. $ D :4 I ! X & :

$TG @ T :4 I ! N / b &

$) ^ N 1 X ; … -.

. 7!

) ,

`R3 ( E @c $ - : C 3 (1 O %

^

"

) DB 40 ( ( .

- , , I 1 63 ! :

4 3 $

, 63 ! 1 I 2 G !!

, Q , I !

1 3

O

! ) . ! , 2 G !! $ N

(6)

$ , 8~

"

P , ! , 5 - % , )3 E

:4 2: 1 @3 % :7@ 3 ! ) . [

! %( K @3

"

) 4 36 ( .(

B D 42 / (

2 3

"

_ D \ 1 % 63 ! 3 :R3 & 3

^ , ! ( 3 ! , 1 [ %( ,: O T "

"

. O :" , k0R 1 3 7. 3 . G O 83 $ D

N.

, ,: ! ( 3 , 8 Z : B 3 I) 1 ! ! ( 3 3 7.

,1 Y , )3 ,

2 , :3 . , 2 G !! $ N :G 3

$ , 8~ !

"

8 I \ ! O, NICU

^ ! , k0R 1 3 7. 3 . O, ^ [! A 3 :7@ , ! @ 3 2 3 Z : B 2 3

2 E3 1 2:@ , ! ) 1 ^ 1

"

) DB 35

( (.

5 \ Z1, O T

; : B &

E 3 P, 7.

! , 2 , O: 3 w:3 $ 1

! /E ; 3 1 $ ! Z : B W , . Z1,

! B, 1

O T O G,

! :. [ N 1

! ( 3 $ " H .

! . 4 3 C Q 3

2 , , Z : B ] W , . O:

B, 1 l:

. , 2 G !! $ N

$ , 8~ !

"

$) \ W , . Z1,

O, V:H 1 P:c, c .

! A 3 o 3 ,:H 3 `

!N !R X- 1 O Z : B ...

X-

& Z : B 1 2 Z:G X- 1, E 21 € B

$

"

) DB 30 ( (.

N E $ , 8~ ! , 2 G !! $

"

3

$) , )3 C

! , [D "

^ ) [ N.

Z : B 0\

^ 3 [ N 1 @ 3 .

-3 P:4 V ! ^ : 3 2: :4 2: 00R. " , 1, ^ )

^ ! & / : 3 C c 1, 0\ [ N. ^ ) (1 @ 3 Z : B " $) 8! 1 s:(: / : 3

@3

"

) DB 35 ( ( .

3 - M N =@

" 4;I :

3 - E

3 w:3 N@ 1 $ 1 3

: B O,1

1

! 3 3 ,1 Y 2B

1 Z : B 3 F N 6 , $8; ,

N \ 2 ,

E 7 1

$ ƒ H 2 B

2B :4 : B O,1 O M , ,

:3 . 2 , 3

8 1 ! ( 3 P, 7. 3 1, 1, , 3

: B O 3 7. & / ,

.

3 E 3 51/(

: B , . ^8 3

. O T N. $ D ! , 3 7. 3

1 . ,

O,1

$ ,1 Y .

! , 2 G !! $ N

$ , 8~

"

`- 5:(:N ,: 1 . , ) 3

3 V1 Z :4 N! 3 1, @ €

3 Z : B 3

"

) DB 45 ( ( .

TG 3 2 ,

O,1 : B : , F

, , 8 1 Z E 1 ` 7 O :" , H 0 4

$ O @ ,:C! $ T " 3 2 : N. $ D .

N

!! $ 2 G

$TG

"

3 / c ) 3

^ 1 3 {^ 3 5 7 1

^ 1 (1 P:4 ! ) ^ ^

•\ 3 1, N. o 4 ! ( 3 [„ ) ^ : 3 3 [D "

V g 1, @3 [H " $ @ A : [ N. :. @ 2: , 1, N. I B Q: , : ^ /3

1 O 3 3 8! k R@. @3 : )3 O,

@3 . 2:@ 2 3 3 1, 2:@ 3 , O: 1, ` „ \

2 3

"

. 2 3 !€

"

: B $) ( 2o ! 3

3 3 g" ^ , 2 ,

1 @3 TG 7

8

" (1 @ ; O, 2 :!\ 3 2 :!\ & ! 3

(7)

O, :;1 Z:. |$) c [ N. : N. o 4

^ ) Q )" 8 1 3 1 $) ;:. ,: !%

1

^ : 3 . @3 O Z : B ^ \ ,:H 3 $)

^ ! I) , 8 .

3 O, S 2 :4 3 , 8

7 , 8

^ E3 ^ 1, 2:@

"

) DB 42 ( (.

3 ,- ,

2 $ D , , 8 1 Z E ` C

N.

:3 O M , ^8 ,: N $ N .

$ , 8~ 2 G !!

"

€3 N B 2 :. 2o

1, O E ) & g [D " O, O E ) $T 1 @3 G 3 ^ €3 ^ , i3 N. 8 D !

3 2:@ :"

"

) 4 30 ( ( .

- 3 " S 4 V:H $ \, 3 . 2 ,

, $8; O,1 1 : 3 I ! D 4

$ ,1 Y , )3 1 O : 4 .

2 , $) 3

G , D 4 V:H [ \ , , 2B :Ec E3 1

G , 3 .

$ , 8~ 2 G !! $ N

"

S:-"

@ $ \, Z : 4 1 : .

, , ; -3 [g

) ^ 3 ^ ! C. X- $) ) ^

^ ! , ,

"

) 4 42 (

.(

- E ^8 3 7.

3 ;:.

O : 4 $ D [H

,:

:3 . , 3 ! $) 3 N. $ D

O : 4 1 2 : Q 3 1 O : 4 $ , @ c 3 8 B Z , 1 O E ; eT" 3 . 3 2 @ , , 8 , )3 `- :. & /A , ! , O : 4

2 : N. !

! T . [ ( 3 N ( " ,

v:Y: $ GB 5 \ 1 N 1 63 ! $ 1 N ,:K3 : ;:. ^8 3 ,

$TG

"

8 4 ( 1 ,:b" ^ G ...

1 $ , @ , 8 1 3

Z : B ....

c

‚

‚ ,:

...

C 3 O , 8!

B ...

:H , ( ...

8!

‚ 3 ,

‚ B

‚ G Z :

‚

$ .

"

)

4 42 (

.(

4 - P4 8=> ; 653 ;9 *K =4 =@

:8 O 3 w:3 N@ 1 `( c 3 $(o -

! : !€ 1 kR@ 1 & . ) , 4 2 - D :E! 3 O j %. ` A 1 1, 5 C , $

$ $ .

8 O P4 S =@ 3 + I 83 :

-

$ :(1 2 , 1 $ 5 C , , . ^8 3 1 " [ ) N /A $ D „ , W s,1

$ . (1

2 ,1 , O !! E@ A $ D 1 / o 4 3

!c ;:. )3 :

. 2 G !! $ N

$ , 8~

"

B [ ) G, 2 : 00R , -

8;:. 4 \ E ) K4 , 2 : " N /A ( Q, 2 : L:04 3 N. [ ) 3 :3 @ 3 4 D 1

O 2o

. O @ 3 $ :(1

@ 3 1 :3 2 1 : 3 O €3 , 8E

[ ) . :3 ;:. $ . €3 im. 1 2 , @ 3 8 1 [ N. 3 w:3 .

;:. @ % O, 4

O , 4 :! !c @3 ^ €3 N. [ ) 3 @ 3 O :

"

.

; C3T63 U =4 :

[N.1 A $ 5 C , 1

, $8; 0R@ 1 1, ! ( 3 [ %( ,:

$ D

, :;1 )3 2 : 3 N.

. )3 E , \ 3

3 :;: $ T " , O,1 2 , $ 3 . .

$ , 8~ ! , 2 G !! $ N

"

3

,:H 3 ^ 3 @3 1 . - D [N.1 A N! 2 3 5 7 : 83 3 1, 2: , : 3 . [ \ k R@. $ :4 `( - 3 W

!

"

. $ , 8~ / 2 G !! $ E N

"

…

N. $ D 3 0R@ [ %( ,: 1 [N.1 A

(8)

5 7 1, $ D Z ) G ^ , O

O 5 7 : ^ Z G ....

"

VW =4 )

; J X*+

Y3 Z [;

P4

8 O 0R@ 1 O j %. ! !€ 1 5 C :

E A $8;

‚ k 4 . K4 A 2 : N. $ %Y1

, :;1 O .

N

‚ ! , 2 G !! $

$ , 8~

"

O E , A

E

‚ N. 3

‚ : [

4

‚ 8 . k4 2 , 3 : N! 3

^ :. 4 1 @ z, 4 $ E ^ ! :. 1, 2: , 7

‚ V

‚

! B

‚

! 3 O

‚ (1 ^

O E , G : [ N. , 1, E A 3 3

4 4

‚ P:

‚ 3 l: :.

"

" 1

‚ • 1 $ ( % O :

" , : I 00R j ~1

‚ O : N. $ D 3

G 3 $ O @ j %. ! 1,

‚ $ ( % O :" 3 :

m 00R

‚ 0\ 1 /

‚ H 3 P

‚ & NT. kR@ ,:

O @

‚ 4 . WA : 1 $

‚ k0R. S: 3 k

! %; 2 : .

N

‚ , 8~ 2 G !! $

$

"

( % O :"

‚ H $

‚

%.

‚ ^ 1 O @ j

D X- T ~1 B

‚ . : $

‚ :.

D `R3

‚ ) Oa 1 $

‚

‚ %3

‚ 4 ^

‚ k

2:@ E A 3 ^ 3 2 E `R3 3 @

^ !

"

.

; V\W* ; 4 =%B 8=>

: 3 -

" k0R 1 : N@

‚ I O :" ,

N.

, O, .

$ , 8~ ! , 2 G !! $ N

"

:.

)-. 3 [ N. • 3

‚

@3 j ~1 ^ .

[ N. O :"

d k0R N $ 3 1, : .

X-

N. $ D

‚ : Z :4 3 G ; ^ . :4

Q 3 3 :;1 [ N. 1 ^ . 3 3 Q 1 [N.1 A

‚ !3 1, 8! ! @3 E

$ Y 3 O 2, i3 3 Z 3 1 ! , ^ )-. ! 8 4 ^ ;

"

.

560

, 8c %( K , 2: b

O,1 3 1,1 E ) [

: B

, 4 $ 1

- , : B

`( c : B 3

$ D ! 1 , 4 : 1

O 3 $ 5 C , N.

17

! -

1 N. $ D , 8 B $ O, 3 , [ 0T. 3 , :R : • 3 3 @ %( K ] 3

.

- 2 @ : B O,1 3 1,1 E )

1 D 3 7.

, , ( 3 2 : I ! , 2 : 1

1

D \

! B 1 ,

2 : , 3 , :.

; K " 3 ;:. 1 , 8 ! :.

;

D N. $ 3 l:

. O,1 2 , , C 3

,:4 3 [H " ! ( 3 3 7. 3 00R. S:

3 v :

N@

%3 , 2 B O : 4 1 K4 A 2 : , N.

Z iA [ D O,1 ! :. 83

$ D !;

N.

2 : O : 4 1 G C , , 2 B

2B 3 $ ) 1

O : ;:.

1 %( K

! 5:(:N ,: , :;: k - 1

, ,:H 3 1 O : M,

! 3 : 2B 6 , , .

- , 4 $ 1

- , Z : B 2 :!\ 3

$ , @ . :3 N. $ D , ^8 [ \ &

v: 7 1 - $ 3 2 G !!

2 :!\ 3 8 B

, , l: [ :\

: 2 \† $ D .

%( K

I 00R. O,1 , ! , 2 @ E , :;1 j%Y / 2 : )

16 - 14 .(

O,1 3 !3

! , : B ` A 2 : 00R. 1 N /A 0\ $ D -

j%Y ,:@ , $ N.

1

, $ D :E! , E 3 3 .

(9)

3 !3 3

$ 4 Y Z : B $ D ! ,

N 3 2 : 1 2 : 00R. S: O,1 , 8!. N.

, 4 j R %( K , / " O,1 ,

$ O kR@ 2 .

A GB 2 / , 3 , [ N. 1 , [" 2 ,

2 : G kR@

2 , A $ g [ N. 1 ,

2 : ) , , 1 ); ^\

( GB „ A: " ,

) 26 ( . , $ D , C 3 3 !3

O1 G @ 3 N /A 5:(:N ,:

O V:Tm N /A A

( 3 N /A 8 ,1 , Q1, o 3 ^7" [

3 2 / , 3 : B

$ D @ 3 3 w:3 ,

N /A A 8 ,1 )

, A ! (

2B Z : B 3 1 )

! . N /A O1 G , .

1, ` / 3 ;:. 3

; s:(:!N. 1 5: \ 1,1 N /A ` 21/

3 51 ,: 3 ) 3 2 %T † m. 1 , C

%. 1 :

L 4 ;:. , 3 , A

: ) 27 ( . 1 , 3 I ! : B 3 2 ,

, D C 7. ,: ; 8 s:(:!N. 1 5: \ % :.

1 G ,

8 ,1 E 3 @ 3

1 2 C! " H C

1, , N3 v ; N .,:H ,

%( K , 3 4

N \ N 1, 1 2 :7@

2 E 4: B ` .

1 O

. 2 C! " H ` 1 P, 7. - T N \ 3 ;:. 3

2 E 4: B ` , D C ,

) 29 - 28 19 (.

]

2 @ / %( K , O [ . [H "

j%Y

$ D ! , 2 : 00R. S: O,1 5:(:N ,:

, l: [ \ 2 :!\ 3 N.

Z : B N. $ D

$ `-

. : 1 %( K :7 ); , !c

, 3 3 @ %( K \ 2 ,

,:4 ^@c 3

4 , 2 !€ w - , )3 , K "

1 ` GB ` / 2 C! " H N /A ^ \

$ C ,: , 2 E 4: B ` ! ( 3 , 8 .

O 3 , 83 @ 8@( c ` 3 / E 2 E@ 1aA ) 31 - 30 ( .

%( K , /

E %( K 3 :) )

2 ( $ , @

. ! B 5 \ 3 2 G !!

K " 3 N. $ D

: 2 \†

. $ D 2 :3 ; [ ( 3 , C 3

3 @ 3 ! B 3 . 2 1 , N.

1 , 8 1 Z : B , ! : 3 . , K "

! 3 l: 2 , .

( 3 , : B , 8 3 3 .

( K , /

$ O B $ 3 j R % )

33 32 .(

3 !3

Z : B , O G, 1 $ 4 Y

[ 0 . "

: ;:. 1 G . ( 3 , : B , 8 3 3 .

,

%( K 5 C , N. $ D ! 1 , 4 :

$ &

H 2: b Z : B ,: , O M ,

$ D N.

F 2 ,

:3 . % $ 5 C ,

(1 $ 5 7 V " , ! , . D c G ,:@

2 ! , _ D ! B 1 5 o $4 : [ ( 3 3 1 2 :3 ! / A G 3 8 1 2 00R 1 E A $ ( 1 ! B 5 \ 1 , N

v:Y:

$ H 1 ƒY 1 $ @ A D

.

Guralnik

3 : 8!@ A , 3 & , 2 :

1 E A )3 ` A . N. C , K4 A $ D , 7 3 I !

N.

1 3

‡ -., I;: G ^@c ,: 3 (:.

$ 2 : ,

: .o 3 ! )

34 (.

" 0 2 N 5 \ %( K $ 1 2 ,

, ! , ! B G " 0 : [ ( 3 ,:@ [

:3 E 8

(1

%( K ,

2 ,

2 1 @83 8 2 8. N /A 5: \ O E@

{

2 E@ A Z : B

O,1

! ) ,:@ , 1 G O T

w - E , Oa31 $ D " 1 2 (: N! [ ( 3 4: B ` E ,:@

O E@

! 3 2 :.

(10)

Q "

-.

O E@ :E(

$ D ,

! O T .

, G H:. E -- 3

. L:04 P, 7.

O,1 . 1 2 E 4: B ` ,

L:04 Z : B

N. $ D ,

2 :

! , 3 .

#2 1

2 @ O O z R ! B 3

[ N. 1 m.

3 O,1 : B I 00R. S:

:

! ,

3 O N. $ D

Z : B

, 8 6 ; 1 ^7)!

! ( 3

! , 2 ,1 ,

! 1 , 4 ƒ 0. 1 [ 0 . , N. $ D

$ 5 C

$ :(1 , 2 G C

$ D

$ N.

.

(+4 !7

1 V T P 0\ @R :. - - . / 2 G !) :

- . / , - -

: 1 !;

( $ " [ ( 3 1

2 , 1 2 2 : 2 N /A 00R. S: 7

" 1

‚

‚ 31 $ D

‚ E@ Oa

‚ O 2 8. N /A 5: \

8

‚

@83

‚ 1

‚ $8; H , N [ ( 3 2

• 3 , $ 1 • 5 7

" 0 1 N@. 1 -.

.

References

1- World Health Organization. 2008-2013 Action Plan for the Global Strategy for the Prevention and Control of Non-communicable Diseases.

[Cited 2012 Jan 28 .[Available from:

http://www.who.int/nmh/Actionplan-PC-NCD- 2008.pdf]

2- Pololi LH, Dennisk KA. Need assessment of medical school faculty: caring for the caretakers. Journal of Continue Education Health Professional. 2003; 1: 21-29 .

3- Sildow R. The internal medicine subinternship (a curriculum need assessment).

General Internal Medicine. 2002; 17: 493-577 . 4- VanGeest JB. and Cummins DS.(2003). An educational needs assessment for improving patient safety. National Patient Safety Foundation White Paper Report. (3). 1-28.

5- Soleimani F, Vameghi R, Biglarian A.

Antenatal and intrapartum risk factors for cerebral

palsy in term and near-term newborns. Arch Iran Med. 2013;16(4): 213 – 216.

6- Soleimani F, Sourtiji H: Evaluation of perinatal and neonatal risk factors of children with cerebral palsy referred from health – care centers in north and east of Tehran. TUMJ. 2009; 67 (6): 428-435.

7- Soleimani F, Vameghi R, Rassafiani M, Akbar Fahimi N, Nobakht Z. Cerebral palsy: Motor types, gross motor function and associated disorders. Iranian Rehab J. 2011; 9(0): 21-31.

8- Gibbins S, Hoath SB, Coughlin M, Gibbins A, Franck L. The universe of developmental care: a new conceptual model for application in the neonatal intensive care unit. Advances in Neonatal Care, 2008; 8, 141.

9- Maguire CM, Veen S, Sprij AJ, Lecessie S, Wit JM, Walther FJ. Effects of basic developmental care on neonatal morbidity, neuromotor development, and growth at term age of infants who were born at< 32 weeks. Pediatric. 2008;

(11)

121, e239.

10- Educational programs in the field of neonatology and perinatal conditions . Developing and Planning Commission of the Ministry of Health and Medical Education, 2009. [in Persian]

11- Aita M, Snider L. The art of developmental care in the NICU: a concept analysis. Journal of advanced nursing. 2003; 41, 223-232.

12- Kenner C, McGrath J. Developmental care of newborns & infants: a guide for health professionals. Mosby. 2004.

13- Coughlin M, Gibbins S, Hoath S. Core measures for developmentally supportive care in neonatal intensive care units: theory, precedence and practice. Journal of advanced nursing. 2009;

65, 2239-2248.

14- Gharib M, Vameghi R, Sajedi F. Needs assessment of pediatricians and assistant pediatrics for training in early childhood development (0-8 years old). Tehran:University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation sciences;2004.

15- Karimzadeh P, Kuimarsi A, Yousefi M. A Survey of pediatrics resident knowledge of growth & development.Iranian Journal of Child Neurology. 2011 Spring;5(2):11-14.

16- Abolhassani H, Mirminachi B, Daryabeigi M, et al. Evaluation of Physicians’ Awareness of Pediatric Diseases in Iran. Iranian Journal of Pediatrics. 2014; 24(1):87-92. [in Persian]

17- Jacobs PM, Koehn ML. Curriculum evaluation: who, when, why, how? Nurs Educ Perspect. 2004; 25(1): 30-5.

18- Delaram M. Clinical education from the

viewpoints of nursing and midwifery students in Shahrekord University of Medical Sciences.

Iranian Journal of Medical Education. 2006; 6(2):

129- 135. [in Persian]

19- Gonsalves CL, Ajjawi R, Rodger M, Varpio LMed Teach. A novel approach to needs assessment in curriculum development: Going beyond consensus methods. Med Teach. 2014;

36(5):422-9.

20- Mehrdad N, Oskoyi SF, Seyed Fatemi N.

Qualitative content analysis. First ed. Tehran:

Boshra Co. 2013 . [in Persian]

21- Hsieh H, Shanon S. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis .Qual Health Res.

2005; 15: 1277-1288.

22- Graneheim UH, lundman B. Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: concepts, procedures and measure to achieve trustworthiness. Nurs Educ Today. 2004 ;24:105- 112.

23- Polit DF, Beck CT. Essentials of nursing research, methods, appraisal and utilization. 6th editions. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams &

Wilkins. 2006.

24- Burns N. Understanding Nursing Research.

Second edition. Philadelphia: Elsevier Science Health Science div; 1999.

25- Streubert HJ, Carpenter DR. Qualitative Research in Nursing. 4th ed. Philadelphia:

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2007.

26- Hajiaghamphsen A, Salahshori Fard A.

Assessment of nursing’ knowledge of the growth and development of children in selected hospitals

(12)

in Tehran University. Tehran: Tehran University of Medical Sciences,2007.

27- Yamani N, Firoozabadi N. Core curriculum in Medical Education: Introducing Some Approaches. Iranian Journal of Medical Educatio 2012; 11(9): 1263-1273. [in Persian]

28- Ahmadi S, Javidan F, Dehghan MS.

Educational strategies in undergraduate medical curriculum. Strides in Development of Medical Education . 2014(2). [in Persian]

29- Omid A, Yammani N, Heidari K, Mousavi T, Mousavi A. Educational needs of general practitioners who enrolled as family physicians in national family medicine program and referral system. Iranian Journal of Medical Education.

2013; 13(6): 470-479. [in Persian]

30- Barekatain M, Aminoroaia M, Ardestani Samimi SM, Rajabi F, Attari A. Educational needs assessment for psychiatry residents to prevent suicide: A Qualitative Approach Int J Prev Med. 2013; 4(10): 1200–1205. [in Persian]

31- Ahanchian MR , Rad M, Rad M. Educational challenges in emergency medicine technician: A qualitative research. Strides in Development of Medical Education . 2014(2). [in Persian]

32- Fakhr Movahedi A, Sadeghi S, Yousefpour M. Assessment of the effect of lecturers' behavior on clinical learning from the viewpoints of nursing students. Strides in Development of Medical Education . 2015(4). [in Persian]

33- Toulabi T, Janani F, Qurbanmohammadi E.

The Appropriateness of educational programs' objectives for professional needs: The Viewpoints of Khorramabad School of Nursing and Midwifery Graduates. Iranian Journal of Medical Education. 2009; 8(2): 263- 273. [in Persian]

34- Guralnik MJ. Effectiveness of early intervention for vulnerable children: a developmental perpective. Am J Ment Retard.

1998;102: 319-345.

(13)

Perceived Experience of Neonatal Subspecialty Students of Developmental Care Education: A Qualitative Study

Soleimani F¹, Nayeri F², Mohammadi Shahboulaghi F³, Shariat M², Dalili H²

1Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran

2Maternal, Fetal and Neonatal Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

3Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Nursing Department, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran

Corresponding Author: Nayeri F, Associate Professor, Maternal, Fetal and Neonatal Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

Email: [email protected]

Received: 17 May 2015 Accepted: 15 Sept 2015

Background and Objective: Advanced educational systems in modern countries continuously revise their scientific objectives and activities to develop the students’ competency which in turn leads to provision of a more accurate and ideal care for patients in the real world environment. The aim of this study was to determine the neonatal subspecialty students’ perceptual experience of developmental care in their educational course.

Materials and Methods: This qualitative study was carried out on 10 neonatal subspecialty students at Medical Universities of Tehran. The data was gathered through semi-structured interviews. After obtaining written consents, the interviews were recorded and transcribed. Data was analyzed through an inductive approach of content analysis. The strategies for results validation included continuous observations at the field site, and supervision and review of the analysis procedures by a research team.

Results: The main themes were found as sufficiently qualified to admit the course, structural and functional constraints of education, challenges to curriculum, lack of structure and procedure of developmental care in health systems.

Conclusion: It is suggested to revise the educational programs in the field of neonatology and perinatal conditions and provide appropriate educational programs to help graduates in getting ready for their new roles in developmental care.

یکشزپ مولع رد شزومآ ی هعسوت ی هلجم

& 8=>

3 N. $ D :4 I ! X & :

References

Perceived Experience of Neonatal Subspecialty Students of Developmental Care Education: A Qualitative Study

Keywords: Medical education, Developmental care, Neonatology, Qualitative study, Content analysis