Pengaruh Perbandingan Jamur Tiram Dan Tempe Dengan Penambahan Tapioka Dan Tepung Labu Kuning Terhadap Mutu Sosis

85 Data analisis kadar air (%)

Perlakuan Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{51,4024 53,2246} 104,6270 52,3135

B1T2 _{51,9353 52,7606} 104,6959 52,3480

B1T3 51,4367 53,3756 104,8123 52,4062

B1T4 _52,9533 52,1558 105,1091 52,5546

B1T5

B2T1

54,0276 54,0803 52,2643 53,9389 106,2919 108,1092 53,1460 54,0096

B2T2 54,7496 53,3782 108,1278 54,0639

B2T3 53,7639 55,1957 108,9596 54,4798

B2T4 53,9239 55,0762 109,0001 54,5001

B2T5 54,1236 55,2203 109,3439 54,6720

B3T1 57,2174 56,2539 113,4713 56,7357

B3T2 56,5546 58,0072 114,5618 57,2809

B3T3 56,7035 58,2338 114,9373 57,4687

B3T4 57,6981 57,4973 115,1954 57,5977

B3T5 57,0150 58,2127 115,2277 57,6139

B4T1 59,0473 59,6447 118,6920 59,3460

B4T2 60,7409 59,7526 120,4935 60,2468

B4T3 61,4573 59,1664 120,6237 60,3119

B4T4 62,0436 59,2542 121,2978 60,6489

B4T5 62,1788 60,7880 122,9668 61,4834

B5T1 62,0514 61,9922 124,0436 62,0218

B5T2 63,2652 61,2066 124,4718 62,2359

B5T3 61,2755 63,3722 124,6477 62,3239

B5T4 62,1849 63,0336 125,2185 62,6093

86 Daftar sidik ragam kadar air(%)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05 F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 671,1843 27,9660 17,1932 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 663,1312 165,7828 101,9214 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 6,1181 1,5295 0,9403 tn 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 _{1,9350 0,1209 0,0743 tn} 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 40,6644 1,6265

Total 49 771,8687

87 Data analisis kadar abu (%)

Perlakuan Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{1,9591 2,0143} 3,9734 1,9867

B1T2 _{2,0407 1,9623} 4,0030 2,0015

B1T3 2,1983 1,8504 4,0487 2,0244

B1T4 _2,1850 1,9107 4,0957 2,0479

B1T5 _{2,1102 2,0892} 4,1994 2,0997

B2T1 _{2,1098 2,1755} 4,2853 2,1427

B2T2 2,1187 2,2992 4,4179 2,2090

B2T3 2,2541 2,1692 4,4233 2,2117

B2T4 2,0995 2,3976 4,4971 2,2486

B2T5 2,1779 2,3583 4,5362 2,2681

B3T1 2,4286 2,3532 4,7818 2,3909

B3T2 2,3059 2,4961 4,8020 2,4010

B3T3 2,4226 2,5071 4,9297 2,4649

B3T4 2,4224 2,5192 4,9416 2,4708

B3T5 2,3448 2,6172 4,9620 2,4810

B4T1 2,4212 2,5842 5,0054 2,5027

B4T2 2,5917 2,5639 5,1556 2,5778

B4T3 2,6243 2,6066 5,2309 2,6155

B4T4 2,5439 2,8672 5,4111 2,7056

B4T5 2,7670 2,6638 5,4308 2,7154

B5T1 2,6517 2,8068 5,4585 2,7293

B5T2 2,7065 2,7719 5,4784 2,7392

B5T3 2,8153 2,7032 5,5185 2,7593

B5T4 2,7879 2,7671 5,5550 2,7775

88 Daftar sidik ragam kadar abu (%)

SK db JK KT F hit

F 0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 3,6676 _0,1528 9,8755 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 3,5427 0,8857 57,2351 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 0,1031 0,0258 1,6660 tn 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,0218 0,0014 0,0880 tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 0,3869 0,015474244

Total 49 222,9361

89 Data analasis kadar lemak (%)

Perlakuan _Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{15,7193 17,0177} 32,7370 16,3685

B1T2 16,7462 16,2191 32,9653 16,4826

B1T3 _{16,5757 17,0145} 33,5902 16,7951

B1T4 18,0320 15,6254 33,6573 16,8287

B1T5 _{15,9791 18,7051} 34,6843 17,3421

B2T1 _{16,4676 14,0576} 30,5252 15,2626

B2T2 13,8502 17,1389 30,9891 15,4945

B2T3 15,5511 15,6174 31,1686 15,5843

B2T4 15,6023 15,6693 31,2716 15,6358

B2T5 15,2046 16,7184 31,9230 15,9615

B3T1 15,6778 14,1772 29,8551 14,9275

B3T2 16,8852 13,0387 29,9239 14,9619

B3T3 16,0275 14,5148 30,5423 15,2712

B3T4 14,9644 16,8261 31,7905 15,8952

B3T5 15,3202 16,5631 31,8833 15,9417

B4T1 13,0911 16,5196 29,6107 14,8053

B4T2 14,6276 15,4113 30,0389 15,0194

B4T3 15,6847 14,9500 30,6346 15,3173

B4T4 15,1051 15,7575 30,8626 15,4313

B4T5 16,6621 15,0243 31,6864 15,8432

B5T1 13,5703 14,3655 27,9358 13,9679

B5T2 15,1844 13,0593 28,2437 14,1218

B5T3 14,9914 13,7216 28,7130 14,3565

B5T4 14,9675 14,0100 28,9776 14,4888

90 Daftar sidik ragam kadar lemak (%)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 35,2885 _1,4704 0,8839 tn 1,96 2,62

B 4 29,3333 7,3333 4,4084 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 5,4432 1,3608 0,8180 tn 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,5120 0,0320 0,0192 tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 41,5877 1,6635

Total 49 76,8762

91 Data analisis kadar protein(%)

Perlakuan Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{8,7215 8,5413} 17,2628 8,6314

B1T2 8,9666 8,6309 17,5975 8,7987

B1T3 _{9,1149 8,6412} 17,7561 8,8781

B1T4 9,1856 8,6968 17,8824 8,9412

B1T5 _{9,5661 8,8513} 18,4175 9,2087

B2T1 _{10,9452 10,0618} 21,0070 10,5035

B2T2 10,9584 10,2425 21,2009 10,6005

B2T3 11,4760 10,2920 21,7680 10,8840

B2T4 11,6462 11,0522 22,6985 11,3492

B2T5 11,9443 11,1287 23,0730 11,5365

B3T1 12,0810 11,7184 23,7994 11,8997

B3T2 12,2646 11,8413 24,1059 12,0530

B3T3 12,4789 12,3046 24,7835 12,3917

B3T4 12,4310 12,3445 24,7755 12,3877

B3T5 12,8413 12,3570 25,1983 12,5992

B4T1 13,0912 12,3362 25,4274 12,7137

B4T2 13,0966 12,6173 25,7139 12,8569

B4T3 13,1632 12,7909 25,9540 12,9770

B4T4 13,3000 12,8700 26,1700 13,0850

B4T5 13,7107 12,9820 26,6926 13,3463

B5T1 14,0289 13,6103 27,6393 13,8196

B5T2 14,1883 13,8511 28,0393 14,0197

B5T3 14,2319 14,0690 28,3009 14,1504

B5T4 14,2498 14,4803 28,7301 14,3651

92 Daftar sidik ragam kadar protein(%)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 166,6534 _6,9439 45,8957 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 163,0613 40,7653 269,4385 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 3,1458 0,7865 5,1980 ** 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,4463 0,02789 0,1844 _tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 3,7824 0,1513

Total 49 170,4359

93 Data analisis kadar serat (%)

Perlakuan _Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{1,5841 1,6101} 3,1942 1,5971

B1T2 1,6115 1,6491 3,2606 1,6303

B1T3 _{1,8262 1,4826} 3,3088 1,6544

B1T4 _1,9723 1,4990 3,4714 1,7357

B1T5

B2T1

2,0406 1,7902 1,4972 1,6321 3,5378 3,4223 1,7689 1,7112

B2T2 1,6384 1,8069 3,4453 1,7226

B2T3 1,9076 1,5644 3,4721 1,7360

B2T4 2,0562 1,5704 3,6266 1,8133

B2T5 2,0854 1,7708 3,8562 1,9281

B3T1 1,8463 1,9464 3,7927 1,8963

B3T2 1,9837 1,8480 3,8316 1,9158

B3T3 1,8836 2,0009 3,8644 1,9322

B3T4 2,0523 2,0312 4,0836 2,0418

B3T5 2,2531 1,8422 4,0973 2,0486

B4T1 2,1166 2,0326 4,1492 2,0746

B4T2 2,1719 2,4094 4,5812 2,2906

B4T3 2,2189 2,5073 4,7262 2,3631

B4T4 2,3032 2,4445 4,7477 2,3738

B4T5 2,6550 2,1188 4,7737 2,3869

B5T1 2,3687 2,1649 4,5336 2,2668

B5T2 2,3824 2,0572 4,4396 2,2198

B5T3 2,3444 2,5222 4,8667 2,4333

B5T4 2,5294 2,3932 4,9226 2,4613

94 Daftar sidik ragam kadar serat (%)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 4,4462 _0,1853 4,4903 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 3,9648 0,9912 24,0243 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 0,3691 0,0923 2,2366 tn 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,1123 0,0070 0,1702 tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 1,0314 0,0413

Total 49 5,4777

95

Data analisis uji organoleptik hedonik warna (numerik)

Perlakuan Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{2,6667 2,3333} 5,0000 2,5000

B1T2 3,2000 3,2667 6,4667 3,2333

B1T3 _{2,4667 2,8000} 5,2667 2,6333

B1T4 _3,8000 3,0000 6,8000 3,4000

B1T5 _{2,8000 2,8000} 5,6000 2,8000

B2T1 _{3,2667 3,4000} 6,6667 3,3333

B2T2 3,1333 3,1333 6,2667 3,1333

B2T3 2,8667 3,4000 6,2667 3,1333

B2T4 3,4000 2,8667 6,2667 3,1333

B2T5

B3T1

3,0667 4,0000 3,1333 3,9333 6,2000 7,9333 3,1000 3,9667

B3T2 2,8000 3,0667 5,8667 2,9333

B3T3 3,2667 3,4000 _6,6667 3,3333

B3T4 3,1333 3,1333 6,6667 3,1333

B3T5 3,0000 2,9333 5,9333 2,9667

B4T1 3,2667 3,4000 6,6667 3,3333

B4T2 3,5333 3,6000 7,1333 3,5667

B4T3 3,0667 3,0667 6,1333 3,0667

B4T4 3,4000 3,6000 7,0000 3,5000

B4T5

B5T1

3,4667 3,8667 3,0667 3,4000 6,5333 7,2667 3,2667 3,6333

B5T2 3,4667 3,6000 7,0667 3,5333

B5T3 3,4000 3,3333 6,7333 3,3667

B5T4 3,0667 3,1333 6,2000 3,1000

96 Daftar sidik ragam hedonik warna (numerik)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 4,7731 _0,1989 4,9061 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 1,3840 0,3460 8,5363 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 0,5662 0,1416 3,4924 * 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 2,8229 0,1764 4,3527 ** 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 1,0314 0,0413

Total 49 5,4777

97

Data analisis uji organoleptik hedonik aroma (numerik)

Perlakuan _Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 3,2667 3,4667 6,7333 3,3667

B1T2 3,4000 2,8667 6,2667 3,1333

B1T3 3,4000 3,2000 _6,6000 3,3000

B1T4 3, 6667 3,6667 _7,3333 3,6667

B1T5 _2,9333 3,0667 _{6,0000 3,0000}

B2T1 3,1333 3,5333 6,6667 3,3333

B2T2 3,2000 3,1333 6,3333 3,1667

B2T3 2,9333 3,4000 6,3333 3,1667

B2T4 3,7333 3,7333 7,4667 3,7333

B2T5 3,2000 3,1333 6,3333 3,1667

B3T1 3,1333 3,0667 6,2000 3,1000

B3T2 3,1333 3,5333 6,6667 3,3333

B3T3 3,0667 3,1333 6,2000 3,1000

B3T4 3,6000 3,8000 7,4000 3,7000

B3T5 3,2000 3,1333 6,3333 3,1667

B4T1 3,4667 3,4667 6,9333 3,4667

B4T2 3,3333 3,4000 6,7333 3,3667

B4T3 3,4667 3,4667 6,9333 3,4667

B4T4 3,9333 3,8000 7,7333 3,8667

B4T5 3,4667 3,4667 6,9333 3,4667

B5T1 _{2,8667 3,0000} 5,8667 2,9333

B5T2 _{3,1333 3,3333} 6,4667 3,2333

B5T3 3,1333 3,1333 6,2667 3,1333

B5T4 3,4667 3,5333 7,0000 3,5000

98 Daftar sidik ragam hedonik aroma (numerik)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05 F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 2,7595 _0,1150 5,3672 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 0,6110 0,1528 7,1307 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 1,7470 0,4368 20,3880 ** 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,4014 0,0251 1,1712 tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 0,5356 0,0214

Total 49 3,2950

99

Data analisis uji organoleptik hedonik rasa (numerik)

Perlakuan Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{3,2667 3,3333} 6,6000 3,3000

B1T2 3,4000 3,4000 6,8000 3,4000

B1T3 _{3,3333 3,3333} 6,6667 3,3333

B1T4 _3,5333 3,6000 7,1333 3,5667

B1T5 _{3,4667 3,3333} 6,8000 3,4000

B2T1 _{3,2667 3,0667} 6,3333 3,1667

B2T2 3,4000 3,7333 7,1333 3,5667

B2T3 3,0667 3,0667 6,1333 3,0667

B2T4 3,5333 4,1333 7,6667 3,8333

B2T5 3,3333 3,4000 6,7333 3,3667

B3T1 3,1333 3,1333 6,2667 3,1333

B3T2 3,5333 3,5333 7,0667 3,5333

B3T3 3,4667 3,6667 7,1333 3,5667

B3T4 3,8667 4,0667 7,9333 3,9667

B3T5 3,2000 3,4667 6,6667 3,3333

B4T1 3,2000 3,2000 6,4000 3,2000

B4T2 3,5333 3,5333 7,0667 3,5333

B4T3 3,6667 3,8000 7,4667 3,7333

B4T4 4,1333 4,0000 8,1333 4,0667

B4T5 3,0667 3,2000 6,2667 3,1333

B5T1 3,0667 2,8667 5,9333 2,9667

B5T2 3,2000 3,1333 6,3333 3,1667

B5T3 3,3333 3,3333 6,6667 3,3333

B5T4 3,8000 3,9333 7,7333 3,8667

100 Daftar sidik ragam hedonik rasa (numerik)

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05 F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 4,1008 _0,1709 10,5041 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 0,3524 0,0881 5,4153 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 2,8457 0,7114 43,7350 ** 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,9028 0,0564 3,4686 ** 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 0,5356 0,0214

Total 49 3,2950

101 Data analisis uji organoleptik hedonik tekstur

Perlakuan _Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{2,8000 2,8000} 5,6000 2,8000

B1T2 3,1333 3,2667 6,4000 3,2000

B1T3 _{2,7333 2,7333} 5,4667 2,7333

B1T4 _3,2000 3,2000 6,4000 3,2000

B1T5 _{2,8000 2,8000} 5,6000 2,8000

B2T1 2,9333 2,9333 5,8667 2,9333

B2T2 3,2000 3,3333 6,5333 3,2667

B2T3 3,2000 3,2000 6,4000 3,2000

B2T4 3,4000 3,4000 6,8000 3,4000

B2T5 3,3333 3,4000 6,7333 3,3667

B3T1 3,2000 3,2000 6,4000 3,2000

B3T2 3,0667 3,0667 6,1333 3,0667

B3T3 3,4667 3,0667 6,5333 3,2667

B3T4 3,6000 3,7333 7,3333 3,6667

B3T5 2,8667 3,1333 6,0000 3,0000

B4T1 2,9333 3,3333 6,2667 3,1333

B4T2 3,0667 3,0000 6,0667 3,0333

B4T3 3,5333 3,5333 7,0667 3,5333

B4T4 3,9333 3,8667 7,8000 3,9000

B4T5 3,0667 3,2667 6,3333 3,1667

B5T1 2,8667 2,6000 5,4667 2,7333

B5T2 3,0667 3,4667 6,5333 3,2667

B5T3 3,2000 3,1333 6,3333 3,1667

B5T4 3,8000 3,6667 7,4667 3,7333

102 Daftar sidik ragam hedonik tekstur

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 4,8946 _0,2039 8,5291 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 0,9719 0,2430 10,1617 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 2,4581 0,6145 25,7007 ** 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 1,4645 0,0915 3,8281 ** 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 0,5978 0,0239

Total 49 5,4924

103 Data analisis uji skor tekstur

Perlakuan Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{2,9333 2,8667} 5,8000 2,9000

B1T2 2,4000 2,9333 5,3333 2,6667

B1T3 _{2,3333 2,6667} 5,0000 2,5000

B1T4 _{2,1333 2,8667} 5,0000 2,5000

B1T5 _{2,6000 2,8000} 5,4000 2,7000

B2T1 2,4000 2,8000 5,2000 2,6000

B2T2 3,0667 3,1333 6,2000 3,1000

B2T3 2,4667 2,8667 5,3333 2,6667

B2T4 _{2,9333 2,8667} 5,8000 2,9000

B2T5 2,4000 2,7333 5,1333 2,5667

B3T1 2,7333 3,0667 5,8000 2,9000

B3T2 3,0000 3,4667 6,4667 3,2333

B3T3 2,8667 3,0667 5,9333 2,9667

B3T4 2,7333 3,0000 5,7333 2,8667

B3T5 2,7333 3,1333 5,8667 2,9333

B4T1 3,2667 3,3333 6,6000 3,3000

B4T2 3,4000 3,5333 6,9333 3,4667

B4T3 3,0000 3,0667 6,0667 3,0333

B4T4 3,2000 3,2667 6,4667 3,2333

B4T5 3,0000 3,0667 6,0667 3,0333

B5T1 3,1333 3,0667 6,2000 3,1000

B5T2 3,6000 3,6667 7,2667 3,6333

B5T3 3,1333 3,2000 6,3333 3,1667

B5T4 3,0000 3,0000 6,0000 3,0000

104 Daftar sidik ragam skor tekstur

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05

F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 4,1330 _0,1722 4,1308 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 2,5676 0,6419 15,3977 ** 2,76 4,18

T 4 0,8734 0,2184 5,2377 ** 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 0,6919 0,0432 1,0373 tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 1,0422 0,0416

Total 49 5,1752

105 Data analisis nilai indeks warna

Perlakuan _Ulangan Total Rataan

I II

B1T1 _{49,0328 42,2300} 91,2628 45,6314

B1T2 42,1388 51,4495 93,5883 46,7941

B1T3 _{64,5694 61,7064} 126,2759 63,1379

B1T4 61,4206 66,0555 127,4761 63,7380

B1T5 _{67,4982 69,7354} 137,2337 68,6168

B2T1 38,2628 43,3075 81,5703 40,7851

B2T2 44,5554 42,5706 87,1260 43,5630

B2T3 52,1420 45,3813 97,5233 48,7616

B2T4 _{60,3100 58,8538} 119,1638 59,5819

B2T5 61,1134 59,3821 120,4955 60,2477

B3T1 36,8038 35,9534 72,7572 36,3786

B3T2 39,2763 36,6714 75,9477 37,9738

B3T3 50,0082 46,4761 96,4843 48,2421

B3T4 54,5897 61,9617 116,5514 58,2757

B3T5 56,7456 61,1988 117,9444 58,9722

B4T1 35,3061 33,8853 69,1914 34,5957

B4T2 35,9571 34,9304 70,8876 35,4437

B4T3 48,8276 46,3808 95,2084 47,6041

B4T4 55,9469 56,9103 112,8572 56,4285

B4T5 57,5992 57,5960 115,2952 57,6476

B5T1 21,0717 25,4871 46,5588 23,2794

B5T2 24,3753 34,4891 58,8643 29,4321

B5T3 34,3057 32,6151 _66,9209 33,4604

B5T4 49,8753 50,4513 100,3266 50,1633

106 Daftar sidik ragam nilai indeks warna

SK db JK KT F hit F

0,05 F 0,01

Perlakuan 24 6834,5483 _248,7728 28,8528 ** 1,96 2,62

B 4 2076,9527 519,2382 52,6085 ** 2,76 4,18 T 4 4538,9297 1134,7324 114,969 ** 2,76 4,18

B x T 16 218,6659 13,6666 1,3847 tn 2,06 2,81

Galat 25 246,7463 0,0416

Total 49 7081,2946

107 Data analisis bahan baku

Parameter Jamur tiram Tempe Tapioka Tepung labu kuning Kadar air (%)

Kadar abu (%) Kadar lemak (%) Kadar protein (%) Kadar serat (%)

90,18 3,956 4,548 20,728

3,951

61,32 2,461 6,728 18,577 1,172

10,629 1,162 0,599 0,338 0,472