»
«
»
«
)
(
) :
10 / 7 / 1386 - :
15 / 9 / 1386 (
:
!"#
$
% "&
'(
)*
# + ,- , ". / ,0
+ /1 "&
2) 3 4 1 5( &
6 / ! 7 8 9) 3 :) + ;<-
+ )0
= 0 0
5. ; 1 > ? (
&
5!0
2!0
2,> @ , ,#
,-
2 . >
A B-
2C >
/ 2
# - . 2 4E > F 6 A
- C
G ) H "C>
+ - ;<- I <
& * 2!!"#
3 !"#
6 <J 1
:>
2 * K >
5.
# + -
". / 0 + <)
7L ,:> , + ,;<-
M N
+ - /
2 2 <- N I 3
» +
« Q"-
% "&
'(
5 <I "
? 4 1
I : / R#
+ - + ;<-
% "&
'(
#
B- -
2 /
+ ,- + )0 ,
+ I 8 CS / TI ") 5)AR
U <) 3
$ )A F <I1 N 2 4E
6 A , ,& * ,
V 5)W 2 A .
+ !. 6 X :
3
# Y 3 !"#
3 2 4E 6 A 3
".
3
+ 4A
.
: 88306202 [email protected]
Email:
! " #$ % &" ' #()* # +#,- %!./ 0 1 2" % .
! "#
$%& ' ()' * +
* $*
,-.
/0 1 2 345 67832 9$:
;
<' => !
? @A =B C:
8A $D -$
&
>
<' , E:#
*
<F G-6 H 67 I6J:
)D H$' 883;
3D KA
<3!
<6C: 5 L 6)D M , N6. O6'
P684QA ,#
6$@!R S
, $: E5
<' B TOA U
<4.
G M V$ 7A
) democratic governance
-6$A 6' OF (
<' W)1 , A #
> ! L )D
> O' X' )A GM A#
B 64@F
) K6A
effective control
<6$7 6' (
6'
$3F D
$@A
? @A $D
; HQ*
<4Y"
A
) .
Gregory H. Fox, 2001, P328
.(
6A
X -C
"W)1
< J:
"
"
"[-
<' X32 (A 5 X32 ,-: . +
<' ,#
<6 J: \ ] U S
>
<6F
O; ^ H$_@*
: CA ' , F
IJ:
H$' 883;
HEF
;
* 1A
<6: S , -6@^ 6E@
, 6*#
3:
<78' - 3:
X7OA $`'
* . G- L )D : E5 O' )8
, F 6U '
W 6A M
,#
<'
$3*
H4U @.
> $@' %A , F ,#
V 6* 9$^
: 6E5 => 65 6%
(: Y @A ,#
_ 9$^
.
<'
$! S _ $C%
L )D , 6E5 O' B 36.
H4`6:
,#
[-6$a$+
Peter Schwab,2000,PP.218-221)[ 6'
`6! (
H6 M \ ] 6U b c6$D
<6F 61 d %O6;
e73OF
> ! * $*
<4 " 9$:
<78' S ,# M
X32 S B C M
E5 :
<6' X632 [-6A#
C`:
<' H f 8gA -:
<^ S [ Y4* h * `' [-.
,# M
<6' , 6@2 O6. +
> 6' i 6j:
/ Y8Q [ E'
> ' A . .
> A
<F
<' "-$a$+
> .
> ! g%A
<' k46U 6J:
$! A / -E%
L )D L )D ' l : A O'
- 9 . H6 ' 6 M 46*
6382 m6U
< J: M C!
X32 / Y4A
<78' n %4A
<: _^
/ 6Y8Q 6' ' o-6. ' - ' 96$:
[ Y4* h *
> ! X' $p
<^ 7:
O@F A , , O:
<@1] ' o
> 6!
X6' $p X631
. : # 59:
P8Q M L )D M
<$;
> $@'
> O'
; q$%C
> r6:
X`6: S O6F S
>M `F +
> r:
/ 3F 1A S , -'
2 X -D
> ! -: 4*
s6
<j@76. S ...
<6^
-6 '
> * M o F
$3! # S _ [ _ 5
! 4*
[-32
<6F tg6*
: 6E5 -6 -+
<4O"
<' \k32 \ J:
5 d 3 [-$*
A S , [- :
"
B ] # o
>-2
<F tg*
: 6E5
>
W6 6E:#
d 635
A 632 67 65
, 6@^
<4U 6* u64A
<66F
v 5 U / Y8Q ' '
e@F U M
, O:
A ( 34* - C: S-@!
-!
($; 2
> 6_
<F
* 3
> * : E5 -@ # ,-.
L )D p O'
* E:#
6A # o , 6
H6 M
B ] H $@' -2
<' , @2
> 9'
<$82 S E:#
[ E'
<F ' L )D M
<6' O6'
<6' wA 96'
* $*
[ Y4*
A V1A o-@@F
>-):
> ' ej@*
`D i 9;
(6E5 A S : `6F
[ Y46*
<F . H M A M \ 34`A B -2 '9A
[ F /0 1 : E5 x 4:
(86] D H6
<6@$AM
i J:
H$' X83;
;
<' 1A
> * y'
@4CA
" ' L )D
>-: E.
"
o-6: -: 6'
< E@;
H e* + [ 3!
z gA [ '
<F
? @A # 4$@A
> 4
; f 16]
/ -6
L )D '
t$5 O'
[ 3:
o-: .
) Peter R. Baehr,2001,P83 (
* + .
<' H e* +
!
f ^ ^ d 5
$!
, E5 ; 3.
L )D W$ - + O' v 7@F
B D (6Y; A
"
<@$AM
> ! * $*
"
"
[ _4* U
" _@!
6)D L [ 6_ 5 O6' H6
<6; )A -6@ #
: E5 ,-.
L )D E5 9$: O'
> $"
> ! . : ,# M + A I $"
.
{ H M e* + * * $`'
<F L )D # P6 % ' 6@' O'
, 6_3! 6' S -6$ k'
| . X' B 32
*
<7@
f ^ ^ - ' }@!
> 4
<%A 5 !
~ I6E 6.
) C`:
"
(
<2 3jA S X -D
> !
<'
$3*
<4U @.
G-.
: E5 B 6D
" 61A
$: `6:
"
S
8A 62 M , 6^
"
"}6@!
"S
"H6
"
"i 6 i 6* A S
<6' L 6)D 61 O6'
$ u6
7.
> !
$`' %
i J:
H$' X83;
7. b !
<F , AM 6*
X68A -614A
<4. M ' El 9$:
. , E5 V • ; €- = Cg
, }@5
> 6$: S * f 6p
V M
• (8]
, E5 L .
> ! $%A M : E5
g%A
<' L )D
<4`6: 6 M O6'
‚$%&
IF D ,# ' V; 3A
[ )4: A
H$2 A S B D
I6 • M
> 6!
<6A F U S
HOU Bƒ3; ' A 7D
> !
<6' \ ] S " -4 682
H4 6"
(6EC5 -6&
I`6$: 3F S
3D W8gA
<' X32 A
# .
<'
<8' )A \0 3%A _ $C%
> ! V
<C: 5
>
<F
> * M U '
; B 32 ! A
[-.
<' S X 0 * $*
[ '
<:
<' X$;
: _:
6%
‚$%6& M L 6)D
; D b O'
<F
>-A# F : [-. - -+
L )D J@A M
<F S O' IO^
, @3.
6A
`6:
<: E'
>
> ' Y:
> U ' U ' M
L )D / 6$4A
> 6* M 6;
P68Q4A M S-6. '
> * , 4*
* $*
3D A A
"
Christian Tomuschat,2004,P.229) (
H6 M .
/-AM m_!
<a:#
(%A 5 ' : E5
< * [-@7
<^ S
> @4' ' `' [ '
> ! Q 6 S
>
cD CA
| ' A
<'
‚$C`:
6_@!
vM 6
> 6!
A 6' G Y46* S
> 96' d 6& A M
L )D ' O'
> ! * $*
[ '
Kelly Kate S. Pease,2000,PP.206-207) * .(
H ' - '
<47:
<1]
<4. m"
<F . G _:
L )D H $@' O'
> M#
> ! * $*
- ' S
1 g . ! i 41A
3.
[
i-2 .
2 q):
,#
1
„$6!
g 6.
X6'
v m+
`$:
‚$% S @4CA / - '
?6 +
6 "
6* $*
6 7D ,# M
<6F
> ! $%A -2 L )D
(] 2 O' y'
/ - i 6A B 632
<678' R 6Y:
(g86*
[ "
> ! * $*
F D I n %A
<)$sA - -1 A
<6F 6j:# 6 b $"
> $`6' M
?A 5 f ^ ^ S y'
d 345 S
;
<F V Q 6 -6@ # X76.
<64 "
i A L )D S m+
H$: O'
< 5 B 632
,#
(6] 2 : 635 S 65
[ M
vk
$*
* [ "
> ! IF D
>R [ ' R Y:
<F
> 6' 6
…6YD 6$% A
P$%s6 6 6U
$
> ! $%A M S
<4.m" '9A ,#
* $* 9' ' M -):
X -%
> 6 ' 6*
[ "-
[ !
A
(Neil Stammers, 1993,P.74; Issa Shivji,1999,P.253.)-6@!
. 6A
>
<6F
<)$8* ' l : B 32
/ -
* f ^ ^ y'
; d 345 D# ' ! IJ:
W`:
<4 (] 2 \k32
* $*
H$' X83;
V M S / C5 A * ' j
> 342
<' H -6:
G9$_: M ' Y@A
I!
A
4* $* #
X' $p B C
$* `D 6' 6* 6_ M M
> ! 4U *
X$31 5 A
[ F
<'
? E5 M E:#
> $"
> ! (4` ' g%A
<' 3D
L )D -2 M
<4U * O'
<78' S d Y4: 9‚$D M
† U A -@F .
<$. D 6* $* 9'
H4 "
($Ak2 : E5 L )D O' }@5 V • €- f p L .
<€ S
‡ 6 $`6Y
/ -E% M L w$A
H$' 883;
L )D
> 4 2 345 S _@!
E5 [ O"
4*
;
> !
e): S s2 , $`$3F )4: A F F
L )D
<F O'
<6' j@A A0 U#
> 6. 6j
L 6)D H6 S-6 " O6' X6' 46*
6* ' 6*
).
Tomuschat,P.113; Lawrence C.
Moss,2006.PP.4-5 .
( .
A , H
<: "
<j$4:
"
<F i # -:
Ng' X7.
> $"
> 5 / -E%
)D
3*
L )D ' l : tg* O'
: E5 1 S / k4U $ u / A E'
. : P6 % M
32 B L )D * $* => $: O'
;
> !
‚$3F D M U ' [-6.
6*
. H6 6A
> $:
* $*
[-.
3: # ,
H '
<F ' ' 6U '
> 6! j@! M 6@$2
6 kU
> 6'
, _4.m"
B D S , "-@ #
<' , `7
<F ^ S-. ' C4%A : `6: !
<6' S 6]
, `6:
, 6'
>
A D
* H ' ˆ * U ' C`: - C: A
<'
„$!
: `:
i j:
6U ' $"
C`: - ' _
<' : `: ! B 32
Michael J. Perry,1997,PP.461-63)o .
( .
t& +
*
<F
<' Ip f 4. + + -:
(] 2 : E5
,-.
)D L 6! j@!
X -%
$3F D
; /k7OA S ! 5
, @a3!
* 5 ' + .
; A ! L 6)D -6@:
[- : '9A [- : -: $"
A , -' -: $"
<F -D f ^ ^ ( J:
? "
[ 3! S
, `:
: '
* $*
* 38‰
[ '
*
W.Friedman,1984,P.40) .
(
>-: .
<F (C€ . M
B 32
; R Y:
> ! i J: -@3 - H$'
X83;
`$: Š CA .
<6' (6; )A S 6_ 6$C%
6 3D
H$' 883;
L )D M 4D O'
> Y$F )8 , F U ' / Y8Q L )D -2 M - -.
O6'
4D X' $p
$: A H4`:
, *
;
‹ U !
f 7 H B 32 4D B 632
$Dk]
: E5
$)%
(3F 1A H$8A 2 / @5 H$' 883;
W)1 H6 X6]
<6F
„$6!
A jA , -' - C:
/ M jA ' -: 3' )
<F : E5 -A $+ U ,-.
L )D )8 O' A
6.
.(
<O$3!
<' Π1;
> J:
832 B C)4* M S : _3!
< `; ' [ 6C: U '
<678' S 6 +
U ' f j . : / R 7832 M H$'
883;
d 6& A S 6 3D
H$6' 6883;
f ^ 6^
* $*
/ - '
;
> ' !
`F
? @A ' M A r$4* + Bƒ3; '
-
A
$"
.
>-
<F
<' J:
$* `D X'
; •~
C`: !
<'
$3F D
$Dk6]
> 6!
8U ,# S I!
(] 2 X' )
H$' ; -;
<' S 2 : A )A X -C
[-.
*
<F ^ b (] 2
y' H$' ; -;
B 32 ' -$Fu
> 5 H$6' -2 6883;
L 6)D 46* O6' 96' 9
* $*
B 32 / -
;
> ! A -@3 -
<F -@:
<46.m" "
> 6$: M A 6J:
\ 6@82
<$82 \ 3$)4`A
;
> ! 1
<g8*
P$%&
[ Y4*
A I! A S-: F , @F
<F 3:
6' -6@:
[ $.
> ! [ E' ' - -5
> '
> ! 4* M
> 7 382 S _@!
[ Y46* h * 6' 9$:
/ * `D M , -5
A 32 -! S (4.m" h * B C: U
-@@F .
H [ "-
; S
> !
<g8*
IF D "
i J: ' H$' X83;
[ Y46* 6' 6] M
> 6!
<6'
* [-A#
, F 9$:
> ! E:
H$' 883;
T$8C B 32 S - / A @% b-@ 3:
9 4*
* $*
;
> ! Ž 9' E5
<g8*
> "
<F S -!
Bƒ3; ' E:#
i J:
H$' X83;
> $" 85 S M
/ Y8Q q):
L 6)D
> 6) O6' , 6A #
> 6!
L 6)D
> O6' (6%A 5 : 6E5
`6$:
.
) S.Pease,2000,PP.214-215;Tom Campbell,2001.
.(
H$662 B 66D
, S }66@5
66*
> - • L )D M
$%& CE' O' ,#
> * M
;
> ! (4 O$+
4%@]
( J: +
, E5 ; 3.
L )D
> 9' O'
<6$82 6$
6@% S-6@3 - 6;
> 6.
) 6'
David
Forsythe, 2006, P.155
.(
XAu ' L $*
ikF 3$5
•$€ S F WC* E35
B 7 A#
'
H
<F
» i A , E5 * *
<'
e 9 • U
/ • C S *
•6D 64E' 67 9:
<6' 4O6$'
, ! U S _ -3!
* * =L )D -@4`! U
«
) M 7`6@ • ' $@_$' S
1369 S
‹ 165
.(
» A $+
<F A 3
, "-@ 3:
A
† U / M M S
<5 U : " M ' S
>M OF S
>
A H -@: *
*
<F
L )D
$! A O' y'
> ! OF ' A :M _
<
>
H$_@*
<' f `D A H36& 6A S- #
? M
?' @A X$8
<A : '
> ! V3F 5 U , O6: U I$! 6U
<6F W6$32 H 6 6* @A / C
<: 4*
88A ' I$! U
.
<F
<' -E%4A , 3$+
<%A 5 [
<%*
V6$ 7A
[-.
-. ' . C`:
<' I • !
<F
<' q):
8F L )D
> O + O' A
IO6U M ' S-@@F
4 & :
I$! Q: - U
3: ! J 9$: F I$@F
<6F , 63g' 3$36]
6*
«
)
> 6'
H$' S 1363
‹ S 798
.(
H
<: "
<' A J:
<F -*
(; )A L )D XA 2 S O' H$$%
[-@@F
>
y6'
; * ' 7 A )8 !
A [-.
*
> 6A b
<6F (63! \ 6)g@A
<6@$AM
> 6!
>M O6F S
> 4 ...
<4. M ' El - ' -. '
. 7`@ • ' A
<' S , @2 V
` r 4*
? 6"
; H S 7 A
‹ U
<' 8€ `A [ 6.
6A
<6F -6@F
<6^ "
H6 -6$ u 6* $*
A (@ 9" - KA A S- 3:
* $*
, ' ,#
)8 9$:
A . :
»
„$6! M 6A
> O6F
`6$:
<6F
v 7832 -: -:
(@$AM L )D eg' S O' 1 A '
6A 6 $ u -6!
. H6A -6$Fu
A I@F
<F H /k35
<: ! "#
A I "
.
; 7832 4
(@$AM ! L 6)D
6' O6'
y' A $ u E:# ' A ; m"
O):
H$$%
[-@@F -:
.
<5 4A - ' A H
6)$)D I$6. '
<F / JDkA
> _ y' 6; ' A
> 6!
-6: $ u6 6_
. 6JDkA , 6^
? 6@A
<)g@A
>
? @A S
‹ U
<C: 5 X€ `A 4$@A . [ "
<' H • U / JDkA
; ' - ' 6!
y' V 9:
@4CA
> 73! ' I M * '
<F -@^ ! b H
;
! (@$AM L )D O6'
E5
<'
<4* U
> !
<4. -: A -@. '
«
) 7`@ • '
‹ S 199
.(
7`@ • ' H
<6F 46*
?6 '
7 X 0 M G-32 [ Y4*
L 6)D 9' M G Y46* S O6'
> 96' ,# M 6E5
<68' )A 6'
v 4`"
}@5 V • ; €- H3. '
G 3.
V A#
[ ' 7 H ' S , 3"
*
<F ,# S 7 A#
<F •
> . ' - . - ' [ 3@: U '
)$)D
> -6D 6'
/ 6Y (8N`6A M
L )D
<4.m" O' '
.
>
* -)4%A
<F 4` ' 7 A#
[ Y4* ' L )D M
<6' O6' }6@5
i J:
> 47 L @4U
. 9$A#
>
A
) ikF C M S 1372
‹ S 151
.(
H6€ - H6 96$:
‹ U
H ' , 3"
*
<F ($s L )D V E@ O'
<4.
' M y'
G-$a$+
L 6.
f p [ '
*
) H$'
‹ S 761 (.
H U ' S 4*
, -@3O -:
d & A : E5 ,-.
3D H$' 883;
L 6)D M O6'
> _ -%“' M * ' A 9$:
X$81 [
,#
y' M
/ -
> ! Ž 96'
GM CA / - ' M _ -7 ' [ F
,#
(4.m"
6
> 3%46*
> ! O6F , 6E5
i *
`5 [ F 5 -:
. H X$81 L )D S
€95 O' i J: M
)D IF 6D (6%A 5 6'
H$'
> ' ' : = 883;
* @.
A
<F . ,# +
> ! OF S 6E:# 6' " 3%46* -@3 -
A 7D A -: F
) }:
S 1366
”] S 94 - 91
.(
4 m;
G•
: E5 ,-.
H$' 6883;
, 6'
<835 M S-2 L )D -2
O' z • A ()' * "
8 H6 -@ 6. U :
?6A 5 2 -6
A 2 : m; S . ˆ
: _:
H A M ' ! OF -@F
. H$6@^
ˆ `6D 6A
<6F 6.
f p A gU -! U OA
> ! X$31 U - 3:
) I; *-E*
6 S 1375
‹ S 56
.(
| C 6'
$%
)2 = 8 : A "- Q U ' 6Š8A [ "-6 M S 6!
s6%' , -@3O6 -: M
<6' I6p
v m+
: E5 -:
,-.
L )D
x O'
,#
W X8A O@A
> & ) S-14A i A
, E5
> ' H$3s L )D
_4`' O'
G-@ 9
> 4 H$' 6;
- 68A f 6@45 6!
m6+ :
)8 [ F A -$Fu A S
<F -@@F L )D
<' - C: O' XA 2
* $* 9' O
<$82
;
> 6!
X -C _ .
:
» : E5 2 ,-.
X€ `A [- -+
> ! 2 345
<835 M L )D S O'
| C (%* ' V3F
> !
> 4
> ! OF
<%*
<4
<'
> ! OF B D
<%*
-6 ' S
<5 .
<F V3F
> !
> 4
<' - C:
XA 2 * $* O X -C
6.
«
) H$`6D -6' 2 S
1375 S
”6]
55 - 54
.(
H [ "-
f j S
<8] D
<a:# M (%A 5 H$'
883;
, 5
<46.
7D H M
$%
<F (@1]
'
;
!
>
6$3F D M 6U ' , _O6@F S
`F * ' -@3 -
<^ !
? @A 4O$'
† U M
, F P D ($8F M S
>-6@3:
> 6!
P%& U
> !
$ [ Y4*
A -: ' .
> A
<F (AM0 G-2
>M '
> @CA ' 6* $*
/ -6
* .
> * M / • C + S _
"#
!
> !
<8] D ,# M
; S i j: ! / A -6
$; %
> ! XA 2 U
> M
<5 A [
%*
6A
> 46* -6@@F
`6F
H$' r$4* + 883;
…YD ,#
<' S
<a:#
f 8gA A 32 7 -@ . U
: 6E5 6*
4O6$' S
<5 [ F XA 2 U
<' ,#
[ 85 -@!
. 5 A
<6F
<6^
,# S 6U `6' [ 6F 6j
>M * s A
-@@F . H [ _:
; S
> !
<6' -@3 - vk6
6E5 X6$31
<62 3jA
>
M
vM
; ' !
> !
; \ A 32 _ !
<F f ^ ^
> ! $%A IF D
6* $* 6'
H$' X83;
P$%&
)8 A , F @' -: .
> ! 4U * (g8* - -5
> 3%4*
IE4A S A -: .
(Tony Evans, 1999, p.134) .
H ' @' S
;
> ! B D
<%*
f 4. + -: ' => @4' ' : E5
,-.
L )D 9$: O'
()' * * $*
,-6.
>-6@A 9' L 6)D
/kA 6% O6' H$6'
6883;
6* $*
5 6U
, _O@F H$' 883;
, _: S ,#
<F -@4`!
, -'
<5
<' [ _46* U 6_@!
- A 6' 6;
S 6!
/ s A
* $* U ' S
<8U -A \0ƒA -: $"
. H ' E:#
< J:
6A -$Fu
<6F -6@@F
i J:
X8A
<F -14A GM D
G R Y:
/ -
> ! 9' Ž [-A# 4 "
) 6+ EA S 1374 S
‹ 119
.(
<6:
[
<:
: ,#
<F
$3F D
;
> !
> 65 -@3 -
> 6! $%A L 6)D
[- : O'
<78' S $"
(8U -A , AM * X8A
<$82 E@ -14A P$%& => s2
, 7A 6* m+
. M
H 7 S J@A X82 M
2 i-
$) A IF
)$
, AM * X8A W)1 , A #
> ! X8A O@A
($Ak2 -14A : E5
L )D * $* S O' , F U '
H '
<8N`A O@ 9"
X632 , 6F
H
<@$AM
* . H H73A 4*
*
<$Ak2
> 6!
6;
> 6!
6+
‹ 6U
> ! OF , E5
i * L C`A S
<'
<)' * Š8j S e "
f '
<: "
) Patronizing
)8 (
6.
..
(Tomuschat PP.120-121&113)
. X66$81
> 66_
[M 66A IF 66D 665 , AM 66* 66'
X668A
, "
> ! L )D
> O' ,#
Ew1'
<F
<4$3F , $`6$3F 6!
/ 6] 6!
6A
<6' S 6$"
<: "
>
*
<F H$C. U H
H -'
A '
<F -: * z • (8N`6A L 6)D 96' S O6'
* KA U '
;
> ' s2 => !
, # O
* _ -7 ' S
)
<'
‹ 6U
O6
! OF '
*
<F /kA % / C* @A
(] 2 U H$'
883;
[ "-
> ! n 6%4A
-:
(
<:
>M `;
> ' O' `+ ;
> '
?$$s i-2 2 L )D * * , `:
6!
.
' M L )D @2
* $* O' 5 U
4$@A
~ 4OA ( 1
+ , O:
6A -6!
<F e@F ( 1 +
<' / Y8Q L )D M - -.
'
<6 j$: S 6$€M S -6: O
<6A ' S
. 3$
8 -D S
) minimal
' ( ) ineffectual
[ ' (
*
King,1999,P.335) .
( .
<^ "
W' gA (3!
v 9"
> ! 3*
; S 5 A
<$*
<' / ] [ 4`"
>
-2 S
X' B 32 L )D
<: 4* O' Ha^
):
q A
„$! ' A S-@F
<: "
Y; QA
>‚-5 C`:
<'
>r 4*
> ! A J:
<5 A U 3:
. .
> * M
> $`6' 67: S _ L 6)D M
> 6$@'
C`:
<' ] Q.
<F [ _ + /0
[-14A A : 4: "
) 6' F ( 6. M ' [-6.
6* S-6:
;
<' ! 3D J@A . M ' M
, "-.
$p [ 67:
) 6*
P.230 . Tomuschat
.(
H v _:
H - -. S k4U
‹ U
> ! 4OF
>-@3 -!
*
<F • , $; *
> 34A
> * M X$€ * B C:
[-.
A @% b . @$g`68 4O6F
> 6!
IE46A
<6' f 67 B 632
4`
<F
\ A 32 W • M /k3D ! / ] A
> * M $"
/0 G-14A 67 A#
CA * 2002
<' , @2
* $*
3*
<4 m+
[-. -$ u
*
) , 3!
4D (
; 67 A#
B C
* E : `F
<F
` %A [-.
] S-:
<F
> $_4*
H673A S-6. C:
E:#
B 3OA i -2
> !
) : :
extra-legal
)8 (
[ F
) 6*
New YorkTimes,2002 (
.
; D
<F B ]
<Y;KA
> ! L )D : 6E5 -6@ # O' ,-6.
> 6! j@!
6.M M -6 ' S
* $*
,-.
]
<' E:#
, @2 Š8j
$3F D
;
* $* ! 5 U
> $" 685 F
-6@
<78'
* $* ' H$'
883;
8U
; -. ' m" $ u ! .
, 3!
<F • [-6. -6$Fu I6 • S
H$' 883;
L )D p O'
> C! S U V$: Ar!
, 6E5 6* $*
63: 6'
<678' -6'
* @4A \ )$)1 H M A ! F M * '
[ 6' S U
$Dk6]
> 6!
6. : 6$3F D M
; ( * ! @$_@*
[-@7
(Forsythe, P.43) * .
G ' L )D H$' %' O' 883;
v 4`"
,#
* @. J@A M \ ] S Gr 6F
6* $*
/ - i J: 1A H$'
883;
HQ*
<4Y"
[-O:
<78' S
<6' Π61;
Y`68 U
[ _46*
> 6J:
' p
(Forsythe, P.31, Jaek Donnelly, 1982,P433-449),#
XAu A 9$:
W$ -
<4 "
H M c$D 2 :
<$82 - -E
@*
> !
> 7 ' p $p )8
[-.
,# '
> O + A
6.
.
@%
H X$81
<a:#
> * M
;
> ! , E5 i * 6)8 -6 -E 6A
3$! 6YA S 6.
6'
_@! ' g%A
<' vM
> ! 6' p 6*
<6F 6* $* 6 + / -6
> ! O6F 6' S
' p $p X$31
A . . H
;
<6' 6J: ! [ _46* U
6_@!
C!m6A S 2 6345 S S 6U
vM
> 66!
P6684QA
> s664A \ s66%' vM 66'
> 66!
66;
> 66!
66' p
)-66:
ntonio
Cassese,1994,P.14-16,51-54,61-63
.(
vM
> ! 6' p 2 6:
I5 6E 6)8 [ 6F ,# M
A -@* ! . H ' ˆ *
<5 ' S
<'
<
> !
> 5 H$6' 6883;
/ 6& 6J@A M \ ] 6U
<%*
; S
> !
<%*
<4 L )D - C:
[ _4* U ' S O' 6_@!
6' p ,#
<6' S , 6@2
XA 2 * $*
> '
<' O
;
> ! [ Y4* h * A _ -@!
) I; * 6
‹ S 56
.(
<6'
/ ]
”QOA
<4Y"
[-.
<F
» ; D
<F L )D ,# O'
<6: "
<6F H$6' @6*
6883;
Π1;
[- "
† [-.
<' S
„$!
<5 8F
`$:
<78' S 2 :
€
‹ U 6' p 7Y M
/ $s4)A 8F Gr f ^ ^ Q
_@! S :-3 S
@ ,#
* . H6 d 6:
‹ 6U M
L )D , E5 -@ # O' ; 3.
W• @A U P84QA
y 6. ' / 6Y4A \k6F
<6' 6j@A S
,-A#- -+
I`$; ‰A _@!
[-.
* .«
)
; ! "
S 1374
‹ S 153
.(
<'
$% S _ $C%
<: "
: 6"
! m6A
@6* S
> 6!
6_@!
> ! 4U 6*
6* $*
> ! OF P84QA
H$$% S P %
>-D V M i J:
”QOA Ij`6@A
L 6)D
<6F O6'
@* -: 4'
! mA S !
> ! 4U * * $*
_@!
‹ U
> ! OF P84QA
S $" '
H73A $p - . . $`'
[ 3:
* . H M (3! J@A W€ )D
/ $%
/ $D 6%35 S
2 345 4`' }@! S
‹ U
<'
< @A [-$* El -6! +
, 3s6A
‹ U
?' U
, AM
‹ QA
<' -@4`! U .
H (3! ' 4*
> ! 2
| ' A
<' , 6E5
; 3.
L )D i9D ' - ' O'
| $4D 6F 6U '
(Makau Mutua, 2002,P.1)
.
<6' 6$C%
, E5 S _ ; 3.
L )D
<6F S O' (6C@5 4O6$'
6* $*
> 64
<: 4* -: `6: 6 S
3:
~kA -:
> $%A
> ' j@*
e
>-@C +
;
<' ! L 6)D • 6 2 -6. ' O6'
. 6 M
> ! $%A H
@$@^
<: -C: 5 O@ 9"
David Gillies,1996,PP.272-277) *
( .
@CA H ' L )D
> O'
<F H
<5 A m_!
* , `: =, $' 2 6345
* "
<F ( 6$ U 6@2 ' ! 6U U
6‚$@A : `6:
<6$7 -6$
H4O U e U
* ...
H L )D
>9$^
B A# M $p g1@A
<F / QOA M ,-63
f 6p
* ) i 6j; -@: A _4Q$`6"
v96$A# S `6@5
> M# S
•@6j3! O61 S m6" M 6 "
( S
63:
-66. ' . H6 -66.
6647A
> ! 4U 66* S 2 66345
[ 66F -6 -E
> M#
<66' tg66*
i j;
<4Q$`"
BŠ9@
[
* .
> * M
<' _ H .M -$Fu )4:
- @
‹ U [
[-6.
<F L )D y' O' @
<'
‚ 0 4D
, -$A -U 7: * @. : -U [
6*
. M
H e. + 3%4* S I`$: A
[-A#
>- -E m; S
<$82
! * $*
2 345 S
?A 5
Ak*
<' A 3.
- #
)
; ! "
‹ S 2
.(
H L )D S 4*
8% O' ' p S
, `F * 8_:# S
1$`A )8
[- "
<4Y"
[-.
<F
;
> ! , E5 i * ' p $p 3:
<6' -@:
B 6]
/ $€95 ,#
-@. ' -E%4A .
H$$C H d & A [ _: ' S
<' f p 7832
<F : AM M
/ C2 ' $*# M r:
<: 3 U 9$A# $)1
"
M - -E
"
: AM , 4* ‰! $* M V6; 3A
' p
…Y; ' [ $* 9$A# $)1 _:M
i : A
<' S-: ' H
<47:
. [ [-6.
<6F H6 6'
$%6&
S
f p , @F ik* ' ' ( S
E' OA e$+
H$38`A <4 "
`6 " $@'
%A A -@F . ,#
<F -D
> - !
> ' S , -' S A
„$!
<: "
W$)1 O6! r+
S
<' I5 E T$8C
<$82 ik*
38`A , : / 6CA 6A
6.
. H6 / 6T$8C l 6Y;
> 6!
e. +
> CU 2 CgA H ' l :
? ik* S
<' , @2 5 6U @2
> 63%A W68gA
X' $p X31 %A A . .
> 4
<F y*
<: *
> 6!
6! "
/ 62 CgA 67 A
/ jY:
A 3!kF– E.
/ j 9F : 6E5
~ 6 $:
6$@$2
> 4O6$'
) 6
M. Mehdi
Semati,1997,PP.30-33
jY: + (
11
~ $: CA 4‰*
<'
†
-$* U
.
>-6@ #
<F c$D M
< J:
>M + I!
) [-.
( J: m_! M
"
}6@5 E:-63
"
X631A
> 6J:
>
[ F -$+
* .
)
* X€ A , 4_@$4: ! S 1375
”] S 117 - 45
.(
X' ) [-. j e@6F
6!
96$:
+
<4.
H '
<47:
A ]
<F . * ' 7D ! H M
$%
<F
<6:
6E@
> ! OF , E5
i *
<78' S f p U S
» ' p
7 U !
H 4" 9' M , s :
6)D L
O' -@4`!
. L ^ -QA A -$; E:#
i 71A A
I! A b-@@F i 71A
A I$@F .
; Ž 9' E:# U H 6
/0# 96' " 6*
}6@5 -6QA A
...
-@4`6!
. / M 6jA 6 #
H$' 883;
W • M
> ! E:
H$' 883;
<' i-2 • U 2
L )D 86] S 6* 6$"
6 # o
;
> ! ' p A
,
<' -@C + L )D )8 O' o F
«
) I; * -E*
‹ S 2
.( 1
H
$!
<F ˆ * ' ,#
X' ) S
> ! A H$6' L 6)D f 6p O6' L 6.
S 65
> 5 7 L )D
”4QA O' , `:
' p A
<F -:
f p ,#
vM
; p IF D '
> O' 4 )8
[ F
> ' , E5 i * X8A 1 I4*
„$6! S
<6: "
6)D X6€
`6$:
.
[ " ! H [ ' C`:
<' , E5 i * HQ*
A n p 5 S- "
-!
6* $*
\kA 6F
ˆ 38A
* .
> A
<F
<' j@A '
> 342 8A
> ! , E5 i * [-.
* . 82 Ip 6
/ )A
<$Ak2 O4:
> ! L
•+
.m" M B *
> !
> 34A [-6 7A S E:# M
[-6.
<F f p
<' (: E' (2 . B ]
$A # ,-3
<' S i .
H #
B 32
> ! O6F 6) #
S
1 . H
| C A ,
<' : @Q*
3:
G-@
I€
;
>9; A , AM * X8A
<F 29 CA : 1993 (4$3F i * S-.
[ . F :
» , @$3• - ' A I$@F -$+
<F vk
> ' A 3D ) L )D M
<: g$' S O' O@ 9" $p
6*
.
<: Y6*u4A
: @Q*
> !
| ' A
<' L )D J: O' i X8A
<' S-14A [-@ 9 1:
>
* $*
[-.
35 E S
* -@
.
> 5 P*u
*
<F U '
; M
> ! ' p /m;
A
<F -: ' s%'
; M
> ! , E5 i * i :
<' -: C' , @2 q : L )D E:# O'
O_:
-@@F 3:
. ; D
<F , . U
”):
$`' /-A M @! -:
> M 3:
<F m"
H$3!
;
<' ! , @2
" 3%4*
H -' X7.
[ E' 3w4*
OF , `: M [ 4`" %' ! i jA S
<' f `D A -:-A#
. H v
<F e$+
<4 "
[-.
S
W • \ 38`A
> 73!
H$' 883;
(@$AM L )D
$: O'
` ...
«
<' X):
M : S + EA F R0Z
‹ S 120 .
$*#
> 7 A H$ 0 / CA [- M
* .
> ! OF Ak*
I6! M 6@!
> _ 6p 6A
, " 3%4*
<3! -@4`!
[M
<'
<: E'
> ! P84QA
< A * S
> A UR !
> 6@%A , 6:#
> * M
> ! OF Ž 9'
' p
<'
† A ; D S
<6F H6 6@F I46*
615 S
f p
, * M
> - • %.
L )D M
* 9$: O' 3: '
H6
<6' \ 6)$
,#
682
*
<F f p )D L
‹ QA O'
<'
A U
-:
. i EYA L 6)D f 6p M 6A O6'
(C@5
>
<'
<4 " U
*
) W)1A S A 1374 S
”]
209 - 208
.(
I6! H$6^ [-6@ 3: 4* H
<' A 32 ?3jA i * <4$3F 29
CA : 1993
<6F ' ' H ' :
» ; 6D
<6F
<6:
?
<: @$'
<:
832
*
<F B-A ! -: 4*
> ! L )D
> O' (: 3: OF -@^
X6A F
<6'
I4`$* - # 3.
.M * $*
V
<' OF -@^
, @2 (: 3:
iM0 : E5 => 50
<6'
X$31 ! OF _
"
«
) M X): <'
‹ S + EA 124
.(
e$+
> 9" ' M H$A
Y@F
•:
: E5 L )D H O'
> ! OF S $6*#
-6@8
> 9" ' ' `85
P84QA %' S L )D
* ' A O' [
[ "-
> 6!
6U
n '
; U
> ! OF 4%@]
8U A
; *
[ Y46* 6' 6!
(6' D M L 6)D
H S O'
<: "
ik2
<F -@4.
L )D ˆ 6* ' -6 ' O'
> 6! $%A 6_@!
6@ S 4@6*
?A 5 X8A P % .
) I$! ' SŠX 1374
‹ S 10
.(
H
| C d & A S
•: Y@F : E5
L )D
H O'
z •
> * M - "
6U '
<F - " -$Fu ! OF [ _4* U - '
_@!
6@
L 6)D
<65 6' O6'
<6' : " 6: "
, E_@!
* ' A
$"
. (5 U M
>9: -:
H
‹ 6U
•: 6Y@F
. El '9A
:
» ...
A J4:
<F
~
>
<' OA
(aQ M
e -$+
/ $' j
?6A 5
' p X7.
> $"
@*
vM !
> ! _@!
2 345 H
<46. 5 ! OF -6. '
.
: E5
<F (g8*
>
P$%& '
<8U -A
; A
V6 M 6@! 6!
6$%
~ 6:
*
„$! S ! " OF e): U - C:
&
/u$! S
<Y 6@A 65 Au6A 6
> ! OF ' '
-! _
...
wF
> ! OF B D
<%*
i EYA M : 6E5 L 6)D O6'
66 3D 66A 66; -66@@F X66' )A
> 66! $%A X66$31
[-66.
66A )A 66F -66@! U
«
(U.N.Doc.A/CONF.157/24,1993)
.
;
> E35 Ak*
, H3& 9$:
' p 6)8 , 6F
v _:
L )D : E5 O'
•: Y@F S H
<' QA Y;
,# '
* U ' .
•$€
/u$!
"-@ 3:
, H
‹ U
. El
:
» ' p A ! e): -@! U &
, 4* S /u$!
<Y 6@A
(@$AM L )D -@@F Y O' H$2
B D e):
<' 9$: m_: : [-E2
<46.
-@6. '
P % , : I!
$4U ; -. ' E:#
H$@^
4$%&
> ' , E5 i * X' B 6C
`6$:
...
k4U G Y4* S A * $*
L )D M
* O' .
I -6)4%A A
<6F L 6)D tg6* -6 ' O6'
H$' 883;
: `F . 5
<F q : L )D (%A 5 S-@4`! O' : E5
%A -: . . 6A
H ' -:
ˆ * ' -
~kA y' & ! L )D
<6: S-. ' O' ˆ 6* '
/ 6JDkA 6* $*
y' H$' 883;
;
<F !
?
; -@^
A D U L )D
)8 O' , O J:
X$31 -@@F .
? , . U I$3
<F -: $_' ˆ * '
/ JDkA 6* $*
, 6. U i -6F S
; q : L )D
* O' .
]
<F
* $*
> ! 4 3D H
6;
<6' 6!
/ 6]
>-5
<' q):
L )D V3F O' A
-@F ...
H ' A 8gA
I ]
<F : 6CA P6 % -6 '
. ...
<7@
E.
<F . j - ' G Y4*
* $*
L )D M
<' O' -D
X -: * '
«
) , 3!
(.
>-
`$:
<F [M A L )D G 4`" S O' y'
H$' X683;
[ 6_ 5
>
‹ 6U
<6'
‹ 4U U
[
* ; D b
<F
<4.m"
(] 2 S
$Dk]
8U
; -1A !
[ '
* .
‚$%& ‚A : @F
:
<65 -6$F 6' 96$
<6'
> !-6:
6* $*
6_@!
L
<' %.0
<' wA
> ! ‚$T4A H$' - ' \ )$)1 S m" $ A
z • v m6+
G-6 L 6)D
G 4`" O' y'
H$' X83;
(; )A S B 32
> 5 ,#
X€ 9 3 I .
<6F 6^ S (6] 2
H$' 883;
2 S (]
>M ' y'
: _ M '
*
<F V ! i )A B 32
[ 6E' R Y:
> 6'
>-@3: M 4O$'
> ! P%& U
> ! -@4`! C . H M [ Y4* • $% S m_!
L )D M
<' O' , @2
<8$*
>
E5 W)1 -!
* $*
i J: S Cg
XC , + M 5 }6@
6*
$@$2
<4 H
<F - 4D , AM *
> ! H$' 883;
? -6A L 6)D f 6 M ' O6' 6* $*
H$'
; = 883;
> ! Ž 9' -@4`!
David Forsythe,2006,PP.51-52)
.(
<:
, 34Y"
> ! Y`8 : : L )D 4`' S O'
>
* @A [ F -$+
* [M A 9$:
$' m5 + B C
<' (; )A L )D tg* O' H$'
883;
H$@a3!
/0 61
> 6j@!
> 4U *
<F H
<@$AM
— D [-.
I8`6A -6 S H6
6*
<6F G-62 => 46*
>M 6' S
, ' -@A 9' G-2
L )D : E5 O'
<5 A (3!
;
; \ ] U S !
> ! Ž 96'
(4 O$+
4%@]
* . V \ )$)1 m;
4 & : 8F
, E5 * * B C
> 65 $`Y
L 66)D
<66' O66' v
66' p
Donnelly,PP,433-449;see: Tim Dunne,1999) 665 .(
4 & :
<F U '
? A • ):
<' $: M X' )
]
?& A ' 4@6*
"M 6* :
: E5 -@ # ' ,-.
L )D : E5 O' A j@A 9$:
. . H [-6. El 4*
<6F
» H6
[ _4* U
> !
> J:
sE:
L )D , -6' S O' 6' p -6
6*
...
, 6E5 i 6*
<6' 61:
>
$_3O^
<:
>-@3: : L )D
F . O' [-:M *
<4.
<:
<' F H4`' ,#
-6@^ 6! b
<F L )D (3! O' }@!
> ! , E5 )' * ] ...
[‚A H E@
[ _4* U
> 6!
Q 6
*
<F
> $`' 8A M
, "
_@!
,# '
<4.
sE:
L )D
<6' O' , 6@2
V6
: E5 $%A : E5 j@!
m‰:
-:
.
H '
ˆ *
<' M j S L )D
X6* 6' O'
<6' i-62
$2 OA s%'
vM M
> ! ,#
, E5 i 6*
<6$5 6A 6.
...
«
) A 6* A F 67 S
1366 S
‹ 44
.(
?g
$% M J:
> m_4* $*
<: " 9'
<;
<$82 L 6)D : C$4O6+ \ 6)$)1 S O6' 6!
>
[ 4`"
L )D M
> * M O'
> 9" F ! E:
> 6!
64; 6
> 6A S 6;
6!
H$' -: = 8$Y•
883;
L )D
A O'
-!
. %$C•
*
<F
<' " * X'
v m+
`6$:
<F L )D -@ # : E5 O'
<: -@A 9' \ ] X$81
[ F
„$!
<: "
X31A 68)2 4`6'
)g@A
> ' ,#
X€
I O:
.
> 9' -%“' \ ] "
,# S I6!
> 6' \ 6]
6;
> 6!
Ž 96'
$2 & A
<: _^ S
*
<F H X 3
;
> ! , E5 i *
. 5
<F
<5 '
<' i-2 : , AM *
> !
<)g@A
>
, E5 i * S , 1'
> 6!
H$6' 6883;
H M 6A 6J@A M
L )D
> O' , a3! S , 4`: T
> ! E: S H$'
883;
A
` '
; U 4O$'
<4.
6 # o-@. '
H X 3 H - KA
‚$%
`$:
<F
$!
L )D ' M S O' ej@*
,#
-6 C: \ A 9;
U ' 7832
;
!
`5 E -' o . 5
6*
<6F
~ I6E L 6)D O6'
i EYA
> j@!
<4C; m" $ u
> ! F M * M U ' 5
>
(7C6.
• 6C
H$' 883;
<)g@A S
>
8U : AM S
* 4A
<F
»
$; N`6A
~ 4O6A
« B 6C S _ -67
,#
I!
GM D 2 & A
L )D
vM O'
> !
> j@!
| ' A
<' ,#
<4 m+
) .
Peter
Frankental,2000,PP,22-23
.(
H M 8A 67 $* S J@A (4`6 '
L 6)D
<6' S O6' [ 6"
> 6!
$*#
H$Au m+
>-@AM $:
> ! ,#
, 3@!
A . . ;
<O6$3! 6 # e@6F
/ A -6 6!
;
!
>
(%A 5 s2 H$'
883;
B C [- -+
> ! %$C•
%$C• $p
<‚ ‚`6; ' 6*
6 # o
X' \ * * e$+
@$'
*
<F
<^
?& A [ "-
!
`D o- 9" -@! U ' A
E -'
*
;
<F ! W' gA t; A
? @A X32 U 6A
> EO6 " M S-6@@F 6)D
L
/0 1 \ ] U O'
> j@!
> 4U * ,#
[ E'
> A b ' -@! U
<F 6U ' 6A
f 8gA -@ . U
> A
<' -@ . U : A J:
<6a:# 6A b- # I8`6A
6*
/ 6C2 M
B 1
> m" $ u L )D
GM 6D \ ] 6U S O6' X€ `6A
/ 2 6& A i 62
> 6$"
, 66a3!
66. -E' S 66)
$66*# O66 S I€ 665 m66+
, AM 66*
<664 M-66 S
)...
Mary
Robinson,2005,P.25
y' 9$: (
;
A 7D '
i 6A '
<6' S
<6' wA ! _46* U
>
G
; ,# S ! I!
U '
;
> !
‹ U
*
<78' b [ 4`"
>
<' (@E+
<3!
, 6E5
(3!
}@!
A ' ! y' b $"
, `:
, AM ! t8]
}@5 IJ:
W`:
6A -O6Q'
71A
<€
A
<F -@F (3!
; XA . ! A
. .
<' i EYA S _ $C%
L )D O' )
<:
(3!
W A
,#
(
P] M
H$' 883;
B C : 6E5
[ E' -@A [-.
f ^ ^
> ! 7! ! F M * H$'
883;
> ! E: m_! M H$'
6883;
4;
4; $p +
<64 "
6A 6.
.
> 6* M
<6F 6j:# M S 6_
, _ M 6' 86]
(6%A 5
H$' 883;
<' B C:
? @A * $*
‹ U G-2 S-@4`! U
>M ' f j A
<F -@F M
<6a:# !
XA 2 / / - )8 A [ Y4* S . L )D b-@@F
H M 9$: O' [-62
@w4`6A
`6$:
.
<78' (] 2 '
/ - • * $*
> 9' S )g@A
> A k)2
* .
`6: -6 ' A
<F L )D
>-@A 9' J@A M \ ] O' [ Y4* h *
X$81 - C:
<6F 6^ S . V6 M
6*
B 1
> j@!
> 4U * L )D
G => S O'
; 6E5 !
> 6$"
[-6.
6A 6.
<: _@ \ * * , $@'
<4 "
<O$3! * _ M H
[ Y4* h * ' -:
[ 3!
[ 6C:
<678' S
> A 4D -@^
<$82 [ Y4* h * , "-@@F
)D M L H$s6 : O' ,#
6; S
<67@
<6835 M
B 1 -@3 - 3D
[ Y46* 96$: S-@. ' E:#
[ 6E'
> 6' [-6.
6*
.
\ 38`6A
@4 m+
<F ' -! Q:
<' \ ] X$;
B 34D [ Y4* h * i j:
H X32 8$;
I$: -6'
<6F
?: A B 32 L )D O' tg*
H$' 883;
6)8 6.
. f ^ 6^
<6a:#
L 6)D 6' l 6:
: `:
{ S
>-@' -$ ! M A S-. '
, H '
<6F 6' 6' [ Y46* h * \ 6* *
6@% S
G9$_:
n 42 h *
<'
;
> ! q : L )D ' \ )g@A S O' A @%A
-6 3:
.
<678'
<6a:#
I6EA
* B 3.
B 1
> j@!
L )D
A O'
H ' @' $"
<65 6A n 642
(%A 5 D#
H$' 883;
>9$^ S Y: 95 X32 t$C) gU kU
`6$:
6@% b e@6F
<6$82
Y8Q
<F , -5 A 32
<.-U A
-@F
1.
$!
L )D
‚$8F S O'
<g): S U
!
>
$*#
U '
;
<4U 6* M ! 6A S
(3!
; A 7D ! XA . !
6A
„$6! 6.
64;
,# M
$: 6A -6:
. I6J:
)D
? * -: M 4A S- -5 f 4. +
: E5 ,-6.
v 4`6"
/ 6• C
<6
> 6!
H$' 883;
<] 2 S
> !
<)g@A
>
: E5 : " " S X6'
<6JDkA
>
<64 m+
-6:
. 6"
1 . H
| C A ,
<' v 9"
, AM * [- , ' L )D v 9" S O' B *
2004 [ .
<F F
> @4' '
> ! $%A ' L )D
i - S O' X$€ * H$AM *
> ! ; T.
H$g`8 )
<: F
> 4U ' : [9p (
<'
<: E' }@5
<$82 I`
<' [-$O6F -6):
* . , .
~ .
<' .Kenneth Roth, (2004):
/ A - : : /0
G-14A
•+ 7 A#
M 11
<' CA 4‰*
[-$OF -):
[-.
. M '
> 6!
<: 6* U P6$
> 6!
> * L 4*
?3*
> !
<: $YQA ' . M 4D S A : 4: " !
<5 '
<' / $4U , AM }@5
•$€
B 6* M S E35
[ ' .Alison Parker, (2004)-.
<4.m"
> !-@
6)D 61 S d %O6;
> !-6:
6* $*
6_@! 6 H$6'
; -6;
6
A [M A S-@4 "
>-@A j@! M ' El [ F -$+
<F -:
> !-:
* $*
6_@! S 64D
> 4 A J:
1 d %O;
A U
-@!
.
3J:
)D
<F
<' \ ] L )D -2
[- _: 1@A O'
<78' S H IEA (A J@A
/ -E%
H $@' H$' 883;
A
<F -!
[ $.
> ! 6 5
‹ 6U 68• 6U 6A
-6@F .
<^ "
> 5 L )D -2
> A O'
$Dk6]
68U 6;
6A 6 6!
6A S-6!
> ! F M * J:
H$' 883;
D • 6A
<6F -6@F W6
Erga Omnes P6]
/ -6E%
/ ] S '9A B -2
[- : H4. _:
P8Q S
<' (%A 5 H$' 6883;
6g%A
<4U 6*
> ! E:
H$' 883;
> ' P8Q4A ' U '
>R S
?Y:
8 ) A
.(Ian Brownlie,1998,P.71)-@F
> A
<F / ] W)1
/ $s4)A J@A M SM D t8]
$@A
> O' i984`A S /-2 `6A
(8U -A
<: 4* -2 :
*
<F
`D
A A
,
<64C; S f ^ 6^
i 6J:
6$@A 6%35
X68A O@A [ 6E' 96$: M M S-614A
.(Nicholas J. Wheeler, 1996,pp.140-141, 148-163) 6'
, 9 H ' i EYA S
$Dk]
8U Bk)4*
X32 d : M W8gA IJ:
)D
<6F -6 -5
<4.m"
X31A : :
> E4A 7D
> -C4*
/ & 42 ' '
$A 71A
> ! H$' 6883;
<F j:# S '
<' B ] L )D -2
| ' A O' A
V .
> j@E' : Q
)8 [-.
<: " ! -
‚$3!
)D
* .
H v _:
{ S
$% M
<4 " ' / - ] @2 M
i J:
H$' X83;
L 6)D =ˆ 6* S
H $@' H$' => ! F M * O' 883;
J:
,#
<5 A S (6%A 5 -$Fu
: 6E5 6*
k4U B 3. -D S J:
,#
* . 2 & A
<6F f ^ 6^
6$3F D / -6
y6'
H 7 -@ # ! $:
i J:
H$' L )D = 883;
,# S O' I!
<65 6'
<6' W' 6*
6g%A
<6'
> E4;
X' S-@3 -
~
* .
> "M [ ' 9$:
6*
<6F 6" ' q$6%C S 3w46* S
V; 3A * 3%4*
8U A S
<' 1@A
$Dk]
8A )8 A -: F . 4$%6&
<6F
[M A
<:
)8 M jA E@
3:
<78' . (%A 5
H$6' 6883;
H6 d 6:
B 632 6 kU $p
: `: $p )8
$; N`A Y; QA
' )A
<8 H$8A 2 ' ,#
[-E2 9$:
* . H6 46*
A , L )D i A E4$8 A '
<5 A
<6F 6
<6' 6_
> 6!M A 6$ T5
<F j:# M S-@4`$: 1A L )D
<; )A S O'
>
> ' $"
<3!
iM0
* 50 / A - S
4`
' ;
<
G9$_:
<8' )A ' ' 4; -2 e@F
<' q):
L 6)D
<6' S O6' X6$;
6$! A
: OU 2 9$A#
> #
<F , $: ' ,#
' \ A 32 [ @"
q : = A - U S-@4`!
L )D
H $@'
* O' .
H ' @' f 4. + -:
L )D ' l : O$+ S O'
6!
X6] D [-6.
<6F
<6' (68D A
<%*
x [-$*
* . , `6:
> 6!M $:
f ^ 6^
> 6! $%A 4 6! -6 -5
<)82
> ! 8A
<' S
> E
<C: 5-@^
, 3@!
[-.
* . _Q* +
$ Y.
/ A -
> E4$Dk]
;
>R WD
>R , ' $4U i A
A A 7D
6A -$Fu A
6$"
<F j:#
B 32
$3F D [ Y4*
<$; 2 -4 M
"- '
> '
"
6 4,A
<6:
"
6E:# 6'
"
-. ' .
> A
<F (; )A
$2 OA
; z gA A
-@F . H6 [ "-6 6; S
M 6U '
‚$3F D ( + ' )D
<F
<' i A A
$@A -!
63J:
<6F
> 6' 6A 6 ' 6E:#
S-6@F
' M A
"
. @%
X -%
X$8) GM D X32
B 3. -D
$Dk]
;
<F i984`A
_Q* + H$Au
* U M $:
/ `$*u ! E:
%A G-@ 3:
(%A 5 :-A : E5
<@$AM
> ! / Y4A .
, N P84QA
* . H6 6E5 , -: E6. S
?6A 5 P684QA X6˜C• M
! "#
ˆ `D !
~ 4OA
<8] D : E5 M ,-.
/ • C v 4`6"
/ 62k•
<6' S
> 65
<7@
f ^ ^
> ! $%A 4@*
X32 tg6* S-@@F : 6E5
i -6 6A (63! M S-6@ 3:
> ! F M * 8A
H$' 883;
E5 W)1
y . $s4)A
[ E' 6A
<6F -6@ 5 (6AM0
/ • C
> @%A [r6 => A
>
6*
<6F
>
i 6J: 4U 6*
6;
> 6!
M 6U '
$3F D
<' ( @A [-$* El
* .
! B ] L )D => ! j@!
: E5 O' )D ' l : S
L * * H $@'
*
<F
<6835 M
L )D R )8 [-.
A F ' => @4' '
$w$D , `:
6€95 S L 6)D M
X6' $p 86*
X' )A
;
<%A 5 )8 [-.
; C`: !
<' 2 i 4D
<' L )D S '9A
i98A P87A )8 [-.
-:
. , E5 ; 3.
>
<F H M
<6& 2 m_!
6A
> 61: $p 6.
* ,#
A 3 S }@!
* @. A ! A
<' -: $"
H
| 6.
<6F 6!
V6 ,# M
X€ S U S E_@!
<'
> ' ' ,u.
A 3 , `:
-. ' ! .
$! A / -E%
H$' 883;
. : B ] M L )D -2
<F O' P6] M
i 62 B 3O6;
> A U '
U '
W A M
,#
<' i )A [ 6A# -2
) Jus Cogens
[-$6* (
S-6:
/ ] q):
P8Q i-@4`A / A -
X' )4A (4` ' H$' 883;
)8 A H A S-: .
<6' A
<8U -A -$€u => @%A
> * M
;
> !
> 4* -@3 -
> !-:
* $*
_@!
IF D
y' '
H$' 883;
`$:
. d & A e@F
<' / Y8Q L )D -2 M
<; )A S O'
>
`$:
<F
”$QO
> 5 ,#
<'
; [-. m" !
<78' S-. ' '
g%A El
<' H 6* 6A
<F , 7A
> ! 4`' s4)A
> '
> ! E:
H$' 883;
E5 3D
, $: ' M I! 6
-6 #
![$,6 M@EU-32G6R+/.l@-$:3(/<# E"89# f K)D6S@-3( O $D,R;+I$;e ;.(-])T amp amp;'(!1,2& amp;9$:2;< = 3$>?@A'( B13C5%D$E2 F ;%,$3G;H;I-&' 3$>?@A'(( J .$% 2& K&'!L'MN7 OP<' I &;, = $Q8+IR3'2&Q3&' S!< F 9$T,'()&!I 1A'( UV?WW''2 ";H;I -X%YR%W'( V3V>87)&!I(.'!U2$ZF.'2( J %Y]()