Nguyen Minh Nguyet va Dtg Tgp chi KHOA HQC & CQNG NGHE 1 3 6 ( 0 6 ) : 6 3 H 6 7
THV*C T R ^ G G I A N G DAY VA LlTOfNG GIA TH^TC H A N H T . ^ P H 6 N G T H ^ r C T A P CUA T R U d N G DAI H Q C Y DU'OC T H A I NGUVflN N A M 2014
Nguyin Minh Nguyft, Bui Thi Quynh Nhung vd cong sy Tru&ng Dgi hoc YDuge — DH Thdi Nguyen T 6 M TAT
Qua hon mft nam thyc hifn doi mdi ttong cdng tdc gidng day vd lugng gia cac bgc phan thyc tap d tat ca cdc bg mon trong toan trudng. De danh gid nhihig ket qua da dgt dugc, nhiing van de bat cap vd de xuat bidn phap ndng cao chdt lugng gidng day va lugng gia thyc hanh tai cac bo mon, de tdi nghien ciru: "Thyc trang gidng dgy vd lugng gid thuc hanh tai phong thuc tdp cua ttudng Dai bgc Y Dugc DHTN nam 20I4" dugc Ihyc hifn tai 12 bo mon diupc 4 khoa Khoa hge co bdn. Yea sd, Y te cdng cfng, Dugc. Ket qud nghien ciiu trdn 1483 phieu ty dien ciia sinh vien cho thay 4 quy dinh vd giang dgy va lugng gia thyc hdnh theo kdt lugn sd 849/KL-YD ngdy 24/12/2012 cua Hifu trudng Trudng Dgi bgc Y Dugc - DHTN tai hgi nghi nit kinh nghifm vd gidng day va lugng gid thyc tap nam bgc 2013 - 2014 tai 12 bf mon nhu sau:
- Nfi dung giang day: Khoa khoa bgc co ban dugc sinh vien danh gia cao nhdt (2/3 bg mdn loai tdt).
-To chiic gidng dgy: Khoa khoa hoc co b ^ dugc sinh vien danh gia cao nhat (2/3 bf mon logi tdt).
-Td chiic lugng gia: 02 khoa dugc sinh vien danh gid ydu (Y bgc co sd, Y te cong cfng).
- Dieu kifn ddm bdo chat lugng giang dgy: 04 khoa dugc sinh vien danh gia kha.
Tir khod: Lugng gid thuc hdnh DAT VAN DE
Qua hai nam thyc hien ddi mdi frong cdng tdc gidng dgy vd lugng gid cde bgc phdn thue t^p d tat cd cac bg mdn frong todn trudng. Theo Kdt ludn sd 849/KL-YD ngay 24/12/2012 cug Hifu trudng Trudng Dgi hge Y Dugc - DHTN tai hgi nglu rut kinh nghifm ve gidng dgy vd lugng gia thye tap nam hge 2013 - 2014, frong dd quy dinb vd ngi dung gidng dgy, td chiic gidng day, td ehde lugng gia va cac didu kifn ddm bdo chdt lugng giang day thue tgp. Dd ddnh gid nhiing kdt qud da dgt dugc, nhung van de bdt cap vd dd xuat bifn phdp nang cao chdt lugng giang dgy va lugng gia thyc hdnh tgi ede phdng thye tap cua cdc bg mdn ehiing tdi tien hdnh dd tdi: "Thue trgng giang dgy va lugng gid thye hanh tgi phdng thyc tap cua trudng Dgi hge Y Dugc - DHTN nam 2014" nhdm:
/. Md td thuc trgng gidng dgy vd lupng gid thuc hdnh tgi phong thifc tgp cua cdc bp mdn Truang Dgi hpc Y Duprc - DHTN.
2. Bdnh gid viec thvc hiin gidng dgy vd lugng gid thuc tgp theo Ket lugn so 849/KL-
YD cUa Hiiu trudng Trudng Dgi hpc Y Duac
— Dgi hpc Thdi Nguyen.
Tu dd gdp phdn nang cao tinh thdn frach nhiem cua gidng vidn, giiip giang vidn didu chinh hogt ddng gidng day, xay dyng ddi ngii gidng vidn cd phdm chdt dgo diic, ed trinh dg chuyen mdn cao, phong each gidng day tidn tidn gdp pbdn nang cao ehdt lugng gid gidng.
dap iing nhu cdu hge t ^ cua sinh vidn.
MUC TIEU D E T A I
/. Mo td thifc trgng gidng dgy vd lupng gid thuc hdnh tgi phong thtec tap cua cdc bp mon Trutmg Dgi hpc Y Duac - DHTN.
2. Ddnh gid vipc thuc hipn gidng dgy vd lupng gid thtec tgp theo Kit lugn so 849/KL- YD ciia Hiiu truong Trudng Dgi hpc Y Duac
— Dgi hpc Thdi Nguyin.
DOI n r O N G V A PHUONG P H A P NGHIEN cbu
Doi tugrng n^iien cini:
Gidng vidn vd ky thuat vidn giang dgy hge phdn thyc tgp tai cac bg mdn Trudng Dai hge Y Ehigc Thai Nguydn frong nam 2014, 2015.
Tidu chuSn ch9n (khi tugng nghidn c ^ : Chgn ehu dieh cac can bg tham gia gidng dgy thyc hanh cho ddi tugng smh vidn dgi hge hf 63
Nguyin Minh Nguy?t vd Dig Tgp chi KHOA HOC & CONG NGHE 136 (06): 63-67 ehinh qui nam 2014, 2015 tgi cac phdng thuc
tap ciia cdc bg mdn thugc khoa: khoa bgc ca bdn, Y hge ea sd, Duge va Y td cdng cgng trudng Dai hge Y Dugc Thai Nguyen.
Dja diem nghien cmi: Trudng Dgi hge Y Dugc - Dai hge Thai Nguydn.
Phutrag phap nghien cihi:
Nghidn ciiu md ta.
Chi tidu nghidn c ^ : - Ndi dung gidng day - Td ebiic giang dgy - Td chde lugng gia
- Didu kidn dam bdo ehdt lugng gidng dgy Ky thuat thu thap so Iifu
KET QUA NGHIEN CCfU
Bdng \. Kit qtid phdn hoi vei
Sinh vidn trd ldi phidu (tiieo man) Mdi cdu hdi pbdn hdi dugc ddnh gid theo thang didm 4 (I la diem thap nhat; 4 Id diem eao nhat).
Muc dg danh gia nhu sau:
Tdt > 3,5 didm; Khd 3,0 - 3,5 didm;
Trung binh 2,5 - 2,99 diem; Ydu < 2,5 didm.
Thdi didm phat phidu: Sau khi ket thiie bgc phdn thyc hdnh, tgi cdc budi sinh hogt ldp, tidn hanh phat phidu tu didn eho 100% sinh vidn frong ldp, hudng ddn eho sinh vidn edeh dien phidu va thu phidu lai ngay.
Phuong phdp xu* ly s6 lidu: Nhgp vd xir Iy sd lifu bdng pban mdm SPSS 18.0.
Khoa
KHCB
YCS
YTCC
Dugc
B$ mdn Hoa bgc Sinh hpc Vat ly - Ly sinh
Ky sinh triing H6asinh
Visinh DDATTP
Dichte Siic khoe MT
D u g c l y Hoa dirge Thgc vat dugc
Bang n 140 132 136 114 119 106 115 123 113 112 l U 101
Muc tieu phu hgp v<H n$i dung biii giiing(X'± SD)
3,77 ± 0 , 4 5 3,83 ± 0,41 3,57 ± 0,70 3 , 3 4 * 0 , 7 5 3,46 ± 0 , 6 0 3,69 ± 0 , 5 5 3,34± 0,75 3,48± 0,70 3,57 ± 0 , 5 9 3,29 ± 0 , 6 9 3,45 ± 0,69 3,50 ± 0 , 6 1
Mvc tieu cua HPTH dugc d i p irng sau lihi KTHP (X f ^ D )
2. K£t (jtid phdn hoive td ehue gidng day thue hdnh 3,56 ± 0 , 5 5 3,60 ± 0 , 5 5 3,40 ± 0 , 6 9 3,16 ± 0,69 3,13 ± 0,68 3,33 ± 0,55 3,52 ± 0,55 3,23 ± 0,69 3,42 ± 0,67 3,23 ± 0,69 3,50 ± 0 , 6 4 3,49 ± 0 , 6 1
BM cung cap bang Idem tu Bg mon bgc cho SV (X±SD)
GV±KTV GV+KTV thao tic giim sit man chu4n dinh gii tot
ti mi cic HB bgc tip ciia SV
BMco nhan xet phin bdi sau buoi tbg-c binb
BMthgc bifn gift*
f b ^ binh dung quy
djnh Hoa hge
Sinh hge VL-LS
3,79 ±0,62 3,83 ±0,41 3,57 ±0,70
3,32± 0,62 3,55± 0,69 3,60± 0,73
3,26 ± 0,73 3,37 ± 0,73 3,63 ± 0,59
3,4ft±0,81 3,61±0,73 2,97±0,59
3,40±0,46 3,76±0,53 3,81±0,47 KST 2,96 ±1,07
H6asmh 3,29 ±0,74 Vl smh 3,45 ± 0,79 DD ATTP 3,27 ± 0,94 Dich te 2,28 ± 0,98 SKMT 3,40 ±0.96
3,10± 0,70 3,19±0,85 3,71± 0,45
Dirge ly 3,01 ±0,94 Hoa dugc 3,52 ± 0,73 TV- dugc 3,44 ± 0,69
3,44± 0,70 3,12± 0,77 3,46± 0,68
3,02 ± 0,76 2, 96± 0,87 3,27± 0,68
2,73±0,98 3,08±0,87 3,15±0,81
3,26t 0,98 3,47± 0,74 3,47± 0.72
3.26 ± 0,76 3,05 ±0,79 3.27 ± 0,85
3,62±0,56 3,69±0,56 3,64±0,57 3,19±0,90
2,9O±0,89 3,44±0,80 3,32 ± 0,72 3,56 ± 0,56 3,35 ± 0,63
3,16±0,89 3,52±0,72 3,38±fl,68
3,67±0,57 3,56±0,66 3,58±0.69,„
3,66±0,52 3A9±«,63 3,63±0,5Q,
Nguyen Mhih Nguyf t vd Dtg Tgp chi KHOA HQC & CONG NGHE 136 (06): 63-67 Nhan xet: Ket qua bdng 1 eho thdy:
- Myc tidu phti hgp vdi ndi dung bai gidng: cd 4 bf mdn dugc sinh vien danh gid d muc tdt (Sinh hge, Hda bgc, Vi sinh, SKMT), 8 bg mon duge sinh vidn ddnh gia d muc kha.
-Myc tidu cua HPTH dugc dap ung sau khi ket thuc HPTH: cd 3 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gia d muc tdt (Sinh bgc, Hda hge, DDVSATTP), 8 bg mdn duge sinh vidn ddnh gid d miic kha.
Nhgn xet: Kdt qud bang 2 eho thdy:
- Bf mdn eung cap bdng kidm cho sinh vidn:
ed 4 bd mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gia d mue tdt (Sinh hge, Hda bgc, VL-LS, Hda dugc), 6 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gia d muc kha, 2 bf mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gia d miic tnmg binh (KST, Dich td).
-GV, KTV thao tac mlu chudn xdc, ty my: 03 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn ddnh gia d muc tdt (sinh hge, hda hge,vi sinh), 9 bg mdn duge sinh vidn danh gid d miic kha.
-GV+ KTV giam sdt t6t ede boat dgng eua SV: 2 bg mdn dugc sinh vien ddnh gid d mde tot (VL-LS, Hda dugc), 9 bg mdn duge sinh vidn danh gia d mde khd, 1 bd mdn dugc sinh vien danh gia d miic trung binh.
- BM cd nhgn xet, pban hdi sau budi thye hdnh: 2 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gid d miic tdt {sinh hge, hda dugc), 7 bg mdn dugc
Bdng 3. Kel qud phdn hoi
sinh vidn danh gia d miic khd, 3 bd mdn duge sinh vidn ddnh gid d muc TB.
- BM thue hifn gid TH dung quy djnh: 11 bd mdn dugc sinh vien danh gid d miie tdt, 1 bd mdn dugc sinh vien danh gia d mue khd.
Nhdn xet: Ket qud bang 3 cbo thay vd cae ndi dung dugc SV danh gia
-Lugng gia frong qua trinh thyc tap: 05 bd mdn dugc sinh vien danh gia d miic tdt, 05 BM d mde kha, 02 bd mdn dugc sinb vidn danh gia d miic TB.
-Lugng gia kdt qua thuc tap theo bang Idem:
5 bd mdn dugc sinh vien ddnh gid d miic tdt, 6 bd mdn duge sinh vien ddnh gia d miic kha, 1 bd mdn duge sinh vidn ddnh gid d miie TB.
- GV ddnh gia cdng bdng ehinh xde: 3 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn ddnh gia d miie tdt, 8 bg mdn duge sinh vidn ddnh gid d miic kha. 1 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn ddnh gid d miic TB.
- Kdt qua phan anb duge ndng luc cua SV: 10 bd mdn duge sinh vidn danh gia d muc kha, 2 bd mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gid d muc TB.
- Bg mdn cdng bd didm ngay sau budi thue hanh: 4 bd mdn duge sinh vidn danh gia d muc tdt, 1 bd mdn duge sinh vidn ddnh gid d muc khd, 1 bg mdn duge sinh vidn ddnh gid d miie TB, 6 bd mdn dugc sinh vien danh gid d miic yeu.
ve to chuc liepng gid
KHCB
YCS
YTCC
Dirge B$mdn Hoa hoc Sinh hge VL-LS
KST Hoa sinh
Vi sinh DD ATTP
Dieh te SKMT Duge ly Hoa duge TV- duge
140 132 136 114 119 106 l i s 123 113 112 111 101
LGqui trinb bgc (X±SD) 3,79 ± 0,54 3,79 ± 0,55 2,99 ±1,00 3,21 ± 0,94 3,31 ±0,76 3,68 ± 0,64 3,60± 0,64 2,57 ±1,18 3,48 ±0,81 3,32 ± 0,77 3,53 ± 0,64 3,42 ±0,63
LG It^t qua theo BK (X ± SD) 3,71 ±0,59 3,77 ±0,51 3,04 ±0,92 3,15 ±0,98 3,33 ± 0,76 3,68 ± 0,59 3,58 ± 0,64 2,52 ±1,16 3,46 ± 0,79 3,29 ± 0,80 3,51 ±0,66 3,47 ±0,67
Dinh cii cong bang (X±SD) 3,48 ± 0,62 3,72 ± 0,53 3,61 ± 0,63 3,18 ±0,98 3,21 ± 0,80 3,55 ± 0,62 3,41 ± 0,79 2,95 ± 0,82 3,30 ±0,83 3,37 ± 0,67 3,47 ±0,73 3,33 ± 0,76
Ket qui pban inh nangluc (X±SD) 3,30 ±0,71 3,40 ± 0,64 3,26 ± 0,75 2,95 ± 0,87 3,10 ±0,66 3,36 ± 0,62 3,31 ±0,77 2,75 ± 0,84 3,07 ±0,85 3,29 ± 0,70 3,45 ± 0,72 3,38 ± 0,67
Tra di^m cuoi buoi (X ± SD) 3,84 ± 0,40 3,63 ± 0,59 1,78±1,10 1,97 ±1,22 1,81 ±0,99 2,22 ±1,07 3,84 ± 0,45 2,48 ±1,18 3,78 ±0,51 1,24 ±0,64 3,32 ± 0,92 2,85 ± 0,53
Nguyin Minh Nguyet ra Btg Tap chi KHOA HOC & CONG NGHE 136 (06): 63 - 67
Khoa
KHCB
YCS
YTCC
Dugc
Bing 4. Kel Bg mon H6ahgc Sinh hoc VL-LS
KST Hoa sinh
Vi sinh DDATTP
Diehtl SKMT Dugcly Hoa dugc TV Duoc
• qud phdn hdi ve didu hen ddm bdo chdt It/fmg gidng dify Phdng TH du rong,
dii inh sing tboing mit (X±SD) 3,64 ±0,46 3,73 ± 0,56 2,90 ± 0,95 3,29 ± 0,78 3,59 ±0,58 3,46 ± 0,70 2,82 ±0,98 3,07 ±0,85 3,50 ±0,64 3,27 ± 0,74 3,41 ± 0,67 3,32 ± 0,72
Dgng cy, h6a cb4t sinb vftjibiim day dii
(X±SD) 3,46 ± 0,67 3,61 ± 0,58 2,99 ± 0,89 3,19 ±0,81 3,54 ± 0,54 3,58 ± 0,64 3,13 ±0,76 2,95 ± 0,77 3,15 ±0,75 3,25 ± 0,65 3,39±0,71 3,32 ±0,63
sa lu<img SV ctia nbom TH pbii bgp
(X±SD) 3,49 ±0,56 3,52 ± 0,54 3,07 ±0,70 3,32 ± 0,81 3,58 ± 0,62 3,44 ±0,82 3,44 ±0,79 3,20 ± 0,78 3,34 ±0,60 3,26 ±0,60 3,40 ± 0,63 3,50 ± 0,63 Nhgn xet: Kdt qud bdng 4 cho thdy vd cde ngi
dung duge SV danh gid
- Phdng TH dli rgng, du dnh sang, thodng mat: 3 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gia d mue tdt, 7 bg mdn duge sinh vidn danh gid d mde khd, 2 bf mdn dugc sinh vien danh gia d miic trung binh.
- May mde, dyng ey, hda ehdt sinh vat pham day dli, chat lugng tot: 3 bg mdn dugc smh vidn danh gid d mue tdt, 7 BM d miic kha, 2 bf mdn dugc sinh vidn ddnh gid d miic TB - So lugng smh vidn cua nhdm TH phii hgp: 02 bg mdn dugc sinh vidn danh gid d miic tdt, 10 bg mdn dugc smh vidn danh gia d mue kha.
KET LUAN
Qua qua trinh nghidn ciiu vifc giang dgy va lugng gid thuc hanh tgi 12 bg mdn fliugc 4 khoa Khoa hge ca bdn, Y ca sd, Y td cdng cfng, Duge ehiing tdi cd mdt sd kdt lugn nhu sau:
- Ngi dung gidng dgy: 02 BM Khoa KHCB (Sinh hge, Hda hge) duge sinh vidn danh gid d miie tot nhdt(2/2TC)
- Td chuc gidng dgy :
+ BM dugc sinh vidn ddnh gia d muc cao nhdt BM sinh hge Khoa KHCB (4/5TC d miic tdt)
-I- BM dugc sinh vidn ddnh gia d mue thdp nhdt BM Ky sinh Trung, BM Dich td (2/5 TC d mue TB)
66
- Td chiic lugng gia:
+BM sinh bgc Khoa KHCB dugc sinh vien ddnh gid d mue tdt nhdt (4/5 TC d miic tdt) + BM dugc sinh vidn danh gid d miic th^
nhdt BM Dich t l (5/5 TC d miicTB) - Didu kifn dam bdo ehdt lugng gidng day;
+ BM sinh hge Khoa KHCB dugc sinh vidn ddnh gia d miic tdt nhdt (3/3 TC d miic tdt) + BM VL- LS dugc sinh vidn ddnh gid d miic tiidp nhdt (3/3 TC d muc TB)
KHUYEN NGHI
- 'Qh ngbi eae bg mdn VL- LS, KST, Hda sinb, Vi sinh, Dugc ly edng bd diem cho sinh vidn ngay sau budi thye hanh.
- Nhd trudng ndn xay dung quy djnh khen, ehd kip thdi ddi vdi nhiing bg mdn tbyc hifn tdt va chua tdt quy chd cua nha trudng dd ra.
- Cde khoa, bg mdn can td chiic nit kinh n ^ d m d nhimg tidu chi chua dugc sinh vien danh gia tdt dt nang cao chdt lugng giang dgy.
T A I LIEU THAM K H A O 1. Do Thj Cham, Nguydn Van Son (2013), Banh gid nfi dung cua mgt sd mdn bgc co sd Tmdng Dgi hpc Y Dugc - DHTN nam 2013 qua phieu danh gia ciia suih vidn ". YD2013-103.
2. Nguyen Minh NgiQ-ft, Trinh Xudn Tr^g (2013),
"Thyc trang ch^ lugng gjd gidng ciia gidng vi&i Truong Dgi hge Y Dugc - DHTN nam 2013 qua phidu ddnh gia ciia smh vidn". YD2013-102.
Nguyen Minh Ngnyjt va Btg Tap ehi KHOA HQC & CONG NGHE 136 (06): 63 - 67 3. Ph6ng TT-KT&DBCLGD Truimg Dai hge Y 5. Tiinh Xuan Trang, Ha Xuan Son, Nguyin Minh Dugc Thii Nguyen (2009), "KSt qua dinh gia gift Nguyet (2010), "Lugng gia bai thuc tap cac mon giang euagiang ViSn nim 2009 quaphiSu dinh gia ^ ^ ^ j ^ g , ^ U,„^ ^ji ^ ^ ^^^ ^ j . ^ ^ „ ^ do sinh vien tu dien", Bao cao npi bo. . ' ' . - . i_, „
4. Phdng TT-KT&DBCLGD Tmdng Dgi hge Y thyc trang va giai phdp .
Dugc Thdi Nguyen (2011), "Ddnh gia gid giang ciia ^- T™ng ^ ^ ^dm bdo chdt lugng gido dye va giar^ vidn va chdt lugng mdn hpc Tradng Dai hoc Y Khao tiii (2010), "Bao cao kdt qua danh gia boat Dugc Thdi Nguydn ndm 2011 qua phidu danh gid do dfng gidng day Tnrdng Dgi hge Su pham Ha Npi, smh vien h; didn", Dy an NPT-VNM-240. hpc ky II nam hpc 2009-2010", Hd Nfi.
SUMMARY
THE REALITY OF TEACHING AND ASSESSING STUDENTS'PRACTICE DV PRACTICING ROOMS OF COLLEGE OF MEDICINE AND PHARMACY - TNU
Nguyen Minh Nguyet*, Bui Thi Quynh Nhung and coworkers College of Medicine and Pharmacy - TNU For over the past year, the innovation of the teaching and assessing in all the practical credits in all the divisions of the univerisity has been done. To evaluate the results obtained, the problems, and to suggest meassurements to improve the quality of teaching and assessing students' practice in practicing rooms of all the divisions, our division earned out the survey: The reality of leaching and assessing students' practice in practicing rooms of Thai Nguyen University of Medicine and Pharmacy in 2014
The method of cross-study was used on 1483 students who had pracUced in 12 divisions in 4 departments: Department of basic science. Department of basic medicine, and Department of public health, and Department of Pharmacy. The survey showed that there are changes in the teaching contents, the organising of teaching, the organising of assessment and the conditions of ensuring the quality of teaching, as follows:
- In the teaching contents: Department of basic sciences was assessed the best (2/3 divisions ranking Good)
- In the organising of teaching: Department of basic sciences was assessed the best (2/3 divisions ranking Good)
- In the orgarusing of assessment: 2 dep20/4/artments (Department of basic medicine and Department of Public health) were assessed being -weak
- In the conditions of ensuring the quality of teaching: 4 departments were assessed being moderately good.
Keywords: students' assessment
Ngdy nhgn bdi:31/3/2015; Ngdy phdn bien:20/4/2015; Ngdy duyet ddng: 15/6/2015 Phan bien khoa hoc: TS. Hge Vdn Vinh - Tru&ng Dgi hpc Yduac - DHTN
