˘ˇ ˆ ˝ ˛ ˚ ˇ

(1)

!

! " # $ )

: 28 / 1 / 1387 - :

16 / 5 / 1387 (

% :

' ( ) # * + # , -. / $ 0 * 1 2 3 4

( * 3 5 67 0 8. / 67 # 7 49 * +

8

': : (

6"

" * ;

< * * # = >

. : :7 ! @

7 '* 1

<

6 ! 7 6 9 3 7 0 ; ' 9 ( A 49 7 +

; B

' < ' " 7 ! @ C # 5 .

:; : 3: 6:7 6:9 7

" <

D : E : ':* : 7 F G< 0 ; # 7 # '*

'

: * -. :/ (: H9 I = 67 '@A 3 # '* < J@K

.

: * * : # : 9 L 7 4 6* 3

3 @

0 ; EM

< 7 # H9 3 7 # '*

. 6:7

;

649 9 7

, I = + ' : ': 9 # '* : : 6:7

7 6 9 < 8 * * # # 7 .2 3 !% 9 * -. / ( H9 .

# " N :

0 * -

#

* * -

# '*

-

# , -

* .

: 66409595 [email protected]

Email:

! " # $% &' () * + ,-. /0 , ) * 123 4 ,"

.

(2)

! "# $!% &'! (% )* # + '" ! ',- .

/01 + '" !

2! 3' 4 "# $!% 205 678! 29:85 # ;9 4' - 4<

$- . /',- ;/= ;/> /=

+ '" !

"# $!% 678! ( 8? ;=

@ ,- (% A /5# ( /< $8, B = C$D 2: C

E F> G 'H 0> # 7I

$ D 6J# K'B 2 '" ! &' B ( L! ;=

. 2H$'M' ;= ;> =

+ '" ! A 5# # &'': ! ( = 2 N #

@ 2 /'" ! ( !G / # ( / L! ( /'! EO9P Q B#

R 89>

. 3'" &',- ;=

@ P 3/S /= 2:> !

# ( / L! ( /'! 2" /,9S + / O9

2! ;9 H T 2 '" ! ( !G D

.

# I/' 28U9I! ! & G V' ! 4< 2 '" ! W T

4< 2 '" ! W T /T 2/:> ! 2 /'" ! ( !G / # ( / L! 2" ,9S + O9P 3S =

2" ? ;< C$D ;9 H 2 '" ! 2" ? D 6> ! &

. /X G

@

;/= ;/> /=

E F> # P + '9P # 2B *S A 5 G "# 2YN A ,9S

;=

( L! Z *S [ 7

+ '" ! 6J# =

@ ',/ ;/= 6/> ! &/ + ,', / /= " $/? ( 2 \B + T

C$D ;9P 8D .

& ;< 2"

[ 7 2! ] Y!

D

@ 'SO/5 /># % ;< &

2 \B # 2" ? 6> ! # = G ! )

" $/? ( / # 2 '" ! 2" ? D (

/=

;/= / ^; HG ; _ 8! 2 A 5 # 25 9P 6> ! ` ;_I0

9D & 205 E$- A L &

.

1 .

1 - 1 . a- G ( B

= C$'*?

= &

; 70b# c,< c + '" ! ;<

;<

3/'! ;= d ND

# P 71 # C _9 3= *!

2! ! S C X9 G ;<

;= $ =

"#

2!

$/ G . K/7b

P ( % 71 # J # ( L! * ! + '" ! 2 [ D e : &

.

W '- $

Daivid Hume)

+ '" !(

2! 2 !$P ( 7> # f g=

/"# C X9/ G ;/< $

2! $ ? D

)

@ ' ' 1348 @ 58 ( .

' I98!

Montesquieu)

2! d ND 2i G 29,IB + '" ! (

/= / ;< $ ;/ 8

$8 9=

C _9 ) % = C ,- P 2i G

$8 , 2! "# ;=

$ G

)

@ ' ' 1348 @ 58 ( .

;9D H + '" ! 35 W$?

! 4

# (% ( = [

= /"# C$/g? /= ;< 2_ j# ;=

/B

@

= .

"#

2! 3,F9! 2> N! $ =

$ H # & D W ! ( '! $ = V' k N! & #

2! a'I*

$D

;`'9 - 5 ; 8 G a? ;:! > G c lm

G C X9 /= # 69,9! "#

(3)

P

; =

e0 ! 2!

$D

;= F & ;= ;< 2,g

# 2/! K/0:

G /n= / H

)

@ /' '

1348

@ d (58 .

< 4/! ag/ &'/': # 4/< / &'/= 2! ,? k N! a'I* + '" ! $ $*9:! 2P = G c - k /N! &'! / /g> ( /B /> ! ;= ;< 2o07! # k N! & g %

p ? O= Y= 2! ,?

2! ;9P 2B *S # 2*'*S d ND q D

)

@2! ! 1384

@ d 19 ( .

2! + '" ! = ;< $'_! # 9N! e :

;< & ;i ( :

» 0 :@ 0 : *

# :7 : = ':/ Q RA 7 8 = F + A< ' 7 + '

S T 3

«

)

@ ' ' 1348 @ d 92

.(

1 - 2 . 2 $9= 6! >

;= 2> '9S

>#

2 I L!

2! ,? + !$P C$8- W ` ;<

$8 !

9IH # ) @t'0

;< u 7

2H$ G # 6! > (%

;0'7B C P H

;:! >

p : !

( X X'=

2! B

C P G c - H

;:! >

;= P ) P G Q

2!

2! &'! Q # '8! 3 # # P ( '! +# \B # + D ;= 2H$' # <

v'- (#$= ;< = ;0'7B t'i C$g? = V' ;0'7B

;8 V- ; H

? &' b ;8 V- = #

2! + 5 H

)

@( G 7gD 1373

@ d 8

.(

a9I' & K7b

@ /P / ,S /F / '8! # '5 = &g< W B # + ? ,>

2! 2! ,? + !$P W ` ;= ;:! > G $:

$89D ,H

# H

2, P

I/

W ` 2! ,? !$P 2! e0 ! $-

$D C g=

+ !$/P &9 H W ` = P w 9 G

# $8< P 2! ,?

;=

;0' # 29P x" 7! &

2! '> < & = 2 I<

$ , .

;= ;> = # # ! ;=

= ( $! 2H$ G ;= ( #% # = ;< $ $> -G '

> = 6! >

< a'I* ;= u ;:! > $!%

$ $D V , # c' _ > ! ! & #

# 2 ND e'"

$D 2? ,9> e j# G 2H P

#

# + /! T9 y/_S # +# \/B 3/'7B G 2? ,9> e j#

'8!

;=

"#

$/D A F! - .

;/`'9 > / 28'4/ g/D ;:/ # 6/! > A /F

;/:!

,- ( H C g= $ $> 2H$ G + ,: # - ! G ;< ;

$ $D $8!

@

$ $ H e0 ! ,g

2 cu <

P Q ,9> C # $gX = P 2i # $!% G

$8 ,

)

@2 9 1335 @ d 17 ( .

P # ;_I0

+ '" !

$! @ 2! ,? -$!%

#

;/8 V- &'!

4/< /-

;8 V- &'! # R /` 2! /,? + !$P W ` ;8'!G 2 X,- -

/<

$/!% G ;/< C

-$/!% G # 2B _ # ,9I!

; /S 2 /H G = # 2/J /T8! ;/=

2! /,? /! C

(4)

2 I # ' + 5 ;= C H # $* + 5 ;= C H # 2I8> + 5 ;= C H ;< $= d 9P

! S '9P 'H G = # X'= $8 ! 2! ;9D H -

C$D

)

@2 9 1335

@ d 18 ( .

2Hz # ;= ;> = # $ $> C # ( $! 2H$ G -

[ /= ! k /N! $ $/D e0 ! W !

$88< &'! 2! ,? ! W ` ;=

/,? ! > ;8 V- &'! 2,g #

$8/D = ;9/D 2!

.

2/! /! &/ /> # C /= / /- ;/< 2,g/ ' & $=

W / + /'" ! /P

H .

)

@( G 7g/D 1373 d @ 8 (

C$D &'': g % = ;< 2 '" ! ;:! > ;< 2 5 .

$ G n

;8 V- # J # > - 2, &'! 2! ,? ! W ` g> 4<

D .

; 8 ;= ;> = ;9D H / C 7 I'! g % K'B > # + *! # &' B 6J#

#

6 8! # :4/" /F " $/? 3/5 # Z *S # I ;4',- ( $8! #G { _ #

/B Q

2!

@ + ? J ! X $8 ! V' + '" !

; m ? '1 b ;=

2!

f / ;0'/ # # $D

Z *S ;= G# ` # C _9 W !

2! B e':J ;*7b # H

.

># V' 2 f 8U9 ;Y= & ;97"

.

; , ( 8? ;=

WO/ 7! /' C # ;0,> G

) d (

;< & $D _0P # 7! ' ( # ;=

) d (

= 3 9!

" $/? /= C /,- + /'" ! A 5#

C = 27I C # & #

# = 27- ! e'" G + '" ! P - W ! W ,?

;> =

; 8 ;=

+ '" ! P D ;= 27- ! e'" ;0,> G

2! , $!%

= 71 # J

;/=

/P

2! W $B + '" !

$ <

.

» a',: + '" ! ;I '7< RO* =

# 6/J# d /P " $? # + # I! A 5

- 4/< / w $ ;= # ;I $9= & G # $D 20,? V' + '" ! A 5# # '* # 281 G a? 4< W , ( g>

|/8> G 3/7B ; 8 $ G n= + '" ! $ = ej !

A# 2 g>

) 1914 - 1919 (

;8'!G L/! 2" /! ? Y9/ # + $B @+ '" ! A 5# # 6J#

= ;Y= # H B ;> ! '" :

+ '" ! P H < ! # 2J # $'" -

' :! A ,? # $?

2 '" ! -

! B ;>

H .

6 ;'0* 3i # Q 9P # + ` ;: =

# + /79? ) V # 'I"

= /< &'/8M,-

+ '" ! & VX > $* + '" ! - 4< 01 $'" $ $> A 5

$/ H 2I/8> - C

#

A /D ;/= 6 G # $'" 3S ! W , + '" ! $ $> -G ' 2P = ($!% > = = # ! ;=

9N!

< /D = + '" ! $8 ! e0

# A /*9 # 3/* + /'" ! @ /- ....

2/! A /5# ( / L! G /D

«

) G 7gD @(

1373 @ d (8 .

ag! ;0,> G + '" ! A 5#

/"# (% ;0' = ;< 2 - - &

2! /, ( ~/D

" P ;:! > 2? ,9> @ 9B 2!

# $ , C H$

- C g> C & G P

2! A ,? ;:! > 2? ,9> # 9B

$ , .

(5)

»

"# CG# ! E $- + '" ! P G -

2! A 7 G

$88<

:

-

;8 V- 2" ! &'! T8! ;= WGm $!% I<

V/' # 2/9"# + !$/P ;= [ = ! -

;8 V- 4< 20P '8! # -G ! G S # y_S ;= [ = ! - .

- V=

9B # 2? ,9> " $? K*F .

&

[ 7

$ = D ;>

U< ;<

3= B < 4! - 4<

"# ;>

&'! g> WGm + !$P ( #% a- ;8'!G -

# 2 /! # 29/D $g= + !$P • 9IH # qI= ;8'!G g % 'YP ;_'j# V' # 2? ,9>

24! qP ;0,> G 2DG !%

( '8= € ! 2 > - 2? /,9> # 9B " $? H

;9P 8D

$D C .

&

! ; H

; H ;=

I'

;/ 0= /'X= /B W ! ;> ! P P ;= ;<

! W ` '" ~I! "#

/= # ;9 H C$g? = ;:_8," W ? + !$P # 2! ,?

+ /'" ! ( /8? ;/= /g % G ;/:! > $!% G 29,IB ! 3'7B & W ` /

2!

$8<

. - + '" ! 2! -

= ( 8? ;= $8 / ' /g> € /! V

$/- # A /98< /H

$ # < ;= T ! # R 0Y! g> ;:! > 9B .

2! =V! W - &'8M,-

"# 9B C$,? E $- 2\:= ;= ($' g> $

( F= g! V' # 9B $D W# $ # y_S ;0,> &!

# +# /€ 3 $/: # e/09N! -

;// m ? 6// G

$//D = ;9//D 2g> // 3//= B )//* C //'1 # A o9//D //` # $//!% //

«

)

@( G 7gD 1373

@ d 4 (

1 - 3 . )

"#$% &' (

)* +

2 '" ! W T - WG " G 2 '" ! EO9P 3S # 2 .

# 2 /'" ! EO9/P /-

$ \S E b

: –1

@ L!

–2 2 /'" ! ( !G / )

/"# C$/8 , .(

EO9/P 3/S 6/> !

'N4 ( > ;< 2 O9P ;= 2H$' g> 2 '" ! E /b # &'/= + /'" ! A /5# # •

2! > = < ! 2! 3' 4 $ %

$ D .

» p 9? KS 2 8D ( L! C$D ;9P 8D Z *S G 2 CG# ! 7I g %

•'N4/ ;=

( $! 2 '" ! Z *S +m F G ;< 2 '" ! 6> !

«

)

@ D

1383 @ d 2 (

a9I/' .

j ;9 4' - 4< ( $! 2 '" ! 2/! /B + /'" ! &'': ‚ ( L! ;! g

/'H . /=

•# & 87!

;! gj &,J $8_0 ! ( L!

$ WO? 2 '" ! ( !G ;= P $!%

$ G n= ;*0:9! + '" ! #

# /87! L/! ;/= ( 8',b # ,9? ejL! ;'" ! ( !G

$- B P <

L! + '" ! # , A /5# # C •'N4 # ;! gj K7b

$/

) /D

(6)

@ / 1383 @ d 2 (

2 '" ! ( !G ;97" .

B 2 = ! ;! gj &

2!

$- ;< 2 5 #

$ , WO? L! ;= $D = ;9D 2J 9?

2 /'" ! ( !G / /T &9 / + /5 q/

2, )' 20 4! L!

$ % . L/! ;< 2 5 /n + /'" ! •'N4/ ( !G / /T

2! $ $ 2 '" ! EO9P

$ % .

» c/ G 2B /*S / 2*'*S G a? ( L! ( '! K W$? ; H - ;= 2 '" ! EO9P

2/! ;9_H 2 '" ! 3i I! d P X E b G 2 '" ! 6> ! # 3! ? # E b /D

5# 2X Xu # + '" ! ! 2? ;= ;<

2H$'/ /= # $D = ;9D " P (% A

C$D 28'= )' 25 P 6> ! V' (% ;=

«

)

@28'IF" $7?

1376 @ d (16

.

9I- C$'M' # 2 N 28' B 2 '" ! &' B

$8 .

&',- 9

# $/: ;/= ;> =

a/- /= &' /B /> ( / L! # A 5# & ! ! 2 '" ! + *! # &' B 2H$'M' 9P 2! $' G - T EO ;9/D ># + O9P & 3S = 2:> ! $ = # $88<

$8D =

)

@28'IF" $7?

1376 @ d 16 (

l /5 ƒ" /! # C + ! V" G „ ;< 2:> ! .

/=

v'- (#$= # + *! # &' B ‚ 2 /'" ! ( !G ( '! EO9P 6 ;= $7 > ; H

$ G n= W ! # .

'SO5 2 9I! "# 0b 'b# 4! G 37B 2/! •'N4

f \/! G t/ #

2! ;" S *= G# ;= A 5# = ;'" ! G#

$ H . ( 'I/',< # ? 'b# 4! $5

2! ] Y! 2i &'!$N9I!

A /< ! ( 'I',< $`! ] b ( 'I',< T > # $ H

= ;'" ! G# T ;=

)

@( D

d @ 2=

371

.(

C # G 2P = -

•# G 2 '" ! &' B 2 /'" ! + / O9P 6/ = C 'I= 2 -

2! C _9 2 '" ! ( !G # ( L! ( '!

L/! ( '! EO9P 3S •# ; , ( 8? ;= @$ <

R ! + ' P + '" ! ( B < ! + '" ! ( ! ! # 6

K= /Y! ( V/'!

18 C$/:* { 1333

& ,B ' P ;*0:9! + '" ! ( V'! ;< = ; H

/= + /' P ,'B G 2 $5 B G +

! ( # < 78 ,'B &'': ;< 2 5 # 3/5 S 2 O9P ;'" ! & ! ! # L! &'=

2!

2! + '" ! ( 8? ;= t8> &'? G 2 $5 $D

$ H

1 .

1 . C ! 2 - B G a'*9I! '1 p ? G ;< A# C ! C < ! + ' P + '" !

$- P ,'B G 2 $5

&'? G 2 $5 D 35 S 2 O9P ;'" ! & ! ! # C$= + '" ! &'= ! ( # < 78 ,'B &'': ;< 2 5 $D I'= $5 B G X' ( ;= 7I C *! + '" ! $D $- P t8>

(7)

R /! ;/'" ! + G# +O' 4 ( B = a< F! ;'7D ;< 2 !G &'9IN 15

G >

1294 C .

= K= Y! • 21

>

1333 - / .

$!% > = Z

;/'" ! + ,< F! C ;= W ! #1

2! 2H$' "# = + O9P Q ;= ;< $D

<

)

@ D

1383 @ d 106

.(

+ '" ! ( B R ! a'*9I! -

1345 - / . + / O9P ;/= 2H$'/ /= 2:> ! •

( L! # "# &'= 2 '" ! G $ = + 7? ;< $D `

: ( 'I',<

•'N4/ /-

# /D

2 '" ! 2" ? .

( 'I',<

C ! K7b •'N4 -

2164

$ = EO9P ; H - ;= 2H$' 6> !

+ '" ! •'N4 ;<

+ '" ! ( B Q J ! - ( / L! # •'N4 & ! ! &'= a'*9I! -

2! > =

$!%

. C ! > ! ;=

3249 ( B &

7I/ T $ $` P ;= 2H$' 6> !

= •'N4 ( 'I',< G X ;7:D @•'N4 ( 'I',< 2:YB '1 f % ;=

.

C ! K7b V' 2 '" ! 2" ? D

4253 G ( / L! + /D ;/= 2H$' 6> ! ( B &

( 'I',< f %

= •'N4 - .

G C /! c E j L!

„O/= /

'I/',< 2/:YB (

2 /'" ! 2" ? D ;= ( B ? W$? 3'" ;= (% ;= 7I p 9? WO? KS •'N4 D . + '" ! ( B -

1366 ( 'I',< ( 8?

+ '- ;= 2 '" ! - /''o EO9/P 3/S -

< $'

$ H f *= K= + 5 ( ,- ;= 2 '" ! 2" ? D ! 5 6.

;< 2 SO5 > ! ;=

1 . C ! 12 - + $ ? •'N4 C e j# A 5 3 { B ;=

:

) 1 ( 6,> # V> ;'g # •'N4 + '" ! 3< 2I8> # $* -

$D $- P 6J# -$:= # C = A ,:! ( 8< ;< 2 - -

6,> # V> ' # + m# # +m = (% a'I* # + ?# # + '" ! 3< ( V'! ;< = $- P b ;= C < ! -

29S # B # + < 0=

= ( !m

$D = &':! C$= + '" ! .

2 . C ! 164 - + '" ! •'N4 ;< EO9P ; H - ;= 2H$' 6> ! ( ! ! G c - &'= ( B & Q J ! -

6> ! ( B & ! + *! > ! ;= ;< ! X! $D = 2! •'N4 ( 'I',< D ` L! # •'N4 C$D &'': X 2H$'

$D = .

3 . C ! 249 - f % '1 2:YB ( 'I',<

-

•'N4 3= B

$ $`

2H$'

;7:D X ( 'I',<

•'N4 + '" !

$- P

=

;<

# _

\?

( 'I',<

•'N4 C$8 , 2

# 9IH lO7B 7I

;=

Q J !

;S# Y!

† C $

$8D = f %

C 5

;0S !

$ $`

2H$' 2:YB

# WGm f >m 2!

$D = .

4 . C ! 253 - 2! [ = ! •'N4 ! ! L!

% „O= G C ! c E j $8 ( 'I',< 2:YB

•'N4 -

2 '" ! ) 2! ':YB ;0S ! ;= 2 L! E b G p 9? W$? 0? ;= ;< ! G '1

$ ( W$? 89 ;=

= # ;? J ! &' B ? 2H$' $ $` # ‡* # $88< D 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;= 2 < 3 m WO?

$8- N=

. 5 . C ! 244 - )' X 6> ! ( B & + *! &,J ;< ! V> 2 '" ! + O9P ;'0< ;= 2H$' 6> ! 28'=

2 '" ! EO9P 3S + '- C$D .

6 . C ! 256 - E b G C H - D 35 # 2 '" ! EO9P 3S + '- 2:YB G *! $? ! 29 D 3< V',! L!

‡* ? ;? J ! + *! # &' B ‡* ? F 0 9S 5 ˆ $! # 8 ;i # 3 m ;! B = (% &,J ;<

;= 2H$' g> D 2 '" ! 2" ? D t' $D = C$D 2H$' , $- P Q > [ = ! :D G 2

.

;7:D

(8)

A 1380 + '" ! ( B ;= 7I C /! E /S /= H + 5 a'*9I! -

247

;/0S !

$ H E S 2 '" ! 2 W T G - ! T $ $`

.

2 . , - ./

2 - 1 . , - ./ # 01 $%

6> ! 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2" ?

4/< 2 /'" ! a9I/' 2 /'" ! EO9P 3S /

#

+ '- f % G D ;= 2H$' 2 '" ! EO9P 3S -

C$/g? /=

.

< /! /D

C 'D = ;Y= T gj 6> ! &'8M,- &'/ % ;/'g # 2 /'" ! + *! # &' B > -

;!

)N= # -

;!

! # 3i I! C = T gj # 2 '" ! &' B > ;= [ = ! - + ? J

2 '" ! .

D &

\? _ w8 # I'=

;<

$ = G

&'=

# 6/0Y! @ T S 5 d ND

ˆ $/! 3B $/S ;/< 2 = I/S # $= I/S @2" /! @ 9B @2B *S ! R `!

/! - ;9D A :! 2 8D < 20' F

$8/D = <

$ /D R /N9 /g % R /9 #

;/=

i g84' # 4< 2 '" ! ! ( !G 3< t'

=

2/ # 9B ! G# a S

+ /5

2!

'H . 9B ! + G# ( 8< < G $ = 2 '" ! 2" ? D f \? G _ C V 3B $S

( !G # 2 # 31 4/! /< ;*= / )/D 3B $/S ;/< (% ;:= -$S # # -

$8D = 2 '" ! $ D R N9

) C ! 252 + '" ! ( B (% c C 7 # a'*9I! -

(.

+$! & # R 9 G A ; 2 '" ! 2" ? D \? \? C # ( D P J * ;= X! $89I' ''o 3= B 25 /9P C /H 2:YB a S > ! ;=

C ! Q J ! 267

+ '" ! ( B a'*9I! -

A / ;/ \/* G t f \? $`! R 9 @1

6 !O= < ! .

i t' /! + G# $/8! < ;/< /D f \/? &'= G 2 '" ! 2" ? D

l 5 ! '- ! ;= # # (#$= ej ! =V!

2H$' ( = 3! < # + _ 4 ? ‰ F" G

*= Y! # 2 B -

% ‡* = 2\9*! 2 B 3 m # R 7 # + g> ;= $89I! # 2H$' Q J ! ;= ;? J ! + *! # &' B = ! '- + + '- % ‡* = 2\9*! 2 B 3 m # R 7 # + g> ;= $89I! # 2H$' 3S - 2 '" ! EO9P 3S -

H $'B &9! $ = '0B T # 79? [ 8! U< = ;7:D @$ , 5 =V! D # .

1 . C ! 267 :

! 2" ? D \? 2! T9 + _0N # 9B ! G# 9 ;= 2! T9 2" ? + '- \? # 2 '"

@ 4< 2" ? ( t'i 2 :! ;= 4< 2" ? ( :D # G 2 G < ! 25 9P C H 2 2! B 2H$' ! 4< 2 '" ! ! ( !G 3< t'i # + 7 F! ( 3< t'i K7b = ;< 'H

;= 2H$' ( B

, $- P 5 '! F! i = = # 2H$' [ = ! + *! # + _0N .

# 2:YB &

WGm

>m .

(9)

@$D = 2 # 9B

= 2 /'" ! ! ( !G 3< t'i g84' /! / G# a/ S # 4/<

2! R 8! 2 # 9B

D ) C ! 253 '" ! ( B +

a'*9I! - (.

;7:D 4- 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;<

/ \/? /_ ;/ G < ! ;7:D - .

2! R 8! 2 '" ! 2" ? D t'i E b G :D \? # t'i

$ D ) C ! 254 ( /B

+ '" ! a'*9I! - (.

C H -

; # ;= 4! ! ;= 7I 2 '" ! 2" ? D :D e/09N! -

C$/D { /N

/ 4/< 2 /'" ! /! ( !G 3< t'i 2 # 9B ! G# Q > IS $D = # # D t'i \S = 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2! ,? + '- 2 '" ! 2" ? D t'i 3' 4/ /D t'/i R /N9 ;/= /D (% \? G _ c ;7:D t'i R '1 # :D

! # $D $- P N (% ;= 7I # C < 2 = EO9P ! Q J

{ a', C , B # W $

2! #$5 ;=

$ , .

&

2:YB \? W , % W # = ;< 2! ,? + '- + 5

+ '- # 2 '" ! 2" ? D :D = WGm ;= 4/! /! 2 /'" ! EO9P 3S -

Q 7 m )

C ! 258 B + '" ! ( a'*9I! - (.

2 - 2 .

.12 3 4 )* 5 6 7 , - ./ 8

G ] D ;= 2 '" ! 2" ? D + '9P # e j#

:

1 -

&' % ;'g

;!

;! 84N= # - + '" ! ( B > ;= [ = ! -

/! a'*9I/! -

! G# E b G ;<

# 9B 4< 2 '" ! ! ( !G 3< t'i 2

Q />

-2/!

H

# 2/! # J (% ;'g 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;< ! $/

#

;/= ;/'g G t/

$8< g84' 4< 2 '" ! ! ( !G 3< t'i .

2 -

! # &' /B > C 'D ! T WO? # g84' T8! ;= ;:" Y! # 2 = + /*

# 2 '" !

;/= g %G 2\:= E S # 2 '" ! + *! # &' B ''o # ]O5 g84' &'8M,-

4< 2 '" ! ! ( !G 3< t'i 2 # 9B ! G#

.

3 - t'i 2 # 9B ! G# ;< 2 '" ! 3 I! # + ? J ! ! T gj

! ! ( !G 3<

2 /'" ! 2" ? D ;= T gj # + 4! = \9B IS 4< 2 '"

2! Q >

$ , .

4 - + '- 2:YB % ;= 2H$'

‰ /F" G ;/< 2 /'" ! EO9/P 3S -

': :

W 6 X 0 3 <

6/B # 2 /'" ! ! C L! D !

$D = C$D )

C ! 255 ( B + '" ! a'*9I! - (.

(10)

5 -

&'':

( V'!

+ IP

@

! -$/8= /*!

1

# 2 C /!

270 + /'" ! ( /B /-

•'N4 & ! ! + _0N G 2D a'*9I!

.

$8= = K= Y!

1 C ! 270 + '" ! ( B a'*9I! -

! ( ! /! ;/< D W 0:! (% ( = p 9? 3= B '1 # + '" ! •'N4 G $:= C H - # 2 /'"

/ $/,: # G @2 /'" ! EO9/P 3/S + /'- \/? 4/< 2 '" ! ! ( !G ( H$8 , L! $!% 2 < + *'*F (#$= # L! ˆ $! # 8 ;= ;> (#$= @;F! I!

/ /9,<

C •'N4 2:B # ( V'! G 94'=

C # + IP $ = $

;=

2 V'!

;<

D 2" ? 2 '" !

&'':

2!

$ ,

$8 , ( 7>

.

$/8= K/7b &'8M,- 2

C /!

270 + /'" ! ( /B a'*9I/! /-

;< ! + '" !

/'1 / ( /!G # ! A ,4! 2 '" ! ( ! ! 0_1 # ;F! I! € = ( L!

;! gj ! V> H A 5# 3= B C /! /> ;< 2 -

) 158

1( + /'" ! ( /B /-

a'*9I!

;/< 2/ V'! ;/= /"# ;/= C # ( / G ;/= 7I e0N9! I' 2! V" (% ;= 2H$'

•'N4 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2!

2 $! '" ~I! $- .

2 '" ! ! ( !G # 2i # 9B ! + G# 2 4! #G = 2 '" ! 2" ? D 4<

. 49! 2:> ! ># ! ($D 2 N ;= ;> = C # 4/! = C 7P G 3

a', = 29"# + ! *! ;= ( A$9I/! /> ! # ]#$,! # A *:! ! 9g= 'H

A ~I! + ! *! + ,', ($D 2!

H .

2H$'/ 'SO/5 / C$D ;9 H T 2 '" ! 2" ? D = ;< X ;_'j#

20 D + '- f % ;= 7I O9P 3S -

+ /'- q/ ; # +$S# #$5 # 2 '" ! E

2" ? D :D # 2" 6> ! = f % & ;< D & 2! ,?

2 '" ! Q /7 m WGm

. 2 = 94'= 3' _ = D ;_'j# &

2!

D .

'SO/5 $/ H ( '= ;< b ( ,- # 25 9P 6> ! 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2H$' 20 D / % $ $ = ! C$g? = 2 '" ! EO9P 3S - + '- f % ;= 7I

^ HG ; _ 8! 2 A 5 = ( V'! ;u ! &

! +# \B

f \/B /! ;= 2H$' B c' _ ; T K7b # ',- = # 2 N

2:> ! ;= $ = ; `! C B G 3*9I!

&',- D C n 9

lm 5 2 <

V /,9! $ =

C H # $D = 28'8* # 2 > e j# G ;9/D ;/ `! C B G 3*9I! # $> 27 ! ;0I0 -

AO*9 $8D = 2 \B 6> !

D y_S .

1 . C ! 158 : 2! 4< 2 '" ! ! ( !G

$= 2\9*! ;< 2b * # iV> O< 2 '" ! 6= 8! G 2\:= ! $ K7b $

;! gj $:= A ;< $ , WO? A - A# ;,' C 498! 2gH $8D = C , a'0I 6B ! ;= ;< =V! ( L! -

; , Y= g % G $: q* # C , A 7B 2H$' (#$=

$- P B 2H$' ! ( B & + *! K7b # 'H

.

(11)

20?

= ! 4< 2B *S W T Z 0Y! a1 ':7

2B /*S W /T - 4< G

# 28! Š 2!#

•Pm = ;I

@2 > # g !G (#

25 9P 6> !

$D 3' 4 C

;<

C = ;b = ! ( !G G 2:=

# C$/g? /= # ? ;= 2H$' ;_'j#

$ . C H t' 68! # -

9IH a< F!

;= 2H$' G # /?

;I/

N 3 m G 2D 94'=

2 . 2/=O* ( $B *S ,9? 2= ;I '7< RO* G t

&'4' W T G C$ ! H ;= 2 \B C X9 ;= 7I 4< &

@

;'i \/B C B ;< $ H ‹? =

+ '- 0,? AOP ` G 6/8! /g % 3oD ;= 7I &'" ~I! \S # -

3,? G 25 P •ND H # D

\9! 29"# W *!

# C$ H + IP 2!

2! $ I

G# •ND ;0S ! & P% # $8< ;:> ! # Z ! W *! ;= g8 -

? 3 2J B

2!

<

) 7`

@ 1382

@ d 102

.(

G# > ;= # < ''o ; # & w $ ;=

@ a/- (% ;97" ;< 29"# D W ;= 2 D

C B ;= ;9I= #

$ H H # ; `!

.

C H ` # ; # &

( $/B *S / G +$D ;= 2 \B a< F! G 3*9I! -

H B p 9? ! 2I'0X .

C H t' g % ;/Y'S ;/= /D% G# /` -

2! ;'i \B C B $9B

2 \B 2 G 2 c' _ # $89I

2!

$/ <

/u

(% ;<

@ B c' _ = e" N!

" $?

2 \B

)

@C G 2 ! 1377

@ d 20

" $? A 5 = e" N! #(

1 ; #

# ; _ 8! 2 # ....

2!

$89I .

/T /! " $/? 2:'7b # C $? B 2\:= ;< (% WV09I! 2:B # " $? ? 3'7B G 'X= B 2J B :

1 - v'- t<

$D = P ? 2J B $ 7 .

2 - C H 2! 2H$' # ? ;= ;< 2 - # # I! g> - G ? &' b $ = $88<

$8< 2H$' &' b 3im # + gj ;= ; _ 8! b ;= # $8 $= a- p ?

)

@W /P 1345

@ d 16 (

.

1 .

; # " $? A 5 )

procedural justice

# 3! D ;< $89I- ; _ 8! a S #$5 # 2H$' = - ':! 3B $S (

2! 20< 35

$D = :

- C$88< 2H$' 6> ! AO*9 # 2 b 2=

). rule against bias (

- D C$'8D ) ? ;< 2 !G X! < W F! $ 7 t< v'- ; 8 # ;'0? 2?$! ag9! Q KS ).

audi aleram

partem.

. (

;= ˆ :

@2,b $' B 1382

5 @

• 68 - 65 .

(12)

2/Hz # $B 7" 1 25 9P 6> !

$89I/- Z / /- .

;/> /=

;/=

/! &/

# 2! /,? + I L! # "# + G# ` ;= 2H$' 6> ! &I< 0X % W T - 4<

&' % # &' B #$S G g % ( ! !

;!

lm 5 + ,', # - C H ( ,-

2! /,? /-

$89I- 3/,? €L! b ;= 4< & > ! 2 \B &8 K7b ;<

2/!

$/88<

) 28, /! 2i /7b 7b

@ 1370 @ d 239

.(

2H$'/ ;_'j# ;< $ ># 2:> ! W T & ;< <{ ;= WGm ;97"

$ C$g? = # ? ;=

. C H = 6> ! & +# _ ;I/ W T -

2 \/B T $/ $` ;/< 2/0< 3/5 c/ ‚ = ;< &

) Judicial Review

C$/'! (

2!

@ D W /T /' &/ ;= # 'H 2! B 2 \B 6> ! + T ! g % + ,',

( $ # g/D A /,? $/8 ! /"# / 0,? # ;9 H B • ! $S # 2i \B 2! R IF! 2" ,:!

C H 9 g # D 2- P T $ $` 3= B 9IH ? -

//

)

@ //

1383 d@

73 Abraham,1998,p289#

(.

C //H + //T &//

//? //- //=

H C + /5 & /'8= Z /*S &',\/ # ( /B /',< S &',\/ E$- = -

2!

'H

)

@2? G 1378 @ 21 Wade, 2004, p22#

.(

2H$' 2 '" ! 2" ? D 20 D

+ '- f % ;=

( /8? ;/= 2 /'" ! EO9P 3S -

25 9P 2:> ! 2 \B ;7D

2! #$5 # 2H$' ;= W $B

$ , .

@;/_'j# &/ !

D 2= 6> ! c /P )/D < 2! , ej ! # "# C$8 , ; 0= I' E b

= < ;= "# 6_ ;= 3'" 3' F = .

;< 2"

[ 7 ;/ Xu ;/ 8 ] Y! D ;_'j# & = 2/! 6/> ! c/

$/

^ ? E b V' P ;< 2" S $D = P 0,? 2J B

;7/D 25 /9P 6> ! ;= # ? EO9P 3S # 2 Cz # < ( n 2 \B 2 b 2= 35 = )

v'- 2, t<

2/J B / 6/_8 { (% /P ;/< ! $

$D =

1( I' 6,> 3= B .

2" ? D K/S # / 4/< 2 /'" ! ( !G / G 2:= 2 '" !

2! ;9P ( !G q (% f \? ;,SV"

D . ( !G / q/ 2 /'" ! 2" ? D f \?

&'': 2 '" ! 2!

2= ! $89I' AV? 3= B A ,:! b ;= ;< $8u - $ D 3! 3F! ( % 2 b

.

&

[ 7

& ;> " > Q J ! + /'- f % ;= 7I D 'SO5 ;<

/-

$ - ! 2H$' KS D # 20 D 'SO5 g8 2 '" ! EO9P 3S )

C /!

256

+ '" ! ( B a'*9I! -

(.

1.(nemo judex in causa sua)

(13)

2 - 3 . , - ./ 9 : *

2! 2 '" ! ! C L!

- 2/:YB † „O/= G C ! c E j $8 3/S +Œ/'

# &' B ? W$? 89 ;= @2 '" ! EO9P 2H$'/ •/* ;? J ! + *!

WO/? /=

/ P 2H$'/ $/ $` # † ‡/* # /D 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;= 2 < 3 m

$88<

1 . L! E b G C H - 3S +Œ'- 2:YB † G *! $? ! 29 D 2 '" ! ! C

3 m ;! B = (% &,J ;< D 35 # 2 '" ! EO9P / l 9S /5 ˆ $/! # 8/ ;/i #

* ? l F 0

‡ /* /? ;? J ! + *! # &' B

•

$/D = C$/D 2H$'/

/i t'

2 '" ! 2" ? D

$- P Q > [ = ! :D G 2 ;= 2H$' g> D

<

.

ej ! =V! ;7:D

! '- ! ;= # # (#$=

0 Y : ': Z )* + [ 8 2

7 ( "

3 < 7 ' 7 \ < # 5 6 X 0

Q /J ! ;/=

;= l $89I! # 2H$' +Œ'- f % ‡* = 2\9*! † 2 B 3 m # R 7 # + g>

3S -

5 =V! D # 2 '" ! EO9P [ /8! U< = ;7:D † @$ ,

# / /79?

T H $'B † &9! $ = '0B

2 .

2! ‡* ;7:D E b G D ! † ;< ! 2H$'/ g> ! C$ # H

X 2 '" ! EO9P 3S +Œ'- ;= $`!

c/ 3F! (% ;< 2 5 # $D $- P Q >

- ;= $D 7 94'= +Œ'- c V 2 '" ! EO9P 3S +Œ'

/=V! 3/F! /= ;/< g/D & /

c C #$F!

2! Q > $D = ( 9 D

.

$/`! /=V! 6> ! /= EO9/P /! Q /J ! ;/= l

† # 2H$' 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;7:D T ?

2! 5

$ , . ' & $= ;< 2 †

2! 5

WGm # 2:YB D

>m .

"

2! 5 + 5 & $= ;< 2 ;= 7I D ;97 $/8= K7b V' D

2 C /!

13 ( /B

" $? (

R !

1385 " $? ( 'SO5 .

3 . , - ./ ; - , ) . <= 4

2! K*F! 29B# ( B ',< S C X9 ;< ` % $8 9= W ! ;< D

( B EOP =

2= # 3*9I! 6> ! ;= $8< 2! 3,?

$88< Q > P KS Z *S g> 2 b .

;!Gm /',< S

1 . C ! 251 + '" ! ( B a'*9I! -

.

2 . C ! 256 + '" ! ( B a'*9I! -

.

(14)

C H # 6> ! ># ( B

;< 2 - 'SO5

;= 2H$'

+ D

ND G d

!G -(

$8D = ;9D 2 > # - .

( B ',< S 2:> ! &'8u ># (#$=

$B ,/J

>

C = D $- N 2! g_! #

)

@28, ! 2i 7b 7b 1375

@ 48

.(

;'i \/B C B ;= 29"# ( ! ! # "# ;'0? W ! # ? +# \B # 2 d 9P

# W /T? f /'7 Cz/ # (% $ / ;/< / WO f \B 'YP ! = a< S A 5 = 2897!

f '5#

. j# f \B WO $<L! W S K7b # / q 4/" 6! /> & $/g9`! 2? D ;_'

/ C /'7< C /8H # /YP $89I' WGm q D $> # ;< 2 I< q 2g" ! & A o9D @

/ WO W S ƒ 5 e" N! ; `! C B ;= ag! & ‡ _ ;`'9

)

@2j _F" $/5 1372

@ 55

.(

B 2!O g,> f \B ! = ;Y= 2 ( A$/? ;/ = 2i \B a9I' `

/= # / C$/D 2/8'= )'/ 2/8 K'B q= J ;= 8D% # A ? + \B G 3 49! # 2!O f \/B /! 2 ( B e09N! A 5 87! = # C$ H $'< 2 \B a9I' AO*9 C H # ;'i \B C B 25 9P 'SO5 / 9IH -

.1

3/5 K/7b 156

/B (

2H$' 2 a S #$5 #

+ ,0T !

+ $: @

+ D @

3S @ 3 / # # /?

#

+ ! P 6

;'i \B C B C$g? =

@

;/0,> &! 25 9P 6> ! ; 8 ;= ;> =

2/! 2i \/B 'SO5 $B # $ B ;'i \B C B G k P 2 '" ! 2" ? D $/ = $8/D =

2:> ! $/D = ;9D ># 6> ! & f % G W ! + D ;= 2H$' = 2 \B

)

@ /7`

1382 @ 121 ( .

29"# D ;I 4< ;< D ;> ;9 & ;= $ = V' 2*'7Y Z *S T8! G C H f % G 2- P W > 6> ! G 2 /'" ! + / O9P 3 / # 3/S ;/< / /-

+ '9P C H &

+ ,', / ;/= 7I/ 2- /P W /> K/S 2 /'" ! ( / L! # / -

C H $ 29"# D V -

)

@ C G 2i J 1384 @ 84

# 137

.(

1 .

;!$*!

:

2 ( B \B

: 2!O < S qP W ! Z *S G $ = ;Y= \B ;" I!

@ G 'X4' T8! ;=

! 2!O ! (# 2:J ! + F

2 'S

@ G 3 49! # 2!O A$? ; = 2i \B a9I' ` # & G

C$D 28'= )' 28 K'B q= J ;= 8D% # A ? + \B

@ (% ( = 279 ! B # '8= ' IS 3'" ;= W T &

$D = a" + 7 8! # ;Y= Q - G # ;= WGm )

( ‚ 8" &'= a9, S { # A$:" = , F

( .

35 57 : B a< S 2!O g,>

( G $8 7?

: C B

;88*!

C B @

; `!

C B #

;' \B

;<

m# T G

;*0Y!

# !

! !

! K7b = A 5 C$8 %

&

( B A ,?

2!

$ H .

&

3*9I! B

$ X $ G .

35 156 : C B

\B

;' C B 3*9I!

;<

( 7'94 Z *S 2? ,9> #

I! #

~ A K*F ($'4N=

;=

" $?

C$g? #

e j#

G : 1 - 2H$' a S #$5 # + ,0T !

+ $: @

+ D @

3S @ 3 # # ? + ! P 6 #

a', P # W $B #

WGm (%

,IB

;'7IS ! G

;< @ ( B

&':!

2!

$8<

.

35 159 : 2, 6> ! + ,0T

+ D #

9IH @ .

3' 4 C H

&'': # - 'SO5

;= [ 8! g % a S

( B

.

(15)

&'8M,- ( 'I',< + ,', ( 9I0X

W /! A ! ;< '€ ;= ;> = 2 '" ! -

2 8'9 2H$' 3= B C H

9IH -

)

@W P 1345 d @ 53 (.

W T C$D ;9 A 5 G 2 '" ! 6> ! f % G 2i \B T $ $` KS 35 CG# ! /-

e09N! 2B *S

)

@ D

1383 d @ 25

;< u(

- 2 2H$'/ 6/> ! 2 /'" !

'" ! A 5# A ~I! # "# C$8 , ; 0= I' E b 2=

/ e/j ! & = 8= +

2! _ c ; Xu ; % A S # = < ;= 3'" 3' F = P )D < ;,- $/

^$ , 5 a S P ;'0? # $8'48= \B $8I! = a- # $D = ? E b a- $S # (%

# 6/> ! ( /B /',< S 3/5 /> &',\ " $? ( t' G E$- C X9 6/> ! G C /5 f % = + T # - 25 /9P

2 \/B ;7/D /

.

l F /5 C$/88< /5 6> ! % ;< ! & ;= 2H$' 3! D ( < & = 8=

/

C ,8 a', { N # W $B @2H$' = *! + 7' # + *! # &' B e" N! 8,J

$D = .

&'8M,- ( /B /*! = K7Y8! # ƒ'F5 89 $? B G =V! 6> ! [ 789

/H

^; C =

)

@ g0<

1378

@ d (117

.

+ /T ( ;_'j#

2 \/B k# /P G 'H /0> # (% + $/B /g! # ;/ `! C /B /=

20? # ( B #$S G 2 > -$S # D ;0,> G ; `! C B G g - A 5m

\? ;< 2 '" ! 2" ?

% 2! &'': 2i # 9B ! G# ( + /T /F $/ = $/8<

2 \B

$D = " $? ( .

/ 'SO/5 2 /'" ! 2" ? D + '9P # e j# ;= ;> =

" $/? (

2! a'I* ;9 # ;= D + ,', = ;Y=

D :

1 – '#>

-. 9

$8= > ! ;=

1 C ! 19 R /! " $/? ( / ( /B 1385

( / 2! /,? + /'- @

;! &' % G 2B *S # 2*'*S d ND + ,0T # + D ;= 2H$' 'SO5 + /! T # -

( B = g % + o! 89 ;= 29"#

. + /'- f % @ " $/? ( / 2! ,? + '-

2! ,?

2" /? /D :/D /= + /'- (% f % ;< Am$9 & = 2 '" ! 2" ? D + '- # 2 '" ! Q /7 m WGm + /'" ! A /5# # •'N4/ & ! /! # 2 '" ! EO9P 3S -

;! W T '- ! C$8- ( 4 V' ! &',- # C /! A ,4/! @ / f % &

19 ( /B

(16)

! " $? ( R

1385 /B 2H$'/ /! - /! + /5 ;/= # C •'N4 @

2!

$-

1. 2 -

9 '#>

?0/

G 2 '" ! 2" ? D :D ; 8 ;= ;> = 2 \/B ;7D 25 9P 6> ! ;0,>

2! R IF!

‚ = $ D

$8=

2 C ! 13

" $? ( ( B + /J 9? ;/= 2H$'/

7I 2/! 20 /D 2H$' & ;< " $? ( C$g? = :D & f % ;=

$/D =

)

@2 = B 1371 @

(.557

'

$

( 2H

" $/?

+ /'- f % ;/= 7I/

$/8 ,- 2 /'" ! EO9/P 3/S /-

20 D f % & ;= 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2H$' .

,- ;! B = 2:8! v'- ( B ( /!V

$ ># Z 6> ! # - ? )

7`

@ 1382

@ d

(115

;/= ;/> /= /X / G #

K/7b $/ 2! p 9:! C$4 ;9 H T 290g! ( ;= ;:> ! = ( B ; 8 C ! 251 + '" ! ( B + '- 2:YB #$5 G t C ! c a'*9I! -

EO9P 3S -

'" ! ;Y= & D 'SO5 # $ , D 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;= f % & ;= 7I 2

( ,- / 20 /D $ H <{ ;< b .

/X / G

@ 2/! p /9:!

$/

( /!V,- f % G

+ '- 2 '" ! EO9P 3S - $8= K7b

2 C ! 13

" $? ( ( B

R !

1385

@

;=

(

V' ( 2H$' ;< $ , D

;Y= &

20 D .

( ! & p 9:! =

# $ , D 2 '" ! 2" ? D ;= $9= ;< ># V' 2 /'" ! 2" /? D H 29S

$ , D " $? ( ;= D G , 5 # ;'0? = .

[ 7 D 'SO5 = 2H$' 2 '" ! 2" ?

20 /D + /'- f % ;/=

3/S /-

A + SO5 G 37B 2 '" ! EO9P 80

+ '" ! ( B C ! K7b a'*9I! -

258 ( /B &/

WGm # 2:YB 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2! ,? + '- f % ;< = C$D ( '= # = C$D ;9P 8D Q 7 m

'" ! 2" ? D 2! ,? + '- 2

; R9 67 ]9

< 0^ 5 /''o 3= B

= $- N .

1 . C ,D f % 231 ;P ! 24 / 11 / 71

; O< C$ # 71 / 190

@ C ,D 124 ;P ! 10 / 7 / 72

; O< C$ # 71 / 191

@ C ,D

56 ;P ! 2 / 4 / 75

; O< C$ # 74 / 77

@ C ,D 51

;P ! 11 / 5 / 76

; O< C$ # 75 / 91 C ,D @ 360 ;P ! 26 / 7 / 83

; O< C$ # 82 / 697 .

(17)

20? ( !G ( ,- " $? ( 2_09N! f % @( B ƒ a1

A /Y= ;= W $B 1

2 '" ! 2" ? D 2! ,? + '- f % 2!

<

.

! ;/= V/> 2 /'" ! 2" /? D 2! ,? + '- f % ( = ''o 3= B '1 ‹F=

/T />

+ '" ! ( B + SO5 ( B 2! ,? +Œ'- A a'*9I! -

1380

$/ H E S #

C ! 258

<{

$D :/D /= / 2:YB \? W , % W # = ;< 2! ,? + '-

+ '- # 2 '" ! 2" ? D 2 '" ! EO9P 3S -

Q 7 m WGm ;= 4! ! .

ag! G 2 + g'> &

t' Œ 25 /9P 6/> ! 2 \/B ;7/D

C /B (#

! 3,? ? # + f \9B ; `!

. X G

@ /- ':! G 2

'SO/5 &9 /H /T ; % A S 2 $8 ( = 2 m b W$? ; _ 8! 2

! 2" ? D = G ! + 5 ;= 20 D ($D 2 m b > ! " $? ( # 2 '"

C$D Z A 5 ‡* ;`'9 # 2H$' ;># O=

.

; # " $? 2 87! - ':! G v'- ;< ! &

2, t<

P 0,? 2J B $

$D = . 2= # AO* 35 & K7b ; _ /8! 2/ c/ WG " G C$88< 2H$' 6> ! 2 b

2! T ;= ! & ;= ;> =

" $/? ( / 20 D 2H$' 'SO5 ># $

+ '- f % ;=

2! _< 2 '" ! EO9P 3S - /D q/ < & W ` ;= G ' # $8<

$- P 2H$' 6 I ‹? = D 'SO5 ;Y'S G ! & E S # I' 2 '" ! 2" ?

$D .

& ,! ;< $8u - /># 2 /'" ! 2/ G T $ $` ;0S ! E S = @ D ;9_H

+ '- f % ;= 20 D 2H$' 'SO5 ;/u /- &',\/ 9 2 '" ! EO9P 3S -

;/> $/ = @ / Z / •/* 6/ g> 20! ? # ( L! Z *S 94'=

/<

;/<

2 / 8D

20 D 2H$' 'SO5

q

" $? ( ;<

/= 2 \/B + T K*F 9

2! + 5 C 2! &'!Œ Z E$- 'H

$/ , .

;/0S ! c/ ;/97"

2H$'/ ( /=

2 '" ! 2 6> ! )

/D q 20 D 2H$' 'SO5 ># &9D T = 29S

" $? ( # 2 '" ! 2" ? (

;0S ! # 35 = o! !

$' ( =

2H

)

@ =% /8!

1384 @ 62

2! (

$D = .

@ $ - 9 ( /,- = 2 '" ! 2" ? D +O' 4 # 9P 2 = Z 9D G E$- ;/< ;/ H

$ H &''7 'SO5 2 '" ! 2" ? D

2 H H e j# # - :

2 / G D

1 . C ,D f % 231 ;P ! 24 / 11 / 71

;/ O< C$/ # 71

/ 190

@ C ,/D 124 ;/P ! 10 / 7 / 72

;/ O< C$/ # 71

/ 191

@

C ,D 56 P !

; 2 / 4 / 75

; O< C$ # 74 / 77

@ C ,D 51

;P ! 11 / 5 / 76

; O< C$ # 75 / 91 .

(18)

G # 4< 2 '" ! ( !G 2 N 2 4! #G = 2H$'/ 6> ! X

20 /D

+ '- 2:YB f % ;=

2 '" ! EO9P 3S - .

[ 7 , ( '= D IN 'SO5 = /># ! ($D 2 N ;= ;> = ;< a

# A$9I/! ‹/? = # / / 8! /! 4/< 2 '" ! ( !G (# 2 4! g &'8u + ,', ($D $89I!

( !G 4/< 2 '" !

$/D $/- P .

/D 'SO/5 /= ;/Y=

2H$' 20 D + '- 2:YB f % ;=

( '= V' 2 '" ! EO9P 3S -

$ H 'SO/5 & ;<

2X' " $? ( 'SO5 = G ! D G + /D ;=

+ /'- f % 3/S /-

o! ! & ;< 2 '" ! EO9P W$? 35 =

;" b W$?

2 /! ? 35 #

2! T ;= # ;/= ;/> /= 2 /'" ! 2" /? D = 29'SO5 &'8u ># $

# 2/ ;/" b ‹/? = # $D = ;># G 2" P ;Y= & ( 'SO5 ;/`'9

‡/*

2" /? /D 'SO/5 G /! &/ E /S # $/D = 25 9P 6> ! ` p 1

!

$D $- P 2 '" ! + O9P ;= 2H$' 6 I ‹? = 2 '"

.

A%B C; D -

1 .

@$,F! @2! ! )

1384 D(

* 0 "

@ ( V'! 4 @( g .

2 .

@• 2"# @ ) 1383 (

+ # 0 "@

D# ; Z )*

@ @\

@( g 4 a`8 Ž u @( V'!

.

3 .

@&'IS @ ' ' )

1348 (

@ 0 * D 6 * 5

69 7

@ 8' &= @( g .

4 .

@20? @W P ) 1345 D(

D A '*

@ 20! c = ; N u .

5 .

@ >$,F! @C G 2i J )

1384 ( D

= ' .2 6A 8 # _" )

# # 67 ;I/ ! @( /g @

C &':!

.

6 .

@3\/_" = @ 7`

) 1382 (

@ : 6 * * + /'" ! ( /B ;,',/J ;/= @

a'*9I/! /- -

R /!

1366 #

(% $:= + SO5 –

27 / 11 / 80

$`! @ .

7 .

•&'IS $,F! @2? G

@\ # )

6A 8 A # 6A

@(

$/S # ( g 2!O G% C X4

20' F A @2 ' W 0? # Z *S 20', +O' F V< ! @V< ! –79

78 .

8 .

• 8? @( D

@

0 * `!Q 'A 7

2= @ 2= @ .

9 .

@&'IS @ D )

1383 (

@

* 3 = 0C )

;! ( @

$D 2 8D <

C$ 4/ @294/g= $'g/D C X4 @

Z *S .

10 .

@• $,S @( G 7gD )

1373 ( 0 * 1 )

+ _ A # 5

1345 +

@$/D 2/ 8D < ;! ( @ C X4/

2 ' W 0?# Z *S C$ 4 @( g .

11 .

@• @2j _F" $5 )

1372 (

@

# '* '* 1 7 F G< 0 ; gD @( g @

.

12 .

@ gu 8! @28, ! 2i 7b 7b )

1370 (

@

# +=

7 # 5

( g C X4 @ .

13 .

@ gu 8! @28, ! 2i 7b 7b )

1378 (

@

#

# ;:" Y! ( !G @ C X4 2 I W 0? 9< & #$

- ) , (.

(19)

14 .

@a *" = @28'IF" $7?

) 1376 (

@

* 0 8. / 67 3 F=

;! ( @

$D 2 8D <

C$ 4 @( g C X4 @

# Z *S 2 ' W 0?

.

15 .

$' B @$,F! @2,b )

1382 (

@ 2 4 9 7 @ I/ 2 < ! # ƒ05 @ 4= Z *S 2 < @( g @

$'gD C X4 294g=

.

16 .

@;" k @2 = B )

1371 (

@

# '* 0 I = 6 $

# '* <

2 # @ .

17 .

@ > @ g0<

) 1378 (

@ 1 7 G< 0 ; '*

;! ( @

$D 2 8D <

C$ 4 @294g= $'gD C X4 @ Z *S

.

18 . 8!

=%

@

‚ 7?

@ ) 1384 (

"@

; $ J

6 C ! = 8

"

@ )

;0`!

;4 $ 2B *S -

@ C ,D 8 .

19 . 2 !

@ J @C G ) 1377 (

@

# 1 D2 0 "

4 @ ( V'!

.

20 .

@$'`! @2 9 )

1335 (

@ F f 2= @( g @

.

E - 7 %

1. Abraham, Henry Julian, (1998); an introductory analysis of the courts of the United States, England, and France, New York, Oxford University Press , seventh edition. 2. Wade (H. W. R.) Henry William Rawson, (2004); Administrative law, New York, Oxford

University Press, ninth Ed.

>

? " @ % A !B @9> +C $ < ( &9 A9 :

» - B 2Hz #

« A @ 1387 C ,D @ 2 .

» 2 N EO9P 3S - D 2 = # $*

C = 2 \B + T 2 7! = $'<Œ = " $? (

«.

A 1387 C ,D @ 4 .