HOAN THIEN PHAP LUAT VE CONG KHAI, MINH BACH, KHACH QUAN TRONG TUYEN DUNG CONG
C H Q C ,VIEN
C H Q C0 VIET,
ThS TRAN THI T H a r i
Tdm tit: Bii viet phin tich thUc tr$ng quy dinh vi td chdc thdc hien quy dinh phap luat ve cdng khai, minh bach, khich quan trong tuyen dung; di xui't mot sd kii'n nghj nham dim bio cdng khai, minh b^ch, khach quan trong tuyen dung cdng chdc, vien chdc thdi gian tdi.
Tdkhda: Cdng chdc, vien chdc; cdng khai, minh bach, khich quan; tuyen dung; thdc hien phap luat.
Abstract: This paper analyzes current situation of regulations and the implementation of legal regulations on publicity, transparency, and objectivity in the employment process, and propose a number of solutions to ensure the publicity, transparency, and objectivity in the employment of civil servants and officials in the upcoming time.
Keywords: Civil sen/ants, officials; publicity, transparency and objectivity; employment; enforce- ment of legal regulations.
Ngiy nhan bai: 16/3/2020 Ngay biin tip: 25/3/2020 Ngiy duyit ding: 15/4/2020 1. Quy djnh phap luat ve d i m bio cdng
khai, minh bgch, khach quan trong tuyen dung cong chUc, vlen chUc d Viet Nam
1.1. Trong tuyin dgng cdng chdc Luat can bp, edng chQe nam 2008 da quy djnh ve cae nguyen tae d i m bao eong khai, minh bgch, khaeh quan trong tuyen dyng cdng chQc. Cae van ban hQdng d i n thi hanh Luat can bd, edng chQc lien quan den npi dung nay bao gdm: Nghj djnh sd24/2010/ND- CP; Nghj djnh sd 93/2010/ND-CP sQa ddi, bd sung mot sd dieu cua Nghj djnh sd 24/2010/
ND-CP; Nghj dinh sd 36/2013/ND-CP ve vi tri vide lam va ed eau nggch c6ng chQc; Nghj djnhsd 161/2018/ND-CP sQa ddi, bd sung mot sd quy djnh ve tuyen dyng CCVC, nang nggch c6ng chQc, thang hgng vien chQc; Thdng tQ sd 13/2010/TT-BNV eua Bp Npi vy quy djnh ehi tiet mot sd dieu ve tuyen dgng va nang nggch edng ehQc; Thdng tQ sd 09/2012/TT- BNV eQa Bp Npi vg quy djnh ve quy trinh, npi dung thanh tra ve tuyIn dyng, sQ dgng va quan ly CCVC; Thdng t g s d 03/2019/TT-BNV cua Bp Npi vy sQa ddi, bd sung mot sd quy djnh ve tuyen dyng CCVC, nang nggch c6ng ehQc, thang hgng chQe danh nghe nghiep vien
(*) Vign Khoa hgc to chdc nhi nudc, Bg Ngi vg
ehQc va thge hien che d6 hpp ddng mot sd loai e6ng viec trong cd quan hanh chinh nha nude, ddn vj sg nghiep cdng lap;...
NhQng npi dung cu the nham b i o dam cdng khai, minh bgch, khaeh quan trong tuyIn dung c6ng chQc bao gdm:
Mdt li, can cd, diiu kien, thim quyin tuySn dung cdng chdc.
- Viec tuyen dyng c6ng chQc phii can cQ vao yeu cau nhiem vy, vj tri viee iam va chi tieu bien che cua cd quan sQ dyng edng ChQc. Hang nam, ed quan sQ dgng cdng chQc xay dgng ke hogch tuyIn dgng, bao cao cd quan quan ly c6ng chQe d l phe duyet va td ehQc tuyen dgng.
- Quy djnh ve viee b i o d i m cong khai, minh bach, khaeh quan va dQng phap luat;
b i o d i m canh tranh; tuyen chpn dung ngudi dap Qng yeu eau nhiem vg va vj trf viee lam;
Qu tien tuyen chpn ngQdi co tai nang, nggdi ed cdng vdi nQdc, ngQdi dan tpc thieu sd.
- Quy djnh ve ed quan nha nQdc d cap trung Qdng va dja phQdng ed tham quyen tuyIn dung edng chQc; ve phan cap tuyen dung cong chQc, ehi tieu bien che, kinh phf, ve sQ dgng eon da'u va tai kholn.
Hai la, trinh td, thu tuc tuyen dung cong chdc.
Tren ed s6 ke hogch tuyen dyng, cd quan To chuc nha nuoc so 4/3020
eo tham quyen tuyen dyng cdng chQc phii thong bao cdng khai ft nha't 01 lan tren bao viet, bao ndi, bao hinh; ddng thdi phii dang tren trang thdng tin dien tQ va niem yet cdng khai tgi trg sd lam viec cQa ed quan cd tham quyen tuyen dung trong thdi han nhan ho sd dang ky dQ tuyen. Ndi dung thdng bao tuyen dgng dUde phap luat hien hanh quy djnh rat cu the, chi tiet Cae quy dinh ve trinh tU, thu tye tuyen dyng cdng khai nhU: lap danh saeh ngudi cd du dieu kien dg tuyen va mem yet cdng khai tgi try s6; td ehQc tuyen dyng cdng ChQc; thdng bao ket q u i tuyen dung cdng chQe... dupe quy dinh ey the tQ Dieu 15 den Didu 18, Nghj djnh sd 161/2018/ND-CP. Viec td ehQc thi tuyen, xet tuyen eong chQc dupe quy dinh tai khoan 2, Dieu 4, Thong tU sd 03/2019n"T-BNV.
1.2. Trong tuyen dung vien chdc Cae quy djnh cua phap luat ve edng khai, minh bgch, khach quan trong tuyen dyng vien chQc dQpc quy dinh tai Luat Vien chQc va cac van ban hQdng d i n thi hanh nhg: Nghj djnh sd 29/2012/ND-CP ve tuyen dyng, sQ dyng va quin ly vien chQe; Nghj djnh sd 27/2012/
ND-CP quy dinh xQ ly kj- luat vien chQc va trach nhiem bdi thQdng, hoan t r i cua vien ehQc; Nghj dinh sd 41/2012/ND-CP quy djnh ve vj tri viee lam trong ddn vi sg nghiep eong lap; Nghj djnh sd 161/2018/ND-CP; Thong tg sd 15/2012/TT-BNV cua Bp Npi vg hQdng d i n ve tuyIn dyng, ky ket hpp ddng lam viee va den bu chi phf dao tao, boi dudng ddi vdi vien ChQc (dQdc sQa ddi, bd sung bdi Thdng tusd 04/2015/TT-BNV); Thdng tgsd 03/2019/
TT-BNV eua Bp Npi vu sQa doi, bo sung mot sd quy djnh ve tuyen dyng CCVC, nang ngach cdng chQe, thang hang ehQc danh nghe nghiep vien chQc va thQc hien che dp hpp ddng mot sd logi c6ng viec trong eP quan hanh ehfnh nha nQdc, ddn vj sQ nghiep cdng lap...
Phap luat vien ehQc da quy dinh kha cg t h i , chi tiet, minh bach ve dieu kien, tieu chuan dang ky dU tuyen vien chQc; ve viec tuyen dgng vien ehQc th6ng qua thi tuyIn hoac xet tuyen; ve phan cap tuydn dyng va tham quyen ky ket hdp ddng lam viec vdi ngQdi trung tuyen vao vien chQc. Trinh tg, thu tye tuyen dyng vien chQe dupe quy dmh
cdng khai thdng tin tgi Nghj djnh sd 29/
2012/ND-CP va Nghj djnh sd 181/2018/N0-CP sQa ddi: thdng bao tuyen dyng va tiep nhan Phieu dang ky dg tuyIn vien chQe; td chQc tuyen dung; th6ng bao ket q u i tuyen dgng vien chQc...
1.3. Uu diem va h$n chd trong quy djnh ve dam bao cong khai, minh bach, khach quan trong tuyen dgng cdng chdc, vien chdc
a) Uu diem
Phap luat hien hanh ve cd ban da khac phye dQdc hgn ehe va d i m b i o cdng khai, minh bach, khach quan trong tuyen dyng CCVC theo yeu cau mdi. Da the hien tfnh nha't quan, tinh than doi mdi theo ndi dung cua Luat can bd, cdng ehQc nam 2008 va Luat Vien chQe nam 2010, bao gom: ve nguyen tac tuyen dyng; ve tieu chuan, dieu kien; ve phQdng thQc tuyen dung va quy trinh, trinh tU tien hanh; ve nang cao chat IQdng tuyIn dgng;
ve gu tien trong tuyIn dgng; ve tham quyen tuyIn dgng.
Nghj dinh sd 161/2018/ND-CP da sQa ddi, bd sung 19 npi dung eua Nghi djnh sd 24/
2010/ND-CP; 20 ndi dung cua Nghj djnh sd 29/2012/ND-CP va 5 npi dung eua Nghj dinh sd 68/2000/ND-CP ve thge hien ehe dp hpp ddng mdt sd loai eong viec trong cP quan hanh ehinh nha nude, ddn vj sQ nghiep. Do dd, ndi dung cua Nghj dmh sd 161/2018/
ND-CP da thao gd dupe eP ban nhQng vQdng mic ve dam bao cong khai, minh bgch, khach quan trong tuyen dgng CCVC, cy the nhQ:
- Da khic phue dQdc tinh trang "cue bd"
trong quy dinh ve xet tuyIn dgc each ddi vdi lao dpng hpp ddng du thdi gian "03 nam kinh nghiem... tai mot vj tri ddi vdi vien chQc" va
"05 nam kinh nghiem... tgi mot vi trf ddi vdi cong chQe" d l de nghj ed quan ed tham quyen xem xet, tuyIn dyng khong qua thi tuyln. Day la van de da tQng n i y sinh kha nhleu trdn thQc te, do cac cd quan, ddn vi sQ dyng CCVC
"dpi" eho nhQng ngQdi thgc hien che dp hpp ddng du dieu kien tham nien d l dupe xet dac each, lam Inh hudng den viec cgnh tranh va cd hpi tuyen dgng ddi vdi cae trQdng hdp khac (dae biet la ddi vdi cac sinh vien mdi ra trQdng, cac trQdng hpp chua du dieu kien ve thdi gian kinh nghiem trong ITnh vge cdng tae).
To chuc nha nuoc so 4/2020
5 Noi vu td chdc khai mac Ky thi tuyen dung cong chOc, ngay 10/5/2019.
Anh minh hoa.
- Viec quy djnh 2 vdng thi, trong dd vdng 1 dupe thgc hien tren may tinh da tgo dgpc su khach quan, minh bach trong edng tac tuyen dung.
Ngoai ra, viee quy djnh ve thdng bao tuyen dgng va tiep nhan Phieu dang ky dg tuyen tgi Thdng tU sd 03/2019n"T-BNV la eu the, rd rang, mpi cdng dan ed du dieu kien, tieu chuan deu cd ed hpi nhu nhau de dang ky va tham gia qua trinh iga chpn vao CCVC, khac phgc dupe tinh trang ed quan, ddn vi tuyen dgng tg dUa ra eac dieu kien, tieu chuan trai quy djnh hoac tim each loai bd hd sd cua nhQng thf sinh khdng than quen.
b) Han che
- Quy djnh ve tham quyen tuyen dyng vien chQe tai kholn 2, Dieu 5, Nghj djnh sd 29/2012/ND-CP ngay 12/4/2012 cdn kha chung ehung, khd quy trach nhiem cho ngudi dQng dau cd quan, ddn vj cd tham quyen tuyen dgng khi d l x i y ra tinh trang thieu cong khai, minh bgch, khach quan trong hoat dpng nay.
- Quy djnh cua Nghj djnh sd 161/2018/
ND-CP ve vdng 2 (thi mdn nghiep vu chuyen nganh) bang hinh thQc phdng van hoae thi viet v i n cdn bat cap d chd neu cd quan, ddn vj iga chpn hinh thQe thi la phdng van thi cd the khdng dam bao khach quan, minh bgch do khdng td chQc phuc tra, ghi am, ghi hinh;
rat khd d l thanh tra, kilm tra hoac phQc k h i o bai thi.
Nghi djnh sd 161/2018/
ND-CP quy djnh ve vdng 1, phan thi kien thQc chung bao gdm 60 cau hdi ve "he thd'ng ehfnh tri, td chQc bp may eua Dang, Nha nQdc, cac td chQe chfnh tri - xa hpi; quan ly hanh chinh nha nude; eong chQc, cdng vg; ehu trgpng, dgdng Idi cua Dang, chfnh saeh, phap luat cua Nha nUdc ve nganh, rrnh vge tuyen dyng; ChQc trach, nhiem vy eua cdng chQc theo yeu cau cua vj tri viec lam dg tuyln" la phu hpp. Song thgc te eho thay, mdt sd cd quan v i n ap dung he thdng tai lieu nhu quy dmh chU chUa xay dung danh muc tai lieu cg t h i de cdng khai eho tat c l thf sinh tham dg dupe biet va dn tap.
Nghj djnh sd 161/2018/ND-CP da'sQa ddi, bd sung mot sd quy dinh ve tuyen dung CCVC nhim ddn giln hda thu tyc hanh chinh, tang cQdng tinh cdng khai, minh bach, gan tham quyen tuyen dyng vdi tham quyen sQ dyng. Tuy nhien, quy djnh ca 2 vdng thi phan ca'p cho cae bo, nganh, dja phUdng la ehua hpp ly, bdi le cd nhQng dot tuyen dung chi cd 30 den 40 thi sinh, nhQng quy trinh, thu tgc, thdi gian co khi phai keo dai den vai thang.
Ben canh dd, do ky thi ed quy mo phan tan nhd le nen d i n den han ehe trong viec kilm scat va dam bio tinh minh bach, khach quan.
- Dilm c, kholn 5, Dieu 3 cua Quy che td ChQc thi tuyen CCVC, thi nang ngaeh cdng ehQc, thi thang hang chQc danh nghe nghiep vien chQe ban hanh kem theo Thdng tQ sd 03/2019/TT-BNV cua Bp Ndi vy quy djnh
"Ngudi dQdc cQ lam thanh vien Ban de thi khdng dQdc tham gia lam thanh vien Ban coi thi". Tuy nhien, do quy dinh cd 02 vdng thi nen hien nay cdn thieu quy djnh ngupe lai, nghTa la thanh vien Ban coi thi (d vdng 1) v i n ed t h i dupe lam thanh vien Ban de thi (d vdng 2).
- Khoan 7, Dieu 3 eua Quy ehe (ban hanh kem theo Thdng tU sd 03/2019/TT-BNV) quy djnh: "Cac thanh vien tham gia lam de thi deu phai each ly vdi ben ngoai tQ thdi diem tap trung lam de thi eho den khi ket thuc mdn thi To chuc nha nuoc so 4/2020
do". Tuy nhien, ndi dung nay Igi khdng dQpc de cap den trong hoat dpng giam sat hoae thanh tra ve tuyln dyng, sQ dyng va quan ly CCVC tai Thdng tU sd 09/2012/TT-BNV. Do vay, tren thgc td nhieu ed quan, ddn vi khdng thgc hien viec each ly eae thanh vien tham gia lam de thi tuyln CCVC.
Kholn 1 Dieu 12 cua Thdng tQ sd 03/
2019/TT-BNV quy dinh v l each thQc td chQe thi trie nghiem tgi vdng 1: "Sau khi ket thuc phan thi nao thJ mdi tiep tye td chQe phin thi ke tiep" la nham d i m b i o khach quan, edng bang hdn cho cae thf sinh dg thi; tuy nhien, neu ap dyng dieu nay cho phan thi trie nghiem tren may la chua thge sg phu hdp ddi vdi ed quan, ddn vi td chQc tuyen dyng theo he thdng nganh dpe (thue, ngan hang, kho bac...).
2. ThQc trang thQc hien phap luit ve d i m bio cong khai, minh bgch, khach quan trong tuyen dung cong chQc, viin chUc
Tren cd sd Luat can bd, cdng chQe, Luat Vien ChQc va cae van ban hQdng d i n thi hanh, cae bp, nganh, dja phgong da xay dgng ke hoach cg the, b i o dam cong khai, minh bgch, khaeh quan trong quy trinh td ehQc thi tuyln hoac xet tuyen theo quy djnh. Viec td ehQc thi tuyen, xet tuyln CCVC da tQng bUde di vao ne nep va dUde td chQe thudng xuyen d cae bp, nganh, dja phuong. Viec phan cap tham quyen tuyln dgng CCVC da dgpe tiep tye thuc hien va day manh, tQng bQde thge hien nguyen tac gan tham quyen tuyen dgng vdi tham quyen sQ dgng, tao tien de thuan Ipi cho viee td chQe tuyln dgng CCVC g i n vdi vj tri viec lam.
Bp Ndi vg da ehu ddng nghien cQu, di dau trong viec ddi mdi, ap dgng cdng nghe th6ng tin trong tuyen dyng CCVC thdng qua phan mem td chQc thi tuyen tren may tfnh. Nam 2019, Bp Npi vy la cd quan d i u tien td ehQc tuyen dyng edng chQc vao eae ed quan thupc va true thude theo Nghj djnh sd 161/2018/
ND-CP (vdng 1 bang hinh thQc trac nghiem tren may tinh va vdng 2 bang hinh thQc phdng van). TQ nam 2019 den nay, mot sobp, nganh, dja phUPng da td chQc tuyln dyng CCVC theo quy djnh mdi thanh cdng nhQ: Bd Ke hogch va D i u tu, Bd Giao thdng van t i l , thanh phd Ha Npi, eac tinh Thanh Hda, Dak L i k , D i k Ndng, Yen Bai...
Tuy nhien, trong qua trinh thuc hian v i n edn tinh trang khdng cong khai, lam dgng yeu cau bao mat thdng tin d l kh6ng e6ng khai hoac cd cdng khai nhUng ndi dung khong cg t h i , thidu minh bach, c6ng khai trong phgm vi hep, cham cong khai theo quy dinh cua phap luat. Trong qua trinh td ehQc tuyen dung, mot sd bp, nganh, dja phQdng da chip hanh khong nghi§m, tham chf cd nhQng vi phgm nghiem trpng nhQ: can thiep lam 16 de thi; khdng xay dgng va phe duyet ke hoach tuyln dyng trQdc khi tien hanh tuyen dung; xay dQng de thi, dap an thi khdng cd thang diem ehi tiet; thdng bao thi tuyln, nhan hd sd dg tuyen khdng dung quy djnh; thanh lap hpi ddng thi tuyen, xet tuyen kh6ng dung quy djnh; khdng to chQc giam sat ky thi..."'
Ben canh dd, theo edng bd ve Chi sd hiau q u i quin tri va hanh ehfnh cdng d p tinh d Viet Nam (PAPI) 2016-2018, sd lieu dilu tra ddi vdi 14.000 ngudi dan tai 63 tinh, thanh phd trQc thude Trung Udng eho thay, cd 54%
sd ngudi dan dupe hdi cho rang can phai dUa
"hdi Id" mdi xin dupe viee lam trong khu vQc nha nudc, cao hdn tile 5 1 % cua nam 2015 va 46% cua nam 2011'^'.
3. Mot sd de xuat, kien nghj nham dim bio cong khai, minh bach, khach quan trong tuyen dung cong chUc, vien chUc thdi gian tS Mdt li, Luat can bd, edng chQc, Luat Vien chQe (sQa doi, bd sung) va eac van ban hudng d i n thi hanh can eu the, chi tiet hdn, giam bdt sd IQpng van b i n . Bao dam hdn nQa tinh ddng bd, thdng nhat giQa quy djnh cija Nha nudc vdi quy djnh cQa Ding; tfnh thdng nha't, fien thdng vdi quy djnh v l xQ ly k$' luat, danh gia CCVC; vdi quy dinh eua Luat phdng, chdng tham nhung, Luat td chQe Chfnh phu, Luat to chQc chinh quyen dja phQPng va eac van ban quy pham phap luat ed lien quan.
Hai li, phap luat da quy djnh can cQ tuyln dgng CCVC la nhu eau edng viee, vj tri viec lam... Nhg vay, viee xac djnh ehQc danh, tieu chuan, vi tri viee lam va chi tieu biSn chd dupe giao dupe coi la van de cdt Idi d l tuyln dyng dung ngQdi, dQng viec. Do dd, can day manh viec hoan thien xac djnh vj tri viee lam, xay dung b i n md t l eong viec va khung nang igc cua tQng vj tri d l iam can cQ khoa hpe,
^
Td chuc nha nirdc sd 4/3020khaeh quan eho hogt ddng tuydn dung CCVC.
Tr§n cd sd dd, xay dQng he thdng ngan hang eae eau hdi cho e l phan thi trac nghidm va phdng van cua tQng vj tri vi§e lam, dae biet la cae vj tri viec lam ddi vdi cong chQc.
Ba la, quy dinh thdng nhit kiem djnh chat lupng dau vao CCVC ddi vdi cac mon kien thQc ehung, ngoai ngQ, tin hpc (vdng 1) trQdc khi cae cd quan, ddn vj cd tham quyen lua chpn, tuyln dung CCVC (vdng 2). Theo dd, sdm sQa ddi, bd sung quy dinh ve tham quyen tuyen dgng theo hQdng giQ nguyen thdm quyen tuyen dyng eua cac cd quan, ddn vj nhQ quy djnh trudc day; bd sung tham quyen ddi vdi to chQc dpc lap do Chinh phQ hoac Thu tudng Chfnh phu thanh lap thdng nhat kiem djnh chat IUdng dau vao eong chQc tren phgm vi e l nQdc.
Bdn la, sQa ddi, bd sung quy djnh vd tuyln dyng vdng 2, ndi dung thi mdn nghiep vy ehuy§n nganh tai ky thi tuyen edng ehQc theo hQdng thi viet hoae thi phdng van hoae ket hpp ca hai hinh thQc thi viet va thi phdng van nham kiem tra toan dien nang ige, trinh dp, ky nang cQa ngQdi tham gia dQ tuyen cdng chQe.
Ddi vdi phan thi phdng van, c i n ed quy djnh ghi am, ghi hinh va cho phep phue tra bai thi nham hgn che tinh trgng thieu minh bach, tgo can cQ cho viec thanh tra, kiem tra.
Nim li, de nang eao trach nhiem cua ngQdi dQng dau cd quan cap tren eua ddn vi sg nghiep edng lap trong tuyen dgng vien chQc, dae biet la ddi vdi cae ddn vj chQa dgpe giao quyen tg ehu, can quy djnh tham quyen td ehQc tuyln dung vien chQe eho ngQdi dQng dau ed quan ed tham quyen bo nhiem, miln nhiem ngQdi dQng dau ddn vj sQ nghiep cdng lap, thay vl giao tham quyen nay eho ngUdi dQng d i u ddn vj sQ nghiep edng lap nhU quy djnh hien nay.
Siu la, hoan thien Quy che td ehQc thi tuyln CCVC, thi nang ngach edng chQc, thi thang hgng ehQc danh nghe nghiep vien chQc theo hQdng quy djnh cg the hdn ve tidu chuan thanh vidn ban de thi, ban coi thi va each ly eac thanh vien tham gia lam de thi tuyen CCVC; quy djnh phu hdp hdn ddi vdi trinh tg phan thi trac nghiem vdng 1 tren may tinh. Ngoai ra, phai tach bach quy djnh vd xQ ly ket qua cham thi viet, thi trac nghiem
tren gia'y nham dam b i o quyen Idi cho thf sinh dQ thi, dae biet la vdi bai phQc tra trac nghiem khi ma diem sd can sat vdi dieu kien "dgt".
Bay la, tang cQdng cdng tae kiem tra, thanh tra, giam sat, ddng thdi cd cd ehe, chinh saeh thu hQt rpng rai va tao dieu kien d l cac chu the tham gia kiem soat viec thge hien eae d i m b i o ve edng khai, minh bach, khaeh quan trong tuyen dgng theo hQdng: tang CQdng vai trd eua cdng luan va bao chf trong viec phat hien vi phgm, danh gia thge hien eac quy djnh; cae cap chfnh quyen can hpc hdi kinh nghiem tQ nhQng dja phQdng dgpe danh gia cao hdn trong viec dam b i o edng khai, minh bach, khaeh quan trong tuyln dgng CCVC. Ben canh dd, can thgc hien nghiem quy dinh ve quyen khieu nai, to eao va quyen cua ngudi dan trong tiep can thdng tin va xQ ly nhQng hanh vi vi pham quy dinh ve tuyln dgng CCVC.
Tam la, tiep tgc nghien cQu, de xuat loai bd che djnh "ehe dp edng chQc sudt ddi"
nham cham dQt tinh trang nhQng ngQdi khdng du nang igc, trinh dp cd tim mpi each de dgpc tuyln dyng vao cac ed quan nha nQdc./.
Ghi chu:
(1) Cac bao cao kdt luan thanh tra cQa Thanh tra 86 Npi vy (giai doan tQ ngay 01/01/2016 ddn ngay 31/3/2019).
(2) CECODES, VFF-CRT&UNDP, Chi sd Hieu qua Quan tn va Hanh chinh cong cap tinh d Viet Nam (PAPI): Do IUdng td kinh nghiem thi/c tiin cua ngUdi dan (tU nam 2011 den nam 2018). Bao cao nghien cQu chfnh sach chung cua Trung tam Nghian cQu hd trP phat trien va Hd trd cong ddng (CECODES), Trung tam bdi dUdng can bd va nghign cQu khoa hoc Mat tran To qudc Viet Nam (VFF-CRT) va ChUPng trinh Phat trien Lien hPp qudc (UNDP). Ha Noi, Viet Nam.
Tai Mgu tham kh^o:
1. Hoang Mai, "Hoan thien quy dinh phip luat ve tuyen dung cdng chdc bao dam tinh thdng nhi't, khich quan, minh bach". Tap chf Qu^n ly nha nUdc, thang 12/2019.
Td chuc nha nudc sd 4/2020
