HERRINGS TO THROW PEOPLE OFF THE SCENT
If
atanypoint
in thedeception
youpractice people
have theslightest suspi-
eionastoyour
intentions,
allislost. Donotgive
them the chancetosensewhatyou are
up
to: Throw themoff
the seen!by dragging
mlherrings
across the
path.
Usefalse sincerity,
sendambiguous signals,
setup
mis—leading objects 0}’
desire. Unabletodistinguish
thegenuine fmm thefalse, thrgr
ccmnatpick
outyourvealgoal.
TRANSGRESSION OF THE LAW
Over several
weeks,
Ninon deLenclos,
the most infamous courtesan ofseventeentlrcentury France,
listenedpatiently
astheMarquis
deSevigné explained
hisstruggles
inpursuing
abeautiful but difficult youngcountess.Ninonwas
sixty~two
atthetime,andmorethanexperienced
inmattersoflove;
themarquis
was alad oftwenty-two, handsome, dashing,
buthope lessly inexperienced
in romance. At first Ninonwas amused to hear themarquis
talkabout hismistakes,
butfinally
shehad hadenough.
Unabletobear
ineptitude
inanyrealm,
least of allinseducing
awoman,shedecidedtotake theyoungmanunderher
wing. First, he
hadtounderstand that thiswaswar,andthatthe beautifulcountesswas {citadeltowhich he had to
lay siege
ascarefully
asanygeneral. Every step
hadtobeplanned
andexe-cuted with theutmostattentiontodetail andnuance.
Instructing
themarquis
tostart over,Ninon told himtoapproach
thecountesswith abit of
distance,
an air of nonchalance. Thenexttimethe two were alonetogether,
shesaid,
he would confide in the countess aswouldafriend butnotva
potential
lover. Thiswastothrowher off thescent.Thecountesswasno
longer
totake hisinterest inher forgranted-perhaps
hewas
only
interestedinfriendship.
Ninon
planned
ahead. Once the countess wasconfused,
itwould betime tomake her
jealous.
Atthenextencounter,atamajor
féteinParis,
themarquis
would show up with a beautiful youngwoman athis side. This beautiful youngwomanhadequally
beautifulfriends,
sothat wherever the countesswouldnow seethemarquis,
he would be surroundedby
themoststunning
youngwomenin Paris. Notonly
would thecountessbeseething
with
jealousy,
she wouldcometosee themarquis
as someonewhowasde-sired
by
others.Itwashard for Ninontomake themarquis understand,
but shepatiently explained
thata womanwhois interestedinamanwants tosee that otherwomen areinterested in
him,
too. Notonly
does thatgive
him instant
value,
itmakes it all the moresatisfying
to snatch him from theirclutches.Once thecountess was
jealous
butintrigued,
itwould be time to be-guile
her. On Ninon’sinstructions,themarquis
would failtoshowupataf- fairswhere thecountessexpected
to see him.Then, suddenly,
he wouldappearatsalons hehadnever
frequented before,
but that the countess at-LAW 3 I7
18 LAW3
tended often. She would be unableto
predict
hismoves.Allofthis wouldpush
herintothestateof emotional confusion thatisaprerequisite
forsumcessful seduction.
These moves were
executed,
and took several weeks. Ninon moni- tored themarquis’s
progress:Through
her network ofspies,
she heard how the countess wouldlaugh
a little harder at his witticisms, listen moreclosely
tohisstories.She heard that thecountesswassuddenly asking
ques- tions about him. Her friends told her that at social affairs the countess would often look upatthemarquis, following
hissteps.
Ninonfelt
certain that the youngwoman wasfalling
under hisspell.
Itwas amatterof weeksnow,
maybe
a monthortwo, but ifallwentsmoothly,
the citadel would fall.Afew
days
later themarquis
was atthe countess’s home.They
werealone.
Suddenly
he wasadifferent man:Thistimeacting
onhis ownim—pulse,
rather thanfollowing
Ninon’s instructions, he took the countess’s hands and told her he was in love with her. The young woman seemedconfused,
3reaction he didnotexpect.
She becamepolite,
thenexcusedherself. Fortherestof the
evening
she avoided his eyes,wasnotthereto saygoodnight
tohim. The nextfew timeshe visited hewas told shewasnot athome. When she
finally
admitted himagain,
the twofeltawkwardand uncomfortable with each other. The
spell
wasbroken.Interpretation
Ninon de Lenclos knew
everything
about theartof love. Thegreatest
writ-ers,
thinkers,
andpoliticians
ofthetimehad been herlovers——menlikeLaRochefoucauld, Moliére,
and Richelieu. Seductionwas agametoher,
tobepracticed
with skill.Asshegotolder,
and herreputation
grew, themostim~portant
familiesinFrance would send theirsons tohertobeinstructed in mattersof love.Ninon knew that men and women are very
different,
but when itcomestoseduction
they
feel thesame:Deep
downinside, they
oftensensewhen
they
arebeing seduced,
butthey give
inbecausethey enjoy
the feel-ing
ofbeing
ledalong.
Itisapleasure
tolet go, andtoallow the other per-son to detour you into a strange
country. Everything
inseduction, however, depends
onsuggestion.
Youcannotannounce yourintentionsor reveal themdirectly
inwords. Instead youmustthrow yourtargets offthescent.To surrendertoyour
guidance they
mustbeappropriately
confused.Youhave to scramble your
signals——~appea.r
interestedinanotherman orwoman
(the decoy),
then hintatbeing
interestedinthetarget,
thenfeign indifference,
onandon.Suchpatterns
notonly confuse, they
excite.Imagine
thisstory
from the countess’sperspective:
Afterafew of themarquis’s
moves, she sensed themarquis
wasplaying
some sortof game, but the gamedelighted
her. She didnotknow where he wasleading her,
butsomuch the better. Hismovesintrigued her,
each of themkeeping
herwaiting
for thenextone———sheevenenjoyed
herjealousy
andconfusion,
forsometimesanyemotion isbe-tier thanthe boredomof
security. Perhaps
themarquis
had ulteriormotives;mostmendo. But shewaswilling
towaitandsee,and
probably
if she had been madetowaitlong enough,
what hewasuptowouldnothavemattered.
Themomentthe
marquis
utteredthat fatal word“love,” however, allwas
changed.
Thiswas nolonger
agamewithmoves, itwas anartless show ofpassion.
His intention was revealed: He wasseducing
her. This puteverything
hehad doneinanewlight.
All that beforehad beencharming
nowseemed
ugly
andconniving;
thecountess felt embarrassedand used.Adoor closed that wouldneveropen
again.
Donotbe heldacheat,eventhough2'! isimpossibletolive
today
withoutbeing
one.Let yourgreatest
cunning
lie incovering upwhat looks likecunning.l:ia.lm.s'm(}rzu‘iz1u., I 6/)1 I6 58
OBSERVANCE OFTHE LAW
In1850 the young Ottovon
Bismarck,
thenathirty—five—yearvold deputy
inthePrussian
parliament,
wasataturning point
inhiscareer. Theissuesofthe
day
were the unification of the many states(including Prussia)
intowhich
Germany
wasthendivided,
andawaragainst Austria,
thepowerful neighbor
tothe south thathoped
tokeep
the Germans weak andatodds,
even
threatening
tointervene ifthey
triedtounite.PrinceWilliam,
next in linetobe P:ussia’sking,
wasinfavor ofgoing
to war, andtheparliament
ralliedtothecause,prepared
toback any mobilization oftroops.
Theonly
ones tooppose warwerethe
present king,
Frederick WilliamIV,
and his ministers,whopreferred
toappease thepowerful
Austrians.Throughout
his career, Bismarck had been aloyal,
evenpassionate
supporter of Prussianmight
and power. He dreamed ofGerman unifica- tion,ofgoing
towaragainst
Austriaandhumiliating
thecountrythat forsolong
hadkept Germany
divided.Aformersoldier,
hesawwarfareasaglo-
riousbusiness.
This,
afterall,
was the man who years later would say, “The greatquestions
ofthetimewill bedecided,
notby speeches
andresolutions,
butby
ironand blood.”Passionate
patriot
andlover ofmilitary glory,
Bismarck nevertheless gave aspeech
inparliament
attheheight
of thewarfeverthat astonished all who heardit“Woeuntothestatesman,”hesaid,
“who makeswarwith-outa reasonthat will still be valid when thewarisover!After thewar,you will all look
differently
atthesequestions.
Will you then have the couragetoturn tothepeasant
contemplating
the ashes of hisfarm,tothemanwho has beencrippled,
tothe father whohaslost his children?” Notonly
didBismarck go ontotalk ofthe madness of thiswar,
but,
strangestofall,
hepraised
Austriaand defended heractions.This wentagainst everything
hehad stood for. The consequences were immediate. Bismarck was
against
the wa.r——what could thispossibly
mean? Otherdeputies
wereconfused,
and severalofthemchanged
theirvotes.Eventually
theking
and hisminis-terswonout, andwarwasaverted.
A fewweeksafter Bisma.rck’s infamous
speech,
theking, grateful
thatLAW 3 19
20 LAW 3
he had
spoken
for peace, madehimacabinetminister.A few years later he became the Prussianpremier.
Inthis role heeventually
led hiscountry
anda.
peace-loving king
intoa waragainst Austria, crushing
the formerempire
and
establishing
a German state, with Prussiaatitshead.lnterpretation
At the time of his
speech
in1850,
Bismarck made several calculations.First,
he sensedthatthe Prussianmilitary,
which hadnotkept
pace with otherEuropean
armies,wasunready
for war--thatAustria,
infact, might
very wellwin,adisastrousresultforthefuture.
Second,
ifthewar werelost and Bismarck hadsupported
it, his careerwould begravely jeopardized.
The
king
and his conservative ministers wanted peace; Bismarckwanted power. Theanswer wastothrowpeople
off thescentby supporting
acausehe
cletested, saying things
he wouldlaugh
atif saidby
another. A wholecountry
wasfooled. Itwasbecause of Bismarck’sspeech
that theking
madehimaminister,at
position
from which hequickly
rosetobeprime
minister,attaining
the power tostrengthen
the Prussianmilitary
andaccomplish
what he had wanted all
along:
the humiliation of Austriaandthe unifica»tionof
Germany
under Prussia’sleadership.
Bismarckwas
certainly
oneofthe clevereststatesmanwhoeverlived,
amasterof
strategy
anddeception.
Noonesuspected
what hewasuptoin thiscase. Had he announced his realintentions,arguing
thatitwasbettertowaitnowand
fight later,
he wouldnothave wontheargument,
sincemost Prussians wantedwar at thatmomentand
mistakenly
believed that their army wassuperior
tothe Austrians. Had heplayed
up to theking, asking
tobe madeaminister inexchange
forsupporting
peace, he would not have succeeded either: Theking
would have distrusted his ambition and doubted hissincerity.
By being completely
insincere andsending misleading signals,
how-ever, he deceived everyone, concealed his purpose, and attained every-
thing
he wanted. Suchisthe power ofhiding
yourintentions.KEYS TO POWER
Most
people
areopenbooks.They
say whatthey feel,
blurtouttheiropin-
ionsatevery
opportunity,
andconstantly
reveal theirplans
andintentions.They
do this forseveralreasons.First,
itis easy and naturaltoalways
wanttotalk about one’s
feelings
andplans
forthe future. It takes efforttocontrol yourtongue
andmonitorwhat you reveal.Second,
manybelieve thatby being
honest and openthey
arewinning people's
hearts andshowing
theirgood nature.They
aregreatly
deluded.Honesty
isactually
abluntinstru-ment, which bloodies more than it cuts. Your
honesty
islikely
to offendpeople;
it ismuch moreprudent
totailor yourwords, telling people
whatthey
wanttohear ratherthanthecoarseandugly
truth of whatyoufeelor think. Moreimportant, by being unabashedly
open you makeyourself
sopredictable
and familiar thatit isalmostimpossible
torespect
orfearyou, and power willnotaccruetoaperson whocannotinspire
suchemotions.Ifyou yearn forpower,
quickly lay honesty aside,
andtrainyourself
inthe artof
concealing
yourintentions. Master theartand you willalways
have the upper hand. Basic to an
ability
to conceal one’s intentions is asimple
tmth about human nature: Our first instinct is toalways
trust ap- pearances. Wecannotgoarounddoubting
thereality
of whatwe see andhear—-constantly imagining
that appearances concealedsomething
elsewould exhaust and
terrify
us.This fact makesitrelatively
easyto conceal one’s intentions.Simply dangle
anobject
you seem todesire,
agoal
youseemtoaim
for,
infront ofpeople’s
eyesandthey
willtakethe appearance forreality.
Once their eyes focusonthedecoy, they
will failtonoticewhatyouare
really
upto.Inseduction,
setupconflictinghsignals,
suchasdesireand
indiiference,
andyounotonly
throw them off the scent, you inflame their desiretopossess you.Atacticthatisoften effectivein
setting
uparedherring
is toappeartosupport
anideaor causethatisactually contrary
toyour ownsentiments.(Bismarck
used thistogreat
effectinhisspeech
in1850.)
Mostpeople
willbelieve you have
experienced
achange
ofheart,
since itis sounusual toplay
solightly
withsomething
as emotional asone’sopinions
and values.The same
applies
foranydecoyed object
of desire: Seemto want some-thing
inwhich youareactually
not atall interested and yourenemieswill be thrown oil thescent.making
all kinds oferrorsintheircalculations.During
the WaroftheSpanish
Succession in1711,
the DukeofMarl-borough,
head of theEnglish
army, wanted todestroy
akey
Frenchfort,
becauseit
protected
avitalthoroughfare
intoFrance.Yethe knewthat ifbedestroyed
it,the French would realize what he wanted-to advance down that road.Instead, then,
hemerely captured
thefort,andgarrisoned
itwithsomeofhistroops,
making
itappearasifhe wanteditforsomepurposeof hisown. The French attacked the fort and the duke let themrecapture
it.Once
they
haditback, though, they destroyed
it,figuring
that the duke had wanteditforsomeimportant
reason.Now that the fortwasgone, the roadwas
unprotected,
andMarlborough
couldeasily
marchintoFrance,Use this tacticin the
following
manner: Hide yourintentions notby closing
up(with
the risk ofappearing
secretive,andmaking people suspi- cious)
butby talking endlessly
about your desires andgoals—~just
notyourreal ones. You will kill three birds with one stone: You appear
friendly,
open,and
trusting;
you conceal yourintentions; and you sendyourrivalson
timeconsuming wild~goose
chases.Another
powerful
toolinthrowing people
oh’ thescentisfalsesincer-ity. People easily
mjstakesincerity
forhonesty.
Remember-their firstin stinctis to trust appearances, and sincethey
valuehonesty
and want tobelievein the
honesty
of those aroundthem, they
willrarely
doubt youorsee
through
your act.Seeming
tobelieve what you saygives
your words greatweight.
ThisishowIago
deceived anddestroyed
Othello: Given thedepth
ofhisemotions,theapparent sincerity
of hisconcernsabout Desde—rnona’s
supposed infidelity,
how could Othello distrust him? This is also how thegreat
con artist Yellow Kid Weilpulled
the wool over suckers’eyes:
Seeming
tobelievesodeeply
in thedecayed object
hewasdangling
LAW 3 ,2]
22
f
LAW 3in front of them
(a phony stock,
a.toutedracehorse),
he made itsreality
hardtodoubt.It is
important,
ofcourse, not togotoofar inthisarea.Sin~cexity
is atricky
tool:Appear overpassionate
andyou raisesuspicions.
Bemeasuredand believableoryourrusewillseemthe
put-on
thatit is.To make your false
sincerity
aneffective weapon inconcealing
your intentions, espouseabeliefinhonesty
andfertlirightness
asimportant
so-cial values. Do thisas
publicly
aspossible. Emphasize
yourposition
onthissubject by occasionally divulging
someheartfeltthought-though only
onethatis
actually meaningless
orirrelevant,
ofcourse.Napoleon";
ministerTalleyrand
wasamaster attaking people
intohisconfidenceby revealing
some
apparent
secret. Thisfeigned
confidence——adecoy—-would
thenelicitareal confidenceonthe other
person’s part.
Remember: The best deceivers do
everything they
cantocloak their{roguish qualities. They
cultivateanairofhonesty
in one areatodisguise
their
dishonesty
inothers.Honesty
ismerely
anotherdecoy
intheir arsenal of weapons.1 r I 5.-
PARTII: USE SMOKE SCREENS TO